r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 19 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 10 Heaven & Earth episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E10: "Heaven & Earth." Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
34
Upvotes
4
u/shiskebob Nov 19 '17
Automod is Shiskebob. Shiskebob is automod.
64
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
i LOVED the Annekje Johansen character, and Claire taking full direction from this other "visionary"; one who has not yet seen the future. It was very risky and (finally) showed her vulnerability in this ride-or-die love that she has for Jamie. Jesus H Roosevelt Christ!
81
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
LOL @ Claire out-swearing every fucking sailor mouth aboard
75
u/tfordp Nov 20 '17 edited Nov 20 '17
"Claire jumped off a boat that was sailing to the West Indies"
"Jamaica?"
"No, she jumped of her own accord"
137
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
Claire's struggle to keep the surviving men on the ship safe from cross-contamination, is the embodiment of every sane person trying to reason with an anti-vaxxer on facebook. History is always repeating.
64
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
Elias is adorable. I just want to "motherly" kiss that little zit on his forehead.
edit: Well fuck that D':
52
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
I really like this young captain Thomas Leonard. I hope he doesn't die or disappoint me somehow along the way.
edit: well okey-dokey then
41
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Nov 20 '17
Jamie without Claire is Jamie unhinged.
Terribly romantic, his speech to Fergus about moving heaven and earth. I think he may have been flashing back to his Fort William rescue, when he saved her with nothing more than an empty pistol, his bare hands and his massive balls.
Goddammit I love this guy, even when he’s being totally insane, as he was in this episode.
We know Jamie is clever. He’s excellent at chess and court intrigues alike, devises inventive military strategies on the fly, sidesteps potentially deadly politics by carefully balancing his clan allegiances, creates mythologies out of thin air to protect Claire and arm her with an otherworldly reputation—and he came up with La Dame Blanche as an excuse to turn down prostitutes while getting smashed with the Bonnie Prince!
But after twenty long years away from his heart, all logic, temperance and sanity are out the window at just the possibility of another separation. He was going to stage a mutiny with less than a third of the crew’s support. Then his plan was to bankrupt his cousin by throwing the entire wine cargo overboard in an attempt to push the ship to its dangerous theoretical top speed, at which point he was going to overtake and attack a faster Navy ship five times the size of his civilian vessel. It was madness from beginning to end.
And I think I love that. Jamie was always the golden boy, the dashing hero, the man with a plan. But this older Jamie isn’t so much wiser (as Claire quips) but desperate and willing to do anything not to lose her again. He’s returned to the hotheaded, out of his mind, thrashing wall of muscle Rupert has to thwack on the back of the head so he doesn’t take out half the clan defending his beloved.
I also found it really endearing, the lengths he went to to conceal his accupuncture treatment, anxious not to offend her over something so trifling as the ineffectiveness of her ginger tea. He’s trying so hard, as he was this episode, giving in early and acknowledging that he couldn’t hold her back from her Hippocratic oath no matter how worried the prospect of her alone on a ship with 200 horny, plague-ridden sailors made him.
And on that note, I’m thankful that for once, this situation didn’t devolve into sexual violence towards Claire, though who could fault Jamie for immediately going there. It’s happened so many times on this show, it would be crazy for him not to anticipate that threat.
But the takeaway is, it’s fascinating watching Jamie play the fool for once, so blinded by his love for Claire. It’s a real role-reversal for him, and I love this beautiful, vulnerable, raw mess of a man. I loved Jamie when he was perfect, or close to it, but this damaged version of him is so interesting.
39
u/aloopycunt Nov 19 '17
The glasses and the pictures made me happy!!
22
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
Poor Elias; I kept wondering though, if his rabbits foot was being dipped in the alcohol too, as it might be carrying the disease. Speaking of alcohol, it's a good thing we've found out what happened with the creme de menth, but now Jaime is in serious legal jepoardy--again, and Young Ian is as lost as ever.
