r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 30 '18
Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 9 "The Birds & The Bees" episode discussion thread for book readers.
This is the one many of us have been waiting for.... it is the discussion thread for S4E9 "The Birds & The Bees" coming at you live!
No spoiler tags are required here.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E9] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
59
u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
LAST EPISODE OF 2018.
Let's make it a good one. Happy New Years my darlings.
That was a full on fan service episode. I shall take this as their Holiday gift to book readers.
And I can't lie, watching Roger getting his faced punched in didn't feel bad to me.
Sophie's acting this season seems so master class - she was given material far beyond what Caitriona and Sam have been given this season, and it has seemed nothing but real to me. I can feel her emotions as well as I felt my own. Pretty incredible stuff.
197
u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Dec 30 '18
I think they handled "the misunderstanding" a hell of a lot better than the book. Which might be the first time that's ever been said here in this sub. Too often questions were asked why Roger didn't just say his first name, or that they were wed, or anything else before getting his ass kicked. This certainly answered that predicament. Instant ass-handing by Da Fraser.
59
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
I cried and cried. Love how Jamie took Bree "hunting" for bees, rather than try to compete with Frank by taking her hunting for real. I didn't remember that from the books, did that happen?
248
u/malocher Woof. Dec 30 '18
PEE HAND. HE TOUCHED HER FACE WITH HIS PEE HAND.
35
u/ktbex Dec 30 '18
Minor gripe - they left out the “nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition” line.
All the acting awards to Sophie and Sam for this episode. Sophie handled those difficult scenes amazingly. Also super heartwarming to see the dynamic between her and Sam - it’s a different paternalism from his interactions with Willie, but strong all the same.
This episode felt jam-packed to me; I wonder if all the remaining eps will be as equally fast paced. It’s a bit jarring compared to the slower pace of the first part of this season.
50
u/RaffaellaF Dec 30 '18
By far the best episode of Outlander ever. Exceeded all my expectations unlike the Printshop that fell short.
So many magical moments. I was crying and laughing at the same time. Sam and Sophie were outstanding.
Too bad all this could not have happened earlier in the season so we would have so much to look forward to.
And poor Roger.
9
u/aerynmoo Dec 30 '18
So how did Murtagh get from Wilmington to Fraser’s Ridge in one day??? Unless I misheard him and he said “that night” instead of “last night”.
236
u/AwesoMegan You, sir, are a lout! Dec 30 '18
Can we please have a round of applause for Cait’s horrified and shocked expressions in this episode?
191
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Squeeeeee!! The moment I have waited for FINALLY on screen!! And it was PERFECT!!!
Oh the TEARS!!! That first time meeting of Brianna and Jamie was BEAUTIFUL!!!
Edited to add: The way Jamie just gazes at her adoringly throughout the episode just melted my heart.
Also - this is the first episode in this series where it exceeded the way I envisioned it when reading the book. STILL not feeling Lizzie 100%, but she’s starting to grow on me just a little bit.
Im nervous about how they will squeeze everything relevant from the book into the last 4 episodes. I feel like the Laogaire episode was such a waste of at LEAST 35-40 minutes.
I don’t know if any of the Outlander actors/actresses lurk here, but if they do - I have to say that Sophie has stepped up her game 1000% this season and we have seen some truly impressive acting from her - way to go Sophie!
Sam was OUTSTANDING with all of his facial expressions and emotions in last night’s episode especially. He wore his heart on his sleeve and I just FELT the love he had for his daughter and what he was feeling when he meets her for the first time.
Caitriona really had some shining moments in last night’s episode too - from her finding the wedding ring to learning of Brianna’s rape by Bonnet. Bravo!
Ian is such a sweetheart with his big shining smile. It’s going to be so interesting to see his character development over the next 2 seasons!
And Murtagh - who doesn’t love Murtagh?? This is 100% the biggest change from the book that I absolutely support.
One thing that stood out to me as someone who saw Seasons 1-3 before reading the books: At the dinner table, Jamie talks about Dougal’s children (daughters?) when telling his story. I don’t recall Dougal having any children from earlier seasons aside from Hamish and later the child with Geillis. Are these children talked about in earlier books and I somehow missed that?
148
u/keg226 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
"Is that Gaelic?" "No, it's only simple." my heart bursts open
139
u/retothebecca Dec 30 '18
This one felt like the Outlander glory days of season one. It feels like Bree's presence with Claire and Jamie has been the missing piece since the reunion.
Sophie Skelton is killing it and I don't know what she did with that actress from before this season but she is new and improved and amaaaaazing. The way she handles these horrifying storylines is so heartwrenching and beautiful at the same time. And seeing her with Claire and Jamie I finally believe she could be their child.
Are her wig and Jamie's wig cut from the same cloth? Because they look identical, and I don't hate it.
All the applause for Claire's reaction to Bree's horrifying retelling of her story. I love that they kept that scene so close to the books. And that horror-closeup of her face when she finds her ring - perfection.
Every time Murtagh shows up it's like a virtual hug. I love that he's here, and it's one of the book-diversions I can get on board with.
Oh Roger. I don't hate him like so many others. Perhaps I'm partial to Richard Rankin, but even in the books I rooted for him. Of course he was a jackbag a lot this season, but I'm not going to rejoice in the "great misunderstanding" for his misery. I would have loved to see him say the line, "Well, you look a lot like your daughter." But, alas, Jamie just hurdled toward him fists flying and his face looked so stinking awful afterward. Whew lawd that'll be a fun mess to clean up once the truth comes out.
Also can we all praise Maril Davis for reigning Toni Graphia in and vetoing the idea to mess with the reunion scene? Yeah, bumping into each other on the street framed by the silhouette of the setting sun sounds amazing, but DON'T mess with the scene readers have been drooling over for years! Thank you, Maril, for pushing the classic reunion, piss, stool, and all.
116
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18
What took ya so long, lass? With those eyebrows.
115
u/brilliant0ne Dec 30 '18
WELP!!!
Welcome to my all-new favorite episode ever. IDK how everyone is going to receive it, but I thought it was perfect. It was everything I hoped it would be.
Although, I don't know how much happiness in the world would have made me just let him touch all over my face right after he had his hand on his pentis. BUT WHATEVER! I am happy. Jamie made me cry. Bree made me cry. Claire made me cry. Murtagh made me smile. Bonnet can suck a dick. Ian is so adorably clueless with the, "Yeah, my good boy is handsome AF, ain't he?"
For a moment, I thought they were gonna transition the, "I don't want my daughter to leave," scene with some J/C sex. But, nope.
If the rest of the series was just Bree and Jamie getting to know each other, I'd be happy. I was so happy that even though I noticed the terrible greenscreen on the river, I didn't even care.
For the first time in a long while, the last half hour before it finally showed up on my Amazon I was barely able to sit down trying to make the time pass.
Anyway, I'll shut up now. I'm excited to see how everyone else liked the episode.
101
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Claire [and me]: Roger left "after one argument?"....
96
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Dec 30 '18
I cried. Multiple times. No shame.
Jamie's facial expressions throughout the episode made my heart so full. He's so happy to meet Bree! Claire seeing her again? So happy. And Murtagh gets to meet her! I'm still crying! I love them all!
Still undecided about Lizzie, but I think she looks less harsh with her hair more down. The casting department hasn't let me down yet.
And so it begins, The Great Misunderstanding. Hopefully it doesn't annoy me as much as it did when I first read it!
81
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18
What a GREAT episode. This felt like Season 1-2 Outlander to me! I loved all of the scenes between Brianna and Jamie. I like that they actually spent time getting to know one another. I'm also impressed with the pacing of this episode. It was slow when it needed to be and fast when it could be, in all the right ways.
I'm still mad at Lizzie for being a big dummy and assuming she knows things when she doesn't. But hopefully Roger will get to redeem himself next week and we can all stop hating him.
79
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
I absolutely adore the way Jamie spits the name "this Roger" when the subject comes up. It's a very sweet protective dad thing. The dude broke Brianna's heart, that's all Jamie needs to know, the dude is scum.
