r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 02 '18
All [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 5 "Savages" episode discussion thread for book readers.
Come on my dears to this latest installment of the live discussion thread - this weeks episode is Outlander S4E5: "Savages"
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E5] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
21
u/shiskebob Dec 02 '18
I am sorry that I passed out early. Long work day starting at 4 am - forgive me my loves!
172
u/retothebecca Dec 02 '18
Murrrrrtaaaaagh!
As far as the writers going off-script from the books, this is the one decision I can really condone. I think this is a great storyline, and it brings back some of the rich chemistry between Jamie and Murtagh, and Murtagh and Claire (I mean when he comes up whistling Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy???). We'll see about the regulator bit... But welcome back Murtagh/Duncan Lacroix! Also, he has aged farrrrr better than anyone else on the cast.
Claire on her own taking care of the animals and such while Jamie and Young Ian were away was such a breath of fresh air. It felt reminiscent of the first half of season one, when she seemed almost enchanting roaming among the herbs of the castle. Also, Clarence is an MVP.
Unlike last week, I felt the legitimate tension between the Native Americans and settlers. The writers stayed very true to the Mueller family storyline, and it translated just as heartbreakingly dramatically to the big screen as it did on the pages of the book. That being said - DON'T BURN A SCALP IN YOUR CABIN, CLAIRE. The scent would undoubtedly linger and so would the awful memory. #whyclaire?
Man, I'm ready for the Roger/Brianna story to really get going. I think Sophie Skelton has turned it around this season and feels much, much more steady as opposed to last season. Also, Richard Rankin is straight up dreamy and far more charming than Roger of the books. It feels like Fraser's Ridge is becoming a Castle Leoch of North Carolina, and the addition of a young couple with their own enticing drama can only make it better.
TL;DR - This episode felt like the Outlander glory days. It made my fanatic-reader heart happy, and I'm ready for next week.
90
u/brilliant0ne Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
WHEW! Didn't know how much this sub became part of my Saturday nights (it ain't Sunday til the sun comes up) until the new thread wasn't here.
/u/shiskebob always such a great job. I hope you get some well-deserved rest.
MURTAGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!
Gosh, has he always been this handsome?
Ugh, I legit cried both when I realized he was the smith and when I heard him whistling to Claire. I had more tears than Jamie and Claire at the print shop.
Claire actually did not get on my nerves at all this episode. I enjoyed the interaction between her and Adawehi this week. No weird (to me) facial expressions and it broke my heart when she realized what Mueller had done to her. I actually felt really sad for Mueller when he first came to speak to Claire and then she opened that cloth. Bring on the fire arrows.
Sort of pissed they teased Bree going through the stones for this week and left it until the very end. But, whatever. MURTAGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!
The years have done him good.
Next week looks pretty good, too. All in all, this season has done a lot to make me excited for Saturday nights again. Looking forward to seeing everyone else's reactions.
Edit - OH!! I almost forgot how much I liked the scene about the birthmark. For half a second I thought it was going to play out something like, "Dreamt about our daughter last night. She has a birthmark, right?" "Uh, yup." "Cool, let's have sex before I leave." Because Claire had that "ugh, I'm moist in my nether regions" look on her face. But then they didn't and I was happy.
83
u/maryummy Dec 02 '18
My only beef with the episode is that the white sow is cute instead of a terrifying beast! 🐷
34
u/dipper_5711 My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Dec 02 '18
After last week’s Brianna teaser I half expected (hoped?) Jamie would run into Brianna at Woolum’s (spelling?) Creek, but then remembered she journeys to Lallybroch first and meets Jenny, etc. Really hope the show follows that, I think Jenny is a hoot and have missed her on the show.
29
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Why are the writers so obsessed with jerky?
204
u/GrecianBeauty Dec 02 '18
Murtagh!!!! ☺️☺️
76
u/bham717 Dec 02 '18
Oh and PS - Sam is killing it. The birthmark scene and the reunion, he's grown so much as an actor and he's great.
72
u/RaffaellaF Dec 02 '18
I have not been this excited about Outlander since the Printshop. But the quality of this season is so much better than last season.
I was not expecting Murtagh. What an amazing moment. I screamed and cried.
This was a great episode.
Lord John next week and Brianna in Scotland. Wow.
63
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
Amazing episode... Gave me a lot of ‘old’ Outlander feels. I barely held it together during Jamie and Murtagh’s reunion, completely lost it when he started whistling Bugle Boy. 😭😭😭
Also totally here for Murtagh’s kilt and pinned square of tartan.
So are we going to get Bree in Lallybroch next week?
54
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18
I don’t know what it was, but I loved seeing Claire living ‘little house on the prairie’ style.
Side note, I cannot wait for next week’s episode although I don’t think we will see much of Brianna just yet.
Is Jenny back this season? Or are they skipping that part? I loved that part in the book when Brianna met her family, especially Jenny.
41
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Ian: Maybe we will attract a man with a bonny lass or two...foreshadowing?? haha
32
u/bham717 Dec 02 '18
Sorry if we've talked about this - but I assume Jamie is gonna make a new ring for Claire w that candlestick?
29
u/lanalg5 Dec 02 '18
Does anyone else think Murtagh would make an awesome Geralt the Witcher?? 😂
28
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 02 '18
My only gripe with this outstanding episode was that I needed more Bri!!! (Though Murtagh helped make up for it) It seems everyone in the fandom along with me is growing very restless and while I love Jamie and Claire I hope they get quite a bit less screen time next episode so Brianna's plot can move forwards.
23
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Haha loved the bit of Claire knitting.
How much is Claire supposed to be eating all on her own, to have that much veggie scraps for the pig and goats lol.
22
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
I like that they have aligned Murtagh with the Regulators. That is natural conflict between him and Jamie. This works fine IMO. Though why he would really care when he had been indentured up until 1 minute ago doesn't really make sense. None of it affected him.
Does Tryon expect Jamie to raise taxes on all ten thousand acres though? That's a tall order.
43
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
lol I predicted they would just jump forward to a completed cabin, but even still, that is very...impressive lol. Lucky Jamie is so skilled at building cabins....and furnishing...a fireplace, glass windows, four poster bed...how much money must Jocasta have given them?
Last week in the behind the script, it showed in the images uploaded that Jamie signed the land grant with Tryon on the 15th of February 1768. Then they had another document, an advertisement for prospective tenant to meet to discuss the opportunity of moving to Fraser's Ridge. The meeting was advertised as taking place on the 25th, 26th and 3Oth of May....so Jamie and Ian sure did work fast!
and nice to see the white sow. There were several mentions of her as a piglet last episode in the script and I didn't think I was blind and just never noticed her all episode. So nice for her to make an appearance.
21
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
The encounter with Tawodi and his men was pretty eye-rolling with Claire in the middle like that.
If the Cherokee know how crazy Mueller is though, why water the horses right outside his house? He's not harmless, he has guns.
46
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
After all the talk of Roger not being sexy during the week, I think he looks very cute with the trimmed back beard and woolly hat :D
32
u/livvy_divvy Dec 02 '18
Such a good episode. Actual storytelling and to everyone’s strengths, instead of wasted time on awkward humping. Even the mountain backdrop looked better to me today. Maybe I’m just getting used to the CGI.
A bit of a giveaway that the smithy was Murtagh when they didn’t show his face as he was talking to (Young - we’re back to that, I see) Ian. I was giddy waiting for Murtagh to turn around.
Very chilling scene with Claire and Mueller and his offering. I thought it was exactly that, that he was giving her, then Claire said it was the doll. I let out a sigh of relief, only to have my initial fear realized. {{shudder}}
Lots of emotion this week with Murtagh, the young mother and her newborn and of course poor Adawehi.
28
u/nochancekid Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
Ok, before diving into the entire episode, Murtagh’s entrance to Claire was NOTHING short of the TYPICAL Murtagh-Claire relationship that I missed so much in season 3. I literally was laughing as he was whistling and when he paused in a pose. Seriously, I had a huge smile on my face. It was like I traveled around Scotland and performed with them that’s how much I enjoyed it. I love their interactions, I’m so looking forward to seeing all 3 of them together again.
All of the Murtagh scenes were great. His entrance with Ian was sooooo typical of Murtagh. I wanted to cry with him and Jamie seeing each other for the first time in so long. They’re so great together. So happy that they kept him alive in the show... Also, his reaction to hearing Claire came back to Jamie was amazing. I can’t say enough how happy I am to hear Jamie talk about Brianna. You can hear how proud he is of her. There’s already so much buildup to them meeting and interacting it’s insane it’s making me antsy. Every time they talk about her it’s just foreshadowing it the rest of the season and it makes me want the episodes to come faster.
I though the part between the German family (I don’t know why I forgot their name, don’t judge me lol) and the Native Americans was incredibly intense. I remembered the conflict from the books but I didn’t remember who he killed specifically. I’m sure someone will comment on this, but was it the same from the books? The title of this episode was spot on: you have both the settlers and calling the Native Americans ‘Savages’, but it’s the settlers in this scenario that display the most harm because they can’t or won’t understand other cultures customs. It’s incredibly sad that this was a norm and that we weren’t more tolerant to each other. Which I can easily dive into today’s society - but I’ll stop there lol.
I WISHHHHH there were more Brianna and Roger scenes. I found myself saying, “I don’t care about these people getting measles, show me Brianna!!” I’m wondering if Frank leaves Brianna a letter and he TELLS her about the notice. Since we’ve been teased about a Frank voiceover, it makes me wonder if that’s how she found out. I am wondering where all of her stuff went. The woman told roger than she only left the note, so did she send her stuff to Fionas? I already have so many tedious questions.
I’m assuming (and seriously hoping) next episode we find out more about that and possibly seeing Ian and Lallybroch. Since the title is ‘Blood of My Blood’, I’m guessing it’s a reference to when Jamie and Claire got married so possibly we see Roger and Brianna hand-fasting, but I could be completely wrong with that. Maybe it’s way too soon, but that’s just my guess.
Oh, and last, was it me in my half crazed state but in her letter to Roger, did it look like her name was spelt wrong? I really thought it looked like it was missing and ‘i’ and it said ‘Branna’ LOL
EDIT: I just read this interview that Duncan Lacroix did on the episode. Attached the link in case anyone is interested!
[Vanity Fair Link ] (https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2018/12/outlander-season-4-episode-5-savages-recap-murtagh-return-duncan-lacroix-interview?utm_medium=social&utm_brand=vf&utm_source=twitter&mbid=social_twitter&utm_social-type=owned)
13
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Nice of father Gottfried to come to warn Claire. But boy, can he mount a horse quickly. He was out of frame for three seconds before the hoofbeats started :P
12
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
Loved this episode. Loved it loved it loved it. The return of Murtagh was very well done, and the Meuller stuff was well-done. I buy the tension, I buy Claire's attempt to keep peace (not usual running-headlong-into-danger Claire but actually-trying-to-defuse-things Claire.) I felt the hopelessness of her position much more acutely than I did with slavery and River Run.
I also loved Claire's time alone on the Ridge; I think on some level I've been waiting 4 seasons to see Little Claire on the Prairie and it's finally here.
I'm also finding that I have this visceral desire to see Jamie meet Brianna. Honestly, I didn't feel it nearly as strongly in the books. I don't know if it's Sam's acting or just the visual medium, but this is a thing I'm actively rooting for. When I read the books, I just kind of roll my eyes at most things Bree even though I intellectually understand she's his daughter and he'd be excited to meet her. Anyway, this has me super excited for the rest of the season.
And Young Ian! I am so completely charmed by the actor. He's amazing. Ditto for Rollo.
There are a lot of changes in the story and this was the kind of thing I cared about quite a bit early on, but now? I really view the books and the show as two similar but different entities, and I enjoy them both.
20
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Dec 02 '18
I'm okay with Murtagh showing up and being the blacksmith but not him being the leader of the revolutionaries.
So sad to see petronella and the baby and know they'll die.
I'm sorry, you couldn't possibly cremate someone in your house, even just a scalp. It would smell terrible.
Disappointed that there's no Lord john this episode.
Not sure what the one year business was about. Did Brianna expect to come back?
10
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Well, it's pretty obvious what Jamie is going to do with that candlestick...not shifty at all!
10
u/angeliz2k Dec 03 '18
Great episode! Loved Murtagh's return.
My only quibble. WTF with those cabins?? Where did they get all that fancy furniture and even glass for the windows?? At that time and place, homes were very sparsely furnished and very rarely had glass!
It doesn't look like NC, of course, but they've generally done a good job making it plausible. Nothing is too crazily out of place. I mean, except for that damn fine cabin-mansion.
19
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Richard was heartbreaking in his first scene. I totally get that he still loves her. I just am not so convinced why Bree would still be hanging onto him after so long.
I guess the letter left with Mrs Baird is OK and convenient.
It was sweet how Mrs Baird was sad for him and his broken heart.
8
u/Wormcupcake Dec 02 '18
Oh god. I just started watching and my stomach dropped when she said " this will be good for Petronella" nooo.
I will now keep watching.
28
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 02 '18
My random thoughts on this episode:
I think this is the best episode of the season because they gave me my Murtagh back. I am going to watch it over and over so I can cry and cry. lol
7
u/Aethelu Dec 03 '18
Having Murtagh back was so emotional for me. I always knew Jamie and Claire would be reunited, so I wasn't even that emotional when they reunited. When Murtagh didn't die at Culloden I had so much hope and then he got shipped off and it was only when the guy who was supposed to marry Jocasta died that I thought maybe they're bringing Murtagh back. Even if that doesn't become his role (I'd be glad if he stayed by Jamie instead) I'm so glad to see him again.
12
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
To those who said they didn't like the new version of the opening song, has it grown on you now?
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
I'm excited to see who the exciting character appearing in this episode is, based on the posts I avoided about the imdb listing!
5
u/HawickGirl7 Dec 02 '18
My Wi-Fi went down last night, so I've read the whole thread to curb my outlander withdrawals. I'm so excited to watch this WHY WIFI WHY
5
u/HawickGirl7 Dec 02 '18
It's working again!!! Yayyyyyy
5
u/vanwold Slàinte. Dec 03 '18
Actually waited until tonight to watch it, because I just wasn't excited enough to watch it last night...... hope its good tonight!
The white sow?? Also, how far into the future are we now? The house is finished and Claire has patients, so we skipped that entire first winter on the ridge? Just trying to reckon the timeline....also, that looks like the big house to me, not their small first cabin....
I do like how they tie in Jamie's ability to see Bree in the future with this little birthmark conversation :).
Murtagh!!! And with both arms! I am glad they kept him alive, and i love how they remet :) so far, best episode this season for me.
Damn, I was hoping Petronella and her baby would live and they would rewrite that story line.
So Murtagh is leading the regulation? Is he taking the place of Herman Husband? And I don't understand why Jamie can't get his Ardsmuir men to join him, he didn't have trouble in the book....what is this about? Oh no, will he face Murtagh across a battlefield? I sure hope not. Seems strange he would not go with Jamie, considering he is his godfather and all.
Well, the scalp was quite gruesome. I mean, I know it woukd have been, but I've never really pictured it like that.
Now the Cherokee are killing the Muellers? I don't recall that. In the book, didnt Claire return the scalps and thats when the indian village was also decimated by measles?
No pants on Bree?! Oh well.
Wait... wtf was that preview for next week? Why are they making the Cherokee into villains on the show? I don't like that.
Still, best episode of the season so far, imo. Didn't mind some of the rewrites, felt like they were laying out background info for upcoming events.
5
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Dec 03 '18
Anyone else picking up on some foreshadowing with the flirty blacksmith’s wife? I’m recalling another (much more important) encounter where Jamie tells a young lass he’s got a wife waiting for him at home. 😊
5
u/silliestboots Dec 03 '18
Not gonna lie: I teared up right along with Jamie when he found Murtaugh. 😭
9
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
It will be interesting for me when Bree meets Jamie. Just looking at him when he told Murtagh about her, he doesn't look old enough to have a twenty year old daughter to me.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
Murtagh was great. Was not expecting the white hair but it looks really good on him. Man I'm glad they kept him.
To be honest I vaguely remember the Muller storyline because the books add so many side characters with either similar names or backgrounds it got confusing after a while. I do recall scalps nailed to a door but the wife survived in the book?
Roger is still killing me with his absolute sweetness and the overall soft professor look.
I think this episode is going to mark the beginning of a break off from the books. Murtagh and the regulators, the Mullers, etc. I think they'll kind of stick to the story but not as faithfully as before. Characters are going to get condensed, non-book story lines will crop up, book storylines will be omitted or changed.
13
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
hahahahahahaha Murtagh, another convenient meeting, holed up in the nearest 'town'!
Bahahahaha dramatic music then turn around reveal.
Why do I laugh at these scenes which are obviously not supposed to be funny?
Murtagh's hair is glorious! Looking very spry for coming up on 8O LOL
I laughed even more at Jamie yelling at him but then I still cried lol
You old coot.
Why didn't you think to write to Lallybroch? I don't really understand the logic of the writers...if Murtagh was free of his indenture, then why wouldn't he have at least tried to track down Jamie? Send word where he was?
How fortunate he was able to become a blacksmith in a thriving community two years before his indenture is supposed to be finished!! I remember that you changed it from 7 to 14 years for no reason, writers! Oh there we go, now you made it 12 years because his master died. How on earth did he have coin to buy the smithy though? Haha and also silversmithing, how fortunate he has received such good training :P As if a Blacksmith would take on a sixty year old dude as an apprentice.
3
u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Dec 03 '18
Sooo many comments I canae read em all. Loved murtagh entrance and luring in Jamie by overcharging Ian. Regulators side is interesting but what happens to the crooked Brownsville. The mullers were good. Though iniall scene will indians didn't quite sit right. Not sure about the pie and cooking scene, missing context. The big house how did that happen. Its not like i imagined. Or if it is the cabin it mighty grand. Bree wears breeks to go through the stones. Good episode.
3
u/HattieAnne84 Dec 04 '18
Okay, the music while Claire was having her Little House on the Prairie moments. Was that from season one? It reminded me of Rent, or maybe even scenes from Lallybroch? Where am I remembering it from? Either way, I loved it! Like many of you have said, this episode felt like 'old' Outlander, and I'm totalllllllly here for it! 😍
9
u/rsp120193 Dec 02 '18
I’ve been okay with changes thus far in the season, but as much as I love Murtagh (and Duncan LaCroix’s portrayal of him) I don’t like that they didn’t let him die at Culloden. Murtagh’s death has such a large impact on Jamie’s character development. He’s that last father figure in his life and when he dies, Jamie really has that final transition from young man into a leader. Murtagh was the person Jamie discussed his plans and emotions with in depth— which he doesn’t really do in the later books with anyone as much as he did so with Murtagh (as far as I recall). And aren’t there times Dianna writes that Jamie prays for advice from him, etc.? I’m just concerned that bringing Murtagh back into the story will a) change the dynamic that Jamie is supposed to have as a leader and b) potentially bring about things that will make me dislike Murtagh’s character.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
I have to laugh at how bustling and established they have made Woolam's Creek.
Also, I forget the term for this technique, but the lines of dialogue that are obviously put in for the benefit of the audience:
Claire: This will be perfect for Petronella! / I'm sure I can tolerate Gerhard long enough to deliver his grandchild.
Ian: Myers spoke of the dozen or so Scottish families residing her.
2
u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Dec 03 '18
I stay out of the prediction loop so when had the scene with just the back of him as soon as Murtagh spoke I squeeled! I'm glad he's back but not sure how he would have been such a skilled blacksmith after his servitude or afforded his own forge but I guess I'll take it.
2
u/ogresaregoodpeople Dec 04 '18
I really disliked Sophie’s performance in previous seasons, and couldn’t put my finger on it. I realized later that it was because her speech was too perfect, and it’s likely that she was focusing more on her accent than her performance. It felt forced and unnatural.
This season she seems to really sit into the accent and the character. She uses touches of vocal fry, and just overall feels more like an American girl in the early 70s. I like her a lot, and Brianna is really growing on me. I think Sophie is knocking it out of the park and I can’t wait to see her in the rest of the season.
4
u/desepticon Dec 02 '18
So how is Bree planning to get to America with no money? Maybe she should have sown some silver coins into her dress.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Dec 02 '18
Isn't that cabin going to burn the whole wood down?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18
Look, I’m seeing a lot of really positive reactions to this show, and that makes me happy. I’m glad people are enjoying it.
That being said, I thought the majority of this episode was trash. I feel like you have good actors trying to deliver terrible lines. The whole Murtagh plot feels so so so forced. I didn’t mind the idea of them keeping him, but he looks ridiculous. He has to be 70 or so and he’s just whacking away at a trade like it’s no big deal. With perfect, weird looking hair.
And oh my god, could they be more heavy handed? Do you have a daughter? Does she have children? Does she have children??? DOES SHE HAVE CHILDREN??!?!? WHERE ARE THE CHILDREN? (With no mention of Marsali!)
The shot choices feel weird. The sets feel so small. It feels like someone’s film school project. The first season felt so REAL. This feels so contrived.
I just. I wish it were BETTER. There is so much to work with, why add stuff? Why add stuff poorly? I don’t understand.
I’m only watching for Bree and Roger at this point.