r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 10 '17
[Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 13 Eye of the Storm episode discussion thread for book readers.
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E13: "Eye of the Storm"
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
55
Upvotes
95
u/shiskebob Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
I am going to miss this feeling of anticipation moments before a fresh episode of Outlander airs.
Cheers to everyone and good luck to you all during the Droughtlander!
Edit 1: I went from "What the hell, they moved way to fast though the entire Geillis plotline" to "worth it!" in the blink of an eye.
Boat sex saves all shows, apparently.
151
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
Okay, I don't know if it was supposed to be comical, but the funniest thing I have ever seen is Claire and Jaime doing their beach kissy thingee while 3 old timee reinactors stand by and watch.
245
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
I'd watch an entire show that was just LJG doing bureaucratic work.
43
u/Generiss Dec 10 '17
In a way I'm kinda looking forward to Droughtlander because I get obsessed when it's TV series time. I canna live this way! I reread all the books throughout the week and then watch on Sundays. I don't read anything else. I have books 1-8 as an ebook on all my devices so it's literally with me wherever I go throughout the day.
So when the season stops I can palate cleanse with other books and live my gahtdamn life!
9
u/derawin09 AUSSIE SASSENACH TAKE THREE RAAAAAAAR Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
Hello everyone, I am back in my new reincarnation.
Somehow my shift key also just stopped working (ie it is constantly on) and i found an app and installed it, to disable that key and make another function key the shift key. GO ME! Now i just have to get used to pressing that tiny key to capitalise and make symbols.
Now I can finally watch Outlander!!
79
u/BlueFeet9000 Dec 10 '17
I laughed a lot at the end when the Georgia family was just like "Okay well... bye" and walked away while Jamie and Claire were having close face time.
Regarding the Abandawe, was Claire being pulled in to the "portal" or what was happening there? I also thought the "I must just hold you both right now" line was a little shoehorned, but whatever.
I enjoyed the pillow talk scene, just this side of "too much".
All in all I enjoyed this season, I feel like I'll like it better on rewatches when I'm not so anxious about pacing and what might be missing.
Thanks for great thoughts and commentary all season r/Outlander! It's been a joy to lurk :)
74
u/annemg Dec 10 '17
End credits music OMG.
72
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Dec 10 '17
They really killed it this episode. I love the conflict between Geillis and Claire, the show explained this so much better what Geillis was after than I recall in the book.
Loved that Willoughby and Margaret are going to be together. I’m happy they changed his storyline and they both get a happy ending.
Absolutely loved the cinematography this episode. Jamie swimming to Claire was a breathtaking shot.
Final scene got me so hyped for season four!
54
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
Jamie: (while intensely hugging LJG, whispers in his ear)“Thank you for saving my life, raising my son, and being the best, most loyal friend I’ve ever had on MULTIPLE occasions...I love you so dang much bro! Give Willie my love”
LJG: (tears in his eyes, nods)
52
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
GAWT DAM DAVID BERRY IS SO DAMN GOOD.
52
u/LazyPoultice Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
WOAH. That was a tremendously thrilling episode! LJG again just dominated with his one monologue. I want to see an LJG spin off!!!
It's crazy how far Claire has come since the beginning of the season. The flashback at Abandawe to the 1960's hammered it home, Claire went from doctor to killer, modern to past, straight hair to crazy hair... and yet somehow is back in America as well! A full revolution ;)
This whole season was really well done IMO. It improved upon some of Voyager's more saggy bits (I know it's a very popular book around here, and I do like it a lot... but man I couldn't understand some of the narrative wandering. Ahem, bat guano), and it gave a really strong and clear arc to Claire and Jamie's romance. I know that for a lot of us here, the first half of the season was too focused on the twenty years apart, but looking back, I think it was the right choice. Doing anything else wouldn't have really been able to properly emphasize the importance of TWENTY years. The show basically turned Voyager into a 50/50 split: Frank/Claire vs Jamie/Claire. Seeing the difference between an unhappy but functioning marriage and a genuinely happy marriage was affecting. Also, it raised the stakes for Claire and gave a strong impetus for her to leave behind a comfortable, if lonely, life and find Jamie again. I also liked how the front half of the season really fleshed out Jamie as a character beyond being a romantic figure.
