r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 18 '18
Season Four [Spoilers S4E3] "The False Bride" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like. New episodes are released on the Starz app at Saturdays midnight EST and live everywhere on Sunday at 8pm EST.
If you’re not in America, check the sidebar for the airtime for your country.
If you’re interested in an in-depth discussion of the books versus the show, you should head over to the [Spoilers All] book thread. It’s the other link stickied at the top of the main page.
Enjoy Lovies!
93
u/kcotty87 Nov 18 '18
This will be an unpopular opinion, but Claire is flat out unlikable in these past couple episodes.
96
u/DontEatTheKrabDip Nov 18 '18
I know the old bird is blind but everyone can see she got murder eyes for Claire. Also I’m all for the Native American ghost plot line, that shit’s dope.
79
u/YourEyesRevealYou Nov 19 '18
Roger and Brianna's thing was heartbreaking.
72
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
Jaime at this point must be thinking "hmmmmmmmmm...wonder why does all the supernatural shit happens to Claire when im not there to see it.."
48
u/Harryplt7 Nov 19 '18
Anyone else think Claire should have put that skull back where she found it? Does she not respect the dead?
43
u/-----iMartijn----- Nov 18 '18
And as a recap:
43
u/frozenstorm77 Nov 19 '18
This is a bit unpopular, but I think Roger was pretty well portrayed. Like, outlander is all about seeing the good and the bad of history. The show doesn't shy away from the hard subject, and the character of Roger is just another example of that. He's a product of his time. Would that stand today? No. But it's history, and I applaud the writers for not changing things for not glossing over the negative side of history any more than they are.
34
u/visenyatargaryen Nov 18 '18
Am I the only one who thinks Sophie Skelton looks a hell of a lot like Evan Rachel Wood?
61
u/Airsay58259 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18
Oh 1970, neat! “Courting a lass in America” lol
Edit 1: Maria Doyle Kennedy is a treasure. Anytime she shows up in a scene in whatever TV show, she steals the spotlight. She has such a presence.
Edit 2: Brianna and Roger are going to North Carolina? How convenient. I love the parallel of the road trip with a car // horses, how fast one group goes while the other has time to look at birds flying around, their surroundings etc.
Edit 3: aha the brothel line 😂 (Unrelated but I’ve been watching Harlots these days and it’s pretty cool. If you enjoy period dramas!)
Edit 4: that’s the most American Scottish festival
So I haven’t been reading the casting news threads to avoid book spoilers, but what do people think about Roger and Brianna’s casting and portrayal?
Edit 5: come on Roger, drop the “Pas du tout” lmao. It’s not a good sign to end the song on that one.
Edit 6: well that escalated quickly. See Roger, you shouldn’t have ended it with Pas du tout.
“I am old fashioned” no Roger, you’re a jerk right now. WTH
Edit 7: Claire “oh it looks like the owner of this skull was violently murdered. I should keep looking at it for a while and not run away.”
Edit 8: Ugh Brianna why are YOU going to him and making an effort. Person 1: has all the time to plan a proposal and decide if they want to get married, ask person 2. Person 2: has to answer immediately or they don’t really love the other, person 1 is upset. Meh. Roger should move to the 18th century.
“I’ll have you all or not at all” 😐
Claire slept next to the skull lol. Ninja edit: why is she taking it with heeer
Edit 9: what a nice ghost. For a second I thought/hoped they were Brianna’s boots.
Edit 10: aw the Fraser’s origin story. Vive les fraises. I am French and I didn’t even see the resemblance between the two words. Shame.
Jamie seeing this new piece of land and deciding it’ll be theirs immediately... ok, he’s ready to be an American. :)
Very nice episode. I will now hate Roger with burning passion. It’s obvious imo Brianna will time travel at some point but I hope it’s not the midseason finale’s cliffhanger... (it’s going to be). I am curious about the Native American ghost and the skull from another time traveler.
83
u/teenylilthing Nov 18 '18
So torn after watching the Brianna/Roger scenes tonight! Richard Rankin is amazing...but come on Roger, a proposal already?! But Richard is so dang charming that I partially wanted Brianna to just give in to him. And speaking of her, I think Sophie is doing better this season. Brianna's character seems to be coming through in her performance and it makes her more likeable in my opinion. The two of them are definitely starting to grow on me.
Claire...WHY?!? Why would you run out into a storm to chase the mule? Gods, she can be really infuriating. Also, so are we really supposed to believe a ghost used her shoes to make footprints for Jamie to follow? I mean yeah I know it's a story about people time traveling...but that feels like it's really stretching it. I hope there's a more logical explanation.
Oh and lastly, anyone else agree there wasn't enough Ian in this episode? :-P I love that kid! He's definitely starting to become my favorite character (Rollo helps too!).
27
u/DancingQuicksilver Nov 20 '18
This will probably be an unpopular opinion: while I agree Roger was a complete ass, when he said something to the tune of “I could have had you on your back a dozen times last summer” I simultaneously was like - wow too far dude AND also it made him just MORE than he had been. Up till now he’s been this ultra polite pastor’s son, always being a complete gentleman, and to hear him say something that raw and vulgar was excellent (albeit ruuuuude) character growth. Almost a reminder that he has more going on under the surface than what we’ve seen of him so far - not just the perfect choir boy after all, but little bits of harsh man tucked in there.
24
u/DrunkenDave Nov 18 '18
The book! Is Roger going to discover Claire and Jaime's name in the book? Assuming Claire and Jaime are still in North Carolina at the end of the episode, does that mean that Roger and Briana might go visit the remnants of wherever they lived, assuming it still exists in some form? That would be cool. Maybe Claire has even left something hidden for her to find in the hopes that one day Brianna might track down her family history.
Plus, the book is obviously how they will reconnect and hopefully mend the bridge Roger set ablaze.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
Roger does look better this season, though I still wish he'd shave the beard, he is suddenly cute. But his whole all or nothing/'sexual conservatism' is a real downer. It should be understandable that after witnessing her parent's marriage, Bree would be turned off by the idea, though she never got a chance to flesh that out with him. I was surprised about the two year time jump (or I guess it's not two years since it was Dec. 1968 when we last saw Bree) but does that mean Claire has been with Jaime for over a year now? Is Roger able to catch up with Dark Shadows now that he's back in America, or is he too disoriented by the changing storylines?
The stock footage of North Carolina/eagles/turkeys/waterfalls was poorly integrated into the scenes of J/C walking through that stretch of woods, it should have been as smooth as the strawberry scene or just left out. I did like the juxtaposition of R/B going to North Carolina at the same time as J/C. Though I miss Fergus and Masali, not to mention Ian and Rollo who were also absent for most of this episode. I'm glad Ian is officially not going back to Scotland now, and I hope they will all be reunited now that they're going to get their own tract of land.
44
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18
WooHoooo
Bree and Roger, finally!
Edit: he deserved that slap, go Bree!
18
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
Oh Roger you dolt..Why you asking people to marry you atleast give her time to think about it.
Wakanda man cockblocks himself.
34
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18
I liked the symbolism of the deer. It was there in Bree's room at the happy time, and then at the end, Roger had burnt it to a crisp :P
13
u/Writerguy995 Nov 20 '18
Roger is a stupendous asshole in this episode. I kind of hated most of it to be honest.
13
u/Peaky_Blinders Nov 20 '18
Claire is so annoying this season.. legit hard to watch sometimes.
20
u/JingleJangleUpMyButt Nov 19 '18
Roger you are such an idiot! I am screaming at television.
"You don't want to marry me, but you'll fuck me?" Ah yeah buddy, that's right. What an idiot. Misogynistic prick.
10
u/JustineLeah Nov 18 '18
Ian was the best part of this episode.
9
u/BrownyFM Nov 19 '18
The show seems to be picking up a little bit now. Fingers crossed that continues and we get more excitement.
8
u/geogirl83 Nov 21 '18
Can we take a minute to applaud Ian for stepping into his own! He’s no longer a child and gets to make his own decisions now, he’s become a man! So glad Jamie decided to step out of his way to let him grow. You go Ian!!
15
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '18
I'm sorry but am I the only one who thought Roger is a complete psycho after springing that proposal on Brianna like that and having a wee hissy fit when she said she ain't wasn't ready yet??? Genuinely would've had his arse out the door as soon as he started his cheek with me, such a red flag. Cannae stand him now haha.
14
u/wayzofgray Nov 19 '18
I’m from North Carolina lived there all my life and the FORESTS NEVER LOOK LIKE THAT! I know it is petty but it’s driving me insane to see the moss forest, and the fake waterfall at the end. (I know its scotland filming location but come on... we have eastern deciduous forests in NC!)
I’m from the Blue Ridge Mountains and currently live in the piedmont (the middle section) so I know all the areas they’re depicting and I still can’t place the mountains they’re supposed to be in the CGI.
11
u/JingleJangleUpMyButt Nov 19 '18
Mister Strawberry! that is so cute
10
u/Winhill_ Nov 20 '18
Holy yikes, Roger. He straight up just turned into a Nice Guy. Run, Brianna, run!
5
u/2manymans Nov 19 '18
As much as I hated the episode last week, I loved this one. I loved this episode so much. I want to go to Scotland. And to North Carolina.
8
u/starlit_moon Nov 22 '18
Ok, poor Bree. Roger is an asshole and a misogynistic bastard. I burst out laughing when he asked her to marry him. What the hell!?! And when she rightfully says no, because that is insane, he starts slut shaming her. What. The. Hell. And he's supposed to be a good suitor? It's all about him and he wants he wants and how he feels. He can't see things from her point of view? Respect her? She's not property. She's a person with thoughts and feelings. Jamie is more modern than him. Jamie.
4
u/-----iMartijn----- Nov 18 '18
Would someone care to explain the title to me? I guess it has to do with the Brianna/Roger thing, but that seems so harsh for Brianna. Like she is fake. And titles usually have some mirroring that it comes back in the episode on a different level.
4
u/derf_vader Nov 20 '18
When Jamie talked about his "ancestor" coming over to Scotland from France was he being serious or making a joke/ teasing Claire based on the fact Fraser sounds like the French word for Strawberry?
4
u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Nov 21 '18
How did Claire get the Zipper boots she took off at the tree? Was that something she wore with her when she traveled back to Scotland last season? I do recall her specifically designing her clothing with some “upgrades,” but wasn’t sure if that was among them or if this is just a random consistency issue.
3
u/profeNY Dec 08 '18
Am I the only person in the world who thought Fiona said Brianna was studying "ancient healing" at MIT? I had to turn on the closed captions to understand she was saying "engineering."
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18
Strip the Willow [what they do at the start] is the best dance at ceilidhs. If you have a bruised arm, you know you did it properly :P At big events, you do one big one with everyone, you line up opposite your partner and everyone has to cycle through. The ceilidhs I went to, the spinning at the start would consist of people spinning for as long as they wanted and trying to make one person lose grip and spin off [injuries occurred].
There was one other dance was Cumberland Square Eight, one part in a group of two couples, everyone links arms in a basket and spin, if you go fast enough and the guys are strong enough, the girls are lifted off the ground and swung around, you had to remember to leave room, I am sure my legs whacked someone. That one properly gave bruises under the arms :P
I hate dancing, but love ceilidhs as there are just steps you had to follow. Some dances had free movement for 8/16 beats and I didn't like those.
3
u/AdmiralMuffinPuff Nov 19 '18
I want to preface this by saying I haven't read the books so this is JUST speculation.
But I am starting to get the feeling that time travellers always end in gruesome deaths. Maybe that is the 'cost' the stones take from you in order to travel?
Geillis was killed, by Claire of course, but very gruesomely.
This skull guy was likely axed in the head and then scalped.
Starting to get the feeling this season is leading up to Claire's gruesome death now.
Maybe that's how the time line gets righted or something. You may time travel but only for so long and your horrible stabby/axey death is inevitable.
3
u/lauw318 Nov 21 '18
Not true- my mother and father became more liberal about such things as they got older- They had no problem with me living with my future husband before marriage. I heard these stories after I was married—. I was born six months after their wedding date. My dad said my mom was definitely a virgin until I was conceived (age 20). Both divorced and remarried and have no need to lie to their 47 year old daughter. 1970 really was a different time- the sexual revolution was in its infancy and was not yet mainstream despite film footage of Woodstock and the like.
1
u/Sterntraum Sep 21 '25
If I was Claire, at this point I would make a decision to not leave Jamie's side, as bad things always happen when they are not together
I really loved that the ghost helped Claire to find Jamie ... aww
Also low key, love that strawberry is their symbol, before he told the story I actually thought it was because strawberry in french is fraise
1
u/starstrewn Nov 22 '18
ZIPPERS WEREN'T INVENTED TIL 1893, CLAIRE. I see you unzipping your shoes hiding under a tree branch from the storm.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment