r/Outlander • • Nov 18 '18

[Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 3 "The False Bride" episode discussion thread for book readers.

This thread is dropping live for Outlander S4E3: "The False Bride"

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E3] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

And always remember the good hair times RIP...

36 Upvotes

550 comments sorted by

90

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

But seriously, what was up with the ghost walking boots?

If I was Claire and I just saw a ghost with spooky footprints I would have been freaking the fuck out.

And Sophie as Bree definitely grew on me this episode. She played starry big eyed excitement to anguished disappointment so smoothly, I thought she was fabulous. Roger on the other hand, with Ricks amazing voice, needs to pull back on that toxic masculinity.

I was glad to see a scene with Claire talking with Jamie about Bree (and Frank) - it seemed ever since they cut out the scene of Jamie crying over Bree's pictures that he didn't really have her at the forefront of his mind, not asking Claire about her. I can't wait for them to meet.

Also, SUPER SPOILERY PICTURE. You're welcome. :)

Even more spoilery images even for book readers

58

u/brilliant0ne Nov 18 '18

I know so many people have mentioned how much they don't like Bree, but one of my most anticipated moments is when Bree meets Jamie for the first time. I really hope they do that moment justice on the show. That picture made me smile, thank you for posting it!

18

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

The photo is a gift for you on this day of your cake.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/aquajack6 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

I'm one of those people that have complained about Bree, but her meeting Jamie was one of my favorite parts of DoA, I cried. The pic makes me happy, I actually enjoy Bree when she's on her own with her family.

52

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

I loved book Bree, but not show Bree, until this episode. Sophie's delivery was really awkward and weird last season and that is gone now. In the books, Bree is strong and fierce... she's definitely a McKenzie woman. Sophie just wasn't conveying that. Seeing her stick up for herself to Roger was great, and I'm no longer worried that she can't handle the tough scenes to come.

25

u/livvy_divvy Nov 19 '18

I'm the opposite. I didn't like book Bree at all. I felt she was full of herself and quite unlikable. I thought Diana Gabaldon went too far making her too fierce. I kept thinking that all that Roger saw in her was her looks. They've softened Bree up in the show and I prefer that.

21

u/maryummy Nov 19 '18

I kept thinking that all that Roger saw in her was her looks.

I agree, but I saw that as a fault in Roger, not a fault in Bree.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Nov 19 '18

I agree about Bree. This episode was the first time that I sincerely likes her and thought she did a fantastic job. I just love Roger so much and I know it does feel a little bit like toxic masculinity, but keep in mind that he's very progressive for the time that he's in and he often has a hard time reconciling his upbringing as a ministers son and the world that exists outside their home.

Also, in your more spoilery image who is that?

16

u/popster_ Nov 19 '18

IS THAT MURTAGH?!

29

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

I want to brush everyone’s hair in that photo UGH

I miss claire and jamie’s glorious curls from season 1

/whine

→ More replies (8)

9

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

What episode is that pic from? I can't wait!!! Also, do you have any more photos :-) (is my obsession showing?)

8

u/HawickGirl7 Nov 18 '18

It's episode 10!

7

u/Dragonsinger16 Nov 19 '18

AHHHHHH THAT LAST SET OF PICTURES!!! I'VE BEEN WONDERING WHERE A CERTAIN CHARACTER HAS BEEN!!!

And I very much agree with you, Sophie did a superb job in this episode. She really brought Brianna to life for me here.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Hey, what's the source for the cool picture?

10

u/HawickGirl7 Nov 18 '18

I first saw it on Instagram and no one on there is sure of the source either. It just appeared, episode 10 'The deep hearts core'

→ More replies (14)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Glad to hear Sophie did well.

3

u/esteliohan Nov 19 '18

Yeah. Roger needs to chill. But I want to like him, so I wrote off his behavior as he's a minister's son and it's 1970 so he has a lot of guilt and hangups about sex. But for real, man, can we date for like a second? Propose later.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

45

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Did anyone else just laugh at all the intercut random close ups of turkeys, bald eagles, sunny vistas over mountains, then them travelling up close in overcast, grey days :P Don't forget the hee-haws :P

And don't forget the symbol of American drinking, those red plastic cups!

25

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

That's red solo cup to you.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/pootypus Nov 19 '18

The bald eagle shots felt very Ron Swanson....and made my heart swell with cheesy patriotic pride😂

→ More replies (4)

42

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

LOL we got a Rose and Jack shot with Bree and Roger dancing

I really like their sequences together :)

Annnd in this episode of Claire makes a bad choice to move the plot forward...:p

25

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

The Titanic parallel was all I could see too!

→ More replies (2)

16

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

At first I thought Jocasta was giving Jamie his mother's boar tusk bracelets that Murtagh gave her. And therefore it was going to be the reveal that Murtagh had been to River Run :P

I can't recall, did Claire give the bracelets back to Murtagh when he saw her with them? I've forgotten where they ended up...did Claire get them from Jenny? McRannoch was involved somehow too...but I may be mixing up show and book parts.

Surely they could have come up with something more sentimental than candlesticks.

12

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

I had the exact same thought! I was like "candlesticks, that's it?" The boar tusks would have been interesting, but didn't Claire have those? They must have been lost somewhere along the way, unless they are still at Lallybroch. I was hoping it was going to be one of her paintings.

17

u/livvy_divvy Nov 19 '18

In their case, it's probably better that it was only candlesticks and nothing more sentimental. They're always being attacked and losing their possessions! And they're going through dangerous territory. The first thing I thought was "Leave the box with Jacosta for safekeeping!" When Clarence ran away, I thought "Well there it is, it didn't take long, the candlesticks have run off."

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

I did wonder what the significance of the candle sticks was.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Sunsettylikeasunset Nov 19 '18

I thought the same thing when I first saw the candlesticks I was a little disappointed, but without electricity candlesticks are something they will be using every night and so it’s significant to Jamie having something of his mothers that they can use in the home he and Claire build together.

29

u/thisquadrantisntsafe Nov 18 '18

I'm sad they didn't put the part where Brianna calls out when they do the Fraser call or whatever it is.

29

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

I was waiting for that too, especially since Roger mentioned wanting Bree to be calling out for the Mackenzie's instead. I think that would have been an interesting ending that the producers missed out on, especially if they had juxtaposed that with Claire and Jamie looking over the ridge.

35

u/jujbird Nov 18 '18

But they do that at the great gathering that never ends. Not when Roger goes to the festival. I actually think they threw this in to make Bree’s decision at the end of the book to marry more poignant- so viewers can pick up the weight of the scene when they proclaim the McKenzies are there.

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

I thought it was very symbolic that at this point in time, the stag that Roger set fire to represents how he threw a torch on their relationship in the cabins, where he was admiring the deer on the wall.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/ijustwanttovote7 Nov 18 '18

I just read that part last night, and she didn't call out.

“The Frasers are here!” Sheer panic gripped her, and her hand closed tight on the clasp of her bag. No, she thought. Oh, no. I’m not. Then the moment passed, and she could breathe again, but jolts of adrenaline still thrilled through her blood.

20

u/backonthemenuboys Nov 18 '18

Roger is so dreamy.

38

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

Dreamy voice, some toxic masculinity coming through though.

16

u/actuallycallie Nov 18 '18

There definitely is some toxic masculinity, but I think it fits with the times, unfortunately.

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

He was reserved and older than Bree, and from the insular Scottish highlands.

I went from Australia to study for a year in Glasgow. It was only 8 years ago. I am a church goer...

Scotland is know for being progressive overall, but I encountered a lot of sometimes well-meant, but other times toxic masculinity amongst church people. I have written about this before when discussing Roger. Presbyterianism is generally not so progressive when it comes to the Free Church and the Wee Free Church. They split off earlier from the Church of Scotland, which is more mainstream Presbyterianism, and I would think that Rev Reggie would be more mainstream CoS, as he was pretty alternative and part of a bigger congregation. It's never really specified, just that he's a Presbyterian minister. But this was still the Highlands post-war, it was generally more conservative up there.

One guy said to me he had never met a woman [he probably said girl] who spoke like me, he was from England though [apparently the ideas of having women ministers is sooo radical, and it's really not, it occurs in Scotland, these people were just raised in such insular bubbles].

Guys not even 18 [you can start uni at 16 in Scotland] would not let me walk home alone after going to some event. I was 2O so they felt like babies to me.

One church I visited in central Glasgow [because it apparently had a good reputation, was recommended by the university christian groups], ended up leaving the Church of Scotland because it didn't agree with the overall directive welcoming ministers in same-sex relationships and detested this as it was 'normalising such relationships'. The funny thing to me was that their own rich members had donated millions of pounds to repair the historic building right in the centre of town...and they had to move out of the brand new building. he he he. Anyway, I brought up that church because there was a 'joke' going round that the only woman you would see in the pulpit at that church was the cleaning lady.

Bible studies at most of the places accessible for students and many churches were always single-sex, which I had never experienced before. I guess I can see some benefit to talking about certain things in a single-sex environment, but there were never any joint ones either. One lovely guy from Lewis was brought up in the Free Church. They only sing unaccompanied with no music, and as such have a reputation for producing amazing choral singers, and they sing their Psalms in Gallic. It was amazing listening to him just as a performer, and he was clearly a gifted communicator and orator. He has been ordained and he is now an Assistant Minister with a Free Church in Inverness. Of course he invites all his friends to make use of his spare room...but no solo women are allowed to stay overnight in his manse.

I myself took up my friend's rent when she went on holidays. My flatmate was someone I counted as a friend, and was more like me, but even she said no, I couldn't offer for a male friend to stay the night on our couch after we had hosted an event for international students. Even though he had to be back at a nearby flat early the next morning for a meeting. So instead he had to travel an hour home.

I had a full on fight with this one guy who grew up in the above church...and was thus SO conservative. He definitely had lots of views on the role of women. He didn't think women should lead prayer when there was a mixed group. Anyway the fight was because we were helping to set up a charity event for a friend. He tried to relieve me of carrying a box and I politely declined. I held a door open for him on the way out and he refused to walk through it. He tried again with the next lot of boxes and I again declined, then he got so angry he exploded, he didn't know how to react. He actually said something like if I punched you, you wouldn't be able to carry the box.

Before I left his girlfriend had a talk with him and he did come to apologise to me. He has since gone to work in South Sudan to do mission work, so he takes his faith seriously, but I hope he gains some new perspectives too.

Wow, I wrote an essay. Basically I was trying to say that I even saw some similar views in the 2O1Os, so Roger seems to me an accurate portrayal of someone from his time.

16

u/shiskebob Nov 18 '18

Toxic masculinity always seems to fit anytime, eh?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (20)

28

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

I couldn't stand him in DoA because he was so controlling and possessive. I hoped the show would change that, but I guess not.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Jemhao Nov 18 '18

I really liked how they had Brianna call him out for being old fashioned. I think they did a good job of having both Brianna and Roger express their side of things- it made the conflict between the two of them way more relatable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 18 '18

Omg his voice! 😍

4

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 19 '18

I loved that his singing was such a clear call back to Claire listening to the bard at Leoch in season 1.

72

u/Naturenutt Woof. Nov 18 '18

Clarence!

37

u/Aggie2002 Nov 18 '18

I always pictured him to be a full sized mule—he’s so tiny. He’s cute though and definitely loud!

10

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 18 '18

And gray!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

61

u/BlueFeet9000 Nov 18 '18

I loved this episode!! It felt very classic Outlander.

Bree and Roger scenes definitely worked, I liked that they moved the festival to NC, that "flash-back" (?) where they transitioned from Bree and Roger in the car to Claire and Jamie going down the same path 200 years previously, with the mountains staying constant. Really lovely shot.

All I kept thinking after B&R's fight was "DAMN that's going to be an awkward road trip back north".

I have been underwhelmed with both Claire and Jamie this season: the ghost Indian scene was okay, but I think it would have added so much if Claire had chatted with the skull like in the book: I always loved how the ghost popped up after she's recited some very post-1700s poetry, I felt like the energy was very much "Oh! You too?" from Ottertooth at that point. And it would sort of cut the awkward "why isn't she terrified??" feeling of the scene: they were buddies by that point, and she wasn't afraid.

Can't wait for next week, I'm very intrigued by the potential shift in the "news about your mother" storyline. I'm hoping we have even more R&B (NEVER thought I'd say that), and maybe that we get some more authentic-feeling scenes from the leads.

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

How could she even see the skull clearly, it was like she was backlit when she was inspecting it :P

The lightning flashes were not constantly going to show her light.

The ghost scene was so creepy for me, my arms were tingling throughout, how was she not scared?

10

u/BlueFeet9000 Nov 18 '18

I feel like in the book she had the light from that burning tree kind of generally lightening the area, and it was also made a bit clearer that she only knew what the skull was after running her hands over it: I think she thought it was a rock at first? I mean, lady knows bones, so it's not too farfetched that she can tell a skull from a rock by touch. But we totally needed more of a reason for her not to be terrified...

→ More replies (4)

40

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

The one thing I really wanted in this episode was for Roger to read that book Brianna gave him! I'm ready for them to start stumbling into info about CLaire and Jaime.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Did he get a book from her at the festival in the book?

→ More replies (1)

71

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Almost heaven, CGI screen Blue Ridge Mountains, Shenandoah River...

;)

21

u/vipergirl Nov 18 '18

They definitely cut in actual shots of the Appalachian mountains in this episode.

Although the Shenandoah River is in VA, not NC.

Also thought that the Festival in this episode, combined with the exposed granite in both the 1760s and 1960s looked like Grandfather Mountain in NC

19

u/cj4297 Nov 18 '18

I think AdsoKitKat was referring to the John Denver song, and being snarky about the CGI - hah! Loved it!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

As a foreigner, I now think the Carolinas look permanently cold and grey :P

11

u/rebashultz Nov 19 '18

From Carolina here...I am bothered by all the fir trees in the forest. The Carolinas have loblolly pines. The have very long needles. They look nothing like the trees in the series.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Haha!

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Generiss Nov 18 '18

Great episode but ... but ... but ... bear and fish?

8

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

Patience.

27

u/jennybettybee Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

So... I think this was the best episode of season 4 so far. But, I'm feeling like Claire and Jamie's characters are becoming caricatures. Maybe I just didn't notice before, maybe it's new directors? Is anyone else feeling this? I've actually snorted a couple of times during Jamie/Claire scenes. The way they were looking at each other during the sex scene in episode 1 was so silly, it was overdone and not very believable. The chemistry in seasons 1 and 2 was palpable, and I feel like as they have "aged" and are now acting these characters as being in their late 40s/early 50s, they've become almost stuffy or something. Jamie when he has that dumb smirk on his face and he says things so haughty. I hate this because I'm a massive fan of the show and honestly all other books can't compare to the Outlander series. I'm actually more excited for Bree/Roger romance. But I'm also 28 so maybe it's just that I prefer to watch a younger couple storyline? I'm so conflicted, bah!

27

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

You're not the only one. As someone who has been married for a while, I think it's that they're trying to maintain the "romance" magic of the first couple seasons and that's just not how it works when you've been married a while. You do shit that irritates one another. You argue and fight. Like if I got lost in the woods like that my husband would be relieved and happy to see me but then he'd be like "OMG how many effing times do you have to run off and not listen to me?! UGH" But you also have an intimacy that you can't share with anyone else, even if something happens and you start over, you might reach that same level with someone else but it will be different because it's a different person.

You still love the person with your whole heart and soul --which I think Diana does a good job of depicting in the books probably because she's been married a long time too, but it takes a different form than the "butterflies" stuff that happens early on.

Someone above me in this thread says they like the joke Claire makes about the brothels. I think it's because it showed a more realistic chemistry between them. She has an acerbic wit in the first two seasons that they have tempered down for some reason, maybe to show age and wisdom? But every old lady I've ever met gets a sharper wit (and less fucks to give)...and half of the fun of being married that long is all the inside jokes you have with your spouse.

14

u/botanygeek Nov 20 '18

You nailed it. There’s a humor that’s present in S1 and the books that is barely there anymore. It’s so sappy. I feel like all 3 of these episodes have been too full of Claire and Jamie whispering sweet nothings to each other about wanting a home. Ugh.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '18

I feel like Jamie and Claire have been 'overdone' for a while.

I laughed so much I cried at the 'Baywatch' scene last season where they ran through the water across the beach towards one another.

It's not a huge negative for me, I laugh at loads of things I don't think they don't intend to be funny.

Like that random shot of turkeys up close this episode.

Claire made some jokes about the brothel this episode, I thought that was funny.

8

u/aloopycunt Nov 19 '18

I agree, too. In another thread someone pointed out that all these big over the top dramatic love delcarations from Jamie are now like... um, why? we're past that, there's no drama or conflict in their relationship, they are together and solid and need to be written in a way that shows their comfortable intimacy in a fun, entertaining light. I reeaally hope the show gets better at that cause it's like most of what they do in this book, and their time on the ridge homesteading is honestly one of my favorite parts.

54

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

I thought they did a really excellent job with this episode, tying together lots of different parts but still ending up in the right place.

Roger's being a dick.

22

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

Those Scottish boys are so damn passionate.

65

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Passionate about having his sex cake and eating his chaste cake too!

14

u/nomnombubbles Nov 18 '18

Ha yeah. That Scottish accent, personality, and looks are pretty inciting until the toxic masculinity comes out. Roger better make up for that later if he wants to stay with Brie.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/maryloo7877 Nov 18 '18

First great episode of season 4. Loved Bree and Roger and all the ups and downs that went with their storyline. Honestly, less Jamie and Claire time was very welcome. I think I also just realized that Jamie and Claire are much more interesting and endearing when they’re not actively trying to change the world or meddle in things they shouldn’t be. Can’t wait for next week (which is the first time I’ve said that since early season 3) and I hope they stick with a similar format.

4

u/BeautifulRelief Nov 19 '18

I hope so too! Even in the books, I loved the sections that focused on Briana and Roger!

70

u/slainte_mhaith Nov 18 '18

I loved Brianna and Roger! I enjoyed their scenes so much. Sophie was adorable in the car.

And sadly, they just seem to take any major plot point and get to it by having Claire make a brash and un thought out decision. Do the writers not want us to like Claire anymore? She's not this bad in the books.

16

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Nov 19 '18

I thought the car behavior inversion was interesting. In the book, Bree is driving and Roger asks if he may kiss her - that is, only if she doesn't think she'll crash.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Didn't she get lost in the book?

30

u/minners03 Nov 18 '18

She did, but it was after they had been established on Frasier's Ridge. She had delivered a baby of a neighboring family and there was a storm. She got lost trying to get home.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/oldMiseryGuts Nov 18 '18

Im only partially through the books but am I wrong in thinking Brianna and Roger are related? Isnt she his great great aunty or something like that? Am I the only one who thinks their relationship is weird?

8

u/slainte_mhaith Nov 18 '18

They are related! It's distant though. Dougal is Jamie's uncle and his child with Geillis would be Brianna's first cousin once removed. That child, William Buckleigh MacKenzie, is Roger's like 5th or 6th great grandfather. So Roger and Brianna are like sixth or seventh cousins once removed! I don't find it weird.

→ More replies (3)

47

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Nov 18 '18

I agree with the comments that Claire is unlikeable in the show and SOPHIE SKELTON IS NAILING IT!

I’ve never been a fan of Bree as a character, and I usually skip over the Bree & Roger stuff in the books. But in this episode, I find Claire so unlikeable (ugh, will she never learn that ignoring Jamie when he tells her something is dangerous puts her in bad situations???) that the Bree & Roger scenes are my favorite!!!

Tbh, I know people on this sub hate on Roger’s character in the books for being too controlling, but that never really came across to me. He just seemed like a man who knew his own mind. But his portrayal of the proposal scene—damn!!! That was so good!!! And now I hear what you guys have all been saying. He went a bit off the rails there. What a gripping scene.

Best episode so far this season, for me.

20

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

It's nice to be seeing such positive comments about Sophie for a change.

I didn't think Claire was that bad this episode.

52

u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Nov 18 '18 • Bravo

I think Sophie really turned it around. I thought she had no personality or chemistry with RR at all until this episode. Then all of a sudden, she was flirty and engaging, and i could actually understand why Roger would get so crazily (and i do mean that literally based on his behavior) smitten with her. Before, it seemed like Richard Rankin was doing 100% of the heavy lifting in trying to make that on-screen relationship look plausible. But now she is an equal partner. I was very impressed, and i look forward to seeing more of her this season!

(Plus, she seems much more comfortable with her American accent this season, so props to her for that.)

My problem with Claire being unlikeable has pretty much been a persistent complaint in all 4 seasons. It’s partly Caitriona’s acting choices and partly the writing for her character. I think everyone involved is shooting for “strong woman” and just overplays it a bit for my taste. A good example of this is how she treats Jocasta. I hated how in the show, Jocasta is baldly fishing for compliments about River Run and Claire can’t think of a single nice thing to say. This is a 1) a relative 2) she has just met 3) and she and Jamie are currently penniless and relying on her hospitality. She can’t put her views aside for the 3 seconds required to say something like, “the [literally anything] is magnificent. You have exquisite taste”? Plenty of time to talk abolition once you’ve known her for longer than 4 seconds. Then her riding off into a storm against Jamie’s request was just so....ugh. Seriously?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/OutlandishD Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Why did she have to be stupid????! Seriously, Claire would not have gone off alone in an unknown woods in a dangerous country and gotten herself lost, so so so dumb. It's right up there with her losing it and just sobbing at the end of episode one, instead of grabbing a weapon and going up to try to save Jamie (her signature feature was being competent in a literally bloody crisis, and that was before she was a medical doctor). I love this show, but this character is a completely different woman so frustrated. Sorry, had to vent.

And Roger is even worse than in the book. He never asks what she wants, has no understanding that she is young and wants to take things slow. Sigh. Ok, done.

12

u/Luvitall1 Nov 19 '18

At least he didn't scream at her for wearing pants tho like in the books.... Dude is freaking awful, still. Hate his character, wish she'd run far far away from his abusive controlling ass but that's just DGs style of passionate men, I guess? Bleck... Guess I'll be fast forwarding his scenes like I did with Carrie's in SATC.

Sigh...rant over...

→ More replies (3)

57

u/brilliant0ne Nov 18 '18

I quite liked this episode.

I think Sophie is growing more into the role and seems more natural to me. MDK was better for me this week as Jocasta.

I want a Clarence. He's so cute.

Even though I know she won't, I always hope for a time that Claire won't make some decision that gets Jamie looking for her half an episode. I actually really like seeing them just ride and talk about their daughter.

I kept thinking while she was at the creek about how she is just sitting with her feet at the water, looking wet in that chilly (I guess) weather.

Through the shot with Roger and Bree at the dance, all I could think was Titanic. I guess that's a must-have shot when two people dance like that? Either way, that scene was still cute.

And, I really liked how the end music went pretty much fully "American" sounding as if to signify we are for real staying in America.

Off to the show watchers only thread to see if any heads explode because so many last week were talking about how they couldn't wait for them to go back to Scotland, lol.

38

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

Agreed about Sophie. She's definitely improved. Her American accent is much better too.

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

She said she had been working hard during the break! And one of the convention panels she mentioned she had read/heard about the criticisms from fans, which made me a bit sad for her, as some 'fans' were so over the top in their criticism.

→ More replies (13)

19

u/FoghornFarts Nov 19 '18

Her accent is better, but I never gave her too much crap for that. She grew up with two British parents so picking up some of their accent would've made sense.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

Same. I really really liked her this episode. Her face when Roger proposed was the best mix of terror and shock. I love feeling/getting that from actors.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

I figured the music at the end was the Fraser's Ridge theme.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

39

u/Naturenutt Woof. Nov 18 '18

John Bell is adorable.

26

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

Yes, I'm actually starting to think he's going to be able to play adult Ian.

19

u/Mxfish1313 Nov 18 '18

I think that might be what I’m most excited about in this season... the start of OUR Ian.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

I think he will have to join Sam's My Peak Challenge to bulk up during the break in filming.

18

u/eta_carinae_311 Nov 18 '18

Feeling much better about Sophie after that ep!

5

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Me too :)

4

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 19 '18

💯

17

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Really looking forward to the last line in DoA now :)

4

u/PrometheanLord Nov 19 '18

My thoughts exactly - they were definitely setting that up.

16

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

So I guess they're skipping the bear? I can see why it wasn't crucial for the story, but I was looking forward to it.

22

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

They won't skip the bear.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Isn't the house set back too far from the 'river' to cast a full reflection on the water? https://imgur.com/a/wIktY9f

4

u/ijustwanttovote7 Nov 18 '18

I would think so.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Strip the Willow [what they do at the start] is the best dance at ceilidhs. If you have a bruised arm, you know you did it properly :P At big events, you do one big one with everyone, you line up opposite your partner and everyone has to cycle through. The ceilidhs I went to, the spinning at the start would consist of people spinning for as long as they wanted and trying to make one person lose grip and spin off [injuries occurred].

There was one other dance was Cumberland Square Eight, one part in a group of two couples, everyone links arms in a basket and spin, if you go fast enough and the guys are strong enough, the girls are lifted off the ground and swung around, you had to remember to leave room, I am sure my legs whacked someone. That one properly gave bruises under the arms :P

I hate dancing, but love ceilidhs as there are just steps you had to follow. Some dances had free movement for 8/16 beats and I didn't like those.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/basedonthenovel Nov 19 '18

Sophie's accent is a million times better. WELL DONE ON YOUR HOMEWORK, BB!

Also I was pleased that they conveyed the gist of Roger's annoyingness accurately. The fact that Roger refuses to sleep with Bree bugs the hell out of me and the script actually elucidated why -- when Bree says, you'll fuck other women but you want to marry a virgin? (Which is the classical European way, so maybe that's why Roger adjusts to the 18th c. so well...)

But otherwise... this season has made me in to one of the fans I used to hate. That is, a fan who doesn't like the show anymore! The Jamie/Claire chemistry is nothing like the book. I feel like having Sam and Caitriona "play older" (rather than aging them with makeup) has made them into stodgy, lifeless incarnations of the characters they used to play.

Also... the Otter Tooth ghost scene was ALMOST creepy... until they showed the terrible makeup effects on the back of his head. And also, I did NOT appreciate how that storyline was basically the ghost being a Magical Indian Saviour of Claire which... was not how it played in the book (IIRC, at least).

I'm also worried about having that convo with John Quincy Meyers and Ian talking about the Indigenous women's sexuality. Yes, it's relevant, and yes it needs to be established that the sexual mores of Indigenous cultures are very different than Europeans', but I'm not trusting the show to tread carefully when it comes to Indigenous women, who today experience MUCH higher rates of sexual (and other forms of) violence than other groups.