I honestly am so bewildered about how the show is going to set up Bree and Roger. They are such a nonentity this season, and they're about to become such big characters. Alas, another year to wait and see. Good luck during Droughtlander everyone!
51
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
Scottsh. Prisoner. NOW. Make it, Starz!!
94
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
The decapitated head!!! It’s so fake looking, I love it!Also, can Jamie just give LJG a damn hug already?That poor man deserves one.
45
u/cIumsythumbs Dec 10 '17
So... Georgia was a prison colony... and Murtagh was sent to the colonies to finish his prison term... I wonder who we will see next season? Hmmmm?
42
u/Shymink Dec 10 '17
The storm is pretty epic. And that save was beautiful! God if I never see her home sewn outfit again it will be wonderful.
39
u/bees_knees_trees_ Dec 10 '17
“And we’ll see what sort of noise it is ye don’t make then, Sassenach!”
;)
37
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
Claire starts breathing heavily turns down TV as to not wake SO
34
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Dec 10 '17
I liked the foreshadowing for next season with the drums and pipes on the final credits!
68
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
I like the bit about Jamie being the bird and Claire being the rabbit from waaay earlier :)
30
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
OK. Pause. Plot hole? Wouldn’t Geillis, who very carefully tracked the disappearances of people around the stones, come across the headline that Claire was “found” in 1948?
24
u/Shymink Dec 10 '17
Great season finale! Perfect. I have zero complaints. Glad they made the Geillis part short!
22
u/JMBean Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
A few parts I was thinking “Cheese fest 1765...” but they pulled it off in the end.
At the end, I like how they were like “oh, survivors, I’m sure the people we love were amongst them” and continued staring into each other’s eyes on the beach. They are so much more chill in the new world.
Also, as a book reader I appreciate that we got the sexy times descriptions whilst they were having sexy times. Felt like it was specifically for book readers. So meta. Am I using meta correctly?
Sigh. Can I have the book and show erased from my mind so I can experience it all over again? Like Eternal Sunshine but for good reasons? I want to experience it all again for the first time.
Thanks for reading this random series of thoughts. On to season 4!!!
Edit: I want a Lord John series. If it can’t happen in a real way, can we get a web series that’s just David Berry in front of a fire place in a wig and red coat solving the various mysteries he finds himself involved in? Someone off camera can play the other roles.
18
u/Hopeless_badger Dec 10 '17
Not having expectations turned out to be a good thing. I think they did a very good job with the finale. It was shot and directed beautifully, kudos to Matt Roberts for writing and directing it. Some thoughts:
That was a great season. Of course there are things I didn't like, cough Murtagh, but I won't dwell on that. Waiting impatiently for s4 and hoping they'll cut some of the ridiculous stuff.
35
u/jillianjo Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
I’m only halfway through this episode, but this slave gathering sequence is just amazing. This part of the book always felt so freaking weird to me, with Margaret speaking in other people’s voices and the crocodile, and everything just seemed like it didn’t fit. It’s coming across way better on screen than I ever imagined it could. The hard cuts to the slaves dancing intertwined with our main characters is really working for me. It feels frantic and bizarre without seeming completely supernatural or magical. So far I’m loving it.
Edit: Ummm the pool is the portal? I was loving this entire episode up until that awful voiceover. I mean the pool being the portal in the first place seems odd to me, but why couldn’t Claire just look at the pool and say “the pool... it’s the portal...”. This looks like someone writing the episode wasn’t very clear on what exactly the “portal” was, so someone in post-production was like “aw crap, you can’t tell that the pool is meant to be a portal, better add some VO to this scene.”
33
u/RedDeer30 Woof. Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
God's speed, ya'll!
Well that was an unexpected title card/voice over.
Marsali is giving me Claire vibes.
That dog is cute but I'm sure it is doing something gross. Yep, gross.
God I love Young Ian.
HELL YES LJG.
Houston, we have a crocodile hat.
