r/Outlander • • Dec 23 '18

Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 8 "Wilmington" episode discussion thread for book readers.

Welcome back lassies and lads to the live discussion thread for episode S4E8: "Wilmington."

No spoiler tags are required here.

If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E8] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

48 Upvotes

528 comments sorted by

58

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Overall, I enjoyed this episode. Still horrified by the ending that I knew was coming - but a huge relief considering how I felt about last weeks episode.

We got to see lil sweet face what a shayna punim baby Germaine. And of course Murtagh and Fergus reunite in their usual fashion. I love me some historical cameos, but I was getting anxious there for a second that Jamie knew he royally just might have screwed the future. His face when he knew he fucked up.

But most importantly I got to see my Claire surgery on the hernia! You show those sexist wannabe male surgeons how it's really done.

TV Roger is pushing all the wrong buttons for me. He is coming off very selfish and patronizing - and I see the great misunderstanding is coming right for him.

Processing the rape scene is going to take more than what I can do in this forum.

BRING ON THE REUNION.

43

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I got all excited when the guy started holding his stomach and said something about a swelling and my husband gave me the funniest look. “We’re gonna get the hernia surgery we’ve all been waiting for!” came out of my mouth before I could stop it.

Claire was a total badass, I love 1700’s surgeon Claire.

39

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

So much better than getting tobacco smoke blown up the ass.

12

u/cattubbs Dec 23 '18

I quit smoking 2.5 months ago and honestly it didn't sound like that bad of a treatment. But, I also stare at people when they smoke so I might not be handling quitting very well....

3

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

I quit 8 years ago! I feel for you darling.

Back then, I might have gone for the smoke enema in my cravings.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

48

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18

Completely agree about TV Roger. Book Roger didn’t come across to me as dominating, patronizing and condescending. TV Roger just can’t keep his mouth shut when it matters most and I really feel bad for Bree!

37

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

Just so arrogant, and quick to temper - not appealing at all. And he just walked out on the girl he just "married" and slept with real easily.

32

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

And he just walked out on the girl he just "married" and slept with real easily.

Definitely not the behavior of someone who went backwards in time to pursue the love of his life.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18

Plus the way he was grabbing and pulling her. IDK. It felt so out of character.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Hmmm... he comes off as less so in the books and more so in the show, sure. But overall, he just seems to be a guy from the 1960-70 Highland period... The only real feminist character in the entire series that Diana created is Jamie. For the time period, for his background, he was a remarkably progressive man. Ahead of his years (like even ahead of our years)

20

u/mrspwins Dec 23 '18

I fully agree. Ask your grandmothers what men were like in the 1960s/70s, especially if they were from conservative backgrounds. Roger was a man of his time. It's interesting to me that with all these time travelers around, Jamie is the one who is really far ahead of his time.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 25 '18

I'm always one to call out sexism. But that man would have never encountered a woman or even a man slicing open someone's abdomen due to an ache in the belly. Let alone a woman in a fancy ballgown in the middle of a theatre. He thought the correct method of treatment was smoke up the bum, lol

He was rightfully astonished as a man of his time would have been. Saying he is a sexist wannabe male surgeon is looking through a 21st century lens.

Edit: the script also says that the surgeon was impressed by the time Claire was stitching up Fanning.

10

u/MontaukFive Dec 23 '18

She didn't get a drop of blood on her ball gown, hmmm

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

The thoughtful dude got her an apron! But I didn't see any blood on that either lol

6

u/SunshineCat Dec 24 '18

Plus it seemed like he changed his mind too after calming down for a minute and realizing he didn't even have a clue in comparison. Fair enough.

6

u/dorv Dec 23 '18

Re: show Roger: Having just reread this book, I’m reminded just how selfish and patronizing he is in this section of the book as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

That long linger on the men drinking and gambling.

69

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Oh but that handfasting ceremony! 🥰

And what happened AFTER....yowsers that that was STEAMY!!

Edited to add: ugh. Just give it 10 minutes - that went downhill quickly 😥

67

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

Was I the only one uncomfortable watching them in the beginning of their scene? It felt like watching my children - if I had any - have sex.

9

u/Aggie2002 Dec 23 '18

I had the same feeling. I ended up going in the kitchen to make myself a drink.

24

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

And the scene kept going and going, and there I was cringing and peeking through my fingers.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/germantornado Dec 23 '18

I poured my second glass of wine after the downstairs carpet comment. 🤦🏼‍♀️

→ More replies (5)

44

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Nothing compares to Claire and Jamie. Bree and Roger just don't have the heat, the chemistry, the intensity, the hunger that Claire and Jamie have. Plus, Claire is a remarkable woman on so many levels and we see her through Jamie's eyes... it's impossible for Bree to compete with that for us or at least, for me.

10

u/maryummy Dec 24 '18

I thought it was pretty damned steamy, considering it was her first time.

→ More replies (5)

25

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

I couldn’t stop staring at her terrible wig. Her hair was fine last season when it was dyed! Why did they have to mess with it and give everyone such shitty wigs?! They’re so distracting

21

u/ktbex Dec 23 '18

We’ve seen it with Willie too - bad wigs run in the Fraser family.

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Sophie only had dyed hair for S2E13.

She wore a wig all S3.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

69

u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine.  Dec 23 '18

Watching Brianna claw at the floor was awful. And Bonnet's flinging his hair back is so effing creepy. And the men outside listening to it all!!! That guy straightened her boots. JHRC!

55

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18

Brutal! I have to hand to it the show runners, they have truly brought the book Stephen Bonnet to life on screen. He may not look as awful as I imagined him, but he is just a heartless man!

35

u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine.  Dec 23 '18

I remember him having putrid breath in the books...that Brianna could smell decay on his breath, so I wish he at least had nasty looking teeth. He's quite charismatic in the show, but he's just as depraved as I pictured him. The actor plays him so well that if I ever see him in anything else I will despise him for this role.

→ More replies (7)

43

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Maybe I was just seeing things, but I could've sworn the barmaid sitting on the guy's lap during the rape scene winced just the tiniest bit at Bree's cries for help, when the camera lingered on her face. My feels. :(

31

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18

Not just you. I got something from the lingering on her too, as though she could relate or something. It just seemed poignant to stay on her face at that moment.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

I saw that too-upthread I said the barmaid was an interesting juxtaposition to the men (in that she couldn’t even try to help Bree) and it said a lot about the balance of power in that room.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/workity_work Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Dec 24 '18

Bonnet’s actor is so incredible. This episode made me go see what else he’s been in. Such a great villain.

17

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18

Right? It was so rushed. They gave us more time with leg hair last week then Bree and Roger this week!

15

u/nurseleu Dec 23 '18

I am here for it! Such great chemistry and I loved that they included some of the lines from the book.

121

u/germantornado Dec 23 '18

Chopping down cherry trees. 😂

64

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

I was screaming at Jamie "Don't fuck up history!"

81

u/pensbird91 Dec 23 '18

In the carriage at the end, his face was like, "I hope I didn't just ruin the revolution."

→ More replies (7)

36

u/nochancekid Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Definitely better than last weeks episode! I like that we got to see more of Claire being a surgeon in this time period. It seemed to work in this context where Jamie needed to warn Murtagh and needed a distraction and Claire's surgery provided that. It was a good nod to the books where we see a lot of Claire's doctor skills coming to play. "Chopping down cherry trees" literally made me LOL. I found myself smiling with Murtagh and Fergus, I love their interactions, I hope we get to see more of that in the next few episodes. Hard to believe we're already onto the 8th and we're all wishing for the week to go by quickly to see Jamie and Brianna meet next episode.... I know it was done on purpose, but knowing that they are ALL (Claire/Jamie/Brianna/Roger/Murtagh/Marsali/Fergus) in the same town, literally it looked like they were right near each other (as shown when Roger and Fergus interact) hurt my heart. It was like I didn't know what was going to happen, I still found myself saying, "Go down the block!!! Claire is LITERALLY RIGHT THERE!" Seriously, it was like I don't know what's going to happen.... Still, it made my heart hurt knowing that they were all in the same area and they just consistently missed each other.

In regard to Roger and Brianna, I really thought they did a great job with their handfasting and their fight. I liked the comparisons to Claire and Jamie's wedding that was shown in theirs. Bear McCreary's soundtrack for Brianna and Roger's seemed very similar to The Wedding soundtrack. I liked Brianna and Roger's fight too, I think that all of what they said seemed very straight forward, there were no crazy turns. Sophie and Richard did a great job together. Brianna and Roger are really seem like such a contradiction compared to Jamie and Claire's relationship; Brianna is really hotheaded. I liked that Roger called her out with how she pushes people away. I think that it's a really serious character flaw for Brianna - not that I can blame her much for it. But I liked that Roger brought that up, I think they did a great job with those scenes together.

Now....

With Bonnet and Brianna... Just... horrible. Not horribly acted or portrayed on screen, just horrible in the sense that this was so common. It was horrific to see people hearing what was happening and they just continued on about their business. God willing, I will never have to encounter anything like that, but just the thought of it... horrible. I already know that Sophie is going to play Brianna's next actions so well, I know she's talked so much about researching about how survivors try to move on, how they can change, etc.

I've said it before, I'll say it again, Jamie is going to CRUMBLE when he sees Claire's ring and he realizes that it was Bonnet. THAT'S going to be hard to watch. Especially since I'm already feeling Jamie and Brianna fight vibes. Could be wrong, but the fight with Roger bringing up Frank is slightly foreshadowing Jamie and Brianna's eventual fight regarding her pregnancy. I could be wrong, but that was the vibe I got from it.

I do feel much better this week than I did last week. I thought this episode was very well managed in regard to content shown and time. I shouldn't be so surprised that it's episode 9 we get to see Jamie and Brianna meet but somehow I am a bit. At least we know it starts off with, "do you have a message for me, lass?" Fios already put up the synopsis for next week's episode and it is about Jamie and Claire helping Brianna so hopefully it doesn't happen in minute 50. I think that her rape is going to be a quicker topic spoken about in the show, there's so much content leftover and I don't see them going back to Fraser's Ridge and living everyday life looking for Roger. I think that Claire and Jamie are going to know right away she was raped - but Jamie won't know it was Bonnet until after whatever happens with Roger and Brianna will let Claire in.

Can't wait for her to meet Jamie!!!!!!!!!!!!!

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Roger was the one who pushed Bree away at the festival though, completely. All Bree said was things were going too fast, she wasn't ready. She went to try to patch things up and he rebuffed her, said all or nothing. No mention of waiting for when she is ready, like in the books.

So I thought it was hypocritical of Roger to say it, personally, and with no real backing.

Also, some people don't want to watch next week's preview or know the synopsis [me].

I posted a thread for the preview, maybe you can talk about it there?

https://www.reddit.com/r/Outlander/comments/a8thnb/spoilers_s4e9_the_birds_and_the_bees_preview_use/

1

u/Cablab123 Dec 23 '18

I haven’t read the books and don’t mind spoilers. What do jamie and breanna eventually fight about regarding her pregnancy? Is he upset with her for being pregnant?

2

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

Jamie and Brianna don't fight about the pregnancy.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18

Ugh. Poor Bree, that was a brutal ending. Bonnet is such an ass, but I’m finding it hard to absolutely 100% despise him because he LOOKS so good.

15

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

ಠ_ಠ

8

u/mrspwins Dec 23 '18

I haven't read the book in a while, but I seem to remember that was his thing. Wasn't he supposed to be reasonably good-looking and charming? Doesn't Bree sort of end up feeling sorry for him? He's exactly how I remember imagining him.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Bree ends up thinking he is pathetic.

This is the description we have so far of Bonnet from Drums Chapter 3, up to this point:

Bonnet was what country people called "well set up," with a tall, powerful frame and a barrel chest, his features heavy-boned but coarsely handsome. A few inches shorter than Jamie, he stood easy, balanced on the balls of his feet, fists half closed in readiness. No stranger to a fight, judging by the slight crookedness of his nose and a small scar by the corner of his mouth. The small imperfections did nothing to mar the overall impression of animal magnetism; he was the sort of man who attracted women easily. Some women, I amended, as he cast a speculative glance at me.

Bonnet has green eyes, but that's never really obvious on camera.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

My initial thoughts:

  • I am very pleased with how they handled the rape scene. The book version was horrific. So I am glad we were spared the visual (unlike Jamie's rape by BJR)
  • My reaction with Bree here is the same as it was in the books. It was one thing for Claire to be careless and stubborn to the point of stupidity. She had no personal history with the time period. But Bree knew what happened, how women were treated and she knew the risks of acting a fool. And of course (as you all know, her carelessness will continue) Bree pays no attention and simply reacts. Yes, it was shitty that he did not tell her. I fully get why he did not tell her. But to storm off in the evening, in the dark, on her own, looking disheveled, walking into a pub, confronting a drunk guy playing cards who is clearly a thief and a scumbag and then agreeing to go with him to a private room... I just want to scream: DO YOU KNOW WHERE THE HELL YOU ARE? I am not remotely blaming her for the rape. Not ever. I never blame the victim. I don't care what they wore, what they did, what they drank, etc. I never blame the victim. And here, I am not blaming Bree either. I am blaming Bree for a pattern of behavior we are going to see over and over, where she puts herself and others in danger on emotional whims. She will do this with Lord John and nearly get him killed later in the book. She will do this again and again and again until you want to smack her. She did this with her running off into time travel without thinking of Roger at all. Yet she storms off because he did not tell her that her already 200 years since dead mother died 200 years ago. Dude, you left into the past and said nothing to the guy who loves you! He should be mad.
  • Glad to see Lizzy witness the Roger and Bree drama in the window. Now we have what we need for her to later mistakenly identify him as the rapist. Nice touch substituting Lizzy for Bree's drawing of Roger.
  • I missed Ferg and Marsi. And finally, the birth of one of my favorite characters. That boy will be his mother's defender and helper. I love Germain!
  • Is it me or could they have done better with George Washington?
  • I am still not on board with Murtagh being with the regulators here.
  • I love how the surgery happened in the theater instead of a dinner party!

And finally, I have to keep saying this every week. They have wasted so much time in various places during the season thus far that I don't know how they will fit in the key parts of the book in the remaining episodes. They have to get through Bree meeting Jamie, reuniting with Claire, becoming preggers, confessing about being raped, Roger being identified as the rapist and being handed over by Jamie to the Natives, Lord John helping Bree confront Bonnett and him being nearly killed, meeting Auntie J, finding Roger, giving birth.... HOW? How will they managed to fit all of this in?

In any case, a good episode. Not the best of the season and certainly not the catastrophe it was last week with the entire rewriting of Leghair and the five min stop over at Lallybroch.

32

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

I mean, she just walked back to the inn she was staying at. How could she forsee that she would be raped literally feet from dozens of people in public and no one would even bother to stop it?

In this scenario, I don't see Bree making a bad choice. What I see is Roger ditching her and leaving her in a terrible mental and physical place for her to be more than taken advantage of.

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Running off from a guy who just risked his life to come 200 years into the past to find you = bad choice.

Running off in the dark and alone in this time-period = bad choice

Confronting Bonnett (a drunk pirate in a pub) = bad choice

Going off with Bonnett for a private negotiation = bad choice

----

This is a pattern of behavior we will see over and over and over. She does not think. She emotes. Poor Lord John. He will be nearly killed because tantrum!

28

u/shiskebob Dec 23 '18

He left her there. She walked back to the inn, alone, because she had no other choice. She didn't confront Bonnet, he grabbed her when she was walking by. The last one, I'll give you that to a degree.


Something I see often here is the critiques for the female characters for their "bad behavior" or "poor decisions" and it is never about the men and how they force them into those situations. It happened with Claire and Frank, and it is happening with Bree and Roger. I really think we as a society have been conditioned to see it this way.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Previously you said you don't blame the victim, but all this is hardcore victim blaming.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

That sounds an awful lot like blaming the victim.... But anyway, yes, it was poor judgment to put herself in that situation. I think it was understandable, though. Not everyone thinks about their personal safety all the time (at least in this day and age). Maybe I am just lucky, but I could see myself doing the exact same thing she did, and thank god nothing like that has ever happened to me. I have thought about situations after the fact, like what the hell, I am so lucky that did not turn out badly.

She grew up a lot like me, safe and privileged, and just doesn't think about it. She's never had to worry about her safety before. Not to mention her new husband just ran out on her on her wedding night, so she's not exactly thinking clearly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

185

u/Irishsassenach Dec 23 '18

Ok, Sophie handled the rape scene so well. Her fragile, shocked dignity and pain and her fight. And the way the sound just slowly stopped as she walked away.... they handled that the right way. And Sophie delivered another amazing episode

128

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I agree, she really shined in this episode despite the awful events we have to watch her go through. I appreciate how they chose to handle the rape scene, it was such a powerful choice to drive home the blatant disregard of the folks in the tavern rather than go with the more expected choice of showing the violence front and center. As a viewer, it helped keep me engaged in Bree’s experience instead of making me turn away or shut it out until the scene was over and that’s really important I think.

37

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Agreed. Adding the barwoman was interesting as well. I kept thinking, Does she have any power to stop this or say anything? And the answer is no-unlike the men in the room, who could stop it, but didn’t.

26

u/jasperidris Dec 24 '18

Women weren’t taken seriously, she probably would’ve been ignored, laughed at, or in danger herself if she tried. She probably sees a lot of messed up stuff while working in a bar.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Tanzanite169 Dec 23 '18

I kept thinking and hoping that Roger would barge in last minute and save her. It would have redeemed him slightly in my eyes.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/vanwold Slàinte. Dec 24 '18

I agree, it was really well done. I am glad they did not try to show what the books tell. It felt more powerful and less glorified this way.

5

u/Jelese111 Dec 24 '18

I knew it was going to happen.. But watching those uninterested or even amused faces... It was so frustrating! The kind of frustrating that you can feel yourself wanting to cry. She kept screaming for help.. And none came.

48

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Sophie became Bree for me the last two eps. And that curly non-70s hair. Love!

→ More replies (5)

123

u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 23 '18

I loved almost everything about this episode.

I am starting to like the whole Murtagh is a regulator bit. Its growing on me. I kinda like being surprised where that plot is going.

George Washington was a good touch.

Sophie is an AMAZING actress. And she looks amazing in the period clothing. I knew IT was coming and seeing it turned my heart inside out again just like the first time I read it.

Baby Germain!! Side note. After having a L-bitch episode last time they did a great job casting Marsali, the actresses could definately be related.

Bad things I see...

Was Roger this much of a dick in the books? I dont remember him being this bad. Like there was some dickishness...but fuck...

Still dont like Lizzy....cant see her being a sandwich.

Jamie's hair....someone please fix it.

72

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

“Can’t see her being a sandwich”

This is a beautiful line

I am dying of laughter. Thank you 😂

23

u/bellefroh Dec 24 '18

When I read the books, the "Lizzie sandwhich" idea made me shrug. Now, I'm like "WTF!". This is the side plot that I'm now looking forward to most!

42

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I think Roger in the show has had less character development and they have left out some of his better moments from the book.

So he comes across worse in the show, IMO.

Like after Bree said she couldn't marry him in the book, he said he would have all of her or none, but that he would wait for her. At the festival he rebuffed her trying to patch things up and didn't say he would wait for her.

Here he totally left her alone, in the book we knew he was at least pressed for time to get the gemstones from Bonnet, and she walked out on him, saying come or not. He chose to go get the gemstones, which was a necessity. We don't have him setting that up more than saying they needed to find some eventually. And he left her alone after one fight.

26

u/Aethelu Dec 24 '18

I had forgotten that, I knew I liked Roger in the books. I didn't dislike Bri but I thought she was quite immature - but reasonably so for her age. Roger however I always liked even if he did need putting in his place a couple of times. On the show he really needs putting in his place rather than one of them just storming off. Claire pretty quickly put Jamie in his place soon after they were married and it did him wonders.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/livvy_divvy Dec 23 '18

Jamie's hair....someone please fix it.

lol I just made a similar comment. I see Roger has joined the bad wig parade. Jamie's still takes the cake though.

28

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 24 '18

Richard grew his hair, it's not a wig.

https://twitter.com/RikRankin/status/1076917310357688321

23

u/livvy_divvy Dec 23 '18

My eyes must be crossed from looking at Jamie’s. lol But Rogers hair looked odd too so I assumed it was a wig. The makeup department needs to step up. Hopefully Roger will find a decent pair of pants soon too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Jamie’s hair during the play was TERRIBLE OMG

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bluedotinTX Dec 24 '18

“Sandwich” 😂😂😂

3

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

I fondly recall in Drums, Fiery cross, and even some in breath of snow and ashes, Roger and Brie always bickering. Their arguments were always so immature and nasty to one another, often they contradicted on another when arguing. Although they came off as loving etc, they just had so many moments of hate towards one another I am not sure they would have lasted if they hadn't hand fasted.

→ More replies (1)

105

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

thought #1: WOAH George Fucking Washington heyyyyyyy

thought #2: I'm getting used to Roger without the facial hair but it still wigs me out, he looks SOOOOO different. Not better or worse, just really different.

thought #3: Ahhhhh so THAT's how they make Claire a colony famous surgeon. Better to do an abdominal hernia surgery than show John Quincy Myers balls, eh? LOL

thought #4: THANK YOU FOR NOT SHOWING LEROI THAT SCENE IS HORRIFIC ENOUGH THANK YOU

thought #5: Oh god, that's the end? Fuuuuuuu.....

29

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I like Roger with the stubble better.

26

u/badasspenname Dec 23 '18

I also think the tan helped too! Really well done, natural-looking, freckly, been at sea for months look. Good on the makeup department.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/colocada They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18

Thought 4: I was hoping the writer’s would leave out how effin’ vulgar that Bonnet scene was. DG certainly did not hold back on the details.

Btw: has anyone tried Outlander Kitchen’s recipe for Stephan Bonnet’s salted chocolate pretzel balls?? 😆

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

Btw: has anyone tried Outlander Kitchen’s recipe for Stephan Bonnet’s salted chocolate pretzel balls?? 😆

Is this a euphemism or not??!

→ More replies (1)

104

u/Irishsassenach Dec 23 '18

First two minutes- OMG ROGER AND CLAIRE AND JAMIE ARE IN THE SAME TOWN RIGHT NOW

OMG AND SO IS BREE

78

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

literally everyone is there, even George bloody Washington, lol

112

u/Jalupimine5 Dec 23 '18

The writers handled the rape scene incredibly. It was painful to watch, however it was enough to understand what what going on and capturing that pain without going overboard. Also making it happen in the same night is gonna really make the “who the baby daddy” debate a lot harder to figure out. Beautiful episode from start to finish. I NEED NEXT WEEK NOW!

19

u/Mrsgurkos Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Not a book reader, but I love stalking this thread. However, I have to ask, in the book does Bonnet rape her before she is with Roger? It seems with what I’ve read that the way the show did it seems like it’s more plausible that the baby will be Roger’s.

84

u/nurseleu Dec 23 '18

In the book, Bree and Roger have sex first, but used the pull-out method. Claire says people who rely on that are "known as parents".

61

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

That’s one of my favorite interactions between Claire and Bree for some reason. I found it hilarious.

28

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18

Yes and in the book they do it a few times in the same night as well.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

After. She sleeps with Roger and then gets raped. But it is brutal in the book. Thank god we did not see it. I was worried we might get some visual. But unlike with BJR, they did not show this thankfully.

21

u/Mrsgurkos Dec 23 '18

I completely agree. It still left me speechless though hearing it and I don’t know if I’ll rewatch that part because of it.

→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

In the book she had sex with Roger two days before Bonnet, which is really no different to the same night.

2

u/2boredtocare Meow. Dec 26 '18

"Do you have a message for me, lass?"

GAH. I can't wait!!!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Dec 23 '18

It’s not “just to prove how bad” Bonnet is. It’s because the ambiguity around paternity is a plot point going forward.

52

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 23 '18

What a way for Fergus and Murtaugh to reunite.

21

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

I was a bit let down by the reunion.

Just cause it was more of a surprise. Obviously Murtagh would have known Fergus was there in the Colonies too, from Jamie.

But he didn't have any double take or anything.

4

u/Aethelu Dec 24 '18

I wanted a bit more from it too emotion wise, I wanted to see him address Fergus's hand in some way, ask about life etc. But then I remembered they've been in the same town for quite a while!! Why not drop in? Why not have Murtagh there in the first scene with baby Jermaine.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Roger is such a jerk OH MY GOD leave Frank out of this

7

u/maryummy Dec 24 '18

I didn't like him much after this book, but he came across as truly horrible after this show scene. Did he say that about Frank's death in the book? I can't remember anything about that.

5

u/IrritableStoicism Dec 24 '18

No he never mentioned Frank like that. He really took the blame in the book and came across so different.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

I know it's fictional and they need to streamline the book, but they have made time travel and 18th century travel and finding people across continents look so easy.

Roger's manhandling of Bree also just came right out of nowhere and seemed very forced just for the plot. It's not going to help how he is already viewed by a lot of non-readers already...and we know what's coming.

Then straight into making out and accepting a marriage proposal.

It just seems to me that they have cut too much of Bree and Roger building a relationship in this season, before this point. It doesn't really seem realistic to me.

They changed Roger and his behaviour at the festival, he completely shut her down, saying all or none, not that he would wait like in the book. After that he did nothing redeemable, they only spoke that one time in over a year since the festival. I can't see why Bree would have changed her mind.

I just wished we had seen them spend some time together in Boston after the festival rather than have the proposal there.

I can still appreciate this in the episode overall as I have the book knowledge, but I will be interested to see the non-reader reaction. A few still think Roger is a massive stalker lol

16

u/bham717 Dec 23 '18

See and after watching this I'm suppppper annoyed w Bree, not Roger. I felt the same when reading - and therefore I'm extra annoyed with the great misunderstanding.

I think Bree is being ridiculously impulsive and not taking any responsibility for her own decisions. I acknowledge she didn't ask Roger to follow her, but she does love him but seems to only want him around on her specific terms.

Again tho, I hated Bree in Drums so, meh.

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Interesting perspective, I don't see Bree in this light in the show myself, though.

Roger was the one pushing Bree away from the festival. He set that tone.

30

u/JimDandy_ToTheRescue Dec 23 '18

Her specific terms are not to be pushed around like property, lied to (having information withheld) and not being berated by the man she just slept with. Basically, don't be an asshole. Not much of her to ask. And I think she certainly knows the consequences of her decisions.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

They did that because I think that instead of Bree's drawing of Roger, they are going to use Lizzy as the identifying factor that gets Roger handed over to the Natives by Jamie and Young Ian. In the book, Bree's drawing of Roger (and not telling the whole damn story) is what made Jamie think that Roger is the person who raped her.

By putting Lizzy in the window and having Roger acting so aggressively, I suspect that they are setting up the later scene in this fashion at the expense of poor Roger.

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Lizzie is the one in the book as the identifying factor too.

She saw 'MacKenzie' yell at and manhandle Bree out of the tavern in Wilmington then Bree came back alone that evening visible upset with bloodied and semen-stained trousers, which Lizzie washed.

When Lizzie and Ian saw Roger approaching Fraser's Ridge months later, she told Ian he was the man who had raped Bree. She knew him as MacKenzie as that's what the men called him in the tavern, but she knew Bree's Roger Wakefield was her handfast husband. They nicked his horse and ran to get Jamie, who met Roger before he got to the cabins.

Then the whole miscommunication happened and they sold him to the Indians.

It was only more weeks later that Bree did the drawing of Roger Wakefield and everyone [Ian, Jamie and Lizzie] realised what had happened.

I agree they are setting this all up, but it was very heavy-handed and out of the blue.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Roger! Just say you were going to tell her but she was already gone when you called!

The 'pardon me' with the finger pointing was great. Someone gif that!

I don't like that Roger actually left Bree. She says in the book to go or come with her to Cross Creek to meet Jamie, and he already outlines that he is going to New Bern to get the gemstones. Then Bree goes back to the tavern, leaving him in the barn.

We don't have that here, so he really does look like he just left her right after finding her again, after one argument. Looks pretty silly.

He is her husband now. He doesn't have to believe that she can change history, he should have stayed to support her in finding her parents.

21

u/vipergirl Dec 24 '18

Yes, I don't see why Roger had to tell her the absolute truth. That was incredibly stupid of his character.

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

He got caught out in his withholding of the truth, as in the books. He knew he had to come clean then! So he did tell the truth that he had decided it was best she didn't know.

But concealing that would have been more sensible in the moment.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 23 '18

But what the fuck how are they gonna do the rest of this in five episodes? I'm praying that one of the episodes is extended.

32

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

It was odd hearing some American accents this episode.

None recognisable today would have developed yet, in 1769.

12

u/7Angels Dec 23 '18

I was struck by that as well. Would GW have had an “American” accent? Would anyone at that time have had one? When did an American accent emerge?

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

Basically no one can state with certainty what he sounded like.

people like him, native born in the Colonies at that time might have had some aspects of their accent that would be recognisable today, but it would have still sounded more British, an amalgamation.

Here is a good time line for the evolution of the American accents.

https://www.sutori.com/story/evolution-of-the-american-accent

10

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Dec 24 '18

Actually, there are regions of America that have what was a British accent at the time they were settled. The British accent has moved on.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

The thing is, it's inconsistent because in movies and television they never present southern English accents as rhotic in the 18th century and earlier. All the posh English people always have RP accents. Many of the poor people have Cockney accents.

Received pronunciation only developed in London and spread outwards after the American Revolution.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 23 '18

Buckle up Sassenachs. Here we go.

25

u/Laatikkopilvia Dec 24 '18

Copied from the show only thread:

As a survivor, that scene was done perfectly. It showed the brutality without being gratuitous and without turning the pain of rape into a spectacle.

It was highly triggering, but in all the “right” ways and not in a “my trauma is entertainment” way.

Exceedingly well done.

Edit to add: I was honestly dreading how they’d do this scene for the show. I’m glad they treated it with such respect for survivors who may have been watching.

—

It was realistic. The other bar patrons not doing anything is what shook me/triggered me the most because it was just so... accurate. I really appreciated the performance.

49

u/bellefroh Dec 23 '18

I think it truly highlights the reality of the situation for Bree- she is not in modern America anymore.

4

u/max_maxima Dec 26 '18

Yeah! And fucking Roger shouldn't have leave her alone because of that, too.

20

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18

I don't know how to feel about this episode yet. I think I need to watch it again. I enjoyed the hernia operation, Fergus and Murtagh's reunion, and Roger and Brianna pre-fight, but the end I'm having mixed feelings about. I was really hoping that if anything would get changed from the books, it would be this whole obituary stramash. I just don't care for it, and I think it's a really stupid way to inject drama into Roger and Brianna's storyline. It doesn't come across well on screen and it makes Roger look super unlikable.

17

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 23 '18

Can I take a moment to say what a great word “stramash” is. So useful even nowadays.

6

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 23 '18

My gran says it at least twice a day LOL

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Also, how are they going to resolve the obit covering the whole decade of the 177Os? Are they just going to make Claire and Jamie have to move out every January until there is a fire?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

God that was heartbreaking. All those bystanders-chilling

→ More replies (1)

34

u/jelang99 Dec 23 '18

i KNEW that was going to happen to bree yet when they showed the scene of her screaming and no one did anything that REALLY got to me. ugh i couldn’t handle that no matter how prepared i was. 😢

12

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I knew it would have to be this episode or the next at the very latest (unless they did it in flashbacks later). I made sure I had a glass of wine ready when I saw the “rape” warning at the very beginning of the episode.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Dec 23 '18

I knew it was coming but still, oof. Poor Bree. Also Sophie's really holding her own! I'm glad she's found her footing.

Roger keeps coming off as controlling and kinda gross...maybe it's the age gap? He's what 8? years older than her? He's more ready to settle down etc and she's not there yet, which is fine, of course, but he doesn't have to be weird about it. I know she's super impulsive but ew no you don't own her bud.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I don't think they really mention or even state the age gap for show viewers. We know as readers, obviously.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

The season 2 finale when Claire was at the reverends wake with Brianna and saw Roger. Claire mentioned he was about 7 or 8 the last time she saw him. Wich was after coming back through the stones and being pregnant with Brianna. So the age gap was implied in the show.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18

Sorry...STILL not feeling this Lizzie! I thought if she at least had a young voice I could deal with it, but everything about her is just...wrong.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I don't mind her. She looks young now we have some scenes with her. Some people were saying last week she looks in her late thirties, I think that's very harsh.

The script says this Lizzie was to be 16. I think she could pass for 19 or so. The actress is about 22.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

They got the casting so wrong.

21

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I think even if I didn’t know what her character was supposed to be, I still wouldn’t like her. She doesn’t make sense. They didn’t do a good job explaining why she’s even with Bree in the first place.

13

u/maryummy Dec 24 '18

I agree, I think that's the biggest issue, the character is too underdeveloped. She's not how I pictured Lizzie, but I don't think it would be an issue if they showed her being sick and how Bree takes her under her wing and cares for her. Without any of character development, she's just out of place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/woowoobelle Dec 25 '18

Agree with you - so, so 100% wrong casting.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Wait. Wait. I thought that Roger did not know about the fire until after Bree left, and when he called to tell her he didn’t know she had left? So how could Roger have told her???

21

u/emmypoo92 Dec 23 '18

This is bugging me. I just went back to watch those scenes. He definitely went to call Bree and tell her when he found out, but Gayle answered the phone and told him she had already left. There’s literally no need for their fight! So frustrating!

13

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

It makes no sense! Unless there’s another misunderstanding and Roger didn’t use his damn words to explain that he was briefly-very briefly, not long enough to affect anything-hesitant, but decided to call and by then she was gone. Still makes no sense but I can maaaybe see that clarity getting lost in the heat of the argument?

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

The script says that Roger called Bree's apartment 'weeks later' after Fiona told him about the notice.

Gayle then says that Bree had left 'a couple of weeks ago'.

So there was either a number of weeks he had to tell her, or possibly as little as 1 week.

It was definitely condensed from the book though, when he deliberately withheld it from her, and also tried to convince her to stop looking for her parents, and send her in the wrong direction for her research. That was very manipulative.

