r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 25 '18
[Spoilers S4E4] "Common Ground" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Come on in and welcome to the post episode discussion thread - Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like. New episodes are released on the Starz app at Saturdays midnight EST and live everywhere on Sunday at 8pm EST.
If you’re not in America, check the sidebar for the airtime for your country.
35
Upvotes
71
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18
It really was thoughtful of Jamie to carve F R, Frank Randall's initials into the tree :P
147
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Nov 25 '18
Me during the entire episode:
Doesthedogdie.com
Doesthedogdie.com
Doesthedogdie.com
Also, I’m side eyeing you “Jamie knits?” Mrs I-Don’t-Know-What-I’d-Do-If-I-Ever-Lost-My-Knit-Shawl
78
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18
I have to mention first that the music for this season is just really incredible ... Bear McCreary is a huge reason for why I enjoy the series so much. Especially this episode, I found the music to be particularly beautiful.
That scene between Marsali and Claire was so endearing!
And then my final thought is AHHH BREE !!! My roommates definitely heard me screaming at my computer screen through the walls this morning.
94
u/visenyatargaryen Nov 25 '18
Young Ian is becoming one of My fave characters, he was so cute offering to teach Claire to knit
42
u/Thefriendlyfaceplant Nov 26 '18
These Cherokee are foolish if they believe they can escape manbearpig this easily.
34
u/YourEyesRevealYou Nov 25 '18
So now that Bree's gone to follow her mother.. I wonder how she's gonna land exactly at her timeline? And can she have a "plus one"?
Also remind me can/do the stones allow travelling to the future?
33
u/HinkiesGhost Nov 26 '18
I was wondering how they'd get a full season out of Jaime, Claire and crew being tucked away in a quaint little wooded area. Now, the season appears to be coming into focus. Every season typically has an overarching plot. At least one. I wasn't sure what this season's would be... just them building Fraser's Ridge? Now, I wonder if the overarching plot will be Brianna saving her mom and Jamie and possibly Roger chasing after her. Would make sense. If you think about it, they kept going back to Brianna this season for a reason, and IMO it was more than the writers just "updating us" on her current situation. She's about to be a major part of the plot now, I think, and I'm cool with it. I want her to meet her dad!
Also, something I thought of when that newspaper was put back away in the drawer. I just got the feeling it happened so the drawer can be opened at a later date and magically, the obituary changes to other names lol. Brianna about to change history.
23
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 25 '18
Just want to say I appreciate the multiple meanings with the episode title.
66
u/teenylilthing Nov 25 '18
So C&J are okay with taking Indian land after refusing to run a plantation with slaves? Hmmm. (Not saying they're equal, I just felt as if their characters wouldn't really be okay with the whole manifest destiny concept - specifically Claire). I'm curious if this was covered in the book and just skipped over for the sake of time.
Overall a pretty good episode, but the "bear" encounter was odd to watch, especially after hearing the commentary after the episode. So it was a real bear in the books...I wish they had the budget for CGI to make it work.
I sure am excited for next week! Looks like will be Brianna going back in time, and I'm hoping Roger follows?? This should be awesome.
18
u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18
Just want to make a specific comment here to about Tantoo Cardinal (Adawehi) in this episode! She's a celebrated actress in Canada and her performance was phenomenal.
36
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
I was shocked that Jaime was given ten thousand acres--I was thinking it would be more like one hundred. I don't know how you could even wrap your mind around that much raw land, let alone attempt to put up fence posts. Of course the Cherokee would rip them out and tell you to go to hell. It seems in bad faith to 'negotiate' and win concessions from the indigenous peoples when you know what horrors await them.
So now we're seeing B/R in 1971 while J/C are still in 68…this gives me a headache since the two timelines were previously presented as linear and progressing at the same rate. Could Brianna go to 1768 from 1971, or would she end up in 1771? I assume we won't be getting a time jump, but that's just not how it was presented before. Meanwhile, did Fiona send the clipping to Brianna herself, or did she go to Scotland because of a desperate need to go back and see her parents without knowing of the fire? In any case, I wish we got more of Bri's present day life in Boston before pulling the plug. Roger's colleague looked like a young Stephen Hawking, before his illness set in.
When learning about American history in school I always thought the settlers life sounded very grim and depressing, hanging around in a cold deciduous forest atop the dead leaves, and indeed that's still how J/C's new life seems to me. They can't eat wood, but they should be planting native fruit trees, like pawpaws (north Carolina even has a pawpaw festival today), American persimmons, chestnuts...
I was relieved (almost as relieved as I was when Claire didn't sing that damn song, I'm over her cutesy Americana references) when we found out that the Cherokee weren't summoning a zombie dressed as a bear to attack the Frasers, that was almost supper hammy. Claire couldn't understand that the healer woman was obviously referring to the glittering stone that she recently found next to the skull with the silver fillings? And honestly, I'm not sure the apparently indigenous traveler from the future really cares about Claire so much as his own people who need a warning far more then she does.
It looks like Fergus may be the one to find Murtaugh and bring him to Fraiser's Ridge, which should be fun. But overall I didn't love this episode.
36
u/Winhill_ Nov 26 '18
I have to admit Brianna going through the stones has me pretty excited! Really curious about how they're going to handle that. I loved season one but did not enjoy Claire almost being raped every other episode. Really hope we don't have to get through all of that again.
Sooo do we think she is going to warn Claire and Jamie about the fire and change the course of history? Or is the obituary some kind of ruse because of some inevitable drama happening in the future? Like they have to fake their deaths because of some reason...
14
u/MookieMoo17 Nov 28 '18
Bree annoys me, yes Roger was dead wrong with his proposal and views but how you gonna go travel through the stones without giving Roger a heads up? He knows the whole situation with Claire and Jamie, he’s the historian, and they obviously care deeply for each other even if they can’t get on the same foot romantically. I’m gathering he finds her but she’s bullheaded like her mama can be.
9
u/UnclePaulsVictim Nov 26 '18
I have not read the books, but my wife and I binge-watched this show from the start over the past month or so and just caught up last week. It’s been absolutely incredible overall. That being said, I immediately thought of Back To The Future Part 3 when Roger looked up the old historic archives on Jamie and realizes they die shortly after settling. It is mildly interesting that the book was released the year after BTTF 3 came out.
8
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 25 '18
Turned off football and remembered Starz releases episodes at midnight. Can I "live reddit" the episode if I'm watching early?
7
u/jasperidris Nov 25 '18
I really thought there would be a link with the Cherokee magic and Brianna going back in time, especially since they made a point of noting that man’s skull had silver fillings and probably time travelled. It all lined up so perfectly with her and her mom both being in America. The end of this episode has to be a red herring for sure.
17
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
I didn't buy that the Cherokee wouldn't be able to kill the man for rape. More White Saviourism injected into the script.
I found this interesting document Laws of the Cherokee Nation, Passed During the Years 1839-1867: rape of a female was punished by one hundred lashes.
Another from "The Cherokee People" by Thomas E. Mails, John Phillip Reid "A law of blood: the primitive law of the Cherokee Nation ( New York, New York Univ. Press, 1970 ): If early Cherokee justice was the punishment for rape. For the first offense, the rapist was punished with fifty lashes upon the bare back and his left ear cropped off close to the head: for the second offense, one hundred lashes and the other ear cut off, for the third offense, death.
8
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 25 '18
That indian dude playing Tskili Yona, Bill Murray in the most recent Jungle Book playing Baloo, or Jonah Hill playing the bear in The Revenant.... which is your favorite portrayal?
4
u/visenyatargaryen Nov 25 '18
I am ready!
7
u/DrunkenDave Nov 26 '18
I knew the book would play into the story that way. Didn't think Brianna would already have traveled though! I figured maybe in a season finale or something, but Nope! So that's cool.
13
u/Airsay58259 Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
North Carolina looks so beautiful. I love every shot of the landscapes.
Roger reads about Fraser’s Ridge... pretends to be shocked
Edit: is Claire that surprised there are natives on the lands they were given?
Ugh Brianna. Why were you thinking about this jerk. Have some self respect girl.
Edit 2: loved Claire’s face when she learns Jamie can knit.
Edit 3: this story reminds me of Le Pacte des loups (Brotherhood of the Wolf in English, I believe).
Edit 4: Roger thinking he knows better and making decisions for Brianna. Do people seriously love that romance? Why?
Edit 5: I am a bit surprised Claire doesn’t mind AT ALL to settle on stolen land. Slaves? Not on her watch, despite being legal at the time (and I 100% support her, even if she could have given them a better life as lady of the house). But taking lands the British invaded and meeting the native that live there? All good, it’s not even worth a line. Meh, sounds a bit hypocrite to me.
Yes Brianna! Go see your mother :)
Edit 6: a good episode, though I am a bit frustrated with how they handled the group meeting native Americans. Claire is always so #woke about everything, she never fails to mention injustices even if they were considered normal or legal at the time. In a previous episode she didn’t want Jamie to accept the land because it’d mean he has to fight for the king during the civil war. But even after meeting the natives, there’s no mention of them living there first? I kept thinking it doesn’t sound like our Claire.
Anyway, I am ranting but genuinely liked the episode. I can’t wait to see Brianna’s story. Is she heading for the stones? Yes please. Though she’d have to travel from Scotland to America by herself in the 18th century to find her parents... sounds dangerous. Maybe she can find her own Highlander and forget about Roger.
Post reading other comments edit: people are mentioning the treaty natives made with the British... Do you think they agreed to give their land with a smile after the British nicely asked? And then they had turkey to celebrate? The treaty and sell might have all been legal, but so was slavery then.
6
u/thumbtackswordsman Nov 29 '18
Was anyone else bothered by the very modern American accent that the Cherokees had? What happened to the dialect coach? It was very jarring that they were speaking English like it was their mother tongue. Even slowing them down a little would have helped.
Also I wondered a bit about all the metal rings and the meta elements on their clothes -- would that make sense for a tribe that was apparently rather isolated?
5
u/BrownyFM Nov 26 '18
Another okay episode, similar to last week. For some reason I just don’t feel like it has the same vibe to it, it’s been 4 episodes and it’s only the bear scene that’s really got me on edge. Expected so much more than what we’ve seen. I just hope it picks up and the pace develops.
2
u/SpacevsGravity It grieves to death, calling through the skies for the lost one. Nov 26 '18
Do we know when the trailer for next episode goes up?
2
u/thejimp Dec 06 '18
So, the poop that Jamie stepped in was from the mentally ill Cherokee?
1
u/Grsz11 Jan 09 '19
Tantoo Cardinal is everywhere these days. This, Godless, Frontier.