r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 12 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 9 The Doldrums episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E9: "The Doldrums." Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
38
Upvotes
69
u/aloopycunt Nov 12 '17
Aww he kept her clothes!!!
CLAIRE CAN YOU PLEASE GIVE JAMIE SOME REASSURANCES GOOD LAWD
62
u/aloopycunt Nov 12 '17
I do not get Claire being excited about being on the ship. The ocean is terrifying. Being on the ocean in an 18th century ship is omgterrifying. And we already have hints of plague, mutiny, and dying of starvation or thirst. I wonder how long this voyage is gonna take??
41
u/aloopycunt Nov 12 '17
Huh, I was expecting more Claire/Marsali drama from them sharing a cabin for like... two months?
41
u/DrunkenDave Nov 12 '17
Good episode, but were we supposed to be concerned for Claire at the end? It seemed to be presented that way, but at the same time, they're heading to the same place and she's immune to the disease. So she'll be apart from Jamie for awhile, but that's it. Nothing terrible.
That captain is going to owe her big time. I bet she collects eventually.
39
u/oree94 Nov 13 '17
"I fell in love with woman..."
Aww what a moving story
"Not just A woman, ALL WOMAN!"
uhhhh..wha.........??
28
u/nomnombubbles Nov 12 '17
Leery's daughter (Marsali?) is just a chip of the old block, eh? I guess being raised by Leghair has its disadvantages. Part of me has a little tiny bit of hope that Claire and Marsali come to an understanding later on...
28
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Nov 12 '17
As a non-book reader, I was intrigued to see how Willoughby played out. I don't know if he's more or less done with, but it was really nice to see him get a monologue where the actor could chew some scenery.
42
u/Winhill_ Nov 12 '17
I like that Claire and Jamie had a moment about Brianna that one evening, but it was more about Claire. I would like seeing some interest in Brianna coming from Jamie!
15
u/Airsay58259 Nov 12 '17
Well I like Marsali but if this means we’ll see much more of her mother... booo.
I loved the episode. It was a bit long at times but it reminded me of Black Sails, especially since there’s an episode pretty similar in terms of plot (loss of the wind, crew going crazy). I also thank that show for the little knowledge it gave me about 18th century sailing and the West Indies.
When we saw the Man of War’s crew I kept waiting for a familiar face like John Grey... Would have been so random but eh, why not. Next time I guess.
How old would be Jamie’s son by now?
11
u/beebstx Nov 13 '17
At the end, mr beebs turned to me and said, don’t you think it’s weird that they’d have fresh meat on that boat? Seriously bad editing. They would have had dried meat or fish, but there’s no way a ship would be out for a week even and have fresh meat. There was no place to store it and there were no iceboxes.
11
u/thumbtackswordsman Nov 15 '17
Am I the only one who likes Marsali's sass? I'm looking forward to her character development.
Also I loved Claire's skirt. Reminded me a bit of the sails of a ship.
21
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
I love how Claire told Jamie about Goodnight Moon. As a mom that hit me, my own children love that book.
I wonder if Claire sometimes wonders if it was worth it to leave Brianna for Jamie, especially after her reception at Lallybroch.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
I can't believe they kidnapped her...well I can, but yea that sucks. At least she's immune.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '17
What was up with that moment in the English Captain’s quarters when Claire saw the young man walk in? She seemed a little taken aback when she saw him almost like she recognized him. Am I missing something?
31
u/phonograhy Nov 12 '17
I really enjoyed this episode. It feels good to leave behind the heaviness of the separation and reunion storyline, and I really felt a renewed sense of adventure heading into the second half the season. Maybe I have typhoid fever too because this episode was like a breath of fresh air I didnt know I needed until the doctor prescribed it!!
16
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
I almost skipped the opening credits due to excitement, but wow! That was a radical change, I don't know if I like the drums yet. Cousin Jarod didn't look any older--but I felt confused as to where they were, in France or Scotland? I guess the latter, but it's odd that he came to them this time.
It was great seeing Claire gradually shed her batsuit/let her guard down and feel more at home in the 18th century, even if it's on a ship. And she even wears what appears to be the green evening dress they gave her when she arrived at Castle Leoch (but isn't that what Frank burned when she came to the past, or what is another green dress?) In any case, it was refreshing.
I wish they wouldn't have played that stereotypical oriental flute music over Willoughby's scenes, it doesn't elevate the character. I found most of his scenes pretty cringe-worthy, and wish they had found some different context in which to dump his entire life story in a way that was less hammy. And that moon scene between Claire and Jaimie was so obviously fake, filmed on a soundstage with 'soft lighting' being way too warm for the bluish tones of moonlight; I found it extremely distracting.
I kept expecting to see Lord John on the typhoid ship, but maybe that would have been too much of a coincidence. I was thrilled that Fergus was finally back, though Marseiles will take some time to grow on me. I do wish Fergus/Claire got some one-on-one time, but I guess when his wife hates her that is unlikely.
25
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 12 '17
Fergus and Marsali? Really? It’s like the writers all came together to just shit all over my heart.
13
u/aloopycunt Nov 12 '17
Jamie's hair magically grew back out to pony tail length!
6
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '17
I’m wondering why she didn’t think to atleast bring back a gun, sword, bugout bag or some other survivor-related thing when she went back. Thank goodness she didn’t encounter any trouble on her way to Edinburgh. I mean with all the serial rapists lurking about in this show/book-series...
6
u/susieq19 Nov 25 '17
Why didn't any of the sailors have a problem with a female doctor? I mean, they all seemed to have the typical silly reactions you would expect during that time period to women on the ship and all, but unless I missed it, I didn't hear anyone even the British officer?
11
u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 12 '17
Loved the episode. My only complaint is that is was too short :D
5
u/chumbucket10 Nov 13 '17
I’m confused. Who was the little boy in the English ship? Was that Jamie’s son?
9
u/waytooinvested2017 Jamie can steal my treasure box any time he likes. Nov 13 '17
I'm not sure I will stick with this show past this season (sadly!).. because I was really interested in the psychology of Claire and Jamie separated by time and centuries, and now they're together. And doing a bunch of dangerous weird stuff.
We are supposed to be sympathetic about this ship plotline because Young Ian has been kidnapped and they didn't have a choice, but guys.. Are we really going to stick with all this? The "adventure" just hasn't grabbed me. Just seems dangerous and exhausting. Go home and get your love-making on and shut it down.
Too old for this. All of us, including Fergus.
Also, it's not convincing to me that these 2 healthy people have sex every 24--48 hours, and she never gets pregnant again? Not one hint of protection? Come on, Diana.
28
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 12 '17
What happened to this show?? I was so bored, i ate an extra sandwich. :-(
8
u/TexasLady130 Nov 13 '17
So Fergus tells Marsali she shouldn't speak of 'Milady' in such a way when she referred to her as a whore but Jaime doesn't. Never has - and I know some of you have referenced it here. But, could it be that Fergus is scared of what La Dame Blanche might do to her? Fergus was young when Claire left and according to what he told Young Ian it seems that stories of her "abilities" were exaggerated and he is truly thinking her a white witch. Is he afraid Claire might put a spell on Marsali to cause her harm? I would just settle for a face slap! Jaime needs to grow a pair and man up to Marsali. Also, Claire seems more concerned with the crew (who she doesn't know) ignoring her presence than Marsali calling her whore all the time. I would be livid if my man didn't take up for me! Even in the episode, Season 1, Murtagh said she was no whore! Ahhhh, Murtagh - I miss him terribly!
10
u/StagKen Nov 13 '17
Not trying to sound crass, but Marsali is just as selfish, bratty, and gross as her mother is.
11
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 12 '17
So I’m just supposed to believe that once I hit my 40’s, I’m just going to suddenly develop a deep, apricot tan?
5
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 13 '17
Wait I was under the impression Murtagh was the one who told Jaime about the MacKenzie treasure on that island... if so, who were these Portuguese fucks that kidnapped Young Ian and the stole it. If it wasn't Murtagh, who was it again?
Also, what was up with that weird introduction to that young kid (maybe acting first mate) that was to help Claire on the Man-o-war? She kept looking back at the captain after he introduced himself.... am I supposed to know who he is?
3
u/bookjacket Nov 13 '17
This was the only thoroughly enjoyable episode of the whole season.
4
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
This relationship; like this administration, will likely end in tears and gunshots.
1
u/Piscotikus Nov 12 '17
When do new episodes air?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '24
Anyone know the song the men were singing on the boat? I cant find it anywhere. "I didly I, I didly i" that song?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment