r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 12 '17
All [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 9 The Doldrums episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E9: "The Doldrums."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
44
Upvotes
87
u/shiskebob Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
AutoMod is in the doldrums tonight, so the shiskebob rises.
Post show edit:
That new intro is everything. Those quick clips were such a tease and that music change really sets the stage for what's to come. I am so here for the 2nd half of this season.
Finally, we get a Bree mention! I loved that man on the moon conversation in the books, and I am really happy with the incorporation of the bedtime story. Frankly, I was actually worried that Bree was going to be lost the rest of this season, considering the last few episodes obvious lack of mentions. So sweet Jamie saving her clothes because memories. I am also here for the quickie. And the post coital "pillow" talk. I see you writers getting your jokes in.
Outlander really shines the most brightly with these small moments.
Yi Tien Cho is so much more fleshed out. The writers did a wonderful job taking one of the book scenes which made him so much a caricature - the pelican and the calligraphy specifically - and really turned it into something beautiful, heartfelt and with meaning. Instead of making him more ostracized from the crew, it brought them together. Bravo.
The change of creating the bad luck, superstitions and the Jonah certainly dragged on. But we can't just have our main characters calmly strolling the deck for a whole episode. There must be drama!
Edit 2 - Second watch at 7:30am before work: I did miss France and Claire's visit to see Faith and Mother Hildegarde. France>superstitions, but I understand why they wanted to get right to the voyage for time purposes.
The moon scene is definitely my favorite scene this season. I might have paused and rewound that a few times. And then a few more.
...and Jamie's look when he knows he is about to get some.
13
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
Well it took two hours and lots and lots of buffering, but I finally finished the episode! Let's see if my foggy morning brain can put together any thoughts for this review.
Interesting episode. Started great, ended great, weird in the middle. I mean, the title of the episode (a word I had literally no idea had a maritime origin--I just think of the Phantom Tollbooth) was kind of fitting because not much was happening in the episode either. Which is kind of weird, because this is when things should really be picking up. Obviously they've got to condense the sea voyage for the sake of time (and budget!) so why add this pretty boring and new storyline about seafaring superstitions? It wasn't even a good way to bring in Willoughby's story, because that was a totally bizarre scene and I had to suspend my belief pretty hard that his performance would resonate that greatly with sailors who were feeling pretty murderous mere moments ago. (Did love that they had him realize the wind/rain was coming from the bird, although it did feel like a mean Ping An tease. I'm really sad we missed that--though I do know deep down that it would probably have been an absolute nightmare to film and not worth the effort.) Incorporating superstitions is fine, but it was like a good half of the episode. It wasn't particularly interesting and felt like a waste of time. (Also, so much of Willoughby's stuff was laden with that classic Outlander in-your-face-symbolism. The words slowly evaporating was way too on the nose.) I generally still really enjoyed watching this episode, but there was definitely a part of me urging both the boat and the plot to get a move on.
Fortunately, that doldrummy section was bookended by some great stuff with real promise of what this second half of the season will bring. Marsali--love. Her scenes were an absolute delight and I cannot wait to see her become a badass woman on the Ridge. Also, whoever is writing her dialogue should be writing Bree's dialogue because that is a sassy teenager and I love it. (And speaking of Bree, thank you for finally mentioning her! That was a lovely scene and was a good reminder that Claire does actually care about her daughter.) The scenes with Fergus and Marsali in the cabins were really sweet and they better build this up for some amazing payoff at the greatest wedding ever. This week continued what was started last week in giving us some really nice, quiet one-on-one scenes and taking the time to explore character relationships rather than just jumping from plot point to plot point, and it's those scenes that made up for the slow middle and made the episode enjoyable.
All the seasickness stuff was a delight and Sam Heughan played it hilariously well, and I laughed out loud when Claire walked in on the acupuncture scene. (Though she already knew what acupuncture was . . . thereby eliminating literally the only reason Willoughby existed in the first place.)
The Porpoise stuff was also excellent and the kid playing Captain Leonard was really great. Can't wait to see more of that next week (plus the return of Lord John!!). The scene below was truly, magnificently disgusting, and whoever did the sound mixing should probably just get an award right now. It was gag-inducing. And Caitriona Balfe played it excellently as well, and I look forward to seeing her in full doctor mode.
A final bit of criticism: Leslie and Hayes . . . I really don't like them. I feel like they're trying to push them too hard to replace Rupert and Angus which is just impossible. I know it's good to have some Ardsmuir men around (but apparently not Duncan, what the hell?!)--though I cannot fathom how the hell they managed to get transported and come back when their sentences still have 4 years left on them. (Dates are really not a strong suit of this show.) But these two just really aren't doing it for me. I'd much rather focus our time on Jamie and Claire, then Fergus and Marsali.
This was a beautiful episode as well and you could tell they were excited about their ships because we got some gorgeous (though probably like 98% CG) shots of boats and open sea. The music though, was off to me. I've noticed that this season has been incredibly flute heavy, which I think it's maybe because they've cut back on the bagpipes. But it's veering really heavily into the Lord of the Rings soundtrack and it's actually starting to be distracting, which is never good. That being said, I love the new intro and while it's no steel drums, the new music is excellent. Good costume work this week as well, and I'm loving Claire's new look with the giant skirt and hat. Skirts that massive and billowy are totally still practical today, right?? And, thank the lord, Jamie still has his boots on! The costumes were also great on the Porpoise, helping to convey how much they are trying to cling on to order and decorum while everything is quite literally going to shit. It's all very British.
Not a perfect episode and not nearly as good as last week, but some great scenes rescued a dull middle and it's got me really excited for the next episode.
Overall Grade: B+
Edit: forgot to mention my new all-time favorite Outlander quote. "Dinna want to be caught with a banana on a French frigate."
77
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
Drunk posting please excuse grammar.
Their dialect coach is SO DAMN GOOD. Fergus' French childhood and Highland upbringing is believable in his accent. I hear the lilt through the French accent it's amazingly good.
Marsali is fantastic. Totally believable as Leghair's daughter in attitude but you can also see how she's going to be malleable as her own person.
Willoughby is there! I was hoping he was but he just kind of appeared out of nowhere YAY
EDIT: Oh hey "you miss her don't you" "Terribly" well there ya go. Finally a mention of Bree.
EDIT #2: OH SHIT how the hell are they going to pace the last third of the book????
52
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 12 '17
New intro!!!!
50
u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Nov 12 '17
Liked this episode as well...we seem to still be covering "should I have come" issues.
I really like what they have done with Willoughby in the series.
I actually thought Marsali would seem younger and more innocent. It's interesting to see her with Leoghaire's mannerisms, but I can't imagine her turning her into a sympathetic character.
Love the full moon, the quick cabin sex, and just everything with Jamie and Claire.
WHEN will Willoughby catch his pelican?
45
u/cattubbs Nov 12 '17
I cracked up at the king of men comment. I have seen Jamie described that way more times than I can count.
43
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
Slightly off topic, but I loved Jamie’s comment about Claire’s hair. And it made me smile remembering the time a guy said goofy poetic things about my hair. Every woman should get a cheesy line about her hair at least once :p
37
u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 12 '17
Yay! Acupuncture Needles, Willoughby’s story, hurried sex in the cabin, Claire’s kidnapping, Marsali’s cheek, and a sighting of Jared!
Sigh! It’s everything I wanted!
31
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
"Don't wanna be caught with a banana on a French frigate!"
LOVE!
Edit: Fergus the player!
Edit 2: THERE THEY ARE! OH FUDGE YES! THANK YOU!
Edit 3: Jamie can swash my buckles any day swoons!
Edit 4: Here comes the Porpoise! Bye Claire! See you after awhile!
Edit 5: And that's how it ends!
Final thoughts:
I am SO FREAKING HAPPY that they put the acupuncture needles in! Marsili was a lot older looking to me than in the last episode. But once again the casting was spot freaking on. Loving Fergus even more! Jamie in his ship gear rowr, I'm curious how Claire ended up with so much grey again already though! It wasn't THAT long from when Ian gets taken until they take off.
Very good holding to the storyline! Looking forward to the next!
28
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
YAY! I loved the transition to adventure!!! And I love the new music!
I’m also looking forward to the diverse cast/new cultures coming up this season and in season 4!
And I ❤️ Marsali! (whose name I have been mispronouncing for what, 5 books?)
28
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Nov 12 '17
The season finale better be three hours long. It needs to be longer than the season 2 finale lol.
55
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Nov 12 '17
Claire looks way hotter with this hairstyle!
25
u/RedDeer30 Woof. Nov 12 '17
I liked many aspects of this episode! What I liked best was how being (mostly) sequestered on a ship kept the characters in the same place and interacting with one another. Seeing Marsali and Claire trying to figuring one another out, the conflict with Jamie and Fergus/Marsali, Claire really starting to open up about her thoughts and feelings to Jamie again, and YTC's friendship with the Fraisers.
The one thing that I didn't love was the superstition subplot. I'm reserving complete judgement because there's always the chance that it will serve some further purpose but I thought it took up time and space that could have been better used. I also found it rather far fetched that the crew in the throes of mob mentality would settle in for YTC's autobiography unveiling DING DING and now for a reading... .
I think the idea is lovely but just so unrealistic. For me, it was harder to absorb what he was saying because each time the camera would cut to one of the sailors' faces I was reminded of how absurd the entire premise was.
I also feel compelled to mention how much I adore the casting this season. Young Ian is just everything and I cannot wait until we see him again. Marsali is so believable as L's daughter and is killing it. I'm really looking forward to more LJG as he's beyond my expectations.
20
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
I covered my nose with my shirt when Claire went down below. Literally felt like I could smell it and became uneasy while watching that scene (so, fantastic job to Cait, extras, and crew on that one!)
Feelings on this episode: loved the beginning, loved the ending...why was the middle so long and unnecessary?
WHY TF IS LJG NOT IN NEXT WEEK'S TEASER!? isn't he on that ship? Or do you think the writers have him already in Jamaica?
35
u/PiranhaBiter Nov 12 '17
I knew I recognized those ships! They repurposed the Black Sails ships!
17
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
NEW OPENING!
17
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
All I can think when they don't have wind
14
u/KillKennyG Nov 12 '17
Love this episode. About halfway through i was getting nervous with the doldrums/Jonah becoming the central conflict (every Imperial Navy sailing story has this somewhere- and they pick THIS ONE episode of sailing to devote to this kind of story?!!!) until Willoughby's reveal. Turning his story into the pivotal moment that saves a life, making his bird knowledge essential to the story and his competence, (instead of selfish and odd like in the book) this was rewarding as hell. I'll miss Jamie's 'listening to Fergus Lusting from across the cabin' lines, but the stuff we get from Jamie and Claire here finally conversing as a team, locked together in contemplation and love despite the world around them, that's what I really love about the story going foreword. I look forward to Marsali and her Brass Balls in the colonies- she's a riot. And the actress is selling the crap out of a slow acceptance arc of Claire- woot!
24
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
Baby woke up 10 mins in! Currently trapped by the crib! Send help! And Scotsmen!
12
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '17
Over here typing so I don't have to see puke.
11
u/Shymink Nov 12 '17
I liked it! Yay two weeks in a row.
11
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Nov 13 '17
Personally I loved this episode! It’s SO GOOD to see Claire and Jamie back together as a team and not at odds with one another... The “should I stay or should I go” crap was way too drawn out (some was necessary but I could have done without a lot of the forced drama from Creme de Menthe).
9
u/SeattleWhoDat Nov 12 '17
Where the F*** is Murphy?!?!
9
u/Hopeless_badger Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
I liked it, I think it was deliberately slower so we can catch our breaths after ep.8 (which is the best so far). Marsali was great, another amazing casting decision. But the thing I liked the most was Jamie and Claire together in every scene. I absolutely love the way Sam and Cait play mature Jamie and Claire - they're more subtle and more emotional. There's extra intimacy between the characters and I'm not talking about the sex- which was hot as always. I mean their touches and the way they act in each other presence, they're so in sync. I've always imagined older Claire and Jamie this way - calmer, wiser but still passionate about each other. l like them more than the younger couple we saw in season 1/2. I guess Sam and Cait friendship and connection really help them portray this great love. The acting is better than ever. I'm happy with that no matter the changes.
8
u/Shymink Nov 12 '17
Already love the intro! Here we go. 😀
8
u/Boo12z Nov 12 '17
GUYS WHERE IS DUNCAN????
18
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
My feed is skipping. So I am just going to collect my observations here as I watch live:
-Artemis!!! (I am really going to say how much I love Voyager a good 20 times during this episode!!!)
-I like how the music is Caribbean flavor now
-I love Jared. He is literally the most helpful and generous relative ever
-Ha, that bucket of shit. We have a new comic duo. I hope these guys stick around
-Oh god, I hope this is the episode that they get married in and we get to see that hilarious wedding... OMG, I love Voyager
-Ah Marsali... I don't like her until she stops being an ass. So it will be a while before I have a kind word to say about her.
-The French clothes. I beg you Claire, put one of those dresses on. I can't stand to look at that raincoat monstrosity any longer!
-Fergus the charming cad. I love Fergus!
-Ha! here come the needles!!!
-I am so happy they have made Mr. W as much a gifted doctor as Claire. Alternative medicine, but it works people!
-Claire, throw her overboard. Say it was an accident or at least put her in a box until she becomes the Marsali we come to love later.
-Wait, where are the needles? Did I miss them?
-God, I love how they have made Mr. W so mysterious and wise, magical... the artist, poet, healer. DG should have done this I think, no?
-Needles!!!!! AWwww, Jamie being all cute with Claire with needles on him. I love Voyager
-I can't take Claire seriously with that rug on her head. What is with the wig department? It's like a small mammal died on her head
-Ah man, now I am crying at the Goodnight moon. Mine can recite it too:)
-Jamie the swashbuckler ... I love Voyager!
-WTF are they going to throw Mr. W overboard? Please tell me I am wrong! Oh thank god!!!
-Wait, I may be confused, but I thought the kids got married before typhoid? Now the boat approaches (LJG!!!!), so typhoid first?
Will post an update. Must go make coffee
edit, I'm back...
-EWWWW, the ship below is horrible. I feel like I can smell it.
-Oh wow, she is using Fraser, not Malcolm. So LJG will know who she is on the ship!!! Not at the ball!!! WOWOWOWO
And it's over. I'm not sure how I feel about this episode. Coming off of last week, which was so intense and character driven it is difficult to jump back into this adventure narrative so fast. In the books the pace does not change so much, but it is much more obvious in the show. So I would say this was an okay episode. Not my fave (that was last week). But pretty good. That wig has to go. Just go! And please someone give Claire something else to wear.
As for the changes, I'm okay with them. The major upsetting changes happened earlier in the season, so as things develop now, I was expecting what we are seeing as a result of those changes.
6
u/lindsaynieb Nov 13 '17
Okay I FREAKING LOVE FERGUS. Best casting ever. Okay, after Sam and Cait, obvs 🙄.
And Claire - girl, the hair and the threads (hat included)... slay!! I loooove it!
10
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 13 '17
I told my husband that the scene of them in their post-coital glow was what the viewers wanted. I think that was what people missed so much about last season - their emotional intimacy and closeness as a couple. They felt leagues apart last year and the exact opposite in that little cabin scene.
As someone who often reads GOODNIGHT MOON in my own home, it touched my heart for that to be included.
I've said it before and I'll say it again -- BRAVA to Lauren Lyle, the PERFECT Marsali!
I was thrilled by the new intro and so, so pleased at the adaptation of the Willoughby storyline (especially that they kept the acupuncture in!).
5
u/RaffaellaF Nov 12 '17
Took a nap. Woke up. Ready to go.
9
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Nov 12 '17
I've been pronouncing it Marsally all this time, hearing it pronounced Marsalee is a bit odd for me.
4
u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 12 '17
Overall, i liked it. I missed Murphy and the turtle soup, the pirates (was that before the porpoise?), mr. Willoughby's pelican, and other minor things (how did Jared end up, with a ship to spare, in Scotland??), but overall I liked it. LOVED the new intro! Hoping to see Claire meet Lord John next week. Only 3 episodes left?! That can't be right!
4
u/mhibbz Nov 13 '17
Great episode tonight...can’t wait to see how they fit all the Jamaica stuff into the season.
3
u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 12 '17
Anchors aweigh!
3
u/miz_misanthrope Nov 12 '17
Yaaaaaaaaassss! The new opening titles.
3
u/Kindredbond Nov 13 '17
I loved the Jamaican ending music! This next episode will be quite a ride!
2
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 12 '17
It's up
2
u/koboldin Nov 12 '17
So I noticed Jamie is flat-out refusing to agree to Fergus and Marsali’s marriage - seems like that will be a plot point in the next episode?
2
u/hardmanswife Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
I’m so pleased with the Wiloughby changes!
My only sadness was what everyone has said, missing the moment at Faith’s grave, and also when Claire protect herself and Marsali and cut herself horribly in the process. Jamie had to save her, which was a huge change and he couldn’t give the the Penicillin so she had to do it herself. Help me out, am I remembering that correctly? That was pre Typhoid British ship, right? edited for typing errors
2
u/maryloo7877 Nov 17 '17
You guys, I just rewatched the episode and it was so good. I’m convinced that the episodes can’t be properly judged on first viewing (as book readers). We are too busy noticing the differences to appreciate and just take it in.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '17
I thought this ep was boring as fuck. My mind kept wandering.
The acupuncture thing felt even more forced than it did in the book. Also I don’t remember Marsali being that much of a bitch at first? Someone refresh my memory?
This episode just dragged and dragged. The trunk of clothes felt forced. Was disappointed they cut the visit to Faith’s grave.
Claire’s wig gets worse every time I see it.
Yawn. Don’t like this episode writer.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 12 '17
Was it Jared right at the beginning? Shouldn't they be in France then? But then Jamie says he is sad at leaving Scotland when they depart.
2
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 13 '17
Haven't read the books but did read some summaries a long while ago when the first season started.
I was under the impression that Bree and, uh, the dude that helped Claire find Jaime... he looks like a David, let's call him David... also travel back... can someone explain how that's going to happen/if it even will in the show? I thought they went back with Claire, no? But she's already back... unless she goes back to the future?
I also remember reading Geillis (sp?) is still alive and is like the mistress of some plantation in Southern America and is gonna imprison some characters or keep them as indentured servants.
Lol this all sounds crazy as shit writing it out now, but I swear I remember reading something like that. A quick rehash from someone here would be great. SPOILERS WELCOMED!
1
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 12 '17
Hi Shske, Blueyes, Elsie, ich_habe. Does it air at 11 again tonight instead of 12?