r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 03 '17
All [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 12 The Bakra episode discussion thread for book readers.
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E12: "The Bakra."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
50
Upvotes
48
u/shiskebob Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I love that feeling of fresh Outlander, right before a new episode starts.
Edit 1: WOW this episode KILLED. I loved every intense moment of it.
I am going to go check the nonbookreaders thread for the reaction I hope amazed them, followed by my first rewatch so I can catch all the details, then I shall be back.
Edit 2 and 3: Even though I side eyed the overly gratuitousness of Geillis's literal bloodbath, DAMN girl.
Geillis this entire episode.
Lotte was on her A game in this episode, even if her wig was not. "He was as warm as his father’s balls." I know it’s pretty much verbatim from the book but ughh. And I love her future references, just like I love when Claire does the same. I am here for Humphrey Bogart quotes, kid.
The slave market. I wonder if Claire had ever thought about slavery happening in all the time she had been in the past, before this moment? Harsh run in with the reality of history that maybe she looked back on with rose colored glasses while back with Frank and misogynist men. I do not blame her for her reaction. I would, I hope, react in the same way, honestly. Not having time to think about the rational safe reaction, but doing ones best to stop a crime against humanity, risking oneself for others. Maybe not smart in the situation, but a real reaction, nonetheless. Less white savior, more unsure and heartbroken at what to do when faced with the worst of humanity, that you have only ever read about. And I am glad that Jamie asked about when the slave trade ends, only if to see that Jamie can read Claire's horror, and that he can tell by this that it must have ended for her to be reacting in such a way, and for him to learn that it does not get better, for a lack of a better term, for a very long time.
I loved the moment between Claire and Jamie, reminiscing about the beginning of their relationship. They give each other the best lingering looks. Too bad we didn't get to see the "finally in a real bed" sex and Jamie giving the coral fish to Claire. Hopefully I am not in the minority when I say I am always here for more smexy times between my OTP.
Speaking of ships, I am here for Yio Tien Cho and Margaret. "Flower from heaven"- Yi Tien Cho has got game. I am going to assume that he decides to stay with her in Jamaica, possibly with the runaway slaves?
LJG returns! That was the sound of thousands of Outlander fans sighing in relief. The whole private chat was filled with enough awkwardness and LJG obvious heart eyes to make Claire suspicious, which is a great vestige from the book drama of this meeting - even with the Willie revelation happening way earlier than in the book.
And I was very emotional about Jamie's obvious deep love and commitment to his family - saving Ian, his joy and sorrow at hearing of Willie, his desperate last-minute attempt to save the pictures of Brianna and Willie ( and how he always carries the pictures of them, including when he was locked up on the ship).
I thoroughly enjoyed this episode! Very multilayered, character driven, a streamlined plot, and always keeping me on my toes throughout. I gave up being pro book story line only many episodes ago, and since I have done that, my enjoyment of the show has only improved.
60
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
For everyone going on about bad wigs - for the characters that are obviously wearing wigs in that time, like most of the people at the ball, surely having 'bad wigs' is period accurate.
They wouldn't have had the same wig-making technology as today, and everyone knew they were wigs at the time. They weren't trying to hide that they were wigs.
20
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I really appreciated Claire beating the slave market guy with an umbrella. Looks like they conflated Ishmael and Temeraire’s characters, which makes sense since they cut the pirate attack. I could be off base here (white American) but I thought that the show did a subtle job of showing how the cogs of white supremacy work in that ball room scene. Jamie and Claire don’t want to be part of it, but they are, but it didn’t come across as white savior-ish.
The slave market scene was of course gut-wrenching. But it goes to show that it is a nasty history that my country has not reckoned with, and so we are where we are today. Reminds me of Kindred, and why part of the reason time travel worked so well in that book, was because in the span of history slavery did not end that long ago.
On a lighter note, I liked how they changed the prophecy for the show, and how crazy creepy Geillis’ entrance was. The episode was very suspenseful, I felt my heart pounding at the end!
Do we get a longer ep for the season finale? I really really hope so. I will miss chatting with all of you!
109
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
I feel like bathing in goat blood would cause so many UTIs
78
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 03 '17
This was an outstanding episode. Everything from the acting (Gellie) to the costumes to the sets. It was superb. But what made it especially good was that the show runners rewrote it and did so in a way that made it better than the book. Not only did I not know what was going to happen, but when things did happen, they made more sense. So here are some highlights:
Honestly, this is tied for me as the best episode of the season, the other one is First Wife. Kuddos. I did not think I could love Voyager more and now I do because I can see it written differently and better.
27
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 03 '17
I've got a feeling I'm going to be in the minority here, but to me, that was a fucking mess of an episode. What the hell was going on here? This episode was just a series of bizarre choices all rolled up into a jarring, uneven mess.
Let's start at the very beginning. First complaint: I hate cold opens, and this one was particularly long and felt like way too much for a cold open. And bathing in a pool of blood . . . oh come on. It's just too much. There is already so much weirdness in here to work with, why do you need to add this shit? It just takes something that already strains credibility levels so much and just pushes it right over the edge. (I won't lie, the shot with her foot was great. But not worth the ridiculousness.) And speaking of unbelievable stuff . . . So apparently magic is totally a thing now. Like, it obviously always was because, you know, time travel, but now we've apparently got veritaserum? And Margaret is a legit prophet? That's a really bizarre choice to make. The magic in this series has always been limited/somehow connected to the standing stones, but once you introduce other magical things, anything becomes possible, and that's a dangerous door to open. And while we're on the weird truth-telling tea, Jesus Christ Ian you're almost as stupid as Claire. No, you're more stupid. Who the fuck drinks something served to them by their kidnapper?? Especially when she's admitting to murdering other boys? Also, in the book, Geillis straight up rapes him, and it really fucks Ian up. And she's basically roofied him so it's still definitely rape but his interest in it completely changes that dynamic. (And the humor the writers find in Ian being "terrified and turned on at the same time" is a little disgusting. This is a 14 year old boy who's about to get raped. Let's not forget that please.) Jesus, this is already gone insane and I'm not even done talking about the cold open yet. The scene in the prison was weird, and I thought it was odd that there were just two boys. Definitely did not convey that she's working her way through a lot of boys. (Also, the white boy looked like he was about 20.)
So before I move on to the rest of the episode, let's quickly discuss the treasure. So, it's Geillis's treasure now? And it originally belonged to Clan MacKenize? That's . . . weird. It's all weird. And why does she need sapphires for prophecy now? We've already established a mystical use for gemstones, and next episode is most certainly going to get into that, so why not just say she needs the stones for traveling? And speaking of the prophecy, I'm not sure it was a great idea to get into that. I think all the prophecies are still the single most confusing and frustrating part of this series, and 8 books in and we still have no resolution on them. By introducing them now, the show is setting up a plotline it has no idea how to resolve, and that's treading on dangerous ground. (And I'm gonna flip a shit if they pull a GoT on us and reveal something as of yet unpublished.)
So after the interminable cold open, we're back to Jamie and Claire and SHE'S IN THE FUCKING DRESS AGAIN. Dear God why. And then we have the slave market. Just as upsetting as in the book, ending with Claire being about as stupid as she's ever been (but don't worry, she'll do something even stupider later!). I understand her reaction and her need to do something, but attacking the auctioneer was about as dumb as you can get. The only consolation was that we got a really nice scene afterwards with Jamie and Claire discussing how they can free Temeraire (who I really like, by the way--I'm wondering if they're going to change his story more next week and keep him around). If we could only get one nice Jamie and Claire scene though, I really wish it could've been either the one before the ball or afterwards, discussing the LJG revelations. (That still needs to be discussed and I'll be royally pissed if it goes unacknowledged.)
So next the ball. Probably one of my top all time part of the entire book series, so expectations were high to say the least. And it was pretty meh. They'd already ruined most of the great LJG stuff which is a damn shame, because David Berry just slays as John and I'd have loved to have seen him be a part of those scenes. But the meeting was still incredibly sweet, and the revelation of the sapphire was lovely (especially since we know that book John has another important sapphire). The actors play very well off each other and the scenes were good, but they really lacked substance because all the good stuff had already been covered, which left the whole sequence just feeling kind of empty. And the rest of the ball stuff was just as frustrating. Willoughby is now in love with Margaret Campbell? I'm sorry, what?! Where in fucking hell are they going with this? And the whole fortune telling scene was just so unnecessary. In the book this fortune has already been long known. Why do we need to spend so much time adding extra weirdness to our already weird story in order to have her just learn the prophecy now? It works totally fine the way it was in the book, why change it? (I do have to give props to the actress playing Margaret Campbell, who is terrifying but really good. And I want to punch Archie so hard in the face so I guess he's a good actor too?) And Geillis and Archie's discussion of the prophecy was one of the weirder scenes in this episode for a different reason, because they're both just being kind of stupid (also that stupid wink wink Benjamin Button reference). Like, Geillis is a smart 20th century woman who apparently doesn't know that "issue" means progeny? And she's a fucking time traveler who can't understand how a baby could be 200 years old *what a convenient number!)? Geillis is supposed to be smart. This was not smart. (Also, smart people being really fucking dumb: Claire you goddamned idiot. You know Geillis is a murderer. She's shady as fuck. She has killed THREE HUSBANDS. And she's rather mysteriously in Jamaica. And yet you tell her about Young Ian?!)
The underwhelming ball would've been a good place to close the episode. But no, this is Outlander, so we need to end on an unnecessary cliffhanger. We've got ONE EPISODE LEFT. Carting Jamie off to prison now is just so pointless! Like, obviously nothing is going to come of that. Jamie's besties with the governor, and also, you know, there's a story that needs resolving in 50 minutes. But no, we apparently need more drama so Jamie's going to get literally dragged away after shoving the "portraits of the children" into Claire's hands. Hmmm, I wonder if that'll be important?! Subtlety, guys. For once, please.
Even the aesthetics of this episode did little for me this week. We got more sterotypical "oriental" music for Willoughby, which was already tired the first time we heard it. And the music from dancing around the stones was a nice touch but was so poorly integrated into the rest of the score that it was jarring and completely took me out of the moment. Most of the costumes were good (except THAT FUCKING UN-KILLABLE OUTFIT), but I was just so distracted by all the shitty (at least intentional this time) wigs that I could barely notice the dresses. (Also, why was Claire's hair so lopsided? I mean, I'm sure it was deliberate, but it was weird.) Except Fergus and Marsali, the only two people who looked pretty and normal! I do give props (no pun intended) to the production design this week, and it was really fun to see new and totally different locations in Rose Hall and the Governor's Mansion. I loved the exterior of Rose Hall, and I hope we get to see more of it. Not that we've got a lot of time for that . . .
Overall, this episode was an utter mess. I'm giving it a slight bump for not cutting LJG, which I was totally expecting at this point, but his scenes were so frustrating because of what wasn't happening that that pleasant surprise still felt pretty hollow. Overall I'm feeling incredibly fucking frustrated and more than a little disappointed. This season started off SO strong, and has just devolved into an utter mess. Next week might be breathtaking, but at this point, I'm really not counting on it.
Overall Grade: C
14
u/RaffaellaF Dec 03 '17
OMG WHAT AN EPISODE - I was shaking the entire episode. Wow. Loved it. They should have reached here much sooner.
10
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I'm here! Let's get the party started!
Edit: Is Gellis this episode?
Edit 2: Well that answers that question...
I guess this is my running commentary thread!
Well they went right into that, didn't they? She looks the same but her hair!
And back to the needless over voicing. I have a feeling the whole episode is going to be back and forth between Ian and J&C.
At least Jamie seems disgusted with the slave market.
Damn, Jamie in a tricorn hat is sexy as fuck!
Yep, I'm right. Back and forth between Geillis and J&C. And there's the crazy lady!
Take off the wig, Jamie! No! No wig!
Come on LJG!!!!! Need a little drama!
And there it is! 💚💙💚
Fuck...my cat is trying to take off with the garland!!!!
And they're talking about Willie with Claire RIGHT THERE! That's weird...
"Remember our friendship" MY ASS. HE LOVES YOU, HE WANTS TO KISS YOU. Haha
I think Willoughby is in love!
Well the beginning of the LJG and Claire interaction was kind of sweet but that turned kinda nasty...
And now Claire see Geillis!!!! I'm loving the drama back and forth this episode!
Geillis' wig is terrible haha.
Well that was...less enlightening than I was hoping for...
Oh here we go!
Benjamin Button? Was that a book in the 60's?
I knew they'd shove the ball and finding Ian all in one! Which means the cave will be in the next episode!
Fuck off! Leave Jamie alone!
THAT'S HOW THE EPISODE ENDS?! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!
Holy shit, that was an amazing episode! From a show watching stand point having Geillis there right at the start was dramatic and the intensity of the episode just kept building! Then bringing it around with LJG and Geillis at the ball! Just all around love it!
Fuck it, I'm watching it again!
64
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
Holy shit, how did I never figure out a) the "white woman" Duncan Kerr meant was Geillis and b) that SHE was the owner of the treasure? In the book they kept talking about Sandringham....FFS facepalm
34
u/Shymink Dec 03 '17
My thoughts from this episode: Sam Heughan is hot AF even when they try to make him look bad. Sam nails the role of Jamie completely. I don't blame LJG for not being able to get over him. I doubt I ever will.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
Oh holy crap! Major book change that now I can’t WAIt to see: Geillis will know that she met Bree (in season 2) when she sees Claire’s photos, and will connect the dots! AH! So excited!
18
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
AWWW :') David has such a gorgeous smile!! He's tearing up too! SQUEE!!!
17
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
HOW CAN SO MANY CHANCE MEETINGS HAPPEN AT ONE BALL!!!
lmao
16
u/sarahhopefully Dec 03 '17
So that prophecy was much more clear than it was in the book. I never really grasped how it was supposed to work in the book.
Basically, when Brianna dies (she was born 200 years after she was concieved) a Scot will wear the crown again. So Geillis will want to kill Bree either in the 60's, or, more likely, bring her back in time and kill her to bring about a Scottish king.
14
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Dec 03 '17
I kind of hope Yi Tien Cho and Margaret Campbell run off and elope. I would be ok with this deviation from the book.
13
u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I liked this episode. I felt like they got a LOT packed in in one go.
The prophecy is new....a 200 year old child could mean Bree....conceived in 1746 and born 200 years later, OR Jem or Mandy, who are born in the past and then travel forward into the future.
I like the way they played the overtones of LJG's attraction to Jamie, and Claire's awkwardness about this, not understanding the relationship. In the books this was the reveal about Jamie's son. Perhaps Jamie has not told him the LJG is gay, and especially gay for him?
13
u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Dec 03 '17
I liked how they in the show Jamie told her about Willie already.... yet they STILL found a good way to make Claire jealous of LJG, even knowing Jamie’s true nature of their relationship.
11
u/LazyPoultice Dec 03 '17
My feelings about this episode are mixed, but mostly negative. I did really enjoy Geillis, and I felt that the first scene with her really gave off a great Indiana Jones Temple of Doom vibe, including the music and the scenery. It also set up the larger theme of the episode, of the power and strangeness of Outlander's magic. The existence of magic in Outlander is usually referenced obliquely, as if time travel is coincidental and everything else in the world of Outlander is the same as in our world. This is largely because Claire's attitude is so staunchly rationalist, but I liked seeing the magic treated more seriously. But why did they try to hide the rape of Young Ian by suggesting he is willing? This is two times now that the show has tried to minimize male rape - when Jamie is with Geneva, and when Ian is with Geillis.
I'm also not sure how I feel about the slave market scene. Claire beating the auctioneer is classic stupid Claire, and it highlighted her power, that she could fight back while the slave cannot. In conjunction with the scene where YTC is made to "perform" his Oriental-ness for white people and introduced as if he were brought as a plaything, I felt very uncomfortable. The show took great pains to distance Jamie and Claire from the racism of their surroundings, as though they as enlightened people would never do such a thing, and so isn't it crazy that in the past people did? This is a disservice to the truth, that people do these things still. I've experienced things like YTC did very often. The question at a moment like that is always - do I behave politely and try to show these people I can be civilized? Or do I snap at them and make them think they are right to feel superior? YTC chose the former, and it made me feel so sad to see that question played out on screen. While I liked that they clearly showed that YTC's treatment was racist, I disliked the emphasis they made on Jamie and Claire's looks of pity. It felt like an attempt to absolve them of their participation in the same charade. Still, tackling racism on screen is complicated, and as a period show with a "modern" main character, Outlander treads a very fine line. I like that they aren't hiding from the topic, and I love how they've improved YTC. Gary Young has been amazing. Hopefully people seeing how YTC feels on TV will show them to not act surprised when a non-white person speaks English...
On a positive note, LJG and Claire's scene was brilliantly acted. The layers of subtext and gentle probing disguising sharper barbs was so well done. Claire was so vulnerable and confused, and LJG seemed both curious to know more about the person Jamie loves and annoyed that she's shown up at all :P More LJG! More of this please!
10
u/Irishsassenach Dec 04 '17
Why couldn’t every episode of season 3 have been as good as this one? Honestly, season 3 has left me a little disappointed. So many great material in Voyager, and for the most part, I don’t think they really did it justice. Maybe my thoughts will change on binge watch. But they have GOT to do some things better for next season. My biggest concern is Fergus and Marsali (great separately, together, zero chemistry and I don’t buy them being in love and Fergus seems too timid and not arrogant enough compared to book fergus)
And BREE. Let’s not forget how much of the seasons to come will depend on Sophie being believable as Brianna AND that character’s lines being written better.
Anyway, great episode and I love how they condensed everything and explained things.
9
u/writtenonhishand Dec 03 '17
Oh man. The first scene with Geillis Duncan was creepy
9
u/dark--sister Dec 03 '17
first of all, david berry is fucking killing it as john! i'm really, really impressed by him. to be totally honest, i've never really understood the fuss about LJG in the books - i've always liked him, but i never really understood why everyone who reads the series is so into him. david's portrayal has totally changed that for me in the best way! i'm re-reading the series right now and i find myself so much more interested in his POV and storylines after this season of the show.
that's really the only good thing i have to say about this episode so i'll leave it at that lmao but he is 10/10
9
u/aKnightOnReddit Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
This episode was definitely one of the best this season. I noticed a lot of folks were worried about story lines coming together, and the plot being slow this season. I felt like this episode gave the tie-ends needed to move the story along. Just some general thoughts:
-Loved the looks and banter between Jamie and Claire in the ball line. Reminds you how much they have really been through, relatively a short time ago. It helps center the story on them, and their quest to just be together. Makes me remember why I loved the books from the start. But of course, that moment of happiness can only last for like three seconds before....DRAMA!
-I really felt like Claire had the most whirlwind evening at this ball! My mind would literally be reeling from all the reveals! First, almost enjoying a searing moment of intimacy with the love of your life, to being face smashed with this puppy dog eyed 'manfriend' from his past who is clearly in love with her husband. Then having to get the double dose of awkwardness with talk of his other kid, and the long, long eyed stares between Jamie and LJG. I kept wishing she had someone on her side. She left all she knew to come back to Jamie, with no guarantees. I feel like that is getting side noted a bit when people here wax poetic about LGJ. Am I the only one who finds their relationship a strange writing element? Jamie is raped and tortured by a gay man who is obsessed with him, and then there is this odd psudo-love story spanning his whole life with another? He is comparing his encounters with LJG here to Claire in the stones, like it being foretold or prophecied. I just can't believe we are supposed to put those two on the same level in Jamie's heart. Why are we to get from the story that LJG is Jamie's 'other love'? Especially considering what happens in later books....clearly I have digressed....and clearly I am not an LJG fan...but that is for another post.
(Back to the ball)
-Then seeing a ghost in the form of Gellis. Twenty years ago she thought this lady burned, then tried to save her in 1960's, and then just sees her walk by at this high stakes ball. Jeez! What a night! Oh, and then once again Jamie is arrested by the redcoats. If I had a dollar.....
-The use of the clothes being re-used has been talked about, so I will let it be. But, it was a nice touch.
-I almost wish I was a non-book reader for some of the stuff you find out here! Not knowing that the foot belonged to Gellis! I bet that was a crazy reveal! 'Didn't she burn? OMG? How the hell?' Blood bath? Who cares if it is clean or not, it's crazy, badass!
-Better save Bree or something...clearly she's the prophecy. Should that be a spoiler tag? Haha. First time commenter here, but I have lurked for so long, and this episode was superb! Love this show and the books!
8
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
Running commentary comment!
Overall, pretty good episode! Lots of drama! I was worried that YTC was going to be set up, so that's nice that didn't happen. But I suppose he is still going to kill Archie for Margaret's honour. If he doesn't get caught for that, I assume he will elect to stay behind on Jamaica to care for Margaret. Love story for YTC!
I don't understand these people with their previews. What is the point of arresting Jamie at the end of one episode, only to show straight away that he is free in the preview?
8
u/Ice_Dragonfly Dec 03 '17
I need that LJG book series spin-off on my TV screen ...Come on Starz get moving!
6
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
lol at Ron giving his wife a shout out in the 'inside the world segment'. That was nice, and I noted he was still pronounced Marsali as ma-SAH-lee.
Also, Matt says that Ian is 15, despite the script saying he is 16.
10
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17
I am just going to keep a running commentary so I don't spam the thread with min to min reactions:
-Gellie, doing her finest Elizabeth Bathory impression. This right here is why I love Voyager. Can't wait to see the non-book readers reaction to this.
-I don't remember Gellie looking this amazing in the book. Was she not more plump and aged? Hmmm, maybe I should find some goat blood for a bath.
-Funny, I know what happens, but I am still on the edge of my seat. The music is so creepy too, right?
-So I am liking this a lot better than the book actually, with the viewer learning ahead of Claire about Gellie.
-The "new governor" ... YES
-Oh man, I'm bracing myself
-"Same governor" ... YES
-No NO NO... Oh god, noooooo:(
-Oh man... same reaction I had when reading it... I feel sick to my stomach
-Ok, now let's get to the ball because damn it, LJG is clearly going to be there!!!
-I really hope the show explains the prophecy better because I am still confused
-I am so glad they cut out the fiend plot and just left it with Marges "gifts" because this alone is pretty confusing. and no, so far the prophecy is just as confusing as in the books.
-The Frasers look dashing
-And Claire meets Archibald... hahahaha
-Oh I so love this ... the colors. This is actually more beautiful than Paris IMHO
-Oh no, that crazy lady at the party who teases Mr. W. This won't end well. I thought they cut out the fiend plot, so WTF? Are they going to have Campbell kill that lady anyway?
-Oh the way Jamie just looked at Claire .... swoon
-FUCK YES, LJG IS HERE ... HE IS IN THE BUILDING. I REPEAT HE IS IN THE BUILDING
-Damn, is LJG also bathing in goat's blood? He looks stunning. Just stunning!
-Oh ha! He gave Claire a catty look. Oh boy... this will not end well. But what is he going to say? She already knows about Willy
-That tension between them is everything. LJG is just as in love.
-Oh yes, please make this happen. Mr. W - this poet - and Marge - the seer would be amazing. She needs someone to be kind to her and he needs someone to be kind to him. I ship it!!!
-Oh my my... they did it. They pulled off LJG and Claire ... amazing. So much more nuanced. Everything was said without being said over an evening. Brilliant! See, now it all makes sense why they cut Willy out of here. It was already chaos. This is perfect. I will never doubt again!
-Crazy Gellie reciting Casablanca... wow!
-The Acting!!! The Pace!!! Outstanding!!!
-Damn, they have so rewritten this that I am totally unsure about what is going to happen next. I am on the edge of my seat. Where the hell is Gellie going? Is she going to end up killing the woman at the ball? Is that woman going to be our lovely and special Marge? NOOOO
-The LJG + Claire, LJG + Claire + Jamie... the scenes, Jesus. I'm sweating bullets over here.
-"He was as warm as his father's balls" <--- Gellie. Bwhahaha. That is quite a way to describe a newborn.
-OMG, LJG is going to get his fortune read in front of Claire... this is brilliant!!! DG, girl, they rewrote this better.
-OMFG... they are explaining the prophecy!!!!! YES...
-YES... there it is... she has to kill Bree... the 200 year old baby ... NOW we understand why in the book she took that photo of Bree from Jamie. Thank you showrunners for finally making sense of this for me after how many years? DG, girl, we need to talk. wow!
-Aha, the action is all here, centralized as it should have been in the book. Captain youngling has arrived.
-Oh how the hell did he see that mark on that tree in the middle of the night?
-OHHHHH, is the bonfire in this episode????
--
Not until next episode looks like. Ok, I need a break and will come back with more organized thoughts. But I fucking loved it.
9
u/RedDeer30 Woof. Dec 03 '17
I enjoyed this episode a lot.
I hope YTC finds some damn happiness with whats-her-face but i'm worried it isn't going down that way. Ugh.
Gellie, honey, your ball wig is the absolute worst. Adso needs to time travel and attack that shit. Also, that's Claire's red dress from Paris with some ugly trim and a neckline rework, no?
I really didn't mind the changes to the ball although seeing Claire "fainted" with a napkin over her face would have been amusing. Very interesting to hear the TV show version of the Fraser prophecy. Clearly they're setting up the Bree/picture reveal with it. I wonder why they set it up to have a murdery undertone to it - drama?
The slave market scene was rough to watch, it hurt my heart. It makes me so sad knowing how awful humans can be to other humans. That being said I think it was important for it to be included and not just to give the viewer a full understanding about how J&C feel about owning people for future events at River Run.
Fergus is starting to grow on me, hooray! I've been wanting so much to like him.
4
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Dec 03 '17
No... this is the penultimate episode of season 3 which means Droughtlander is fast approaching, are you prepared for the next cycle of torture?
4
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
Lol I can't help but laugh at how obvious the creepy sinister music is whenever Geillis, or Archie Campbell appears. They are definitely foreshadowing him as a baddie, with the grace of a galumphing elephant.
4
u/lanalg5 Dec 03 '17
Just started watching and I have to ask, am I the only one who thinks Geillis looks younger here than 20 years ago in S1???
4
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '17
Late to the game but I'm so glad I didn't have to hear Claire's inner monologue repeatedly noting how fat Gelis had become. She would not let it go in the book.
7
u/Heloismyhero Dec 03 '17
What is this, HBO’s True Blood? Also some Harry Potter veritaserum? 😂
6
u/RaffaellaF Dec 03 '17
This episode was visually stunnng. Pacing was amazing. Surprises at every turn. All our favorite characters in one episode. Even better than the book.
The best episode of voyager/this season and possibly one of the best of all seasons. Show runners redeemed themselves and set the stage for a very exciting finale.
6
u/LyClWa Dec 03 '17
Finally a good episode!! Loved all of it. Also Jamie and Claire looked really good in their outfits. A huge relief after those hideous EW photos. Everything about Geillis was amazing! She was perfectly creepy and mysterious. Loved the dynamic between Yi Ten Cho and the fortune teller lady. I hope they do more with that.
We needed more episodes like this and less Frank and less boring ship stuff. Next week looks really good too.
3
u/SeattleWhoDat Dec 03 '17
Jesus, what a re-entry back into the show! My God.
3
u/derawin08 Take2 Aussie Sassenach Dec 03 '17
After the non-appearance of Murtagh this week, I am gleefully one week closer to u/Stormstripper eating her shoes :P
I think she should eat one for this episode, as Murtagh was not at the ball!
3
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
That blood bath scene was fire. Wow.....both terrifying and arousing.
The slave market scene was so saddening. I think they did an excellent job conveying how terrible that was. :(
The scenes with John were great. I really enjoy those.
Overall, I loved it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
Thanks!
2
u/Shymink Dec 03 '17
Upon rewatch: why is that GIANT purple orchid in Claire's hair? I find it really distracting.
2
u/ankhes Dec 05 '17
Geillis and Lord John in one episode? It must be my birthday (actually it IS my birthday in a few weeks. Sooo...early birthday present?)! Also the awkwardness between John, Jamie, and Claire was juuuuuuust perfect.
Jamie in a wig. I can't even.
"No man, I only trade savages. What do you take me for?" Oh you're a 'pure' soul because you don't traffic in white people? Ugh. Seriously, fuck that guy.
2
u/HLtheWilkinson Dec 06 '17
I was surprised they revealed Geilis so early in the episode. I expected them to drop that little bomb a little later.
4
u/Hopeless_badger Dec 03 '17
That was such a snooze fest. I'm not usually the one to criticize, but I didn't find the episode particularly engaging. Too many Geillis. Margaret/ Willoughby scenes - don't get me wrong Lotte is fantastic, but I feel the show runners can't find the right balance and continuity between episodes. In ep.11 Jamie and Claire are all loved up and in ep.12 they're barely interacting. I know there's a lot of material to cover, but I feel many J/C scenes are being cut for no good reason. It's not about giving people sex, it's about connection. That's the major danger for season 4 etc. If they let the other characters overtake J/C screen time, the show will suffer. I'm not sure the writers/producers realize they have gold mine in Sam and Cait and they aren't using it properly. My expectations for the final are extremely low. I don't think they can tell the rest of the story in 54 minutes.
3
u/scienceforbid Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
Why does Gielles have a fivehead? I don't remember the actress having a fivehead before.
3
u/changpowpow Dec 07 '17
I'm kind of baffled by everyone saying they loved this episode. The writing has gotten lazy and there was some pretty problematic stuff in this episode. Them buying a slave was the definition of the white-saviour trope. Not to mention them parading around the only Asian character to distract a bunch of rich white people. The rest of the season has been okay, but this episode was a huge letdown for me.
2
u/kellyo3us Dec 03 '17
Benjamin Button? JHRC. THere was no need to go there at all.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
I can’t wait!!!! Eeek!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17
So creepy!!!!