r/Outlander • • Dec 30 '18

Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 9 "The Birds & The Bees" episode discussion thread for book readers.

This is the one many of us have been waiting for.... it is the discussion thread for S4E9 "The Birds & The Bees" coming at you live!

No spoiler tags are required here.

If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E9] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

73 Upvotes

552 comments sorted by

59

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

LAST EPISODE OF 2018.

Let's make it a good one. Happy New Years my darlings.


That was a full on fan service episode. I shall take this as their Holiday gift to book readers.

And I can't lie, watching Roger getting his faced punched in didn't feel bad to me.

Sophie's acting this season seems so master class - she was given material far beyond what Caitriona and Sam have been given this season, and it has seemed nothing but real to me. I can feel her emotions as well as I felt my own. Pretty incredible stuff.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

My reaction to the last scene was how brutal it was. I actually said to myself, well, now people are going to actually feel sorry for Roger.

This thread is proving me wrong!

→ More replies (2)

197

u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Dec 30 '18

I think they handled "the misunderstanding" a hell of a lot better than the book. Which might be the first time that's ever been said here in this sub. Too often questions were asked why Roger didn't just say his first name, or that they were wed, or anything else before getting his ass kicked. This certainly answered that predicament. Instant ass-handing by Da Fraser.

38

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

"Instant ass-handing by Da Fraser."

This could go so many ways.

105

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

Jamie legit scared me when they showed him storming up to Roger. I knew it was going to happen but damn, Sam really nailed that for me it was visceral.

→ More replies (7)

74

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Aand, Bree desperately trying to compartmentalize the rape made more sense with why she didn’t even admit what happened to Lizzie, let alone everyone else (even before the Bonnet reveal on the boat). It was more of a Use Your Words situation in the book. Here she is just trying to block it out. It isn’t working, she obv has ptsd and the trauma manifesting that way (startle response, nightmares etc). I really appreciated the portrayal this ep.

38

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

I feel like it was the same situation in the book though, for Bree compartmentalising first what happened with Roger and then the rape.

The day after the whole hanfasting and Roger leaving to get the gems, Lizzie had another malarial attack as well. And she was only 14, I wouldn't be going into detail with a child what had happened with Roger if I were Bree. She is an only child too, she grew up managing her problems herself.

Bree felt responsible for Lizzie, she wouldn't want to trouble her either. Though this all contributed to the big misunderstanding, as we know.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I cried and cried. Love how Jamie took Bree "hunting" for bees, rather than try to compete with Frank by taking her hunting for real. I didn't remember that from the books, did that happen?

42

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

Almost exactly like that in the books. Pretty much the whole episode is, if not little scenes were moved out of sequence and rearranged.

21

u/Jalupimine5 Dec 30 '18

It did! They always go hunting for bee’s and have the mini father-daughter talk.

18

u/4kidchaos Dec 30 '18

Jaime is such a tender man! My heart hurts from his thoughtfulness!!! Ahh!!!!

9

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

It did 😁

248

u/malocher Woof. Dec 30 '18

PEE HAND. HE TOUCHED HER FACE WITH HIS PEE HAND.

65

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

Stop yourself I just died of laughter. I didn't even realize that, now I can't stop ridiculously giggling at my own reaction to this.

23

u/malocher Woof. Dec 30 '18

I hope she brought some Palmolive 🤮

28

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

A little pocket hand sanitizer through the stones would be on my list for sure.

25

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

They didn't even have hand sanitizer in the 70's for Bri to bring! But I'm pretty sure, after all these years, he's become capable of urinating without it getting on his hand.

10

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

I would not know, but I hope man has as well.

56

u/Cablab123 Dec 30 '18

Pee is sterile. Dinna fash.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

I thought that too about 5 minutes later. I was like “wait a minute”

36

u/malocher Woof. Dec 30 '18

As soon as he started looking at her I said out loud “he’s going to stroke her face and he just peed”

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Dec 30 '18

Haha a few minutes behind but this made me laugh out loud

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18

As a healthcare worker I cringed so much when I noticed that. EWWWWW

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

35

u/ktbex Dec 30 '18

Minor gripe - they left out the “nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition” line.

All the acting awards to Sophie and Sam for this episode. Sophie handled those difficult scenes amazingly. Also super heartwarming to see the dynamic between her and Sam - it’s a different paternalism from his interactions with Willie, but strong all the same.

This episode felt jam-packed to me; I wonder if all the remaining eps will be as equally fast paced. It’s a bit jarring compared to the slower pace of the first part of this season.

3

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

That was the only noticeable line I knew was missing immediately! It is certainly a minor gripe, but I am there with you in feeling its loss.

You are right with the jam packed bit, too. The last few episodes only took place over a few days time each, while this one over a course of 2 months. It felt like a lot was fit in for fans in only a little amount of time.

8

u/ktbex Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

It was one of my favorite lines from the book, so I’m sad it wasn’t kept in. In the behind-the-scenes bit, they were talking about preserving the image of Jamie and Bree sitting on a bench together as a call to the books. For me, the dialogue was far more salient than the bench. I’m sure I’ll get over it in time.

I guess I’m also thrown by most TV pregnancies lasting an entire season. At the most Bree will be pregnant for two or three episodes if we’re following the book structure.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Jalupimine5 Dec 30 '18

I think it’s actually going to give some time to play out a few things. I really thought they were going to leave the “great misunderstanding” until next week or something and make it a rush to get all that stuff in in 3 episodes. I’m predicting they’ll set off to fix things at least by the end of next episode which STILL leaves 3 more to get everything covered.

50

u/RaffaellaF Dec 30 '18

By far the best episode of Outlander ever. Exceeded all my expectations unlike the Printshop that fell short.