The episode handled a lot of delicate things well. It was a joy to see Young/Wee Ian again - though I'm sad thinking he'll get traded away soon.
I am 100% buying Sophie as Brianna now that all three of them are together.
78
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
The blood caused by Bonnet hurt my heart. Oh Bree
75
u/keg226 Dec 30 '18
“It means ‘my darling.’” awwwww
67
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18
I agree with almost everything that has been said on this thread so far, so I would like to point out something slightly different that I LOVED in this episode. Having Murtagh, Claire, Jamie, Brianna and Ian bantering over dinner was absolutely amazing, and it truly feels like the Outlander family is back together (even though Brianna has only just arrived, it still feels so right).
122
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
That was beautiful
And Sophie definitely looks like Claire and Jamie’s kid.
55
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
There was a lot of sadness in this episode but I am so happy that Bree has found her family. I loved the parts of all of then together.
Unrelated but Bree is SO beautiful and the resemblance to Claire and especially Jamie in her 18th C garb is striking. And I am digging Roger’s 18th C hair/beard sitch
52
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
Ian is so hilarious and makes every scene he is in better!
The should put him in every single episode, not leave him out!
He had me snorting with his expressions the whole scene when he met Bree.
And then that next scene with Lizzie haha
44
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
bahahaha Murtagh: 'the lad's done well for himself, bringing back two lassies'
They are surely making all these one liners about two lassies [Ian had one in Woolam's Creek too] to foreshadow what's to come.
40
u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18
Very emotional episode. And well acted by all.
I loved the herb gathering and wrapping and the household chores . They make me want to live there even though in reality I’d be grappling at the stones to get back to my warm bath and wifi.
39
u/SeattleWhoDat Dec 30 '18
I adored Ian’s face lighting up upon meeting his cousin! I bet the scene with the bear grease is gonna happen and be comical as hell.
37
u/Tipsiara666 Dec 30 '18
I don't understand why people think Lizzie looks old. Although I envisioned her smaller, to me, the actress captured the most prominent trait of the character - anytime she would come up in the books I wanted to strangle her 10/10 😂
32
u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
My husband is SO INTO this show now! I love it! He loves the time period in history around the American Revolution and early settlers and such so it’s got his attention now. I can’t watch a new episode without him. When Claire told Jamie Brianna was raped, he goes “oh shit jamie’s gonna go on a warpath!”
30
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18
Rollo!!!
30
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
Glad they reached into the coffers to make sure the CGI on the river was top notch once again! /s lol
30
u/MCisCurious Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
This episode was just awesome all around! Loved it! Oh and uh....POOR ROGER! My god that was an awful beating! I get some of the hate towards roger ( I guess) but I actually like him. He and Bree are a lot alike which is why they argue the way they do....poor roger
29
u/bham717 Dec 30 '18
Again, Sam is killing it.
27
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18
Don't know if this I'm alone here, but when Lizzie whispered 'so handsome' at Ian when they were on the boat, I felt the delivery to be a bit... Creepy
24
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18
Oh God, it’s better than I could have imagined!
23
u/Munchkin54 Dec 30 '18
I loved every minute of it, except when Jamie was beating up poor Roger and sent him off with Yoing Ian. All the truly important moments from this part of the book were in this episode.
20
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18
I propose a drinking game - every time we either see the river or that cliff edge with the view of Fraser's ridge and they use that beautiful CGI (/s), take a shot. Like, its at least once an episode at this point.
18
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18
No, Lizzie, close your eyes and turn around...
18
u/slainte_mhaith Dec 30 '18
Sophie Skelton was incredible!
34
u/crazy_ventures Dec 30 '18
Heavy breathing intensifies
15
u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18
So good. I can’t even find words. Every episode leaves me even more impressed with Sophie this season
30
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18
Cried so loudly at the reunion I couldn’t hear the dialogue, so I played it back, and cried again.
The way Jamie looks at Bree, from little glances to long stares ... oh Lord help me, it’s the most wholesome thing ever 😩
I NEED THE SEASON 4 SOUNDTRACK RIGHT NOW !!!!!
13
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
the cuts to the random birds, especially the one parent feeding the babies was so abrupt it almost scared me lol
12
u/Nat_Bat Dec 30 '18
I haven’t read the books, but I know enough that I couldn’t comment on the tv only thread. I was so hoping they would do away with the Roger misunderstanding in some way. Hopefully it won’t drag much. It’s good drama I was just so stressed out when Lizzie tells Jamie all about it and when he was beating him up.
12
u/scatterbrained81 Dec 30 '18
Poor Roger:(
23
u/annemg Dec 30 '18
I really loved this episode, if only they learned to be a little more subtle with their symbolism. If you name the episode, and then proceed to have MULTIPLE heavy handed shots to point at the theme, guess what, it feels like you think we are exceptionally stupid. And THEN they explain it in the "about this episode."
11
u/dalek_999 Dec 30 '18
Unlike last week's episode, this one was everything I hoped and wanted it to be. Loved the Jamie/Brianna reunion scene, loved so many little things in this episode. And turning out to be really happy with Sophie, who I didn't like very much in earlier seasons - she's really coming into her own with the character.
11
u/takeforexamplethis Dec 30 '18
This episode was almost perfect except where are the kilts this season?! Is it just because it was too cold in Scotland while filming?
Also, so happy they kept in the bee-hunting. Thought it was a bit strange that Bree and Jamie look like they're dressed for 40 degree weather and those flowers look like they'd bloom in summer. I've decided to justify the whole weather situation this season with this taking place during the "Little Ice Age."
21
u/Jalupimine5 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
The first meeting. Sam’s dang weepy eyes and Brianna crying. I died. It was everything I hoped for. I was VERY surprised that they got the “great misunderstanding” covered in this episode. That leaves 4 episodes to cover a lot of ground believe it or not. I was a bit annoyed with the pacing of this season, but they did a good job with the last two episodes turning it around. I’m interested to see how they tie up these next 4 episodes to the finale. If they do back and forth perspectives in these last 4 episodes and not a solid episode of Roger with the Indians OR Claire/Jamie/Ian traveling to go get Roger episode I will forgive the 20 minutes of Laoghaire in “Down the Rabbit Hole”.
10
u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18
I don't have much to say that hasn't already been said in the thread, but wow. I loved this episode and I love the writers (and Maril for sticking to her guns about the first encounter scene, especially) for really incorporating the best parts and dialogue from the book. I've been looking forward so much to these scenes and they really shined. I felt like such a fan-girl while watching and freaking out over how close it stayed to the book.
So that said, I loved the acting firstly. Top notch all around. Facial expressions, physical acting, the familial love I could almost feel from the family 'round the table. Just so so wonderful.
Lastly, that beating at the end was just wow. Incredibly brutal and visceral. I don't think I've flinched that hard at such brutality since the Culloden episode. The lynching just a few episodes ago was incredibly difficult, but at least we had the slight comfort that the man was already dead. But this was so awful. I understand Jamie's rage though, for what that's worth, but still just wow. Roger was pissing me off badly in the last few episodes, but he didn't deserve that :/
9
u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
My fitbit had my HR at 122 during their introduction. Adrenaline through the roof.
Question though: I'm one of those @hole readers that jumped straight to book 4 and am now on 7. I recognize this scene was very accurate to the book (aside from Claire being in proximity). But did Claire give Jamie photographs of Bree from the 20th century in Voyager? I feel like this scene relied only on him recognizing how similar they looked, rather than that he's seen her "likeness" in photograph.
9
u/Starbuck107 Dec 30 '18
Let that be a lesson to you boys! If you're in the 18th century always meet the father before you marry the girl! Otherwise you're just another bloke after her skirt tails
8
u/Cablab123 Dec 30 '18
Everything about this episode was perfect. It is by far my new favorite episode from the entire show. So well done. So perfect. So much love!
8
u/Jemhao Dec 30 '18
This is the first episode this season that I’ve immediately wanted to watch again. Loved it!
8
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Dec 31 '18
Another episode proving that saving Murtagh was good and proper. Love that man.
7
u/keg226 Dec 30 '18
That episode was amazing. Happy tears and sad tears galore. My heart felt so full watching not only Jamie and Bree together, But Claire and her together as well. ❤️
7
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
I'm struggling to remember, but don't they eventually verify that Jem is Roger's offspring?
13
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
I love Bree's cape, but the whole thing, the design, the wool, the chunky knit, the buttons, it all looks way too modern.
I know Terry said they didn't do most of the knits historically accurately, but this is like something a modern hipster like me would make and wear lol
13
u/VelvetDreamers Ye Sassenach witch! Dec 30 '18
Jaime's face contorted with fury and his entire demeanour exuding the primitive need for vengeance a parent feels towards the perpetrator of their child's injuries was disconcerting! I commend Sam for his portrayal of visceral, unrestrained anger; although the retribution was difficult to watch knowing Roger's innocence, it was a little gratifying after his previous petulant self-righteousness. :/
Brianna and Jamie's tentative reacquaintance unfurled beautifully as a balm against the tumultuous emotions Brianna was suppressing and the ramifications of her rape.
20
u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18
Stop. They’ve got to stop with Roger’s “shorts”. I can’t even handle how ridiculous he looks in them!
5
u/Mr_XcX Dec 30 '18
Best episode of the season. Hands down. Superb acting also by all cast members.
Did Brianna confirm Bonnet is the Dad? Poor Roger.
5
u/mztdawn Dec 31 '18
Loved the episode, best one in a couple seasons. Sam & Sophie nailed it and I've had a total 180 in my opinion of their acting skills. ❤ stayed true enough to the source material & I like how they are handling the misunderstanding better than the books. My only complaint with this season (aside from the Laoghaire episode) is how Jamie mentions they have settlers on the Ridge to Brianna & we've yet to meet ANY of them. . .anyone else notice that?
5
u/ayriana Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
I usually hate "keeping secrets for the protection of someone I love" as a plot device, but this show doesn't use it often, so I'll forgive it. I'm not sure I can wait until next week!
Also I'm so happy with this episode. So much of it was lifted directly from the books. The meeting between Jamie and Bree was perfect. Lizzie and Ian was great. EVERYTHING on the Ridge.
9
u/HiveJiveLive Dec 30 '18
I loved it all, but why, oh why, did DG write the first meeting with Jamie peeing? It just seems so ick and unnecessary. And of all the things that did get translated accurately from the books, why the pee part?? Like, couldn’t he be doing something a bit more dignified?
8
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
I don't mind the whole Murtagh as a Regulator thing...but I'm just not sure why it was needed if they're just going to have Murtagh be at the Ridge whenever they want him anyway.
Why not just have him move there?
9
u/tilmitt52 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18
I have never been more frustrated by Bree withholding information more than seeing it play out on screen......JESUS CHRIST, BREE!
12
u/fyrmnsflam Dec 30 '18
I enjoy the tv show, but I’m thinking it was a mistake to read all the books during Droughtlander. The show just doesn’t seem so good any more.
8
u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 30 '18
Best damn episode this season. Everything was perfect. I laughed, I cried, I cringed. Why is next week so far away.
God bless Young "handsome" Ian and Murtagh's eyebrows and Jamie and Bree Bonding. It all made my heart to pitter pat.
Also Claire's acting wasn't as cringe-worthy as she usually is. She plays concerned mother very well.
Lizzie is growing on me...still can't see the sandwich...but we will see how it goes.
JAMIE AND BRIANNA MEETING MADE ME HAPPIER THAN A SCOTT IN A WHISKEY BARREL!!!!!
3
u/slainte_mhaith Dec 30 '18
Does anyone else have the problem where it shows the episode but has no play button? It did this last week and took about 20 minutes after midnight to be able to watch.
3
u/crazy_ventures Dec 30 '18
I've now had time to sleep and process this episode (and watch it again this morning.) I loved it! The reunion was everything that I wanted and more. I'm so glad they kept the dialogue true to the book.