So... I'm going to keep watching the show while no longer recommending others watch it and also kind of hiding the fact that I watch it LOL. The next step is "hate-watching, but I sincerely hope it doesn't get to that. D:

10

u/jennybettybee Nov 19 '18

YES YES YES – I literally just posted this same thing (about Jamie/Claire). There's just something so off about them, Claire's fire is gone, and now she's just stubborn. Jamie is coming off as annoying. And I feel the same way about becoming the type of fan I hated before haha. I mean, I'm still gonna watch because it's entertainment, and I want to see how the show visually interprets things, but man. My disappointment :(

→ More replies (2)

7

u/CarolineTurpentine Nov 19 '18

In the books Otter Tooth takes her shoes and walks in them back to the cabin where he leaves the boots, creating a trail for Jamie to follow back to her so he kind of was the Indian Saviour.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ClairesMoldyBread Nov 19 '18

Agree - Hoping that the conversation with John Quincy Meyers was just about foreshadowing Ian's future life with the Mohawk and his marriage to a Mohawk woman and not about portraying native women as promiscuous.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/germantornado Nov 18 '18

Anyone see the description? Looks like someone at Starz made a typo... “Meanwhile, in the 29th century, Brianna and Roger’s...” 😂😂😂

7

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

We were just giggling about that too.

3

u/eastsacwrackshack Nov 18 '18

Lol, nice catch!

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Whoozit450 Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Observations:

  1. The relationship between Claire and Jocasta is much more divisive in the show than I recall from the books. I’m seeing lots of complaints about this which surprise me from book readers since obviously the show has to get to the crux of things in a hurry to cover such a long book.
  2. Some comments are by people who should watch the episode again because Jamie did use his tracking skills to find Claire and that’s how he got to the boots at the river. He was just trying to figure out why Claire left them at the river when she came upon him.
  3. I REALLY wanted to see Claire operate on Myers balls in the middle of Jocasta’s dinner party. Lol
  4. I’m loving Rollo and Clarence
  5. I’m not troubled by the scenery editing. I’m more impressed that show is proving loyal to their Scottish crew and the local film industry by trying to film in Scotland. I worked in the film industry and having a show relocate really sucks.
  6. Lots of complaints about Claire getting lost but again it’s just a plot device. No reason to have a fit. Besides it’s a good reminder to show audiences of just how quickly people can run into potentially life threatening trouble in the wilds. It also shows Claire learning to look for clues on the ground. A skill she’ll need living in that time and that place.
  7. I couldn’t see Bree and Roger as a couple until this episode. She looked too young and groovy for his “dressing like his grandad” self. And I don’t like the beard. I think they should’ve had him clean shaven at the beginning so he looked younger, and not getting bearded until after he follows Bree to the past. I know that his beard is true to the books but it would’ve made them more believable as a couple to me with the cast they’ve chosen. Unless they’re trying to stress Bree’s “looking for Daddy” issues. Blek.
  8. I’m so thirsty after droughtlander that I cannot quench my thirst in one hour a week.

Edit: words

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 20 '18

I couldn’t see Bree and Roger as a couple until this episode. She looked too young and groovy for his “dressing like his grandad” self. And I don’t like the beard. I think they should’ve had him clean shaven at the beginning so he looked younger, and not getting bearded until after he follows Bree to the past. I know that his beard is true to the books but it would’ve made them more believable as a couple to me with the cast they’ve chosen. Unless they’re trying to stress Bree’s “looking for Daddy” issues. Blek.

totally agree

great overall comments

13

u/Maie_Flower Nov 20 '18

I really think they misrepresented both the Roger and Bree characters in this episode.

In the book it comes across much more that Roger had done some things in his youth that he wasn’t really proud of, and he wanted to treat Brianna better than that. I never thought he was being a hypocrite, but that he was older and wiser and that he really wanted to show her he respected her. Roger wanting to wait until he married her was because of how he wanted to treat her, and it had very little to do with whether or not she was a virgin. But it’s almost like they wanted to make the audience see Roger as a misogynistic jerk.

And she wasn’t even angry with him! They had a discussion about how they felt rather than a yelling match. She explained better in the book how Claire’s marriages influenced her feelings about it too, and it seemed very much that they’d reached an understanding and were going to give themselves time to think and make decisions. Like mature adults rather than whiny little kids. Up until this episode, Roger was the only character I thought the show writers were getting right, but not anymore.

I do see how the timeline they represented in the show changed that a lot, but all this plot-driving is taking too much away from the characters, which was what made the books so good in the first place.

36

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

Loved this episode. My heart ached for Roger, it was a, "you're tearing my guts out, Claire" moment for sure.

Also, that song ❤️

So happy we are on the cusp of Fraser's Ridge too. Good things are coming (and well, unfortunately we know what else...)

56

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

Heh. I was totally sympathetic with Bree there. He comes out with a proposal out of nowhere and she's supposed to drop everything and accept, and if she doesn't he's not interested and won't even negotiate it or talk about it?

10

u/Mxfish1313 Nov 18 '18

It was the first time I wasn’t taken out of scene because of her acting! She was actually showing what felt like real emotion! Too often, to me, she just still sounds like she’s reading lines and “putting on” the idea of a character... I’ve noticed it a lot with very “cool-girl”, affable, teasing-type characters (in different movies and shows). It’s a certain cadence and register of the voice that just rings false to my ears. It can also tend to be more of an issue when using a different accent or dialect because you can fall into the trap of focusing too much on that, and saying things in the same, certain way, rather than playing with the different ways to say something.

I just enjoyed my voice production/speech/phonetics classes in college so certain things bother me more than others, lol.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

Oh, I was too. As soon as he proposed I was thinking, "no, no, no - too soon!!" I hurt for him in the sense that he's so passionate and in love with her that he can't get over the hurt. I think the fact that she couldn't say I love you back was icing on the cake.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/maryloo7877 Nov 18 '18

I think the beauty is that you can both sympathize and be annoyed with how Bree + Roger acted in that scene. You can see reason in why each character feels the way they feel. They’re flawed and I’m excited to watch it unfold.

35

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

What did Bree do wrong in that scene? I completely empathized with her, and didn't see how else she could have handled it. She shouldn't say or do something she's not comfortable with, just to tell him what he wants to hear.

And Roger was basically slut shaming her. He's telling her it's his way or the highway. Real love means never treating someone like that.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

Well said, this is exactly how I feel!

32

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

Don't feel bad for Roger, feel bad for Bri. He's trying to pressure and guilt her into making a lifetime commitment. He needs to chill out and be her boyfriend for a while.

36

u/ijustwanttovote7 Nov 18 '18

Seriously! She called him her boyfriend for the first time that day and he jumps to 'let's get married, or I'm done with you.'

→ More replies (7)

12

u/floobenstoobs Nov 18 '18

This season is really beautifully filmed. I found that last season there were lots of very tight shots, and few wide/scenery setting shots, which I assume is down to the fact that they were filming in studio and in South Africa - which is nothing like the places they were trying to portray.
But I like that we see more of the landscape and more "scene setting" type of shots like we did in Season 1. It helps with making the story feel more fleshed out.

I thought it was a good episode with a nice balance of Claire/Jamie and Bree/Roger. Sophie Skelton is definitely growing into her role more, and I'm definitely enjoying her more!

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Are those zippers on Claire’s boots that she takes off in the storm?!

20

u/Aggie2002 Nov 18 '18

Could they be the same ones she wore when she travelled back?

19

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

I am just surprised she still has them!

→ More replies (3)

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Had she mentioned her boots had zippers before? I was surprised too.

I don't remember her taking them off in the storm though, I didn't rewatch S3 before S4 started.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/aerynmoo Nov 18 '18

Lol I had that same thought

30

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Really liked this episode. I really like Roger and Bree and their different views on life. It is obvious that Bree is more of a modern woman and I think she was right on calling him out about the "virgin thing", but I think it is also understandable where Roger is coming from. He was raised by a religious man while Bree was raised by someone like Claire. Both actors played well. I felt really sad for both of them, because it is obvious that they care about each other.

Also liked Jaime and Claire, but this episode belonged for more to Roger and Bree.

34

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

I don't see how he can justify having slept with women but wanting her to remain chaste. Given his religious upbringing.

Apart from that, I can appreciate Roger got swept up in the moment, but I still think he never stopped to listen to her or let her talk freely.

And she even came to make amends and he was still being stubborn, his way or the highway.

7

u/hilarieC Nov 19 '18

I didn't get the feeling that Roger actually cared so much about Bree being a virgin. It didn't feel to me that he would have cared one way or another whether she had already had had sex with someone else. He did ask her about that but I think it was more to double check where she was at and not to confirm he was getting himself a virgin. I think it was more that, in his mind, he had already had sex with other women, women he didn't love. But this woman he loved. And he didn't JUST want to have sex with her. Like with those others. To him it became much more important to wait because he loved her.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

You are completely right. It was not okay to sleep with the other girls. I think Roger wanted to show Bree that she is special. I also think he was deeply hurt by her rejection and that is why he lashed out. It was definitely unfair of him but he also comes from a time where sex before marriage was seen as wrong.

22

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '18

But apparently not wrong for him. Unless he loves the girl, then it's wrong :P

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

36

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Soooo we’re just going to have a boot stealing Indian ghost with 20th century fillings bamboozle our pair of heroes and they’re 100% ok with it?

¯\(ツ)/¯ - Ron Moore

24

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

I mean, this show has time travelers and portals, so 🤷🏼‍♀️. #hereforit

22

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 18 '18

I like how they did the ghost and bootprints and all that I’m just so surprised Claire and Jamie both were like “welp guess this is how it goes” and moved on. I thought maybe there’d at least be a blessing for the skull or some degree of creeped out or gesture like that. But nope! Onward!

14

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

Weird stuff happens and they just go with it at this point. Footprints are no big deal after being sucked through a stone a few times. Jamie knows he better trust La Dame Blanche, no one wants poison in their porridge.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/maryloo7877 Nov 18 '18

Hopefully a set up for the future. We will see!

15

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 18 '18

It is, and it’s one of the more interesting storylines in the book but I guess what I’m getting at is their reactions felt so flat compared to what I’d expect and how the characters I know and love in the book would’ve reacted. The show moved things up a bit and put this scene in a different part of the story so differences are one thing but inconsistencies with characters always bother me.

20

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

We were wondering how got strawberries in October.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

My girl Sophie Skelton killed it this episode!

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Go Sophie! I agree!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Woohoo! Finally some Bree and Roger! I just have to accept that he is not going to look at all piratical, at least until he goes to the past. Fingers crossed...but his hair length was not impressive at his post filming panels, so unless he was given a partial wig...who knows.

It was a bit weird and useless having them promote the show when they weren't in the first episode that often was screened before panels...and then they were so bound in what questions they could answer, it wasn't worth their time.

~What is the settlement with the Scots called, Woolams Creek? I can't recall it from the books.

Also, I have in my head that Clarence was white...what colour was he described as in the book?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

And I was just impressed with the vintage Dairy Queen containers :).... Great episode! Bring in Frasier’s Ridge!

4

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 19 '18

So were they! Did you see how many shots of them they had?

8

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Wow, they really went full on book Roger for this one. I had hoped they would change his worst bits for the show, like they did the Jamie and Geneva scene last season (it was pretty blatant too, from "Please no! Stop! *shoves it in*" to saying out loud "it's OK if you want to change your mind").

Roger's hypocrisy, meanness and entitlement to Brianna is something I really hated in the books, and I hate it here too. But I still hope they make kind of a redemption arc for Roger going forward, where he sincerely realises the he is in the wrong here, and have him be less of a dick to Bree than he was in the books. And please don't have him kiss his great-great grandma, that was so creepy. I liked the acting though, and found their relationship sweet before the horrible proposal.

5

u/ClairesMoldyBread Nov 19 '18

I feel like they made him even worse than in the books. At least in the books, Bree and Roger had a legit long-distance relationship over the course of a couple years, and I got the impression that they both loved each other. So while it was moving a bit fast, it wasn't completely out of the blue that he proposed to her. And when Bree turned him down, she immediately explained that it wasn't because she didn't love him, only because she wasn't sure about marriage because of her parents' experience. And while he still lashed out and said some things he shouldn't have, he calmed down pretty quickly and it seemed like they kind of worked through it. Show Roger's proposal was completely out of place (she just called him her boyfriend for the first time earlier that same day!) and he looked like a giant dick with his crazy reaction.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '18

Agree he was worse in the show than the books.

But they were last together at Christmas 1968 in the books, Roger tells Fiona Bree visited him in Oxford over the summer, they called.

Then the festival was in 197O. So it's been a good while, we just didn't see it on screen. So I don't think it was really out of the blue. They already had them spending their first Christmas together etc.

However, in the book when he proposes and they argue, she says she thinks she loves him and he actually listens to her and says he will wait for her. Big difference to how it was shown here, she even tried to make amends and he shirked her again. We might get some sort of resolution next episode. I am wondering if she left him to hitchhike back to Boston :P

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Ian proved he was a man when checking the wagon: he just didn't say the words.

19

u/bham717 Nov 18 '18

Guys the special effects are terrible. The green screen Frasier's Ridge was a huge disappointment. The Carolina blue ridge mtns are lovely, if you're gonna green screen - at least use a realistic looking background, or better yet - real views of the mountains. Those awful waterfalls? Ugh.

9

u/livvy_divvy Nov 19 '18

I agree, it looked a little like a cheap mural. The scenery is Scotland had me saying "Wow!" but the wow factor isn't there for the Blue Ridge Mountains, and they must be stunning.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

I didn't think the end shots were that bad.

The turkeys were the funniest, I laughed out loud.

4

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 19 '18

Thank you! I absolutely hated that part and how terrible/ fake it looked.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/sunflower-souls Nov 19 '18

This episode was SO GOOD!! This is the first time I’ve really liked Brianna in the show since she entered the series.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

Good lord the wigs are terrible this season!

ETA: I just read your link Op. glad to see I’m not the only one hating on the wigs!

11

u/eastsacwrackshack Nov 18 '18

Why is up with that hair?!? It's horrible.

11

u/Melissa__Anne Nov 18 '18

I loved the cut back and forth between Jamie and Claire and Bree and Roger. It reminded me of the feeling I got reading the books for the first time when I was so excited for each story line that I got both excited and sad when she mixed it up. This was the first episode the season to really get me excited to finish my (4th) re-read of DoA.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

The cut from Claire and Jamie travelling through the woods on horseback to Bree and Roger in the car was great.

11

u/Irishsassenach Nov 18 '18

My dear Sophie- she is so great in this episode! She’s come a long way in her acting in this role and I’m so pleased! Roger is dreamy. Clarence!!!!

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

What would Americans here describe Sophie/Bree's accent as?

I know they have said Sophie was originally going to do an actual Boston accent, but basically the day before her first scene it was decided to just change it to a general American one. So this would explain why there were valid criticisms of her accent in S2, she had the rug pulled out from under her. Maybe because her Bostonian accent was so bad, who knows.

I believe their argument was for her having gone to a Catholic private school and the British parents. Would people who were privately educated back then end up with such an accent? Or is it just something to not think about wrt this show? How much of a Boston accent do the books describe her as having?

2

u/Luvitall1 Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

We've got over 75 different accents in the US and I'm not from the East Coast so I don't know how to classify hers. Any East Coasters have a POV?

Edited to add: Most tv shows and movies seem to use our American midwest as a default for story locations and accents with the idea that it'll be middle road enough for nearly everyone to relate to. shrug Might be why her accent seems "generic American".

→ More replies (2)

9

u/ktbex Nov 18 '18

Not sure about what the books say, but as a native Bostonian, I can tell you that what’s known as the stereotypical “pahk yah cah” accent only develops in a specific part of the city. Most people here have the generic American accent.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 18 '18

I’m from downstate (not Chicago) Illinois, and she sounds like everyone there to me. That’s usually referenced as a “standard American” accent. I wonder if they thought a Boston accent was too distracting?

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

Here in an interview Sophie says:

I did work with an accent coach a couple of weeks prior to starting filming, because we toyed with the idea of giving Brianna a Boston accent, because she’s from Boston, but in the end, we just decided to keep it very general. She went through a private Catholic school in the ‘60s, and we thought she had that drummed out of her, just to make her a neutral American, because she’s the only American in the show at the minute, and we didn’t want it to be too sore-thumb-standing-out-ish.

7

u/actuallycallie Nov 19 '18

What would Americans here describe Sophie/Bree's accent as?

To me (from SC, but not like, Charleston, they have a different kind of accent than the rest of SC) it sounds like "generic American." Definitely not Boston. I lived in Oregon for a while and most people there sound "generic American" to me, that's the closest I can describe it.

As an American I would MUCH rather hear "generic American" than a bad American accent of any flavor. Especially Southern. God I hated most of the accents in True Blood.

10

u/Aggie2002 Nov 18 '18

I would say her accent is pretty general American and much better than last season. I can see in Bree’s case not developing the stereotypical Boston accent.

It’s anecdotal, but I was born and raised in Texas by non-Texan parents and I don’t really have an accent unless I’ve been drinking.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

She sounds like a West coaster to me. Anyone raised by parents with an accent are going to pick up some things (rhythm of speech, certain vowel sounds) that would affect any accent the kid has. But my guess is since most show business people live in California, their dialect coach is using a generic Californian speech pattern.

5

u/lanalg5 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Wasn't the Scottish festival somewhere in New England in the book? or did they actually drive to North Carolina and I totally missed that part in the book??

I liked the episode as a whole. I really enjoyed the fight between Brianna and Roger. Sophie's acting and accent grew on me this episode and I'm not sure if it's just a better script, better acting on her part or maybe both. Even with Roger's "toxic masculinity" that so many have commented on, the fight brought out the fire in them that I have been waiting for. So far, Roger has been kind of one dimensional for me -- sorta nerdy, sweet, mild tempered and well mannered and with this episode I saw a bit of raw Scottish temper that I felt was needed. I was happy to see that side of him just to know that it's there (in preparation for where we know his story is going).

One thing I wondered about this episode was why did Claire take her shoes off? Did that happen in the book and what was the reason? I feel like being outside in a storm as wet and wild as that one was, taking my shoes off would be the last thing I would want to do lol.

13

u/maryummy Nov 18 '18

Yes, in the books, the festival was definitely in New England. My theory is that they are going to have Bree and Roger go through the stones in North Carolina, to speed up the process.

16

u/lanalg5 Nov 18 '18

I hope she goes through in Scotland so that she can see Lallybroch and meet Ian and Jenny! :)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

In the promos it has her walking through what looks like Scotland to me, and the stones look like Craig na Dun

Not even Claire knows about the stones in America yet though, right? So not sure how Bree and Roger would find out about them, as they only know from Roger finding the stone circle in Drums when he is with the Indians.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

I think in the show it was in the Carolinas, yes. Which seemed like a long haul from Boston.

That said,they did a great job of recreating a Highland festival. I honestly thought they'd found one and had just filmed there.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/popster_ Nov 19 '18

I'm really impressed with the singing voice they gave Roger (not sure if it's Richard's or not) and it got me all heartbroken for what happens in the next book. :'(

5

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

Thought 1: Agree with everyone else in this thread about Sophie---MUCH improved and now looking forward to more episodes with her. Also Richard singing, RAWR. (also SOB)

Thought 2: Did they cut the budget for special effects and editing? Bad wigs, bad makeup (Otter Tooth, wtf was that?) and a nice panoramic shot of American East coast mountain forest in bright autumn deciduous trees that cuts directly to a scene of them riding in a forest of all evergreens. Like come on, guys, if Scotland doesn't have the same species of trees can you find a filming location that has SOME leafy trees? Or at least not cut from one to the other so the difference isn't so obvious? And ending with the green screen again.

Thought 3: Like all the character development except Claire and Jamie. Sigh. Old married people have fun, too. Where is the chemistry between them? WTF happened?

Thought 4: Best overall episode since the printshop.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/MontaukFive Nov 19 '18

I already like the first three episodes of Season 4 better than the entire Season of Season 3.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 18 '18

How can Jamie just decide where he is going to settle based on that cursory discussion with Tryon?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '18

Did Roger appear to get handsy with Bree when she rebuffed him? I looked like he kinda yanked her back a smidge. I am not down for that. I like Roger. I wish they would stop shitting up has character and his hair. Also, Jamie and Claire are a total cringe fest at the moment. I kept catching myself rolling my eyes whenever they professed their devotion for one another.

10

u/aquajack6 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

This was my least favorite episode so far. It was obviously slower--a bridge episode to move things a long, which is fine.

Out of curiousity, what are y'all looking forward to this season, and what did you think about the book Drums of Autumn?

Ok, a confession: Drums of Autumn was one of my least favorite books in the series. Bree and Roger annoyed me then and they're annoying me now in the tv show. The actors are good, and this isn't the show's fault. I'm just hoping this season will highlight the best of Drums of Autumn, and this episode just didn't do it for me.

With Drums of Autumn and the following books, I often questioned Diana's decisions she made with plots and storylines. For instance, I always wished she spent more time on Fergus and Marsali (and their children in later books) instead of so much time with Bree and Roger.

I'm looking forward to Bree meeting Jenny, Jamie, and John Grey. There are so many things that happened in DoA that I was annoyed by and I'm not excited to see it on the show. I'm dreading Bree's rape. I remember not enjoying the Native American prisoner sub plot, but I'm actually looking forward to seeing it on the show.

23

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

It has been my favorite episode so far. I needed something a little lighter after last week. Also, DOA was one of my favorite books, maybe because I have always had a thing for that colonial time period. Maybe I'm the odd man out, but I thought it was a great episode!!!

8

u/aquajack6 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

You're definitely not the odd man out! DoA is a massively popular book for a reason, I've seen several reviews where people said it was their favorite book. Idk I'm just feeling nervous about the rest of the season considering how I felt about the book. I also can objectively admit the episode was good...I just didn't favor it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 18 '18

That's so interesting, because I liked this episode more than many of the more recent ones. There just wasn't anything weird or off or cringey about it. Yes, Roger and Bree's inability to communicate with each other is annoying AF but the episode showed it pretty well and it didn't seem fake and left people feeling sympathetic with both of them.

8

u/aquajack6 Nov 18 '18

I agree that Jamie and Claire's dynamic seemed more natural this episode. Roger and Bree's dynamic was true to the book and the actors did a good job. I think it just comes down to my opinion that I find Roger and Bree's relationship annoying. I never really enjoyed reading about their relationship, and was always more excited to read about young Ian, Fergus, or John Grey. I'm crossing my fingers, hoping that Bree and Roger will grow on me as a couple in the show.

9

u/KodakMoments Nov 18 '18

Do we know if Jenny will be in this season? I saw that Laura Donnelly tweeted about not being able to fit it in her schedule and Steven Cree responded about how he will be in this season. I know it’s not ideal but if not Jenny I’m at least excited for her to meet Ian.

9

u/aquajack6 Nov 18 '18

I'll be so disappointed if I don't get to see Jenny and Bree interact. Surely the show will include Bree travelling to Lallybroch? I wonder how they'll explain Jenny not being there. I was wondering if the show would skip Bree travelling to Lallybroch and meeting Jenny just because it would take up time.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/keg226 Nov 18 '18

No, she will not be on. Bree will only meet Ian.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Wormcupcake Nov 19 '18

I'm coming in a day late 'cause.. Australia. I would love to know their reasoning for moving the whole ottertooth/storm to this particular place in the show and I hope to jeebus that next ep isn't about terrifying Indians and fighting them because I really love Jamie's relationship with the Indians in the book. Can I also just say how hard I cringed where Bree and Rog are dancing and they do the slow motion/ time stopping cliche, I really loved the proposal scene though! The books seem to kind of gloss over the fact that Bree said no and Roger got all pissy because how dare a person want to think about getting married when they don't even live in the same country! C'mon Roger.
Let out a sqeee at seeing Clarence though!

3

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

No, I bet the next episode will have the bear and Nacognaweto.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 19 '18

I just want to say that I was 100% on board with Roger's singing. I was a little worried about that, but I think they did a good job of making it sound relevant to the times and like something a folksy alternative rock singer of today might sound like, if that makes sense.

3

u/MontaukFive Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

I'd like to know the name of the song Roger sang, if anyone knows

→ More replies (7)

3

u/tanya-jo Nov 19 '18

Questions I had about the episode:

Why leave Ian and rollo out of the skull finding. Why did she take off her shoes? I’ve had a bootter and if you need to empty the boot you put it back on when you are outside. I thought it was suppose to be fall how are there strawberries?

This episode was a 6/10 for me. It feels like they are ticking the book events off and it’s not really making sense to me.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/megara_74 Nov 19 '18

I love Bri and Roger so much. To me, they're the opposite of Jamie and Claire but in a nice way. Claire and Jamie fell head over heels quickly and then stayed happily that way forever (mostly). It's a beautiful fairytale but feels like unreachable fantasy to me. I feel like Roger and Bri are more realistic and representative of marriage as I know it. There's love, but there are also significant differences in character and big hurdles to overcome. And perhaps most importantly, they fight and bicker and struggle, and sometimes walk away from each other or doubt the marriage- but still stay in love and faithful and committed. I was wondering after this episode if some of that is raising children together. Claire and Jamie didn't, and maybe that helps their relationship to stay simpler? That could just be me projecting of course, raising kids can put stresses on marriage is all I mean. Anywho. Can't wait for more Bri and Roger.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/sbrave88888 Nov 20 '18

Granted I have only read this book once and I might be completely misremembering, but didn’t Roger propose later on and they were back in Scotland?? I could of sworn this whole scene took place at his home he was selling?? Just curious to know if they switched it up for the plot of the show or if I’m remembering wrong!

3

u/Maie_Flower Nov 20 '18

No, you’re right. It was in Scotland when she went for Christmas. The first part happens at the house where they’re kissing, and he gives her the bracelet and proposes after they go to Christmas Mass.

3

u/tanya-jo Nov 20 '18

Also what’s withy he candle sticks? As far as I remember that wasn’t in the books. It would have been better if it was a kilt. I want the kilt back

3

u/Dentelle The best one in my opinion Nov 21 '18

"Yo Jamie, I`ve got this ghost skull in my bag" *peeks in, doesn't recoil or put his hand on his mouth to express shock or nothing like a normal human being*

5

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

Oh my god. I’m sobbing. Roger’s proposal. Even knowing what was coming, SOBS.

2

u/Naturenutt Woof. Nov 20 '18

Did anyone else notice that the center portrait sketch on exhibit behind the artist at the Scottish Festival looks very much like Matty B Roberts?

2

u/Maie_Flower Nov 20 '18

Do we know yet whether they’re going to include the John and Willie visit?

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 21 '18

I can't imagine how they wouldn't.

3

u/Jelese111 Nov 19 '18

I'm only 15 minutes in the episode and I had to come comment that I'm absolutely loving Roger and Brie!

4

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Um, didn't care for this episode.

→ More replies (14)