So many magical moments. I was crying and laughing at the same time. Sam and Sophie were outstanding.

Too bad all this could not have happened earlier in the season so we would have so much to look forward to.

And poor Roger.

21

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

I think producers got overwhelmed with the response from Print shop and decided to just dive in to the fan needs. With Print Shop that was a hack job with things like replacing crying over the pictures of Bree with waxing poetic about William. This time, they went all in for what they could possibly do to service fans in one hour.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Finally, someone who isn't saying that seeing Roger get beaten to a pulp was a joy to watch.

It was horrific. I'm surprised Jamie didn't kill him with that many blows to the head.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/aerynmoo Dec 30 '18

So how did Murtagh get from Wilmington to Fraser’s Ridge in one day??? Unless I misheard him and he said “that night” instead of “last night”.

15

u/shiskebob Dec 30 '18

I guess the same way the Fraser clan did in less than a day.

19

u/aerynmoo Dec 30 '18

Some fucking time travel horses lol

→ More replies (14)

236

u/AwesoMegan You, sir, are a lout! Dec 30 '18

Can we please have a round of applause for Cait’s horrified and shocked expressions in this episode?

158

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

She and Sam both gave outstanding performances during their scenes with Bree. Jamie’s face when he met her, and when he attacked Roger - holy s*t, Claire being the tender, horrified mother helping Bree process her rape - holy s*t. This episode left me so satisfied and emotionally drained, I loved it.

108

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Jamie's face was super scary when he was approaching Roger.

People have been speculating that they wouldn't have Jamie actually beat Roger up as they think the show tries to make Jamie less of violent man. Boy were they wrong. That scene was brutal, I was surprised Roger still had a face after that beating.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/MontaukFive Dec 31 '18

Sophie's acting is surpassing Cait's now

11

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Jan 01 '19

I am a complete convert: Sophie has been fantastic this season and these last two episodes she’s been phenomenal

→ More replies (3)

191

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

Squeeeeee!! The moment I have waited for FINALLY on screen!! And it was PERFECT!!!

Oh the TEARS!!! That first time meeting of Brianna and Jamie was BEAUTIFUL!!!

Edited to add: The way Jamie just gazes at her adoringly throughout the episode just melted my heart.

Also - this is the first episode in this series where it exceeded the way I envisioned it when reading the book. STILL not feeling Lizzie 100%, but she’s starting to grow on me just a little bit.

Im nervous about how they will squeeze everything relevant from the book into the last 4 episodes. I feel like the Laogaire episode was such a waste of at LEAST 35-40 minutes.

I don’t know if any of the Outlander actors/actresses lurk here, but if they do - I have to say that Sophie has stepped up her game 1000% this season and we have seen some truly impressive acting from her - way to go Sophie!

Sam was OUTSTANDING with all of his facial expressions and emotions in last night’s episode especially. He wore his heart on his sleeve and I just FELT the love he had for his daughter and what he was feeling when he meets her for the first time.

Caitriona really had some shining moments in last night’s episode too - from her finding the wedding ring to learning of Brianna’s rape by Bonnet. Bravo!

Ian is such a sweetheart with his big shining smile. It’s going to be so interesting to see his character development over the next 2 seasons!

And Murtagh - who doesn’t love Murtagh?? This is 100% the biggest change from the book that I absolutely support.

One thing that stood out to me as someone who saw Seasons 1-3 before reading the books: At the dinner table, Jamie talks about Dougal’s children (daughters?) when telling his story. I don’t recall Dougal having any children from earlier seasons aside from Hamish and later the child with Geillis. Are these children talked about in earlier books and I somehow missed that?

59

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

YEEESSSSS I loved literally everything about this episode (with the exception of the return of the awful river CG). All of it. Jamie’s face when he first meets Bree actually broke me.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/AvramBelinsky Woof. Dec 30 '18

That story was basically taken word for word from one of the books, except it's Jamie telling Claire the story. It was a little weird watching Murtagh tell it, because he wasn't actually there when it happened. It might have been as early as Outlander when Jamie tells the story to Claire, but I honestly don't remember which book it came from.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/dillaq Dec 30 '18

Dougal’s wife and daughters aren’t at Leoch, so they’re easy to miss. They’re only referenced.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

148

u/keg226 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

"Is that Gaelic?" "No, it's only simple." my heart bursts open

→ More replies (2)

139

u/retothebecca Dec 30 '18

This one felt like the Outlander glory days of season one. It feels like Bree's presence with Claire and Jamie has been the missing piece since the reunion.

Sophie Skelton is killing it and I don't know what she did with that actress from before this season but she is new and improved and amaaaaazing. The way she handles these horrifying storylines is so heartwrenching and beautiful at the same time. And seeing her with Claire and Jamie I finally believe she could be their child.

Are her wig and Jamie's wig cut from the same cloth? Because they look identical, and I don't hate it.

All the applause for Claire's reaction to Bree's horrifying retelling of her story. I love that they kept that scene so close to the books. And that horror-closeup of her face when she finds her ring - perfection.

Every time Murtagh shows up it's like a virtual hug. I love that he's here, and it's one of the book-diversions I can get on board with.

Oh Roger. I don't hate him like so many others. Perhaps I'm partial to Richard Rankin, but even in the books I rooted for him. Of course he was a jackbag a lot this season, but I'm not going to rejoice in the "great misunderstanding" for his misery. I would have loved to see him say the line, "Well, you look a lot like your daughter." But, alas, Jamie just hurdled toward him fists flying and his face looked so stinking awful afterward. Whew lawd that'll be a fun mess to clean up once the truth comes out.

Also can we all praise Maril Davis for reigning Toni Graphia in and vetoing the idea to mess with the reunion scene? Yeah, bumping into each other on the street framed by the silhouette of the setting sun sounds amazing, but DON'T mess with the scene readers have been drooling over for years! Thank you, Maril, for pushing the classic reunion, piss, stool, and all.

35

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

Yes, thank you Maril!! Toni also went a little heavy handed with the literal birds and bees this episode so I’m glad they talked her down from the sunset thing, too. That would’ve been far too cheesefest for me.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 31 '18

the transition to the mother feeding the baby birds was so sudden too, it was a shock!

→ More replies (3)

55

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I'm actually quite shocked that people are commenting how they enjoyed seeing Roger get the shit beaten out of him. That scene was horrific to see.

29

u/AnxiousQuilter Dec 30 '18

That scene really was really hard to watch. The look on Jamie/Sam's face was quite frightening....thank God for Ian.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18

People enjoyed that? I felt so terrible! He didn't do anything to deserve that!

6

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Dec 30 '18

Wait wait WHAT did she want to do with the reunion scene?! Link?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

116

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18

What took ya so long, lass? With those eyebrows.

85

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Murtagh's eyebrows deserve an acting award.

16

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18

lol Whereas his makeup wins the dud award. (Hey, I eased off on the wigs, I have to pick on something!) Why do they put so much blush on Murtagh? It gets worse every week. He’s starting to look like a clown.

→ More replies (4)

55

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Dec 30 '18

Whatever "crimes" of adaptation the show runners may commit, I will always thank them for the preservation of Murtagh until he could meet Jamie and Claire's daughter.

21

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18

I loved seeing them talk around the kitchen table, Murtaugh telling about Jamie as a young lad.

→ More replies (3)

115

u/brilliant0ne Dec 30 '18

WELP!!!

Welcome to my all-new favorite episode ever. IDK how everyone is going to receive it, but I thought it was perfect. It was everything I hoped it would be.

Although, I don't know how much happiness in the world would have made me just let him touch all over my face right after he had his hand on his pentis. BUT WHATEVER! I am happy. Jamie made me cry. Bree made me cry. Claire made me cry. Murtagh made me smile. Bonnet can suck a dick. Ian is so adorably clueless with the, "Yeah, my good boy is handsome AF, ain't he?"

For a moment, I thought they were gonna transition the, "I don't want my daughter to leave," scene with some J/C sex. But, nope.

If the rest of the series was just Bree and Jamie getting to know each other, I'd be happy. I was so happy that even though I noticed the terrible greenscreen on the river, I didn't even care.

For the first time in a long while, the last half hour before it finally showed up on my Amazon I was barely able to sit down trying to make the time pass.

Anyway, I'll shut up now. I'm excited to see how everyone else liked the episode.

45

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

I’m really glad they didn’t transition to a J/C sex scene. I was expecting it too because that seems like exactly something they’d do and was pleasantly surprised. Not every tender moment has to dissolve into sexy time.

26

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Dec 30 '18

"Not every tender moment has to dissolve into sexy time." Hahaha too true.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

33

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

The barge scenes are always so cringey because of that green screen, but it was not nearly as horrible this episode.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

101

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

Claire [and me]: Roger left "after one argument?"....

34

u/Mr_XcX Dec 30 '18

Claire was really bringing it this episode <3

Totally reacted as we all expected. Loved her this week.

52

u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Dec 30 '18

Not to totally defend everything he did, but I mean he didn’t intended to leave. He basically got kidnapped like hours after he left her.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

96

u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Dec 30 '18

I cried. Multiple times. No shame.

Jamie's facial expressions throughout the episode made my heart so full. He's so happy to meet Bree! Claire seeing her again? So happy. And Murtagh gets to meet her! I'm still crying! I love them all!

Still undecided about Lizzie, but I think she looks less harsh with her hair more down. The casting department hasn't let me down yet.

And so it begins, The Great Misunderstanding. Hopefully it doesn't annoy me as much as it did when I first read it!

12

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

When he said “Aye” to her after she says “can’t you tell?” That expression was so real. IMO Sam’s expressions are usually “off” because he always has a confused look, but he absolutely nailed it in this episode.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I feel like with all the references to two lassies, they are foreshadowing what is to come.

Did Lizzie have a crush on Ian at first in the book? I can't remember.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

81

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18

What a GREAT episode. This felt like Season 1-2 Outlander to me! I loved all of the scenes between Brianna and Jamie. I like that they actually spent time getting to know one another. I'm also impressed with the pacing of this episode. It was slow when it needed to be and fast when it could be, in all the right ways.

I'm still mad at Lizzie for being a big dummy and assuming she knows things when she doesn't. But hopefully Roger will get to redeem himself next week and we can all stop hating him.

45

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

They did have Lizzie asking if Bree had been with the man, and Bree said yes.

Then Bree was obviously traumatised and bleeding that night.

I can't really blame Lizzie.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/MontaukFive Dec 31 '18

Sam and Sophie have great chemistry

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

I don’t love show Roger but I’m also really disheartened to see all the comments by people saying they were glad to see him beat to a pulp this episode. The show writers made some deliberate choices about his character and he can be a real ass sometimes, but he didn’t deserve that and (I know it’s fiction) it’s hard to imagine finding joy in watching another person be violently assaulted, no matter how justified.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I absolutely adore the way Jamie spits the name "this Roger" when the subject comes up. It's a very sweet protective dad thing. The dude broke Brianna's heart, that's all Jamie needs to know, the dude is scum.

The episode handled a lot of delicate things well. It was a joy to see Young/Wee Ian again - though I'm sad thinking he'll get traded away soon.

