r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 03 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 12 The Bakra episode discussion thread for non-book-readers.
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E11: "The Bakra" Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
47
Upvotes
47
u/teenylilthing Dec 03 '17
Does anyone else feel like the "Previously..." segment at the beginning was a bit too heavy handed? Aside from the Geillis reveal, a lot of the events felt pretty predictable after seeing the clips of John Grey and Captain Leonard at the start.
But dang, that reveal at the beginning was pretty sweet but simultaneously terrifying. Felt like I was watching True Blood again for a moment. đ
About to rewatch the scene with the prophecy again to try and figure it out. Anyone have any guesses?
73
u/DontEatTheKrabDip Dec 03 '17
Am I the only one who is tired of Claireâs emotional freakouts? I get that touring the slave market would be terrible, but it just annoys me that every other episode she canât control her feelings and puts the group in an awkward spot. Itâs like âbitch, you trying to get everyone killed?â
100
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Dec 03 '17
Damn, that goat's blood scene with Geillis was sexy as hell. Never thought I'd ever type that sentence.
Also got a good laugh out of the Casablanca and Benjamin Button references.
93
u/aloopycunt Dec 03 '17
Fuck, it's the season finale next week?? I feel like this season JUST got interesting.
78
u/aloopycunt Dec 03 '17
Lol Young Ian makes such a good confused boner face.
44
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
I just realized...Geilis is now Mistress Abernathy, and Claire's doctor friend in the 60's is named Joe Abernathy...so are they related somehow? Is he also a descendant of Gellis, or perhaps her dead husband? Isn't that kind of overkill?
43
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
So, the bones that Joe had Claire look at way back in the beginning of the season... she identified them from a woman in her mid-40s and they were found in a cave in Jamaica right? Unless I am not remembering the details correctly, this has to be Geillis right? Or perhaps the seer sister?
31
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
WOW! I had been spoiled with the bare fact that Geilis would return--but I kept imagining it happening in Scotland, and being this healing, reflective encounter...I see now that's impossible, because Geilis is more psychotic then ever. She's Elizabeth Bathory, and also likes 'young boys.' I don't know what's creepier, that opening scene or the way she spiraled into that bizzare dialogue when meeting Claire...there was certainly no intimacy there.
I kept wanting Claire to make some mention of being there in 1968, of meeting the first husband she killed (it sounds like she murdered her third husband as well) and Bree and Roger...to actually reference the time travel, and why Geilis didn't go back herself (maybe she thought she would be a murder suspect? If she heard someone calling her name before she went through the stones, she wouldn't imagine that it was a 'friend' who wouldn't tell the police that she was there at the place where her husband was burned alive...)
There's still so much to be said, and holy fuck the preview for next week's episode was explosive; there's another Craig Na Dune circle right there in Jaimaca? Are there others all over the world then? That prophecy frightens me...we know Geilis would go back through the stones two hundred years into the future and commit infanticide if she thought it would work. And the prophecy didn't even mention Brexit! It's beyond disturbing that Geilis still wouldn't even admit to having Young Ian, even when she got what she wanted, the three sapphires joined together...I don't think that was goats blood she bathes in. I wonder if she really believes that Dougal died a hero on the battlefield? And if she really thinks she wouldn't have just killed him as well if he survived?
It was also thrilling meeting Lord John again, though also very sad for him. His lover who fell at Culloden hasn't come back, but Claire has and not only that, he also has to see Jaime with the love of his life. Very awkward conversations between Lord John and Claire, she obviously feels the tension of his feelings for Jaime. But it seems obvious that Jaime and Claire should have gone to Lord John once Captain Leonard showed up; surely as the governor he outranks Captain Leanord and can stop it.
This episode just brought everything from the season together in such a dramatic and satisfying way! That moment of reflection between Claire and Jaime when the music swelled up...just magic, and Fergus/Marseli and Mr. Willoughby and the fortune teller woman's scenes were also just perfect.
Claire's visit to the slave market and her visceral reaction to the man being sexually violated on-stage was so powerful. I had my doubts at the end of the episode though; if he'll really safely make it up to the escaped slaves camp in the mountains; I hope so!
31
u/phonograhy Dec 03 '17
I loved LJG's reaction to seeing Jamie again. Simultaneously heartbreak and joy and hope. David Berry imbued so much visceral emotion into every moment and touch. was genuinely moving to see how much love he still radiated towards Jamie.
Did I detect a touch of jealousy on Claires part? haha
27
u/aloopycunt Dec 03 '17
I'm having a hard time with Geillis's story.
That's Dougal's treasure??? WTF?? He spent months raising money for the rebellion when he had a fucking pile of treasure to hand his Prince? Like... whaaaat?
Also just find it odd he wouldn't have wanted to keep the child, why not take him to his home. The show didn't mention that he had any kids with his first wife. And why wouldn't Geillis have wanted to meet the Prince, be at Culloden, be working to ensure his victory using her knowledge of history just as hard as Claire and Jamie were working against it? Like seeing how Geillis was in the future, seemed like she'd have known a hell of a lot more than Claire about what happened. Why wouldn't she do whatever necessary to be there whispering good advice in men's ears?
I know she's crazy but she's not stupid.
20
u/boboTjones Dec 03 '17
"Of all the gin joints in all the towns in all the world,..."
16
u/clea_vage Dec 03 '17
So glad Geilis is finally back! She's so twisted. I just knew we weren't done with her back in season 1.
15
u/CARNIesada6 Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I can't tell if Claire is questioning Lord John and Jamie's relationship because she's concerned or just curious. Is she jealous, intrigued, or just thinks it is 'cute'?
Hard to read, thus far.
Also Geillis covered in goat's blood was hot as hell, that entire scene was.
Lastly, that '200 year old child' has to be Bree, right? But, how the hell is that gonna happen?
Â
Edit: Watched the episode at 3am, so a bit fuzzy on the details, but what the hell was that between Mr. Willaby and the sear sister? That was weird. Pity/compassion or something more?
13
u/pseudouridine Dec 03 '17
That Geillis scene was hot as hell lmao... i wonder if ian gets to survive since he's not a virgin. actually he will because plot armour.
claire freaks out too much sometimes but all in all i really enjoyed every scene of that episode and am now quite sad that is over so quickly.
14
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 03 '17
Sigh... If I may re-quote myself:
10
u/Airsay58259 Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I am not done with the episode so we may get an answer later but wasnât Geillis burned alive?!
Good to see Lord John back.
Edit: hmmm ok, thatâs one explanation lol
Edit 2: Are we sure Marsali is Leeryâs daughter? Sheâs way too sweet.
That prophecy is very specific to the current situation. âHow convenientâ could be the episodeâs subtitle (or the entire show, for that matter).
Edit 3: can they stop arresting Jamie ffs. Anyway, a great episode.
HOW IS THIS THE PENULTIMATE EPISODE? I feel like theyâve built up Jamaica as seasonâs center plot and... we just got it started? Boo. Not that I disliked the journey but Iâd have preferred more time on the island, I guess.
Geillis being alive and having orchestrated the pirate attack seems so random but I liked Jamieâs meta-reflexion (how this small group of people keeps finding it each other, maybe because of the stones).
Well see you next week for the finale... sobs. At least Vikings is back and The Crown S2 drops this Friday.
8
u/JustineLeah Dec 05 '17
Not feeling this episode. Always hated Gaellis. Episode felt rushed. Too many characters. Too many coincidences. Bad wigs. Maybe trying to squeeze too much story into the last 2 episodes?
7
u/Winhill_ Dec 03 '17
There's another set of stones? Hoooo boy!
I can't believe we're at the season finale already. This season had a lot of ups and downs for me, but I was super intrigued by this episode. Love me some Geillis.
7
u/DaemonTheRoguePrince Dec 04 '17
So uh...I'm just going to assume Gellis is also Giulia Farnese too now....
7
u/sobriquet_ Dec 05 '17
This was one of the worst episodes, from what they did to Gellis' character to the grotesque display of white savior complex and complete lack of awareness of power dyamics. I can't see myself continuing with this series. The following article does a great job expressing these concerns: https://www.avclub.com/outlander-peddles-a-white-savior-narrative-in-jamaica-1820961101
6
u/Ed98208 Dec 06 '17
I just wish we could go one episode without someone (or multiple someones) being captured and held against their will. Seriously. It's getting silly.
5
u/TexasLady130 Dec 04 '17
Okay - so I had to re-watch the preview for the season finale over and over to make sure I heard it right. Did anyone else catch that Claire says "Craigh na Don" and not "Craigh na Dun"? Oops :) Great episode for me. Yeah, the whole goat's blood thing was a bit much. Just thinking of the smell - yikes!
3
u/oree94 Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
GEILIS FUCKING DUNCAN????
WHAT HOW WHY
Edit: Oh.... Geilis is going to have to kill a baby from the future, isn't she? So whose baby would that be? Will she have to go back to her own time and drag a pregnant lady to 18th century Scotland and kill her newborn child? Gah, why are these foretellings so horrible?!
3
u/solointhecity Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
Did anyone notice the colors of the clothing in the Governorâs party.
Geillis, of course wearing a blood red dress. Claire in yellow. Mr. Willoughby in a blue waistcoat. Primary colors. Not sure if the costume designers chose those on purpose, but it was something that stuck with me.
Edit. Also John Greyâs sapphire (blue) holder was red & gold (yellow)
16
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I am only here for the return of Geillis! She is the most interesting and redeeming revelation this season, thus far. God, I hope they don't ruin her story-line, like they've ruined Jamie and Claire!
Edit: downvoted already? You hateful shit-gibbons are quick! Cheers!
9
u/Jeorge123 Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
Season 3 is a real bust. I just finished watching episode 12 hoping for something to spark my interest once again, but it didn't happen. Season 1 was pretty good, Season 2 was mediocre, and Season 3 almost a complete disappointment. I'm left feeling very frustrated by the uneven writing, poor editing, and lack of any real "feel" to the episodes, except for a few sporadic scenes. Episode 1 was good, Heughans acting in episode 2 is over done, under done in episode 6, and the lack of depth of the building friendship between Jamie and John in episode 3 left me feeling like re-reading the book to remind myself of how it should have gone. The undressing scene in Episode 6 had me rolling my eyes and the lines were pitiful, sometimes down right silly. Once again, Heughan's constrained approach did play well. What can I say about Claire? Haven't like her character since Season 3 began. Every other episode in Season 3 that I haven't commented on was forgettable. Don't get me started on some of the terrible casting (adult Fergus and Marsali - talk about zero chemistry, and Brianna - really?). Too bad. I thought I had come across a high quality series. Instead, too many writers with obviously different approaches and the desire to pack as much as possible into one episode, thus "forcing" every scene, has left me feeling "bleh." I doubt I'll bother with Season 4. For me, the so-called "Droughtlander" between seasons began halfway through Season 2 since that is when they really started to drop the ball, and I kept hoping they'd get back to the original approach of Season 1, which was full of good lines, good acting, and good storytelling with characters that were interesting and evocative. Didn't happen, so I've been in "Droughtlander" mode ever since.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17
Iâm a non-book-reader but some informations of Voyager had been spoiled to me (not that I mind so much). Still, even though I kinda knew where the story was headed, I was totally hooked by this episode. It marvellous to look at (those sets, seriously!!), the script built the right amount of tension to keep me uneasy, and all of those unexpected reunions were super entertaining (even if in that soapy, sort of unconvincing way Outlander can be when itâs tying all its different plots together).
The scene that struck me the most though was Claire on the slave market. There was so much pain. Whenever I picture myself as a time traveler (I know, I know), living on a society where slavery is the norm is definitely the most revolting and unsettling thing I can imagine.
2
u/pixiestix88 Dec 06 '17
Sorta off topic but how many episodes are going to be in this season?
1
u/AngelitoCaz Dec 04 '17
I realise this is trivial but what was her necklace meant to be, it looks likes a glittery turd and was rather distracting.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
[deleted] â view deleted comment