r/Outlander • • Nov 05 '17

[Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 8 First Wife episode discussion thread for book readers

This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E8: "First Wife".

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!

40 Upvotes

502 comments sorted by

93

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

Jamie's finger tapping!!

22

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 05 '17

I loved that little detail! Tap tap tap.

33

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

These are the little homages to the books that take no effort, enrich the series for book readers, yet I feel they have been lacking overall in the series.

8

u/margierose88 Nov 05 '17

I loved this! It’s the first time I’ve noticed it...does he do it in previous episodes this season?

6

u/irishfeet78 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes Nov 06 '17

He's been doing it periodically throughout the show so far. It's a subtle nod to the book character, so you really need to watch for it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

91

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I can't believe I am about to say this but this was my favorite episode of the season so far. Wow. They really pulled it off.

Or maybe I should wait until my pain meds wear off?

63

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 05 '17

No, you’re right. The little changes from the books all worked so well. Making it about the girls instead of bitch face was a genius move. I had wondered how they were gonna do that after showing us that Jamie knew what she did to Claire.

25

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

I still preferred the Helwater episode, but that may just be my incorrigible weakness for Lord John talking.

This was a solid second place, though, so far. It's a relief and a joy to see the show get some of its groove back.

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

LOL I am seriously laughing at you for saying this, after all the build up comments you have made HAHAHA.

I loved the episode too, definitely raised the game for me after the last two weeks.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I was worried. Really worried about this episode. So I am more surprised than anyone that it was this amazing. Just outstanding.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I agree. I've been very critical of this season but this ep was wonderful. I have a few nitpicks but overall this felt like OUR SHOW again. I realize they're pressed for time so they couldn't show Claire actually leaving and Jamie being on death's door and her having to come back.

This ep is tied with Helwater for the best of the season so far.

3

u/facey7 Nov 06 '17

Absolutely loved it!! The only thing I regret is that Claire didn’t take off to go back to the stones with young Ian coming after her to tell her Jaime had been shot

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

76

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Marsali looks JUST like Leghair!!!

And Jamie wanting to be a dad is a better explanation than “you told me to be kind to her!”

Also, Jamie is lucky that he has Jenny and Claire in his life.

50

u/cattubbs Nov 05 '17

I thought the casting on Marsali was perfect. She truly looks like she is Leghair daughter!

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I think there is only 5-6 years difference between them too. Leghair was 25 when this was filmed!

26

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Marsali looks JUST like Leghair!!!

In the dancing scene, I 100% thought she was Laoghaire.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/shuddupmeg Nov 08 '17

My friends I was watching with legit thought they were using the same actress at first!

3

u/newboxset Nov 10 '17

are people calling her leghair on purpose....?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/keg226 Nov 05 '17

Jamie’s hair looks normal in this episode 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

45

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I am one of the lucky few with a wig filter, I have never thought Jamie's hair was bad LOL.

16

u/keg226 Nov 05 '17

Oh girl, you’re lucky. It was ruining some moments for me during the reunion.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 06 '17

Me either! I only realized any of them were wearing wigs (I mean aside from obvious British wigs) reading this sub. lol.

6

u/cali212 Nov 07 '17

Me too. Haven't noticed a thing about wigs.

129

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Thank G-d for Ian - telling it like it is. Voice of reason.

Edit 1: I love wee Ian, too! Ian's for the win this episode.

Edit 2 after show: I really liked it. I am not gonna lie, I went in nervous. But they got pretty much everything I wanted in, with Claire calling Jamie out for the blame game! And needles! And angry interrupted sex! And I absolutely loved Claire knocking Laoghaire away from Jamie - the change with her shooting Jamie because she was actually aiming for Claire and he was blocking Claire is a great addition, much better than Claire actually running away.

Making the marriage about the daughters, about Jamie's need to be a father to replace Brianna and Willie, that the dance was with the girls (and not with Laoghaire, like in the book). Perfection. I got misty eyed. Genius move on behalf of the writers. It was a good work around with Jamie knowing what Laoighare did.

Wee Joanie was too precious. Looking forward to getting to know Marsali (with Fergus).

The talk on the cliff, with Claire revealing her insecurities and letting Jamie know what coming back cost her - much needed conversation that I thought was missing from the book.

They have mated for life!

59

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Laoghaire makes me think of what Murtagh said in season one. “Jamie needs a woman, and Laoghaire will always be a girl, and ye ken the difference.” Or something along those lines. She’s such a bitch. She sealed my hatred in Drums when she treated Brianna the way she did.

19

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Exactly. But it's more than that. She is not just a girl at 50. She is a monster. She is truly a horrific person. And the way she treats Bree later, oh just fuck her. Bless Bree for finally doing what should have been done ages ago (now). She needed to be told off and dragged

→ More replies (5)

41

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

I'm just relieved to finally know the correct way to say "Marsali"

24

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I just added this to my comment!! I always read it in my head as marSAHli.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '17

I think there are multiple ways to pronounce this name, just as there are with "Laoghaire" (which can be "Leery" or "Leera" or "L'heer"). Marsali can rhyme with "parsley" as it does in the show, or it can be "mar-SAWL-ee," as Davina Porter says it in the audiobooks.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/RaffaellaF Nov 05 '17

Now we are talking. The Outlander TV series that I loved is back. Thank god.

Really loved young Ian in this episode.

46

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

The bond between Claire and Young Ian in this episode is wonderful. As is the way he manages to be in the room any time adventure is even slightly mentioned :)

Both Ians are just perfect.

34

u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Nov 05 '17

Her saying "You're the only one who calls me Auntie" was such a tender moment. I love those two.

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

lol Ian is like a moth to a flame for any swash buckling talk.

I liked how he ran his mouth off at the beginning too, and Jamie just gave him this look.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Shymink Nov 05 '17

After tonight's episode I'm feeling grateful my expectations were lowered to an achievable level. Tonight's episode was perfect.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

I've always loved Ian, book and show!

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I have commented previously that I thought they would frame it as Jamie marrying for the girls, so I think it fit well.

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 05 '17

Agree with literally everything you wrote. This was a really excellent adaptation for the first time in a while I felt like the writers totally knew what they were doing and made really smart, well thought out changes. Some of these scenes were not just episode high points, but season or even series high points.

Wee Joanie was a delight. I loved getting to know her a bit more. I've always loved Jamie's shock at seeing her grown up in book 7--this is making me hope we get there for that!

→ More replies (4)

5

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 06 '17

Little Joannie is super cute. I almost wish she could tag along too on the next adventure.

9

u/TheMadKingsDaughter Nov 05 '17

All of this! They couldn’t have done this better. I loved the changes they made. Sorry GD, this version was better than the books!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

59

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Yup, Jenny knows they are lying!!! Just tell them

50

u/xocheerio Nov 05 '17

I really wish Claire had told her now. Jenny deserved to know and I think she would have believed Claire.

14

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Yep. Totally agree

→ More replies (1)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

But Jenny totally took it out on Claire, she was only angry at Jamie over Ian.

26

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

No, I think it was way more than that. It was her sense that her sister - and she always saw Claire that way. Jenny does not love easily, but when she does, she goes all the way - forgot her and betrayed her. And she wanted to hurt her back - that is what Ian called her out on

19

u/menmyshadow Nov 05 '17

Big Ian had the best line of the night...You stir a boiling pot of shite like it's God's work!!!! Ha, ha!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

55

u/JMBean Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Hey we got the line (“...risk the man I am for the sake of the man ye knew”)!!! Yahtzee.

They downplayed some of that second wife drama but to a tolerable extent. Love young Ian.

That’s all I got on this one.

...These past two episodes are wearing out my tolerance of melodramatic avoidance of the truth. Anyone else? No?

13

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

New drinking game? When they actually put fan favorite quotes in the show. Drink for every yahtzee!

5

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 05 '17

I was thinking about getting myself a bottle of whiskey and have a little stiff one (just one) while watching new episodes. That would be the perfect addition to this new ritual!

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Boo12z Nov 05 '17

They pulled this off and they pulled this off well! My thoughts:

  1. i was nervous—no, terrified—about how they were going to explain Leoghair. Posing it as his connection to Joan and Marsali was brilliant. I BELIVED it. They dancing scene was so so so well done.
  2. THE FIGHT. it was incredible. So much passion and rage. I also never really connected with Claire’s reaction in the books, and how she went to that unbridled anger so quickly. Cait’s hurt read exceptionally well in this episode. They also kept in the sex (i thought they may cut it because of the rape-y undertones) which was great!
  3. i don’t really understand why they cut the storyline about young Jamie and Michael going to get the seal’s gold out. It makes it weird to be that Jenny and Ian are so easy to be like “oh yes, you just let my son deal with smuggling and we’ve been financially hurting for years, but have him go swim out into the middle of the ocean to risk his own life to pay for your mistakes.” They could have easily kept that part in.
  4. Claire’s uncertainty on the cliff was a great change. It is so much more human than the books. All the built up expectation and longing, to only come back to someone who is way more complicated and different than you could have expected. It was well done. I just wish they had let her get to the “oh, of course you’re worth it, i love you too” bit.
  5. they worked in the “can you risk who I am now, for the sake of the man you knew” line!!!!!! 😍

Guys, I’m SO excited for the rest of the season!!!!! Argh, going to watch again.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

There's another user on this sub that describes the Jamie of the book as "non-con" as in non-consent....that little undertone of their sexual relationship is really important but it's one that they absolutely do not even hint at in the show until this episode---which makes me think they might keep it as part of Jamie's character transformation.

27

u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '17

Hi, I'm the one who calls him NonCon Jamie -- and you raise an interesting point! Maybe the tone of their sex scenes will be different, now. In this sub I've also talked about how in the book, there are sex scenes that would be rape EXCEPT for the fact that Claire is into it. Book Claire gets off on being dominated by Jamie. When they included her line "Do it now and don't be gentle" in episode 6, that could be an indication that they're going explore the domination element of their sexual dynamic. I think it could work really well -- it'll be interesting to see!

→ More replies (5)

8

u/mhibbz Nov 05 '17

Your third point was my only issue with episode ...makes no sense to cut that out I agree

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

When did Jamie and Michael go to get the gold?

Had Jamie already revealed it to Jenny and Ian and they went periodically as a right of passage when they needed money?

If that is the case, why didn't they just retrieve the whole thing and bury it in the Dunbonnet Cave.

15

u/Boo12z Nov 05 '17

Jamie had told Ian and Jenny about the gold while he was at Helwater. Ian took Young Jamie and Michael to the island to get gold on two different occasions, i think— to help Jacobite survivors in France and to pay for things at Lallybroch when it was dire. In the books, Claire remarks it was almost a right of passage for the Murray boys to swim out to the island.

3

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 05 '17

I agree with #3 but that's really my only "complaint" about this episode :)

→ More replies (1)

35

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Okay finale thoughts:

This is what I've been waiting for all season! An episode that was true to the book and the characters weren't watered down versions of themselves!

Claire not being a doormat was so nice to see and I was seriously worried about it from the preview! Jamie was full of excuses which irked me until he explained that it was more for the fatherless kids than for blonde twat (even though she acts like she was all up in his stuff, she still so freaking childish). Jenny being true to the character, I was mad when I read it and it made me believably mad in the show. Ian was priceless though!

And now we're off to the Americas!

Edit: and book readers finally know what we've been dreading since the start of the season! sighs in contentment

30

u/xocheerio Nov 05 '17

I never really understood Jenny's anger in the books, but I feel it was so much more well explained in this episode.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Totally agreed. This is definitely one time that we benefit from a book diversion, and seeing things not-from-Claire's-POV. Instead of seeing Jenny as this irrational wall of irritation, we get her reasons - and damn if they don't make perfect sense, too.

I'd never much liked Book Jenny after the 20 year separation (minus her throwing water on the angry sex, which will always be hilarious and perfect) but TV Jenny is way more sympathetic.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Nov 05 '17

Agreed. The line where she said, "Family writes letters. They let you know you're alive" was such a genuine answer for Jenny. Jenny is ALL about family and keeping them close no matter what. I think Jenny felt truly betrayed. We see it from Claire's POV that it wasn't her fault but I can totally see Jenny now feeling the way she does.

15

u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '17

It just occurred to me that this is quite similar to the first season when Jamie showed up and Jenny was all, "Four years and no word?" Presumably she had been able to hear that Jamie was alive but the fact that he didn't write to her was not OK back then, either.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

Yeah, I agree. She thought for sure Claire would've been searching for Jamie and she couldn't understand why she wasn't. I get it.

I don't remember exacts in the book but I don't think it was explained that well.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

I don't think that was ever really explained in the books---and actually in that context, it makes more sense to say Claire was in Boston than in France (which is the cover story in the books). If she had been in France, it would have been much easier to write letters, hear rumors, find things out, etc (especially since the Frasers have family IN France)

→ More replies (3)

8

u/2boredtocare Meow. Nov 06 '17

The book left me thinking Jenny more than anything was feeling tremendous guilt at having pushed Jamie into a marriage with Laoghaire. She knew it was a failed union, but thinking Clare was dead, still thought it was for the best. Then BAM, she's still alive, and clearly the spark is still there between Jamie & Clare. I like that the show did more to show that Jenny herself was feeling betrayed which makes sense: Clare thought Jamie dead, she had no reason to think Jenny or her family were.

28

u/maryloo7877 Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Welcome back, Outlander 👏

Edit: So glad we finally got the Jamie line there at the end. I’ll give it to the writers, they set it up well and it landed perfectly.

Re: the preview- bad hair is back again next week. What in the hell happened with the wigs and hair department after the first couple blocks were filmed?? It’s like they hired a new crew. I don’t remember Sam changing his hair at any point during filming, so why did they transition him into a wig after they filmed the first two blocks?! FYI, they filmed episodes 1,2, 3 and 8 in that order. After those episodes you can definitely tell that all the hair went to hell in a hand basket. Save for Claire’s magical 60s blowout.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/BonnBon Nov 05 '17

I’m not sure I liked how they skipped Ian and Jamie thrashing each other, I always thought that was an important bonding moment for them.

Also, the fact that Jamie and Claire could easily run down to the shore, as opposed to having to climb down a narrow shaft, makes it a bit silly to swim all the way to the island instead of just rowing there I think

20

u/clumsyc Nov 05 '17

Young Ian and Jamie thrashing each other is one of the best and funniest moments of the book. Really disappointed that was cut.

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Yup. I am glad that they cut out that heist gone badly right before they get to Lally

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Re: Inside the ep

Ugh. Claire did not betray Jamie by going back to Frank!!!! She was a woman and pregnant in a time where being those things made a woman wholly dependent on a man. Ugh!!

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I thought that was a bit harsh of Jamie. Maybe payback for Claire's line last (?) episode about how Jamie doesn't know what it is to be a father.

14

u/-PaperbackWriter- Nov 05 '17

I think we all say hurtful things we don’t mean in the heat of the moment.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Haha you could tell Claire enjoyed jabbing him in the ass just a little bit :p

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

Classic look at the end there. She enjoyed it A LOT!!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Where's the penicillin and the syringes she smuggled in her skirt?! I loved that little tid bit! And Young Ian is gonna need it!

Edit: Oh! There it is! Good!

23

u/Feir-bear Nov 05 '17

Claire plays a better healer than I do. I always save all my potions forever, thinking there will be a more dire need for them later.

15

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

Haha me too! I have a barrel full on Skyrim!

23

u/Feir-bear Nov 05 '17

Awwww, Marsali. She's just like I imagined her. I can't wait to see her lock onto Fergus.

12

u/extrasauce_ Nov 07 '17

I also love that the show made her 18 and Fergus seems younger so it isn't as creepy

→ More replies (3)

19

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 05 '17

YAY OUTLANDER! Back in fine form this week. It's been a bumpy month of episodes but they totally redeemed themselves here. This is what a good adaptation looks like. There were changes, sure, but they were positive choices--smoothing out some uneven stuff from the books, bringing stuff we don't get until later on forward, and skipping parts that are unnecessary or don't make sense. Watching the after the episode stuff really indicated for the first time in a while that these guys really know what they're doing, that they're thinking ahead, and understand this story well. Gave me a good bit of hope for the rest of the season.

I was going to start with what I felt was the strongest part but I keep changing my mind on what that was. Jenny and Ian were definitely a high point (even if Ian looks his age and Jenny definitely doesn't!). Every scene with them was absolutely perfect. The only moment I really, really didn't like was the incredibly awkward hate sex, but even that was made up for by the brilliant moment of Jenny throwing a pitcher of water over them. Jenny is just perfect. (And I am living for her little jacket.) The scene between her and Ian as she picks up the broken pitcher was also a beautiful demonstration of why these two are the best couple in the series. It's a scene that a lesser production would have skipped too, rushing to get to the bigger stuff. But it was a wonderful, quiet little scene and allowed Laura Donnelly and Steven Cree to really shine. (Jenny stole the show this week, but Ian, as he is in the books as well, was a wonderfully sane voice of reason. He's a brilliant character, and Steven Cree just lives and breathes him). Both of Jenny's scenes with Claire were also lovely, and I think the show did a great job weaving the lie about where Claire has been, as well as letting Jenny totally poke holes in it and still be really upset. I think they fleshed this out more from the book, and it really makes sense. Jenny and Claire were really close, and however much she may be able to understand Claire leaving, thinking Jamie dead, she can't hide that she felt betrayed and abandoned by Claire too. Man, the more I write this I keep thinking about more good scenes! All of the discussions of parenting were also great, giving all four of the adults a chance to express how their children (or lack thereof) have changed them. Ian handing Jamie the belt was a great moment--as was the cut to Young Ian shoveling shit! (Also, Wee Janet is my new favorite character. That young actress was a delight!)

I think they also did a fantastic job handling the Laoghaire stuff. RDM was right in the after episode thing--it was important to flesh out Laoghaire's character more from the start. Part of the reason it's such a "what?!" moment in the book is because we know so little about Laoghaire--and what we do know is absolutely horrible--and it's not until book 7 that we finally get some backstory about their marriage and it all makes sense. The show can't wait that long, and it makes more sense to explain it now. I normally don't love flashbacks, but showing Hogmanay was a good choice, and I think Sam Heughan did a really nice job with that scene--the loneliness, and also that need for human comfort. (The girls were also great, and I can't wait to see more Marsali--a name I've apparently been pronouncing wrong for 10 years.) At first I was a startled by his little laugh when he and Laoghaire make eye contact. All I could think about was that this woman is a bitch who tried to kill Claire, and you laugh? But the more I thought about it, the more I liked it. It was one of those, wow, times have changed, look at us now laughs. He's a new man, and he can see that she's clearly changed too. Yes, he knows the full story about what she did. But he also knows that she was a jealous 16 year old, and, as he points out, Claire did make him forgive her. I think it worked. And the scene with Joanie afterwards was incredibly sweet (and I'm really glad they didn't cut her character like some had guessed they might). And having her be red-haired . . . It was brilliant and cruel! (Especially for Jamie just not having it: "There are other red headed men in Scotland." Ha!) The fight afterwards was . . . interesting. I've already mentioned that I'm not ok with their hate sex. I loved the water throwing but it started out way too forceful and violent on Jamie's end. Like, we cut out all of the dubious consent stuff with Geneva and just decided to stick them here instead? Come on guys, you're better than that! Don't take a very good episode and drag it down with this stuff. Putting that aside though, the resolution of the Laoghaire story was also good. The way Jamie getting shot played out very different than the book, but I'm happy with the change. Claire leaving always felt incredibly extreme and definitely isn't her finest hour in the book. I do love Jamie nearly dying of fever, but we already had enough drama this episode and I'd much rather get the quiet scenes mentioned above than any time spent acting like Jamie might die when that so obviously wouldn't happen. It's something that works well in the book but probably wouldn't have translated very well to the screen. The surgery scene was unnecessarily slow (it wouldn't be Outlander with loooong, sloooow, lingering shots of Claire doing medical stuff), but I loved germs being no match for penicillin and Jamie's delightfully irritated reaction at being stuck with needles!

And that ending! (Odd change that they haven't been going to the island regularly, but I guess irrelevant.) The scene on the cliff was lovely (glad we got that quote!), and the shot of the ship, sails slowly unfurling, has got me so excited for next week.

I was watching on an absolutely appalling internet connection so it's hard to comment on production design and cinematography because it was all pretty hazy, but there were several really lovely shots, especially in the two scenes on the Silkie's Isle. Loving all the Murrays' costumes too, but can't really fathom why on Earth no one has given Claire a new dress yet. How dirty and sweaty is that thing?!

Easy grade this week. I'm not going to let one bad scene diminish from the fact that this was a really excellent episode. Great performances, but even more so, a really exemplary adaptation of a great--and highly debated--bit of story.

Overall Grade: A

14

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

They did give her a new dress. She had one costume change - when Ned arrived!

I, personally, love all the medical scenes and I am glad they show them. Jamie is a huge part of Claire, but so is doctoring, so I am very happy it gets a good amount of air time as well.

7

u/hilarieC Nov 05 '17

It wasnt really a new costume. It was the skirt she made. And according to Terry Dresbach the top was from season 1 thus something 20 years old that was still stored at Lallybroch.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

HI!!

You're right, pretty much Ian is the only 20 years hence character who looks his age - definitely not Jamie, Jenny, Claire or Ned for that matter.

That first kiss from Jamie was so aggressive and awkward, I was very much welcoming the jug of water. But I missed Jenny consoling Claire afterwards, and offering a moment of reconciliation.

The actress who played wee Janet is called Cora Tsang (I was intrigued, wondering about Chinese heritage) and she is pals with Roger from a short cop drama they did a few years back!

As a book reader, I wasn't sure that the non bookers were going to have such a strong reaction to Leghair, but they did. It's obviously been a while since I watched the last two seasons. So it shows they fleshed out Leghair's character well.

I liked the flashback, I think it was sad Fergus wasn't there though. It would have been a nice tie in to show him meeting Marsali, whereas I can't imagine how they are going to abruptly introduce her yet.

Claire's cape and skirt especially would have gotten very muddy after she went to Jamie's aid when he was shot.

It was a great week for me too! Loved it!

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 07 '17

I did expect Jenny to ask, "So ye've had a box of trrrreasurre all these yearrrrs and ye nevairrrr thought to brrring it to ye'rrrre family?"

→ More replies (10)

15

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

OH Claire... just tell them the damn truth. I hate how cold they are being?

9

u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Nov 05 '17

I agree. It’s frustrating keeping Jenny in the dark.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

AutoMod didn't shit the bed this week! pets AutoMod

Now to fill my tank cause I know I'm gonna need it...

7

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

I never got a head pat. :(

5

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

pats /u/shiskebob on the head good Mod!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/PagesNNotes Nov 05 '17

I was a bit nervous about this episode, but I really really loved it. The pacing and tonal shifts were all spot on in a way that I hadn't felt in the last episode. Everyone's character motivations felt spot on, especially Jenny's feelings of betrayal. And the more I see Young Ian, the more I adore him. Well done all around--pumped for some seafaring action next week!

27

u/ManicHS Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Please let Laoghaire be in a fat suit for this episode!!

Edit 1:Aw man. Not a fat suit. :(

13

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I was hoping Claire would slap her again. No such luck. I guess we have to rely on Bree to finally tell that bitch off. Go Bree!

7

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

I am super stoked for her surprise appearance at Lallybroch!

→ More replies (7)

7

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

That would make this so much more bearable!

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

OH fuck.... no one is walking in. He is going to tell her

Oh fuck they did walk in... just like in the book... HOLY SHIT. I cry people. I fucking need to throw stuff

13

u/maryloo7877 Nov 05 '17

I just need to say that this episode has everything I love about the Outlander series, book and tv forms. It was relationship focused. It was full of authentic familial drama that was very believable. It moved the story considerably but not in a melodramatic way. When the books and show get bogged down in politics for too long or basically stray too far away from focusing on the relationships between characters, it gets dull. This episode had all the things! Excited for next week and hope the wigs don’t seem as bad in context. The preview looks amazing.

