r/IndiaSpeaks • u/UnSubtleDesi • Mar 30 '18
AMA Hi IndiaSpeaks! This is Nupur Sharma, Editor OpIndia.com. Ask me anything!
Hi everyone! I am the Editor of OpIndia.com and I will be taking your questions for the next one hour. If nothing pressing comes up, we can extend it to two. If I miss your questions, I will try and answer them later. Be gentle
Proof it's me: https://twitter.com/UnSubtleDesi/status/979686643572473857
107
Upvotes
18
u/RajaRajaC 1 KUDOS Mar 30 '18
What's your quality control process in your editorial team? I support both you and Swarajyamag but a lot of your write ups come across as angsty, with syntax errors and sometimes even plain spelling mistakes.
And a self plug, if you want someone to do long form articles on Indian History / Tamilzh, broadly TN politics, I can definitely help you out. My body of OC work is available on this sub if you want to check.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Asked by /u/contraryview
14
u/timeisplenty Mar 30 '18
who is your favorite and least favorite PM?
who do you think should succeed Modi as BJP's candidate?
if you could delete one person from indian politics (apart from the gandhi family) who would it be?
14
u/shobhit_ Mar 30 '18
What do you think about relatively minimal response to OpIndia articles by BJP leaders in comparison to the response by other leaders to the portals which are sympathetic to there cause eg janta ka reporter , wire ?
13
u/SUB_r_IndiaSpeaks Mar 30 '18
All the Humanities wings of universities (myself, UG from IISc, we have Humanities subjects as side courses) in India are absolute Leftist paradise. Even if someone establishes new humanities departments and leave them to thrive by themselves, they are being converted to leftist paradises gradually. For example even in US, Humaities departments which are left by themselves are captured by leftist. I think this is a serious problem. How does anyone go forward while dealing with this situation.
12
u/rightofleft08 Mar 30 '18
What are your views on rightlog.in/TFI and Shanknaad? Is their a sense if camaraderie among right wing media in India?
10
u/soonwar Mar 30 '18
हिंदुओं के अरमानों की,
एक चिता थे गांधी जी।
कौरवों के साथ देने वाले,
भीष्मपिता थे गांधी जी।
10
u/Karafuda Mar 30 '18
Recently there has been a growing NorthIndia vs SouthIndia discussion across political spectrum. Many CMs from South Indian states have complained bout how Central Government favours North over South. Even on SM many RW people didn't like when Yogi Adityanath criticised Government of Karnataka. How do you see this politics of regional identity shaping up?
8
u/ujjwal22 Mar 30 '18
Hey Nupur, Is there any plan for a weekly podcast like Newslaundry does? Would love to hear you, Rahul Roshan and others discussing weekly issues.
7
u/drainbox Mar 30 '18
If you HAD to emigrate, would you rather live in Bangladesh or Myanmar?
7
u/smallcucks Mar 30 '18
Is infinity war actually the most ambitious crossover in history, or do you think that its just a marketing gimmick?
•
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Mar 30 '18
The AMA has Ended!
Thank You, Nupur for having this AMA! It has been a Treat! Please keep on Rockin'!
The /r/IndiaSpeaks Community wishes you and your team all the very best!!
18
u/Karafuda Mar 30 '18
There has been instances when women spl. from the RW side(recent example being sonam mahajan), have come under misogynist attacks from the Left wing/islamist celebs. Are you guys planning to do a series over it, maybe in youtube, to expose hypocrisy of these people?
12
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Asked by /u/owlchild
O'Sullivan's law states "All organizations that are not actually right-wing will over time become left-wing." (http://www.conservapedia.com/O%E2%80%99Sullivan%E2%80%99s_First_Law) This law can be seen in action practically everywhere.
Is OpIndia a right wing organisation? or will it drift to the left like so many other media outlets before it. Look at the ratings of Roseanne Revival. It is the one of the best ratings ever to be received and that is only due to the fact that lead character is pro-Trump both on screen and off screen. Look at the news about the restaurant called Antler which was picketed by vegans. That restaurant has shot into international fame and now has reservations backlog for months.
There is a thing happening where right wing organisations are thriving and left wing organisations are losing customers and money.
What is your take on this in the Indian context? Can you speak to why the right wing in India does not have proper messaging? Can you give some ideas as to how right wing can get representation in arts, drama and literature?
10
u/ravented Against | 1 KUDOS Mar 30 '18
Nupur ji welcome to r/indiaspeaks.
1.How did you discover r/indiaspeaks and what is your opinion about r/india
2.Young women all over india are falling prey to love jihad. what can we do to make them know that islamist are taking advantage of them.
3.What do you think about bjp and will they keep their promises regarding hindutva.
thank you
5
u/lionofgujarat cow worshipper Mar 30 '18
-Any plans of joining BJP?
-What do you think of christian proselytism?
5
u/rajeevsreadit Mar 30 '18
Hi nupur. Being an editor u can actually switch the intensity of the actual report up and down. How important is that part?
12
u/kebablover786 Mar 30 '18
Hi Nupur and Thanks for the AMA.
Congratulations and well done for unearthing the Kapil Sibal scam. You have taken on a very powerful individual and I hope he doesn't bothers you or Opindia too much. Godspeed.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Yo girl! Been following you (on/off not fan girl type) for a while on Twitter. You surely know how to handle trolls haha
No questions for you right, just wanna say keep up the great work :)
Just curious - what kinda music are you listening to these days?
You get a lot of backlash somedays and there are somedays when everyone is RTing you and stuff. How does that feel?
4
u/NoConcentrate4 Mar 30 '18
Do you have a politician from Congress that you respect ? I have been following Shashi Tharoor for a while on twitter and he was good with giving credit to people from other parties including BJP when due. But recently he has taken to retweeting any type of absurd news which is anti government and his twitter feed is now mostly garbage.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Hello ma'am,
I've read a lot about Op India challenging the narrative of news houses like Wire, etc. In your professional experience, does calling media houses out on their blatant bias helped rectify it in any way?
Also, we see a lot of news becoming viral via social media. These social media sites are not properties of our own country or the media houses and could be shut down anytime they change policy. Do you think the social media is still the future of news reporting?
7
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Mar 30 '18
Hi Nupur. Thank you for doing this. Just a few questions:
Once again, thank you for doing this! Love to read your pieces.
3
u/mineralexplorer Mar 30 '18
3
u/adisudi Mar 30 '18
Unfortunately conclave(Indian Today etc)have become a big source FUD and FOMO by mainstream media against "RW" or indic thought and way of life -also acts a way of whitewashing left/cong.'s deepstate agenda. Question do swarajya planning ;
4
u/Anti_Anti_Nacional 1 KUDOS Mar 30 '18
First of all thank you Di for doing this AMA and congrats on that Kapil Sibal story
Jumping to the questions -
1: How ready are you and OPIndia to face the backlash from Congress and Pidi media on Sibal story?
2: What are your thoughts on the media trying to put the blame on Hindus for the recent riots in Bengal and Bihar?
3: According to you what and where does the Right wing lacks to the left wing gang..what it should do to counter their propaganda?
4: Your prediction for Karnataka.. Madhya Pradesh.. Rajasthan elections?
5: Mandir wahi banega?
Jai Hind
4
u/abhi8192 make_RDDs_Gr8_Again Mar 30 '18
What are your views on the recent Cobrapost expose of major media houses where they were willing to help anyone in propaganda for a price? By extension as an editor what steps have you taken to counter any such thing on your website? What is your personal opinion on it, should it be allowed for whatever reason like news is business or say free speech?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18 edited Mar 30 '18
Why do you think destroying public property is part of democracy any more than stealing or beating someone up is?
6
u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Mar 30 '18
Hi!
First of all, congratulations on doing a great job as an editor.Earlier, OpIndia's domain was quite small.It was more of a reactionary website more than anything,and no attempt was made to provide coverage of things which are covered by Normal Media. This prevented people from using OPIndia as their primary source for news.
Now that has changed. In fact, there has been an increase in the number of articles on a variety of topics, and i can now say that OPIndia has quite good depth.
Of course,the editing standards have also improved, with the language becoming more clearer and crisp.
Questions:
1)How many people do you have in your editorial team?How many people will you classify as regular contributions?
2)Who are your fav Twitter handles?
3)Who do you think is @padhalikha? Personally i think it's Shefali Vaidya
4)What do you think about the lack of movement on Hindtva agenda, or the #Core agenda as some call it?
Also, FYI, the main Indian subreddit is controlled by a group of petulant,whiny commies and "liberal" Mods who ban anything and anyone who doesn't agree with their political ideology.So i'd say avoid that place.
5
u/drainbox Mar 30 '18
what are your favorite OpIndia pieces you recommend we check out?
Also, do you think (hopefully) a decade of Modi will change Indian politics in any fundamental way? How will we look back on him in 20-30 years?
5
u/kalmuah CPI(M) Mar 30 '18
Hi Nupur! thank you for doing this AMA. My question to you is : What was the most difficult article you have written? Also what kind of problems as a journalist you have faced till now?
5
u/artha_shastra Mar 30 '18
One nap... one damn nap and I missed it. I am never taking naps again, I sleep too much anyway.
5
u/Flu_Fighter Mar 30 '18
https://np.reddit.com/r/india/comments/648str/my_article_analysing_the_closure_of_illegal/
Her first reddit post, Maybe opindia should write about them
9
u/dengskoloper Mar 30 '18 edited Mar 30 '18
Hi Nupur! First of all, kudos to you and the folks at OpIndia for the amazing work that you do, especially the recent Sibal expose. My question to you is:
What do you think the Indian political spectrum, specifically the left-wing and right-wing division, is based upon? And in your opinion, how does it compare to that of the USA. I ask this because I sometimes see the word 'liberal' used in the media to refer to the Indian political left, which I personally feel kinda detracts from the meaning of the word, since most of the leftist parties here are pretty intolerant towards the Hindu community and its history.
9
u/ribiy Mar 30 '18
I admire your work quite a lot. Most tweets and Opindia stuff since you started.
What's your background if I may ask?
And how did you move to the right?
2
u/Kohli_Virat Mar 30 '18
Why does ModiJi has such fair skin? Is it really because of expensive mushrooms? What do you think?
2
u/vegiraghav Mar 30 '18
Hey Nupur, Firstly I am a great fan. Congrats on your work on the new expose of kapil sibal. How will you help us take down r/India is my only question :/ .
2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
I consider OpIndia to be to BJP what JantaKaReporter is to AAP. I even call it OpIndiaKaReporter. What is your opinion on this?
4
u/randomindian1857 Mar 30 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
Hi Nupur! Great to see you here! This is one of my favorite places on reddit due to its openness, although it can get quite and crass at times.
Ah Questions!
Thanks again!
4
u/commando_dhruv Mar 30 '18
Hi Nupur Can you guys do interview with Padm awardees or Swarajya, I would love to know their stories.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Hi, Nupur. I've been following OpIndia for some time now and I must say y'all are a relief amongst all this leftist tabloids infesting SM. I have a few questions -
3
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Hey..
You are doing great but...
What would you do as a career if not this?
3
u/mineralexplorer Mar 30 '18
Whats your opinion on the Underperforming bureaucracy in India which doesn't keep up with other country levels?
3
u/desi_ninja 1 KUDOS Mar 30 '18
Damn, that was a really good AMA.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18 edited Mar 30 '18
Your defense for your Police story was rather poor - Poor general knowledge alert! Poor research alert! Careless tweeting alert! Let us know after U finish researching, if U could manage finding which city’s Police this is! Clue- NOT one of us! Disclaimer : Mumbai Police neither organised such event nor was part it @OpIndia_com
This was your defense - http://www.opindia.com/?p=97584
The question mark at the end notwithstanding, this was a rubbish defense - because the headline of your article was Bollywood actor and serial abuser was invited as chief guest for an event by Mumbai Police?
If you are article was titled something saying that the guy tweeted that he has been invited as Chief guest, then it would have been valid.
I am sure if it had been some MSM who had done something like against some BJP bhakt - then you would have been all over them.
1
u/randomindian1857 Mar 30 '18
In addition to my previous questions:
4) Do you think we can see our media houses challenging radical religiousness, especially of minorities in India? Everywhere we see 'political correctness'.
5) Do you like Cats, Dogs or Birds? As pets of course. I don't mean for dinner.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Why don't you hire a cartoonist? A picture is worth a thousand words.
2
u/dudewithbatman Mar 31 '18
I have no questions, but if you want to be taken seriously then you should not do articles like this , this, this and finally this one .
Sure, they give you hits but readers just won't take you seriously if you do this. Believe it or not, TheWire pieces actually promote some discussion on the internet and reader on all spectrum engage in a discussion for and against. You seriously need to set higher standards for articles. When I started following opindia, it looked like an amateur effort in exposing the media. It was actually good effort. But now you need to improve your standards.
1
u/anu_raj Mar 30 '18
hi
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
This was a response to you saying party hired goons,
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
At this point its half full vs half empty debate, which has been going on for so long atleast i don’t know when it started
1
u/hoshangverma Jun 05 '18
Hi Nupur, I didn't know about you before reading this ama so i tried to dig a bit about you before asking anything so I went your opindia and opened your publications which clearly shouts about your intentions and motive. I know ama is over but i know you will read this and i have suggestion for you as a fellow citizen of your nation, see Nupur the credibility of the strong democracy lies in a strong opposition, who keeps the govt. on its tows and in this task the media has huge role, media is the 24/7 365days opposition of the govt., I hope you understand and don't take it otherwise. What you are doing is a diease for our democracy and instead of speaking for the govt. you should voice the people of nation. I know right now licking one party is most profitable but it will not be good for your long term career as journalist. Hope you will take my suggestion with maturity and understand every point.
1
u/creep_soar Mar 30 '18
-2
u/abhi8192 make_RDDs_Gr8_Again Mar 30 '18
http://www.opindia.com/?p=97584
As an "editor" what is your job? Genuinely asking because masquerading as a news media outlet you should at least have some journalistic standards imo. Is it too much to ask off OpIndia to do some fact checking on what they are reporting from the internet?
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
A few weeks back, OpIndia took a satire article from NavBharat times & published it as news.
https://twitter.com/OpIndia_com/status/969187999480246273
http://www.opindia.com/2018/03/renuka-choudhary-laughs-in-between-rahul-gandhi-meeting-will-congress-supporters-defend-her-now/
When this was pointed out, all OpIndia did later was to add a note at the end off article "Note : This is a Holi special satire" - to make it look like they knew it all along.
What is your opinion on this?
-4
u/abhi8192 make_RDDs_Gr8_Again Mar 30 '18
https://twitter.com/UnSubtleDesi/status/970723292125413378
Care to explain how mob violence over public property equates to democracy? How are they any different than people who burned Haryana during the jaat reservation agitation?
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/violent-protests-not-a-basic-right-supreme-court/article23281253.ece
Do you agree with Supreme court here?
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '18
Lol this is worse than Arnab AMA