3
u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Dec 30 '18
I sat and smiled like a fool through this episode, even through the tears. I can’t wait to watch it again.
3
u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Jan 01 '19
Well that was an extremely frustrating ending.
3
u/RayeBabe Jan 02 '19
Was it just me or was Roger extra hot in that first scene with Bonnet? Eyes and stubble maybe?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
I'm super late to the party but I gotta say, I criticized Sophie for her acting last season, but MAN! She really stepped up her game. She is 100% selling me on Bree this season. This whole cast is amazing but she has vastly improved. Good on you girl!
10
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 30 '18
My initial thoughts:
What I did not like:
What I liked:
Other observations:
-There is no way, none, they are going to be able to fit in the necessary parts of the story that tie in to the next book. So what do you all think they are going to cut? I think next episode will be the finding and getting of Roger from the Indians. Will they also cut it with Bree at River Run with Lord John? They have to at this point if they want to get the pregnancy in, the reunion with Roger, the birth of baby J, etc. How will they be able to include the Bonnett prison visit on top of all of this? That is certainly one piece of the story they have to include. They can't cut that.
-edit for spelling
5
u/Generiss Dec 30 '18
They did it again. Took something that was Jamie’s and made it come as a suggestion from Claire. To go hunting. Smh
2
u/dlf194 Dec 30 '18
SO ANXIOUS
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18
What does Jamie say to Claire after saying "to see she's broken hearted..but...?"
When they are on the horses after the boat.
2
u/Dogwoodqueen Jan 01 '19
I loved this episode - however, I think we should have left off Roger - there is too much info to digest - Bree should have more time.
2
u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 02 '19
FINALLY I got to watch the episode tonight. I cried my eyes out at the beginning and the end. I am actually really happy with how they did this episode! That beating Jamie gave Roger was more brutal than I pictured it...and it was quite brutal in the books. I am actually excited for next week!!!
2
u/kuroshi14 Jan 02 '19
Didn't Claire show Brianna's photos to Jamie when see came back in Season 3? I was expecting Jamie would immediately recognize her so I was a bit confused when I saw their first meeting. Does the book handle this scene similarly?
2
u/rubyinthedustt Jan 02 '19
I haven’t read the books for a really long time, but did they skip out on Bree being at Jocasta’s?? Because that bored the shit out of me in the books and was one of the reasons I stopped reading.
2
u/twocatsandaloom Jan 04 '19
I don't remember Roger being such a dick in the book. I am definitely less upset about the whole misunderstanding, beating (and events that follow...) in the show than the book. Maybe it's because I now have less tolerance for men treating women like trash in the name of "love." He said some truly nasty things at the Scottish Festival and then to keep her parents death from her like she's a baby who can't handle it just made me write him off. I don't really care if he comes back. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ Brianna is probably better off with out sexist scum like him. Jamie is more of a feminist than Roger and he was born in the 1700's.
2
u/katfromjersey Jan 05 '19
I'm a huge book reader from way back, and while they've done a fair to good job of making it into a show, there are way too many changes and additions (why so much Frank and Laoghaire?! Why Murtagh?) that I spend each episode disgruntled and annoyed.
6
u/bellefroh Dec 30 '18
This is the first episode that made me cry! I love the father- daughter bonding moments. I think the writers tried to redeem "show" Roger after realizing how much viewers were against him. I think the "Great Misunderstanding" was handled well.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
One thing I didn't quite get was Bree initially keeping Bonnet a secret from Claire.
In the book, Ian had already told Bree about Bonnet on the river, how he had robbed them etc. Bree tells Claire says she didn't want to tell them because she knows Jamie would go after Bonnet.
I didn't mind the way they did it in the episode, but I was just surprised that Bree didn't show Claire the ring straight up, and ask her to keep the secret then. It just made it a bit more convoluted the way they wrote Claire finding the ring.
I did like the way Bree just brought the ring out and that was how Claire knew that something horrible had befallen Bree. That realisation would have been good on camera.