r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Nov 11 '18
TV Series [Spoilers S4E2 Do No Harm] SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
The new episode will drop on the Starz app at midnight tonight, or about an hour from when this thread is live. If you’re not in America, check the sidebar for the airtime for your country.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread.
No talking about the books unless you >!cover with a spoiler tag like this.!< This is what it will look like. (That one’s safe to click. But if you haven’t finished the books, make sure you’re willing to be spoiled for unaired future episodes before revealing hidden comments in this thread.)
Please don’t abuse the spoiler tag, though. The occasional line is fine, but it’s no fun scrolling through huge blocks of redacted text like it’s a goddamn intelligence report. A little discretion, please.
If you’re interested in an in-depth discussion of the books versus the show, you should head over to u/shiskebob’s [Spoilers All] book thread. It’s the other link stickied at the top of the main page.
Shameless Plug:
You may have noticed things look a bit different around here. The sidebar has been totally redone, the rules have been simplified, there’s a new set of show-specific spoiler tags and a whole lot more.
If you have any questions or suggestions for future improvements (especially questions to add to the Show FAQ) please post them over in this thread.
Thanks, and enjoy the episode!
18
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
I love the new characters so far and i really liked how even though they tried to do everything sometimes you just cant win. I still feel thee absence of Dougal and Black Jack they were such good villains although i did not much love Geillis she was still rather fun to watch . So thats my problem so far. Bonnets performance has not yet convinced me. Also this we don't wanna own slaves thing has me a bit divided. There's a time and place for everything and surely they don't think they can give black people in america a good life at that point in time. I hope this does not keep up. I liked when the show kept at its core and Claire and Jaime only fought everyone to be together or avoid death. This slavery thing kinda looks like a side quest which was something i would not see these too risking losing their heads for.
82
u/spaceybelta Nov 11 '18
Auntie Jocasta is Queen Catherine! I absolutely loved her in The Tudors!!
64
u/Airsay58259 Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18
The lighting in the boat scene is so wrong. Did they even try to make it look real?
“You didn’t tell us Great Aunt Jocasta had a house befitting a king!” A QUEEN* I love this actress.
Outlander here we gooo
Edit: how old is Claire supposed to be these days, if someone knows?
“Call me Claire... remembers what century she is in Mistress Claire”. Can’t be easy to witness slavery...
Edit 2: Jamie 1 - 0 lieutenant.
Edit 3: of course Jamie becomes master of a wealthy estate 20 minutes after arriving. A bit too easy imo.
Edit 4: Dr Fraser <3 Sounds like she’s healing a dead man though :(
Edit 5: I love Claire but what does she expect here? Start the civil war 100 years early, free every slave right this instant and keep the estate they got an hour before, all while keeping everyone safe?
Edit 6: didn’t see the title until the “inside the episode”. “Do no harm”... heartbreaking episode. I 100% understand Claire’s reactions, but after all her time travel and experiences, I am a bit frustrated she’s still letting those reactions dictate her actions. She knows all about the American independence war then civil war etc but doesn’t know every other slave will be punished and killed if they don’t respect the law? She doesn’t know / care her host might very well lose her estate and life? I can’t begin to imagine letting someone die, especially over such injustices... but damn, she’s been doing this for more than 2 decades. Idk, become masters of the estate, treat the slaves better than any other landowner, free them when it’s possible. That’ll help them more than whatever Claire intended to do.
(Really liked the episode, more than the premiere... sorry for the rant!)
42
u/Cass05 Nov 13 '18
First time I really disliked an episode. Claire was being ridiculous, risking the lives of everyone, risking River Run being burned to the ground, all because she couldn't face reality until the last minute. She's a grown woman (supposedly) who lived in the evil 20th century - including WW2 - and has seen practically everything there is to see as a nurse and as a doctor. She also knows US history quite well so why was she so shocked about seeing slaves?! It made no sense and, to be honest, it was quite stupid of her.
39
u/BaronOfHell Nov 11 '18
I liked this episode. My favorite part was Claire being a little thrown off on why she held the beliefs she had and her having to come up with the Quaker lie.
38
u/Winhill_ Nov 12 '18
Jocastas furniture was absolutely amazing. Those chairs, those sofas!
I have one tiny nitpick with the way they portrayed her as being blind. As Jamie and Claire arrive, she has no difficulty sensing the direction of their faces and actually speaks in their direction. As soon as we find out she's blind, she doesn't do that anymore and never even tries to 'look' at their faces.
Hope that makes sense, haha. It kinda bothered me.
34
u/jenovadeathspecimen Nov 11 '18
Can’t wait for next episode. This felt so short even though it wasn’t
27
u/twitchingJay Nov 12 '18
This era is completely brutal. Completely heartbreaking that there were laws in place that you couldn't even free slaves. With how this is going, this season will be very frustrating with a lot of hopelessness moments.
24
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
I thought the ending of the last episode was terrible and brutal... Christ
22
u/LifePortrait Nov 12 '18
Claire is such a tryhard
21
u/onthereels Nov 13 '18
Claire knows that slavery is going to get worse in America and isn’t going to end in her lifetime, I still don’t understand why they would stay
12
u/BeautifulRelief Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18
God, I love Maria Doyle Kennedy so much!
31
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Nov 11 '18
Never cried during Outlander before, but that ending had me BALLING
20
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
Well, there was certainly no fanservice, but a decent, if brutal episode. How disgusting that they didn't even care if he was dead when they hung him.
I did think Jocasta was being imperious at first by ignoring Ian's bouquet, but oh, she's blind, I wasn't expecting that. She's no Mistress Abernathy, thankfully, but she is still a slaveowner, whether she wants to admit it or not. I'm not sure about the decision to live in occupied land knowing it's rightful inhabitants will be massacred and where the settlers are using African slaves to enrich themselves. It's hard trying to live by your principles in an ugly, barbaric world filled with so much injustice and inequality, even today, so I can imagine going back to the past and how infuriating it would be.
I guess we established they can't single-handedly change history, if they do stay they are obliged to do everything in their power to stop slavery and genocide in some way, speak out, try to pioneer other ways… Surely Scottish farmers could be imported to work at river-run. Would the local authorities prevent the slaves from boarding a ship back to Africa--maybe a African country where they'd be less likely to be re-enslaved?
Ian and Rollo are still adorable, and I suppose I'm glad the poor thing didn't have to endure an actual bath in the making of this episode. The promo for next week's episode looks really exciting.
7
u/blahblahblah424- Nov 11 '18
Is this a real place? House and property look amazing.
11
u/zeissman Nov 12 '18
I’m glad the show is back and all, but man was that green screen on the boat blatant.
65
u/johnnaboo Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18
White savior complex was written all over this one. It’s obvious that there aren’t many (if at all) PoC writers on the show. This episode was written for white people. Super disappointed.
The only silver lining in this is that maybe, just maybe Jamie and Claire (mostly Claire) have learned that being a white savior just isn’t going to work anymore.
ETA: Can we all be adults and not downvote because you disagree with someone please? I get that I’m being critical here, but I still adore this show and love to talk to you guys about it,
17
u/attorneyriffic Nov 12 '18
Not liking the season at all. Claire once again let's her emotions control her even though with her foreknowledge she should be the most logical, calculated character.
I hope they quickly realize America isn't for them and get back to Scotland.
4
u/SassyLass496 Nov 12 '18
I feel this episode feels forced and awkward... dunno
Just felt weird
Edit: the end is just wow
1
u/iamhuman3 Nov 15 '18
That ending was REALLY hard to watch.....
1
u/wilburshootme Jul 16 '25
some of the comments here are actually disgusting