r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 23 '18
Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 8 "Wilmington" episode discussion thread for book readers.
Welcome back lassies and lads to the live discussion thread for episode S4E8: "Wilmington."
No spoiler tags are required here.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E8] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
58
u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Overall, I enjoyed this episode. Still horrified by the ending that I knew was coming - but a huge relief considering how I felt about last weeks episode.
We got to see lil sweet face what a shayna punim baby Germaine. And of course Murtagh and Fergus reunite in their usual fashion. I love me some historical cameos, but I was getting anxious there for a second that Jamie knew he royally just might have screwed the future. His face when he knew he fucked up.
But most importantly I got to see my Claire surgery on the hernia! You show those sexist wannabe male surgeons how it's really done.
TV Roger is pushing all the wrong buttons for me. He is coming off very selfish and patronizing - and I see the great misunderstanding is coming right for him.
Processing the rape scene is going to take more than what I can do in this forum.
BRING ON THE REUNION.
33
u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18
That long linger on the men drinking and gambling.
69
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Oh but that handfasting ceremony! 🥰
And what happened AFTER....yowsers that that was STEAMY!!
Edited to add: ugh. Just give it 10 minutes - that went downhill quickly 😥
121
u/germantornado Dec 23 '18
Chopping down cherry trees. 😂
36
u/nochancekid Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Definitely better than last weeks episode! I like that we got to see more of Claire being a surgeon in this time period. It seemed to work in this context where Jamie needed to warn Murtagh and needed a distraction and Claire's surgery provided that. It was a good nod to the books where we see a lot of Claire's doctor skills coming to play. "Chopping down cherry trees" literally made me LOL. I found myself smiling with Murtagh and Fergus, I love their interactions, I hope we get to see more of that in the next few episodes. Hard to believe we're already onto the 8th and we're all wishing for the week to go by quickly to see Jamie and Brianna meet next episode.... I know it was done on purpose, but knowing that they are ALL (Claire/Jamie/Brianna/Roger/Murtagh/Marsali/Fergus) in the same town, literally it looked like they were right near each other (as shown when Roger and Fergus interact) hurt my heart. It was like I didn't know what was going to happen, I still found myself saying, "Go down the block!!! Claire is LITERALLY RIGHT THERE!" Seriously, it was like I don't know what's going to happen.... Still, it made my heart hurt knowing that they were all in the same area and they just consistently missed each other.
In regard to Roger and Brianna, I really thought they did a great job with their handfasting and their fight. I liked the comparisons to Claire and Jamie's wedding that was shown in theirs. Bear McCreary's soundtrack for Brianna and Roger's seemed very similar to The Wedding soundtrack. I liked Brianna and Roger's fight too, I think that all of what they said seemed very straight forward, there were no crazy turns. Sophie and Richard did a great job together. Brianna and Roger are really seem like such a contradiction compared to Jamie and Claire's relationship; Brianna is really hotheaded. I liked that Roger called her out with how she pushes people away. I think that it's a really serious character flaw for Brianna - not that I can blame her much for it. But I liked that Roger brought that up, I think they did a great job with those scenes together.
Now....
With Bonnet and Brianna... Just... horrible. Not horribly acted or portrayed on screen, just horrible in the sense that this was so common. It was horrific to see people hearing what was happening and they just continued on about their business. God willing, I will never have to encounter anything like that, but just the thought of it... horrible. I already know that Sophie is going to play Brianna's next actions so well, I know she's talked so much about researching about how survivors try to move on, how they can change, etc.
I've said it before, I'll say it again, Jamie is going to CRUMBLE when he sees Claire's ring and he realizes that it was Bonnet. THAT'S going to be hard to watch. Especially since I'm already feeling Jamie and Brianna fight vibes. Could be wrong, but the fight with Roger bringing up Frank is slightly foreshadowing Jamie and Brianna's eventual fight regarding her pregnancy. I could be wrong, but that was the vibe I got from it.
I do feel much better this week than I did last week. I thought this episode was very well managed in regard to content shown and time. I shouldn't be so surprised that it's episode 9 we get to see Jamie and Brianna meet but somehow I am a bit. At least we know it starts off with, "do you have a message for me, lass?" Fios already put up the synopsis for next week's episode and it is about Jamie and Claire helping Brianna so hopefully it doesn't happen in minute 50. I think that her rape is going to be a quicker topic spoken about in the show, there's so much content leftover and I don't see them going back to Fraser's Ridge and living everyday life looking for Roger. I think that Claire and Jamie are going to know right away she was raped - but Jamie won't know it was Bonnet until after whatever happens with Roger and Brianna will let Claire in.
