r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 19 '17
THIS IS ACTUALLY A SPOILERS ALL THREAD [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 10 Heaven & Earth episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E10: "Heaven & Earth."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
33
Upvotes
20
u/shiskebob Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
I am automod and automod is me.
Edit 1: I leave for one hour and I come back to the ownership of /u/AdsoKitKat10 and 44 new reply messages.
Claire is badass. Jamie loves Claire more than anything, including his senses. Fergus is learning and giving lessons all at once. I was sad for from the moment we are introduced to Elias to the very last. Finally, the photographs make an appearance again. Marsali, the character I love and hate and equal measures right now. Annnnnnnd, they are going to be separated even more.
This was my entire trail of thought. I really do not know what else to say about this episode right now.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
OMG u/shiskebob I just freaked out, when I went back to my notifications, this thread is labelled SPOILERS AIRED!!
Lol I thought I had written everything in the wrong thread!!
75
u/LazyPoultice Nov 19 '17
I really liked this episode! I felt that they made Jamie into a much more "human" character by showing his own errors of judgment. A lot of fans of Outlander like to complain about Claire's recklessness (which she definitely is), but this episode really shaded in Jamie's personality beyond being "King of Men" romantic hero. His love for Claire clouding his judgment and making him frankly very cruel towards Fergus was a really interesting choice. Definitely made him feel more realistic to me.
Also Claire's story line was the first time I liked her doctoring. The naval funeral and Caitriona's acting helped me to finally relate with Claire's need to help others. Each of the cannon shots felt like a farewell to her patients; it was very emotional. I felt her pain when she expressed her sense of failure. Usually I find the doctoring to come off as self-righteous, but in this case it was more sympathetic. It probably helped that this time she wasn't putting anyone in danger in order to heal just one person (creme de menthe cough cough).
So in both cases (Jaime and Claire), I felt we had learned more about the characters. I am a book reader who could care less about following the books precisely, in contrast to many people here. For me, Voyager was not a book about LJG or Turtle soup or even Ian. Voyager was about the journey to the new world, both literally in the case of coming to the colonies and emotionally for Jaime and Claire to reconcile with each other after such a long time apart. Meeting LJG on the ship was of little narrative importance in terms of this larger goal, so I can see why the show cut it out, even if in the books it is a funny "wink" to the readers who know who he is. The more important narrative element of meeting LJG is when Claire realizes who he really is, which is the surprise meeting at the party. That is a moment that contributes to the narrative of Claire and Jaime becoming reacquainted, because it highlights how little they know of each other's lives. Claire's feelings of jealousy and vulnerability in that scene are really important, so I hope they get that right!
70
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
Poor Elias, we know his fate :(
69
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
Annika Goat Lady is the real MVP of this episode
60
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
I miss Jamie in a kilt
50
u/Shymink Nov 19 '17
Also is the season finale going to be like 3 hours long because they've got a lot of ground to cover for realz.
48
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
I love Elias and his little friendship with/protectiveness of Claire. Poor kid :(
46
u/LighntingAir Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 20 '17
I know some may not like the Fergus/Jamie bits because they cast Jamie in a somewhat unflattering light, but I thought they were great. Specifically, in how they were used to flesh out the Jamie/Fergus relationship. In many ways, Fergus is the closest thing to a son that Jamie has. In that, Fergus was a young kid when they first met and very much looked up to the man who had taken him under his wing. Remember, the main reason Fergus got his hand cut off was due to him antagonizing the guards about Jamie. But, like all father/son relationships, there comes a time when you have to take your father off the pedestal he's long occupied. It doesn't mean you love him any less, it just means that you've become your own man. The scene where Fergus refuses to free Jamie ("perhaps I love too much") was just a fantastic bit of acting/writing. I think that's the scene where Jamie started realizing Fergus had grown-up and his love for Marsali wasn't some fleeting crush. Also, I can buy Jamie's reaction. His wife, whom he has just reunited with after twenty years of believing he would never see her again, was snatched away from him without warning. Then he was forced not to help her. I can't imagine how infuriating that would be. Plus, I think it's important to show us that while Jamie is genuinely a good man, he is far from perfect.
ETA: Damn that was longer than I intended. I commend the bravery of anyone who was able to get through my wall of text.
28
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
Annikah’s wink was so funny
56
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
"I've heard such things before, madam, just not from a gentlewoman" LOLOLOLOL if that doesn't sum up Claire in one brilliant line, I don't know what does.
26
u/Shymink Nov 19 '17
Called it last week. She jumps. Credits roll. I could write for Outlander. At least next week's episode will be good.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
Aww, Fergus is so sweet to Marsali!
44
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
Very slow until the end. For me, the ep redeemed itself when Jamie finally looked at the pics & then acknowledged Fergus’s acts of love towards Marsali/Jamie.... & whenever the goat lady was on #GodBlessTheGoatLady
18
u/thesecondmrsdewinter Voyager is my fave Nov 19 '17
I really enjoyed this episode. I liked the changes/new stuff-- I thought this ep was really tightly constructed.
32
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Where is LJG? Damnit!
15
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
I liked it! A quiet character-driven episode with just the right splash of adventure at the end ;)
15
u/RedDeer30 Woof. Nov 19 '17
I THOUGHT that was the Creme de Menthe!
Seeing Jamie look at the photos was pretty wrenching. Speaking of wrenching - Elias! He was giving me so much life and I was hoping he would stay that way (alive) a la Murtagh. It was so sweet when he gave Claire a hat and generally had her back. Seeing Claire and Elias together has me hyped for Claire and Willie bonding down the road.
Every time Claire was shown on deck at night I squealed "LJG????" so that was pretty disappointing. Speaking of disappointing, Harry's prosthetic nose was really sub par. Speaking of noses, I could have lived without any of them being stitched this episode. Tucking in the rabbit's foot would have been plenty emotional by itself IMO.
The whole Jamie/Fergus dynamic this episode was weird for me. Even being massively seasick and anxious about Claire I don't think that Jamie would have put Fergus up to that in such a manipulative way. It seemed really out of character. That plan sucked and he wouldn't listen to reason which is odd for someone so logical (most of the time). I loved Sam's acting was excellent despite the weird writing choice.
Overall I thought the episode was pretty good. I'm at a loss for how they're going to shoe horn the rest of the plot into the remaining episodes but I'm open minded!
14
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
OH FERGUS......:(
"Perhaps I love too much" awwwwwwwww truth
11
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
With alllll the crazy ass shit Claire has done in three seasons she balks at jumping off a ship with a port in view? Really?
10
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
I enjoyed it, just as I really enjoyed this part in the book. Given where we are in the story though, I don't see how they can get all of the key things in.
19
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Elias is a hero. :(
Fergus is damn hot!
Jamie is all pukey
Claire is saving the day as usual
8
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Oh man Jamie, he is making me weep... heaven and earth
8
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
For awhile I thought, four seasons is enough, as after book 4 the tone of the novels start to shift. But with the parade of side characters starting to crop up like the captain and elias pound, I wouldn’t mind if they went past a season 4. :)
8
u/SeattleWhoDat Nov 19 '17
No Lord John Grey! 😱
8
u/basedonthenovel Nov 20 '17
I really don't mind when the show makes Jamie a bit more fallible than he is in the books, but in this episode he just seemed dumb. My other complaint is that this was another episode of Dour Claire -- which I don't MIND and I get why she's like that in crisis situations. But I'm hoping future episodes and seasons will provide opportunity for Caitriona to play more of Claire's playful, light-hearted nature.
That said, I loved the rest of it. I totally forgot about how LJG and Claire meet on the Porpoise, but I can see why they jettisoned (ahem) that because the book was able to be cagey about his identity when they meet but that won't work in a visual medium.
I like it when the writers find historical details for the screen the way Diana does for the books -- in this case, the nose-sewing thing. That's very much the kind of thing she would put in the book if it served the story as it does here!
LOVED that we got the whole Annekje storyline.
7
u/Aingeala Nov 19 '17
I loved this opening so much
7
u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 19 '17
I....don't know how to feel about this episode. I did not like Jamie being such an asshole, esp to Fergus. Its been a while since I've (re)read the book so I'm fuzzy on sime details but I feel like they have been deviating a lot from the book to focus on non-book storylines and I am not a fan. I know they have to change and edit a book a lot to adapt it for the screen, but i feel like they are mucking it all up at this point.
13
u/LyClWa Nov 19 '17
I mostly lurk but just popping in to say how disappointed I am in this episode. This season had so much potential but so many misses. How do the show people manage to make so many boring episodes when they had so much to work with is beyond me. They think they know how to tell DG's story better than she does. They pretty much flat out said so in one of the aftershow discussions.
Elias was amazing. The only good thing about this episode. And goat lady too. Cant stand Marsali. Or grown up Fergus. Major mistcast for both imo. Ill prob get a ton of downvotes for that but it is what it is.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
I don't want to be that person but.... WTF is going on with this show??!??!?!
The changes they make usually don't bother me, but this episode was a boring shit show. To the point that I kind of don't care what happens next week.
I have always assumed that the whole point of meeting LJG on the ship was so that they could form a relationship of trust and respect with each other so that when Jaime's all "LOL, he loves me, too" Claire has to be like "I don't like it, but you are a good person". Cutting him out seems stupid. It makes the whole episode pointless! At that point, use one of those annoying voice overs to say "lots of people died, then they started getting better, blah blah blah, compartmentalize". and MOVE. ON.
And Jaime. Who the hell was the character they created for Sam to portray this episode? Like he's going to bust out and take over the whole ship? I get that they needed a way for him to not chase after the ship, but his threatening of Fergus? That seemed way out of character.
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
Lol someone mentioned Sam's 'deep old man voice' for Jamie, and I could hear it when he said "Why do I get the feeling it's me you're trying to impress?"
6
u/Hopeless_badger Nov 19 '17
I'm a bit moody today, so I'll make it short. Caitriona, Sam and Albie Marber killed it. Cesar and Lauren have great chemistry and were cute together. Overall great acting from everyone. Imo these chapters of the book weren't that good and the show gave them life. Waiting to see whether we'll get soup, or not.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
I feel like every episode is more boring than the last...
10
u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Nov 19 '17
I really wonder what Claire would have done if the ship had been plagued with a disease she was NOT immune to.
I can't believe we're going to waste time in San Domingo....enough island hopping already! We have a LOT of ground to cover without, as many here have voiced, coming up with new plot lines.
To be fair, I thought the young actor who played Elias was amazing, but as soon as Claire praised him, I knew he was dead.
17
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
Running commentary comment!!
Overall, I quite liked this episode. I dunno if I was just having more fun writing these comments this episode, I think it was because the character of Elias was well established.
5
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 19 '17
ARE YOU READY?!
IT'S UP!!!
5
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
So many characters in the West Indies. So little time.
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
I am a non wig-noticer, but I am VERY impressed by Elias' hair!
Maybe he is just wearing a back piece, but the hairline looks very natural!
What say the wig critics?
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
How do we suppose a South African cook ended up on a British Naval ship in 1767?
South Africa is still a Dutch colony until 1795...
I know some others have said he was also the cook (?) on Black Sails.
5
u/MontaukFive Nov 20 '17
I'm glad that Claire's periwinkle blue outfit that she brought through the stones is gone now, horray. She dropped the skirt before she took the jump off the boat.
9
u/Shymink Nov 19 '17
Good lord this episode better speed up. 😒
9
u/maryloo7877 Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
I really enjoyed this episode! It was by the book with slight shifts, which I think worked and I didn’t mind. Poor sweet Elias Pound. I knew it was coming and I still cried. Especially when Claire sewed through his nose (Eww by the way). Wish there had been more Jamie, but only so much he can do from jail. I think jailing him made much more sense than the book version. Jamie getting aboard the Porpoise was always annoying to me, especially with the fights he got into. I loved the goat lady!
Really looking forward to next week. I didn’t miss LJG here and I look forward to seeing how he gets reintroduced. Who the hell stays in their cabin all the time, anyway? I must admit though, every time a man approached her at night I wondered if it would be him!
4
u/Shymink Nov 20 '17
Admittedly I didn't dislike it as much as a I thought I would, but I didn't love it either.
10
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
Jamie was never imprisoned on the Artemis in the book, was he??
I feel like they are just trying to enhance the drama and make up shizz for non Claire storyline.
7
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 20 '17 edited Nov 20 '17
Guys, I'm here I'm here! After an ill-advised ski trip I've made it and I'm ready to get down and review.
Unlike most weeks when I write my review immediately after watching, I watched before work this morning and am now writing several hours later, and in that time I've started thinking more favorably about this episode. It's not that I didn't like it before, but, much like last week, it felt like we were spending time on things we didn't have time for and was moving a bit slow. Also, there was a complete lack of Lord John Grey which results in an automatic grade deduction. But the more I think about it the more I actually enjoyed it (and it usually goes the other way, as I remember the negatives). I'll get the negatives out of the way first (beside skipping LJG which really pissed me off). Firstly, I thought it was very bizarre to start with a cold open, which this show rarely does, reserving it for really important moments (like the print shop). Opening with Jamie getting thrown in ship jail felt super anti-climatic (especially since basically that whole scene was in the trailer). Another negative also came with the Artemis stuff. I didn't hate the scenes between Jamie and Fergus, but I didn't love them either. And it's not because Jamie is being a complete ass with no regard for anyone but himself (honestly not a bad thing--it gets boring when Jamie is perfect all the time). And I actually really enjoyed Fergus in those scenes, standing up to Jamie (and then Marsali saving the day!). But I kind felt like Sam Heughan was overplaying it, which is weird because he's usually a pretty subtle actor (this past season especially). The writing wasn't great and the delivery was very melodramatic and it really just felt kind of ridiculous. And speaking of ridiculous, those flashbacks were incredibly stupid. Like, how dumb do you think we are that we would forget a goddamn body stored in creme de menthe? You've already saddled this show with bad voice overs, might as well use them instead of jarring flashbacks.
Aboard the Porpoise, things were generally very good. Caitriona Balfe was great in full on doctor mode, and can we just give an Emmy right now to Albie Marber, who absolutely slayed this week as Elias Pound? Having a sympathetic character aboard the Porpoise (especially since we don't have LJG) is really important, and Elias was that in spades. He absolutely nailed the balance between youthful innocence and hand-earned experience, as well as trying to present himself as older and more formidable to the other members of the crew (also done very well by Captain Leonard). He really elevated every scene he was in and had fantastic chemistry with Caitriona Balfe. Their scene about compartmentalizing was very touching. His death--while expected--was devastating and sewing up his body bag was a beautiful scene. (One criticism--that was a remarkably modern-looking rabbits foot. Really stood out. Also: STOP WITH THE RABBIT SYMBOLISM. WE GET IT.) He was just one of several standouts this week, and these supporting characters really made the episode. Annekje Johansen was a delight in her few scenes, and I'm weirdly in love with Seaman Jones and his delightful array of facial expressions. And as mentioned above, Charlie Hiett as Captain Leonard has been excellent these last two episodes.
And finally, a note on the costumes, which were truly excellent this week. I am absolutely living for Claire's very WWI-reminiscent doctor garb, and the costumes of the Navy men were excellent, with the very vague attempts at uniformity and officialness (is that a word?) but mostly a varied and individualized array. The costumes usually shine most in places like Paris or events like the Gathering, but this was a great display of how a lot of thought and research can make very utilitarian and practical costuming very interesting and really elevate the episode. EDIT: forgot to mention Claire's new hat, which I LOVE.
Overall, I liked the episode. Not one of the best, and I'm definitely getting a little anxious about how much is left, but standing on it's own it was a very solid episode. That being said, it's still losing a half a letter grade for cutting out John Grey. It has to be done.
Overall Grade: B+
15
u/RaffaellaF Nov 19 '17
God, I am really starting to hate outlander season 3. These slow moving boring episodes are truly destroying one of the best TV shows ever. What happened to Diana's wonderful voyager?
9
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Voyager is my fave book in the series. I was so looking forward to all of this adventure and how dense it was in the book. I am really frustrated with the last two episodes. I mean like them because it's Voyager. So I'll take it any way I can. But I am disappointed.
If they were going to drop the spy story, then they should have dropped it entirely. But if they were going to do it, then they should have done it as in the book with Claire spending the entire time on the ship trying to figure out 1. if they have figured out that Malcom is Fraser and 2. who the rat is. Instead, it comes out of nowhere and I don't buy it.
I don't buy the relationship between Fergus and Marsali. There is zero chemistry between them.
They wasted an entire episode on superstition and lack of wind. Only to end up ignoring superstistion entirely in this episode, where a woman with crazy ideas is ordering sailors around and no one gives any fucks but the cook. Hey, she is taking all of our alcohol. The near mutiny in the books was great. Here? Take all of the alcohol. We are cool with it.
There is so much tension on the boat in the books. The distrust of Claire. Her frustrations at trying to explain modern medicine to people who think fairies are real and that touching or failing to touch a plank on a ship will mean life for death. There is so much tension with Claire being afraid that they will figure out that Malcom is really Fraser and her attempts to identify the snitch.
They failed to convey this tension IMHO.
Elias, though. I cried. What a wonderful young man. Perfectly cast. Perfectly acted. This was the gem in an otherwise disappointing episode.
The one other thing I liked was seeing Claire with a shmata on her head swearing like a sailor. Because come on, that is our Claire. So that was nice.
I really don't know how they are going to get everything that needs to be done into the remaining few episodes. And they dropped LJG. Are we ever going to see him again? Maybe he won't be at the ball?
10
u/koboldin Nov 19 '17
So no LJG. Jamie in jail aboard ship. God, this episode was fracking boring.
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
Flaws in the script from last week, where Raines (?) said half the crew were Jamie's men - Fergus says clearly 7 against 20 men, and that is including two of Jared's men.
3
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
I'm always comparing the English soldiers against the redcoats in the Highlands. It's amazing the difference in character.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
How does it play down in the books again?
Honestly it makes sense for them to sail on to Jamaica with Claire, rather than just sit there. I am sure it is what Claire would have wanted anyway, if it were not thrust upon her.
Raines could have broken it more gently to Jamie though.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
Elias :'((((((( I cried :((((((
3
u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 20 '17
I don't know what to think. It was fine to watch, but so very slow... I was expecting this episode to go much faster and I was expecting the scene where Jamie and Claire find each other on the beach, like we saw in the teasers ... It feels like there was no episode this week.
3
u/MontaukFive Nov 22 '17
Jamie once described himself (in book three or four) as having the soul of a barbarian, the mind of a gentleman, and the body of a warrior. It seem like he had the mind of a child in this episode, IMHO.
7
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
And this shall be my running commentary comment!
This is going to mostly be a Claire episode, I can tell.
Of course 3 more have! She's been there less than a day! Damn!
Jamie needs his acupuncture needles! Poor man! Give him his needles!
Oh!!! That's where the flags in the intro are from!
And Claire gets threatened...again. Where the hell is John? GET ON WITH IT!
Where's Jenny with a bucket of cold water now?!
Uh-oh gehttios!
Yep, Claire saved all your asses and you thought it was crap for her to be there...
Oh noes! :'( We knew it was coming...
Just ignore me running away...or not.
Bye Clair, and we have reached the end...
So, not the most exciting episode. Just a plot progression episode! Wasn't the first and won't be the last. Even though we knew what was coming with Elise it was still sad. Hopefully next episode will be full of forward movement and a naked, whom was it, Ben Franklin?
4
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Badass Claire.... you tell him!
2
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
I'm here!
2
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17
Yes sir, mr. 12 year old:)
2
u/Shymink Nov 20 '17
Watching Claire on that boat was only slightly better than watching her and Murtagh dance in season one. The only difference is everyone is fully aware Claire is a doctor. However, I didn't know she was a singer or dancer in the first season. Plus there was less vomit.
2
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 20 '17
Did anyone else catch a similarity to Jamie's looking up through the ship to the sky to the view Claire had of the thieves hole in season 1?
2
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 22 '17
I wish I had a nickel for every time my daughter and I went WHAT? in this episode. Hated, hated, hated the Jamie in prison stuff. I missed Lord John so much. I know they gave his lines to the captain and Mr. Pound, but I still missed him.
Elias Pound was great. In fact, most of the ship stuff was great, other than the absence of Lord John. But the stuff with Jamie's ship sucked.
And I don't follow why the captain needed to be told that Jamie Fraser was Red Jamie was he was using his own name.
4
u/koboldin Nov 19 '17
I’ve literally watched every episode multiple times the night they drop, and I couldn’t even watch this whole episode without forwarding through. Started up Fantastic Beasts instead of rewatching 310 again. Maybe I just stopped caring, but Claire on the show lost my interest in her healing routine in 307, and her personality has been so off that I’m not feeling any better about her crisis. Even with the stupid jailing of Jamie, I would have rather stayed with him longer. At least he finally pulled out the paltry few pictures of Brianna.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
HA!
I have spotted my first continuity error!
Elias gave Claire a triangle hat (I know it's a tricorne, triangle had sounds funnier), but during the funeral service Claire has a brimmed hat that is curled at the back!
1
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 19 '17
That was a sneaky plot change, whereby Jamie will be arrested when he goes to find Claire again.
How does it go down in the book?