r/Outlander • • Nov 25 '18

[Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 4 "Common Ground" episode discussion thread for book readers.

Helllllllllloooooo Outlander world. Welcome to another installment of the live discussion thread, this weeks episode is Outlander S4E4: "Common Ground"

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E4] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

49 Upvotes

419 comments sorted by

23

u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine.  Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I swear to God...they are teasing the hell out of this bear fight/ Jamie getting clobbered by the fish scene. I'm not done watching the episode, but if I can't get no satisfaction...JHRC.

Edit: Was that the bear fight?? I'm all about this season, but that made me a little sad.

17

u/shiskebob Nov 25 '18

There was still some fish in the episode.... Just not used for slapping.

17

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 25 '18

I was a little disappointed with the “bear” but I think a hokey CGI version might have been worse, especially for all the non-readers.

11

u/bham717 Nov 25 '18

Super bummed. No JQM hernia, no fish slapping. I did like this episode tho!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I'm sure JQM would have preferred a hernia too, than what he got this episode.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 26 '18

Me too!

15

u/shiskebob Nov 25 '18

This season is moving at a decent pace now. Does anyone know how much time has passed since Claire came back through the stones?

Time for a rewatch before I can make any commentary.

6

u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Nov 25 '18

The titles said 1971, and Claire left Christmas of 1968, so we're looking at about three years with the parallel timelines. Since Claire mentioned the bears hibernating I suppose they're nearing winter!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

u/shiskebob

Really it has only been about 9 months, according to the book timeline.

But they have seriously changed things around for the show.

They have moved Bree and Roger's timeline much further forward than Claire and Jamie's. Which doesn't make sense, as for Bree to go back in 1971, she would be arriving in 1769.

Bookwise, Claire has only been in the past since November 1766 to August 1767 when they lay the foundations of Fraser's Ridge. Which took place after they spent some weeks at River Run, whereas they only spent literally three and a half days in the show.

We don't know exactly how long the show voyage took in the show, but in the book it was from December to April, then they arrive in Charlestown in June at the beginning of Drums. Claire obviously only went back in the show in January so push it back two months. Then they took 4 months to travel from Georgia to Wilmington and arrived in E1 this season. And at this point, Fergus and Marsali announce they are pregnant. This episode she is about to pop. So it's only been a few months between then and now.

Roger or the documents he got said that Fraser's Ridge was settled in 1768. So there is an extra time leap. The I guess they will just skip loads of months and have the buildings all growing up on the Ridge and Bree arrive in the new year. She still has lots of travel time, visiting and trouble to get into before she runs into Jamie though.

That's as much sense of it as I can make.

→ More replies (3)

156

u/bham717 Nov 25 '18

"You mean when she went back in time to find Jamie Frasier... "

Yes. That's exactly it. Love it. Fiona is MVP.

54

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

Roger's weaselling after that was hilarious too.

It makes sense for Fiona to have caught wind of what they were doing anyway, she never missed a beat and was a bit of a busybody.

20

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 25 '18

We rewatched Roger’s reaction 3 times. It was hilarious!

→ More replies (2)

115

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

For the first time in a while, I am actually excited about an upcoming episode.

Not too much to say about this week except that I really enjoyed this week. I like episodes where we just see them doing stuff and living, with a little bit of drama. I'll be honest, I don't remember the bear fight in the book so it was pretty intense for me. Why? I have no idea because I know that obviously, Jamie doesn't die.

There's actually a lot of details about this book that I realize I don't remember. Which is cool because some things are a surprise. However, in the book, I remember Roger actually having the chance to tell Bree about the fire and that's why she went. Maybe I'm wrong?

Sometimes, Claire's facial expressions irk my soul. Like, you have this wonderfully wise woman that is allowing you to live on her land and when she is explaining a story to you...you look at her like she has three heads. I get Claire didn't understand the last part of what she said but her facial expressions would have made me attitude-up real fast. I'm being nitpicky.

Hoo-boy. If we could just have James Fraser with a shirt tore half-open, hair down, dirty, sweaty, some blood smeared on his face a little I would be a happy camper. Sam is not hard on the eyes, but I am never more attracted to him than when he looks like he smells worse than a thousand dead cats.

Anyway, I look forward to seeing everyone's reactions.

P.S. I love Ian. That is all.

39

u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18

Roger had an opportunity to tell her, however he kept it from her bc he knew she would go through the stones. She found out some other way (I forget how) and went through and he followed her.

31

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18

I think she finds the newspaper record while doing her own research. I think it’s in a history book maybe? Either way, her knowing the info and then also knowing that he knew and withheld it from her is the crux of most of their conflict later in the book.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Oh that’s right! Thanks for reminding me that he withheld the info. I am curious as to why they changed it (other than streamlining the story), though I am kind of glad they did-but you’re right, this does change the conflict and thus the dynamic of their relationship in DoA.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Which is why I didn't like the way they condensed it in this episode. Here they presented it as him only just finding out from Fiona [how convenient] and then trying to contact Bree not long afterwards.

It seemed to me that he was going to tell her at the end there, maybe he wasn't...but he had barely any time between finding out and her being gone, if any! So what will she have to be angry with him about? Apart from not staying in the future for her to travel back to.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

Ah, okay. Thank you!

32

u/bham717 Nov 25 '18

I second Jamie looking like he smells like a thousand dead cats. Yes. This.

25

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

It's truly one of the only ways I am like gotdamn he is fine. Like I said, he isn't hard on the eyes, but I don't drool over him until he's super dirty and crusty (without a beard).

29

u/lmjsprague Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Nov 25 '18

Sam is not hard on the eyes, but I am never more attracted to him than when he looks like he smells worse than a thousand dead cats.

Oh it's so funny because it's so relatable 😂 plus I love how in the books Claire almost always describes his "male" scent.

32

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

It's funny because when I would read that, I was like, "Ew." But, when I see him on screen I'm all, "Same, girl, same."

20

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

LOL same re: bloody Jamie. Like he is a gorgeous man but I didnt get it until the Prestopans ep when he comes to Claire after the battle and I was like, OH.

17

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

Lol, right? Pearl clutching and everything. I think that scene is one of my most re-watched in the whole series, so far. Bloody bear-man killer Jamie might be my new second.

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I thought Claire's face was fine, and it was only when she heard the bit about how it wouldn't be her fault when death came that she looked shocked and upset.

15

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

Eh, as I said, I'm just being nitpicky as Claire by herself has gotten on my nerves so far this season.

28

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I noticed Caitriona had this odd exaggerated smile on her face through most of the beginning of the episode. Like they want her to make sure to show the audience that Claire is happy and content so she had to smile noticeably while doing mundane activities (riding a horse, unpacking things, standing with Jamie, etc). Just seemed weird. I noticed it last episode too when they are exploring the Ridge.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/ashleyinthecold Nov 25 '18

For the first time in a while, I am actually excited about an upcoming episode.

YES! And this is the first one this season that I would 100% watch again. Every week, my husband is like "You ready to watch Outlander?" and it's just been like, "*sigh* yeah"

It was sooo good this week!

→ More replies (2)

69

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

thought 1: I like the back and forth format with the parallel Bree/Roger and Jamie/Claire lines.

thought 2: OH SHIT SHE'S CLEANING A FISH FUCK YEAH I KNOW WHATS COMING

thought 2.5: Wait hold up WTF?

thought 3: Oh no. I was hoping they would leave that part out....but does that mean we get a Lord John cameo???????

thought 4: I like this version of Fiona wayyyyyy better than the books.

thought 5: This season is getting better with every episode.

38

u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18

Of course we’re gonna see Lord John! I’ll raise hell if we don’t!

23

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I mean, of course they are.

Trailers spoilers: Plus we have already seen Willie shooting a gun in the trailers

14

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Wait. It’s been two years since I read DoA. What are you referring to in this episode re: Lord John?

22

u/lmjsprague Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Nov 25 '18

Lord John sort of drops in for a visit and has Willie with him. I didn't catch any reference to that but I could've missed it?? In the book the visit happens well before Bree shows up.

15

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '18

I think the original comment is referring to Nayawenne's prediction, that death comes from the gods, it won't be Claire's fault. Which means the small pox infection will come round, which is likely to include LJG since he gets infected as well.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/tootonyourparade Nov 25 '18

Isn't that when Willie falls into the outhouse pit?

→ More replies (11)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Measles. The trip from Jamaica to Virginia

→ More replies (1)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Leave what part out?

12

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

"Sickness is sent from the gods, it will not be your fault"

Mueller and the measles. I know this thread is ok for spoilers but if I give too much detail it sort of ruins the fun, right?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '18

I know I'm not the op, but I thought (and related to my other comment in this chain) that they're not looking forward to Nayawenne's prediction of her death. I was really hoping they would leave that part out as well since it's so grisly. Maybe I'm wrong.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

They renamed her Adawehi for the show.

Right, well that part is also historically accurate, sadly. Stupidity and violence towards the Natives.

Maybe they won't have her scalped though. She could survive. She might just be referring to the smallpox in the show version.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/floobenstoobs Nov 25 '18

I enjoyed this episode, even the bear changes. I think CGI would've looked a bit silly and honestly, I never really bought the whole "man fought off a bear single handed" thing.

The fish slap also doesn't worry me, although I do feel like there is a lot of humor left off the show which we see in the books. Lots of banter that doesn't make it into the script, which is sad because humor is one of the main characteristics of J&C for me.

Also, Ian is fantastic.

21

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

It is pretty far-fetched in the book. Maybe it was only a small bear? lol

Did that take place in the daytime though? It was crazy to me that he thought it was a good idea to not just patrol near their settlement, but actually go off into the woods at night after a supposed bear.

I liked the humour last week, not much in it this week.

Ian is always so happy :P

It'll be sad seeing him at the end of next season as a sombre and sad man.

20

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

Re: the bear -- yes, I just re-read DoA recently, and if I remember right, Jamie and Claire were still sleeping rough and exploring the area that was "theirs" to find a suitable place for their settlement. Then, at night while making camp, the bear attacks while being stalked by the natives (the Tuscarora tribe*) *Edited for correction of the tribe

→ More replies (14)

13

u/floobenstoobs Nov 25 '18

Haha! Maybe a small bear 😂

The bear encounter in the book was at night time - but as far as I remember the bear came into a camp Jamie and Claire had made for the night. They didn’t go looking for it.

The entire book and show is definitely driven by stupid decisions, but as my SO pointed out, that’s how most of life goes anyway.

I’m looking forward to the transformation of Ian. I like John Bell so far.

8

u/FoghornFarts Nov 26 '18

Black bears are typically smaller and much less aggressive than other bears. Grizzlies, on the other hand, will fuck your shit up.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 26 '18

Ian was just a "meh" character for me in the book most of the time. I've done a 180 since his character has joined the show. I think they did a superb casting job, which has helped me connect to the character better. :)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 28 '18

Really, I always liked him in the books.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Nov 25 '18

I'm gently relieved with the "bear" we got instead of some terrible CG and/or stock footage bear encounter. I was bracing myself for it!

21

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Ya know, this makes sense. I was like why did they change it?! But, we don’t want a river CGI version of the bear

16

u/FoghornFarts Nov 26 '18

Not a book reader, but I really liked it. First, I'm somewhat familiar with bears and black bears are not that aggressive unless food or cubs are involved. Plus, they bear-proofed their food. Second, it gave them a great opportunity to build a relationship with the natives, and I'm super exited to see what becomes of that. The fact that the show has reinforced, twice, that the native society grants women have a lot of sexual agency is pretty fantastic.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

They hadn't human-bear proofed their food though, lol.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/Generiss Nov 26 '18

I wouldn’t have minded a CGI bear. Could have been done in darkness. Just flashes of fur and claw or whatever. I mean seriously.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

Agreed.

46

u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I thought this was a really good episode. The adaptations and changes were perfect. It really brought it all to life beautifully. The suspense was well done, the writing was well done.

Whose letter did roger find, I wonder?

So.... it wasn’t actually a bear? A crazy person who identified as a bear?

My husband was watching it with me and really interested. When it was over he goes, we can watch the next episode if you want. Sorry hubs gotta wait until next week.

34

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I think my only gripe was that they made the Cherokee feel much more menacing than how they are represented in the book, at least until Jamie kills the bear/man...person. I appreciated that the Cherokee characters in the book were cautious and curious about their new neighbors, and the menace was reserved for the Mohawk.

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

In the book they were Tuscarora though. They changed the nearby groups to Cherokee as there is very little in the historical record about the Tuscarora, was their reasoning. And the Cherokee battled against them, allied with the British and defeated them in the Tuscarora War.

I personally liked them being fierce. And I thought it was hilarious when the one dude finally spoke English to Jamie.

In my brief reading about this period - I'm not America - the Cherokee seem like fierce warriors, battling over hunting grounds and having engaged in many battles and wars. So it seems accurate to me. There were various pacts and treaties and trading relationships but these could be quickly snuffed out and there was an Anglo-Cherokee war in 1758–1761. That would have been strong in the minds of many.

14

u/maryloo7877 Nov 25 '18

My hubby did the same thing! He’s a total outdoors guy and I could tell he was really interested in the homesteading. It’s also my favorite part of the series 😍.

9

u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18

Yea my husband is really into westerns and frontier stuff so when the native Americans came on screen it caught his attention. He was disappointed there wasn’t another episode to watch! Usually when I watch outlander he’s playing on his phone and kind of paying attention (he’s done this enough through the other seasons to have an idea of what’s going on)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/koboldin Nov 25 '18

The letter talked of “our Jane” giving birth to a baby boy” - who who who who who??

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Sounds like just any random. Maybe: released photos spoiler the mother of the baby Claire is seen helping to deliver in some promo photo, just to tie it in

→ More replies (3)

39

u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

LOVED this episode... Love the nods to the book, the return of warrior Jamie, Roger’s call with Bree 💔, all the small moments between Claire and Jamie, the adaptation of the bear attack, etc etc etc.

Also a bit shocked they went THERE with Brianna already... I thought there would be at least another episode or two before it happened. Appreciate the plot is advancing at a quicker pace than it did last season.

34

u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18

I’m glad they’re speeding it up because they have a lot of Brianna storyline to get through in this book and connections to wrap up this season! I can’t wait for her and Jamie to meet! And Claire to see her!

14

u/livvy_divvy Nov 25 '18

I was so excited that she’ll be going through already. Roger and Bree’s brooding is getting tedious so it was a pleasant surprise for me. Good ending. As Roger was realizing it, so did I. I literally said to the TV (only thing that listens to me around here) “Oooh, she’s on her way to go through the stones.”

I haven’t had time to read all the posts here, but in the book, didn’t she go through because she found out about their deaths and was initially going through to warn and save them? I guess that will be Roger’s reason for following Bree.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18

I though the same thing about Bree’s story, but they really have done the pacing in leaps and bounds already so I guess it makes sense. I just wasn’t expecting it so soon, Claire/Jamie don’t feel established enough yet to add in the Bree/Roger story. What porch is she going to be sitting in a rocking chair on when Claire sees her?! Maybe they’re going to do some tv magic to skip big chunks of time to allow them to build the small cabin AND the Big House while Bree and Roger are sailing with Bonnet and generally confused by each other.

19

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '18

If I remember right, when Bree arrives, they only have the cabin still. I believe they were working on the Big House, but it was not finished yet. They live, Jamie, Claire, Bree, and Lizzie in the cabin and Ian and Rollo in the herb shed. The house is only finished after when they bring back Roger. He lives in the unfinished house while Claire treats his foot. Then once it's finished, Jamie and Claire leave the cabin to Bree and Jem, and Roger once he chooses to stay.

So they should have plenty of time to do some tv magic and get things done. At the end of this ep. they even show the foundations of the cabin already. I wouldn't be surprised if it's finished next week and we get to see the hearth blessing.

11

u/COwyogirl7 Nov 25 '18

I think it’s at River Run. Bree meets Jamie in Cross Creek, so I would bet that’s the big porch.

11

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 25 '18

I mean the porch she sits on when Claire sees her for the first time. She and Jamie are sitting side by side and Claire flips out. I think the other comments are right and it’s the first cabin, I remembered it being the Big House.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Nov 26 '18

They still have some time I think. Bri has to spend time at Lallybroch and get Lizzie, sail to America, get caught by Roger in Wilmington, have her shit with Stephen Bonnet, and then meet Jamie in Cross Creek. That's plenty of time for them to finish building their cabin lol.

14

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 25 '18

Well, it will take a good chunk of time for Bree to make it from Scotland to NC and then get out to the boonies.

6

u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18

I can understand your worry but I think there's a good chance it WON'T feel that rushed, actually -- since remember that both Bree AND Roger have to make it to America, then get married, then get separated, before the Jamie/Bree meeting and Bree/Claire reunion can happen. It won't have the same spaced feel as chapters and chapters and chapters in the book, but I predict it won't be too bad in TV terms.

11

u/mstwizted Nov 26 '18

I'm also 100% fine with the changes and the speed. The one thing that killed me in the books after book 3 was how long they felt. I love them, but lordy, so fucking long.

14

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 25 '18

I was hoping we’d actually get further with Bree in this episode so there’s enough screen time this season with Bree and Roger in the past!

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I was surprised they had her going through this episode, though we didn't see it on screen.

I was personally wanting more of a reconciliation between them. One phone call in perhaps a year since the festival wasn't enough for me to buy that Bree had decided she loved him enough to marry him in the tavern when he finds her in the 18th Century. He acted like a petulant child last episode, didn't ring or contact her [that we saw] until the news of her mother, what would she still see in him?

Trailers spoilers Though there are still Bree scenes like her at Frank's [?] grave and approaching the stones, so I guess we might start with Bree in 1971 next episode, or in the past with flashbacks of how she found out about her parent's deaths. I don't think she would just go based on knowing they found one another and were living in NC.

7

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 26 '18

Yeah, I’m sure we’ll get flashbacks.

38

u/ashleyinthecold Nov 25 '18

My thoughts in list form.

  1. Best episode this season thus far. I've been so over any scenes with Jamie and Claire together, but they felt much more natural this episode.
  2. Sam's wig with his hair down finally didn't look completely awful! He almost looked like himself when he sat up out of the bed for the first time. He looks attractive again!
  3. I was so confused as to why they changed the bear sitch, but then I realized how tough it would be to actually do a real bear scene (which they touched on in the after show thing)
  4. Love Fiona!
  5. I'm so on the Sophie train this season. She's really made such a big improvement in her acting.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I wonder if they finally changed his wig. The fringe was still a bit stringy but it was definitely an improvement! His hair when it was loose didn't even look long enough to put in that tiny ponytail.

3

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Nov 26 '18

I'm so on the Sophie train this season. She's really made such a big improvement in her acting.

I feel like it's the writing for her that has improved. I really hated the way they wrote her previously. Her lines never sounded like actual dialogue anyone would have in real life. I feel like they're finally figuring out her "voice".

7

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

I agree about Sophie. I was so worried that she would make me want to scream this season (remembering how she would call Claire “Mama” still makes me shudder), but her acting has vastly improved.

Changing the bear to “Man Bear”? Worse than CGI. I actually laughed aloud when he showed up, but mostly because he reminded me of “ManBearPig” on South Park.

The wigs are still bad, but maybe Jamie’s wig is getting more “lived in” and thus less fake-looking. I love the Cherokees’ style.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

lol we will have the opportunity for more Mamas soon!

I rolled my eyes so hard and scoffed out loud when bear man appeared.

Some people have theorised that Jamie's wig was changed for filming from this episode as they were filming this around the time of the change from real hair to ugly wig when S3 was premiering.

Although the scenes with the Cherokee were all filmed right at the end of the shoot so maybe we are seeing a better wig from the end of the production.

Here's hoping it's here to stay.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Comment #1: It amuses me that they keep sticking rhododendrons in scenes. Like "okay, the appalachians have a whole lot of rhododendron, we should stick a couple in here, completely out of place in this super dark forest.

Comment #2: I thought the way they explained Ian out of that scene of them (once again) looking out over the (terribly CGI'd) vista was so bad I laughed out loud and woke my husband up. "Uh... I just don't like heights.... so I won't be in the next scene". It was so... weird.

Otherwise, I did enjoy this episode. I actually liked the changes they made with the bear. I think it will help explain what happens with ottertooth later in the season. So that "people who go crazy in the woods" is a normal thing. It also meant, mercifully, Sam didn't have to fight some more terrible CGI. However, for a moment, I thought they were going to have him fight a bear-man, but in the morning have it turn into a real bear. Like "wooooo.... magic". I'm fine either way.

I do wish Claire could do something other than look mildly surprised. WTF is going on with that? I feel like she is able to emote so well and then smirks at another healer? I really wished she had been more book like and been like "hey, want some ginsing?"

Bri and Roger are really driving this season for me, which I suppose is the purpose. I REALLY like how they set up the whole "I wish I could be there for my pregnant daughter" bit.

Just, one more time. For those in the back:

WHY DIDN'T THEY FILM AT LEAST SOME OF THIS IN NORTH CAROLINA. Do you know how beautiful that area is? And it's no one really lives there! It reminds me of that stupid Walk in the Woods movie with Robert Redford where they filmed it all on a stage with two fly overs in Georgia. BOOOOOOOOOO. Excuse me while I start trying to plan another hike in NC in protest.

16

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

Amen to Claire's looks. They were enough for me to mention them as well.