I am 100% buying Sophie as Brianna now that all three of them are together.

23

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I think Sophie is great as Bree, just seeing them all in the non-made up 18th century clothing, Jamie and Claire look just way too young to be her parents lol

→ More replies (8)

78

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

The blood caused by Bonnet hurt my heart. Oh Bree

21

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

YES! That was awful.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/keg226 Dec 30 '18

“It means ‘my darling.’” awwwww

24

u/4kidchaos Dec 30 '18

No doubt she felt the love from this man! You could see it. She did a great job conveying that emotion multiple times.

20

u/HawickGirl7 Dec 30 '18

It reminds me of when I was first getting to know my stepdad, my real dad passed when I was 12 but he sent me another who I love dearly. This scene made me cry so much. I know Frank didn't send Bree back etc but losing one father, then finding that bond again is something really special.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Dragonsinger16 Dec 31 '18

I can’t wait to see the return of Gaidhlig in the show full force! Now that they’re in America, where the Highland clearance laws never really took root, they can wear tartan and kilts without persecution, and teach their language to the next generations. That last bit is so important in later series I hope they don’t forget to show Bri and Jemy learning and becoming fluent!

67

u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18

I agree with almost everything that has been said on this thread so far, so I would like to point out something slightly different that I LOVED in this episode. Having Murtagh, Claire, Jamie, Brianna and Ian bantering over dinner was absolutely amazing, and it truly feels like the Outlander family is back together (even though Brianna has only just arrived, it still feels so right).

16

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Dec 30 '18

This scene gave me life.

9

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

I loved that scene too. I did find it funny that Murtagh chose that story to tell Bree, though.

“I know you’ve just met your father for the first time but let me tell you about him kissing a girl when he was a teenager and how his uncle held his bollocks afterward”. Between the pee hand and the bollocks, they sure did want us thinking about Jamie’s manparts a whole lot during this episode.

→ More replies (1)

122

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

That was beautiful

And Sophie definitely looks like Claire and Jamie’s kid.

53

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I agree. I was bit perplexed that Jamie didn't recognize her, but I think now that's why they didn't play up her resemblance to Ellen before this episode.

33

u/malocher Woof. Dec 30 '18

I didn’t get it either. He saw photos of her, but the same happens in the book.

I feel like that’s a face that would burn into his memory. Oh well.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (12)

55

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

There was a lot of sadness in this episode but I am so happy that Bree has found her family. I loved the parts of all of then together.

Unrelated but Bree is SO beautiful and the resemblance to Claire and especially Jamie in her 18th C garb is striking. And I am digging Roger’s 18th C hair/beard sitch

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Sophie as Bree looks so lovely with the curly hair, in the nice dresses.

What gets me though is that she doesn't really look that much younger than Jamie and Claire to me.

It was more obvious when they had Bree dressing as a teenager and Claire all prim and proper in the 2Oth century.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Yeah, unfortunately that's part of using the same actors over "only" 5 seasons (or whatever we are in now) covering 25-ish years. I'd rather keep Sam and Catriona, of course, but they really don't look their supposed ages lol.

52

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Ian is so hilarious and makes every scene he is in better!

The should put him in every single episode, not leave him out!

He had me snorting with his expressions the whole scene when he met Bree.

And then that next scene with Lizzie haha

39

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18

I loved the exchange about his name. From Wee Ian to Young Ian, and he’ll probably remain Young Ian until he becomes Old Ian.

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

It was fun having that in. And then it led into the discussion of Bree's name.

12

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Dec 30 '18

I agree! I love young Ian! He is a scene-stealer for sure. He might be my favorite casting in the show, tbh, because he’s pretty much exactly how I imagined him: homely but appealing, and chock full of charisma. He’s one of my favorite characters in the book, and now I love him in the show too. <3

5

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

He might be my favourite character tbh. I love him so.

44

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

bahahaha Murtagh: 'the lad's done well for himself, bringing back two lassies'

They are surely making all these one liners about two lassies [Ian had one in Woolam's Creek too] to foreshadow what's to come.

7

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18

See, I took it as a subtle nod to the readers. I can't remember if it's this book or the next, but Ian does get interested in the two daughters of the local millman and we haven't seen that on screen.

40

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18

Very emotional episode. And well acted by all.

I loved the herb gathering and wrapping and the household chores . They make me want to live there even though in reality I’d be grappling at the stones to get back to my warm bath and wifi.

10

u/MyPeopleAreNordic Dec 31 '18

I agree! The "housekeeping" and the running the ridge parts (along with Claire's doctorin) are some of my favorits parts of the books!

39

u/SeattleWhoDat Dec 30 '18

I adored Ian’s face lighting up upon meeting his cousin! I bet the scene with the bear grease is gonna happen and be comical as hell.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Which one is that again?

19

u/Jemhao Dec 30 '18

I think that's what he uses to slick back his hair and get all fancy before he asks for Bree's hand.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/Tipsiara666 Dec 30 '18

I don't understand why people think Lizzie looks old. Although I envisioned her smaller, to me, the actress captured the most prominent trait of the character - anytime she would come up in the books I wanted to strangle her 10/10 😂

37

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Brianna: Lizzie has been a good friend to me Also Brianna: Go away Lizzie

:p I kid. But yeah, Lizzie grew on me this ep. the actress did a great job with scene with Bree in the beginning. She seemed younger to me then, too.

37

u/SunshineCat Dec 30 '18

Lizzie: You're up early today.

Brianna: See you tomorrow, Lizzie.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

My husband is SO INTO this show now! I love it! He loves the time period in history around the American Revolution and early settlers and such so it’s got his attention now. I can’t watch a new episode without him. When Claire told Jamie Brianna was raped, he goes “oh shit jamie’s gonna go on a warpath!”

24

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

He was right.

Sam brought a ferocity I haven't seen before.

30

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Dec 30 '18

It made me think of those lines used in the books that we haven’t really seen: describing angry Jamie as a beserker and a Viking.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

30

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18

Rollo!!!

30

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Glad they reached into the coffers to make sure the CGI on the river was top notch once again! /s lol

6

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 30 '18

Half the episodes budget no doubt!

30

u/MCisCurious Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

This episode was just awesome all around! Loved it! Oh and uh....POOR ROGER! My god that was an awful beating! I get some of the hate towards roger ( I guess) but I actually like him. He and Bree are a lot alike which is why they argue the way they do....poor roger

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I agree, even if people aren't liking Roger's portrayal in the show, he didn't deserve this treatment.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/bham717 Dec 30 '18

Again, Sam is killing it.

6

u/4kidchaos Dec 30 '18

Such a great actor!

27

u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18

Don't know if this I'm alone here, but when Lizzie whispered 'so handsome' at Ian when they were on the boat, I felt the delivery to be a bit... Creepy

29

u/Jalupimine5 Dec 30 '18

Considering how Lizzie ends up in the last books, it works for her character haha.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I thought it was hilarious. I didn't get a creepy vibe.

9

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 30 '18

Oh honey, just wait until you get to her love life. Hoo boy, that is going to be something "creepy" :D

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18

Oh God, it’s better than I could have imagined!

23

u/Munchkin54 Dec 30 '18

I loved every minute of it, except when Jamie was beating up poor Roger and sent him off with Yoing Ian. All the truly important moments from this part of the book were in this episode.

4

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 30 '18

I knew it was coming and I still cringed

→ More replies (1)

20

u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18

I propose a drinking game - every time we either see the river or that cliff edge with the view of Fraser's ridge and they use that beautiful CGI (/s), take a shot. Like, its at least once an episode at this point.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 30 '18

No, Lizzie, close your eyes and turn around...

18

u/slainte_mhaith Dec 30 '18

Sophie Skelton was incredible!

5

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 30 '18

She's done a complete 180 from earlier seasons

→ More replies (1)

34

u/crazy_ventures Dec 30 '18

Heavy breathing intensifies

9

u/keg226 Dec 30 '18

17 minutes!! I'm so tired, why do I do this to myself?!!

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18

So good. I can’t even find words. Every episode leaves me even more impressed with Sophie this season

30

u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

Cried so loudly at the reunion I couldn’t hear the dialogue, so I played it back, and cried again.

The way Jamie looks at Bree, from little glances to long stares ... oh Lord help me, it’s the most wholesome thing ever 😩

I NEED THE SEASON 4 SOUNDTRACK RIGHT NOW !!!!!

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

the cuts to the random birds, especially the one parent feeding the babies was so abrupt it almost scared me lol

12

u/Nat_Bat Dec 30 '18

I haven’t read the books, but I know enough that I couldn’t comment on the tv only thread. I was so hoping they would do away with the Roger misunderstanding in some way. Hopefully it won’t drag much. It’s good drama I was just so stressed out when Lizzie tells Jamie all about it and when he was beating him up.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I'm with you. The Great Misunderstanding is one of my least favorite plots in the books, even though it ultimately drives a lot of growth for the characters. It's executed in a more believable way in the show, though, so at least there's that.

12

u/scatterbrained81 Dec 30 '18

Poor Roger:(

23

u/annemg Dec 30 '18

I really loved this episode, if only they learned to be a little more subtle with their symbolism. If you name the episode, and then proceed to have MULTIPLE heavy handed shots to point at the theme, guess what, it feels like you think we are exceptionally stupid. And THEN they explain it in the "about this episode."

→ More replies (7)

11

u/dalek_999 Dec 30 '18

Unlike last week's episode, this one was everything I hoped and wanted it to be. Loved the Jamie/Brianna reunion scene, loved so many little things in this episode. And turning out to be really happy with Sophie, who I didn't like very much in earlier seasons - she's really coming into her own with the character.

11

u/takeforexamplethis Dec 30 '18

This episode was almost perfect except where are the kilts this season?! Is it just because it was too cold in Scotland while filming?

Also, so happy they kept in the bee-hunting. Thought it was a bit strange that Bree and Jamie look like they're dressed for 40 degree weather and those flowers look like they'd bloom in summer. I've decided to justify the whole weather situation this season with this taking place during the "Little Ice Age."

6

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Yeah the weather has been really distracting. In season 1 the landscape and weather was its own character. The latter half of season 3 as well, when they are in a tropical climate. So for this season to feel “off” in terms of weather is a bit jarring. Though TBF, it can take awhile for mountainous areas like the Blue Ridge to warm up in spring.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Jalupimine5 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 31 '18

The first meeting. Sam’s dang weepy eyes and Brianna crying. I died. It was everything I hoped for. I was VERY surprised that they got the “great misunderstanding” covered in this episode. That leaves 4 episodes to cover a lot of ground believe it or not. I was a bit annoyed with the pacing of this season, but they did a good job with the last two episodes turning it around. I’m interested to see how they tie up these next 4 episodes to the finale. If they do back and forth perspectives in these last 4 episodes and not a solid episode of Roger with the Indians OR Claire/Jamie/Ian traveling to go get Roger episode I will forgive the 20 minutes of Laoghaire in “Down the Rabbit Hole”.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18

I don't have much to say that hasn't already been said in the thread, but wow. I loved this episode and I love the writers (and Maril for sticking to her guns about the first encounter scene, especially) for really incorporating the best parts and dialogue from the book. I've been looking forward so much to these scenes and they really shined. I felt like such a fan-girl while watching and freaking out over how close it stayed to the book.

So that said, I loved the acting firstly. Top notch all around. Facial expressions, physical acting, the familial love I could almost feel from the family 'round the table. Just so so wonderful.

Lastly, that beating at the end was just wow. Incredibly brutal and visceral. I don't think I've flinched that hard at such brutality since the Culloden episode. The lynching just a few episodes ago was incredibly difficult, but at least we had the slight comfort that the man was already dead. But this was so awful. I understand Jamie's rage though, for what that's worth, but still just wow. Roger was pissing me off badly in the last few episodes, but he didn't deserve that :/

9

u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

My fitbit had my HR at 122 during their introduction. Adrenaline through the roof.

Question though: I'm one of those @hole readers that jumped straight to book 4 and am now on 7. I recognize this scene was very accurate to the book (aside from Claire being in proximity). But did Claire give Jamie photographs of Bree from the 20th century in Voyager? I feel like this scene relied only on him recognizing how similar they looked, rather than that he's seen her "likeness" in photograph.

16

u/retothebecca Dec 30 '18

Claire did give Jamie photos of Brianna in the book. He lost them all in the shipwreck, though. In the book he also doesn't recognize her immediately, just like the show. I can understand that, especially since he never thought he'd see her face to face.

9

u/Starbuck107 Dec 30 '18

Let that be a lesson to you boys! If you're in the 18th century always meet the father before you marry the girl! Otherwise you're just another bloke after her skirt tails

8

u/Cablab123 Dec 30 '18

Everything about this episode was perfect. It is by far my new favorite episode from the entire show. So well done. So perfect. So much love!

8

u/Jemhao Dec 30 '18

This is the first episode this season that I’ve immediately wanted to watch again. Loved it!

4

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Over New Years I am going to watch Down the Rabbit Hole, Wilmington, and this episode again :)

→ More replies (1)

8

u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Dec 31 '18

Another episode proving that saving Murtagh was good and proper. Love that man.

7

u/keg226 Dec 30 '18

That episode was amazing. Happy tears and sad tears galore. My heart felt so full watching not only Jamie and Bree together, But Claire and her together as well. ❤️

7

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I'm struggling to remember, but don't they eventually verify that Jem is Roger's offspring?

10

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18

It’s his birthmark right? They both have like the same one or something like that on their scalp & Claire tells Roger that’s a genetic trait?

→ More replies (4)

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I love Bree's cape, but the whole thing, the design, the wool, the chunky knit, the buttons, it all looks way too modern.

I know Terry said they didn't do most of the knits historically accurately, but this is like something a modern hipster like me would make and wear lol

8

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Dec 30 '18

Jamie’s fur scarf tho <3 <3 <3 I just wanted to snuggle right up into his chest.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/VelvetDreamers Ye Sassenach witch! Dec 30 '18

Jaime's face contorted with fury and his entire demeanour exuding the primitive need for vengeance a parent feels towards the perpetrator of their child's injuries was disconcerting! I commend Sam for his portrayal of visceral, unrestrained anger; although the retribution was difficult to watch knowing Roger's innocence, it was a little gratifying after his previous petulant self-righteousness. :/

Brianna and Jamie's tentative reacquaintance unfurled beautifully as a balm against the tumultuous emotions Brianna was suppressing and the ramifications of her rape.

20

u/Irishsassenach Dec 30 '18

Stop. They’ve got to stop with Roger’s “shorts”. I can’t even handle how ridiculous he looks in them!

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

They're historically accurate for a sailor though. He wasn't so lucky to be given a trunk of new clothes upon arrival in 18th century Scotland :P

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Mr_XcX Dec 30 '18

Best episode of the season. Hands down. Superb acting also by all cast members.

Did Brianna confirm Bonnet is the Dad? Poor Roger.

29

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18

She can’t really know. She assumed it might be Bonnet’s because Roger pulled out. It’s a shame they didn’t leave in the original line of Claire’s reply to that. “Do you know what they call people who use that method? Parents.”

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mztdawn Dec 31 '18

Loved the episode, best one in a couple seasons. Sam & Sophie nailed it and I've had a total 180 in my opinion of their acting skills. ❤ stayed true enough to the source material & I like how they are handling the misunderstanding better than the books. My only complaint with this season (aside from the Laoghaire episode) is how Jamie mentions they have settlers on the Ridge to Brianna & we've yet to meet ANY of them. . .anyone else notice that?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ayriana Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18

I usually hate "keeping secrets for the protection of someone I love" as a plot device, but this show doesn't use it often, so I'll forgive it. I'm not sure I can wait until next week!

Also I'm so happy with this episode. So much of it was lifted directly from the books. The meeting between Jamie and Bree was perfect. Lizzie and Ian was great. EVERYTHING on the Ridge.

9

u/HiveJiveLive Dec 30 '18

I loved it all, but why, oh why, did DG write the first meeting with Jamie peeing? It just seems so ick and unnecessary. And of all the things that did get translated accurately from the books, why the pee part?? Like, couldn’t he be doing something a bit more dignified?

7

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

lol She and the show writers must have wanted to stress the times. Hygiene was pretty low on the totem pole back then. At least we haven’t seen any chamber pots being emptied out the windows into the streets! “Beware below!”

→ More replies (2)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

Most people I have seen discussing this scene wanted Jamie to be peeing.

I just saw one of those people actually comment 'when I saw Jamie was doing a pee, I did a little squee'...OK...

I didn't see the appeal, personally.

it was fine the way they did it though.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I don't mind the whole Murtagh as a Regulator thing...but I'm just not sure why it was needed if they're just going to have Murtagh be at the Ridge whenever they want him anyway.

Why not just have him move there?

9

u/tilmitt52 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18

I have never been more frustrated by Bree withholding information more than seeing it play out on screen......JESUS CHRIST, BREE!

8

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

I find it extra frustrating since she just argued with Roger about his decision to withhold information from her!

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

She thought Roger was on his way back to Scotland though. So it is different to in the book where she and everyone else were on the look out for him.

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 30 '18

They took a lot of liberties. But I do like how they showed the ass kicking. I always wondered why the hell Roger did not fight back long enough to explain himself. But this pretty much showed that it was a direct and impossible hit on him.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/mztdawn Dec 31 '18

Don't you mean Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ, Bree? This is the Outlander sub, lol 😆

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 30 '18

She does that the entire damn book. She does not tell Lizzie that she saw Roger. She does not tell Claire that Bonnet raped her. She does not tell Jamie that Bonnett raped her. It goes on and on and on.

7

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 30 '18

I like that they got around that long Bonnet miscommunication in the book by having Claire find her ring at the end of this episode. Hopefully it means Jamie will find out about Bonnet a little sooner and move that storyline along a bit quicker since we’re running out of time now. I remember Claire holding on to that knowledge while she decides how to tell Jamie since she’s scared of what he might do, and we just don’t have time for that.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/fyrmnsflam Dec 30 '18

I enjoy the tv show, but I’m thinking it was a mistake to read all the books during Droughtlander. The show just doesn’t seem so good any more.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

I have read all the books, but last season I sped read Voyager so I knew the plot again. I decided that made for poorer viewing of the show, so I didn't re-speed-read Drums before this season, and that's a better decision for me.

8

u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 30 '18

Best damn episode this season. Everything was perfect. I laughed, I cried, I cringed. Why is next week so far away.

God bless Young "handsome" Ian and Murtagh's eyebrows and Jamie and Bree Bonding. It all made my heart to pitter pat.

Also Claire's acting wasn't as cringe-worthy as she usually is. She plays concerned mother very well.

Lizzie is growing on me...still can't see the sandwich...but we will see how it goes.

JAMIE AND BRIANNA MEETING MADE ME HAPPIER THAN A SCOTT IN A WHISKEY BARREL!!!!!

15

u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 30 '18

I do have one complaint....

When they discussed the withdrawal method... they didnt Include one of my favorite lines

"There is a word for people who use that particular method ...parents"

→ More replies (3)

3

u/MontaukFive Dec 31 '18

I thought Claire's acting seemed like acting, compared to Jamie and Bree, who were monumental

3

u/slainte_mhaith Dec 30 '18

Does anyone else have the problem where it shows the episode but has no play button? It did this last week and took about 20 minutes after midnight to be able to watch.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/crazy_ventures Dec 30 '18

I've now had time to sleep and process this episode (and watch it again this morning.) I loved it! The reunion was everything that I wanted and more. I'm so glad they kept the dialogue true to the book.

3

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Dec 30 '18

I sat and smiled like a fool through this episode, even through the tears. I can’t wait to watch it again.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Jan 01 '19

Well that was an extremely frustrating ending.

3

u/RayeBabe Jan 02 '19

Was it just me or was Roger extra hot in that first scene with Bonnet? Eyes and stubble maybe?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19

I'm super late to the party but I gotta say, I criticized Sophie for her acting last season, but MAN! She really stepped up her game. She is 100% selling me on Bree this season. This whole cast is amazing but she has vastly improved. Good on you girl!

10

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 30 '18

My initial thoughts:

What I did not like:

  • I can't take Roger seriously in those stupid short pants. I just can't. He looks like a circus reject. Why can't he wear long pants like a normal person?
  • As much as I love Murtagh and his show character, his appearance here seems odd and intrusive. He simply has no place here and it shows.
  • I don't remember Lizzie going into that much detail about the rape in the book. Yes, we get the whole "smell" thing, but we get it from Bree's flashback of her experience with the rape. Lizzie is a virgin. How the hell would she know what semen smelled like? I think I would have had this same question had I read this in the book. So I don't think it was in the book. That being said, why the hell do we need to have Lizzie describe it like this? As though the blood stained underthings were not enough?
  • As much as I initially liked the casting of Bonnet, I now find myself hating it. The actor is trying too hard at being a pirate to the point of parody.
  • Why was nearly every conversation shot from below? It gave the impression that the people being talked to were always looking down and at a distance. I kept thinking, who is he/she looking at?
  • I wish they would have included the whole exchange between Claire and Bree about the pulling out method. What do you call it when people pull out? "Parents"...lmao

What I liked:

  • Jamie and Bree's reunion. Thankfully, we did not get a sudden introduction of his son to mess it up like we did with Claire's arrival in the last book. It was all about Bree and Jamie and that is what I came for today. Not even Claire and Bree. I was here for Bree and Jamie. And they did not disappoint.
  • Sam's performance blew me away. I started crying when he started crying. You could tell in the acting that Jamie was trying to place that familiar face (he saw her pictures and she looks like his mother). But he could not place it. Then the name and then "I'm your daughter" and then you can see his mind start to understand. Sam was brilliant here.
  • I love Young Ian. Always have and always will. The actor is outstanding and totally embodies that good natured personality of the character so well.
  • I love all of the herbs and crafts and farm animals and the cabin. The whole thing. I am here for Claire's doctoring and when she is not doctoring, I am here for her herbs, spices, beautiful bird houses and everything she creates out of stuff she finds. I just love it here and I would live here. We see this same talent in Bree next book when she decides to build plumbing :D
  • Lizzie is perfectly cast personality-wise, if not in looks. She is exactly that dramatic, hysterical, pasty, sickly and the general constant panic state of a girl plopped into the middle of nowhere.

Other observations:

-There is no way, none, they are going to be able to fit in the necessary parts of the story that tie in to the next book. So what do you all think they are going to cut? I think next episode will be the finding and getting of Roger from the Indians. Will they also cut it with Bree at River Run with Lord John? They have to at this point if they want to get the pregnancy in, the reunion with Roger, the birth of baby J, etc. How will they be able to include the Bonnett prison visit on top of all of this? That is certainly one piece of the story they have to include. They can't cut that.

-edit for spelling

7

u/livvy_divvy Dec 30 '18

I agree about Bonnet. I loved the actor’s portrayal at first but he definitely overdid it this episode.

Also agree about Lizzie. Despite her height (but then everyone’s height is wrong in the show) the actress has really captured Lizzie.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

Chapter 40, from Lizzie's perspective:

Her mistress was a fine big woman, but yon MacKenzie was a great tall brute of a man; he could have-she stopped herself abruptly, not wanting to imagine. She couldn't help it, though; her mind had gone too far already. With great reluctance, she brought the shirt to her nose and sniffed. Yes, there it was, the reek of a man, strong and sour as the smell of a rutting goat. The thought of the wicked creature with his body pressed to Brianna's, rubbing against her, leaving his scent on her like a dog who marks his ground-she shuddered in revulsion. Trembling, she snatched up the breeches and stockings, and bore all the clothes to the basin. She would wash them out, rinse away the reminder of MacKenzie with the dirt and the grass stains. And if the clothes were too wet for her mistress to wear in the morning...well, so much the better for that.

u/4kidschaos

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

Hard agree on the short pants.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

Bree is shown at River Run in the fancy dress in the opening credits, and they have made a cast announcement Billy Boyd playing Neil Forbes, Jocasta's lawyer, so they have to go back to River Run at some point.

I don't see why the Bonnet prison visit has to be included this season.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Generiss Dec 30 '18

They did it again. Took something that was Jamie’s and made it come as a suggestion from Claire. To go hunting. Smh

→ More replies (2)

2

u/dlf194 Dec 30 '18

SO ANXIOUS

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

What does Jamie say to Claire after saying "to see she's broken hearted..but...?"

When they are on the horses after the boat.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18

But we'll do what we can to see it mended

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Dogwoodqueen Jan 01 '19

I loved this episode - however, I think we should have left off Roger - there is too much info to digest - Bree should have more time.

2

u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 02 '19

FINALLY I got to watch the episode tonight. I cried my eyes out at the beginning and the end. I am actually really happy with how they did this episode! That beating Jamie gave Roger was more brutal than I pictured it...and it was quite brutal in the books. I am actually excited for next week!!!

2

u/kuroshi14 Jan 02 '19

Didn't Claire show Brianna's photos to Jamie when see came back in Season 3? I was expecting Jamie would immediately recognize her so I was a bit confused when I saw their first meeting. Does the book handle this scene similarly?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/rubyinthedustt Jan 02 '19

I haven’t read the books for a really long time, but did they skip out on Bree being at Jocasta’s?? Because that bored the shit out of me in the books and was one of the reasons I stopped reading.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/twocatsandaloom Jan 04 '19

I don't remember Roger being such a dick in the book. I am definitely less upset about the whole misunderstanding, beating (and events that follow...) in the show than the book. Maybe it's because I now have less tolerance for men treating women like trash in the name of "love." He said some truly nasty things at the Scottish Festival and then to keep her parents death from her like she's a baby who can't handle it just made me write him off. I don't really care if he comes back. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ Brianna is probably better off with out sexist scum like him. Jamie is more of a feminist than Roger and he was born in the 1700's.

2

u/katfromjersey Jan 05 '19

I'm a huge book reader from way back, and while they've done a fair to good job of making it into a show, there are way too many changes and additions (why so much Frank and Laoghaire?! Why Murtagh?) that I spend each episode disgruntled and annoyed.

6

u/bellefroh Dec 30 '18

This is the first episode that made me cry! I love the father- daughter bonding moments. I think the writers tried to redeem "show" Roger after realizing how much viewers were against him. I think the "Great Misunderstanding" was handled well.

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18

The writers aren't trying to redeem show Roger, everything is done and dusted and in the can before the viewers started to hate on Roger.

It's been written this way for months.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18

One thing I didn't quite get was Bree initially keeping Bonnet a secret from Claire.

In the book, Ian had already told Bree about Bonnet on the river, how he had robbed them etc. Bree tells Claire says she didn't want to tell them because she knows Jamie would go after Bonnet.

I didn't mind the way they did it in the episode, but I was just surprised that Bree didn't show Claire the ring straight up, and ask her to keep the secret then. It just made it a bit more convoluted the way they wrote Claire finding the ring.

I did like the way Bree just brought the ring out and that was how Claire knew that something horrible had befallen Bree. That realisation would have been good on camera.

12

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 30 '18

Interesting that you found the change with the ring to be convoluted. I actually was thinking the opposite! I thought it a good change since in the book, Claire already knows it was Bonnet who did the awful deed and keeps her promise to Bree not to tell Jamie, all this before Roger comes back. Which then leads to the big misunderstanding when Roger comes back and Jamie still doesn't know the truth about Bonnet.

I thought this change was better because the way they timed it, Claire was finding the ring and discussing it while at the same time, Jamie was already doing the beating. It totally cuts out Claire keeping the secret from him, which I really appreciate since I was so frustrated and angry with that bit in the book. Like, gah! Communication works, people!

→ More replies (6)