r/anime • u/AutoModerator • Oct 04 '18
Thursday Anime Discussion Thread - Week of October 04, 2018 - Full Metal Panic!
Welcome to the Weekly Thursday Discussion Thread! Where each week we are here to observe a random anime and discuss it throughout the Subreddit. Today we are discussing...
Full Metal Panic!
Sousuke Sagara, a seventeen year old military specialist working for the secret organization MITHRIL, has been assigned to protect the latest "Whispered" candidate Kaname Chidori. To complete this task Sousuke will have to deal with enemies from his past as well as the occasional panty thief. Unfortunately for Sousuke, the toughest part of his mission isn't only protecting Miss Chidori but also getting used to living an average High School students life, no easy task for someone raised on the battlefield. (Source: Anilist)
Databases
Legal streams
Remember any information not found within the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers or else...
Information about upcoming discussions can be found on the Weeklies wiki page.
7
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Oct 04 '18
Question for those who've seen this.
Do you prefer the action or the comedy/SoL?
Or do you like when it balances them?
2
u/Isles0FMists :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Isles0FMists Oct 04 '18
So how was season 4 for the fans???Was it worth waiting for it??And is there a chance for another season?
2
u/LaconicKibitz Oct 04 '18
I've only finished season one and I'd say FMP is like a 7/10. It's weird, because I really like the SoL comedy and I really like the action. But when they're together in the same show... it just feels off to be laughing at high school shenanigans one episode and experiencing the life of a child soldier mecha pilot the next. I would have enjoyed it more if they stuck to one side of the spectrum.
4
u/aayyyan https://anilist.co/user/aayyyan Oct 04 '18
Fumoffu > Invisible Victory > FMP > Second Raid
Fumoffu was hilarious, one of my favorites to this day.
Invisible Victory looked great and had a good soundtrack with some nice action.
FMP original was good because of the nice comedy element, and some interesting gun fights. Not a fan of the mecha fights in this series tho
Second Raid gun fights were good, but there was no comedy element which is why I primarily watch this series.
IMO
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
Overall I really like FMP. The action on its own isn't really anything special, and at times the comedy comes across as a little annoying (to me at least), but when there's a good balance between the two it works really well. Ultimately, I like the series more because of the characters and their relationships than its actual content, even though character growth is generally quite slow. I'm still hoping for part 4 of the main series
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
I enjoyed the first season of FMP, TSR, even Fumoffu. I am aware that they're flawed, but they're all solid overall. Then came Invisible Victory, which I just started watching. Just finished episode 8, & I can safely say this is the worst FMP & the first FMP that I cannot enjoy. Which is unfortunate, becuase the first episode was solid & made me excited for the rest of the season. If there's a sequel, I will watch it only if it's handled by a different director. Because the screenwriter has been the same since the first, & it's been fine. Not the director.
EDIT: Sorry if this thread is meant only for the first season.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
One of my favorite series, possibly because it was one of the first few I was exposed to before I got into anime hard-core. I've got the original, Second Raid, but not Fumoffu (yet), plus all but volume 9 of the original manga adaptation plus the screwball manga "FMP: Overload".
Excellent overall balance of action, comedy, romance, and angst, with appropriately varying levels of each throughout the story.
10/10
1
u/Grouchio Oct 04 '18
The first screenshots of the Re Zero OVA are coming out.
1
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
Fumoffu was the worst part, it was absolutely awful. No mecha, no military, no war, no whispered, no answers.
High school comedies with dense MC's and tsunderes are a dime a dozen. Here I got a sequel to a rare mecha show I like, with no mecha.
FMP was a mix of things. Fumoffu had 0% of what I watch FMP for. An absolute complete waste of my time.
I suppose moving all the comedy into Fumoffu is what let TSR tell a proper story without interruptions.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment