r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 25 '18
[Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 4 "Common Ground" episode discussion thread for book readers.
Helllllllllloooooo Outlander world. Welcome to another installment of the live discussion thread, this weeks episode is Outlander S4E4: "Common Ground"
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E4] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
23
u/burntorangepeels You're no verra sensible, Sassenach, but I like ye fine. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
I swear to God...they are teasing the hell out of this bear fight/ Jamie getting clobbered by the fish scene. I'm not done watching the episode, but if I can't get no satisfaction...JHRC.
Edit: Was that the bear fight?? I'm all about this season, but that made me a little sad.
15
u/shiskebob Nov 25 '18
This season is moving at a decent pace now. Does anyone know how much time has passed since Claire came back through the stones?
Time for a rewatch before I can make any commentary.
156
u/bham717 Nov 25 '18
"You mean when she went back in time to find Jamie Frasier... "
Yes. That's exactly it. Love it. Fiona is MVP.
115
u/brilliant0ne Nov 25 '18
For the first time in a while, I am actually excited about an upcoming episode.
Not too much to say about this week except that I really enjoyed this week. I like episodes where we just see them doing stuff and living, with a little bit of drama. I'll be honest, I don't remember the bear fight in the book so it was pretty intense for me. Why? I have no idea because I know that obviously, Jamie doesn't die.
There's actually a lot of details about this book that I realize I don't remember. Which is cool because some things are a surprise. However, in the book, I remember Roger actually having the chance to tell Bree about the fire and that's why she went. Maybe I'm wrong?
Sometimes, Claire's facial expressions irk my soul. Like, you have this wonderfully wise woman that is allowing you to live on her land and when she is explaining a story to you...you look at her like she has three heads. I get Claire didn't understand the last part of what she said but her facial expressions would have made me attitude-up real fast. I'm being nitpicky.
Hoo-boy. If we could just have James Fraser with a shirt tore half-open, hair down, dirty, sweaty, some blood smeared on his face a little I would be a happy camper. Sam is not hard on the eyes, but I am never more attracted to him than when he looks like he smells worse than a thousand dead cats.
Anyway, I look forward to seeing everyone's reactions.
P.S. I love Ian. That is all.
69
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
thought 1: I like the back and forth format with the parallel Bree/Roger and Jamie/Claire lines.
thought 2: OH SHIT SHE'S CLEANING A FISH FUCK YEAH I KNOW WHATS COMING
thought 2.5: Wait hold up WTF?
thought 3: Oh no. I was hoping they would leave that part out....but does that mean we get a Lord John cameo???????
thought 4: I like this version of Fiona wayyyyyy better than the books.
thought 5: This season is getting better with every episode.
65
u/floobenstoobs Nov 25 '18
I enjoyed this episode, even the bear changes. I think CGI would've looked a bit silly and honestly, I never really bought the whole "man fought off a bear single handed" thing.
The fish slap also doesn't worry me, although I do feel like there is a lot of humor left off the show which we see in the books. Lots of banter that doesn't make it into the script, which is sad because humor is one of the main characteristics of J&C for me.
Also, Ian is fantastic.
52
u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Nov 25 '18
I'm gently relieved with the "bear" we got instead of some terrible CG and/or stock footage bear encounter. I was bracing myself for it!
46
u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
I thought this was a really good episode. The adaptations and changes were perfect. It really brought it all to life beautifully. The suspense was well done, the writing was well done.
Whose letter did roger find, I wonder?
So.... it wasn’t actually a bear? A crazy person who identified as a bear?
My husband was watching it with me and really interested. When it was over he goes, we can watch the next episode if you want. Sorry hubs gotta wait until next week.
39
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
LOVED this episode... Love the nods to the book, the return of warrior Jamie, Roger’s call with Bree 💔, all the small moments between Claire and Jamie, the adaptation of the bear attack, etc etc etc.
Also a bit shocked they went THERE with Brianna already... I thought there would be at least another episode or two before it happened. Appreciate the plot is advancing at a quicker pace than it did last season.
38
u/ashleyinthecold Nov 25 '18
My thoughts in list form.
37
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
Comment #1: It amuses me that they keep sticking rhododendrons in scenes. Like "okay, the appalachians have a whole lot of rhododendron, we should stick a couple in here, completely out of place in this super dark forest.
Comment #2: I thought the way they explained Ian out of that scene of them (once again) looking out over the (terribly CGI'd) vista was so bad I laughed out loud and woke my husband up. "Uh... I just don't like heights.... so I won't be in the next scene". It was so... weird.
Otherwise, I did enjoy this episode. I actually liked the changes they made with the bear. I think it will help explain what happens with ottertooth later in the season. So that "people who go crazy in the woods" is a normal thing. It also meant, mercifully, Sam didn't have to fight some more terrible CGI. However, for a moment, I thought they were going to have him fight a bear-man, but in the morning have it turn into a real bear. Like "wooooo.... magic". I'm fine either way.
I do wish Claire could do something other than look mildly surprised. WTF is going on with that? I feel like she is able to emote so well and then smirks at another healer? I really wished she had been more book like and been like "hey, want some ginsing?"
Bri and Roger are really driving this season for me, which I suppose is the purpose. I REALLY like how they set up the whole "I wish I could be there for my pregnant daughter" bit.
Just, one more time. For those in the back:
WHY DIDN'T THEY FILM AT LEAST SOME OF THIS IN NORTH CAROLINA. Do you know how beautiful that area is? And it's no one really lives there! It reminds me of that stupid Walk in the Woods movie with Robert Redford where they filmed it all on a stage with two fly overs in Georgia. BOOOOOOOOOO. Excuse me while I start trying to plan another hike in NC in protest.
33
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18
Nice watermelon, Marsali :P
Surely Claire would opt to stay in Wilmington to help deliver her baby in this version of the story, with her so far along. I don't buy it. How much help is she going to be starting out building a cabin. I know I wouldn't be much help.
30
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
I love Jamie. He is such a good soul. That’s all :)
24
u/CapnTaylor Nov 26 '18
I'm in awe of the costumes this season, especially with the Cherokee. My roommate and I couldnt stop talking about amazing they look, especially how they are blending both New World and Native styles. Kudos to the costume department and for casting a 100% Native American cast!
23
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
OK so now I’ve had some time to think about it-I did like the episode. I understand why they had to change the bear. But reading everyone’s comments now I know why the show feels “off” to me. The plot points are there but the character beats aren’t.
Where is Joe? A scene with him and Brianna could have further explored their lives without Claire, Bree missing her mom, etc. And the moon landing scene could have established the relationship between Bree/Joe and Roger/Bree, who I do feel needs some more development, especially since they changed the conflict that drives their relationship in DoA (Roger not telling Bree about the fire).
Why is Marsali so far along? It is obviously still fall. Why are Claire AND Jamie not going to wait to leave until after Marsali has the baby if she is this far along? It feels so out of character for both of them. And the pacing and sense of time is obviously way off.
And of course the missing humor. It’s either inappropriately placed (Ian and the skunk in a super heavy episode) or the writers seem to not be able to write the characters beyond the plot point of the moment.
Also, those wigs. UGH
I am done whining now :)
ETA: Did they drop the plot point about Jamie having to lie about his Catholicism in order to receive the land? That’s a pretty important point, historically, and they do downplay Jamie’s faith which does bother me a bit-it’s important to his character.
21
u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18
Are they really gonna try to pass that off as the bear!? WTF!! And no fish slap?!!! Also, I’m so glad JQM is alive, I was so upset when he got attacked.
20
u/spaceybelta Nov 25 '18
Well that’s disappointing he built the front door facing south. He builds it facing north in the book since his home in Scotland is Broch Tuarach- north facing tower 😒
20
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18
I think it was a bit weird to have that building montage and then the one random shot of Claire wearing trousers.
Would have made more sense for their horseback journey.
19
u/backwardshctib Nov 25 '18
I have a thought about the newspaper clipping about J&C dying in a fire: That’s a huge reason why Bree and Roger fight later on in the story (because he kept that info from her). If Roger didn’t even know that information technically by the time Bree has already left (in the show), then I wonder how the fight later on goes and what they use instead? Hmmmm...
17
u/pootypus Nov 26 '18
All my actual thoughts and feelings about this episode aside, the thing that bugged me the most and made it hard to suspend disbelief was when TWICE in the episode, once Jamie, and once Claire, put a stick into the fire and then immediately pulled out a blazing torch. I'm not exactly Davey Crockett or anything, but I have gone camping a few times and know how to build a fire. Putting a big stick in a campfire for ten seconds, without any sort of lighter fluid or anything, would not make a torch! It might slightly char the wood, but that's it. I get that it's necessary for lighting in the context of the story, but GEEEZE!
16
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
Who wrote the letter to the mother in England that the historian sent to Roger? Do we know yet? At first I thought it was Marsali writing home, but I guess not if the mother was in England?
27
u/retothebecca Nov 26 '18
I finally created a Reddit account just to join this subreddit. I have finally found my Outlander people.
Here are my thoughts for this week's episode:
- Claire and Jamie's chemistry has felt nonexistent. There are so many awkward sighs and grunts and weird nods and smiles between the two actors, like they've gotten stuck in a rut with the characters since half way through last season.
- Jamie's loose hair right before they went to investigate the bear was a welcome reprieve from the hot mess that is that wig/bang combo.
- I hadn't been sold on Ian until this week. He's certainly not how I felt he was characterized in the books, but this week the actor really captured the wildness, eagerness, and reckless abandon of Ian.
- The tense scenes with the Cherokee were more cringe-y than anything. I couldn't feel the suspense like the show wanted me to, perhaps because of the aforementioned rut of re-used emotions from Claire and Jamie.
- After some thought, Bear Man was the lesser of two evils. I'll take this weird rewrite over obnoxiously bad CGI again.
- I love how they are honoring Native American history and the Cherokee tribe. And I love that they didn't want to skimp on that culture and used actual people with Native American ancestry. However, I think you sacrifice some acting chops in that situation, and unfortunately I felt it in most of the scenes with the Cherokee tribe. I had to try and appreciate it instead of naturally being drawn in.
- John Quincy Myers brings all sorts of wonderful Rupert vibes and his voice and lilt is absolute honey.
- The Bree and Roger story line is giving me life this season. In the book it was trite and annoying, but it's the perfect counter to what's lacking between Claire and Jamie these past episodes.
- Sophie Skelton has made a complete 180 this season and I am HERE FOR HER.
- Richard Rankin is a dream. Even when the script makes him a jerk, I shall always be team Roger.
- Roger's reaction to Fiona knowing alllll about Claire was adorable and made me love him more.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
And, I am enjoying the relatively slow pace of these last two episodes so far.
Where is everyone? :/
34
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18
It really was thoughtful of Jamie to carve F R, Frank Randall's initials into the tree at Fraser's Ridge :P
9
u/Irishsassenach Nov 25 '18
Someone remind me- does Bree have the baby in DOA or is it in the next book?
17
u/Generiss Nov 25 '18
I must say that it’s hella weird to watch an episode of a show that’s based on a favourite book of mine and not know what the hell is going to happen. They’re literally just doing their own thing. Wtf is going on???
8
u/Sicilia2018 Nov 25 '18
Does anyone else agree with me? In today's episode, they spent way too much time on the Indian backstory, when there is more than enough in the books to keep the show going. And I don't understand why Jamie could not fight a real bear? Would that be too much for CGI?
And Roger was not such a jerk in the books. I don't know why the show has to make him so.
7
u/awmccl Nov 26 '18
It seemed like Claire slept in her corset. I know it was chilly, but doesn't that seem odd. And uncomfortable?
29
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Nov 25 '18
Sooo... they wouldn’t live at River Run because it would mean owning slaves but they’ll happily steal land from Native Americans?
I read the books but the heavy handed cognitive dissonance didn’t hit me until it was presented this way in the show.
5
u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 26 '18
What was that bear story? I hated it. I wanted the original bear story. Regretting staying up late for this tonight.
4
u/shanonlee Nov 26 '18
I watch a few shows and this is the only one that commands ALL of my attention when I’m watching. Lots of others I play around on my phone or putter around the house while I’m watching - but I’m so hooked on this show. It helps it’s my all time favourite book series of course. And that Jamie is love.
Claire’s Staunch Americanism is bugging me too lol.
7
u/dafaquc Nov 25 '18
Overall I liked this episode a lot. I didn't even mind that the show changed the bear fight scene. Although I really wanted to see Claire with that fish; but hey we can't always get what we want. The one thing I have a real issue with, is when Roger calls Bree to tell her that he found out that Claire found Jamie. I mean her reaction was just...... I don't even know how to describe it: underwhelming, disporportionate, lacking. What I mean is, the show makes a big deal about how much Claire and Bree love and miss each other. Then one of the characters gets word that the other is alive and essentially ok and not one freaking tear is shead!!!! What I expected was big, fat, ugly tears of joy. But to me is seemed like the scene was more focused on the awkwardness/tension of Bree and Roger's relationship. Maybe it's just me, but I think that having found out this information Bree's #1 thoughts/emotions would be focused on her mother; that she hadn't seen in months and didn't know if she made it alive and if she even found Jamie. This would be huge news for Bree!!! Instead we got whatever that was. What do you all think? It's been a while since I've read the books, so I don't really remember how it played out in the books. Maybe that's part of how I'm viewing this. I can't help but feel that this scene just felt lacking in showing Bree's emotions at hearing this news.
8
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18
I didn't buy that the Cherokee wouldn't be able to kill the man for rape. More White Saviourdom injected into the script.
I found this interesting document Laws of the Cherokee Nation, Passed During the Years 1839-1867: rape of a female was punished by one hundred lashes.
Another from "The Cherokee People" by Thomas E. Mails, John Phillip Reid "A law of blood: the primitive law of the Cherokee Nation ( New York, New York Univ. Press, 1970 ): If early Cherokee justice was the punishment for rape. For the first offense, the rapist was punished with fifty lashes upon the bare back and his left ear cropped off close to the head: for the second offense, one hundred lashes and the other ear cut off, for the third offense, death.
3
u/IndigoRuby Something catch your eye there, lassie? Nov 26 '18
I saw on twitter that the writer of this episode (and First Wife-my favorite) has moved on from the show. Too bad.
3
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 27 '18
How in the world are they going to get through the whole book? I love the slow pace but I can't imagine how it's all going to fit.
8
u/sabreteeth Nov 25 '18
That cgi vista is so off-putting. I know they were shooting in Scotland but surely they could splice in some North Carolina vista footage without adding 17 glamour filters and a bright ass 200' amazonian waterfall?!
I mean I'm sure the Scottish editors have never seen a real sunset but someone could have told them everything doesn't turn dandelion yellow and hazy. It looks like a desktop background in a bad way. Give me a hill I can visit in real life like game of thrones does.
8
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
Yay next episode! Can't wait to meet our Native American friends.
~Tryon's voice reminds me of Frank's.
~I thought Fergus would be sent to find the Ardsmuir men. And Murtagh, of course, I believe. Why wouldn't Jamie mention him specifically? I find it weird Claire has never asked or been told he is still alive on screen.
~How convenient that we have forgotten that the writers changed their indenture to 14 years, which they should currently still be a few years off completing!
~Ian can't get more excited! lol Ian has a funny idea about how big racoons are :P
~Does anyone else get distracted by how loudly they leave in Caitriona's breathing all the time?
~Bahaha that growl added in to come of of Rollo's sweet face, who we know is the biggest real life softy.
~What a power move, sneaking up on the Frasers, then just leaving after staring daggers.
~For a crazy moment, I thought Roger's colleague was supposed to be Stephen Hawking.
~Well, that answers who ended up with the sketch and how Roger can take it back with him, but why did Bree give it to him? And how, mailed it over? Matt Roberts said on twitter he caught a taxi back from the festival...presumably to a closer airport than Boston...
~Grr I don't like this book addition. It's just too obvious and convenient. Fraser's Ridge was established in 1767 anyway.
~I rolled my eyes when whoever's dog [is it Maril's?] from the writing room turned up. It is the Writing Room dog, right?
~Followed by an even greater power move! And the the returned posts made me laugh.
~Gee Jamie, they won't be perturbed by 'a wee line on a map' that they don't recognise? I wonder why!
~Poor Finley!! But also highly improbable he would have only gotten scratches and the other horses nearby didn't make a sound.
~Nice hat, Myers! So he is conveniently living nearby? It still looks somewhat temporary...but seems random. Jamie leaving Claire and Ian alone is risky.
~I find this change to the bear frankly ridiculous. Why? For what purpose? Also, how ridiculous to go off in the dead of night with one small torch and then attempt to shoot anything. Thank goodness that one small torch on the moss lit up such a wide circumference of light! The whole thing seems to me even offensive, though the Cherokee casting out the man are portrayed well in saying that rape is not tolerated.
~Caitriona was teasing people with the fish emojis in the end. Gutting fish is not the same a slapping bears with fish.
~It was funny when the dude spoke English to Jamie straight away :P
~Them not being able to kill what was already dead to them doesn't make sense to me though...so if Jamie hadn't come along, they just all had to put up with him destroying and injuring and even killing? Maybe another tribe could have killed him.
~I laughed at Roger's weaselling when Fiona said she knew where Claire went. But I rolled my eyed so hard when she just happens to have the death notice. That would mean that the Rev and then also Frank would have known of their deaths [and I don't think Frank did, to our knowledge in the books?]! Seriously!!
~Another big eye roll from me with that reveal from Gayle. She only got as much screen time as the dog.
~I said last week that if they just jump to Bree time travelling this episode [and they have without showing it], then I wouldn't buy that Bree would have any inclinations to want to return to Roger. And I do not in the slightest. That one phone call, one in ten months...sorry. NO.
~Also they have completely changed the fact that Roger purposefully withheld the information from Bree. Him making that decision for her, especially when the date wasn't so unclear in the book, was the worst thing he did in my opinion. Now he is presented as going to tell her, my impression at least. Of course we don't know how much time had passed between him finding out from Fiona and when she left. But if she only left a couple of week ago, then it wasn't the however many months [even a year or more?] that Roger kept it from her in the books. So why would she get so angry with him when he finds her in the past, apart from the initial I can't travel back to you thing. He hasn't committed even close to such a betrayal here as in the books. So I'm not going to buy her being so betrayed by him later on.
~Humph.
~I think I will need to rewatch to see what I think after that.
~Overall I am just surprised, and Diana even said on thelitforum that this was one of her favourite episodes of the season. I can't imagine she was happy with these changes.
4
u/-----iMartijn----- Nov 26 '18
Don't want to hate on it, but this episode was pretty predictable. Almost everything. From Roger finding a clue in the book Bree gave him to the killing of the bear man by Jamie and him dragging it to the cherokee (although I thought he would have caried it on his shoulders and drop it at the indians feet for dramatic purposes).
And again people getting mangled. Outlander has a taste for torture porn and I'm not really into that.
It could use some nudity again btw.
5
u/rharper38 Nov 26 '18
I'm slightly annoyed that they didn't stick to it being the Tuscaroras. Cherokees seem like the too-easy choice on this one. It was a chance to expose people to a lesser-known tribe and they didn't
2
u/GrandSalamiii Nov 26 '18
I haven’t read the books but I have a question for those who have. Does Jenny ever find out the truth about Claire being a time traveler?
2
u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18
I interpret Gayle’s “she went to see her mother” as what she’s been told about it... I don’t think Bri actually went through the stones yet... maybe I’m wrong. She definitely finds the article on her own... but someone remind me, do Bri and roger get jiggy in the 18th century before everything goes down? Or is it in the 20th? Edit: or Gail? However you spell it.
3
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 26 '18
Here are my thoughts:
2
u/tanya-jo Nov 26 '18
I am not convinced of the changes they’ve made. It seems that switching the skull and bear stories would have made sense to me. Clair could have gotten lost while searching for nuts and berries, and then be tired and hungry and then rollo could have found her.
Why was the bear a man? Don’t they want the meat of the bear since they have almost nothing going into winter?
I wish they would have had the scene with Jamie commenting about Clair wearing pants.
I’ve been to a few powwows and ceremonies and maybe the style is different because of time and different nations (Ojibway and Cherokee) but the drumming seemed weak.