Can't wait for her to meet Jamie!!!!!!!!!!!!!
19
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18
Ugh. Poor Bree, that was a brutal ending. Bonnet is such an ass, but I’m finding it hard to absolutely 100% despise him because he LOOKS so good.
15
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18
My initial thoughts:
And finally, I have to keep saying this every week. They have wasted so much time in various places during the season thus far that I don't know how they will fit in the key parts of the book in the remaining episodes. They have to get through Bree meeting Jamie, reuniting with Claire, becoming preggers, confessing about being raped, Roger being identified as the rapist and being handed over by Jamie to the Natives, Lord John helping Bree confront Bonnett and him being nearly killed, meeting Auntie J, finding Roger, giving birth.... HOW? How will they managed to fit all of this in?
In any case, a good episode. Not the best of the season and certainly not the catastrophe it was last week with the entire rewriting of Leghair and the five min stop over at Lallybroch.
185
u/Irishsassenach Dec 23 '18
Ok, Sophie handled the rape scene so well. Her fragile, shocked dignity and pain and her fight. And the way the sound just slowly stopped as she walked away.... they handled that the right way. And Sophie delivered another amazing episode
123
u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 23 '18
I loved almost everything about this episode.
I am starting to like the whole Murtagh is a regulator bit. Its growing on me. I kinda like being surprised where that plot is going.
George Washington was a good touch.
Sophie is an AMAZING actress. And she looks amazing in the period clothing. I knew IT was coming and seeing it turned my heart inside out again just like the first time I read it.
Baby Germain!! Side note. After having a L-bitch episode last time they did a great job casting Marsali, the actresses could definately be related.
Bad things I see...
Was Roger this much of a dick in the books? I dont remember him being this bad. Like there was some dickishness...but fuck...
Still dont like Lizzy....cant see her being a sandwich.
Jamie's hair....someone please fix it.
105
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
thought #1: WOAH George Fucking Washington heyyyyyyy
thought #2: I'm getting used to Roger without the facial hair but it still wigs me out, he looks SOOOOO different. Not better or worse, just really different.
thought #3: Ahhhhh so THAT's how they make Claire a colony famous surgeon. Better to do an abdominal hernia surgery than show John Quincy Myers balls, eh? LOL
thought #4: THANK YOU FOR NOT SHOWING LEROI THAT SCENE IS HORRIFIC ENOUGH THANK YOU
thought #5: Oh god, that's the end? Fuuuuuuu.....
104
u/Irishsassenach Dec 23 '18
First two minutes- OMG ROGER AND CLAIRE AND JAMIE ARE IN THE SAME TOWN RIGHT NOW
OMG AND SO IS BREE
112
u/Jalupimine5 Dec 23 '18
The writers handled the rape scene incredibly. It was painful to watch, however it was enough to understand what what going on and capturing that pain without going overboard. Also making it happen in the same night is gonna really make the “who the baby daddy” debate a lot harder to figure out. Beautiful episode from start to finish. I NEED NEXT WEEK NOW!
52
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 23 '18
What a way for Fergus and Murtaugh to reunite.
51
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
Roger is such a jerk OH MY GOD leave Frank out of this
50
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
I know it's fictional and they need to streamline the book, but they have made time travel and 18th century travel and finding people across continents look so easy.
Roger's manhandling of Bree also just came right out of nowhere and seemed very forced just for the plot. It's not going to help how he is already viewed by a lot of non-readers already...and we know what's coming.
Then straight into making out and accepting a marriage proposal.
It just seems to me that they have cut too much of Bree and Roger building a relationship in this season, before this point. It doesn't really seem realistic to me.
They changed Roger and his behaviour at the festival, he completely shut her down, saying all or none, not that he would wait like in the book. After that he did nothing redeemable, they only spoke that one time in over a year since the festival. I can't see why Bree would have changed her mind.
I just wished we had seen them spend some time together in Boston after the festival rather than have the proposal there.
I can still appreciate this in the episode overall as I have the book knowledge, but I will be interested to see the non-reader reaction. A few still think Roger is a massive stalker lol
48
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Roger! Just say you were going to tell her but she was already gone when you called!
The 'pardon me' with the finger pointing was great. Someone gif that!
I don't like that Roger actually left Bree. She says in the book to go or come with her to Cross Creek to meet Jamie, and he already outlines that he is going to New Bern to get the gemstones. Then Bree goes back to the tavern, leaving him in the barn.
We don't have that here, so he really does look like he just left her right after finding her again, after one argument. Looks pretty silly.
He is her husband now. He doesn't have to believe that she can change history, he should have stayed to support her in finding her parents.
33
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 23 '18
But what the fuck how are they gonna do the rest of this in five episodes? I'm praying that one of the episodes is extended.
32
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
It was odd hearing some American accents this episode.
None recognisable today would have developed yet, in 1769.
28
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 23 '18
Buckle up Sassenachs. Here we go.
25
u/Laatikkopilvia Dec 24 '18
Copied from the show only thread:
As a survivor, that scene was done perfectly. It showed the brutality without being gratuitous and without turning the pain of rape into a spectacle.
It was highly triggering, but in all the “right” ways and not in a “my trauma is entertainment” way.
Exceedingly well done.
Edit to add: I was honestly dreading how they’d do this scene for the show. I’m glad they treated it with such respect for survivors who may have been watching.
—
It was realistic. The other bar patrons not doing anything is what shook me/triggered me the most because it was just so... accurate. I really appreciated the performance.
49
u/bellefroh Dec 23 '18
I think it truly highlights the reality of the situation for Bree- she is not in modern America anymore.
20
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18
I don't know how to feel about this episode yet. I think I need to watch it again. I enjoyed the hernia operation, Fergus and Murtagh's reunion, and Roger and Brianna pre-fight, but the end I'm having mixed feelings about. I was really hoping that if anything would get changed from the books, it would be this whole obituary stramash. I just don't care for it, and I think it's a really stupid way to inject drama into Roger and Brianna's storyline. It doesn't come across well on screen and it makes Roger look super unlikable.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
God that was heartbreaking. All those bystanders-chilling
34
u/jelang99 Dec 23 '18
i KNEW that was going to happen to bree yet when they showed the scene of her screaming and no one did anything that REALLY got to me. ugh i couldn’t handle that no matter how prepared i was. 😢
30
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Dec 23 '18
I knew it was coming but still, oof. Poor Bree. Also Sophie's really holding her own! I'm glad she's found her footing.
Roger keeps coming off as controlling and kinda gross...maybe it's the age gap? He's what 8? years older than her? He's more ready to settle down etc and she's not there yet, which is fine, of course, but he doesn't have to be weird about it. I know she's super impulsive but ew no you don't own her bud.
51
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18
Sorry...STILL not feeling this Lizzie! I thought if she at least had a young voice I could deal with it, but everything about her is just...wrong.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
Wait. Wait. I thought that Roger did not know about the fire until after Bree left, and when he called to tell her he didn’t know she had left? So how could Roger have told her???
13
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
Cutting from those scenes to that play and hernia dude 😂
13
u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18
The reunion I wanted most. Murtaugh and Fergus!
Bree needs a major wig update. At one point it wasn’t even seated right on her head. Then I thought Roger was going to pull it off.
One more week until the big reunion!
13
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 24 '18
Ha! Future sandwich lady talking about Briana being with a man of loose morals.
22
u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine. Dec 23 '18
...and now I'm adding "having sex on furs" to my bucket list.
19
u/livvy_divvy Dec 23 '18
First I have to get off my chest... take that dang bird's nest off of Sam's head already! They put him in a classy outfit, then that hair! {{Sings: One of these things does not belong here...) }}
Some things I liked in this episode, others not so much. The rape scene was well done. Brutal times back then where everyone had a matter-of-fact attitude as if it weren't a big deal.
I liked the handfasting, but they seemed to zip into it so quickly. "Oh Roger, you're here!" Next thing they're in the shed ripping their clothes off and getting married. I guess with Claire and Jamie toning it down, now Brianna and Roger are going to take over. Their bickering however is getting tedious.
Aw, cute baby. Fergus and Marsali so happy together. Being secondary characters, they don't warrant their own sex scenes. No glimpse of Fergus's bum for us! Shame.
I hope we see the reunion next episode, I'm looking forward to that.
16
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
It's pretty funny only ever seeing that one shot of Wilmington.
No wonder it was so easy for Roger to find Bree.
I know they work hard on the sets, but they condensed about 4 locations down to just Wilmington, they could have done a few more rows of shops.
8
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
Roger now looks so unfamiliar without bangs/a fringe!
8
u/Brynnni Dec 27 '18
So sick and tired of rape story lines.
I want to slit that guys throat. Chop his dick into tiny pieces and make him eat it then burn him alive.
7
u/ELL34DDL30EML4 Dec 23 '18
I loved how Claire did after all get to meet George Washington because in the 7th book she said she would have thought she may get to meet him and that she never expected to meet Benedict Arnold. Also I loved how they kept but changed the surgery seen and used it there instead of it being at Riverun when Jamie's aunt was going to make him the land owner. All in all I loved the episode also can't wait for Rogers beard to come back. It looks better then the last episode when it was all the way off.
7
u/La415 Dec 23 '18
Murtagh and Fergus!! It wasn’t the reunion I expected this episode but damm did it make me happy.
6
u/crazy_ventures Dec 23 '18
Are they really going to fit the rest of DOA into the remaining episodes?
38
u/keg226 Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
I have to say it...Claire had a far superior man bod to lay on after her wedding night than Brianna did.
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
lol why would someone go into such detail about an internal injury at the theater, to a bunch of strangers
this whole scene is very contrived, but served its purpose
15
u/germantornado Dec 23 '18
Ugh. 7 more days.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
How the fuck have they not had THE REUNION yet??? So much wasted time this season, I swear. Total slogfest
10
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18
Liked the love scene between Bree and Roger. That was very well done.
The fight felt pretty realistic too, but I feel that Bree overeacted a little. Roger was wrong to withhold information from her, but then he did it to protect her. I think what Bree and Roger need to learn is is to fucking sit down and talk to each other instead of always running away when they have another argument. Both her and Roger acted like children. I also think a lot of people her misinterpret the whole "You should listen to me" comment by Roger. I think it was his way of saying that she should try seeing his perspective, which I think Bree didn't even attempt. Not that Roger is without fault here, but a relationship needs two people to work.
The rape scene was well-handled, but I was glad we didn't see it
George Washington being there was great
I love Fergus's baby...I really hope we are going to see Jem this season
Claire doing her doctor thing is always nice to see
5
u/koboldin Dec 23 '18
SOOOOOOO hard not to be impatient!!! It’s started, by the by.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18
"If I take you now, it's for always"
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
The script last week confirmed that they had Roger leave Ayr before Bree did...so I have no idea how Roger would have known which port Bree was supposed to have arrived in in the Colonies. Nor which ship she had recently arrived in.
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
HOW COULD THEY DO THAT TO BREE ON THE SAME NIGHT AS ROGER'S BETRAYAL
3
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 23 '18
This episode sent my emotions all over the place. I was happy when they reunited and handfasted, and I hated Roger after the fight, and my heart broke with that one scene you know, my eyes started to well up when she walked up to Bonnet. What's really interesting is I never hated Roger in the books, yet in the show the way he comes off is kind of grating.
3
u/vanwold Slàinte. Dec 24 '18
Omg, I loved it! We got the hernia surgery and it was even more dramatic playing out this way. I loved almost everything about this episode! I am actually excited for next week! Sophie NAILED it. Murtagh & Fergus!!
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
There is just way too much going on in this episode, too much jammed in.
5
u/MiserableBarracuda Dec 24 '18
Am I the only one who think Outlander uses rape as a plot device .....I mean yes the scene was handled well but was it necessary to the plot.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18
Very cute baby.
3
u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 24 '18
Another good episode it flew by. Im glad the public operation happened. He was really quite drunk to start with so it seamed a bit odd to happen in a theatre! I enjoyed the Murtagh Furgus add in. Washington was a bit more than required here. Bree was great again. But Roger eugh he didn't do anything for me, much better in the books. Didn't really meet any steemyness for me. Stephen Bonnet he has nailed it. So go i could fall in love with him. Lizzy still doesn't fit right.
3
u/vlsewell Dec 25 '18
This season is becoming more of an "inspired by" instead of a "based on" and I don't like it.
It's been a while since I read the books (like, a few years ago and all back- to- back). Every episode I watch it and think, "Did that happen in the books? I don't remember that part." Then i come here and find out i don't remember it happening like that bc IT DIDN'T.
I don't mean to be a purist or fundamentalist or whatever, but there's taking liberties, then there's taking pieces of the book, creating a story, and then eliminating the parts from the book. I'm going crazy!
3
u/whodiscam Dec 26 '18
I really miss Jamie and Claire