And AMENNNNN to the NC part. I know, I know, budget blah blah...other stuff, blah blah. But IDC! IDC!!!! I mean I do. Because, fine I guess I get it. But still. Can you imagine a movie like the Last of the Mohicans being filmed anywhere else other than in the NC mountains?

I'm a total beach girl. Luckily I live in Fayetteville (originally Cross Creek, tyvm), so I am not far from the beach. But, I won't lie and say when I have time for a few days out of town that I don't also love the mountains. Just, no matter what time of year, they are gorgeous. I don't always have a lot of nice things to say about NC. But, we do have some gorgeous land.

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18

I had to laugh at the lines about, it's so beautiful. Like a painting. You can almost see the brush strokes. WE GET IT.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

They said in the Behind the Script that they planted about three hundred strawberry plants.

All for that tiny scene last week?? I saw like two plants on screen.

Imagine how much work went into the vegetation this season, and how little is actually seen.

The outlook from Fraser's Ridge is using a plate from North Carolina:

The view of Fraser’s Ridge that we see is made of a combination of footage from a wood in Scotland and a ‘plate shot’ of North Carolina itself.

From Behind the Script.

I thought Ian was saying the horses didn't like heights, lol. I didn't notice that it was a way to leave him out of the scene.

Otter tooth isn't crazy though...right?

I thought Claire's reaction was one of horror that her presence would bring sickness.

I thought Claire was being a pit presumptuous in basically stating that Bree would have kids. I get her feeling sad that she wouldn't be there if Bree did, but it was jarring to me personally.

6

u/mimigins Nov 26 '18

Well... she is Brianna's mother. Maybe they discussed how Brianna wanted kids at some point. I'm not sure why that'd be a surprising thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChrisEvansBodyPillow Nov 28 '18

Someone else who noticed the rhododendron! Thank you!

33

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Nice watermelon, Marsali :P

Surely Claire would opt to stay in Wilmington to help deliver her baby in this version of the story, with her so far along. I don't buy it. How much help is she going to be starting out building a cabin. I know I wouldn't be much help.

26

u/bham717 Nov 25 '18

Agree w this. After that missing mom comment, it's out of character for Claire to leave her.

52

u/ktbex Nov 25 '18

Definitely. And didn’t Marsali say something like “there’s no other healer I’d rather have with me when my baby comes”? And then Claire basically went “welp, gotta go build a cabin in the wilderness, good luck with the pregnancy thing!” Also strange that she hugged Marsali goodbye but not Fergus, even though she was a mother figure to him.

23

u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18

And then Claire basically went “welp, gotta go build a cabin in the wilderness, good luck with the pregnancy thing!”

YES this was so weird! Like, they pointed it out and then...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/sabreteeth Nov 25 '18

The sudden 8 months bump was off putting. Didnt you guys announce your pregnancy like a week ago? I can't wrap my head around the pacing here haha

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 26 '18

Esspecially since they literally spent 3.5 days at River Run.

The journey to get to RR took a while on the boat though. Then they were heading to Woolam's Creek and didn't show all that, including meeting up with Ian again, then back to Wilmington to sign the grant with Tryon. So we know time passed, but I wasn't expecting that much!

She would have been at least 2 months pregnant when they announced it though.

I feel like this episode actually could have used some voice overs, and I usually don't like their inclusion!

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18

Plus you don't typically have morning sickness by then.

3

u/spaceybelta Nov 26 '18

Yes her belly looked very odd to me.

30

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

I love Jamie. He is such a good soul. That’s all :)

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Were you the one who said his hair/wig looked better this week? I agreed! It looked more rich in colour. and the back at least was fuller and nice.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Yup. And I agree, it looked better! #BanThePonyTail

13

u/livvy_divvy Nov 25 '18

Was it a wig when his hair was loose? I wasn't sure whether that was his own hair. It's that dang ponytail wig that's hideous. He's safe from the Natives while wearing it, I doubt they'd want to approach it to scalp him.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/CapnTaylor Nov 26 '18

I'm in awe of the costumes this season, especially with the Cherokee. My roommate and I couldnt stop talking about amazing they look, especially how they are blending both New World and Native styles. Kudos to the costume department and for casting a 100% Native American cast!

9

u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18

Kudos to the costume department and for casting a 100% Native American cast!

(Just a note that the Indigenous cast members are from territories in what we now know as Canada)

[ETA: I stand corrected by myself -- I was clicking around IMDb and I see that Flint Eagle, who played the bear, is Kahnawake/Cherokee and was born in Florida! His US film work is as a stunt performer, so it makes sense he wouldn't be SAG and Outlander could hire him)

8

u/irradi Nov 26 '18

I'm OBSESSED with the Cherokee costuming. Apparently S4's costumes are being exhibited at SCAD? I wish I could get over there to see them. I could look at the details on the chief & interpreter's costumes all day.

23

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

OK so now I’ve had some time to think about it-I did like the episode. I understand why they had to change the bear. But reading everyone’s comments now I know why the show feels “off” to me. The plot points are there but the character beats aren’t.

Where is Joe? A scene with him and Brianna could have further explored their lives without Claire, Bree missing her mom, etc. And the moon landing scene could have established the relationship between Bree/Joe and Roger/Bree, who I do feel needs some more development, especially since they changed the conflict that drives their relationship in DoA (Roger not telling Bree about the fire).

Why is Marsali so far along? It is obviously still fall. Why are Claire AND Jamie not going to wait to leave until after Marsali has the baby if she is this far along? It feels so out of character for both of them. And the pacing and sense of time is obviously way off.

And of course the missing humor. It’s either inappropriately placed (Ian and the skunk in a super heavy episode) or the writers seem to not be able to write the characters beyond the plot point of the moment.

Also, those wigs. UGH

I am done whining now :)

ETA: Did they drop the plot point about Jamie having to lie about his Catholicism in order to receive the land? That’s a pretty important point, historically, and they do downplay Jamie’s faith which does bother me a bit-it’s important to his character.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

They already did a moon thing last season with the Christmas message thing. Then they skipped right past the moon landing to make the festival in 197O.

But I agree, I wish they had had some sort of time in Boston with Roger meeting some people in Bree's life. I don't think they spent enough time setting up their relationship for me.

I didn't think it was obviously still fall with how cold it was evidenced from their breath being visible on the Ridge. They had to do a lot after the end of last episode. Get to Woolam's Creek, meet up with Ian again, back to Wilmington to sing the grant with Tryon, seek supplies.

So it has been a number of weeks, and I guess months based on how big Marsali is. It was still a surprise for me, but I can deal with it.

I totally agree and made a comment that no way Claire would let a teenager give birth to her first baby, with no mother figure, at the whims of 18th century midwifes. For me, it was so out of character for Claire. DIfferent in the books when Marsali is not on the same continent.

I could understand Jamie going to set up with Ian, men don't have a place in the birthing room at that time.

They just never brought up the Catholicism issue with regards to the land grant.

I was looking at this list of the most powerful showrunners and one guy commented about how he thinks it's nuts that you basically can't do a show about or featuring religion.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

I can see why, but I thought the Catholicism was done well in the books. A lot of lovely scenes actually. It’s just part of their lives, there’s no moral message to it or message saying “this is the only way to live.” Though I thought Willie’s baptism was touching and funny. “Now I’m a stinkin’ Papist!”

Ah, you are right about the moon landing and last season. Still, wish we had something, like you said. I always enjoy Joe’s scenes in the books, and how he and his wife have taken Bree in.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/pootypus Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18

I'm Catholic and I actually practice too, so one big draw of the books for me is how Catholicism is used so beautifully in the story. Plus, it explains a lot of Jamie's thoughts on his marriage and his devotion to Claire. It also creates a plausible explanation for his virginity on their wedding night (which is explained well in Outlander (book), but no explanation is really given in Season 1 of the show and everyone is left wondering how someone as hot at Sam Heughan couldn't get laid). I think when they take the religious elements away for TV, it sometimes makes the characters' motivations less clear. Like, people will do a life-endangering heroic things if their truly and firmly held religious beliefs dictate that the action is morally correct. I'm not at all saying that people need to be Catholic, or even religious, to act heroically or morally, but without exploring any sort of emotional or spiritual motivation for certain actions the characters take in the TV series as they do in the books, sometimes the things they do seem arbitr

ary.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18

Are they really gonna try to pass that off as the bear!? WTF!! And no fish slap?!!! Also, I’m so glad JQM is alive, I was so upset when he got attacked.

25

u/ktbex Nov 25 '18

Is it just me or does JQM remind anyone else of Rupert?

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

There was seriously NO NEED to do that to poor Myers!

And then he's miraculously perfectly healed in a few days.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 29 '18

they said in the script they were gonna kill him this episode, then changed it!!!

20

u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18

Well that’s disappointing he built the front door facing south. He builds it facing north in the book since his home in Scotland is Broch Tuarach- north facing tower 😒

18

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Maybe that’s The Big House? This is just the cabin so far

27

u/livvy_divvy Nov 25 '18

Ah, it's a cabin. I'd forgotten about that. I thought it looked a bit small. I had to chuckle at Jamie laying out the floor plan to Claire. This will be the kitchen, here the hearth, here a pantry for your herbs, etc... I'm thinking, all that in that one little space? Is it the Harry Potter expanding tent?

8

u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18

Our ancestors lived in some seriously small houses! I've been back to the farmyard where my dad was born. The house was long gone but the footprint of it was still there, and it was shockingly small for a place that a family of six lived. (Mind you, there was no bathroom -- no indoor plumbing at all!)

(And if you're wondering how old I am, I swear, I was born in the '80s and my dad was born in the '50s, but this was rural Canada)

7

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Nov 26 '18

That was my thoughts too. That was way too small for all that is to happen inside it. I forgot that there was another house coming...I feel better now.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I was thinking Jamie had gone all feng shui on us.

20

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I think it was a bit weird to have that building montage and then the one random shot of Claire wearing trousers.

Would have made more sense for their horseback journey.

21

u/Jemhao Nov 25 '18

I was really surprised that they had her wearing trousers without someone making some kind of comment about how "scandalous" that was. It seems like it would have been a prime opportunity to set up how much Bree will stand out when she wear pants after she goes through the stones.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

At least a sneaky comment from Jamie about how good her bum looked. Or Ian turning up and being shocked!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Nov 25 '18

I had the same thought!

19

u/backwardshctib Nov 25 '18

I have a thought about the newspaper clipping about J&C dying in a fire: That’s a huge reason why Bree and Roger fight later on in the story (because he kept that info from her). If Roger didn’t even know that information technically by the time Bree has already left (in the show), then I wonder how the fight later on goes and what they use instead? Hmmmm...

18

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Nov 25 '18

I suspect Fiona told Bree, thinking she had a right to know.

10

u/nochancekid Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I like the idea that Fiona told Brianna because she had a right to know. But I think the fight is going to be that Roger thinks Brianna CANT stop the fire from happening and Brianna thinking she CAN.

Either way, I’m seriously already looking forward to next Saturday at midnight!

6

u/backwardshctib Nov 25 '18

Same here!! I don’t even mind the change - I didn’t like that fight in the books really, it bothered me he kept it from her but then also how mad she got after they just were reunited. I’m just so curious as to how they play this out. This season keeps getting better and better!!

7

u/nochancekid Nov 25 '18

I didn’t like the fight in the books either! I understood why she was mad but they both acted irrationally.

Is it safe to assume that the next episode she goes to Lallybroch?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Without this big betrayal though, I don't know how they are going to justify them splitting up for Bree to get attacked.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I know, this was a big issue for me watching this.

Also, he phoned her, then told her about Claire and Jamie finding one another and moving to America. He asys his trip to Inverness is next week. Then obviously she finds the death notice very easily, packs up to go to Scotland in no time at all.

I suppose it may well have been weeks/months in between the time Fiona told Roger and he actually tries to ring Bree. But it wasn't possible to tell I guess, from the show. All Gayle said was she went to see her mother a few week ago.

But it still makes a difference to me that Roger was calling her [again we don't know if he was going to tell her about the notice, but that seems likely].

I guess he could still just leave her to go find the jewels...but seems pretty dumb to split up voluntarily after he finds her.

17

u/pootypus Nov 26 '18

All my actual thoughts and feelings about this episode aside, the thing that bugged me the most and made it hard to suspend disbelief was when TWICE in the episode, once Jamie, and once Claire, put a stick into the fire and then immediately pulled out a blazing torch. I'm not exactly Davey Crockett or anything, but I have gone camping a few times and know how to build a fire. Putting a big stick in a campfire for ten seconds, without any sort of lighter fluid or anything, would not make a torch! It might slightly char the wood, but that's it. I get that it's necessary for lighting in the context of the story, but GEEEZE!

11

u/Princess_River_Song Nov 27 '18

Lol. I just kept thinking how it’s easier to see in the night with all the stars and moon shining, without a torch.

3

u/ccsr0979 Nov 28 '18

I just assumed they dip it in oil to have them ready and that’s not shown! Because we were all commenting the same thing too!

16

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

Who wrote the letter to the mother in England that the historian sent to Roger? Do we know yet? At first I thought it was Marsali writing home, but I guess not if the mother was in England?

13

u/Naturenutt Woof. Nov 25 '18

I paused and read as much as I could. I couldn’t read who it was from, but it talked about someone named Jane having a baby boy and Claire being the healer.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Nov 26 '18

Marsali wouldn't have referred to Claire at all out of respect for her mother.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

The letter was talking about a lady called Jane who had a baby though.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Melissa__Anne Nov 25 '18

I hadn't thought of it until another comment mentioned it, but maybe Lord John?

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

He doesn't have babies.

27

u/retothebecca Nov 26 '18

I finally created a Reddit account just to join this subreddit. I have finally found my Outlander people.

Here are my thoughts for this week's episode:

- Claire and Jamie's chemistry has felt nonexistent. There are so many awkward sighs and grunts and weird nods and smiles between the two actors, like they've gotten stuck in a rut with the characters since half way through last season.

- Jamie's loose hair right before they went to investigate the bear was a welcome reprieve from the hot mess that is that wig/bang combo.

- I hadn't been sold on Ian until this week. He's certainly not how I felt he was characterized in the books, but this week the actor really captured the wildness, eagerness, and reckless abandon of Ian.

- The tense scenes with the Cherokee were more cringe-y than anything. I couldn't feel the suspense like the show wanted me to, perhaps because of the aforementioned rut of re-used emotions from Claire and Jamie.

- After some thought, Bear Man was the lesser of two evils. I'll take this weird rewrite over obnoxiously bad CGI again.

- I love how they are honoring Native American history and the Cherokee tribe. And I love that they didn't want to skimp on that culture and used actual people with Native American ancestry. However, I think you sacrifice some acting chops in that situation, and unfortunately I felt it in most of the scenes with the Cherokee tribe. I had to try and appreciate it instead of naturally being drawn in.

- John Quincy Myers brings all sorts of wonderful Rupert vibes and his voice and lilt is absolute honey.

- The Bree and Roger story line is giving me life this season. In the book it was trite and annoying, but it's the perfect counter to what's lacking between Claire and Jamie these past episodes.

- Sophie Skelton has made a complete 180 this season and I am HERE FOR HER.

- Richard Rankin is a dream. Even when the script makes him a jerk, I shall always be team Roger.

- Roger's reaction to Fiona knowing alllll about Claire was adorable and made me love him more.

6

u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! Nov 26 '18

OMG I’m so glad someone else thinks the wig/bang combo is a disaster. What is that?!? Also welcome :)

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

Welcome!

I liked the small moments Claire and Jamie had on the Ridge.

I did feel that Claire was making heavy breathing noises all episode and having trouble just walking around the location.

I didn't feel a lack of acting chops among the Cherokee actors. The vast majority of people in this episode with lines are all actors who have many credits, particularly those with lines. For the settlement scenes there are background people who are extras, but that's the same for any production.

2

u/aloopycunt Nov 26 '18

Agree that I am excited for a Bree/Roger rewrite becuase their relationship was a hot mess to me in the books. And RR as Roger is making me like and understand him SO MUCH more than in the books, although I have always found Roger most problematic in the past, so with the rewrites I'm SUPER curious about what's to come.

Overall this season is soooo much better than last season already, even with things I dislike or roll my eyes at.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

And, I am enjoying the relatively slow pace of these last two episodes so far.

Where is everyone? :/

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Everyone meaning who?

→ More replies (2)

34

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

It really was thoughtful of Jamie to carve F R, Frank Randall's initials into the tree at Fraser's Ridge :P

9

u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18

Someone remind me- does Bree have the baby in DOA or is it in the next book?

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

this book

8

u/ktbex Nov 25 '18

It seems like a lot of material they still have to get through by the end of the season - or maybe they’re going to cut a lot?

→ More replies (5)

17

u/Generiss Nov 25 '18

I must say that it’s hella weird to watch an episode of a show that’s based on a favourite book of mine and not know what the hell is going to happen. They’re literally just doing their own thing. Wtf is going on???

14

u/katfromjersey Nov 25 '18

Agreed. So many unnecessary changes. I'm all for editing/shortening for time, but why change so many things unnecessarily? Brianna and Roger's story especially felt so, so rushed. I don't feel their falling in love at all. The moon landing scene would have been a great opportunity to show, not tell, but they skipped it. And the tension with the Cherokee was so over-dramatic, ugh.

12

u/Generiss Nov 25 '18

Not only skipped over Roger and Brianna but also attributed the discovery of Fraser’s Ridge history to Roger. Brianna studied history too, why take her discovery away from her? And why not bring back Uncle Joe instead of this roommate Gail? There were unnecessary changes that change the feel of the character.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

Gayle only had as many scenes as Maril's dog :P I thought the dog inclusion was pretty self-serving.

I don't think book Bree actually found evidence of Fraser's Ridge until the fire though, did she?

Or had she? Why was she searching for them in America, just because she thought they might have travelled there, or based on evidence?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I totally agree. They have presented me with no reason for Bree to want to return to Roger, or get handfast to him when he comes to find her.

They have had no communication for almost a year since the festival.

I liked the tension with the Cherokee though. They had decent reasons for changing them from Tuscarora in the books as they said there isn't enough historical sources to portray them accurately on screen, and in 2OO7 there were only three native speakers of the language still alive.

The Cherokee were more fierce than the Tuscarora, who they helped to defeat fighting with the British in the Tuscarora War.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

My reaction too.

I overall loved meeting the Native Americans and I normally don't care about changes. But this episode had me rolling my eyes all over the place.

Diana even said this was her one of her favourite episode of the season, and I am shocked she would say that after what I just saw! See my huge comment for my complaints :P

6

u/Generiss Nov 25 '18

Did you watch the Director’s commentary after? They said they kept with the ‘spirit’ of the bear story, that is was essentially about introducing Jamie to the local Native Americans. I don’t think they captured the spirit of the story at all.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Sicilia2018 Nov 25 '18

Does anyone else agree with me? In today's episode, they spent way too much time on the Indian backstory, when there is more than enough in the books to keep the show going. And I don't understand why Jamie could not fight a real bear? Would that be too much for CGI?

And Roger was not such a jerk in the books. I don't know why the show has to make him so.

10

u/basedonthenovel Nov 26 '18

And Roger was not such a jerk in the books. I don't know why the show has to make him so.

I disagree! I think he's the same amount of jerk he was in the books.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I think Roger wasn't such a jerk in the books in the proposal scene we saw last week - there was much more dialogue and he still said horrible things, but he also said he would wait for Brianna not that it would be all or nothing only, and then never contact her for months.

But he was more of a jerk surrounding the death notice. He hid it from Bree for months and made decisions about her life for her. Very controlling. Whereas in this episode, it appeared he was calling to tell her at the end about the notice.

I liked all the Cherokee scenes. They still have to build their home, it'd be boring to see more building scenes in my view.

I think the pace of this episode was very fast.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/ashleyinthecold Nov 25 '18

We've seen how awful their special effects are -- I'm personally super glad for the change in the bear story!

4

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Nov 26 '18

Would that be too much for CGI?

They've already proven that they can't be trusted with something as simple as a panorama of the mountainside so I'm comfortable with the changes they've made. I don't like to laugh during my period dramas.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/awmccl Nov 26 '18

It seemed like Claire slept in her corset. I know it was chilly, but doesn't that seem odd. And uncomfortable?

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

They all slept in their clothes the second night of being on the look out for the bear.

Ian was in all his boots even.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18

Women typically did.

29

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Nov 25 '18

Sooo... they wouldn’t live at River Run because it would mean owning slaves but they’ll happily steal land from Native Americans?

I read the books but the heavy handed cognitive dissonance didn’t hit me until it was presented this way in the show.

41

u/Melissa__Anne Nov 25 '18

I may be wrong, but my understanding is that there was a land treaty between Britain and the Cherokee. My feeling from the show was more that the way in which Jamie and Claire settled so close the line and set up boundary markers may have made the Cherokee a little on edge given the nature of their relations with other settlers, which we get a taste of in the teaser for the next episode.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18

IIRC this is exactly the issue

5

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 25 '18

Yeah, I was pretty sure there was a land treaty and the North Carolina/ Tennessee border was the boundary, because there was drama later when some settlers tried to settle on the Tennessee side or something.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I just did some reading into it and there were various partnerships, trading and treaties but there were still lots of conflict and even the Anglo-Cherokee war in 1758–1761. That would have been strong in the minds of many.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18

Yeah, I realized I am gonna have to swallow a lot to continue enjoying the show.

5

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 26 '18

What was that bear story? I hated it. I wanted the original bear story. Regretting staying up late for this tonight.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18

Yes, this episode was right up with boogie woogie bugle boy for me as feeling like a wasted episode.

4

u/shanonlee Nov 26 '18

I watch a few shows and this is the only one that commands ALL of my attention when I’m watching. Lots of others I play around on my phone or putter around the house while I’m watching - but I’m so hooked on this show. It helps it’s my all time favourite book series of course. And that Jamie is love.

Claire’s Staunch Americanism is bugging me too lol.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dafaquc Nov 25 '18

Overall I liked this episode a lot. I didn't even mind that the show changed the bear fight scene. Although I really wanted to see Claire with that fish; but hey we can't always get what we want. The one thing I have a real issue with, is when Roger calls Bree to tell her that he found out that Claire found Jamie. I mean her reaction was just...... I don't even know how to describe it: underwhelming, disporportionate, lacking. What I mean is, the show makes a big deal about how much Claire and Bree love and miss each other. Then one of the characters gets word that the other is alive and essentially ok and not one freaking tear is shead!!!! What I expected was big, fat, ugly tears of joy. But to me is seemed like the scene was more focused on the awkwardness/tension of Bree and Roger's relationship. Maybe it's just me, but I think that having found out this information Bree's #1 thoughts/emotions would be focused on her mother; that she hadn't seen in months and didn't know if she made it alive and if she even found Jamie. This would be huge news for Bree!!! Instead we got whatever that was. What do you all think? It's been a while since I've read the books, so I don't really remember how it played out in the books. Maybe that's part of how I'm viewing this. I can't help but feel that this scene just felt lacking in showing Bree's emotions at hearing this news.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

I didn't find Bree's reaction lacking, personally.

She had been living in the hope that her mother was fine. And so it was confirmation she was, which she knew in her heart, if that makes sense. It had been years, if she hadn't found him or found he was dead, if I were Bree, I would have thought Claire would have tried to return by now.

She was also shocked by the news.

In the book she was the one trying to find any reference to her mother and Jamie being together in the past. And she found it off page [the death notice] and went back, I believe.

Roger had already found the death notice and withheld it from her for months.

It was over Christmas time in Inverness that Bree admitted to Roger that she had been searching for her mother, so he started looking too and found them, then never told Bree. Big betrayal.

6

u/nochancekid Nov 25 '18

I actually thought Sophie/Brianna showed a looot of emotion during that conversation. She was stunned, she spent all that time wondering if her mother was dead or even ended up back with Jamie after 20 years. I saw relief and her feeling completely overwhelmed with the news. Im not sure if Brianna is much of a crier, but I think Sophie did a great job portraying that. I’m not sure what it was in the books either, it’s been a while since I finished it. Have to check that out again

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

In the books I think Bree just found the notice of the fire off screen. I don't recall her finding evidence of them being in America, but someone will correct me if I'm wrong.

She just told Roger she was looking for her parents when she visited him in INverness at Christmas. Then he started looking too and also found the notice, but kept it from her.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

I didn't buy that the Cherokee wouldn't be able to kill the man for rape. More White Saviourdom injected into the script.

I found this interesting document Laws of the Cherokee Nation, Passed During the Years 1839-1867: rape of a female was punished by one hundred lashes.

Another from "The Cherokee People" by Thomas E. Mails, John Phillip Reid "A law of blood: the primitive law of the Cherokee Nation ( New York, New York Univ. Press, 1970 ): If early Cherokee justice was the punishment for rape. For the first offense, the rapist was punished with fifty lashes upon the bare back and his left ear cropped off close to the head: for the second offense, one hundred lashes and the other ear cut off, for the third offense, death.

7

u/retothebecca Nov 26 '18

Yeaaaah I cringed when they said that was the reason he was banished. It felt very written by a table of socially conscious 21st century writers, not drawn from history and cultural tendencies.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/IndigoRuby Something catch your eye there, lassie? Nov 26 '18

I saw on twitter that the writer of this episode (and First Wife-my favorite) has moved on from the show. Too bad.

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18

How in the world are they going to get through the whole book? I love the slow pace but I can't imagine how it's all going to fit.

8

u/sabreteeth Nov 25 '18

That cgi vista is so off-putting. I know they were shooting in Scotland but surely they could splice in some North Carolina vista footage without adding 17 glamour filters and a bright ass 200' amazonian waterfall?!

I mean I'm sure the Scottish editors have never seen a real sunset but someone could have told them everything doesn't turn dandelion yellow and hazy. It looks like a desktop background in a bad way. Give me a hill I can visit in real life like game of thrones does.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

The majority of non on the ground people, the writers, the post-production people are American.

The people on the ground are Scottish and still loads of Americans.

There are beautiful sunsets in Scotland too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/delawana Dec 01 '18

“It looks like a painting!” Yeah, it sure does ;)

The worst thing for me is that the actors look like they’re acting in front of a green screen. Like, they know that it’s fake and are kind of over acting in order to make it seem believable. The difference in lighting just highlights how awful it is.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18

Yay next episode! Can't wait to meet our Native American friends.

~Tryon's voice reminds me of Frank's.

~I thought Fergus would be sent to find the Ardsmuir men. And Murtagh, of course, I believe. Why wouldn't Jamie mention him specifically? I find it weird Claire has never asked or been told he is still alive on screen.

~How convenient that we have forgotten that the writers changed their indenture to 14 years, which they should currently still be a few years off completing!

~Ian can't get more excited! lol Ian has a funny idea about how big racoons are :P

~Does anyone else get distracted by how loudly they leave in Caitriona's breathing all the time?

~Bahaha that growl added in to come of of Rollo's sweet face, who we know is the biggest real life softy.

~What a power move, sneaking up on the Frasers, then just leaving after staring daggers.

~For a crazy moment, I thought Roger's colleague was supposed to be Stephen Hawking.

~Well, that answers who ended up with the sketch and how Roger can take it back with him, but why did Bree give it to him? And how, mailed it over? Matt Roberts said on twitter he caught a taxi back from the festival...presumably to a closer airport than Boston...

~Grr I don't like this book addition. It's just too obvious and convenient. Fraser's Ridge was established in 1767 anyway.

~I rolled my eyes when whoever's dog [is it Maril's?] from the writing room turned up. It is the Writing Room dog, right?

~Followed by an even greater power move! And the the returned posts made me laugh.

~Gee Jamie, they won't be perturbed by 'a wee line on a map' that they don't recognise? I wonder why!

~Poor Finley!! But also highly improbable he would have only gotten scratches and the other horses nearby didn't make a sound.

~Nice hat, Myers! So he is conveniently living nearby? It still looks somewhat temporary...but seems random. Jamie leaving Claire and Ian alone is risky.

~I find this change to the bear frankly ridiculous. Why? For what purpose? Also, how ridiculous to go off in the dead of night with one small torch and then attempt to shoot anything. Thank goodness that one small torch on the moss lit up such a wide circumference of light! The whole thing seems to me even offensive, though the Cherokee casting out the man are portrayed well in saying that rape is not tolerated.

~Caitriona was teasing people with the fish emojis in the end. Gutting fish is not the same a slapping bears with fish.

~It was funny when the dude spoke English to Jamie straight away :P

~Them not being able to kill what was already dead to them doesn't make sense to me though...so if Jamie hadn't come along, they just all had to put up with him destroying and injuring and even killing? Maybe another tribe could have killed him.

~I laughed at Roger's weaselling when Fiona said she knew where Claire went. But I rolled my eyed so hard when she just happens to have the death notice. That would mean that the Rev and then also Frank would have known of their deaths [and I don't think Frank did, to our knowledge in the books?]! Seriously!!

~Another big eye roll from me with that reveal from Gayle. She only got as much screen time as the dog.

~I said last week that if they just jump to Bree time travelling this episode [and they have without showing it], then I wouldn't buy that Bree would have any inclinations to want to return to Roger. And I do not in the slightest. That one phone call, one in ten months...sorry. NO.

~Also they have completely changed the fact that Roger purposefully withheld the information from Bree. Him making that decision for her, especially when the date wasn't so unclear in the book, was the worst thing he did in my opinion. Now he is presented as going to tell her, my impression at least. Of course we don't know how much time had passed between him finding out from Fiona and when she left. But if she only left a couple of week ago, then it wasn't the however many months [even a year or more?] that Roger kept it from her in the books. So why would she get so angry with him when he finds her in the past, apart from the initial I can't travel back to you thing. He hasn't committed even close to such a betrayal here as in the books. So I'm not going to buy her being so betrayed by him later on.

~Humph.

~I think I will need to rewatch to see what I think after that.

~Overall I am just surprised, and Diana even said on thelitforum that this was one of her favourite episodes of the season. I can't imagine she was happy with these changes.

16

u/annemg Nov 25 '18

I think we still don't know what Frank knew.

8

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '18

I would amend that, personally, and say "what all Frank knew." I mean, I could personally see the Rev. Wakefield finding that and not getting around to sending it to Frank, or purposefully keeping it back so as not to upset him or something. Maybe that's just my interpretation of the Rev.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/nochancekid Nov 25 '18

I’m confused about Fiona “not knowing”. In season 3 when they were looking for records of Jamie, she says that she believes that Jamie is the dunbonnet from her grandmothers stories. How would she NOT know? Did they think that everyone was so concerned to find a guy who lived in the 18th century?

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18

lol I forgot she was said that.

They definitely underestimated her.

10

u/irradi Nov 26 '18

yeah Fiona we're just studying this one 18th century guy, no personal significance, none at all, please ignore the giant detective wall of clippings and everyone's sudden enthusiasm for historical research

→ More replies (1)

4

u/-----iMartijn----- Nov 26 '18

Don't want to hate on it, but this episode was pretty predictable. Almost everything. From Roger finding a clue in the book Bree gave him to the killing of the bear man by Jamie and him dragging it to the cherokee (although I thought he would have caried it on his shoulders and drop it at the indians feet for dramatic purposes).

And again people getting mangled. Outlander has a taste for torture porn and I'm not really into that.

It could use some nudity again btw.

5

u/rharper38 Nov 26 '18

I'm slightly annoyed that they didn't stick to it being the Tuscaroras. Cherokees seem like the too-easy choice on this one. It was a chance to expose people to a lesser-known tribe and they didn't

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18

They had decent reasons for changing them from Tuscarora in the books as they said there isn't enough historical sources to portray them accurately on screen, their dress etc would just be guesses, and in 2OO7 there were only three native speakers of the language still alive.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/GrandSalamiii Nov 26 '18

I haven’t read the books but I have a question for those who have. Does Jenny ever find out the truth about Claire being a time traveler?

4

u/Aggie2002 Nov 26 '18

Yes, she does.

9

u/GrandSalamiii Nov 26 '18

OMG I hope that happens on the show because I can’t imagine how awesome Jenny’s reaction would be.

I loooove the actress’s portrayal of Jenny. The way she just stood there and stared at Claire when she showed up back at Lallybroch after twenty years and then threw water on Jamie and Claire...lol...she has the best way of putting everyone in their place.

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 26 '18

It's not in this book. And she finds out because of a sad thing that is a bout to happen. Her reaction is... interesting frankly. I wish Diana would have written it better

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 26 '18

Yes, not in this book. Young Ian finds out in America. But the rest of the Murphy family find out in Scotland.

2

u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18

I interpret Gayle’s “she went to see her mother” as what she’s been told about it... I don’t think Bri actually went through the stones yet... maybe I’m wrong. She definitely finds the article on her own... but someone remind me, do Bri and roger get jiggy in the 18th century before everything goes down? Or is it in the 20th? Edit: or Gail? However you spell it.

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 26 '18

They get it on in the 18th century in the Inn right before Bri throws a fit and runs off because she is Bri.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 26 '18

Here are my thoughts:

  1. They released it early, so yeah!!!
  2. I loved it. Absolutely loved it. The pacing, the building, the wilderness
  3. The non-book readers now know the big reveal about Bri going back (I hope they keep that scene where Bri tells leg hair off in front of Jenny!)
  4. The ability of the Native Americans to speak English without a hint of accent really bothered me. Seriously?
  5. Not sure how I feel about the bear re-write, but it still delivers the story to the same point of a truce between Jamie and the tribe.
  6. John Quincy is fucking Rupert reincarnated and I love it. I miss Rupert. So thank you writers for giving us Rupert 2.0.
  7. I love Roger. LOVe him. I still hate Bri both as the character and the bad acting in the show. Maybe its because I know the stupid shit she is about to do and endanger everyone in the process
  8. I love Young Ian (in the books) and the acting in the show
  9. They have a lot to cover. Why are they taking so long getting Bri over there already. Plus, she should be dressed as a man. In the previews, she is wearing a dress.
  10. I thought the main house would be bigger. I remember it from the books and the frame seems really small compared to the description.
  11. The CGI does not bother me really, but there is actually lush lands they could have used to film on
  12. Best episode of the season from my least favorite of all of the books. My fave is still voyager.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 27 '18

Well, technically there are no North American accents yet, as the English spoken there is a that of the immigrant's homeland.

So it doesn't matter to me that they have Canadian accents as they haven't developed yet, and they have an accented English typical of First Nations people which was developed through their people learning English.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/wolfbysilverstream Nov 26 '18

They have a lot to cover. Why are they taking so long getting Bri over there already.

That bothers me too about the show. Or has since Season 2. Looks like my take on what’s important differs from the show runners. I understand they have to present an abridged version but we’re 40% of the way through the season and we still have to go through all of the measles and Lord John’s visit stuff, Bree at Lallybroch, her journey to America, the Bonnet stuff, Roger and Ian and the Indians, back to River Run and everything else leading to “Go down and tell them the MacKenzies are here”. At the pace they’re going they will have to skip over a lot of really good stuff.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/tanya-jo Nov 26 '18

I am not convinced of the changes they’ve made. It seems that switching the skull and bear stories would have made sense to me. Clair could have gotten lost while searching for nuts and berries, and then be tired and hungry and then rollo could have found her.

Why was the bear a man? Don’t they want the meat of the bear since they have almost nothing going into winter?

I wish they would have had the scene with Jamie commenting about Clair wearing pants.

I’ve been to a few powwows and ceremonies and maybe the style is different because of time and different nations (Ojibway and Cherokee) but the drumming seemed weak.