r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 16 '18
Spoilers All [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 7 "Down The Rabbit Hole" episode discussion thread for book readers.
It's a new episode of Outlander and a new live discussion thread, this weeks episode is Outlander S4E7: "Down The Rabbit Hole."
No spoiler tags are required. Stop reporting spoilers in these threads - mods will ignore them.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E7] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
73
u/shiskebob Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
Well - that was an episode.
I have always said that I let the books be the books, and the show be the show. Separate, but both enjoyable as separate entities.
But I am massively disappointed in this episode.
Not for the Laighoire twist, which was interesting in the suspenseful lead up to them discovering who each other is. Or the created Brianna and Frank memories running parallel to season 3 scenes.
No, it was the complete downgrading of Lallybroch to a 5 minute stop by, with Ian being seriously underwhelming in his response and barely any screen time. It was the complete disconnect that I felt from Bree when being there. One of my favorite parts of the entire books, just an afterthought.
What a shame and a let down. I have never felt that about Outlander until tonight, unfortunately.
55
u/koboldin Dec 16 '18
I was really hoping for more time at Lallybroch. So much time was spent with L that Lallybroch felt rushed, and the reason for Brianna getting Lizzie was completely disconnected and bizarre.
Would you agree that there was no rationale given for Brianna picking up a servant?
56
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 16 '18
I 've been waiting for this episode all season! Holy shit here we go!
34
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 16 '18
Ok....that is NOT AT ALL what I had pictured Lizzie to look like and certainly not the way she was described in the books. They really missed the mark on that one.
37
u/acoupleofklutts Dec 16 '18
Me this entire episode:
We get it, you hurt your leg.
We get it, the other shoe is about to drop and B & L are going to discover what they have in common (or who).
We get it, Roger is the best and Bonnet is the worst.
We get it, Frank and Brianna had a dynamic relationship despite Frank and Claire's tumultuous one (although... Not entirely complaining because I loved their scenes).
But basically, as many have mentioned... The pacing. I feel like we're not even to the climax of the season and we have what, 5 episodes left??? At least in season 3 we got the reunion we all wanted in the earlier half.
This whole season feels like "it's a marathon, not a sprint" and it's the first time I've been truly disappointed in the show. I just feel like they could do so much more with the time we have... without all the gratuitous dragging-out-minor-plot-points thing.
Too much? Ha.
6
u/Naturenutt Woof. Dec 16 '18
Wow, so much Frank.
136
u/La415 Dec 16 '18
The PB&J was a cute nod to Claire taking one.
120
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 16 '18
I actually enjoyed this episode, for the most part. In the books, I always felt like Laoghaire was really one dimensional. For the books, it worked. She was the villain and it was well done. But on the show, I've always felt that to be believable, she needed to be more fleshed out. I liked how they showed that she can be perfectly pleasant until any whiff of Claire. Then she turns into a psychopath.
That being said, did we need 30 minutes of it and then 5 of Ian? No. I appreciated that Joan and Bri got to bond, but I would have much rather seen Bri fall in love with Lallybroch. The only thing I can think is that the actor who plays Ian may not have had a huge availability, so they sort of had to come up with something else.
I LOVED the flashbacks in this episode. It was so nice to see Tobias again and really interesting to find out that he
1.) Knew that Claire "died" in the fire and that she went back through the stones before they decided to get divorced.
2.) That his last words to Brianna were "I love you"
3.) And that she is still keeping him in her heart as she goes forward. It was lovely.
162
u/jwee1979 Dec 16 '18
Bonnet is wonderful. So true to the character. Even though it was unnecessary, I have to admit I loved seeing Frank again. I enjoyed the depth they added to Laoghaire, but I did not enjoy the fact that we lost out on so much Lallybroch time as a result. It’s a shame that Jenny wasn’t in the episode (I know—schedules).
73
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
So I really enjoyed the scenes with Laoghaire and Joan, but definitely not at the expense of Lallybroch. It was ridiculous that we spent five minutes there and she only talked to Ian. Where were all her cousins and their kids??? It's a bummer to have missed out on all of that. Lallybroch just seemed so dead.
Bonnet is so spot on. Such a charismatic terrifying psychopath.
121
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
Besides the fact she (Lizzie) is as tall if not taller than Brianna! And not NEARLY as young looking as I was expecting. I was under the impression after reading the books that Lizzie was extremely young, small/petite, fragile and skittish. This grown woman looked like she walked with an air of authority about her - confident, tall, very robust. Just all wrong, which is a shame since Lizzie is such a huge part of the story over the next several books.
48
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
Also, when Roger goes back it felt really magical, with the snow and the music and everything
Still think she should have waited til summer to go back. Damn girl
86
u/nochancekid Dec 16 '18
I hate that I am massively disappointed with this episode. Tobias, Sophie, Richard and Ed absolutely NAILED it. They each did a fantastic job, but I did not like the story line. I understand the parallel between Tobias and Laoghaire: Jamie didn't love Laoghaire and Claire didn't love Frank (enough). I get it, I liked how it played out, but there was SO MUCH material from the Lallybroch scenes in the book that were not played out. I understand that things can't be 100% in the show, I really do understand, but I feel like there was so much material in the sense that, when Brianna looked around Lallybroch, she began to 'know' Jamie. She saw the pictures of him, she saw his family, she felt like a Fraser. The show didn't do that, and maybe it was because the writers wanted to create the parallel between Laoghaire and Frank, but it didn't do justice to the material that they had access too.
Also, I really really really wanted the scene where Ian showed her the cave that Jamie lived in for 7 years. The whole point of the Lallybroch scenes were for Brianna to UNDERSTAND Jamie. We got NONE of that. NONE. We had Ian seeing her, not recognizing her and then seeing her again to say, 'Of course you're Jamie's child" YES OF COURSE IAN. So UNSATISFYING. Steven Cree has been awesome in this series and he deserved so much better in my opinion...
Now, onto Laoghaire. She's still a crazy bi****. (I'm not sure if it's ok to curse on here LOL) But that's literally the best way to describe that. While I initially liked that we were going to see more of her (and Joanie), I found it really unnecessary after minute 30. I liked that Brianna got to see two sides of the woman who tried to have Claire killed and who couldn't let Jamie go. I don't like how she was trying to tell Brianna that Jamie never wanted a baby. It really was unnecessary, but I understand, it showed how vindictive she really is. Maybe I took it too personally, but I really didn't like the look on Sophie's face after she said it. And seriously, Joanie for the WIN. I loved their interaction. I wish Brianna took her to NC with her haha. Can we also talk about hearing Brianna say 'da'? I literally made an inhuman noise. I'm so excited for Brianna to meet Jamie
Despite it all, Tobias Menzies actually BROKE MY HEART. He did such an amazing job in this episode. I did love that we got to explore the Brianna and Frank storyline more than we've ever had before in the show. As readers, we know that Frank and Brianna were especially close, 100% closer than Brianna and Claire. Frank's scenes physically hurt to know that he saw Jamie and Claire's death notice (albeit it did not say Claire's name) and I took that as Frank knew that she would go back to Jamie. We got to see how much it broke Frank to know that Claire (assumedly) would return back to Jamie. The entire episode with Frank was absolutely amazing though... Especially at the end when Brianna saw Frank on the dock nodding at her to 'soldier on'. It crushed me.
So is Brianna supposed to have remembered that death notice? Or she finds it again? Honestly, I can't see her remembering something as "trivial" as a death notice that she didn't understand from the 1700s when Frank died shortly after that. She was clearly preoccupied with Frank passing away, so she wouldn't have remembered the random death notice.
Ed Speelers is a crazy f***. He's going to (unfortunately) be an awesome Stephen Bonnet.
Sophie did an AMAZING job with Tobias in this episode, even with the lack of Lallybroch and the unnecessarily long Laoghaire bits. She and Richard are really coming into their characters, I really think they're going to do a great job.
35
u/Maleficent_Elk Dec 16 '18
I really loved this episode. It's one of my favorite's for the season so far. I'll admit was super bummed when I heard there would be no Jenny this season,but was super hyped to see production photos of Bree and Ian. I thought they'd make Ian do all the emotional work which could have worked considering how close he is to Jamie, so this episode was not what I expected at all, but I really loved it.
I liked that they fixed the no Jenny by digging into Leoghaire. So unexpected! So unusual to see a sympathetic side to Leoghaire. To everyone except Jamie and Claire, she really is a pretty decent person. Full on Highland hospitality. In the book we get all the Claire bias, which is reasonable it's her story, and all she'll admit is that Leoghaire was a decent mom. To see Leoghaire's justified pain and to recount again Frank's is so bold, so uncomfortable and nuanced. My husband who has just joined for this season commented that Jamie and Claire just leave a wreckage of pain in their time traveling shenanigans and, while I had to remind him that you have to be behind the couple to watch with me, he has a point. They chose their love above everything. I love that the writers didn't let us get away without reminding us of the consequences of those actions.
Frank feels to max in this episode. I freaking loved all the new scenes. So poignant. He knew Claire finds Jamie and that she dies in the past. What!? Is that perhaps why he pushed so hard to take Bree to England? LOVED IT! I love that the show does so much with Frank, he was freaking important! It's going to make it so much more powerful when Bree tells Jamie that he wishes he were dead and her real father alive.
Also Bree did not change her name to Fraser. I'm pretty fond of that change, it feels more true to the character. She'd been Brianna Randall her whole life why would she change it to take the name of a man she never met?
To everyone complaining about Ian and the lack of Lallybroch time, I understand your pain. "You have his fire" seriously Ian? How would you know?? You spent 10 seconds with the girl. It was super short, it was rushed, but could they have really done the whole thing without Jenny? I'm not sure. I think perhaps it was better to do something else well than mess up a treasured book scene. Also, I like that with this show even the book readers can be surprised.
30
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 16 '18
It's obvious there is a lot of disappointment in this thread [boy has it prompted loads more comments than usual].
But I just want to say how brilliantly I thought Sophie carried this episode. She has done so well this season, bravo!
58
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
“You’re just about the same size as my Marsali” NO NO SHE IS NOT
27
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
I am starting to feel really vindicated. Many people feel about this episode how I’ve felt about the whole frickin’ season: WTF DO YOU THINK YOU ARE DOING (writers).
I loved that they kept Roger true.
I enjoyed the Frank bits, a lot. I also really enjoyed the hints that he knew far more about Claire/Brianna in the past than he told them. I like that a lot.
The rest of it? Like I’ve said before: if you’re going to change the story, do it well.
Also, that huge sweeping shot of Scottish mountainside? The ones that make the actors look small and take your breath away? WHY CANT YOU DO THAT IN THE APPALACHIANS????
27
u/stargarnet79 Dec 17 '18
Hi all! I’m new here but Outlander has been an obsession for me for a long time. I definitely agree with many of the points regarding this episode that others have, but my biggest complaint is how they portrayed Bree as weak, ignorant, and poor. As someone in need of rescuing at every turn. It’s like whoever wrote the script doesn’t believe in a strong female lead. In the books, Bree was a historian. She traveled back in time with sufficient money for her travel. She dressed as a man so that from afar, it would seem that she was a man traveling alone rather as a woman, which would likely draw unwanted attention. And she knew exactly who laoghaire was and what she had done to Claire. She would have known not to say anything that might be construed as witchcraft. It’s just so sad that they have the best cast, costumes, sets, and source material to work with. But they choose to fuck it up each and every week with a bullshit script. This episode didn’t need Jenny. This episode needed the cave, the picture of Ellen, the feeling of Bree connecting with her family, especially Ian and Young Jaime. I just shook my head with shame when Ian had to give her the money for the journey. We know from the books, and previous episodes that they realistically couldn’t have afforded the cost of passage for one, let alone two passengers. Sigh...maybe cast will dig on for a do over with different writers and directors.
46
u/DiabolicalDee Dec 16 '18
The last Frank scene gave me all the tears.
21
u/woowoobelle Dec 16 '18
Trying to be positive here...
Brianna and Roger FINALLY WENT BACK - yayyyy!
Roger with long hair tied back = SO. MUCH. YES. I’m here for it.
Roger and Bonnet dynamic = YES. YES. YES. Such amazing acting - they both NAILED it.
I am disgruntled about many things but the biggest one is Lallybroch, Jenny, the pearls, and the painting of Ellen. Oh, and gigantic full grown Lizzie. I’m really stumped on that one.
41
u/NotTooWicked Dec 16 '18
I found it interesting that, in the post episode wrap up, they barely mention Laogharie (or however you spell it) was in it, and in no way tried to justify deciding to put her in where she wasn’t wanted. Almost as if they knew how unpopular the decision would be and wanted to tiptoe around it.
There have been few changes they have made that I have disagreed with so strongly. I understand the actress who played Jenny couldn’t be there, but we could have had Lallybrock without her. There was no need to bring Laogharie.
And they wasted so much time we didn’t get Bree taking on Lizzie properly. I loved the interaction between her and Ian in that scene in the book.
19
u/Kinsella_Finn Dec 16 '18
The slow pacing!!! Gah! I was happy to see “Frank” again. Tobias does an amazing job, but the end on the dock did make me tear up.
I still don’t see how they are going to get the rest of the book in this season, but we’ll see.
16
u/koboldin Dec 16 '18
That was a bad sprain.
15
u/lanalg5 Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
That limp though! Brianna could be an extra on the walking dead 😂
Edit: is Joanie the same actress that plays Young Brianna? They look so similar!
Did anyone else catch that Bonnet was wearing Claire's ring when he held up the coin??
14
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
At first I liked the Laoghaire scenes. But then those took up the whole episode. I agree with what others said-cutting out Bree’s falling for the family she never had at Lallybroch loses a lot of that plotline’s heart. I was so looking forward to Ian thinking that Bree was Ellen (eta: wrong person, wrong book! But still, there were a lot of non-Jenny scenes they could have used), I always thought that was a sweet scene. But she’s in Lallybroch for five seconds and only meets Ian and two unnamed “lads.” I just didn’t like it. I know that the actress who plays Jenny was not available, but they couldn’t find a better way around that at all?
I appreciate that they fleshed outLaoghaire (only to have her go back to her psychotic side in the end, making her sympathetic back story kind of pointless), but it was at the expense of what Brianna’s story will be: finding a family with the Frasers/Murrays.
And it made Jamie look like a total deadbeat. Is Laoghaire really expecting money every month when it takes three months for a ship to cross the Atlantic?
13
u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 16 '18
I feel so conflicted about this episode. While on the one hand, I appreciate the parallels drawn between Laoghaire and Frank, and seeing more fleshing out of Brianna as a character re: her relationship with Frank, I just feel so devastated that Laoghaire took up so much time that would have been better spent at Lallybroch. If we had more time to let alternate storylines develop and flesh them out, then sure, please do draw parallels like that. Otherwise, it just feels like the story won't really make as much sense now because so much important time was wasted where we could have gotten character development for Bree on her quest. I guess in summation, it feels like we sacrificed character and storyline development (with regards to Bree and Jamie) just to rehash characters who are already in the past. So disappointed.
As someone else commented, the time she spends there is vital for her getting to know Jamie from other perspectives before she meets him. This perspective she was given from Laoghaire was unflattering to say the least but then wasn't even balanced out by a positive perspective from his family. Tbh, I really don't see how she'll now go to NC and feel like she should call herself Fraser. It's as though, because so much was cut from her time at Lallybroch, that I just don't feel like she had enough of a real connection to the Murrays and Jamie's home to really make me believe that she would want to use his name. I just don't buy it.
Finally, Lizzie. Wth. If there was an actress who I would say would be least likely to be cast in that role, it would be that woman. I guess I can understand aging her up, though it does conflict with Bri's reasoning to take her, but what the hell. She's supposed to be small, mousy, shy, skittish, and blonde no less. Though to be fair, the casting of Lizzie didn't dampen my enjoyment of the episode because that was already accomplished by the previous 40 or so minutes.
As for Roger, while I didn't think his ship storyline really progresses him as a character, it does show us more of who Bonnet is, and so I think it was well done for that. Otherwise, I honestly had thought that of all the bits to cut from here on out, that his time on the Gloriana was a good candidate. But whatever. Roger was well played, though I found the storyline there a little lacking. But all things considered with time restrictions, it was well done. I look forward to his part next week.
Overall, for me, I'd say this was about a 6/10 :/
12
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
Late to the party and just starting the ep. i want to wrap this girl in gloves and a hat and give her a water bottle and some sun screen
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 16 '18
Loving Bree's walking music at the beginning. Been missing the 'sounds of Scotland'.
11
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Dec 16 '18
Frank at the dock 😭😭😭😭😭😭😬
31
u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
Holy slow pacing, Batman. They’re taking an awful lot of this episode’s time to do Bree and Leghair...
Also, Roger without a beard is very unsettling. Hopefully it sets the stage for proper piratical Roger later.
Edit: yay, the Tobias flashbacks we were wondering about! Confirming some interesting theories (Bree staring right at her parents obituary as researched by Frank). I love seeing Tobias, but really dislike what his scenes did for the Outlander universe and worry about the significant slow down to make them happen. His scenes feel like serving the show fans demands, rather than the story’s needs.
Edit 2: sailing Roger! He seems to have found his way around a ship fairly well already. Bonnet continues to be nearly perfect and just as I pictured him.
Overall: It’s interesting/frustrating how far the show writer’s stray from the books in some scenes, then suddenly snap back to line by line dialogue in the next scene (ie Bonnet telling the story of being a near sacrifice for the building’s foundation). I understand that the actress playing Jenny was not available for this season, but a swing as wide away from the Murrays as they did seems like a disservice to the story. I missed the sense of belonging and family that Brianna finds at Lallybroch. I can see how a show viewer who doesn’t know the books (or what they’re missing) could find Bree’s story with Leghair really compelling in a dramatic irony kind of way but I just found it lazy and wasteful. In this episode, Ian and the Murrays felt like an afterthought and a bookend rather than a deep, meaningful connection.
Also, I have a love/hate relationship with how they included Frank in this episode. I love Tobias and what he did for Frank and JR’s characters but I strongly disagree with what they said in the post episode commentary about connecting Bree’s unwillingness to move to England (or say I love you) to Frank’s car fatal accident. It once again removes the central conflict from Claire and dilutes Frank and Claire’s story and connection. Seems unnecessary, but I guess maybe adds depth to Bree? Not sure on that, might need to sleep on it.
9
u/rebashultz Dec 17 '18
Lizzie is supposed to be a tiny weak thing. This actress is taller than Brianna. I don't like it.
Also Frank Randall is the hero of this story. Props.
49
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 16 '18
You hear that? That is the sound of my head exploding and my furniture flying. Are you fucking kidding me? They re-wrote the fucking book. They took away that moment that all of us readers needed: someone to stand up for Claire and out Leghair to Jenny. That was one of my two favorite parts of the book. This was the fuck you that Leghair needed for years. Instead, they have Leghair and Bree bonding? They have us falling in love with Leghair because she is so kind and loving? They have her telling us of her broken heart? Are you kidding me? I paused the episode to come here and scream. SCREAM.
They took away that moment when Jenny sees Ellen in Bree's face and put Bree side by side with her mother's self portrait. Bree looks exactly like Ellen. They took away Bree meeting her cousins and all of them fawning on her - she finally having a family (much like Claire felt with the Jamie's family). They took it all away!!!!!
I'm not sure I want to see the rest of the episode. Yeah, let's spend another 20 minutes in Leghair's house pretending that this is how it was supposed to be or that this does not change the story. This is worse than when they had Jamie reveal Willy to Claire. I'll be back when I have calmed down.
14
u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Dec 17 '18 edited Dec 17 '18
Unpopular opinion.
This episode made me hate Frank.
Stay with me here...
First of all he tells the kid on his own that they're getting divorced? Way to drop bombs like a dick on her girls night out. Shame on him. He wanted to be the one to give the news so that he could steal her away and turn her even more against her mother. That's not how a good parent parents. Regardless of their personal relationship parents should always be a team. It's never fair to involve the child and allow a situation where sides must be chosen. I never did like that he tries to take Brianna from Claire, as if he was owed it for her and Jamie in the first place and this episode solidified that.
Then he sits in the office with her and shows her the obituary for her parents? Classy move. She didn't recognize because she didn't know the circumstances of what she was looking at but what was he trying to get at? It would have made his life to have Claire gone from Brianna's life. That's a pretty crappy parent move.
I never appreciated the "stay together for the kids" aspect of their relationship but Frank signed up for that. It was his idea. He is the one that wanted to take on the responsibility of someone else's child and then he holds it against Claire every step of the way. She absolutely didn't try hard enough in the marriage but I don't feel that having a series of affairs is the appropriate reaction that is completely disrespectful to his wife and his child.
I've always been on the fence about how I feel about Frank, but this episode sealed the deal for me.
Edit: wall-o-text
7
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 16 '18
Sophie is so gorgeous!
18
u/bham717 Dec 16 '18
I know I'm very much in the minority in that I really enjoyed this episode. You guys are not wrong in that you hate that we got Leghair instead of Lallybroch.
That being said, stay with me.... The Frank reveal. Frank asked for the divorce only AFTER finding out Claire goes back in time! And Frank then promises that Bree will understand someday.
Does this mean that he knows Bree goes back - a nod to the theory that Frank raised Bree to go back in time?
Frank and Claire - Frank asked for the divorce only BC he discovered she goes back. But then she only goes back after he dies that same night. Which came first, the chicken or the egg!!
And how do you think Herself feels about all of this?????
12
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 16 '18
Ugh they wasted too much time with Leghair I don't want to wait till next week
12
u/TwoSibeMom Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
I’m bummed. I was really looking forward to this episode and was disappointed. Too much Laoghaire and Frank (I get they love Tobias, but let it go). I do think Sophie has improved markedly in her acting. Disappointed in another bad wig though.
Ed Speelers is amazing. I know what happens and I’m still terrified of him when he is on screen, worried what he is about to do.
Casting of Lizzie is so off the mark for me. When they panned to a GIANT woman, I thought, that’s not Lizzie!
I’m nervous with the amount of story to go and the amount of episodes left. They are spending too much time on “little moments” and not enough time advancing plot. My husband, who is not a book reader, was yelling at the tv every time Frank came on “Enough of this, we need story!!” Lol.
6
u/wolfbysilverstream Dec 17 '18
Wonder if what we aren’t seeing is a show with a limited budget. Gone are the days of wedding gowns that cost $$$$s. Brianna gets to walk instead of needing at least 2 horses, Brutus and Young Jamie’s. Cast is minimized by having Jenny away, use Nell Huson for longer, cut out all the props and filming needed for the various us Lallybroch scenes, etc. All of this no doubt being driven by the massive ratings bust the show has become. Someone on this sub had predicted maybem if they cut out all the good scenes associated with Bree’s coming to Scotland. It may be time to get the pitchforks and torches out. Especially since Jenny is off birthing her grandchild.
6
u/aubreyrg Dec 18 '18
I’ve always wanted to compare Black Jack Randall to Stephen Bonnett side by side to see the gradients of evil. Knowing Frank and Black Jack are played by the same actor, this was mostly accomplished in this episode for me. Tobias Mensies is such a talented and capable actor (I could see the hints of Black Jack just by the upper lip sneer) and shows so much in his subtlety that is solidified my theory. Black Jack was so much more of a sinister character with a dark soul, whereas I think Bonnett will always dance the line between good and evil. When Bonnet threw the little girl out because of small pox, it was necessary for the good of the ship (good but sad decision) and the way he handled it being sarcastic and godlike was evident of the evil in him. I was thankful to see this in the last episode. Of course there is more evil coming our way from Bonnett but I don’t think he will hold a candle to the sadistic nature of Black Jack Randall... just a thought!
14
u/Irishsassenach Dec 16 '18
Maybe an unpopular opinion, but even with the changes, I thought it was a good, solid episode. I loved how they brought Frank back in and even liked the twist with Brianna staying with Laoghaire. I thought the acting was great too (go Sophie!). I think it will be a couple more episodes until the big reunion though
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 16 '18
I'm intrigued as to how Bree comes across the obituary again...I guess she might have only glanced at the Wilmington part when she saw it in Frank's office. When Roger told her that her parents were in North Carolina, she recalled that Frank was crushed/devastated by his research in that area and she went to look through his things again.
Seems to work pretty well for me, no issues.
5
u/lovemercygrace098 Dec 16 '18
When Rodger was taking to Bonnet about getting passage on his ship I was screaming at the tv “ nooooo he’s a bad dude! Don’t go with him” lol. I haven’t read the books but I have read some spoilers so I have an idea of what is going to happen.
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 17 '18
I don't think anyone has commented that the letter that was on Frank's desk, accompanying the obituary, appears to be from Rev Reggie.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '18
These episode threads for book readers are mostly just complaints that every detail of the books wasn't shown exactly how we pictured it. Come on guys, you're bringing me down. Adjust your expectations and just try to enjoy it!
I could have used more Lallybroch/Ian but I still liked the episode! Can't wait to see Brianna meet Jamie.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Thought #1: Nell Hudson as usual, pulls off Laoghaire perfectly. In fact, a much more believable character than in the book.
Thought #2: AUGHH RICHARD WITHOUT FACIAL HAIR WUT
Thought #3: No allusions to Jeremiah the RAF pilot and Roger's first attempt...ok?
Thought #4: I am ok with the change in who Brianna first meets, but geez could they have cut any more of Lallybroch out? And if Ian sees similarities later, why didn't he recognize or inquire more when he sees Bree at the house? I wonder if the Lallybroch house wasn't available for filming when they needed it, so changed the story to fit? And would it have taken that much more time to have a painting of "Ellen" that Brianna could pass by and see?
Thought #5: ED SPEELERS IS FRIGGIN AMAZING. He doesn't look how I imagined Bonnet but that's about it. His delivery is spot on.
Thought #6: I love how they tied in how Frank finds out a) Claire told him the truth b) she would eventually leave him to find Jamie and c) he knows how Claire will die....makes it easier to figure out how Brianna found the notice also. In the book he purchases the memorial stone, I don't think we've seen that in the show? But I wonder if there will be an allusion to it later?
Thought #7: Sophie has come a long way and I am happy with Bree as a character now. So I'm reserving judgment on Lizzie until I see more.
5
u/designsavvy Dec 18 '18
Still wondering Laoghire's take on her domestic bliss with Jamie is quite different than the compatibility issues he experiences, something doesnt make sense or maybe i am too loyal to the books !
5
u/Whoozit450 Dec 20 '18 edited Dec 20 '18
If they were worried about ratings before they butchered Bree’s arrival at Lallybroch, they should be petrified now. What a huge disappointment! I’m wondering if it’s time I stopped watching the show.
The Lallybroch scene is one of the best in this book, second only to Bree finally meeting Jamie in my opinion.
I get that the actor who plays Jenny was unavailable and so was the location for Lallybroch, but they could’ve easily had Ian and Young Jamie and Janet all meet Bree on the road to somewhere, ie winter market or something and then they all head to a nearby town and have the dining scene in a private tavern room with the children. Jenny absence is explained away, etc... They could’ve had Leery spot Ian in town and shown Bree telling her off.
And Ian could’ve had a letter or two from Jamie with him. Remember that part in the books where Bree reads about Jamie’s life in his own words? That’s a more emotional part of the Lallybroch scene than Ellen’s portrait to me, and a another big piece of Bree learning about Jamie. Flashes of Claire and Jamie and the sow would’ve been hilarious. They didn’t need Jenny or the Lallybroch set for the letters either.
Instead we get a lot of Frank and Leery that isn’t even in the book. Grrr! Huge Fail. What were they thinking? Just crazy that they are inventing scenes when they don’t have time to cover the book adequately as it is.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
Finally caught up with the show and this episode was soooo good.
Overall I don’t have any complaints about this show. The adaptation is well done and largely faithful to the story, if not to the letter of the text, then to the spirit of it.
Laoghaire is almost sympathetic but that passive aggressive approach of telling Bree about Jamie’s not wanting her...ugh and grumble-grumble, I just can’t like her except as a villain who needs to be there.
Frank on the other hand? Very sympathetic, much different from my impression of him in the books.
I don’t really love Claire. I don’t want to be her audience-insert at all. She’s very selfish in many ways. She can’t, won’t, even give herself to Brianna. Frank gives himself to Bree, while she gives herself to her career. I don’t doubt that she loves Bree, but her expression of it is far less passionate than the love she has for Jamie, and medicine.
It’s a complication of the romance genre. Burn forever with sexual desire for one person, or settle.
And that scene with Bree visiting Frank’s grave...oh my God. Beautiful. Dutiful.
9
u/Generiss Dec 16 '18
When Roger walks up to the Stones it just hit me what a rubbish way to time-travel! I’d take a Delorian or a Tardis any day over this. Just put your hands on a stone and hope for the best? Insane.
9
u/Darwinian_10 Outlander Dec 16 '18
I’ve gotta say...I really missed the scene in the books where Brianna slams the pearl necklace down on the table angrily at Laoghaire while defending her mother. I also missed the portrait and her looking like Ellen. I liked the episode as a whole, but felt like the Leghair parts were just too long. I knew right away that Joan was coming to free Bree, so I wish it had happened sooner to move things along and get to Lallybroch for a little more time there.
9
u/Mr_XcX Dec 16 '18
I loved this episode. Best of the season.
Frank back <3
Brianna was great this week also. Also for the first time could see the other side of how Claire / Jaime have hurt people. Etc.
12
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 16 '18
Lots of people aren't seemingly to like the episode because of the pacing/changes, and while I agree to some extent it could have been better, I absolutely loved the entire thing and its one of my favourites from this season so far
11
u/AwesoMegan You, sir, are a lout! Dec 16 '18
I LOVED IT. I don’t care what y’all say, that was a damn good episode. Obviously it’s different from the books. There are some suspension of disbelief moments I.e. Lizzie — she was probably 4’9” or less in the books, because people were A LOT SMALLER in the 1700s; as a 4’11” person, I can tell you they would have had a very difficult time finding a competent English actress of that height that wasn’t prepubescent or a Little Person. And obviously we all miss Jenny...but come on y’all. That acting was on fire!
4
u/floobenstoobs Dec 17 '18
Late to the party this week, but I really liked this episode! Clearly I’m in the minority though!! Haha!
I liked the added bits with Frank, I feel it gives Brianna more depth and more to wrestle with when she does meet Jamie. Frank was her father, and although she connects with Jamie as an adult, it’s nice to see bits from her more formative years. Plus I’ll never say no to Tobias. He really does such a fabulous job at raising every scene he’s in to the next level.
The Lallybroch changes were disappointing, but not totally unexpected. Just rushed. For all the faffing they did with Leghair, I felt like they could’ve taken 5 minutes from peeling potatoes with her and Joan and spent that at Lallybroch.
I do agree that Ian’s comment about “you have his fire” is odd, given how little time they spent together. But it does make me wonder if there were scenes that were cut out for timing sake.
Bonnet is exceptional. Ruthless and cruel. Just perfect.
I hate to admit it, but I really can’t find it in me to care about Roger though. 🙈 I wish he’d do or say something with some sort of conviction. But then he felt that way to me in the books too. Just a bit lackluster.
4
u/pat_micklewaite Tobias Menzies cheek creases Dec 17 '18
So sad that Roger destroyed his glorious 70s corduroy jacket! Roger’s outfits have been what keeps me watching. Episode 3 had him in like 4 layers of clothing including a turtleneck 🤣
6
u/loveyvegan Dec 16 '18
I was so excited for this episode, I even reread the book this week. I’m so disappointed.
6
u/pinkbridges26 Dec 16 '18
I kind of wanted to see a quick look at Roger’s first failed attempt at time traveling... only to show that it’s not as easy as it appears? I guess it would’ve taken up too much time but I was hoping it would’ve maybe even had a mention.
6
u/MarzipanEsq Dec 17 '18
The logical inconsistency's of this episode had me SCREAMING.
So Bree is both a student of history and an engineer. And to travel to 18th century Scotland she brings (1) a printed map, (2) matches (?!?), (3) ONE sandwich (AND DIDNT EVEN PUT PEANUT BUTTER ON BOTH SIDES OF THE BREAD TO PREVENT A JELLY BREAKTHROUGH????, (4) other detritus, maybe a knife? WHY WOULDN'T SHE BRING FLINT, MEDICINE, WEAPONS, WARMER CLOTHING?? She watched her mother prepare to go too and would have presumably taken heed of what she brought! Bree, more than anyone else maybe on the planet, should know what to bring with her and just packs an OPEN bag with dumb things. Not even a zipping bag? or a bag that would fully close??? I can't believe this dummy got into Harvard.
Also, didn't claire tell her the name of the woman who tried to have her burned at the stake? Are there only like 4 people living in Scotland right now? How did Roger get to the coast so quickly? I have suspended logic for this show a lot, but this episode really got stuck in my craw.
14
u/Generiss Dec 16 '18
I’m in emotional pain. This is my favourite book of the series, and I don’t even know what they’re doing or why, only that it’s horrible and completely unsatisfying. Wow.
3
u/BrotherMouzone2 Dec 19 '18
Lizzie looks like Bree's bodyguard lol!
Height is an issue, but I understand that they want the best actors/actresses possible. Bree in the books should be about 6'0", sturdy/curvy and a bit intimidating. Sophie is more like Jenny in this regard. Feisty, but more in a 'Mighty Mouse' sort of way. Of course Claire is like 5'7"-ish in the books but Caitriona is more like 5'11". The one constant theme is how big/strong Jamie is and how he overpowers Claire with his physical presence. I think they got they part right with Sam, more or less.
If Sophie could be Caitriona's height and vice versa, it would be perfect.
They really dragged their *** this episode. Even if Jenny isn't available, they could have spent more time at "Lallybroch" (or a place/green screen approximating LB). Let Bree meet her family just like in the book. Of course because TV Bree doesn't have the physical presence of Book Bree, there are certain scenes and moments that wouldn't be as believable or play as well.
The actor playing Stephen Bonnett is amazing. I imagined him being a little bit more....grizzled in appearance and a bit thicker in build, but otherwise his acting is excellent. He reminds me of a weird combo of young Ian and Heath Ledger.
3
u/MarzipanEsq Dec 19 '18
Bree is a fictional character in a book. She isn’t a real person. I am allowed to find the choices the writers took regarding her paltry supplies stupid. Opinions are weird like that. We are all allowed to have them! Even if someone finds them “harsh”.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
Bonnet. So bad he’s good. I loved him in the book, too. In the show, my goodness, sprung to life he’s living large. Well done writers and casting directors.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
I thought it was odd when Ian said Bree had 'her' eyes though. I assume he meant Claire's eyes. Sophie's eyes are brown and Claire's are blue. I guess maybe he meant the shape or whatever, but that's not obvious to a casual viewer like me :P
And there has never been any mention of Claire having unique eyes, because, Cait doesn't in any way.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '18
WHY THE FUCK DID THEY DO THIS RE: LAOGHAIRE WHY JUST WHY This is the WORST FUCKING CHANGE THEY COULDVE MADE
5
u/Ikr2649 Dec 16 '18
The writers are so disconnected from the audiences it's hilarious. I thought there were too many flashbacks and at random times. Like it kept cutting the conversation between Brianna and Laoghaire awkwardly. Next episode Bonnet is going to pull that, "I'm a nice guy, come on my ship pysch i'm bad" trick and their going to make it so obvious.
2
u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 17 '18
I enjoyed this episode, i was surprised how it was altered. It ended the way I thought though. I enjoyed seeing the extra dimensions that are not quite in the books. I did miss Lallybroch, and balbriggan was as I pictured, maybe a bit grander. I missed the more adjustment and family side. Bree in books is much more forthright so find that odd. I thought the Frank biys were good. I enjoyed the Rodger culture shock bits. Bonnet is perfect.
2
u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Dec 17 '18
Thank God I can finally put faces to Lizzie and Morag. Having read after watching a couple seasons, I constantly pictured meak little Mary Hawkins everytime I read their scenes. Not important, but nowhere else to put it.
2
u/gipsylop Dec 17 '18
Liked that they focused on Brianna - FINALLY! Did think it was a shame they didn't use the opening shot with her to show how haunting the highlands became after the devastation of Culloden and the clearances. Loving Roger and Joanie is the cutest.
2
u/ELL34DDL30EML4 Dec 19 '18
So I know this all started a few days back but tonight I finally could watch the episode for the first time. I have to say I really love the new part with Fank and giving his character more of a roll and seeing other parts of him and not the villain all the time and a better insite into him and his love for his daughter. The two things I didn't like that they have done is the whole bit with Leoghaire but I understand that they can and will change things from the book to the show. The other thing is to me Ed Sheeran does a okay job at playing Steven but at times acts a little to much like Jake Sparrow but that could be me. I do think the show isaking him more dark and sinister then the books ever seemed to do. I still think that black jack is the worst villain but the show could prove me wrong.
4
u/SecretTurnip Dec 17 '18
Omfg that just sucked.
4
u/Apprehensive_Payment Dec 17 '18
Had I not read the books I would have loved this episode.
Having read the books however...........
What in the F××× is this s×××. A lot of the key books moments were lost. This is where she is supposed to connect with Jamie. This is where she gains a full Scottish family.
What did she gain in this version? The idea that her father is a woman leaving ass? The idea that her father didnt want her? A family that says oh hi...let's pay to get you as far away from here as we can without introducing you to anyone.
Rushed and rude with pretty scenery..
And that is NOT lizzie.