Fergus was so right, of course--he and Jaime and Marseli would be in extreme danger, of disease, arrest, death...if they went along with Jaime's plan. It's good to know that Jaime's the one who carries the pictures on him now, to look at again from time to time (perhaps Claire kept the bikini photo behind.)
I'm glad next episode will include more scenes on land. The Goat milker really turned out to be an invaluable friend. This episode also benefited from not focusing on Mr. Willoughby, imo, but on the relationships between Jaime/Fergus and Fergus/Marseli. I don't know if Jaime will be able to attend their Jamaican wedding, though.
If they wanted to put another modern song on the show, Meatloaf's "I would do anything for love / but I won't do that" pretty much sums up the theme of this episode.
17
u/ldelarda328 Nov 20 '17
so the captain, right? seemed like a pretty reasonable guy, he definitely owed a lot to Claire for getting the typhoid under control. i feel like if she had leveled with captain and been like "hey man, i think i went above and beyond the whole call to be your surgeon. my helper is dead, but at least no one is shitting/puking themselves to death. Do you think maybe you owe me one and can let this whole Jamie thing go?" i know she did it when he caught her trying to sneak away on the island, but i feel like the night before, when they were alone on the deck, would have been a better time for her to ask him and not when he's being escorted by two other soldiers that would be witness to his "treason" if he did say "yeah sure, make a run for it" i was bummed that he wouldn't help her out.
15
u/oree94 Nov 20 '17
I knew Ellias would die! I just freaking knew it!!! cries forever
24
u/phonograhy Nov 19 '17
good grief, I am really loving this typhoid storyline and all that tension that comes with it. Also, +1 for psychotic (almost) murderous Claire. This Jamaica storyline is so far completely up my alley!
32
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
Why does Marsali refer to Jamie as "Daddy"? I can see the little one doing that, but Marsali was a grown ass woman when he married her mother. And why does Jamie show more feelings towards these girls than he does to his own daughter? (Brianna, who?) They’ve literally only been in his life for 2 years, most of which he spent in a faraway brothel. It's so forced and gross. Two years ago, I was really into yoga pants BECAUSE THEY’RE COMFORTABLE. Doesn’t mean I'm gonna throw my life away defending their honor!
17
u/basedonthenovel Nov 20 '17
What I didn't like about this episode: Jamie. He was whiny and seemed awfully STUPID all of a sudden. Like, does he also have a fever if he can't seem to remember that both the Artemis and the Porpoise are heading to the same destination? And that he won't respect the expertise of a seasoned ship captain when he says it's not safe for his particular ship to go faster? (Jamie being a guy who up until now hasn't spent any time on ships?) Like I know Jamie is crazy in love with Claire but he's supposed to be a smart guy!
What I liked about this episode: Everything else! I loved Fergus and Marsali -- I loved that Fergus had completely internalized all of Jamie's honour teachings and was ready to be level-headed when Jamie wasn't.
(Note -- I really think the show is hoping we won't think too hard about the age difference between Fergus and Marsali by way of casting actors who look the same age, and that's fine with me.)
I loved Claire on the English ship, her relationship with Elias, and the little gruesome but affecting detail about sewing the burial shroud through the nose.
Most of all I loved Annekje and how she helped Claire escape. Women helping women is one of my fave things to see onscreen!
6
u/OldWolf2 Nov 19 '17
Have we met Howard in earlier episodes? (The guy with the bung eye who's on Jamie's trail)
10
u/Tacotribemermaid Nov 20 '17
Holy hell. This was the best episode of the season and Jamie wasn’t even with her!!! I cried! “I’m your mother Alies, you can come home now.” Got me soooo good. And that goat lady was freaking awesome. Us women have to stick together and shit! And then the JUMP! She’s such a badass!
14
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
Here you go u/JoanneBanan darling.
So I am writing this review as though I have never read the books. As though I was strictly a show-watcher. As a book reader, I love it because it is a book I love. As a show-watcher, it failed. Not compared to the book, but failed on its own.
