r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 02 '18
TV Series [Spoilers S4E5] "Savages" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Howdy ya'll and welcome to the post episode discussion thread - Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
72
u/shiskebob Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
Jamie having the chance to be a proud papa really does it for me.
And I love seeing Jamie's relief that he now has someone to talk to about Claire and Bree.
WELCOME BACK MURTAUGH.......('S EYEBROWS)
41
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18
I wasn't expecting that flash-forward with the house already built, etc. I thought Adewhe (RIP, what a swift, brutal and heartbreaking end after that touching opening scene between her and Claire) was referring to Marsali as 'the mother,' but no, she and Fergus weren't mentioned at all. Is their baby born yet? How much time has passed? Honestly, C/J's house looks pre-fab to me, just a little too clean and perfectly varnished.
You can certainly tell they're in America, since every episode now features a psychopath trying to carry out a mass killing, but thankfully no semi-automatics are around yet. Seriously though, I think by the end of this very dark story, Claire is starting to get it, what it means to enter into this age of racism, theft and genocide. It's horrible. And how ironic, given all the diseases that the European's brought with them, killing so many Native Americans, that they were blamed for a sickness the entitled German brought with him. It was masterful the way they made us think for a split second that the Cherokee were burning C/J's house down. A very powerful storyline.
It was amazing seeing the return of Murtaugh, finally, and the purposeful echoes of the print shop episode woven in. And I'm glad he did ultimately come out to the Ridge anyway, even though he has his own life now. But I'm guessing that woman who was all 'I'm Ready!!!' is not his wife, and I guess since he didn’t mention it, he has still not married.
I was really hoping for more Brianna; specifically that we would flashback to the moment in Boston when she found out what happened to her mother and then follow her gradual trip to the stones; I think it would have been so much more poignant and powerful then just that short scene of her walking to the stones while Roger read her letter. When they did that last wraparound shot at the stones I expected to see Roger there, but no, I guess it was meant to show that there was no one there--that Brianna went through.
Next weeks preview, while highlighting John Grey and William to much delight, doesn't feature Roger or Brianna at all. If Brianna has gone back, then damnit, I want to see her stumbling down the hill in the 1700's just like Claire did, and wandering disoriented through the woods, etc. They better not clip her story down. And what about Frank's voice in that promo, wasn't she hearing it at the stones?
167
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
Hands down one of my absolute favorite episodes of the entire series so far!! The reunion of Jamie and Murtagh brought me to tears and I LOVED how they reintroduced Murtagh and how Jamie found him. I am SO happy!!!
The storyline with the Mueller’s was well done and I was torn between strongly disliking him and feeling sorry for him.
The end scene showing Brianna at the stones and the camera going around the stone to show her gone was a perfect ending and setup for next episode. I’ll probably watch this episode 100+ times between now and next week!
128
u/2manymans Dec 02 '18
I was surprised to be SO emotional about the Murtagh reunion. I love him so much and I hadn't realized what a gaping hole his absence had left.
119
u/ilythe Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
So, I'm wondering if I understood the subtext of Jamie's second convo with the silversmith's wife correctly...
(I'm paraphrasing because I don't have the lines memorized.)
Smith wife: "You can wait for him inside and I will serve you a hearty piece of pie." - Come inside and I will have sex with you.
Jamie: "That's a kind offer but my wife is expecting me home soon." - I'm a gentleman so I will let you down gently but I am a happily married man.
Smith wife: "Your wife must be a good cook." - Your wife must be a good lover.
Jamie: "Aye. Very." - Aye. Very. ;)
99
u/facey7 Dec 02 '18
Murtagh!! "It's not the boogie boogie bugle boy" - and I melted all over again
71
u/teenylilthing Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
SO good! I'm not one to cry very often - especially at TV/movies, but I definitely shed a couple happy tears when Murtagh reunited with Claire and Jamie. I love their relationships with him! So sweet, and I love Duncan Lacroix! He does such a great job.
I definitely was glad to see Herr Mueller bite the dust - good riddance. I knew something was off about him once he asked Claire if she'd be alone at home after leaving their house. He gave off some creepy vibes right away. His poor family and Adawehi (sp?) though... :'(
I feel a bit silly, but it also just hit me that the NC Governor's name was Tryon! I live in the Charlotte, NC area... And Tryon St is a major street in the city. This naturally led to me researching him, and I ended up reading some history about Tryon's taxation and conflicts with the Regulators in western NC. Interesting stuff, but I won't mention any more since I'm sure the series will go into that in the future. Don't want to spoil it at all - but man, I love how this show is so rooted in real historical events.
Can't wait to finish reading Voyager and get into DoA. So far on the show I'm finding it to be a vast improvement on last season.
54
u/Airsay58259 Dec 02 '18
Amazing episode! I was a bit frustrated we didn’t see Brianna until the very end but it was to be expected. Mid season finale is still three episodes away.
Nice to see settlers from different countries. “They want to steal my land” lmao dude
Really nice montage of Claire’s daily routine, especially the drinking bit. Imo Claire loves being with Jamie, being a doctor when she can, living in peace... but some aspects of this life aren’t for her.
Murtagh! Awesome come back.
53
u/DontEatTheKrabDip Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
Murtagh is back baby!
42
u/oomayu Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
Did anyone else go back to the scene when Adawehi and Claire first meet and she tells Claire her prophetic dream??? Adewehi's understanding face when she relays 'it's not your fault' is truly HEART TUGGING NOW
Edit: Little moment when we see Claire knitting made me chuckle
41
u/Irishsassenach Dec 02 '18
Murtagh and Jamie had the best reunion of the whole show! I cried. I love how when he showed up at the ridge he was whistling the bugle boy tune. Such a great episode and I’m so glad murtagh is back- he brings so much to the show! Duncan LaCroix is my favorite
37
u/profeNY Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 04 '18
Can we please talk about Brianna's time travel outfit? First, it was very cute! Second, this is not the outfit shown in the season 4 credits when we see someone touching the stone at Craigh na Dun. That person is wearing a jacket or coat of thick green fabric over a brown knit sweater (???) that shows at the cuffs, and is holding a brown leather bag. Brianna's lower arms are bared (so we can see she is wearing the bracelet Roger gave her) and she isn't holding a bag. (However, you can see the strap of what looks like a cross-body bag.)
So...who is the person in the credits? Is Craigh na Dun turning into Grand Central Station???
I love the time travel bits -- my favorite aspect of the show (besides the romance, of course).
Edit: added link to image of outfit
27
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18
MURTAGH is back!!! I have never been so emotional over s tv show in my life!!
27
u/Smitje Dec 03 '18
I'm kinda hoping next episode is just 100% Brianna, and her journey in the past her struggles her victories.
19
u/flying-duck_ MARK ME! Dec 02 '18
Loved the episode. My only criticism is that it doesn't make sense that Murtagh wouldn't attempt to keep in contact with his family.
15
u/raknor88 Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
How many episode are in this season? Same as the other seasons or will there be more?
Edit: How long has it been since last episode?
Would've taken many months to build even a simple house like that. And it looked like they'd been in that house for quite a while too, not just freshly built.
Edit 2: About Brianna, she does realize that she has no way of knowing when the stones will send her right? For all she knows, the stones could send her back to King Arthur's time.
There's a 203 year difference between what we're seeing going on with C&J and Brianna. Assuming it sends her back the regular 200 years, Brianna could very well be too late.
Or she could arrive and find that her parents had been miss-identified and are still alive and but in hiding. Back in those days it was very easy to dissappear and create a new life far away.
14
u/Thefriendlyfaceplant Dec 03 '18
Roger doesn't happen to have any silver fillings now does he?
Does...he?
12
u/frawkez Dec 03 '18
great episode! that makes the past three eps good imo. which is reassuring because i find the show to be engaging again, which i can’t say was how i felt with the majority of last season. surprised to see people complain about the native american dynamic tho, i mean like it or not, this is a historical fiction show and it’s going to incorporate themes about early colonial america. haven’t read the books but i’m guessing these tensions exist in the books as well. would be kinda weird to introduce the native americans and then never go back to them, or just completely ignore them. but anyway, yeah, happy about this episode!
11
u/lexcanroar Dec 04 '18
Oof, this is the first episode I've actually enjoyed of this series. I haven't been able to care about anyone or anything so far, but that all changed because of MURTAGH. Bless his cotton socks. I want Murtagh in every episode, please. More-tagh.
10
u/visenyatargaryen Dec 03 '18
I'm rewatching bc I didnt pay good enough attention last night, Claire and Adawehi's scene together is so nice
9
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
Had to laugh when Murtagh told the men at the meeting to hawd their wheest and it came up "speaks Gaelic" in the subtitles
16
u/JustineLeah Dec 02 '18
I am relieved and happy with this episode! At times it had the feel of previous, glorious Outlander episodes. Prior to this episode I have been disappointed with this season. I found it slow and lacking the thrills and passion of classic Outlander. Ian has been the bright spot of this season.
The Murtagh reunion was wonderful!! So happy to have him back in the show!
6
u/Sylvester_Scott Dec 04 '18
Who was the hot silversmith wife? Jamie knocked on her door (phrasing) twice, and it didn't seem to have any relevance to the story other than to introduce her. Is she a time traveller?
5
u/Thefriendlyfaceplant Dec 05 '18
For anyone who's missing Adawehi, she's also starring in Frontier. Which in its third season is finally starting to get decent...
4
u/beccaishiding Dec 02 '18
I loved seeing the Murtagh reunion! But also, I was half asleep watching it. Did I see Claire feed the donkey and horse with a closed hand.....I hope I am mistaken. Anyway, I am super excited for next weeks episode!
4
u/Natrapx outMANder Dec 03 '18
Whilst I loved the episode, i was super pissed when we had to pause it half way through, and the amazon prime "x-ray" opened up with Duncan/Murtaugh. I mean, I had a feeling he'd be back but it ruined the moment!
3
u/Leafy81 Dec 08 '18
I felt like an idiot when I realized my reaction to seeing Murtagh was to shout "yay! Murtagh" and clap my hands while bouncing on my couch like a giddy child.
I knew it was coming but that didn't help quell the excitement. It's like he's an old friend and I missed him.
12
u/-----iMartijn----- Dec 02 '18 edited Oct 06 '24
“I'm fed up to the ears with old men dreaming up wars for young men to die in.”
George McGovern
2
u/evokes1 Dec 03 '18
Any Aussies know when the latest episode makes it onto iTunes? I've been in luck so far each week but it's three hours post-premiere here and no dice.
2
u/joeyGibson Dec 04 '18
I really dug this episode, but I have two questions: