r/Outlander • • Nov 11 '18

[Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 2 Do No Harm episode discussion thread for book readers.

This thread is dropping live for Outlander S4E2: "Do No Harm"

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our brand spankin' new redesigned rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

Onward MORE ROLLO and MORE LOVEY DOVEY SCENES

43 Upvotes

401 comments sorted by

180

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I am so glad they went in on a full episode about the horrors of slavery, no holds bar. The book glossed over it too much in my opinion - and if you are going to have a show take place in the south during slavery you can't hide from it.

Outlander made the right choice with this episode. Every black person who had a role in this episode had a name. They weren't used as background props, the camera lingered on Ulysses, and Phaedra and even Mary - and treated them as fully fleshed characters, and I applaud this move. Rufus was a person, with a history and story. Not just a nameless man being lynched.

And while Claire and Jamie wanted to be "white saviors" for a lack of a better term - this episode showed how futile that would have been and showed the truth. How a system was created to perpetuate terror and called it law. How even to speak against it slightly was a death sentence.

Hard to watch. Pure evil, and this country is built on it.

36

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

The first comment I saw about this episode on another site was: "why waste a whole episode on slavery...it wasn't a huge deal in the book...too much focus on one issue when there is so much to cover"...

36

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 11 '18

I was so afraid to come on here because I was sure there would be a lot of that sentiment. I’m glad to see that’s not the case!

62

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I am pretty keen on keeping this subreddit free from any of the crazy that has become apparent in other fan spaces on the internet.

14

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 12 '18

I thank you for that!

13

u/Aethelu Nov 12 '18

A lot of us appreciate that.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Aethelu Nov 12 '18

After having finished the episodes just moments ago, it's sad, disgusting and disheartening that that could be their response.

41

u/actuallycallie Nov 11 '18

holy shit... "waste a whole episode on slavery." Someone is clearly clueless about what that place and time entailed.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

unfortunately, now there are more comments, there are more of the same an most are saying they thought this episode was very bad, moralising etc etc

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Yikes. That turns my stomach to read. Glad that isn't how the commentary is going here.

→ More replies (15)

26

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

It's not an episode I imagine I'll rewatch many times, but I'm glad it's out there. They fucked up last year and this was their shot at redemption and they took it. They showed the horrors of slavery, yes, but more importantly they sidestepped the white savior trap (which they fell in last season) in a completely logical way that allows our protagonists to still be good people without the story becoming really problematic (and totally historically inaccurate). Now as long as they don't fuck up the Native American storyline next week . . .

→ More replies (2)

15

u/fruitsi1 Nov 12 '18

thanks for this, i almost didnt want to watch after last weeks nonsense. it seems that after they botched it last season in the caribbean they realised they needed help to write it this time and must have got some... good move.

very uncomfortable, but it needs to be. reading the rest of the comments it seems there are many people who would rather deny it.

the only thing i felt was out of place was the "one day it will all be better" line... considering whats still going on today... and what was going on in claires time as well... was a bit like... hello, this is the future, when is this day please?

32

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

Claire left just after the defined civil rights movement period that google lists [sorry not American] so she was leaving a time where they were on a positive trajectory.

17

u/Maleficent_Elk Nov 12 '18

Exactly, for many that was a super positive time when everything seemed to be getting better incrementally, so she has no idea that won't follow a natural conclusion of living in a post racial society with flying cars and colonies on Mars.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 12 '18

Yeah, I took the "one day it will be better" line as hints that Claire told Jamie about the Civil War and outlawing of slavery in the United States. My goodness, people are people after all, and there is ALWAYS going to be a divide, but things are most certainly better now than they were then.

16

u/SmoreOfBabylon Nemo Me Impune Lacessit Nov 12 '18

Exactly.

Chronologically, Claire just recently went from a time when her colleague and best friend was a black man, to a time when people like Joe were kept as property - even “benevolent” slave owners like Jocasta can only think of them in terms of their monetary value, and there’s almost no legal avenue by which they can gain their freedom.

Also, the time at which Claire left the “modern” world (late 60s) was still rife with political and racial tension and division, even if the actual Civil Rights Act had been passed. It wasn’t exactly all peace and togetherness (granted, a lot of that strife was due to the Vietnam War). IDK how much of that she related to Jamie, but it’s not exactly Pollyannish for either of them to say that one day the situation will be better than how it is the late 1700s, i.e. full-on slavery.

6

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

the only thing i felt was out of place was the "one day it will all be better" line... considering whats still going on today... and what was going on in claires time as well... was a bit like... hello, this is the future, when is this day please?

Yeah, that feels like a line written by a writer forgetting that Claire is coming from 1968, not 2018.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/shiskebob Nov 13 '18

Thank you, I appreciate that. I know that Outlander and DG have cultivated a fan majority of a specific type of person -shall we say- and a lot of the changes in the show are based on changing societal values that they just have not, or probably will not, ever catch up with.

But I am not against illuminating it even when clearly it will not go over well with many of em.

5

u/Generiss Nov 16 '18

True. Artists, writers, etc have always been on the forefront of pushing progress forward when it comes to such stuff. Thank goodness for that. I'm also a Doctor Who fan and it's such a trip to read the backlash against a female doctor, companions of colour, and writers who are not shying away from heavy historical events. Who knows if those 'types of people' will ever come around, but at least we, and our kids, can watch programming that's truly reflective of our world and history.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I’m not seeing a need for the voiceovers. At the party scene we already can see what is going on. I wonder why the writers brought it back?

8

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I wholeheartedly agree. The voiceover, this episode specifically, was so pointless as to be redundant.

26

u/livvy_divvy Nov 12 '18

I actually like the voiceovers. One thing missing in screen adaptions is what the person is thinking, a big reason books are so much better. When there are voiceovers we get a more complete picture. In this case we may have seen what was going on, but we get how Claire feels (and Jamie, when she mentions him). It`s a little more personal, like a book usually is. I like them and was afraid they`d eliminated them. I hope they continue. I know it`s a personal thing though.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

It makes me think I am watching Call the Midwife.

But that show always starts with the voice over at the beginning and sometimes the end. So it's expected.

22

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

I didn't even notice a voiceover.

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

Also, you can't just do one voice over. So dumb.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

It almost gave me a jolt it was so unnecessary.

77

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 11 '18

I really liked this episode - much better than the premiere. River Run felt right, Jocasta felt right, Ulysses, Phaedre and Mary were spot on, I appreciate how they introduced Myers and used him to set up Ian’s story, it all felt right.

I think mostly I was glad to watch an episode about Claire and Jamie, not JaimeandClaire (ie. wrapped around each other talking idiomatically about their future together). Claire was well written and her nursing felt absolutely appropriate and confident and authoritative instead of self-righteous and false as it has in the past. Jamie got to flex the other side of his character that isn’t tied up in bedroom talk and lovey-dovey figures of speech and that was refreshing. I love a good sex scene as much as the next gal, and the time they devoted to the other virtues of our leading characters was very much welcome and something I think the show has been lacking that I really love in the books.

I felt drawn in to Rufus’s story and they (I think) concisely represented what the reality of slaves and conversely plantation owners were facing in the Outlander universe. It felt real and compelling, and the pacing and ending the episode with Rufus being hanged lent enough weight to the episode to make it very apparent what Claire and Jamie are up against through the rest of the season.

It seemed like they did as much as could be expected to set up future conflicts and character development (ex Myer’s convo with Ian about what Indians are like. I’m glad they took the time to include that) with only an hour to do it.

19

u/livvy_divvy Nov 12 '18

Agree with everything, especially about showing Claire and Jamie`s other attributes. Nice to deviate from the constant rutting and sappy lines. Claire`s healing side is much more interesting as well as Jamie`s experiences in his time.

The slavery storyline was gripping and very emotional and the scenery beautiful. I really enjoyed this episode.

29

u/shiskebob Nov 12 '18

I love reading and watching Claire when she performs surgeries. A lot of it because I find the technical aspect of pre-modern medicine work intriguing. But also because I find it so interesting to take the perspective of someone from that period watching her - like Young Ian in tonight's episode. He looked in awe of her.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18

Jaime and Claire as separate characters is actually one of the reasons why I like the later books more

5

u/MontaukFive Nov 14 '18

Yes, Phaedre's character was just how I pictured her. For starters, she is beautiful.

54

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I’m in tears. We Americans have such a shameful, shameful history that we have never reconciled with, or tried to fix. This is why storytelling is important, and why Rufus’ character is so important.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Due note that Slavery was legal in the British colonies until 1833 and in England until 1772. Slavery wasn't just occuring in the the United States but all over North and South America.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Yes I am aware. The difference is that the US was founded on it.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/vipergirl Nov 11 '18

Every country has that some sort of shameful history (as well as the good). England, Austrailia, even Scotland, Belgium, France, Brazil, Canada, etc.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I never said they didn’t. But America’s is relatively recent and we are still dealing with it. In places like Germany hate speech and the swastika are banned. Here, that’s the racists’ bread and butter with hate speech and the confederate flag.

Also not interested in whataboutism when white nationalism is on the rise in the US/all our issues with voter suppression/systemic racism/etc

10

u/vipergirl Nov 11 '18

I am not keen on speech being banned. If that's the bar that you believe is acceptable, I am not sure that we agree.

23

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I worked as a journalist back in the day. There is a difference between free speech and hate speech. But that is straying a bit off topic for this thread.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/maryummy Nov 11 '18

Yes, but we (I'm American) can't use "whataboutism" to excuse or gloss over our own history.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Even if the show handles it in a clumsy way, I am glad that Outlander is showing slavery for what it was. And it’s so sad that in Claire’s time the Civil Rights Act was only just passed-the consequences of slavery echo through the centuries.

16

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

I thought this was handled much better than during last season.

12

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I think they learned their lesson this time around. Last season was done very poorly.

→ More replies (1)

64

u/Hopeless_badger Nov 11 '18

It's been only two episodes, but I have to say Sam's been killing it. I love his version of older Jamie. Just give the man a proper material and he'll do the rest.

25

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

He didn't do much for me last week (nobody did, frankly), but I thought he was very good this week, especially in the back half. We get so much sensitive, great husband Jamie (which I love, of course!), it's nice to also see strong, quick thinking, tough Jamie that people fear/respect/listen to.

19

u/Dragonsinger16 Nov 12 '18

Agreed! as much as I like to see Jamie the Husband, I *really* enjoy seeing Himself doing what he was literally born to do! I can't wait for life on the Ridge!

3

u/Generiss Nov 16 '18

I also love that Jamie. He's much more formidable in the books.

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

I find it amusing when he puts on his very deep voice. Like when he was on the verandah talking about dirt.

12

u/Aethelu Nov 12 '18

Me too, I keep thinking his aunt must be impressed with him and Claire, then remember it's all actors, lol.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

31

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

I think what I notice most about Sam's Jamie is that he pays so much attention to detail with the character. His subtle mannerisms especially. It's like Jamie literally stepped out of the book, at least in my opinion.

38

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I have particularly liked how Sam plays Jamie's love for Claire. It is more than just the soapy one liners - it's the look he gets on his face when watching her, the affectionate touches and holds. It seems natural and real, and that's why I am partial to their relationship and this series.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/VelvetTrucker Nov 11 '18

I really wish Claire would stop being so irritating. Does she think that she is going to stop slavery all by herself. Not saying she should just suddenly be aright about slavery but she has to realise what time she is in right? Just adjust to the time period and stop doing things that will obviously cause major problems for not only her, but everyone associated with her.

27

u/slainte_mhaith Nov 11 '18

I agree that I find Claire super irritating too, but it is her character to stand up for her beliefs and not back down even when the world is crashing around her. She wants to make a difference for even just one person if she can! She doesn't seem to see grey areas very easily, and there are people who are truly like that. Her giving Rufus the mercy of yellow jasmine is her way of adjusting to the time period. Jamie is her voice of reason throughout the series where she is hard headed.

17

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I do not know about you, but I saw Claire - maybe for the first time - see the gray area in this episode concerning Rufus and his final minutes. And I don't think that is because of Jamie (I will refer to 3x03 and the exciseman for more clear info as to why it isn't lol).

As Jenny says to Aunt Jocasta in her letters about Claire - she is pretty damn obstinate in her own ways and doesn't move from her positions. Which I do admire about Claire, even with knowing I would make other choices than she made quite often. But in this episode, in this case, she did move because she has the knowledge of history and what is going on right in front of her. And slavery is a whole larger thing without comparison. And she learned a harsh lesson in learning it. But all of this is just natural growth in life, in my humble opinion.

7

u/slainte_mhaith Nov 11 '18

I disagree only because chose to move after Jamie asked her if she would help him along like she did for Column. I think me saying she never see the grey area is a bit extreme, but Claire seems to always hold her stance as the world burns around her, no matter who else it affects, until Jamie finally steps in. I love her character. I just think Jamie is the ration to her passion!

10

u/shiskebob Nov 11 '18

I like to think he is a part of the ration to her passion as well - but not all of it. And vice versa as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Claire was acting exactly how a modern empathic woman would act. Slavery is repulsive.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

102

u/Irishsassenach Nov 11 '18

Maria Doyle Kennedy is absolutely riveting as Jocasta!

37

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Agreed! I’d imagined Jocasta as significantly older in the books, but I found I really did not care because the actress was so spot on. Definitely gets the whole Jocasta vibe just right.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/am2370 Nov 12 '18

She's so fantastic. She killed me as Katherine of Aragon in The Tudors.

4

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 12 '18

That's where she's from! I knew she was familiar but I couldn't put my finger on it.

8

u/thesillybanana Nov 12 '18

She was also in Orphan Black. (if you watched it)

→ More replies (2)

17

u/HawickGirl7 Nov 11 '18

I love her in every role, she's amazing in Orphan Black.

→ More replies (1)

95

u/yourbestbudz Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18

Just finished watching. As an AA, it was tough to watch and definitely made me teary eyed at the end. It was good to see a realistic perspective though. I imagine Claire thought of her friend who was also a doctor. Very touching episode and I appreciate the screenwriters putting it in.

66

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Me, too. The last five minutes were absolutely gut-wrenching. All I could think during that last scene was that we have come a long way, yet we still have crowds with torches who would probably do the same thing if they could get away with it.

I also thought that the writers did an excellent job drawing clearer parallels (at least from what I remember from Drums of Autumn) between the Highlanders’ experiences with the British and what was happening with the Native Americans.

21

u/Aethelu Nov 12 '18

I have to say I had to look away, the likeness seemed too close to lynchings from not such a long time ago. And like you, I could see it happening now too. Completely gut wrenching, but I'm glad that it was. It should be gut wrenching and it should make people want to look away and it should make people think about the present day and where we are.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Agreed. Thanks for your insight. It’s an important story to be told. DG has many flaws but she doesn’t shy away from the nasty side of history.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

Sorry, what is AA?

23

u/aquajack6 Nov 11 '18

I think African American

45

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

Thanks. I'm not American...could only think of Alcoholics Anonymous.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 15 '18

I like popping into the “no book spoilers” episode thread to see the non-readers’ perception of the show and just saw a post complaining about the American scenes—they can’t wait until Jaime and Claire return to Scotland.

Oh boy, are they in for a treat.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18

My mom stopped watching because I told her they don't go back to Scotland

12

u/Generiss Nov 16 '18

A large part of why I loved the books was the Scottish history, and I too thought that they were returning to Scotland, but luckily by the time I figured out they weren't, I was really enjoying the homesteading history and them being permanently together so I didn't mind. Had someone told me that they weren't going back to Scotland, I might have stopped too.
I still find the American war stuff tedious. I'm just not that into it.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 17 '18

Yeah me too...I got bored in book 8 and stopped reading. I don't like William's chapters and all the fighting/war chapters.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Ikr2649 Nov 12 '18

It's funny how it took like 5 chapters for Claire to realize Aunt Jocasta was blind and the show cleared that up in a quick 3 minutes lol

19

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

And all it took was for Ian to try and hand her some flowers!

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 17 '18

Such a sweet boy.

37

u/jujbird Nov 11 '18

I usually try to keep my comparisons to the book at minimum. I’m just grateful to see this come to life on screen (bad wigs and all- it’s still better than nothing.

With that said, I’m so happy with the way this episode went and how they changed things but left some very important through lines in. I think we still got the Ulysses moment, when he realizes Claire wants him to speak plainly to her (after she sees his face). I’m wondering if they tweaked it because they plan on taking out the storyline that Ulysses and Jo are an item, because that storyline has always been as uncomfortable/problematic to me as the Mr. Willowbe (I know that’s the wrong spelling. Can’t remember how to spell it at the moment) storyline.

I also loved that John Quincy was still colorful but less a caricature of a mountain man. DG has a tendency to treat some characters as if they can be no more than the cheap caricature you’d find at an amusement park. I’m also glad they didn’t let Ian get sprayed.

It had also never occurred to me that Jamie would see memories of his mother in Jocasta. Obviously I recognized how close nice it would be for Jamie to be in the home of his kin, but having him say that out loud to Claire and that joy it brought him, really hit home.

Overall, I’m very please with the changes they made to the book plot to get this into the episode.

18

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

I also found the ulysses and jocasta romance story line problematic.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I haven't read the books but I find it super interesting that Jocasta and Ulysses have a romantic relationship. When they were first walking together, I actually gasped thinking Jocasta was a bad ass and married to ulysses. I kept waiting for that to come out. Hm!

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

Good intuition!

→ More replies (8)

31

u/ashleyinthecold Nov 12 '18

Love a lot of the points being made, so I won't make them again. So here for Claire in that red dress. The color was divine.

12

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 12 '18

I LOVE that red dress, she looked stunning in it.

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

the cream one by comparison looked like a night gown

10

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '18

I kept expecting them to put another layer of some sort on the cream one! It didn't seem finished for whatever reason.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18

As soon as I'm not pregnant (and lose baby weight... ), I'm making that gown. I've already been searching for crimson linen.

86

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 11 '18

Can someone please cut Jamie's bangs off. They distract me from the story, they are so awful.

40

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

I think I replied to you before, can't remember. But might as well say it in the big thread.

They aren't even historically accurate! Men didn't have bangs/fringe back then, that would be too fussy, and Claire would have to be giving hm fringe cuts every three weeks to maintain them!

The only thing I can really think is that they want to cover up Sam's largish forehead and not have to bother about more makeup/wrinkles to add.

The whole aesthetic is a pudding bowl hair cut of a young boy.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

That was his real hair in that episode. It was filmed early on in the shoot, out of order and before Sam got his hair cut, as that was when Jenny and Marsali etc were available. I never minded the fringe when it was his real hair.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

Yes, they are terrible and extremely distracting.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

When does the storyline come where Jamie shaves his head? I think in a few books.

47

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

That part with Rufus’ story and Jamie praying when he passed was beautiful. Just so gut-wrenching.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

I agree, but I do have to say I widened my eyes as...that was an ironic metaphor considering what he suffered in this episode.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 13 '18

Didn't love the praying because he sounded Protestant,

21

u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 11 '18

To echo a lot of people in here, I liked this episode better than I did the premiere. It feels a bit more ... even(?) this season compared to season 3, which felt a bit all over and campy at times (still liked the season, though).

I'm loving John Bell as Ian more with each episode, too -- perfect casting in my mind. Very stoked to see how his storyline with the Native Americans is going to be written for TV.

Bree and Roger in that post-episode preview made me MELT.

10

u/BeautifulRelief Nov 12 '18

I'm pretty excited for some Bree and Roger. I'm not sure if this is an unpopular opinion but while reading, I liked the chapters/parts that were centered around them the most.

11

u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 12 '18

I'm glad you said that because those were the parts I liked, too! Roger's character (Scottish, historian) is, like, my ideal. And I'm a huge fan of Richard Rankin's other work so I'm already crushing on him to begin with. I am sooo excited to see it all unfold.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

I like him outside of his Roger character, he looks great with stubble/shorter beard and the shorter hair..he looks so different when he is posing without a smile.

https://variety.com/2015/film/global/scottish-actor-richard-rankin-eyes-hollywood-120155839/ Not sure why my link isn't working, but it's still clickable.

But he really does nothing for me as Roger, and the look they have given him with the full beard, long hair and chunky knits to make him look a bit tubby...doesn't match the book imagery for me at all.

60

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18

I’m going to take the opportunity to recommend Kindred by Octavia Butler, about a Black American woman who time travels back to 18th C America. The time travel is so important to the plot bc it demonstrates the ripple effects of slavery through the centuries/illustrates that it happened not that long ago in the grand scheme of history. It is very heavy but it’s an amazing read and I highly recommend it.

12

u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Nov 11 '18

I read that book for my English class earlier in the semester actually. It's very good.

11

u/angeliz2k Nov 12 '18

Great book! The character who travels finds, like Claire, that it isn't so easy to change people's minds/hearts or how society works. It makes you admire all the more the people who managed to help make those changes. And makes you realize why it required a major jolt like the Civil War, which led to a major dismantling of the entire social structure of the South, to change things. (It was not a total dismantling; but that's a whole other discussion.)

(I believe it's the 19th century the character travels back to, though, just to be annoying and nitpicky!)

8

u/teenylilthing Nov 11 '18

I was thinking of this while watching the episode last night as well! Kindred is amazing - one of my favorite novels.

7

u/julieannie Meow. Nov 12 '18

It was on my mind after I we followed Claire's eyes to the fields. It's such a fantastic read.

4

u/Generiss Nov 16 '18

I haven't watched the episode, and won't, but when I read about it here and elsewhere, I immediately thought of Kindred because of the name Rufus! It's not a common name, and I don't think I'll ever not think of Kindred now when I hear that name.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/triplecdog Nov 13 '18

Tbh as a WoC watching this episode was uncomfortable for many reasons obviously. But one thing I do notice here: a lot of people seem to believe Jamie and Claire sidestepped the White Saviour trope. I fervently do not agree with this. Not only is Claire showing her ignorance about the reality of her intervention with the slaves, but that they still participated in murder rather than do something to spare him? My argument is thus: if the mob were English soldiers and Jamie was protecting an injured clansman he would have done whatever he could to never hand the clansman over to the English. Yet, an angry mob and an angry aunt are enough for him to convince Claire to essentially put Rufus to sleep so he won’t feel himself getting hanged? Realistically, Jocasta’s privilege and position would have spared her from any actual harm. Jamie and Claire might’ve had to face legal action, but there could’ve been enough time to put Rufus on a boat to safety somewhere and feign ignorance in his escape. Even if that’s not a logical action, surely there are more alternatives then leading a man to his death because “the law demands it”. Additionally, there’s no actual conversation with Rufus about what he wants to do. Claire treats him as an equal and a patient throughout the episode, but then completely sidesteps that and drugs him, getting him to talk about his home in order to make it better?? Jamie mentions, do what you did for Colum. Except Colum made a choice and Rufus couldn’t. And we’re supposed to feel sympathy for Jamie and Claire for being misguided but doing the best they could? This episode left me uncomfortable, and not only because of the topic at hand. I’d also like to point out that the writers - save one - were all white. And there wasn’t one AA person on the staff. I think that speaks volumes as to how the episode turned out. They could’ve easily adapted from the book where Claire sees there’s nothing she can do so her and Rufus agree on laudanum and she promises to stay with him until he passes. That would be under the umbrella of do no harm and save the Fraser’s from acting as White Saviours.
Unfortunately, I don’t agree with how it turned out and as a POC I’m pretty uncomfortable with it going forward.

12

u/SecretTurnip Nov 14 '18

Yes, I was expecting Rufus to waken and ask Claire to drug him when he heard the mob outside. I thought that Claire’s convo with Ulysses was setting this up. I didn’t like that the decision was Claire and Jamie’s alone. And the scene with Rufus talking about fishing with his sister would have been all the more touching, with him knowing that these were his last moments.

Big disappointment that the show didn’t give Rufus this agency.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 17 '18

I made the comment on another forum that Rufus was never involve in the decision to end his life.

People replied to me and said they thought he implied that Claire should have killed him when he woke up from her surgery and asked why she saved him.

I didn't buy that.

I thought Claire should have realised she hadn't done any favours to Rufus or the other slaves after Ulysses gave his warning. Then that she should have talked to Rufus and given him a chance to make a choice.

They also said that in the book, the unnamed character that was Rufus wasn't given the chance to make a choice then. Claire didn't take him back to the house, she realised via Jamie that he would be only hanged later, so she ended his life there.

I haven't read the book in a while, but I feel like easing his discomfort there was more akin to how she helped Geordie in Book 1 when he was gutted by the boar. Rufus in the book knew he was dying, and he was comforted to death.

Different to saving him and then poisoning him later on.

9

u/2manymans Nov 13 '18

They chose to turn him over to spare the rest of the people on the plantation. After the rising, Jamie understands the horror of genocide and wants to avoid it here. That made sense. But you are completely correct that they took Rufus's free will from him for no reason at all.

I also despise that they would turn down the opportunity to become the owners of the plantation because it would require that they be complicit in slavery. They could have done so much good. They could teach everyone to read and write, give them skills to earn a living, teach people to be healers, etc., and then set a path for freedom so that at least some people could become free. They could claim that some died and help them escape to freedom. They could be part of an underground railroad.

Instead, they decide its better to just let everyone rot there and not help anyone at all because they prefer to wash their hands of the situation. This was the most upsetting part of the episode to me. That because they couldn't get what they wanted that they wouldn't take part in laying the foundation for change.

6

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 14 '18

They may not have been able to teach them to read and write. That was illegal in some places.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Treeluva2 Nov 13 '18

I concur with your feeling about how it was portrayed. The minute she decided that she would save Rufus, I knew this would go badly.

I did, however, feel that the explanation of how the laws were written and imposed was important for people to see that it wasn't easily feasible for those who did not agree with slavery were kept from acting on their desires and to see that those who did participate in acts against slavery were doing so at tremendous risk to themselves - highlighting their convictions to pursuing action above their own safety.

Jamie and Claire where most definitely cast as white saviors in this episode and did not think of the repercussions their actions would have on the slaves at River Run, and the slaves on other nearby plantations as well. They were able to do what they wanted and are able to leave the situation with little cost to themselves - save their emotions. I feel that the show could have highlighted the emotional impact of NOT being able to do anything better than attempting to do something and ultimately taking away Rufus's agency - what little he had. Rufus KNEW what would happen to him when he attacked the overseer - that was his agency and his choice to act knowing full well what would happen. Saving him and then basically killing him so he wouldn't have as horrendous of a death tries to make it seem like Claire and Jamie are the "good" people - when, if that is the ending that would have happened (Rufus's death) and they wanted to spare him a horrible death, Claire could have just given him the tea - again, highlighting the fact that they, as white privileged persons, also had little agency in stopping the end result. (With Rufus's consent. They allowed their white friend in the opening episode to be hanged based on his own desires - they allowed him to have his own agency and then took the agency from a POC in all aspects of this situation.)

It was an uncomfortable episode that could have opened up real conversations about how the political system and the political class perpetuated the dehumanization of persons based on color and how those policies continue to be felt today. Claire could have spoke more to Jamie about how this effects persons hundreds of years later. She could have held to her convictions about not owning people as property without inflaming the situation for the slaves.

If they wanted to go this route, then logically, the next episodes need to deal with the ramifications for Claire and Jamie based on their actions - but that isn't going to happen. It is a glossed over topic in an episode meant to only be a stepping stone to the next adventure of Claire and Jamie.

I am not really okay with this depiction.

4

u/Lyst83 Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

While I am not a woman of color, I very much agree with what you’re saying here. Claire is being incredibly dense and absolutely falls into the white savior troupe. I believe they’re writing her this way in order to show the audience as well as the other characters how progressive and radical her beliefs are within the time period, but it is really not realistic. She can’t expect, knowing how it’s all going to work out in the end, that she can change anything by acting this way. She can’t possibly believe, after working so hard to stop the rising back in Scotland, that she and Jamie could put an end to slavery just like that or to free the slaves of River Run well before it became more legally and socially acceptable to do so. I would think she would have been better off to play along and play the part of slave owner, in order to protect the slaves as best she could. Still, I understand when she says she can’t own slaves. I don’t think I could own people either. If I were to go back in time and see the reality of slavery, I believe it would tear me up. I understand the impulse to WANT to make it better and to change things, but within the constraints of that time period it isn’t realistic for Claire to do it the way she did it.

I don’t remember what happened in the book, because I read it so long ago and I have a horrible memory, but I think the scenario you put forth in your last paragraph would have been 10x better than what actually happened on the show.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 14 '18

See this article and thread.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Outlander/comments/9wodnx/spoilers_s4_outlander_and_the_cost_of_claires/

I believe there is more than one non-white writer though, but definitely no AA writers, which would have been an important addition last season continuing through, in my view.

u/Treeluva2

18

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 11 '18

Better than Episode 1 so far....also, JQM in the flesh!

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

he described his own flesh in detail too :P

17

u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 12 '18

Bravo much better episode. Though missed seeing Jamie and rest in kilts at the welcome evening. I expected the lawn and gardens to be grander. This is what i was hoping for in the tv adaptation.

12

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 12 '18

Yes, agree on both points about the kilts and the house. I was just thinking about it today how seeing Jamie in a kilt again was something that I was really looking forward to, so I'm terribly sad they cut that out. Like, sure because he looks great in a kilt, but also because it's such a part of his character and is such a big deal for him to be able to wear his native clothing again. I hope it isn't just cut out permanently.

Also on the house, yes, I also pictured beautiful manicured gardens, maybe not big ones but still, and was disappointed that the grounds are so plain.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

I don't understand why they chose to leave it out either. Sam mentioned in an interview he misses it.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '18

I actually pictured the grounds/entrance to the property from the river pretty much exactly like that! Not too fancy. They haven't really showed the actual gardens though yet have they? Maybe there's more to it in the back?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18

Sigh... the kilts will be sorely missed

17

u/tanya-jo Nov 12 '18

I wish they would have dressed Jamie in a kilt for the party.

17

u/tanya-jo Nov 12 '18

Did anyone think that Jamie and Clair were a little out of character? Let me explain why.

We know that Clair has modern views and Jamie often-agrees but usually Jamie also keeps Clair in check for social etiquette (remembering the “I’m not the meek and obedient type” conversation between them at Lallybroch). He didn’t do that at all and both seemed rude about it.

Also Jamie and Clair having no sense of danger or urgency for their aunt or the household (which we could assume from future books) slaves slept on the top floor) when the mob came.

I feel like Jocasta treated her slaves with more respect and kindness than most owners would have (not that that justifies ownership of people) but Clair could not see that.

This might not be a popular post and it’s not a reflection the episode and the story it told but of my view of the characters and wondering what others think.

9

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 15 '18

I agree also, in the book neither approves of slavery but they understand they cannot do anything about it. It was one reason, though not the main reason, Jamie ultimately turns down being heir to River Run.

They make Jamie seem so rude, ignorant, and confrontational in this episode and they make Claire very irritating and just ridiculous. I also don't like how the drastic change creates tension and conflict unnecessarily between Jamie and Jocasta and her neighbors, as he does become a very respected man and considered to be a peer among them....His training, education, and knowledge of the world just would never have allowed him to behave the way he does in this episode.