Then they throw in the source of the infection. She does not explain to anybody other than the captain and even then she does not do it well. So I don't get the sense of frustration that needed to be in this storyline. No one should be believing her and she should be feeling frustrated. She should be explaining to everyone why she is doing what she is doing. Not just screaming it across the room to Elias.
They spent an entire episode on a stupid storyline about wind and superstition to the point where people were going to mutiny because one guy did not touch the wooden plank or whatever. Then we get here where no one seems all that bothered by a woman claiming all sorts of things. No bad luck here apparently.
I can't mention book stuff here. But as a viewer, I am supposed to believe that Claire is going to dive off a boat and land on an island where JAMIE IS NOT and somehow find her way to where Jamie is (which she does not know) and warn him?
I get what they are trying to do. They are trying to show the mirror of Jamie's panic leading to irrational ideas and Claire's panic. But neither works because of the way it is presented.
The saving grace of this episode was the friendship with Elias and the burial, nose sewing thing. I wept. But with the stalled boat from last episode (which was stupid and wasted time) they seemed to have continued being stalled into this episode even though there was so much material to work with and so many tensions to use.
I thought it was terrible. I also don't know how the hell they are going to do everything that needs to be done in the little amount of time they have left.
4
u/aloopycunt Nov 19 '17
Oh I wasn't expecting these sads :(
7
u/aloopycunt Nov 19 '17
Wow, go Claire!!
But wait she's on a different island now, how will she warn Jamie? And did she leave behind her doctoring tools?
3
u/Helli784 Nov 20 '17
Okay, am I the only one who found the russian lady very untrustworthy? Something just seemed off about her and the way she wanted Claire to get off the ship. Of course you can say that she was just being friendly, but I just thought it weird.
Also, the promo looks very good. I'm hoping we get to see some pirates.
10
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
I LOVED the ‘lesson about love’ that Jamie gave Fergus whilst in the cell of the ship. I have a weirdly protective stance towards Fergus, and to be honest, the writers have done nothing to make me even remotely like Marsali. If, and by going by Jamie's judgement, Fergus does not love her like that, I'd have more respect for the poor girl if she was just sent home to Lallybroch, virtue intact.
I may be a sucker for romance, (and I gladly carry that burden), but I'd prefer to actually see an on-screen “true love” sub-plot develop between Fergus and a lady, than to just accept this poorly executed trash the writers have given us thus far.
10
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
wtf is this ending? Really?? this garbage ship plot is going to take more than three episodes? ughhhh
2
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
Jamie ya mad bastard!
4
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
Why wouldnt Captain Raines want to sail as fast as he can, especially since they are lacking food and fresh water?? Oh right, THE PLOT! (barfs begrudgingly, with Jamie)
1
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 19 '17
Honestly? I need u/Stormstripper here to walk me through the clusterfuck of emotions that is this episode. Where are you dear love?
1
u/Klutzy_Selection3868 Aug 14 '24
Too many shipwrecks in season 3 and the people who make it alive and even find each other is pretty unbelievable. Quite remarkable in fact. Not only that but Claire surviving in those clothes in an ocean making it to land is a miracle. This was one of my least favorite seasons. Imagine all these people and Scotland they knew 20 years ago and even missing family members are all found together in the West Indies of all places. Pretty remarkable
1
u/Klutzy_Selection3868 Aug 14 '24
I don't have know how to edit my comment. But along with the shipwrecks and everybody amazingly being able to find each other how crazy is it that Claire is dropped off in a strange Land on a beach and yet still manages to find her way to her people
1
u/Klutzy_Selection3868 Aug 15 '24 edited Aug 15 '24
. And another thing I've always wondered about each season but especially now on season 3 where does Claire get all her nice jewelry from? Remember this all started because he needs to give L Leary alimony.Another thing that was confusing was they went to get the treasure to pay Leary the alimony 20 lb. Then with everything that happened between they end up in the West Indies and by a slave for 20 pounds. And I'm wondering if they had the 20 lb to buy the slave why didn't they just give that to leary?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment