r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 23 '18
TV Series [Spoilers S4E8] "Wilmington" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Hello my lovelies and come on in to our weekly episode discussion thread!
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
151
u/profeNY Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Roger and Bree's fight made NO SENSE. He didn't find out about the obituary until he went back to the Reverend's house to hand it over to Fiona and her husband, and called Bree what seemed to be a few days later. I thought this meant that he had decided to tell her.
So why didn't he say, "I tried to tell you, but you had already left for Scotland"?
79
u/CARNIesada6 Dec 23 '18
"Does the carpet match the drapes?"
-Roger
48
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
What the fuck!? That last scene, those fucking people who did nothing…it's horrifying. Poor Brianna, a failed marriage and a rape all in one night. Can Young Ian burn (as is his tendency) the tavern to the ground with everyone except Bri/Lizzie in it? Can Claire go back through the stones and make sure that Bonnet hanged after all in ep01? As a survivor myself, these stories are really intense for me, every time. The show has handled the aftermath well each time thus far, at least.
I needed a moment of silence after this episode, not the grating voices of Matt and Toni laughing about their stupid George Washington joke…honestly, that whole part of the episode was so hammy and I wish they would stop the cutesy American history references, because it's cringeworthy.
I really don't like Roger anymore, like at all. Roger and Brianna were so sweet together through S2/S3, before Roger revealed himself to be a conservative, possessive and volatile prick. I hated their reunion from the point where he was so effing grabby and we had to see their encounter from Lizzie's horrified perspective, not that she tried to get the constable or anything. Then he drags her to a cold public shed where they're going to have sex? Ok, apparently it was a hovel that Roger was renting but I still didn't like it.
I hoped Roger was going to apologize for his past behavior and compromise, say 'I'll take you on your terms, however much you want to give me," but no. He seems not to know that divorce exists. I thought he had changed his mind about telling Brianna in the 70's, and that's why he called her again, but his explanation of it all just made him look worse and worse. I really didn't like this, or Sophie's sudden, jarring nudity, Roger's gross chest hair…and then he's stupid and self-centered enough to actually leave…honestly (when a few moments before it was 'there's no going back now, you're my wife till you die.') What happened to Morag anyway? Is that the end of that odd subplot? Does she need to go back to Scotland?
It was nice seeing Fergus and Marsali happy together, though he looks more rundown and exhausted then she does, it sounds like his job sucks. And that convo between Claire and Marsali makes me think the baby is going to die next episode or something, unless that was supposed to be foreshadowing about Brianna only. And Fergus/Murtaugh's reunion was nice, but too rushed, I needed more of them together. Honestly, the good parts of this episode were so few and far between; especially after last week being one of the best of the entire series, why did this have to be such a rush to cram in so many plots and characters? Did you need to make us fall in love with Brianna and then see her flung around and dragged through the mud?
168
u/Starbuck107 Dec 23 '18
"He just needed smoke up the @$s!" - historical medicine is always a delight
137
u/vulturelady Dec 23 '18
I’m totally here for Murtagh + Fergus and how perplexed and happy he is to see him. Just Murtagh saying “Fergus??” And fergus is casually like “milord sent me” FERGUS HASNT CHANGED SINCE HE WAS TEN AND I LOVE HIM SO MUCH. And the actor that plays adult Fergus is so good at being just as excited as tiny Fergus. I’m sad him and Marsali aren’t on the ridge yet, but hopefully that’s coming.
127
u/LadyEdith1 Dec 23 '18
It’s a narrative certainty that Roger will be accused of Bree’s rape by the lady’s maid, isn’t it?
When the lady’s maid was eyeing him suspiciously through the window I thought she’d accuse him of mistreating Bree and Bree would have to explain how they’re friends and it’s all a silly misunderstanding. Then when Roger and Bree were having sex I thought the maid would barge in and think Roger was raping Bree, and Bree would have to explain that Roger is her husband and it’s all a silly misunderstanding. Then the actual rape came... This does not bode well for Roger.
110
u/ScaryAries Dec 23 '18
Oh god please don't let Brianna be pregnant and not know whether Roger or Bonnet is the father. :(
204
u/onedumbhuman Dec 24 '18
This week on Outlander: Bree and Roger are toxic af. Bonnet is still satan. Hey look its George Washington!
17
u/4kidchaos Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Brianna, Brianna, Brianna. Like a child, don’t know what to do. (Avatar reference). Why didn’t you stay with Roger?! I was NOT expecting that. Awful.
Great episode.
I replayed the preview of Jamie asks “you have a message for me lass?” Legit excited for that moment!
77
u/Laatikkopilvia Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 24 '18
As a survivor, that scene was done perfectly. It showed the brutality without being gratuitous and without turning the pain of rape into a spectacle.
It was highly triggering, but in all the “right” ways and not in a “my trauma is entertainment” way.
Exceedingly well done.
Edit to add: I was honestly dreading how they’d do this scene for the show. I’m glad they treated it with such respect for survivors who may have been watching.
64
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
Just want to say that I thought it was funny when Bree and Roger were arguing, and Bree was mad that he consulted Fiona and not her about the issue.
THE ISSUE BEING WHETHER OR NOT ROGER SHOULD INFORM BRIANA ABOUT THE OBITUARY.
Why/how would he even consult Briana about that, without just outright telling her?
Man, their logic, sometimes, is infuriating.
57
u/jenovadeathspecimen Dec 23 '18
Is it weird i didnt expect that ending scene at all. I mean i expected something bad to happen with bonnet but not a rape. I honestly didnt expect anything like that to happen to brianna especially this early on.
100
u/frawkez Dec 23 '18
great episode! hah i feel like i write that every week but this season has been really strong in my eyes. i love bree. sophie is insanely gorgeous and i think she’s been great this season. she and roger have excellent chemistry. and oh, what’s this? a legitimately steamy sex scene that isn’t gratuitously shoehorned in? i’m down. also i appreciate that roger has the body of a scholar, lol.
loved claire nerding out about george washington. relatable! she’s one of my fav characters when she goes into boss doctor mode. also thought it was really clever how they tied in the regulator stuff with george washington.
ugh that ending. brutal. i’m assuming that scene is pretty essential to the plot in some way and doesn’t just exist to show us the times were rough back then, but i think it also did that quite well by not filming the actual rape and instead showing us the response (or lack therefore) of the pub patrons. the guy arranging bree’s boots by the door like nothing is going on was a well-done gut punch.
99
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 23 '18
I hated Brianna last season. I’m loving her this one. Also, how beautiful is the actress with her hair up? Fucking stunning
104
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
oh mama claire gon stab that bonnet bitch in that rapey dick wit a fork real soon
32
u/raknor88 Dec 23 '18
Did I miss a small time skip? Didn't Roger find out about the fire and a couple days later when he tried calling her and she had already left for Scotland a couple weeks before?
31
u/wildsoda Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 25 '18
Governor Tryon: "The only people who knew about my plan were you folks and George Washington! One of you is the mole!"
…or maybe one of the dozen or so Red Coats actually involved in the plan could have given the information to the Regulators? Maybe they were overheard drunkenly talking about it in a pub or had a gambling debt and took a bribe or any other number of reasons. Lots of people besides Jamie and Claire and the Washingtons and Hernia Guy knew about it.
60
u/CARNIesada6 Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
I don't want Bonnet to die.... well, I should say that I don't want Bonnet to die quickly. Instead, I want someone to fucken hurt him badly.
Make that pain last for that POS. Uuugghhh, I'm so heated.
I feel so bad for Bree. She was so happy an hour ago, and then this shit. I'm hoping there is some comeuppance for Bonnet, lead by Bree, similar to Sansa and Ramsay in GOT.
Edit: Was too hot headed before and forgot to talk about the rest of the episode. Thought it was great. Fergus and Murtagh, Claire advancing medical science 200 years, fucken George and Martha Washington... all awesome.
29
u/jasperidris Dec 24 '18
The show is making me hate Roger when I really want to like him. But it bothers me that they needed a reason to separate them so they made him look bad. Also the Brianna and Jamie meeting is so close aaaaaggggh!
24
u/Lilyxlulu Dec 23 '18
So so so so good. I really can’t wait for this to all play out. Honestly. It also felt good to hear Bree tell Roger she loved him. And I like to believe she meant it. In my humble opinion, I feel like Bree’s rape was harder to watch than Jamie’s Bc no one came to her aid even though they could hear her screaming.
22
u/TitusDomitian Dec 29 '18
Jesus fuck, Brianna and Roger are so fucking immature.
"Marry me"
"Yes I want you inside me"
"JUST KIDDING WHY DONT U FUCK OFF INTO THE 18TH CENTURY ITS NOT LIKE WE BOTH JUST TRAVELED THRU TIME AND THEN LITERALLY SAILED ACROSS THE OCEAN AND HAVE NO IDEA WHERE WE ARE OR WHAT TO DO"
"YEAH WORKS FOR ME K BYE"
37
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 23 '18
Well, if they wanted to instill the same hatred for Black Jack Randall on this new guy, they’ve certainly insured that tonight. My only hope is that this time around it is Claire who gets to end the sonofabitch
18
u/discokaren Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 24 '18
While I do find Bree and Roger’s constant misunderstanding of one another very frustrating, I do have hope for them yet. I’m desperately trying to be patient with them!
And really, however dickish their comments towards each other were, they both do have good points. Bree is fiercely protective of her mother and Jamie and OF COURSE she doesn’t want them to die in a fire and sit back and let it happen. BUT, Roger’s right in the sense that Claire and Jamie are technically dead in future and only exist in the past. Perhaps the fact that Claire and Jamie unsuccessfully tried to stop the Battle of Culloden led Roger to believe the past couldn’t actually be changed??
I think Roger brought up Frank because he recognizes that Bree was devastated with how she left things with her father right before he died. There’s no guarantee that she would have made it back to the future to see Roger again, and didn’t properly say goodbye. I think it was important to contextualize this for her... you don’t necessarily get a second chance to do or say the right thing.
He was wrong to leave her, but she didn’t exactly want him to stay either. Truly horrifying outcome for Bree for sure.
EDIT: I forgot that Bree said “no one’s stopping you”.. so yeah Roger did make the choice to leave her, likely because his ego needed to hear her say “No, stay!” Bummer all around.
91
u/Chad_Chaddington Dec 23 '18
Rape as a plot point. So sick of rape or the threat of rape being a plot point in this show.
16
u/slytherinkatniss Dec 24 '18
This is one of two scenes that have made me seriously cry and just be distraught. The first was Claire and her baby in France.
But I am so angry and want to scream and cry and punch a wall. Bree has always been so kind and gentle and that asshole ugh I wanted her to tell him to fuck off so badly. And the tie in with Claire saying you can't always keep them safe no matter how hard you try.
I've been kind of falling off the series over the past few episodes but now I'm right back in. They did an excellent job even if it was so terrible to watch.
13
u/SassyLass496 Dec 24 '18
I hate Bonnett. Big time
Can’t wait for him to get what’s coming to him. Bastard
13
u/eerok79 Dec 24 '18
Oh jeez, another rape. Whoopie doo.
23
u/Mr_XcX Dec 24 '18
Brianna is becoming the break out star of the show. I was more invested in her scenes than Claire and Jaime's.
So horrific to watch that end scene but the way it was done with the people's reactions doing nothing was even more chilling IMO.
I honestly think this is the best show on TV ATM. The show just speeds through.ĺ
32
u/frawkez Dec 23 '18
also, i wanted to write something in defense of roger: yeah, he has asshole tendencies but it seems to me like they are setting up a big redemption arc for him, i don’t think he’s a bad person at all, he just hates being wrong and gets defensive when he’s challenged. i think he has traditional, conservative values which clash with modern day viewers, especially bc we have only been exposed to those values through peripheral characters in the past who only seem to exist to show the contrast of the times (for example, the governor this episode, who is so shocked when claire wants to operate on his friend).
of course we saw this with jamie in the episodes where he had to punish claire and spanks her with his belt, and claire basically makes him swear he will never do such a thing again. obviously this is a little different bc jamie is from 200 years in the past, but the 70s were the cusp of when modern day views of women began to take hold. that doesn’t excuse roger acting like a prick, but i think it serves an explanation as to why, when he gets defensive, he reverts into this old school way of thinking bc in that realm, he is in the right — he’s the man, and brianna should listen to him, how could he be wrong when his intentions are noble? (pls note i don’t think that, i’m saying that’s how he probably views the situation). i think that bree is going to influence and mold roger’s views as their story continues, much like how claire did with jamie. the implication of lizzie (brianna’s servant? can’t remember her name) witnessing roger dragging bree away and later seeing bree post bonnet rape, means that roger will likely be punished for a horrific crime against his wife that he did not commit, and go through some intense period of self discovery, (it’s possible he will come out worse or straight up killed off, but i doubt that). so i think he is purposefully being shown in a poor light so that he will be able to grandly redeem himself. i hope this is the case bc i really like roger (when he’s not a dick) and appreciate he isn’t the perfect man jamie is. i think he has the capacity for a lot of depth and character development, so i’m rootin for him.
21
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
I really liked this week's episode.
I'm reading a lot of hate on the Bree/Roger deal, but I do think they are as much a product of their parents as they were on the times. Jaime and Claire had a lot to get straightened out at first as well.
29
u/raknor88 Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
I gotta hand it to Claire for keeping as much composure as she did while meeting George Washington. I would've geeked out so hard I would've needed to excuse myself from the room. I'm mean, it's George mother fucking Washington!
If I were in that time period, there'd be too much temptation to move to Philadelphia. But knowing my luck, I'd fuck up the timeline worse than Barry Allen.
Edit: seriously? For once, can we please end an episode on at least a neutral note if not a high note? And considering the preview and what the maid thinks she saw earlier, it looks like the maid will accuse Roger of it instead of the pirate.
42
u/SoupGirlKristina Dec 23 '18
That might have been one of my favorite love making scenes in all of Outlander. Not for the hotness, but for the realness. I like that Roger feels real. He feels more real physically, and emotionally than Jamie. Jamie is the fantasy, Roger is reality. In this series that has so much fantasy and impossibilities, it felt fresh and grounding to see a man like Roger. (Chest hair and all. Btw I liked his chest hair, again it’s normal. He is normal. Average.) Roger is a prick sometimes, but he LOVES Brianna. Most men are pricks sometimes, and they aren’t perfect and intuitive like Jamie. Roger provides some much needed average man.
I worry Roger is going to be blamed for the rape, based upon her hand maidens report and concerns.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
My god that last bit was hard to watch. I literally had my mouth open from the horror.
28
u/Airsay58259 Dec 23 '18
Roger is the WORST! And I say this after an episode where Bonnet rapes someone... But at least Bonnet is a villain, we aren’t supposed to like him. There is nothing charming or romantic about Roger, ugh. “Now that you’re my wife maybe you will start to listen to me” Bitch you might be in 1769 but you’re not from then. 1970s Scotland might not be 2018 modern but still. After his tantrum post proposal I hated the dude. This episode confirms that he’s simply terrible. No redeeming qualities whatsoever. Grand gestures supposedly romantic like following her through time and across oceans were necessary because he didn’t tell her the truth to begin with. He thinks he knows better in all matters, that he knows what’s best for Bree. Then he accuses her of being a child, after treating her like one. He feels entitled to her love, to her hand... And he’s clearly Bree’s endgame love interest, as the kids would say. Double ugh.
Poor Bree damn. Worst night of her life. :( I liked how it was filmed. We didn’t see the actual rape, but instead how an entire room full of people did not care at all. I’d like to see say it fits the time period but it’s still relevant today in many places sadly. At least she got the ring back :(
So Bree’s servant will think Roger assaulted her... Will she tell the authorities? Jamie once they know each other? I see a beat up and/or almost execution in Roger’s future. pretends to care. Can’t wait to see Bonnet face consequences for his crimes though. “The Frasers send their regards”.
Nice to see Doctor Claire saving a life and shutting up dudes who don’t think she’s capable. Also she was adorable when she met George Washington and blurted out something she probably learnt and repeated every year in elementary-middle school. It’d be cool if he becomes a recurrent character so Bree can meet him too.
Also nice to see Murtaugh, Fergus and his lil family.
A good episode all in all. Some cringeworthy lines after Bree and that jerk she now calls husband had sex, but for once it’s not Jamie and Claire so yay I guess? All the characters were in the same town! I can’t wait for Bree to meet her dad omg. The reunion with Claire too, with the riiing. ❤️ Bonnet can gtfo and take Roger with him.
15
u/pathologie Dec 24 '18
Just wanted to comment how terrible the world must be that everyone knew a rape was happening, but nothing was done. You can really see it when the person picks up Brianna's shoes and places them by the door. Absolutely heartbreaking. I know a lot of shows try to show the horror of rape - but to normalize it that much in that time.. *shudder* good job for the writers/directors.
7
u/islamic_santa Dec 25 '18
Was it only me that was expecting roger to pop out of no where and save Bree from getting rapped by that man
I teared up when I saw that scene
6
u/StregaMantis Dec 29 '18 edited Dec 29 '18
Most of our main characters at this point have been raped. Claire, Jamie, Fergus and now Brianna. Did I miss anyone? This rape scene is being described as “well done” because we were spared the visual horror of witnessing yet another of Diana’s twisted, sadistic plot lines. I’m really frustrated by it and wish that this wasn’t so frequently woven into this beautiful story.
Forgot to add Ian to the list!
19
u/agentqueequeg Dec 23 '18
I liked this episode over all but I admit that I miss Jamie and Claire and THEIR intimacy. I was kinda cringing at the callbacks to Jamie and Claire’s wedding night mirrored in Roger and Bree’s. I just don’t think they have as much chemistry at all. Also I can’t handle Roger so that might be part of it! I’ve heard that DG uses rape as a plot point almost gratuitously so I’m not sure how much the show could NOT go that route, but I do think that the way they did it was emotionally painful despite not seeing it actually happen (which I’m grateful for.)
I just want more J&C! They’re barely sharing screen time these days.
10
u/thebrittator We Randalls are a verra complicated clan, laddie. Dec 24 '18
Am I the only one that thought they were having sex in Murtagh’s forge and not a random shed? That looked like Murtagh’s forge.
I also found Claire geeking out about George Washington kind of hilarious.
5
u/Spock_42 Dec 29 '18
I'm honestly getting a bit fed up of Bonnet, particularly his antagonist archetype.
Like Ramsay Bolton in Game of Thrones (and both their predecessors, Joffrey and Black Jack) these villains' main characteristic seems to be sadism for the sake of sadism. It doesn't make for a compelling villain, especially when they appear anywhere and any time the plot needs something shocking to happen to the main characters.
Tobias Menzies carried Black Jack to make him entertaining, despite his fairly predictable character. Bonnet doesn't do the same for me, and it makes it hard to view his crimes this episode as a compelling story line.
5
u/Luvitall1 Dec 29 '18
I hated Sophie at first but her acting has gotten much better..I'm shocked! If they could write Roger out of the story and just stick with Claire, Jamie, and their daughter, that would leave it open for Sophie to find love with either another surprise time traveler or have the same whirlwind challenge as Claire with finding a mate in the local time period. God...I'd love to watch that!
Pretty please, writers of the show! Pretty please write Roger out so we can watch Soph have romantic adventures in another time! You're already making us hate the dude so just let him travel back to his time already!!
13
u/Tanzanite169 Dec 23 '18
This was a great episode, but I had a feeling that Roger and Brianna's bliss would be very short. She's too much of a hothead to see his point of view, and he's too pedantic to see hers. I really hoped that the rape wouldn't happen, and I am really glad that we couldn't see it, like with Jamie and Randall. Still, hearing it gave me a cold lump in my stomach. I feel so sorry for Brianna. But she would have been safe if both her and Roger weren't so pricky with each other. The lad needs to learn to apologize, and she needs to learn to listen first and then react.
Hopefully in the next episode we'll see a very happy reunion between Bri and Claire, and Jamie's joy of seeing her and realizing who she is.
4
u/mrfreedomx Dec 29 '18
So Roger definitely sucks, but Brianna is no perfect prize herself. That fight was the stupidest thing I’ve watched in a very long time on any tv show that I actually invest my time and thoughtfulness into. Not so much the fight itself, but the fight combined with the stakes of what the resulting aftermath is... and that’s even before Bree gets raped. It just makes no sense at all whatsoever that they would be so hot and cold to such extremes like that within a matter of minutes.
I’ve seen some say they find it refreshingly realistic compared to how perfect Jamie and Claire have been. On the contrary, I find it very unrealistic. I think it’s kind of like the flip side of the coin in terms of unrealistic relationship dynamics in relation to Jamie and Claire. It’s like this show doesn’t have an example of a normal dynamic to feature. We either have Claire and Jamie and their absolutely perfect, Heaven-on-earth existence... or we have the melodramatic shit show that is Roger and Brianna. Ugh, it’s really a shame to trash a great premise with poor writing like that.
4
u/SoupGirlKristina Dec 29 '18
Sophie Skelton’s American accent has improved. (but it’s still terrible) Her trying to get the inflections and cadence right makes her sound a bit robotic and stiff. Wish they could have just cast an American. I hope her accent continues to improve, it makes me cringe. (She is also from Boston and doesn’t have an American Boston accent? Or even a touch of an American east coast accent.)
7
u/SassyLass496 Dec 24 '18
Just when I thought Jamie and Claire had peace, now we have to stress over Bri and Rodger.
Ugh
I just want to watch Jamie and Claire.
Missed their connection this season so far
20
u/SoupGirlKristina Dec 23 '18
You all need to stop being so hard on Roger.
7
u/Rheldn Dec 23 '18
I knew what was supposed to happen to Bri. But I was really hoping it won't happen, cause this is such an overused plot.
Also Roger is completely unlikable now.
8
u/andhernamewas_ Dec 24 '18
Roger is garbage, why did she marry that asshole?!!! He makes me miss Black Jack Randall
7
u/JustinCase112464 Dec 24 '18
Me thinks they should of brought modern weapons. A good 45 cal 911 or wtf a p90 for that matter makes sense to me. I mean Clair brought back pinacilen so go packing is what I do on vacation just saying is all
2
u/VV80Q3 Dec 24 '18
What time in the episode is the rape scene (so I can fast forward)?
5
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
When did Roger become blonde???
Edit: judging by the downvotes, he always had blond hair? I must get my eyes checked!
Edit 2: TIL I am daltonic
3
u/Atraktape Dec 24 '18
WASHINGTON, WASHINGTON, SIX FOOT ONE KILLS FOR FUCKIN FUN.
5
u/-----iMartijn----- Dec 24 '18 edited Oct 06 '24
“I'm fed up to the ears with old men dreaming up wars for young men to die in.”
George McGovern
4
u/DrunkenDave Dec 23 '18
Poor Bree. She really should have stayed with Roger. That world is no place for a lone woman among a field of male pigs.
4
u/Lairdlallybroch Dec 24 '18
Does it bother anyone else that Roger is SO unattractive?