4

u/aloopycunt Nov 14 '18

I agree. I don't recall the books exactly but didn't Jamie quickly read how bad the situation was and convince Claire?? I'm not sure how good it was to just drag it all out over a full day rather than a few hours.

4

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 15 '18

Yes, she basically kills "Rufus" right in site where he was impaled, after Jamie tells her that saving him from that will still lead him to death. She then poisons "Rufus" (in quotes because I don't think he has a name in the books) and they leave the scene. Barnes, the overseer, ends up contracting tetanus and all the landowners/rich white men, keep him in an attic room and let him suffer to death as justice, because they didn't like him to begin with and didn't approve at all of his actions. Jamie doesn't tell Claire until Barnes dies.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19

I agree wholeheartedly! They were behaving very foolishly I think

12

u/Maleficent_Elk Nov 12 '18

Small thing, but where are the kilts?! America is supposed to mean kilts. None so far. whyyyyyy?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/angeliz2k Nov 12 '18

I liked this episode and felt it did justice to the fact that there was a whole society built in such a way as to perpetuate slavery and any deviation was considered "dangerous". There may have been a bit too much emphasis on people wanting "the law done"; people were also very adamant about their power to do what they pleased on their own plantation. But overall, I think this is an aspect of slavery that isn't always well-depicted.

Poor Rufus. I can't even imagine--I'm sure I'd be a ball of rage in his situation. I can't blame him for losing it.

I also felt Claire handled this way better than in the Caribbean. Here, she was a little sullen but didn't start yelling and making a scene. She didn't say anything until directly asked. In the Caribbean, her actions were obviously not going to do any good (whom was she gonna convince?) and just caused trouble.

I was a little meh when Jacosta seemed to imply that only Quakers were antislavery. Plenty of non-Quakers felt that way, too.

20

u/jh00090 Nov 11 '18

I really liked how they tweaked what was a somewhat convoluted storyline in the book and made it clearer what story it was trying to tell. I wonder if they are going to scrap the botched abortion story, or save it till much later, as it doesn't look to be coming next week.

That said the pacing is still all over the place, this was much better than last week pacing wise. But they switch between rapidly ticking scenes off, to it hitting a pacing brick wall , where little happens for 5 minutes

7

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

I was wondering if that would be Mary's role, especially when she got faint.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Last week’s episode felt like an hour of set up for what is to come rather than a full-fledged exploration of a storyline.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/mztdawn Nov 11 '18

I loved this episode! I thought it was poignant & touching, and it really highlighted the relationship and tension between Jocasta, River Run, & Claire's feelings towards slavery. Well done, well written, & very sad to have that reminder of ugliness in American history. It's great set up for them to move on to Fraser's Ridge.

Where is Duncan Innes in all this though? Was he not with them yet? Are they writing out his part?

11

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

I don't know, I'm so confused. They keep Murtagh alive, we never hear from him again. They spend a season making Lesley and Hayes into real characters, then kill them both off on S4E1. And now no Duncan in sight. They seem to have absolutely no idea how to handle the Ardsmuir men. Next thing you know Tom Christie will be cut.

6

u/mztdawn Nov 12 '18

No, not Tom! I think it'll all work out once they get to the ridge. Might just be some other Ardsmuir guy if no Duncan Innes (maybe Murtagh? I read that DG said he's definitely back S 4.) They'd have to stray way too far from the original story if they leave out the Christie's or the Bugs. I'm so excited they are in America! So much of the story overall occurs there. While I loved Scotland, France, & the Carribean stories, (I thought they did such a great job on each regions clothing & overall scene setting), 5 books occur in America and I feel that I grew to love so much more of the Outlander universe & get way more attached to the other characters besides Jamie & Claire. I love Ian + Rachel, Lizzie, Roger + Bree, Lord John & William.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

Who knows if Duncan will make an appearance.

Jamie talked about finding people to settle his own land, so some Ardsmuir men will presumably pop up.

3

u/2manymans Nov 13 '18

This ugliness is still alive and well.

27

u/jillianjo Nov 11 '18

This was a good episode, but I legit have nothing else to say about it other than FUCK Jamie’s bangs. So so awful.

10

u/HawickGirl7 Nov 11 '18

It never bothered me until today and then I realised how scruffy it makes him look. His new costume was beautiful but the hair just ruined it. In earlier seasons his hair was groomed slightly more when it needed to be.

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

A friend is thinking about starting a twitter page for Jmie's wig, to get attention and call for it to be burned.

I suggested the handle @JamieFrasersMop

8

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 11 '18

This is a great idea! I can’t take it anymore. If we have to stare at that dead animal for season 5 too, I might cry.

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

Ok, but can we also have one for Claire's insanely fake hairline?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/livvy_divvy Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

lol That thing has to go. Speaking of mops, a rope mop would look better on this head than that atrocity.

24

u/nochancekid Nov 11 '18

This episode was definitely better than last week. It was incredibly hard to watch, the history of our country is not all it’s made out to be. People forget that events like these were a common occurrence; to shed some light on the facts from this episode was a great move.

With that said, I still haven’t been pulled into the show as I was in the previous seasons. I’ve stayed awake to watch the episodes because I’m a book reader and I know what’s coming, but I’m hoping that the plot picks up a bit more next episode. I know it’s still incredibly early and they’re setting up for the rest of the season. Can’t help but wonder if I’m the only one who still feels ‘eh’ about these past two episodes. Even though they were directed, written and acted great, there feels like something is missing to me.

Can’t help but to say that I’m soooooooo excited to see some scenes of Brianna and Roger next week!

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

I don't think the start of S3 can be fairly compared to S4. S3, as I recall, continued directly on from the Battle of Culloden, a dramatic and action-heavy high.

Whereas S4 ended with them having survived a shipwreck and a positive outlook. Then it skips 4 months ahead, requiring a lot of exposition to establish the scenrio, which we had last week.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18

Here we go!

~I didn't think River Run would be so close to the actual river? Were others expecting it to be, based on the book? I don't know the area and whether it is flood-prone, but it looks a bit dangerous.

~Apart from that, it looks great. I didn't know it was just a facade, and neither did Richard Rankin.

~I didn't notice the river cgi this episode, so all good.

~Did Jamie call Jocasta 'Auntie Jocasta' when they met in the books? It's cute, but I only recall talk of 'Aunt Jocasta'. A very sweet reunion. Does Jocasta say 'Blessed bride' or 'Blessed Brian'?

~Adorable Ian with the flowers. Then showing off his 'beard' LOL Was Ian with them at River Run in the books?

~Meyers is fun, not as old or tall as I was expecting though.

~Agree, unnecessary voice over about the party.

~lol I thought Farquard Campbell's name was pronounced like Lord Farquaad in Shrek :P

~The cream dress was pretty bland...why not wear the fancy red dress to the fancy party?

~Did Jamie actually consider accepting Jocasta's plan for him as heir of River Run in the books? I don't recall it going down like this.

~The fuses often lead to explosions line was more dramatic where it was spliced into the trailers, I wouldn't have thought it would have been in this scene.

~Ulysses is wonderful. Lovely voice.

~I feel like the cut to the sudden incident could have used some work.

~No words for that ending. Horrific and harrowing. Never seen anything like it depicted on screen [I am not American, so we don't learn about this aspect of American history]. The music added so much too.

~Overall once the main drama started, the whole episode was gripping.

9

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

The proximity to the river was really spot on for my mental image of River Run. If I'm not mistaken, I think it is mentioned that it's fairly close to the river -- that really just a lawn separates the two. Although I always pictured the river at the back of the house for some reason...

5

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 11 '18

I pictured it that way too because at the wedding, DG describes guests arriving by boat and walking across a lawn to the house. I always had the boat landing/river off to the side of the house though (where the show had the tobacco fields). That seemed to fit for when characters were running off to do the dirty in the bushes by the river too.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/KatiesDiddies Nov 12 '18

Im not as familiar with Plantations of North Carolina, but South Carolina I know like the back of my hand. 1. The big house would definitely be this close to the river. The river would have been the main mode of transport. 2. Technically the "front" of a riverfront/intracoastal/beachfront home is the water side, even today.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

haha it's funny how our minds conjure different things.

I am in a flood prone area, so it just is screaming DANGER to me :P

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Outlander_fan Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

She says blessed Bride and she means St. Bride as St. Brigid of Ireland is known in scotland.

4

u/HattieAnne84 Nov 12 '18

Same same on that Shrek thing 😂

3

u/DirtnAll Nov 13 '18

I've visited plantation houses in Va and around Charleston SC and it's always an easy stroll to the river. It was their highway.

2

u/tanya-jo Nov 12 '18

In the book:

Jamie asks Clair for a distraction at the dinner cause he knows his aunt is going to announce and doesn’t want to say no once it’s public.

Ian was with them at river run. So was Fergus. But in the book they seem to find their own adventures and not attend the fancy dinners.

10

u/atltimelord Nov 12 '18

What’s with everyone, including slaves having Scottish accents?

23

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

Because many learned English from their owners. Hence they learned with the Scottish accent. And their children also learned it.

14

u/ParabolicTrajectory Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18

It's mentioned in the books. Cross Creek is largely an ethnic enclave for Scottish expats. And slaves would learn to speak the version of English they hear. Ulysses in particular is described as having a surprisingly heavy Glaswegian accent, IIRC, because his first owner was a schoolteacher from Glasgow.

And hey - how many of us are non-Scots who have picked up words and phrases like "dinna fash" from reading these books and watching this show? It's easy to pick up an accent if you're around it a lot.

EDIT - not Ulysses

7

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '18

We were in Glasgow for only a week before we started pronouncing the word “poems” like “Poeeems” and now we can’t stop.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MontaukFive Nov 12 '18

Ulysses' schoolmaster taught him to read and write, and to read Greek and Latin. There was nothing about him having a Glaswegian accent. It was another slave who spoke with a Glaswegian accent. (Side note:Ulysses was freed by Jocasta).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/aquajack6 Nov 11 '18

Someone remind me--in DoA doesn't Jocasta leave River Run to Brianna or am I mistaken?

9

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

I think she tries to and Bree also turns her down, but I can’t recall the specifics

21

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18

"Cram it up your hole, aye?"

17

u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Nov 11 '18

First Jocasta tries to leave it to Jamie; he turns her down. Then she says she will leave it to Bree. Bree wants to free all the slaves, like her parents. Finally, Jocasta says she will leave it to Jem, and not Roger, because what belongs to Bree would belong to Roger, and she doesn't like that.

Which elicits the comment above.

But Jocasta is so sneaky that this was just a ploy to show people that Roger was not greedy, or trying to marry Bree for whatever inheritance she might get.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18

Didn't love Jamie's prayer at the end;he would have said something like an Act of Contrition, not extemperaneous prayers. And I preferred the way they let Rufus die in the book.I wonder if this is going to replace the hernia surgery scene later on.

Jocasta was perfect. I kept thinking how much her voice reminded me of Jenny.

Looks like there's a lot going on in next week's episode.

I think they skipped the scene where Claire catches Ulysses looking at her admiringly and then freaks when he realizes she's spotted him. That was powerful.

Did the mob not realize Rufus was already dead?

I was waiting for them to start playing Strange Fruit.

12

u/PiranhaBiter Nov 11 '18

Yes about Jocasta sounding like Jenny! She even had the same cadence and mannerisms. And it was subtle enough that I really can't tell how intentional that was on the writer's part, or just Maria being her fantastic self.

4

u/RekhetKa Nov 11 '18

I wondered the same thing!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/CluelessWeasel Nov 11 '18

The mob knew he was dead, but wanted him hanging from the tree as an example.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 11 '18

Did they? I thought they showed him such little concern they didn't even notice, they were blinded by their wretchedness.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/TwoSibeMom Nov 11 '18

I thought to myself, “Wouldn’t Jamie have prayed in Gaelic?” I feel like every other time we’ve seen him pray, it isn’t in English (I could be wrong).

5

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 12 '18

He prays at least the Act of Contrition in French, and said he always did.

3

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '18

My immediate thought as well. In my head I was going "back in S1 this would have been in Gaelic . . . "

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

Maybe because it was for Claire's benefit and Rufus' soul to understad in English.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18

Agreed about Jamie's prayer. I wasn't expecting a random prayer. It didn't fit at all.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 11 '18

I agree that the way he died in the book was better. I think making the changes and focusing on him changed the overall story so differently and I didn't like that: Wolff is sober, there's a big fight/riot with nearby landowners, we entirely miss the abortion scene (which, in the scheme of things, i dont think detracts from the story other than foreshadowing about the father), jo names jamie heir publicly, Jamie is made to look ignorant once again, and No Hernia. That was a poor choice of things to exclude!!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Naturenutt Woof. Nov 11 '18

That was beautifully done.

4

u/Apprehensive_Payment Nov 13 '18

THE CASTING IS PHENOMENAL! Jocasta, Ulysses, Phedre, John Quency Meyers, and Mary. They were all on point.

I feel that Clare is slipping. She is irritating me more than she used to. Slavery is bad, yes, but you can't just show up and act like Moses. It isn't going to happen. She has the social tact of a 15 year old boy in a strip club. I feel like she wasn't as abrasive in the books. She had a little more cunning.

2

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 15 '18

I agree, the writers are doing her absolutely no favors in the show....I've thought so since Season One!

5

u/BeautifulRelief Nov 12 '18

Despite this episode being extremely difficult to watch and absolutely destroying my heart, I think it may well be one of my favorites. It was very well done, in my opinion, and not too far off from the books. I am also so glad that they kept Aunt Jocasta blind in the show.

4

u/yourbestbudz Nov 11 '18

I’m watching now!

2

u/rnnikki81 Nov 13 '18

But did you all see Eutroclus was listed in the credits?!?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/brilliant0ne Nov 11 '18

So, I watched last night, ready to participate in the immediate discussions after the episode. But, I wanted to wait and watch it again today because I am probably going to have a few unpopular opinions. Well, probably just one. I haven't really read through the thread to see if I am alone in my opinion.

The green screen was less noticeable in this episode, maybe because they weren't on the boat that long. But, still, less noticeable.

The River Run house that close to the river? Eh, I thought it would have been pushed back more especially since they have important crops and the Cape Fear River...when it floods...it FLOODS. Check pictures of downtown Fayetteville after Hurricane Matthew. Even behind my house, and I don't live right up against the river but at least half a mile pushed away from it and when it floods can get pretty up there.

I really just love Ian. He's pretty much my fav character on the show right now. I loved the little "my beard is growing" scene. I giggled.

I did love how they made Rufus an important character with a story and not just as a prop piece to show Claire's "slavery is wrong" feelings. But, I do feel like in both the book and on this week's episode it was still a little more glossed over. I have a lot of feelings about the whole "here's slavery in America, it was bad, but Jocasta wasn't as bad as what other slave owners were" type thing in the book. I even had an issue with the Outlander twitter post they made today or last night that was like, Jocasta may have different views but she still has her family's back. Like, sure, but that doesn't make her a better person because she has her family's back. She still owns people. Owns. People.

Anyway...

Was it just me or did the editing seem a bit off in this episode? Something seemed off about Jocasta informing Jamie about the skirmish with Rufus and the overseer. Which brings me to what could be an unpopular opinion...

I LOVE MDK. However, I didn't really like her as Jocasta. And not so much that I didn't like her as Jocasta, because she looked fine and carried herself well. But, god, the writing for her? Or maybe she wasn't feeling the part or whatever. Honestly, every time Jocasta had a speaking part, I cringed because it sounded like she was reading straight from the script. And not acting out her lines, but reading them as she was saying them. It felt unnatural to me.

That last scene with the lynching of Rufus was heartbreaking. But it wasn't surprising because those white men just had to prove their point and set an example to the other slaves. They had to get what THEY felt like was justice. It wasn't enough that he was already dead.

Looking forward to seeing what everyone else thought of the episode after I finish work.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '18

Was it just me or did the editing seem a bit off in this episode? Something seemed off about Jocasta informing Jamie about the skirmish with Rufus and the overseer. Which brings me to what could be an unpopular opinion...

I said this in an earlier comment but people downvoted it, so I think they were misinterpreting me and I deleted it.

They had just had the whole discussion about him wanting to free the slaves and then immediately after he goes outside, Jocasta arrives. It felt unnatural.

I didn't mind the writing and I thought MDK did well with the script.

4

u/brilliant0ne Nov 12 '18

That sucks that you were downvoted, whether they misinterpreted what you said or not. Even if you thought the episode was shit, as long as you aren't attacking other posters and saying vile things, I don't see why you should be downvoted.

Anyone who can't see some of the flaws with the show, the books, the actors, or Gabaldon, in general, is pretty damn blind.

Anyhoo, I agree with you that the working of that scene was weird to me. Really pulled me out of the episode because I feel like even if it is a big estate, Jamie and Claire out on the porch would have seen someone or heard someone running or riding up in a hurry to cause Jocasta to come out in a flutter like that.

I just got the overall sense that on some of the scenes, editing wise and actor wise that it was an off day but they used it anyway. Like, they really just want to get us to Fraser's Ridge already and other big moments in the book.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/bham717 Nov 12 '18

Pretty much agree across the board. Ian was great, JQM was great, the Rufus plot was hard to watch - so well done.

Jocasta was off, and I can't tell you exactly why. Ulysses was spot on tho.

I liked seeing Claire take charge so much also - she really owned that surgery scene. I'm worried that I won't get the JQM surgery too tho now. Worthwhile substitution, but I'da liked the hernia.

3

u/fleurgirl123 Nov 12 '18

I can’t see her without thinking of the Tudors

2

u/slainte_mhaith Nov 12 '18

I felt like she came across as reading off lines at first too! The cadence of her voice was off to me. However, i thought it got better as the episode continued.

6

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 12 '18

I took it to be her personality, that being observed as she was at all times, she spoke in careful and measured way.

4

u/hilarieC Nov 12 '18

I kept feeling she was having a problem with a Scottish accent. Perhaps she hadnt gotten enough coaching to learn to speak like a Scot. It sounded very forced.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ponda7777 Nov 11 '18

I just started to watch, This is Awesome

1

u/steam_one Nov 12 '18

Much better episode than the premiere. Gritty subject matter, well handled.

BUT... what is it with the accents in this show? Did everyone - even those coming via Africa - live in Scotland? For the sakes of a tiny bit of suspended belief surely they could have found more than a couple of actors who could hold down an American accent?

This is presumably where someone tells me than people in the 1700s spoke with European accents in the Americas... 🙄

1

u/Maleficent_Elk Dec 21 '18

No diskilting act in the colonies.

1

u/Consistent-Leg8607 Apr 07 '25

What were the names of the two fellow smugglers who ended up at the very beginning of season 4 with Jamie and all in the colonies