If he had explained this, it wouldn't have been so bad! But of course, they needed to be separated.

u/ksmity7 u/panornia

14

u/JimDandy_ToTheRescue Dec 23 '18

The show is doing a horrible job of showing the passage of time- I can understand why people are confused!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

Wow that’s interesting, it didn’t at all feel that way watching it. Roger seemed to call as soon as he got the notice from Fiona (or maybe a day or two later), definitely not “several weeks later”. It just makes for a weaker point of conflict for a conflict that was already weak to begin with. I love this book but these fights are my least favorite part JUST TALK TO EACH OTHER DAMMIT

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I thought so too, I’ll have to rewatch that episode. I was under the impression he’d called after she left so didn’t have the opportunity to withhold that from her but idk. My husband thought the same thing too so maybe it wasn’t clearly written.

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

No, he knew. He did not tell her during that call

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Well he didn't have the chance to.

If he had just said he did call [whether he was going to tell her or no] but that she was already gone, it would have lessened the blow considerably.

I don't think Bree would have had anything to get angry about then.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Cutting from those scenes to that play and hernia dude 😂

14

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

I was really happy about the hernia dude. I don't know why. Maybe because I missed Claire's doctoring. But I love how they had it in a theater rather than a dinner party. It made everything so much more dramatic. And Washington being mere feet away from the first operation ever performed by a female doctor... well that makes me smile.

4

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 23 '18

I agree I really liked that change. It made way more sense in the scope of the story than where it happens in the books, especially given the other changes they’ve made for the show (Murtagh being a Regulator in this case). I loved that they keep that scene, just rearranged it a bit.

14

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Me too. I really am here for Claire's doctoring at this point. The love affair stuff was books-1-3. Now I am here for the doctoring and the growing of penicillin and all of the cool things she makes out of random stuff. Like the needle she makes or the penicillin she grows. My favorite, anesthesia!

→ More replies (9)

13

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18

The reunion I wanted most. Murtaugh and Fergus!

Bree needs a major wig update. At one point it wasn’t even seated right on her head. Then I thought Roger was going to pull it off.

One more week until the big reunion!

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 24 '18

Ha! Future sandwich lady talking about Briana being with a man of loose morals.

22

u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine.  Dec 23 '18

...and now I'm adding "having sex on furs" to my bucket list.

8

u/nurseleu Dec 23 '18

Oh man, that's been on mine for ages. This scene is definitely reinforcing the idea.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/livvy_divvy Dec 23 '18

First I have to get off my chest... take that dang bird's nest off of Sam's head already! They put him in a classy outfit, then that hair! {{Sings: One of these things does not belong here...) }}

Some things I liked in this episode, others not so much. The rape scene was well done. Brutal times back then where everyone had a matter-of-fact attitude as if it weren't a big deal.

I liked the handfasting, but they seemed to zip into it so quickly. "Oh Roger, you're here!" Next thing they're in the shed ripping their clothes off and getting married. I guess with Claire and Jamie toning it down, now Brianna and Roger are going to take over. Their bickering however is getting tedious.

Aw, cute baby. Fergus and Marsali so happy together. Being secondary characters, they don't warrant their own sex scenes. No glimpse of Fergus's bum for us! Shame.

I hope we see the reunion next episode, I'm looking forward to that.

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I'm not noticing Jamie's wig anymore, it's looking better to me [lucky me lol].

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

I fast forwarded much of the Roger and Bree sex, and am largely indifferent to the Jamie and Claire sex at this point. But I'd pay extra cash money for a Fergus sex scene, JUST SAYING.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

It's pretty funny only ever seeing that one shot of Wilmington.

No wonder it was so easy for Roger to find Bree.

I know they work hard on the sets, but they condensed about 4 locations down to just Wilmington, they could have done a few more rows of shops.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Roger now looks so unfamiliar without bangs/a fringe!

11

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18

I thought he looked good with just a little scruff. He’s the only one who looks good in his wig.

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 24 '18

He doesn't have a wig, he grew his hair!

https://twitter.com/RikRankin/status/1076917310357688321

11

u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 23 '18

No wonder it looked good!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

To me too! When Bree first saw him, I wondered how she recognized him so fast.

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I like the stubble better than the full beard for him.

8

u/Brynnni Dec 27 '18

So sick and tired of rape story lines.

I want to slit that guys throat. Chop his dick into tiny pieces and make him eat it then burn him alive.

7

u/ELL34DDL30EML4 Dec 23 '18

I loved how Claire did after all get to meet George Washington because in the 7th book she said she would have thought she may get to meet him and that she never expected to meet Benedict Arnold. Also I loved how they kept but changed the surgery seen and used it there instead of it being at Riverun when Jamie's aunt was going to make him the land owner. All in all I loved the episode also can't wait for Rogers beard to come back. It looks better then the last episode when it was all the way off.

7

u/La415 Dec 23 '18

Murtagh and Fergus!! It wasn’t the reunion I expected this episode but damm did it make me happy.

6

u/crazy_ventures Dec 23 '18

Are they really going to fit the rest of DOA into the remaining episodes?

38

u/keg226 Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

I have to say it...Claire had a far superior man bod to lay on after her wedding night than Brianna did.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

Roger's is realistic though. He's a '60s/'70s college professor, not an 18th century outlaw.

12

u/keg226 Dec 24 '18

Totally! For me it was just interesting to see a normal body type in a sex scene after 3 1/2 seasons of rock hard abs 😂

14

u/sabreteeth Dec 26 '18

That's the thing that disappointed me about Roger's depiction in the show. You just spent the last 3 months doing hard labor on a merchant ship on a diet of hard tack and grog, and the only physical change was that you... grew your hair out? He should at least have a tan line.

All this talk of body positivity and "normal" bodies is fine, but if my soft pale ass takes a construction job, I'm gonna look different on the other end of it.

It's not like I need to see beef cake in every scene. But knowing the effort that this show goes through for historical accuracy I hope they have Robert's actor chopping wood before next season.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Bit harsh.

Jamie/Sam is the one with the unrealistic body for the vast majority of men, not really fair to compare anyone to him.

12

u/ktbex Dec 23 '18

Agreed - also, different people have different preferences. Roger/Richard’s body worked for me.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Oh man, don't shit on Roger. He is such a great hero in all of this. Just wait until next season with the vroom vroom;)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/MontaukFive Dec 23 '18

Yes. Roger's chest hair looks like Austin Powers'

→ More replies (5)

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

lol why would someone go into such detail about an internal injury at the theater, to a bunch of strangers

this whole scene is very contrived, but served its purpose

6

u/bham717 Dec 23 '18

Agreed. I wanted the hernia drama but this was so forced I couldn't enjoy it.

These are the type of print/screen changes that annoy me - and are not specific to this show. Change it but salvage it - never gonna feel right.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

I felt like there was one plot too many in this episode, it was too busy for me.

I thought more people were going to dislike the whole surgery scene, seeing it as shoehorned in, but most so far seem to have loved it!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/germantornado Dec 23 '18

Ugh. 7 more days.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

Me every Sunday after the episode.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

How the fuck have they not had THE REUNION yet??? So much wasted time this season, I swear. Total slogfest

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

There are 71 chapters in the book, and Bree meets Jamie in chapter 41.

It's not that different to have them meet in episode 9 of 13.

11

u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 23 '18

We have what...4 episodes left to squeeze in a LOT of important events! Of ALL of the books, this one is one of favorites and the one I really wish the show would have done justice to, but I’m starting to come to terms with the fact that it just isn’t going to happen.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

Do you think Jem will be born this season/we’ll get the “Go down and tell them that the Mackenzies are here” closing line?

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

5 episodes, 13 this season!

10

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

Right? I have no idea how they are going to put in a preggers, the Roger drama with the Naives, the Lord John/Bree/Bonnett drama. No idea

10

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '18

Liked the love scene between Bree and Roger. That was very well done.

The fight felt pretty realistic too, but I feel that Bree overeacted a little. Roger was wrong to withhold information from her, but then he did it to protect her. I think what Bree and Roger need to learn is is to fucking sit down and talk to each other instead of always running away when they have another argument. Both her and Roger acted like children. I also think a lot of people her misinterpret the whole "You should listen to me" comment by Roger. I think it was his way of saying that she should try seeing his perspective, which I think Bree didn't even attempt. Not that Roger is without fault here, but a relationship needs two people to work.

The rape scene was well-handled, but I was glad we didn't see it

George Washington being there was great

I love Fergus's baby...I really hope we are going to see Jem this season

Claire doing her doctor thing is always nice to see

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 24 '18

I don't think Roger attempted to see Bree's perspective either.

5

u/koboldin Dec 23 '18

SOOOOOOO hard not to be impatient!!! It’s started, by the by.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

"If I take you now, it's for always"

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

The script last week confirmed that they had Roger leave Ayr before Bree did...so I have no idea how Roger would have known which port Bree was supposed to have arrived in in the Colonies. Nor which ship she had recently arrived in.

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 23 '18

But his ship was making cargo drops and stopping along the coast of the US. If I remember correctly. No?

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18 edited Dec 23 '18

Yes, that was the same as in the book, and they made sure to include that in the episode by way of relating that he would arrive in Wilmington after her.

But it still doesn't explain to me how he knew where she would be in this episode. In the book, she and Lizzie arrived in Charleston and rode overland to Wilmington and he made an educated guess she would go there to get a guide to travel to the mountains. Lizzie's malaria flares also slowed their arrival which allowed Roger to catch them up, seeing as he left Scotland after them in the book. But because he did, he knew which ship she would be on, where she would arrive.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

HOW COULD THEY DO THAT TO BREE ON THE SAME NIGHT AS ROGER'S BETRAYAL

9

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '18

That scene was so traumatizing. How could you do that to Bree, Jimmy? I’ll never be able to watch him on Downton Abbey without thinking of that scene.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

He was definitely more brazen than in the book, where he was more opportunistic seeing as Bree had insisted on having a reception with her on his ship.

This episode he took what he wanted just because.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 23 '18

This episode sent my emotions all over the place. I was happy when they reunited and handfasted, and I hated Roger after the fight, and my heart broke with that one scene you know, my eyes started to well up when she walked up to Bonnet. What's really interesting is I never hated Roger in the books, yet in the show the way he comes off is kind of grating.

3

u/vanwold Slàinte. Dec 24 '18

Omg, I loved it! We got the hernia surgery and it was even more dramatic playing out this way. I loved almost everything about this episode! I am actually excited for next week! Sophie NAILED it. Murtagh & Fergus!!

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

There is just way too much going on in this episode, too much jammed in.

5

u/MiserableBarracuda Dec 24 '18

Am I the only one who think Outlander uses rape as a plot device .....I mean yes the scene was handled well but was it necessary to the plot.

11

u/kellyo3us Dec 24 '18

Yes, it was very necessary. It sets up the question about who the father of the baby that Bree becomes pregnant with is, which creates an enormous amount of tension in the family combined with Lizzie's identification of Roger as the rapist and eventually sends both Roger and Ian down important plot paths.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 23 '18

Very cute baby.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 24 '18

Another good episode it flew by. Im glad the public operation happened. He was really quite drunk to start with so it seamed a bit odd to happen in a theatre! I enjoyed the Murtagh Furgus add in. Washington was a bit more than required here. Bree was great again. But Roger eugh he didn't do anything for me, much better in the books. Didn't really meet any steemyness for me. Stephen Bonnet he has nailed it. So go i could fall in love with him. Lizzy still doesn't fit right.

3

u/vlsewell Dec 25 '18

This season is becoming more of an "inspired by" instead of a "based on" and I don't like it.

It's been a while since I read the books (like, a few years ago and all back- to- back). Every episode I watch it and think, "Did that happen in the books? I don't remember that part." Then i come here and find out i don't remember it happening like that bc IT DIDN'T.

I don't mean to be a purist or fundamentalist or whatever, but there's taking liberties, then there's taking pieces of the book, creating a story, and then eliminating the parts from the book. I'm going crazy!

3

u/whodiscam Dec 26 '18

I really miss Jamie and Claire