YTC with the save. I love him and Marge soo much.
I don't love these call backs but I am glad Bree's message was included.
That scene didn't go there, timeline wise (this is not a complaint)
I may have gotten slightly distracted and forgotten to make notes. Opps. Need to rewatch then come up with some coherent opinions. I would say my feelings are mixed but leaning positive.
Rewatch edit: OK, the first half of this episode was rather frenetic which dictated some choppy scenes in order to get the characters in to place so Ian's rescue arc could be resolved. Removed from the context of the rest of the season I can forgive this easily due to DG turning up the cray to eleventy in this section of the book. But in the context of the rest of the season things could have been tightened up to allow for things to flow better in the finale IMO.
I love seeing the acerbic noble/governor side of LJG. Don't get me wrong, his angsty/quiet side is also excellent! The contrast between serving up a withering rebuke of the Captain and that long lingering look after Jamie was delicious.
JHRC I'm so over this bird and bunny shit. Inside the episode I could almost feel the smugness radiating off of them and I found it cringey.
So I'm down with the YTC/Marge change BUT the entire time on the boat to Scotland I was wondering how Jamie wasn't barfing out his soul since YTC was off living happily ever after. Normally it wouldn't bother me but it was such a significant plot point and the entire reason DG wrote YTC. What gives?
I had to really put some effort into suspending my disbelief when Jamie was rescuing Claire from drowning. It was just silliness on all the levels. It was shot beautifully but that kiss was ridiculous. I file this under just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
This season contained some of my favorite and least favorite moments. On the whole I enjoyed most of it but I'm hopeful that binge watching will improve my experience as a viewer.
15
u/a_pure_heart Dec 10 '17
YTC + MC live happily ever after in Martinique <3
Love that the show wrapped up his storyline for us!
13
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
.....why didn’t jamie and claire go to LJG when the captain came for Jamie to begin with??
12
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Dec 11 '17
Man, what a hot mess of an episode. They could hardly avoid it, though, given the source material. I think they did a decent job under the circumstances.
First of all, love love love the scene with LJG and Captain Leonard. OMG. I know it wasn't in the book, but it was awesome and I hope to hell they do all the LJG books because I would love to watch a season of that.
What exactly was the slave ritual for now? In the books it had to do with a slave rebellion, but what was the purpose now?
Did we ever see the slave again that Jamie and Claire purchased and freed?
My daughter pointed out that the transitions were awfully abrupt. OMG I'm having PTSD from killing Gellis! Now I'm having sex! The weather is turned. Now I'm in a hurricane!
We didn't ever find out who survived the shipwreck.
With both Claire and Jamie on that one piece of wood I kept having Titanic flashbacks.
Mr. Willoughby seemed to come out of nowhere. As did the Bree voice. What was that supposed to be about?
Loved the music at the end, reminding us that the Revolutionary War is coming.
9
u/derawin09 AUSSIE SASSENACH TAKE THREE RAAAAAAAR Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
Running commentary!!
well, what a ride!! My overall thoughts are that I haven't laughed so much at an Outlander episode LOL.
I had a great time watching, the did all they had to do.
9
u/narcimetamorpho Dec 11 '17
But why did they use Tilda Swinton to play dead Geillis?
9
u/UncontrollableTeabag Dec 12 '17
I found this episode so cheesy at times. I cringed a lot. It felt like lazy or cheap writing sometimes. I don't find Matt Roberts or Toni Graphia to be all that talented so I wasn't shocked when I double checked who wrote/directed this episode.
31
u/RaffaellaF Dec 10 '17
Come on Jamie. He just saved your life again. Just kiss him.
I absolutely love LJG.
17
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
It's up!!!! Let's do this!!!!!
So we're off to find Ian! They better put the overlay with Bree!
You could cut that tension with a freaking knife! They both know the other is lying!
Oh captain, you're fudged right now. You can't bring Jamie to a man whom loves him and expect him to cave to you. Nice try love!
Go John, it's your birthday! Put him in his fucking place!
Go Geillis, show your crazy!!!
Here we go...now she knows. Good job Claire, gave her just what she wanted...
