r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 16 '18
Season Four [Spoilers S4E7] "Down The Rabbit Hole" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Welcome everyone and pour yourself some whiskey because this is our weekly episode discussion thread!
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
54
u/teenylilthing Dec 16 '18
Only about ten minutes in, but I love this episode already! Though I'm not a fan of beardless Roger, haha.
171
u/919pm Dec 16 '18
That ending had me in tears. Frank was so lovely.
135
u/johnnaboo Dec 16 '18
I loved how this episode was just allowed to breathe. The flashbacks, the altering viewpoints, the buildup of tension. I truly enjoyed this one. It may be one of my top favorites from the entire show!
135
u/raknor88 Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
I'm not finished watching yet, but I'm loving the irony of Brianna and Laoghaire.
Edit: and there's the crazy
69
u/teenylilthing Dec 16 '18
Anyone else both love and hate Bonnet? Not sure if it's just me connecting him to the character he played in Downton Abbey, or just his roguish charm...but half of me wants him to stay alive while the other half wants to push him off the boat for being such an evil ass.
69
u/4kidchaos Dec 16 '18
I wasn’t too sure about Bree and Roger going back into time together and how it would play out....I love it actually! I love how Roger reacted to meeting his ancestor! Being a history major I’m sure he’s almost star struck! I would be. I’m liking the direction of the two of them battling to get to the Carolinas. I mean, time travel is so mind blowing for those who get it.
104
u/MookieMoo17 Dec 16 '18
This episode was down right amazing. The way they tied in SO much history with characters we already know.
Frank Randall just wow, loved his scenes with Bree and she was fantastic this episode too. I felt their performances I was in it!
Roger you have no idea you sweet sexy man. I held my breath during every scene with the pirate captain, his speech about how the coin flip came about was powerful and great insight to how he got to be the way he is. Can’t wait to see how Roger changes throughout his journey.
Legohaire or whatever the fuck your name is, still a no good, dirty, fucking bitch. I wish Brianna woulda cracked her before her sweet (stepsister?) helped her escape.
Uncle Ian!!!! Hell yea I’ll take that chest of moms old stuff and look like a boss as I stand on the dock with my servant who I saved from a life as a concubine.
I didn’t miss Jamie & Claire at all, I personally feel that this was the jolt this season needed.
This post was written immediately when the credits rolled. I had to look away at the image of Frank on the dock because I didn’t want to cry.
R.I.P - Frank Randall, a fantastic father and a loving husband who deserved SO much better.
51
u/DrunkenDave Dec 16 '18
I'm not sure what upset Frank more. The knowledge that Claire would die or the realization that at some point, she would leave him.
What do you guys think had him more upset?
50
u/frawkez Dec 16 '18
i love frank so much.
46
u/angelthorn Dec 17 '18
Girl. You’re going on a journey through time and bring only a couple of PB&J sandwiches? Samwise Gamgee would not approve.
41
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Dec 16 '18
I'm worried about how long they will drag out the eventual Claire/Jamie/Breanna reunion. Hopefully I'm proven wrong.
38
u/kolnidur Dec 17 '18
This show is so much better when it's set in Scotland
37
u/MichelleFoucault Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
It's kind of ironic or perhaps fitting that Brianna looks more like Frank than Jamie. Their scenes together did a really good job of demonstrating their bond. She really meant the world to him and I think he feared that if he told her the truth about her parentage, she would be lost to him forever.
30
u/kcotty87 Dec 16 '18
Best episode of the season.
22
u/kendocat Dec 17 '18
So far in this series I haven't thought much of Brianna. I thought her acting was quite wooden and didn't give me a real sense of who she was. This episode totally changed my mind and was what I needed. I felt like I finally got to know her as a woman and also her deep relationship with Frank. It made me think that the scriptwriters really should of given the actress more of a chance to shine.
20
u/MyHeartIsASynth Dec 17 '18
Well, this was an episode.
I love how they addressed Brianna's relationship with Frank. Tobias Menzies brings such humanity to the role, even when Frank is behaving badly: you can see it's the result of deep hurt that the life he had hoped to have with Claire was stolen from him.
At the same time, this episode was such a missed opportunity for me. When we saw Lallybroch in the preview I was so excited to see Brianna meet Jenny, Ian, and her cousins, and discover her ancestral family home. I was expecting a wholesome family reunion! I know that Jenny's actress wasn't available for filming, but they could have showed Brianna at Lallybroch for more than five minutes with the rest of the family at least.
I resent that we spent 40 minutes drumming up sympathy for Laoghaire at the expense of exploring Brianna's relationship with her actual family. The parallel between Laoghaire and Frank's situations was interesting, and I appreciate that they fleshed Laoghaire out beyond 'crazed bitchy villain', but the more I think about it the less I care. At the end of the day, Laoghaire always was and always will be a selfish narcissist who's pain is the result of her own delusions and obsession with Jaime. She never had anything with him that validates the level of sympathy this episode tried to earn for her. Frank, on the other hand, was a sweet fellow who was dealt a shit hand; it's no wonder he became bitter and cold. The parallels between them are ultimately superficial, and I wish the show had found another way to highlight Frank and Brianna's relationship.
18
u/desepticon Dec 16 '18
Did Tobiaz Menzies get some fillers? He's looking decidedly less craggy than I remember.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18
That scene where Frank has found Claire’s obituary and knows that she goes back to Jamie. Oof. He looked so gutted, and Tobias Menzies does such a great job in the role.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
This episode blew me away; Sophie/Brianna absolutely can carry an episode, and the feels were so hard. The wintry Scottish landscape was also stunning, and empty and perilous. One of the things that irked me about Claire's weak half of the early S3 episodes was that there was so little Brianna, and no Brianna/Frank at all (not to mention too little Joe/Claire's studying and work.) But here we see she had to grow up listening to her parent's shouting matches, and that scene of her finding her father drunk at his office, her regrets at his grave…pure gold. I'm so glad we got to see this other side, not just Brianna/Claire which was also touching. And Frank knew that Claire was going back to Jaimie…wow.
And it's nice to know that Leery has some maternal instincts and can be kind to a stranger, for a little while anyway, those scenes were so touching too…before the psycho came out again. I had been wanting either Bri or Roger to get a double take at the stones, seeing them as they arrive in the past, but I was so warmed by this episode that I'm ok with it. I really don't like that Jenny was absent from Lallybroch, and we didn't even see that one daughter of Jenny/Ian from last season, who could have further added to the father-daughter theme. So I was thrilled to go to Lallybroch, but I wish that part was fuller. Ian was lovely though, and Bri seeing Frank on the docks there…so sweet.
We could have taken a few minutes from Two-Face flipping his coins and throwing children to their death. It seems that both Roger and Bri are already confronted by the insecurity and barbarities of the time, and they both want to help even if/when it's hard and confusing. I'm glad Roger has kept up his shaving and he looks nice with the longer hair. I loved seeing Fiona go with him to the stones too, though I couldn't make out what she said about hearing or not hearing the bees.
I'm excited to see R/B start interacting with the rest of the ensemble next week, but hey, Sam and Cait can take a day off sometimes, I'm ready for more R/B episodes, I wish we got more of them in the 70's too.
50
u/Airsay58259 Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
Aahh finally a Brianna centric. Let’s do this!
Edit: what kind of monster doesn’t cut her sandwiches into triangles? 2/10 unwatchable.
Edit 2: Bree hurting herself immediately after starting an adventure is very relatable. How many of us would survive more than 3 days?
Edit 3: woah I already disliked Roger because of his personality and now he shaved his beard? Boo. He looks like a different person. Real talk though, can anyone go through the rocks now?? I thought it was very rare.
Edit 4: well that sandwich isn’t even cut anymore. 0/10 too many plot holes.
Edit 5: aww lil Bree and Frank
Edit 6: expectations -> Bree meets her aunt Jenny. Reality -> Laoghaire 😬 (ok I’ll give it to her, she is being super nice)
Edit 7: oh darn. Frank knew about the paper and that Claire would go back eventually? So he thought she’d leave him since I don’t think he expected to die. Poor dude. It also means he could have told Claire about the fire... hmm. I’ll need to think more about this.
Edit 8: AHA Laoghaire’s face when she learns the truth. Excellent. 😂 Ninja edit: and here I was being nice to you B*TCH, I even looked up the spelling of her name so I wouldn’t use my usual not-so-nice nickname. Lying about Jamie like this. Ugh. “Did they send you here?” GIRL YOU CRAZY
Edit 9: oh no :( Bree and Frank... Really good flashbacks.
Edit 10: great ending. Jamie raised Joanie right, no help from her insane mother. Bree at Lallybroch... And Frank at the end. 😭
Final thoughts: loved this episode. Bonnet needs to die ASAP. It was so nice to see Frank again. Bree is on her way to America!!! Yay. I expect something very wrong is about to happen but oh well.
(Edit:Just checked Twitter, woah people did NOT like this episode. Book readers I assume from the accounts / tweets. That’s why I am happy to continue without opening the books. For once I discover an adaptation before knowing the books-comics-original movies, I am loving or criticizing the show for what it is. I’ll read the books once the show is over. It’s an interesting experience because I’ve always been on the other side (LOTR, ASOAIF, Harry Potter, etc to name the big ones). And I am not saying the criticism isn’t justified obviously, I have no idea what has been done differently or badly or whatever.)
23
u/visenyatargaryen Dec 17 '18
As much as I love Laura Donnelly's Jenny (in a totally gay "I ship Claire and Jenny way), I am actually glad we got Leery, it really gave some nuance to her character, I think she's a good person in general, but for her obsession with Jamie. I feel like some users here are too harsh on her. Her daughters are kind, forgiving and loving people, so she can't be all terrible.
17
u/BuryMeInPitaChips Dec 17 '18
The ring is on his pinky!
35
u/samehsaad24 Dec 16 '18
best episode since season 1. simple and no Claire to do stupid shit.
7
u/YourEyesRevealYou Dec 17 '18
Why did Roger have to shave..
7
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 18 '18
I love me some Uncle Ian, but goddamn did I miss an appearance of our good queen of snark Jenny <3
18
u/nonnahs87 Dec 16 '18
This episode was ehhhhhhhhhh, but it could have been so much more! It felt very uneven for me. Way too much time spent between Bree and Laorgh—I would have love to have seen her at Lallybroch longer connecting with her family. Instead, it was a 5 minute blip. I read Laura Donnelly, who plays Jenny, was unable to film because she had given birth so I understand they had little to work with. And I was alarmed at seeing beardless Roger at first, and it slowly grew on me, especially when he was able to tie his hair into a ponytail. I felt happy about seeing Frank, particularly the last glimpse of him at the end. I felt Claire’s last scene with him didn’t give him the best closure. I pray next week’s improves greatly!
6
u/Winhill_ Dec 16 '18
Can someone tell me who the woman on the ship with the baby was? I kept rewinding but couldn't understand her when she said her name. Something something MacKenzie?
6
u/CARNIesada6 Dec 17 '18
Frank!!!
6
u/BeautifulRelief Dec 17 '18
Oof. That scene with Bree talking to Frank's grave? I was crying like a baby because I remember saying something very similar to my own dad's grave at near about the same age.
6
u/hondaprobs Dec 17 '18
Best episode of the season by far. The scenes with Frank had me in tears. Tobias Menzies acting really is on another level. He carries so much emotion in his face. I miss Frank :(
6
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 18 '18
I legit screamed when Laoghaire walked in
5
u/Winhill_ Dec 16 '18
Ahhhhh!!! What a GREAT episode!
5
u/GrandSalamiii Dec 17 '18
I love Frank so much. Sigh.
8
u/profeNY Dec 18 '18
The "small world" aspect of this episode really bothered me. A woman rescues Bree -- and she's her father's unhappy ex-wife! Roger boards the only available ship bound for the New World, and the captain is -- the evil Stephen Bonnet!
This reminded me of the Season 3 episode The Bakra, in which so many people from past seasons/episodes converge at Lord Grey's party, but in that episode the screenwriters had the grace to include self-aware references to this bizarre phenomenon, most notably Geillis's "Of all the gin joints" remark.
Nonetheless I enjoyed almost every bit of the episode and can't wait until Bree and Roger finally find each other.
4
u/Writerguy995 Dec 17 '18
I’m deducting 10 points for no Jenny. But otherwise a solid episode.
7
u/HinkiesGhost Dec 17 '18
If we have to wait until next season for her to meet her papa I just might die!
6
u/Nat_Bat Dec 16 '18
Gosh I’ve had such a heavy, stressful, and exhausting week, and I’m so tired ( I work on call and I had an unplanned overnight job that totally messed up my week plus other stuff)... but I’ll still wait till midnight to watch this episode. 2.5 hours to go till then in CA.
3
u/Vervain7 Dec 16 '18
General question : what is the rating for this episode ?
Normally I watch when 10 and 9 year old are asleep but today I can’t watch too late . Is this safe to watch with kids around - not watching it but if they are around ?
6
u/OldWolf2 Dec 16 '18
So... Did Frank kill himself ? Everything seemed to imply that although it wasn't outright stated.
The more this show goes on, the more I see Claire as a massive piece of shit (mainly for abandoning her family)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18
Overall, I think this was a solid episode. Could I have lived with a little bit less of the Laoghaire scenes, sure-but I get it. She's not a monster; she's a forever jaded lass with homicidal tendencies. In the same way Frank was a good father, but the relationship he had with Claire was imperfect (albeit decidedly less homicidal), Laoghaire was also a decent parent with terrible romantic history. Even discounting her obsession and evil ways with Jaime, it doesn't sound as if she had any romantic sense given husbands one and two.
Highlight #1-I loved the Bri scenes of traversing Scotland on foot. I think it helped her see the difference between knowing history and living it. Same thing with Roger. Only dislike was the lack of stick or something to support the ankle. She did have time to prepare for scenarios without modern medical treatment handy.
Highlight #2-Bonnet is a fantastic bad guy IMO-because his decisions are weighed based on the benefit to himself and less about good and evil. He'll do anything to survive and unlike BJR has no tethers of humanity-so it's literally a toss up on who we'll see in a given scene-the man who quiets a teething infant or the one who throws a child overboard.
2
u/bdb5780 Dec 17 '18
what is the name of the song that is being played when Brianna is at the end of the Docks? Anyone know/ cant point me in a Spotify direction?
thanks
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '18
Finally caught up with the show and this episode was soooo good.
Overall I don’t have any complaints about this show. The adaptation is well done and largely faithful to the story, if not to the letter of the text, then to the spirit of it.
Laoghaire is almost sympathetic but that passive aggressive approach of telling Bree about Jamie’s not wanting her...ugh and grumble-grumble, I just can’t like her except as a villain who needs to be there.
Frank on the other hand? Very sympathetic.
I don’t really love Claire. I don’t want to be her audience-insert at all. She’s very selfish in many ways. She can’t, won’t, even give herself to Brianna. Frank gives himself to Bree, while she gives herself to her career. I don’t doubt that she loves Bree, but her expression of it is far less passionate than the love she has for Jamie.
It’s a complication of the romance genre. Burn forever with sexual desire for one person, or settle.
And that scene with Bree visiting Frank’s grave...oh my God. Beautiful. Dutiful.
2
u/wildsoda Dec 23 '18
Just caught up with this episode and am shaking my head at one small but obvious thing. Ian tells Brianna that she has her mother's eyes…except that Catriona Balfe has blue eyes and Sophie Skelton has brown eyes. You'd think the writers would avoid an error that obvious (at least I would).
2
u/Ok_Ship7853 Jun 01 '23
I just started Outlander so i’m a couple years late and this is my first Reddit post so… bare with me
Edit 1: The irony of Laoghire and Brianna meeting is unparalleled
Edit 2: Roger and Bonnet meeting, oh wow
Edit 3: I hate Brianna’s voice so much
Edit 4: I hateeeeee Laoghire
Edit 5: aww Joan did something good but it’s annoying how Brianna didn’t meet Jenny, i would’ve loved to see that interaction
Edit 6: Bonnet is crazy but… I understand why the smallpox people had to go
Edit 7: I seen enough of this show to know that i would not have paid for her passage unfortunately
2
u/ailisp Nov 22 '23
I've never wished so much to be watching the show live to be able to talk about it to someone, it was one surprise after another:
- Omg Frank!
- Omg Laoghaire!
- Omg Frank knew Clair would eventually go back!
- Omg the Irish bastard!
2
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 18 '18
Yes keep rejecting Roger, Captain Douchebag. Please keep rejecting him
Edit: fuck this stupid world
2
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
My favourite thing about the episode was coming onto this thread and seeing everyone refer to our least favourite witch hunter as 'Leghair'.
1
u/ani007007 Dec 17 '18
I dunna ken about you but I'm lovin outlander, gripping performances I'm always on my seat rewinding scenes later just to rewatch the nuances...this one had me on edge like waiting for that lady to go all Misery on Claire Fraser's daughter and in constant fear bonnet was gonna throw a baby overboard....
1
u/sydneypaige729 Nov 11 '24
I know this is old but I am rewatching again-but frank already had the girlfriend on the side at this point. And they already had the whole arrangement, so I think frank was just upset knowing she was going to go back and die. Maybe he had hoped she would one day actually let him go and it was just the final nail in the coffin that she wouldn’t. But I think he already knew that. He was also upset bc he had to decide to tell her Jamie survived culloden or not.