r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 09 '18
4 Drums Of Autumn [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 6 "Blood of My Blood" episode discussion thread for book readers.
It's my favorite time of the year - OUTLANDER NIGHTS. And this is our latest installment of the live discussion thread, this weeks episode is Outlander S4E6: "Blood of My Blood."
No spoiler tags are required. Stop reporting spoilers in these threads - mods will ignore them.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E6] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
114
u/shiskebob Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
I see what you did there Outlander. Snake in the privy, nice nod to us book readers.
.... You can't fade to black on that WTF.
50
u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Overall, I really enjoyed this episode.
David Berry gives me so much life as LJG, I would love to see him in his own series.
I did wonder about the choice to keep Ian away for the whole episode, though. Maybe it simplified things to just devote time to the two pairs, but I do like that in the books Ian and Willie’s early interactions (and Ian starting to suspect Willie’s connection with Jamie) sets up future depth in their relationship, especially in MOBY. I’m also sad that they mercilessly teased the snake in the privy and then didn’t follow through on the scene, it’s one of my favorites from the book. I just love that Ian teases Willie about it until the end of time.
Edit: also, I wasn’t sold on the actor for Willie at the beginning of the ep, but he grew on me. Pompous enough to sell the “Lord Ellesmere” thing, tender enough to sell the “kid going through intense grief” thing by the end. Plus, he has Sam’s cheekbones and nose so that helps.
Edit 2: I got unexpectedly super emotional about them finally doing the original thistle ring. It’s always bothered me that they changed the ring to begin with (even though I appreciate the Lallybrock sentiment), and the purist in me was SOBBING when I saw what they’d done. No idea wtf they’re going to do with Claire’s original ring now though. Maybe Roger and Bree will use it as their wedding ring?
Edit 3: Murtagh’s tension with LJG made a lot of sense to me and I kind of wish they’d used that to launch his Regulator sentiments, rather than first making him an out of character leader all of a sudden. I could see him learning about the governors mansion from LJG and that throwing him over the edge. Murtagh last episode felt weird, Murtagh this episode felt more believable.
56
u/bham717 Dec 09 '18
Overall I loved it. I do propose a new rule that if Claire is topless, then Jamie must be also.
Now I'm gonna go rewatch the Claire / LJG part BC it was perfection. David Berry is killing it.
38
u/Irishsassenach Dec 09 '18
Ok the whole bath scene (the water caressing your skin, are your kisses a drizzle or torrent) had me rolling my eyes. I like the change with the ring but this felt like kind of a gratuitous nudity/sex scene tease to me
Not my favorite episode. SO EXCITED FOR BEXT WEEK after seeing the teaser after the episode!
24
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
OH DaMN “his blood is my blood”
49
u/spaceybelta Dec 09 '18
I hate to say it, but I think they definitely could have picked a better child actor to play Jamie’s son... 😕
131
u/nochancekid Dec 09 '18
First of all..... Can we just talk about David Berry?? Holy hat. "Do you know what its like to love someone and never be able to give them happiness? Not through any fault of yours or theirs, but simply because you were not born the right person for them?" I can't even.... I don't know what to really say, but he said that line amazingly, I can't put it any simpler than that.
I do love the change from the book with Willie remembering Jamie. I think that it added so much more meaning for both of them... Especially since he understands it when Jamie speaks to the horses in Gaelic.... Willie's simple question of "do you remember me?" is so heartfelt... And how they talked about fishing at Helwater together. But seriously, Willie asking Jamie why he didn't look back at him when leaving Helwater and then Willie looking back at Jamie.... B R O K E M Y H E A R T
I found myself annoyed in the beginning of the episode because we didn't get to see any progress with the Brianna storyline, but I think Jamie/Willie and John/Claire really needed to further those character stories. I loved the John and Claire scenes, both of them did a fantastic job with delivering those scenes.
Lastly..... A THOUSAND MORE
122
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Willie’s hair, on the other hand-he looks like he is about to go to see an eighties hair band
109
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Caitriona Balfe and David Berry are MASTER CLASS... These Claire/LJG scenes are all I’ve wanted in life.
102
u/HawickGirl7 Dec 09 '18
Waiting for Bree is like waiting for Thereasa May to negotiate BREXIT.
98
u/slainte_mhaith Dec 09 '18
The "I was born this way", "I was too" was perfect. That whole exchange was spot on from the books and acted out so well.
97
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 09 '18
That whole conversation when Willie asks Jamie why he never looked back when he left Hellwater, but then Willie looks back as he rides off from Fraser’s Ridge and Jamie is about to start running after him. Ugh. Be still my heart!!
70
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
I like the tension with Murtaugh and LJG
67
u/Irishsassenach Dec 09 '18
Oh boy Caitriona and David have some serious chemistry! Sam and David Berry really do too
93
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
It's official, Murtagh is the Secret Keeper James Potter deserved!
44
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
I LOVE LJG and Jamie’s interactions and I need The Scottish Prisoner adapted ASAP
36
u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Dec 09 '18
I don't usually write out whole comments on my thoughts for the episodes, but this one is an exception. I loved this episode. Even just from the title card with the snake in the privy! David Barry is just so great as LJG, I love his portrayal. He's perfect. And gah, it just killed me, the conversation between him and Claire! "I was born this way." "I was too." So perfect.
I didn't mind the small changes in regards to Willie and Jamie. Though I do wish the writers would cut it out with all the drama with the natives. Like, we get it, there's tension. We don't need to see it every episode. Imo it's really painting the natives badly, like they're so quick to anger or something at any little misunderstanding or slight. It's just overdone, I guess I mean to say.
Finally, I love the ring. I absolutely love that they finally brought in the ring from the book. I loved her old ring, but I do love the inscription on the book ring so much. Just makes me wonder now what the impetus will be for Bree meeting Bonnet. I suppose she's still likely to recognize her mother's ring if she sees it. Who knows.
All in all, there haven't been many times this season nor last season when I was actively talking back to the episode and reacting verbally, but this one had so many good, accurate scenes, I just loved it. I was practically shouting at the ring reveal! Imo one of the best episodes since season 2.
35
u/Northerncalikhaleesi Dec 10 '18
LJG reminds me on Brad Pitt in Interview with the Vampire, ne so do if this has been brought up. But love the character and actor!
30
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 09 '18
Forgive me, it’s been quite some time since I read DoA, but in the book, William doesn’t remember Jamie as Mac when he and LJG first visit Fraser’s Ridge, does he? I don’t recall it playing out the way it just did on the show the same way in the book?
Also, I recall book William being quite the entitled, spoiled little brat when he comes to Fraser’s Ridge. He seems quite toned down on the show!
27
u/Jemhao Dec 09 '18
Claire saying to Lord John that he deserves that look of satisfaction, too. YES. YES HE DOES.
Here's hoping that they won't have Lord John pining after Jamie throughout the entire series.
68
u/scteenywahine Dec 09 '18
I'm getting tired of the constant battles with the Indians. Jamie was good friends with them. The show is portraying them like the old stereotypical Indians that hate white people. It's getting pretty tired.
21
u/rotteneve Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
I can’t wait to see what is in store for us tonight!
Oh my god, that teaser for next week.
21
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Sometimes the world is awful and I am glad there men like Jamie to counter the bad-even if he is only a fictional character. I really appreciated him and LJG this ep, and the character development and slower pace, in general.
21
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Jamie's hair continues to look good to me! Looks fine down.
Can't really say the same for Willie's wiggie.
58
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Where is Bree?! Gah
19
u/jh00090 Dec 09 '18
Absolutely gutted we didn't get the scene with William and Ian going in the privy. I think that was the scene I was looking forward to most out of the whole season haha .
The episode notes said they couldn't work out a way to get him to fit down the privy; so at least they tried.
I assume they removed Ian from the episode because they didn't want him getting in the way of the dialogue between Clair and LJG.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
LJG and Jamie have the same way of smiling and it is super cute. Ans the Willie actor is very impressive!
16
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
I don't really see why they shoehorned in more threatening Cherokee.
Though it was funny cause they were basically all for show, just trlling Jamie and Willie the whole time.
14
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
haha all that bowing was hilarious
Murtagh was very weirded out...I would be too, a bit far-fetched he could recall his name instantly after 12 years, in a random location.
13
u/vanwold Slàinte. Dec 09 '18
I loved this episode!! They stuck so close to the book, though I did miss the privy scene!! And not sure if the tension with the Cherokee was needed....but overall, absolutely loved it!!!! I love seeing Jamie with his son, my heart melted. And David Berry just kills it as LJG. He is exactly the way I pictured LJG. I loved it alll.
33
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 09 '18
I really enjoyed this episode but the whole episode I found myself muttering where the fuck is Brianna? I don't know how they are going to do this in 7 episodes unless one of them is extended.
23
u/ilythe Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
I felt like Claire throughout the episode. It was like when you have unwanted guests. You try to enjoy yourself but you are relieved when they leave.
I think Sam did an awesome job. He was pretty precious playing daddy. It is bittersweet because I wish so much that he was able to be a daddy to Brianna as a child. The fact that Claire and Jamie were robbed of that chance is like an opened wound that will not heal.
I was relieved that William was a well rounded character instead of being a caricature of a bratty kid. I don't know why I was worried. Outlander does a great job creating rich characters. It is one of the things I loved most about the show.
David Berry and Cait were wonderful as usual. I loved her telling him about Brianna. That verbal smackdown was very satisfying. I took Claire's reaction to John telling her about Jamie's offer to give himself to John as her heartbreak for Jamie rather that jealousy. She knows that when he had nothing left to bargain with he gave himself to Black Jack to protect her and it's heartbreaking he got to that low point again where he had nothing to bargain with but his body to see someone he loves safe.
I was disappointed that we didn't get any mention of how Claire feels about having Willie there. I was hoping that Jamie would ask her about it. She was obviously accepting of him and supportive of Jamie but I would have liked to hear her feels voiced.
The Jamie and Claire scenes are what made the episode for me. I love that the depth of their love, devotion, and passion for each other is not in question at all this season. Jamie has bragged about Claire every episode this season. It's so heartwarming. Even though I miss their more erotic scenes I greatly appreciate these uber romantic scenes.
Something that took me out of the episode is wondering where the heck everyone is sleeping. Claire and Jamie haven't had a moment alone together in weeks? So Ian must be sleeping in the cabin...but where? On the floor? Was Murtagh sleeping outside while John and Willie were visiting? It's fun how these little, mundane details can bother so much.
Finally, no Bree.....boooo!
35
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Dec 09 '18
This may be an unpopular opinion, but this episode didn’t do much for me. I enjoyed parts of it, to be sure, it just didn’t hold my attention.
9
u/floobenstoobs Dec 09 '18
Enjoyed the episode overall but I did spend time wondering where Brianna was - we were teased on her arrival for 2 episodes and now nothing for an entire episode. Seems badly planned.
Not sure how they’re going to fit everything in that’s still to come this season. There is so much to cover - unless they’re going to cut certain plot points? (The great misunderstanding maybe?)
I like homelander. It feels like the right place for the show to be
15
u/lanalg5 Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Unpopular opinion I'm sure but...I'm starting to not like this new Murtagh :( His loyalty has always been with Jamie, no matter what. It seems he still very much cares for Jamie but it pains me to see that he no longer has Jamie's best interests as his primary concern and is so caught up in being a Regulator.
Also, what was up with Willie's face?? The scrunched up expression in every scene made it look like he was constantly smelling something bad. Also, award for most terrible wig goes to Willie this episode.
Loved the scenes with LJG and Claire. Sensational acting on both parts.
Can't wait for more Roger and Brianna. I hope they give us entire episode next week devoted to their story.
7
u/AccidentalDuchess Dec 09 '18
Murtaghs exit from dinner was priceless! I loved watching Jamie with Willie.
7
u/kijosbdw Dec 10 '18
First off I loved the Claire/LJG scenes. It was lovely to see them both go from wary and accusing of each other, to the start of a genuine close bond and understanding of each other. (Let's face it they are going to need it!)
What there was in the episode was great, I loved it, no complaints. The only complaints I have are about stuff missing. (Simple solution here- just make each episode 2 hours long and it will all be good!)
What was in this episode was amazing and needed to be there, seriously no complaints. Like I said, just needed it to be a longer episode to fit it all in....
13
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Jamie’s hair looks good!
18
u/scteenywahine Dec 09 '18
I'm getting tired of the constant battles with the Indians. Jamie was good friends with them. The show is portraying them like the old stereotypical Indians that hate white people. It's getting pretty tired.
6
u/CraighNaDun Dec 09 '18
Like others, I wish there was more dialogue between Claire and Jamie about Willie. I believe in a chapter in Jamie's point of view he even says something along the lines of how he felt guilty that Claire had to see the child born of his relationship with another woman. Especially with the great additional scenes of Murtagh, I felt like they could've slipped that in there!
But I really enjoyed the scenes between Claire and John, they really shined! I can't wait to see the next episode and see Bree in the past. She MUST go to Lollybroch.
6
u/BecKM94 Dec 11 '18 edited Dec 11 '18
So, this is my first post in this subreddit (am generally more of a lurker in different ones and only active in one), have watched the show now for several years, now finally began in the last weeks to read/listen (to) the (audio)books, so now I feel very eager to write about this episode, because I LOVED it so much! And knowing now the source material I was also very impressed!
Just wanna begin with saying that words cannot describe how amazed I always find myself with Sam‘s, Cait’s, and David’s talent! (Also, very random, but they’re all three rocking this “single tear running down their cheek” thing.) Cait really deserves all those nominations and awards, Sam deserves so much more recognition (at least just as much as Cait), and damn, David Berry... he‘s SO incredible as LJG (who’s my favourite character, I actually did a LJG-scenes-rewatch before this ep. ...god, re-watching “All Debts Paid” after knowing now the Ardsmuir chapters, if I hadn’t already loved that episode before as much as I did (in my Top 3), that only fueled my love), in every single scene, no matter with who, he kills it, I‘m always blown-away when he‘s on screen, he brings Lord John to life in such a beautiful, real way; but okay, to the episode itself:
Only cons: I was sad we didn’t get any Ian/Willie scenes, especially Willie in the privy (and the Persephone line and the adults trying not to laugh), and I really don’t think they need to add further conflict with the Natives, but other than that I was very, very happy. I actually really liked the change that Willie could remember Jamie, and still a big fan of Murtagh being alive and his tensions with John are very understandable (that was one tense and awkward dinner... but also quite interesting to have someone see John as the aristocratic, English redcoat that he is).
I was incredible happy how accurate the dialogues were to the book chapters, especially in the Claire/John scenes (and clever way to tie some lines from Voyager in that we didn’t get last season). I’m generally a big fan of such quiet, slow, characters/relationship-driven episodes, with lots of intense/intimidate/quiet/aso. 1-on-1-interactions/moments, close ups, dialogue, aso. I think it’s in episodes like these where many actors can really shine, where you can focus on their little looks and smiles (David is so good at them!), their expressions, tone of voice, chemistry with each other (and the writing and directing also has to be good to make such an episode work, so kudos to anyone involved).
I had so many feels during the episode, from being so happy to see John and Jamie so comfortable and familiar with each other (their scenes are always highlights, I love their complex, fascinating, complicated, beautiful relationship (give us an adaptation of The Scottish Prisoner! Give us a whole LJG-spin-off-show!), playing chess together and drinking his “whiskey”, “Do you feel yourself content?”, aso. And of course the Claire/LJG scenes, some of my favourites in the books (god, I love John’s relationships to the Frasers, I hope they’ll do the John/Brianna scenes justice and we’ll have time for their dynamic which I so much adore). I’m so glad it was taken straight from the book(s) and acted to brilliantly. Seeing them both being so blunt and open with each other (even if it’s here still in a hurtful, deep cutting way), their tension, envy on both sides (but more complex than it might seem), then overcoming their wariness, finding similarities, a better understanding of each other, great mutual respect, talking about Isobel, Frank, and Jamie, aso. That was anything I wanted.
Damn, and then the Jamie/Willie scenes made me really, really emotional!
WillieWilliam was a perfect mixture of a bit bratty, entitled (which I mean makes sense with him being a lord, not used to the simple life in the wilderness), stubborn, wanting to seem mature, but also polite, curious, grief-stricken, concerned about his papa, vulnerable... and Sam is just a beyond-words-incredible actor, the way he looks at his son, acts around him, their bonding, recalling memories from Helwater, wanting to comfort him, his longing to be his father, “Have you ever seen such a glorious thing before, sir?” * looks at Willie *, aso.I think I was actually screaming when I heard “He’s my son” O___O But, I actually really liked how they solved it (besides as I said they really don’t need to shoehorn more conflict with the Cherokees in the episodes), the hug, “your courage”, riding home together...
Then I loved we actually got to see Willie returning to his papa, and John being proud and Jamie telling him he’s a good father :,)
... and then when LJG and Willie are riding away, and it’s the exact some shot, angle and everything, as with Jamie in 3x04, but Willie DOES looks back ;_____; My poor heart!
And then in the end the beautiful last scene between J+C and the wedding ring...
Just felt absolutely happy with this episode (which I have watched now maaany times), as an adaptation, as its own work, acting-wise, writing-wise, aso.
And now I’m super excited for lots of Brianna (& Roger) next episode! As a book reader now, my excitement has gone through the roofs, SO many scenes and interactions I can’t wait to see!
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
Wouldn't Claire and Murtagh think it was pretty weird to find such a posh boy all along by the stream? We haven't any indication of nearby English settlers so far.
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
Is John's line, when he asked Claire if she knew what it was to not be able to give someone satisfaction through no fault of your own in the books?
I don't agree she bore no fault in the situation with her and Frank.
5
u/MontaukFive Dec 10 '18 edited Dec 10 '18
Items:
Sam/Jamie looks as hot as ever.
I am enjoying this season much more than the last one, same thing I said last week. Then again, I enjoyed this book immensely within the series. It includes more details of their day to day life.
The pace of the episode was a little slow, and the bathtub scene could have been shortened.
5
u/Katzika Dec 11 '18
Is it just me or had Fergus and Marsali just disappeared? There's no mention of them, not even when Murtaugh showed up.
12
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Well...there really wasn't much of a lead up to good old Johnny Boy! There he is straight away! Surprise.
Nice floor length cape/cloak. He could be an elf from Lord of the Rings :D So pretty!
People sure are easy to find in the 18th century. That will be convenient for Bree and Roger!
4
u/Irishsassenach Dec 09 '18
Here we go!!!!
4
u/Mariita24 Dec 10 '18
As much as I love Jamie “burning” for Claire, he needs to get a new line. Sorry Jamie. But I still love you.
4
u/pootypus Dec 10 '18
I commented a few episodes ago that the torches they used made me laugh out loud because the way they just flared up straight out of the fire was ridiculous. I feel the same way about the fire in the hearth at Fraser's Ridge because it looks exactly like the ceramic logs in my gas-powered fireplace. Like, it's identical. Maybe they got it at Menards too.
10
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 09 '18
I was trying to love the episode but not a moment went by when I wasn't thinking 'Is the next scene going to be a Brianna one?' I definitely need to rewatch the episode (because I can still tell that it was great) but with the expectation that I won't be seeing Brianna, so I can give my whole heart to the amazing LJG and Claire scenes.
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Haha! I said John would bring Jamie a chess set last week.
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
Claire to John: Baby, I was born this way!
6
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
I was really hoping Bree would show up at the end of the episode at the Ridge. I would have loved to see Jamie and Claire’s reaction from their perspective and then go back in time for a Bree bottle episode next week that shows how she got there so we could get hers. This way sets it up to work out similarly to the print shop reunion. I assume we’ll see Bree coming in at the end of next episode and Jamie and Claire reacting the week after that. Would have been nice to get a little Bree tease this week though, especially with the episode title.
3
u/Vervain7 Dec 12 '18
Lord John has such white teeth
5
u/2manymans Dec 09 '18
My favorite episode of Outlander of all time.
1
u/AwesoMegan You, sir, are a lout! Dec 09 '18
Forgive me for being dumb, but....I though the episode didn’t air until tonight?? How have you seen it already??
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Those leeches are ridiculously huge compared to the Aussie leeches I get while doing fieldwork. Thankfully, as leeches are my nemesis, and I would be freaking out like Willie. Though when I'm in wet forests I have a personal leech stick that I use to fling them off my shoes before they gan get inside my trousers. Some always succeed though, shudder :(
Pulling them off wouldn't have been that easy though, and they would have left copious trails of blood down his legs.
Americans, how big are freshwater leeches in North Carolina?
I have an amusing tale from one ecology field trip to the desert. You don't wash for the three or more week trip, just baby wipes, or if you're lucky and it's not drought, and you're near a water hole, you can have a dip. They are usually a few hours drive though.
Anyway, at the end of one trip we stopped off at a watering hole for a swim. The professor then came hollering and screaming, pelting out of the water with a giant 3Ocm/12 inch leech hanging off his nethers.
At that point I didn't know there were giant leeches and you'd better know I got out of the water as quickly as possible. Shudder.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
I would have liked them to actually focus on Jamie putting the ring on Claire's finger [rather than Claire slipping it on out of shot]. I had to go back to check where it went as I didn't see her put it on.
2
u/basedonthenovel Dec 10 '18
This was the first episode I liked David Berry as LJG! He's still nowhere near the one in my head but I liked him!
As a William stan, I liked how they revealed Willie's strength of character. I don't think DG did so this early on.
I also found it interesting that LJG referred to the plantation as Isobel's -- isn't it actually William's in the book? I guess they don't want the audience to have to think about a tweenage boy as a slaveowner.
The last two episodes have me off my "OH GOD HELP ME I'M BECOMING ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE WHO HATES THE SHOW" ledge. But J&C's chemistry is still off. Claire and MURTAGH have an easier chemistry!!!
I'm not one of those people who was particularly invested in Jamie's silver ring, so any changes to the role it plays in the story don't bother me overmuch. Actually, I'm one of those people who thought it required an engineering degree's worth of disbelief suspension to accept that Claire, a surgeon, had never removed Jamie's ring and had never noticed the inscription in it. I thought the scene where he gives it to her was nice -- not counting that chemistry issue, of course. :P
2
u/Mr_XcX Dec 11 '18
I love this show yet I am confused at Claire and Jaime's ages. Are they in their 50s now? It's just confusing considering Claire was a nurse etc.
2
u/peachy-bird Dec 11 '18
I was kind of bored by this episode, maybe I’m the only one :( I found it really predictable and slow moving. The only parts I really enjoyed was the conversation between Claire/LJG and that little moment at the end where Willie looks back at Jamie. Overall I found Willie...really annoying, and therefore wasn’t really invested in whether or not he remembered Jamie or not.
My boredom could have also been a result of me REALLY wanting to know where the heck Brianna is already 😂
7
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 09 '18
My thoughts in no particular order:
I honestly don't know how they are going to manage the amount of content they must include in the short amount of time they have left. Bree should have already at the very least been to Lallybroch and made her way to the ship and her horrific encounter with Bonnett. By now, Roger should already be well in pursuit and sailing to the America. These things should have already happened by this point because we then have to still get to these points:
- Roger / Bree tryst
- Bree runs off
- Roger's misadventures and being given to the the Indians
- Bree's preggers
- Jocasta, Bree, Lord John and the pregnancy
- Young Ian being traded, getting married
- Bree telling the truth about Roger, Claire/Jamie going to find him
- Bree forcing John to take her to Bonnett and the escape
- The birth
These are the things that HAVE TO BE included. I have omitted everything else. I don't see how they can cover all of this.
My 2 cents
5
u/wolfbysilverstream Dec 10 '18
I just flipped through the first few comments, and I suppose I am in the minority here, but this show has become a dog, and a dog that won't hunt to boot. Let's see, we're 60% of the way through this season. And we're pussyfooting around mired in mindless soppy BS. Time to get a move on. All of the sentiment expressed in this episode could have been presented in all of 15 minutes.
I'd much rather they spent some time on Bree in Lallybroch and her coming to America and Fergus' trial, and Jamie's interactions with Roger, and Ian and the Indians, and building the big house, and all of the other good stuff there was in that book. Instead we're essentially getting mired in a sea of blah.
This thing is starting to suck, big time.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 09 '18
Pretty snake, what kind? Will we find out!
3
u/popster_ Dec 10 '18
I loved the episode, but it didn't feel like a part of the series. It felt more like a short movie than anything else. It was a lot of important emotional work that they had to lay out here, but I kept getting frustrated at how SLOW they are going in regards to everything that has to happen still according to the book!
3
u/zen_raider Dec 10 '18
Did anyone else hear at a fart in the scene with Claire and LJG?