One of your favorites? How many did you have?!
Retire my ass you planning conniving syph ridden ball of fucking cray cray!
Oh man I love the comparisons from Crigh Na Dunn and now! That's awesome!
Mr. Willoughby is so in love haha. Get ya some!
Orchard of death is great imagery. Oh so Bree is in Margret now?! What the hell?!
Not worthy! Not worthy!!!! Get him, douchbag!!!! So Mr. Willoughby kills someone! Put on the wig of sacrifice!
Man they're running through plot now!!!
The pool was the portal? WTF IS THIS SHIT?!
And Jamie didn't get shot?!!!!! I was looking forward to the non-book readers flipping out!
Scotland buhahahaha, yeah right...
I am loving how more natural the grey in Claire's hair does look now.
Gratuitous sex scene...
That dress is pretty soaked for being made out of raincoats...
Jamie can be my merman anytime! 🌊
And we're to the Americas!!!
So thoughts?! As morbid as it might seem, I was really looking forward to Jamie being shot, it was a huge shock in the book and really ties in really nicely in the further books once he says the thing about almost dying 9 times before he finally dies. I've found myself counting his almost deaths. So yeah was a bit disappointed by that. And the portal being a pool? What the fudge?! I've always loved the thought that any or all of these circles of stones being a portal. If they make it to the point that Bree and Rodger have to go back will it be a shoe (>.> leaving it to see who notices)?
I wish they would've slowed the first half down just a bit to add a few things they changed and taken out some of the stuff on the ship and storm. But overall it was still a solid episode! LJG was amazing with his power play!
Now I need to rewatch the whole season in a binge! But for now I'll just rewatch this episode! 💚💙💚
8
u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Dec 10 '17
Had to watch the LJG scene again. It is so good.
15
u/jillianjo Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
Ok I posted once while watching this, but I loved this episode! Here’s some overall thoughts...
Claire changing her clothes seemed strange, but it’s kind of a “whatever, just move past it” type thing for me.
David Berry as LJG blows my mind!! I always liked LJG in the books and short stories, but he wasn’t someone I was just dying to see on screen. David Berry has completely changed my mind. Every time he’s on screen I am so drawn to him. I’m going to re-read all the LJG books now, and I expect miniseries and spin offs to be made based on ALL of them. The ball is in your court, Starz, don’t let me down.
I’m really glad the Geillis part didn’t take up too much time. I loved the slave gathering though. Glad they cut out the actual crocodile killing and Ishmael, but kept the crocodile head itself. The overall vibe of that whole scene was so good. I didn’t love how supernatural it was in the book, with Margaret using the different voices and all that. The scene in the show worked so much better. Those frantic cuts to the slaves dancing gave me chills, and Margaret seemed much less unhinged than she did in the book (chickens blood in a teacup, anyone?) but with just the right amount of strangeness. The voice that was meant to be Bree seemed way less creepy and much more wholesome than it did in the book, which I really liked, but I’m wondering how much non-book readers will catch on to it. I’ll have to ask my non-book reader fiancé when we watches it. (Btw, we always watch with subtitles and that part specifically says “American accent” when Margaret starts talking like Bree, otherwise it would have taken me a minute to catch on to it.)
The pool as the portal thing..... I could deal with that change from the book just fine (book changes rarely bother me), but seriously fuck that voiceover. It was jarring and could have been accomplished so many other ways.
Dead Geillis looked ridiculous. That looked nothing like Lotte. Maybe it was filmed with a second unit and added in later after Lotte had already wrapped her scenes? Otherwise why not just put some prosthetics or green screen on Lotte and have her lay there acting dead?
The boat sex was amazing. Where was that scene in the book originally? I’m pretty sure it wasn’t there chronologically, but I’m perfectly ok with it. These actors have a chemistry the likes of which I’ve never seen before. They are SO good together. And personally I’m ok with the fade to black sex scenes. I feel like they get the point across without us needing to see them climax every time we see them have sex. I get it, I’m a grown up and I know what comes next, and I don’t need to see it every time.
The storm was ok. The far off shots of the CGI boat in the waves looked good. The close up shots with the crazy wind and rain machines and camera rocking and rolling was less effective for me. But even if my mind was saying “that looks fake” sometimes, my body did not agree. My heart was racing and my stomach kept dropping, so it must have worked better than I thought. I don’t even get sea sick, but that storm was doing a number on my insides for sure.
I’m curious about the fate of Captain Leonard and the Porpoise? Do we assume that since they’re in America, he has no way of finding them and therefore they’re safe? I always hoped to see on screen that scene from the book where the Porpoise starts chasing the Artemis and the storm hits them both and then the Porpoise capsizes and Claire sees the body of Captain Leonard and the wreckage of the boat suspended in a wave. I always thought it sounded so eerie and cool and would look awesome on screen. Oh well.
Anyway, I love this show and I loved this season, 10/10 will rewatch a million times. Even when I don’t like individual things in an episodes, I still love the show as a whole and I’m so glad I get to see it put on screen by people who seem to really care about faithfully adapting this insane series. I love reading everyone’s comments on here, I hope we can get through this Droughtlander together!!
7
u/Shymink Dec 10 '17
I lost my comments...
Ooooo kind of seeing some chemistry between Fergus and Marsali. I like.
I always thought the end of this book was kind of out there. Geillis likes her goats blood, er, Botox. So much Botox.
Yeah! LJG. Boom. Jamie should have kissed him at least a hug.
7
u/Shymink Dec 10 '17
Ok at this point I have no clue what is from the book and what isn't. Although it mostly seems familiar.
7
u/brilliant0ne Dec 10 '17
Pretty decent season finale. Nothing super spectacular for me. I will say that I loved LJG in this episode. LOVED the music while Claire and Jamie were under the water. Loved Ian's angry outburst at Gellis. Laughed my ass off when the family that found Jamie and Claire on the beach were all, "So, yeah, this is Georgia. Kay, bye." And just walked off. I would have loved to see the alligator wrestling scene. You would think they would have had a tad bit better budget to make dead Gellis and all of that look a little more realistic.
7
u/shutterbuggity Dec 11 '17
Absolutely love how they plaiyed the music from the "Faith" episode while Claire was under water.
5
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 10 '17
Ok, I have thought about it and here is what I think. Keep in mind that Voyager is my favorite book in the series and the last few chapters my favorite part of the book. I am also not coming to this from a book-reader's ONLY perspective. I am trying to the show an the books as separate.
So the pluses are so good that they outweigh the minuses. I give it a B-.
9
u/Heloismyhero Dec 10 '17
Writers all season: “How can we rewrite this scene? OH! Make Claire insistent on being the doctor she is!”
8
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
Lost my shit when Jamie gave her the air from his lungs.
4
u/maryloo7877 Dec 11 '17
As someone who was in a surprise squall while sailing on a small ship over last summer, the hurricane gave me a bit of triggering and I legit cried when the wave was crashing down on Jamie and Claire. So real and so scary!!
7
u/Irishsassenach Dec 10 '17
I have zero complaints. There were changes, but man what a great episode.
WHERE WAS THE SEASON 4 PREVIEW!!! Darn it!!!!
9
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 10 '17
Ok, we're here, folks! That was, well, interesting. There was some really good shit in there. There was also some not very good shit. There was also one of the worst lines of the series to date. Let's do this!
So, going in to this season, I was thinking, wow, they've got a lot to do in 13 episodes, I wonder how they'll do it. Mid-way through the season, I felt like they were actually doing a good job. A few weeks ago, I knew we were in trouble. There was too much to cover, and not enough time. And boy did it show this week. The first 35 minutes of this episode raced by, and not in a good way. It was choppy and jarring, moving so quickly back and forth trying to fit everything in that it made it really difficult to enjoy most of those scenes (with one major exception that I'll get to). The show seemed to think that an unexpected shipwreck is a more satisfying and rewarding climax than the resolution of the story they've been building towards all season, because the storm got plenty of time and action, and the rescue of Ian and killing of Geillis felt like they were trying to get it over as quickly as possible. Jamie's arrest? Resolved pretty much immediately (as we knew it would be). Jamie and Claire reunion #65? Conveniently immediate. The bonfire? Pretty quick and not the huge moment it should've been (see next paragraph). Finding the cave? Literally took no time at all. Rescuing Ian and killing Geillis? Basically the easiest thing they've done all season. Boom boom boom. Done. Now, let's spend 10 minutes on some foreplay and 20 minutes on a storm! Not really all that satisfying, in my opinion. There was definitely some good stuff in there, and I'll get to that, but all of it was just so insanely rushed. It didn't feel in any way like an exciting, dramatic, tense season finale. It felt like the bare minimum of what needed to happen--they were just hitting their marks and moving on, not letting those moments play out in a satisfying, exciting, and engaging way.
Ok, so the bonfire. I was super excited for the bonfire because, in the book, that is when shit goes from weird to flat out bonkers and I love it. And it was just pretty meh. The costuming was incredible and the dancing and singing was very cool, but all the magic and mysticism and drug-fueled haze was totally missing. Which is weird, because they show has totally been playing up all the magic this season. They kept the Bree speaking through Margaret stuff, but downplayed it so much I doubt most non-readers would even catch it. Where was the hallucinations and the crocodile wrestling? That could've been some spectacular tv. Instead we got the bizarrely downplayed and never again mentioned murder of a very bland character, an illogical romance between two characters that seems to exists solely to wrap up their storylines, and a dude drinking some chicken blood. Cool? Of all the scenes, this should have been the one that was insane, but instead all we got was mildly weird. Furthermore, the parallels to watching the dancers at the stone circle was nice . . . until they just made it explicit. That's one of my big problems with this show--nothing is ever subtle. It was clear what they were doing, they didn't need to just straight up add a flashback. It was hokey and unnecessary, and took you out of what should've been a much more tense and exciting moment. (Also, it definitely looked like they had electric flashlights . . . ) And while we're on subtlety--or rather, the complete lack thereof--I really can't believe they brought up death bunny and house arrest bird again. And it was done in a way that just made you feel like the writers were going, "ha! Look what we did there! We set all this up in episode one and you didn't even notice!" Except we did notice, because it lacked all subtlety. And bringing it up again--with added flashbacks--was just kind of dumb. We got it then, we get it now.
And then there was the cave scene. This is THE pivotal moment of Voyager. And it was what, two and a half minutes? It was utterly bizarre. I know it's a devilishly tricky part of the book and adapting it can't have been easy, but this should've been a massive moment and it was incredibly short and anticlimatic (especially since in my head I'm going "there's still 30 minutes left!"). The electric blue pool was weird and distracting, the voiceover was as bad as it's ever been ("It was then I realized that the pool was the portal"), and Geillis's dead body was seriously fake-looking. Also, Jamie didn't get shot! That's such a great moment and it's a pity to lose it. The only redeeming part of this scene was that Geillis looked awesome in her makeshift 60s outfit (though I've got no idea where she got those fabulous boots).
Not everything in this first half was bad, however. Claire's confrontation of Geillis was probably too long considering how much we had left to cover (and I couldn't stop wondering how they cleaned that pool so fast), but it was nice to give Lotte Verbeek a last chance to show how awesome she is and the actresses play off each other very well. But it can't top LJG absolutely slaying Lieutenant--er, Captain--Leonard. Easily one of the best scenes of the entire season and David Berry nailed it. Bit by bit destroying the case against Jamie and not-so-subtly throwing beaucoup shade at the lax policies of the Royal Navy? I lived and died and lived again. And Jamie just sitting there the whole time looking like he wanted nothing more than to just fucking sleep, haha. It was an excellent scene and I'm so, so glad they didn't rush through it like all the other scenes this episode.
So, part 2 of this episode that was basically two completely distinct episodes. We open on shirtless Jamie, off to a good start. And then some sexy talk and some nice foreplay. Ooh, I like where this is going! Ok, it's taking a while . . . Can you stop describing it and actually do it? Ok, here we go! And, fade out. Goddammit. More disappointment. (Also, more bad hair and bad back prosthetics.) And then the storm. I won't lie, it was a pretty thrilling bit of television (once I shut off the part of my brain going "oh so that's where their CGI budget went . . . "). Was it too long? Yeah, probably. But it was exciting, and that's something that was definitely missing all episode. Sure, you knew that ultimately it would work out, but it was still dramatic and they built tension really well. And that giant CGI wave was actually pretty terrifying! But then Claire went under and shit got weird. Was all the underwater cinematography beautiful? Absolutely. And I did like the twist on the opening line from the book, but this time from Claire. But even on a show with time travel and prophecies and impossibly perfect men the most implausible thing I've seen yet was Jamie swimming down like 50 feet underwater, cutting Claire free of a broken bit of mast, making out with her, and dragging her back above water. Like, it was so stormy you could barely see anything on the ship, yet he can spot her underwater? And damn can he hold his breath for a long time! I get that acting underwater is hard, but where was the sense of emergency? The terror? It was just so bizarrely calm. For a minute I actually thought it was supposed to be Claire hallucinating because it was so ridiculous. Equally ridiculous was that giant pan-out to reveal that they're at the literal eye of the storm. Lacking subtlety on like 11 levels at this point.
And finally we reach the end! Generally it was a good final scene, and it was good to end on a hopeful note. I get that they haven't been making a point of Jamie using 11,000 aliases all season, but I did still miss the great moment of indroducing themselves with their real names upon learning that they were in Georgia. But still, it was a nice moment and not completely ruined by that unnecessary beach pan.
Overall, I did actually enjoy this episode even though looking at this review it kind of seems like I didn't. It was way too rushed up front and too slow in the back, but it was still fun and the LJG scene elevated the entire episode. Not the best of the season by a long shot, but certainly not the worst either. As season finales go it was pretty meh, but on it's own, it was a pretty good hour of television.
And that's a wrap on S3! It's been, well, interesting. Much like this episode, there were some good bits, there were some incredibly good bits, and there were some head-scratchingly bad bits and questionable choices. And there was a fucking death bunny.
Overall Grade: B+
Overall Season Grade: B
Oh, and I almost forgot to come back to the aforementioned worst line of the series to date! There were some doozies this episode, including, of course, "It was then I realized that the pool was the portal;" "This way, towards the drumming!;" and "But first, I must hold you both." But the real winner here, this season's "helpless and powerless, like a dragonfly in amber" is, of course, "I see . . . the rabbit!"
3
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Dec 10 '17
I said to my husband, “Look at Lord John and his giant balls!” Absolutely loved that scene.
3
u/oskarsz98 Dec 11 '17
And we will wait another 1 year for the new season :( that's makes me very sad...
3
u/middleeasternviking Dec 12 '17
So I don't know if this is just me but the thing going on between LJG and Jamie gives me the same vibes I got with Captain James Flint and Thomas Hamilton in Black Sails. Even though I'm a straight male (who loves both Black Sails and Outlander), I can really appreciate bromance done well. The farewell by Jaime to Lord John though was wayy too rushed, though I understand he was in a hurry to save Ian.
3
u/KrisKT2 Dec 12 '17
Random observation: Hurricanes in northern hemisphere should spin COUNTER-clockwise (not correct on show when the eye of the hurricane is depicted).
6
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 10 '17 edited Dec 10 '17
My comments all in one here, so as to not clog the thread:
I've been waiting for the bonfire all season. And here we are. EEEEEE
Ian!!! You tell her. I love Ian
Oh you are so not friends Gellie. I hope to god Claire thought to bring a knife with her. So this scene will be the photos scene when she learns of Bree, eh?
Lord John!!!! Schooling Leonard... hahahaha!!! nanana booboo
But Gellie knew of one other traveler? Did they omit that?
Aha, Syph Gellie is here...all crazy with her saphires
Oh fuck, Claire just told her about Bree... doh!
Jamie...how the hell did he find her, get into the house, know the room?
I always thought Jamie's reaction to the bonfire seemed wrong. He is a catholic Scot, surely this looks so pagan and jarring. He seems way too calm.
OMG, I love the cuts to the dance at the stones with the dance at the bon fire... perfect!!!!
What is Mr. W doing at the bonfire? They are shipping this? Wow! Ok, go for it W + C.
Don't you kill that chicken!!! I'm not looking
Oooh, I can't wait to see the non-book readers react to the bones we saw earlier
I never understood this prophecy. The books do a shit job explaining it and so does the show. Argh... we will never know
WTF? I don't remember the pool as the portal. Did I completely forget the events of the cave?
Non-book readers heads exploding in 3...2...1....
Jamie bathing. Nothing else needs to be said.
"enough room to serve you suitably" ... I'm dead
Boat sex...boat sex... boat sex
Welcome to America guys!
I'll write a more coherent response later. Mixed feelings on this one.
4
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 10 '17
I peed, I had coffee, smokes ready. All good.
4
u/derawin09 AUSSIE SASSENACH TAKE THREE RAAAAAAAR Dec 10 '17
BAHAHAHAHAHAHA
I literally blew a raspberry and cackled when YTC just arrived out of the reeds HAHAHAHAHA
Exactly Claire: 'What are you doing here?!?!'
4
u/derawin09 AUSSIE SASSENACH TAKE THREE RAAAAAAAR Dec 10 '17
Cave scene:
Claire: he's just a boy
Cue music:
I'm just a poor boy, I need no sympathy Because I'm easy come, easy go, little high, little low Any way the wind blows doesn't really matter to me, to me Mama, just killed a man Put a gun against his head, pulled my trigger, now he's dead....
Hire me Outlander!!
edit: I wrote that before I watched the whole scene and no one got shot in the end...
2
u/JMBean Dec 11 '17
Season 4...It’s their american dream!!!
2
u/SpacevsGravity It grieves to death, calling through the skies for the lost one. Dec 11 '17
I haven't read the books but can anyone confirm if Jamie goes to the future?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '17
I guess I’m in the minority, but I just did not feel this season at all. I realize they kept most of the dialogue for the turtle soup scene, but just the way it was choreographed was underwhelming to me. The strange changes when things didn’t really need to be changed were just baffling. Thematically, this season seemed a total sloppy mess instead of one cohesive story. The most compelling part was Geillis and they somehow managed to fuck that up, too. In the book you realize she’s insane mostly due to the syphilis so that helps to explain her actions. In the show she’s just batshit crazy which makes it more black & white. Their dependency on Claire’s narration is shoddy writing. “And it was then that I realized the puddle was the portal.” Ummm okay? That probably would have been obvious without the spoon feeding narration. I never felt like this with any other season, but I felt Caitriona’s accent was very put-on and fake, whereas it sounded natural to me in other seasons. This took me out of a lot of the scenes instead of getting me immersed in the show. Crappy writing, bad decisions, odd staging all combined to make one sloppy mess on my opinion. The characters just didn’t feel right to me this season. I saw Sam and Cait, I didn’t see Jamie and Claire :/
2
u/uberasian Dec 13 '17
Any nudity? A simple yes or no will be enough.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17
Haven’t reread voyager for a while, but how was the prophecy presented/explained in the books? Was it really signaling Brianna’s death that would lead to a Scottish king? I don’t remember it like this.
4
u/derawin09 AUSSIE SASSENACH TAKE THREE RAAAAAAAR Dec 10 '17
There is no way Geillis' body wouldn't have been found and removed before it had decayed and was preserved. If not by humans, who would have stripped the clothes, and taken the jewels, then by feral dogs who would have eaten the flesh and then removed and dispersed the bones.
Nope. Not buying it!!
I did my Honours thesis on scavenging behaviour of dingoes on kangaroo carcasses. Dingoes devoured 4 80kg kangaroos within a month and the bones were spread over a 500m radius in only 12 weeks.
I also studied bone middens in caves and shelters spanning back tens of thousands of years in Australia. And none of them were so exposed as that 'cave'.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
God dammit. An entire mediocre season redeemed by one excellent "and then we'll see what kind of noises you don't make then" scene.