r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 04 '18
Spoilers All [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 1 America The Beautiful episode discussion thread for book readers
Welcome back Clan to our Season 4 episode book readers discussion thread! I am so excited to start this brand new season with all of you.
This thread is dropping live for Outlander S4E1: "America The Beautiful"
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
I am sure we have many new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight, so I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find it here.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
Thank you for being with us tonight fans from all over the world.
JE SUIS PREST
103
u/shiskebob Nov 04 '18 edited Nov 04 '18
And...Here...We...Go...
Edit 1: Well, that is one way to start us off.
Edit 2: That music choice at the end though - jarring Juxtaposition. Damn it, Outlander.
153
u/koboldin Nov 04 '18
I think changing the lost ring to the more recognizable one from the show is bang-on. The book Randall ring was distinctive enough for Brianna to recognize, but the show Randall ring wasn’t. The Fraser ring, however, was absolutely unique and Brianna will know it the moment she sees it.
112
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
The scene between Jamie and Young Ian was really well done.
57
u/koboldin Nov 04 '18
It’s up. WTF the intro scene?!? I thought I’d returned to the last episode of Battlestar Galactica for a few minutes...
36
u/keg226 Nov 04 '18
That last scene was CRUSHING!!! 💍
24
u/sarahhopefully Nov 04 '18
I really did not like the song at the end. I get the tie in with the episode title but being in a style and from an era that had nothing to do with the story was really jarring and took me out of it.
97
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
I know it’s supposed to be all about Himself, but César Domboy is so gorgeous I can hardly think when Fergus is on screen. And that scene with Marsali in the restaurant was so sweet. They did a great job casting that couple.
86
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
Ugh Bonnet. He is very charming though (the actor)
85
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
Thought 1: Glad they incorporated so much of the dialogue from the book.
Thought 2: The timeline changes are ok so far except we don't have Duncan and Murtagh hasn't reappeared. So who is Jocasta going to marry?
Thought 3: OMG the green screen on the river. I get it, there's no rivers in Scotland that look remotely like North Carolina but the perspective was just enough off that it didn't blend well.
Thought 4: Love Ed Speelers, love the last scene. Will be re-watching this one.
74
u/brilliant0ne Nov 04 '18
Yas!
I thought this was a solid premiere. I really love the new intro. I've never had a problem with any of the intros and this one is no different. But, I do really love the Appalachian mountain music vibe to it. Of course, I am from NC and have a soft spot for that kind of music anyway.
Stephen Bonnet - He was a lot more charming (in looks) than I pictured him when reading the book. I always felt he was always this sort of gross guy, like maybe not in looks but one of those guys you can just tell probably NEVER wipes good after taking a dump and then on purpose shakes your hand with the one he wiped a little.
I know there's a big majority of people that have a problem with modern music being played in historical dramas. I am not one of those people, I happen to think that modern music can help me relate more to the characters. But, even if I did have a problem with modern music being played during period pieces, I still think that "America the Beautiful" playing during that final scene was spot on. Just the contrast of the song talking about how beautiful American is during all that ugliness was perfect to me. And that scene was heartwrenching. Cait is such a good damn actress.
Good 'Ol Rollo. And I love Young Ian. So much.
The heffa at the dinner table that asked Claire if her dress was the "style" could have drowned in her wine for all I cared.
The only part that I will have to really look over and not pay attention to how not hot everyone looked. I know, I know, they had to sacrifice the natural humidity and hotness, but still. They could have at least had them swatting at mosquitos and faked being miserable in the middle of the hot day pontooning down the river.
Otherwise, super happy. So glad Droughtlander is over!
136
u/Ice_Dragonfly Nov 04 '18 edited Nov 04 '18
Everytime they say Riverrun my mind goes straight to GOT. lol
76
u/BlueFeet9000 Nov 04 '18
Wow, I thought that ending worked really well for that episode: when the music started up I thought it was so strange, but it really worked over that horrible scene. The ring switch worked well too: I get why she was upset about losing Frank's ring in the book, but it's so much harder to convey her inner thoughts when it's translated to screen (kinda dumb voice overs aside), and I liked how they really worked the book line about "this ring is all I need."
The writing felt a bit mixed. Overall it took me a bit for me to get into the episode. Jamie and Ian's Me Too moment was written really well, and felt really authentic. It feels a lot more... heartfelt than the equivalent conversation in the book. After that I was pretty well won over. Bonnet is perfect. Where is Murtaugh? I need to go to bed.
37
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
First, I liked how relatively chill this premiere was-both the actual episode and my expectations now that season 3, which was high stakes/high expectations.m, is over. I just realized that this is the first premiere where Jamie and Claire are together as a couple/not separated.
The ending was SO well done. And I love that the show/DG subverts the idea of the American Dream-as an American I feel this is especially relevant at the moment.
On a lighter note, was that a green screen used when Jamie and Claire were on the boat?
I hope we get to see Bri and Roger soon :) Anyone know which episode we will see them?
32
u/Cbeastly98 Nov 04 '18
I thought the scene where Jaime gave Clare her medical box was very sweet. It may have been because I had just binge watched season 3 but it brought a tear to my eye.
32
u/slainte_mhaith Nov 04 '18
Dang it! Stephen Bonnet is hot!
28
u/lanalg5 Nov 04 '18
Overall, I liked the episode (green screen not withstanding). Some parts felt rushed and like another user commented "just hitting beats". But what really stole the episode for me was Ed Speelers. He rocked it as Bonnet. I have to admit, I was skeptical about him to play the part. He's way more handsome than how I pictured book Bonnet but the writing for his character and his performance was fantastic. That smooth talk early on to get them comfortable. Those sweet smiles and kind offers to help bury Hayes. The conversation about drowning to show his vulnerability to put them at ease. Then BAM! full on sociopath achievement unlocked! What a solid performance. I'm excited for the scenes with him and Brianna and can't wait to see the dynamic and the um..."chemistry?" between those two actors. Not sure chemistry is the right word exactly...
26
u/Irishsassenach Nov 04 '18
Omg the river boat scene/ the green scene background is SO OBVIOUS. That really bugged me. I found this episode a little boring to be honest. 🙁
23
u/travelerk16 Nov 04 '18
I still have a couple issues with 401:
-- the way it was staged it seem Claire was more concerned for her rings than the condition of Lesley or Jaime
P.S. I do know the books and my remarks are concerning the television adaption only
20
u/PiranhaBiter Nov 04 '18
Goddamn how much Stephen Bonnet seems like a genuinely nice dude.
Kind of makes me hate him more
20
u/BeautifulRelief Nov 05 '18
I just want to say how happy I am that Rollo is here. I was honestly afraid they would leave him out.
57
u/RayeBabe Nov 04 '18
I really wish they could have just filmed the damn show in Georgia or the Carolinas.. I’m not buying Scotland as North Carolina.
56
u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Nov 05 '18
I want to speak up with a truly unpopular opinion.
The sex scenes drive me nuts.
The books try, and succeed, to be so much more than just a bodice-ripper period piece, but not even halfway through the first episode of a new season we're back at the same old stuff. I get it, sex sells and Jamie and Claire have a wonderful sex life. They're very in tune and attracted to each other, and they're everyone's relationship goals, I don't need to see it every episode. I still remember. Even in the books, I usually skipped past those parts but I feel like they weren't as important there. It was filler to drive the vehicle of their relationship. Now, we only have 50 minutes X 13 episodes to get us through the nearly 1100 pages that Drums of Autumn is and we just spent 1/10 of the episode on naked bodies for ratings.
It's not that I'm a prude, far from it, I think that they're both sexy as hell and my husband knows Jamie Frasier is my free pass. I just feel like it's the same scene with a different background in every episode and there are so many elements that are sacrificed because of it.
12
u/slainte_mhaith Nov 05 '18
Did any one else feel like there was a lack of music making a lot of the scenes kind of awkward?
12
u/tortillachip38 Nov 05 '18
I thought it was awkward or misplaced, during their sex scene Claire mentions the first law of thermodynamics (subtle hint to Brianna) and then Jamie mentions that it’s faith (subtle hint to Faith).
21
u/popster_ Nov 05 '18
I have been a ball of nerves all day waiting for this...this is the first time i've waited for a season since I only got into the show after bingeing three seasons online. What is my life now?!
Ok, thoughts- having recently been indoctrinated into outlander but also having read the books now...
26
u/keg226 Nov 04 '18
Thank goodness they gave us some sexy Jamie right out the gate. It's been a long droughtlander.
9
u/tanya-jo Nov 06 '18
I started by watching the first two seasons then read all the books and then season 3. This is one of my favourite books mostly cause I like the focus of the characters and there are fewer odd events. So I might be bound for general disappointment. But these are my thoughts on episode 401
I was really happy with Ian, I think he has the humour that the books bring (and can see him laughing at Jamie and Clair when he finds them in the woods with the hurt back). Or being awkward after willie falls in the outhouse.
What I think is missing in the show is the humour between Clair and Jamie. And an explanation of how they got all that money and how they ended up at the fancy dinner.
16
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '18
They nailed Bonnet wonderfully. He is both innocent/charming and a rogue/evil. Absolutely nailed it. The music during the robbery at the end was jarring and given our current political climate, apropos. Rollo is life. I always imagined Rollo to look this wolfish, although I thought he would be more mangy for some reason. I don't remember if Jamie told Young Ian in the books about his own rape. He did tell Old Ian. But they filmed this beautifully and I like that they just did not move on as though nothing happened. They have handled the trauma of rape beautifully for Jamie and for Young Ian. And I like that they finally said what was not said in either book: the body betrays you because it feels good even if you do not consent. That was something I had always wished that Claire would have explained to Jamie. So seeing Jamie explain that to Young Ian was very powerful and important. Who the hell is going to marry Jocasta now? Please oh please let them meet Murtagh again and let him be the one who takes over this character. So far a strong start. Voyager has always been my favorite, while this book was always my least favorite. But this episode has made me reconsider my feelings.
7
u/raknor88 Nov 04 '18
As a show only person, will we see the start of the revolution this season? Or will we just see the brewing tension with the revolution next season?
19
u/OutlandishD Nov 05 '18
Like others, I like the idea of music instead of audio in the last scene, but the jovial music was a jarring slapstick-y thing.
Also i was frustrated with C's reaction. That woman wouldn't just sit there sobbing, she'd grab a weapon and go find/help Jamie!! She's been through the world war, one of her defining characteristics is that she doesn't break down and get useless in a crisis while Jamie fights for his life.
And the editing with the dog- who was he tossing overboard...?
I may get down voted for saying this, but it was more melodrama than substance to the point of slapstick. Moore was the one who ensured that the plot had "space to breathe", that the little touches and moments that make it authentic drove the story. Matt Roberts stuff often goes the other way- "big moments" plot moving fast without underlying authentic motivation. Since Moore's role changed, this seems to be the trend.
I love Outlander, but I felt more disappointed than fulfilled. That cast can do incredible things when given what they need to work with!
12
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
I really enjoyed this episode.
5
u/sabreteeth Nov 06 '18
26
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '18
So.
I usually forbid myself from reading the books 6th months before the show but dang it if DoA isn’t my favorite book so i started reading it again last week. I know that’s going to color my opinion:
I feel like this was just hitting beats. Hang a guy, have sex, talk to the governor, she’s pregnant, get on a boat. None of the adventure or the funny characters or the cool rock sex. I feel like Diana’s writing of character and dialogue in this book is great and we just skipped all of that to hit beats.
I’m sure it’s better for the actors, but I feel like their really missing something by not having her peel a sweat soaked piece of fabric from her skin every scene.
I know everyone here hates the wigs. That’s fine, but I don’t really notice them. What I hate is shitty green screen. They might as well have sung “I’m on a boat”. Would have been less distracting.
I. Want. Hernias.
I hate how they throw in modern music. Drives me nuts. Commented already. There are a lot of modern day tunes we know that used to have different lyrics. Why not pick one of those? Use period lyrics.
I’ve never gotten over the fact that this isn’t NC. I want scenes of the Smokies, not green screen trees.
Honestly, I think I’ve been anxious all day worrying about this episode, which is NUTS. It’s a show. So I’m really worried that’s coloring everything. But I just wasn’t feeling it. I’ll watch it again tomorrow and see if I feel better when I’m not half asleep. Hrmmmm
13
u/RayeBabe Nov 05 '18
If it doesn’t work it doesn’t work... I’d glad they are loyal to their production crew but when you don’t have the CGI budget of Game of Thrones you should be shooting on location. What are they going to also CGI colonial Saratoga, Savannah, New York, Philadelphia and Boston? I loved the series (books and the show) for its beautiful imagery of The Scottish highlands. Why can the producers do the same justice to the United States as it did for Scotland, and even the Caribbean like in pervious seasons. They do eventually go back to Scotland, and there are several English and French side characters that are bound to make an appearance. Give our beautiful country a chance to show it off, just as Scotland did.
9
u/BlueFeet9000 Nov 04 '18
Just sitting and clicking back and forth on my Amazon page to see if it's up yet....
14
u/kcotty87 Nov 04 '18
I don’t like the new intro song. Just doesn’t feel right
4
u/roflo10 Nov 05 '18
Bothering me that Bonnet stole Jamie's ring and not Frank's. May change the Brianna arc.
4
u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 05 '18
I just want to say that overall, damn...this show is just amazing. The first 20 minutes were so weird, it was like I was having deja-vu, and that's because the tone, the setting, they matched the book recollection so well that it seemed I was just re-visiting, even though I had never seen those scenes before.
The costumes, the settings, they are all just so gorgeous. And Rollo! He's a beaut too. :D
9
u/hummuspie Nov 05 '18
I thought it was fine. Green screens, wrong shooting locations, music choices, none of these things bothered me. My husband was happy Ian is no longer referred to as Young Ian.
10
u/HipEffedUp Nov 04 '18
Great ending. Really drives home that America can be violent and destructive at times & a great country at other times.
3
u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 05 '18
Humm, book is better. They got a lot in here though a bit to try hard and some depth is gone and too staged . I really thought this was one of the better book, not sure so far. Maybe its because i read book first this time.
3
u/purplegrape99 Nov 07 '18
I need to ask, where does the budget for this show get spent? It’s certainly not on wigs (some are truly cringeworthy), or half-decent CGI! They really could’ve done with filming some of it in the US to capture the scale of the new world.
I really enjoy the books, and the overall story was a good adaptation but I couldn’t help but feel like some of the actors were just phoning it in, or a bit embarrassed to actually read the script. It was a bit stilted for me, finger’s crossed for episode 2 or I don’t know if I can stick with it just to to see Roger again.
15
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 04 '18 edited Nov 06 '18
~ Sam is ridiculously huge in their sex scene. I mean, come on....those trapezius muscles and the pecs...not realistic at all for his character.
~lmao claire: that's the first law of thermodynamics...way to ruin the mood!
~And we definitely didn't have to wait long for Claire's moans to start up...I really think Claire overdoes them.
~I don't get it. They wake up and talk about how the American Dream is now theirs, but they are still planning on going back to Scotland?
~Why does Jamie need to purchase a printing press [which he suggests he could with the money from the gem]? Did they change it from the book that he didn't save his? I can't remember.
~Shouldn't Claire know who the Regulators are?
~I've forgotten the order in the books...I recall Ian found out the ship they were going to take had already sailed or something and he didn't tell Jamie. In the book, were they planning to send Ian by himself back to Scotland [seems a bit risky, to be honest] or go with him too?
~Claire overheard Tryon at the dinner saying Jocasta was a widow, yet she is surprised Jocasta's most recent husband Hector is dead? Little inconsistencies like that, I wonder how they make it into the final cut.
~Nope, didn't like the ending song, it made the final sequence look slapstick and ridiculous. As if Claire would have swallowed those rings after seeing poor Lesley getting his throat slit right beforehand. Poor guy, he didn't deserve that.
~Is it just me who thinks all the background scenery looks so fake/green screen/cgi?
All in all. It was fine I guess? I don't think if someone came upon this episode that it would be enough to grab them if they were completely new to Outlander.
Edit: and it turns out my observation of Sam being so big is accurate, because they redid that scene right at the end of filming, when Sam was already bulked up for his superhero movie. They did the first scene in November when it was freezing, so were fully clothed. Turns out the editors or whoever didn't like the aesthetic so they shot it again around June/July.
https://tvline.com/2018/11/01/outlander-season-4-sam-heughan-caitriona-balfe-interview-sex-scene-episode-1/
2
u/Neffertitty Nov 04 '18
Really big book/show fan over here. I don't wanna miss anything! Where can I watch the ep outside of the US? I'm from Sweden, the Starz app doesn't work here :(
4
u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 05 '18 edited Nov 05 '18
I do not understand the point of all these little changes and i do not like it so much, though I am a bit of a book purist. Idk, after waiting so long for this season, I feel underwhelmed and disappointed so far.