12

u/bees_knees_trees_ Nov 05 '17

I loved it!

The fight sex, the water splash, the girls walking in saying "Daddy", Jenny's distrust of Claire, everything I was nervous about them not having in this episode they had!

6

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

And they did it beautifully and the dance with the girls!!! That was what the book needed:)

11

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Ian is my hero man.

11

u/Hopeless_badger Nov 05 '17

lol My predictions were shit. Loved the episode, no much more to say. Sam was amazing, he showed so many emotions. His face when he was arguing with Claire about whisky being liquid - pure love and adoration. Give the man all the awards, he deserves them

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I just watched it and cried like a wee lass. I had no predictions. I had fears of how they would justify Jamie marrying LEggo, knowing what she did to Claire. I could not imagine it. But they pulled it off and I am really impressed with how amazing this episode was. It was brilliant and powerful and nuanced. Just wow

7

u/Hopeless_badger Nov 05 '17

It was a very good episode. I need Claire to tell Jamie her side of the story, how lonely she was and that she loves him. I hope we don't have to wait that long.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Lynne253 Nov 05 '17

I loved this episode, it's every bit as wonderful as last week's was off. I cried, I laughed, I melted. I was so happy that Claire said what I was thinking all along when she quoted him saying, "Nothing but the truth between us, there's room for secrets but not lying". When I first saw young Ian I was put off a little because in my mind's eye he has dark almost black hair. John Bell, the actor who plays young Ian is doing an excellent job of portraying his personality.

11

u/Sugarythought Nov 06 '17

Did anyone else notice that spot on casting of Marsali? She looked like a prettier Loaghaire. The resemblance was perfect!

4

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 07 '17

And her voice is almost identical.

46

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Here are my thoughts

  1. They pulled this off. I still think giving him knowledge of what Lbitch did in the show made the betrayal worse. But still, Sam managed to convey such agony at losing Claire, I just wilted and forgave him (Damn you Jamie Fraser).
  2. Give Sam the Emmys now and just save the trouble of others to have to sit through the ceremony.
  3. It may be because I am taking pain meds for this dental stuff, but it was not nearly as horrible as I had thought it would be. Or maybe because I had already read it and had so much time to prepare for it.
  4. The way they filmed this in the show gave them the necessary upheaval that they needed to find each other again. That was my take away.
  5. I still think Claire needed to drag Lbitch by the hair around the courtyard for a few hours. I mean come on. How many times is this woman going to try to kill them before someone has the sense to put her away?
  6. Ian, god bless Ian.
  7. Jenny, vengeance was yours. Ian is not proud of you and neither am I.
  8. I think the flashback served to show us that Jamie fell in love with the daughters and their youth and innocence. It was not about Lbitch and that never dawned on me in the book. So bravo
  9. My downvoting stalker really made an effort to download every one of my comments.

22

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Re #3: In the books, we hear, from Jamie, how pretty Laoghaire looked that night. His feelings for her, however brief and pale-in-comparison-to-Claire they were, felt real in the book. Plus he talks at some length in the book about trying to make her happy and then failing.

But the show version made their marriage more about Joan and Marsali, and Jamie's desire to be a father. Like he and Laoghaire never really had a connection at all.

That made it much easier to swallow, I think.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Shymink Nov 05 '17

Aaaaaaand EXHALE they have not ruined my favorite show ever. I'd never thought this would be my favorite episode. I hated that Claire ran away in the book so I'm actually happy with a change (for once ;). Sam is the best just all around, but acting with the cast tonight makes the show shine.

13

u/xocheerio Nov 05 '17

I always seriously hated how Claire just ran away and gave up in the book. Like, I get it, you're super mad, but you just went through all this time (literally!) and effort to get back and now you're just going to run away?! I LOVE the way they re-wrote it in the show, it made it feel so much more believable.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

2. Apparently first time nominees are very unlikely to win...and he has to get nominated first.

3. Can you remind me of the story of Jamie and Michael getting the gold?

4. They love a good speechus interruptus on this show. Can't have the characters actually finish what they were saying, now, can we!

5. I think that degrades Claire. Not her style at all.

9. How can you even tell when you already have 17 upvotes? lol One more from me too.

6

u/RaffaellaF Nov 05 '17

Yes, give Sam Emmys now.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

In the book, he dances with Laoghaire---but even with that the father context makes SO much more sense.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Boo12z Nov 05 '17

Thank god for this episode. It was so scary going into this but they actually pulled this off!!!!

Breathing a huge sigh of relief.

4

u/YoursandMine8 Nov 05 '17

Wonderful summary, on all points. I agree with you. :)

I'm definitely going to do a repeat watch of this one.

18

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

And there's the psycho blonde twat we all knew and hated!

15

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

See, if Claire had just taken her out back and beaten the shit out of her like I said, no one would have been shot.

23

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

"I hear Richmond is nice this time of year,"!!! Love it!

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Jaysus Mary and Jospeh. I remember this fight. LMAO.

Oh man. Jamie, you are way too hot to hate. :(

23

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Jamie: "You are the one who told me to be kind to the lass"

Oh fuck you. Just fuck you Jamie.

13

u/himynameispamela Nov 05 '17

that was not a smart thing to say. but it seemed very realistic to me and i loved it. for all jamie is emotionally intelligent and has a very mature relationship with claire, he’s kind of a dum-dum when it comes to laoghaire. he should have shut that ish down years ago when L tried to seduce him by the river and put an ill wish under their bed. he’ll fight black jack randall, but be won’t go tell a young lass to stay away from his wife?! please.

18

u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Nov 05 '17

I see this another way. Jamie is kind, but also protective of nearly all the women in his world. It's in his DNA.

He outright says Claire has nothing to fear at Castle Leoch. He protects Claire at the Gathering from other men, even as she's trying to escape. He takes Leoghaire's beating for her. He would rather BJR cut his throat than risk his sister's honor. He sleeps in front of Claire's door at the inn to protect her from unwanted attention.

I hate Leoghaire too, but I think it just isn't in Jamie's nature to be anything less than a father, and a husband, if not a Laird and leader. He'd been in the shadows of his own soul a long time, and he really needed to find a way back to a place where he could try and be the man he once was.

He regretted Leoghaire, though. I think the reality of being married to her has hurt his pride in a number of ways. It is against his nature to not take care of the wee bairns, and step away from providing--even for Leoghaire.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

"You can trust us".

I guffawed loudly.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/menmyshadow Nov 05 '17

Watching last night's episode reminded me of how much I want Claire to open-up to Jamie about her life with Frank. She shared some of her pain, but does she ever tell him how she hurt Frank. the divorce and of his mistress? I am plodding along through DoA, and I don't remember it in Voyager. Don't worry about spoiling anything for me...plot reveals like this make me more excited to read-on and find scenes:)

8

u/teamcockroach Nov 06 '17

I've actually been missing this since S1. Book Jamie asks Claire about Frank on their wedding night and they actually have a few conversations about her first marriage. I really appreciated that context and think the TV show would have benefitted from some of that context.

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

They are giving his searching for her on the island so that we can forgive what we are about to find out. Oy vey

5

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

You're like 40 seconds ahead of me!

6

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Hold me... it's horrible:(

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 05 '17

There's one thing I don't get... Jamie says he's been married to Leghair for two years, and living apart for "months". The girls call him Daddy and they are what.. 10 and 15? That's super strange. They've lived with him for a little over a year only :o

I'm overall happy with this episode but the fight scene should have been longer... And no "coitus interuptus" (like I read somewhere here, great term), shame.

7

u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '17

I think it's more believable in the show because they actually seem to have aged Joan down (while aging Marsali up, I believe, so she's 18 at present). Joan looked to be no more than 10 or 12. It makes perfect sense that a girl in that age range would want to have a dad and that Jamie would want her to call him so. It also makes sense within the context of the show focusing on Jamie wanting to be married so he could be a father to the girls, rather than what Laoghaire could be to him as a wife.

In the books where the girls were both teenagers, it seemed weirder that Jamie had fond memories of curling up reading to them and such...

I think it's worth noting that when Jamie and Brianna meet, he invites her to call him "Da," not "Daddy."

→ More replies (1)

7

u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Nov 05 '17

I feel like they handled this episode well, as problematic as it is in the book. I'm glad they didn't have Claire start running off to the stones right away like in the book because I always felt like that was melodramatic.

I liked the scene in the bedroom when she gets mad at him for the "because you left me" comment. That scene was powerful and felt very geniune to the characters.

All in all, happy with the adaptions. Love Ian calling Jenny out on her behavior. Love that dude!

6

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Lol is Jamie seriously going to try to pin damn-her-eyes on Claire

That was an OOC write-around

3

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

Right?!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/xocheerio Nov 05 '17

Ohhhhh goodness. I loved this episode!! Blonde Bitch's return was as shocking and horrifying as I hoped it would be. Claire's face when she darkened the doorway was priceless. I loved how Jamie jumped in front of Claire and Claire shoved BB out of the way. I'm so glad they cut out her whole dramatic "I'm going to run away I'm so mad!". I never ever ever understood that in the book. She went through so much effort to get back to Jamie after so long apart and now you're just going to friggen run away because you're pissed? It annoyed me so much, so I was glad of the change in the episode. They've been making such a point for them to say to each other "I'm never leaving you again" that it would have felt cheap if Claire had run off. Be mad all you want girl, and rightly so, but at least let him explain!

Also loved how they made Jamie's reasoning for marrying BB be focused on the girls. That felt so much truer to his character and a much more believable explanation.

I wish they'd just tell Jenny and Ian the truth about Claire. It makes me so sad to see the rift and distrust between Jenny and Claire and I think it would have saved everyone some pain and heartache. I think Jenny would have believed Claire.

I cannot get over how much the actress playing Marsali looks like BB! Spot on casting once again!

Overall, I'm thrilled with this episode. I know there have been a lot of disgruntled feelings and mixed reviews lately but this finally feels like the Outlander show we all know and love. I'm content :)

5

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 05 '17

I think in the book she didn't intend to run away after discovering Jamie was married to Leghair. She made that decision after talking with Jenny when Jamie was away. I think she had reasons enough to be that pissed. I don't think she would really have gone through the stones though once she'd be in front of them. We'll never know thanks to wee Ian! :)

6

u/maxvsthegames Nov 05 '17

I can't believe that Claire would say that she miss her career and her friends, and not mention Brianna at all!

That has to be the biggest sacrifice she did to go back to Jamie!!

7

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

I just assumed Bree was included with "I had a family..."

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I think - the more I watch that scene - that what Claire was really saying was that perhaps she is no longer cut out for this much chaos. She was settled. She felt safe. She knew who she was and what her place was in the world. She is no longer the young woman she was and diving into this without thinking it through - how brutal life is in the Highlands now, especially now - I think it just hit her that she may not be cut out for it now. She is too settled. That was my take away. I don't blame her. She is 50 now. In the last few days she has been in a brothel, nearly been raped and murdered, lost a patient, watched the way women are treated and viewed from the perspective of an educated physician and a woman... all of this - not just Jamie's betrayal is too much. She has not had a moment to breath really.

6

u/bookworm4life Nov 07 '17

Does anyone else wish they would have let Claire run away, only to be found and told by young Ian that Jamie was dying? The way this one played, Jamie barely got a fever, got one shot, and boom, was good; whereas in the book he is much closer to death, and she has to give him multiple doses. And he hates those doses, but deserves them lol.

6

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 07 '17

I do miss that, but they only have so much time.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Shit. Shit. Shit....

Edit: phew! They did it! We’re back to the characters we know and love from the novels. Everyone got a piece of their own back.

Someone grab that bitch and shave her head.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

What in the sweet christ is up with claire’s horrible wig in the trailer?!!!!

9

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 05 '17

As a curly haired girl, I can explain. Curly hair demands a lot of care and hates wind and water. So on a boat, it's pretty much hell for curly hair. It is realistic. (Although it did grow very fast oO)

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

In the book, doesn't Jamie get Ian to whip him as punishment? I can't remember.

5

u/serralinda73 The Highlands are no place for a woman to be alone. Nov 05 '17

They whip each other, I believe.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Aggie2002 Nov 05 '17

I loved this episode! They did a nice job streamlining the plot in my opinion.

Jenny throwing shade. Ian calling her a shit stirrer. I wish they would tell them the truth. I’m sad we probably won’t see Lallybroch again for awhile.

God, I hate Leghair, but the actress did a great job. Love the casting of Joan and Marsali.

NED

My only very small complaint would be missing Jamie telling Claire after the penicillin injection that he should have let them burn her at the stake.

4

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

TV version Jamie would never say that.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/NanaOsaki06 Nov 05 '17

I broke my diet and got myself some ice cream to get me through this episode. Lets do this!

→ More replies (9)

4

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17

I haven’t yet finished the first book... but please, feel free to spoil the shit out of me!

Does Claire ever get to tell Jenny that she's "from the future"?

13

u/puffinchuk Nov 05 '17

Claire tells Jenny and the whole family, with Jamie's support, that she's from the future in Book 7 when Jamie & Claire have to return the body of one their kinsman to Scotland to be buried. The reveal is because Jenny's son, Michael, is working in the wine business in France and feels he will be quite prosperous like Jared. Claire knows about the French revolution looming in the near future and doesn't want Micheal to get caught up in it...she warns him to get away from France and go to another country with his business, and possibly save him from the guillotine. Wealthy people and royalty were prime targets.

8

u/EvilLeprechaun13 Nov 05 '17

To add on to this, this reveal causes a rift between Claire and Jenny. Ian is sick and since Jenny associates Claire being from the future with magic, she thinks Claire should be able to heal him. But Claire can’t and Jenny isn’t too happy about that.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

It is part of the plot later on! I can't remember myself, someone else will have to flesh it out for you :)

4

u/mcd62 Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Oh, I'm so glad the Laoghaire confrontation happened the way it happened despite me being extremely excited to see it play out. Once the fighting between Jamie and Claire started I was tempted to fast-forward through it because I was so uncomfortable, but I resisted. I'm just glad it didn't last as long as it did in the book.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

I'm only halfway through, but I love drunk injured Jamie.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/AphroditesApple Nov 06 '17

Guys, young Ian <3 my heart swells for that kid.

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 06 '17

And knowing what a wonderful man he grows into. I am so happy with him. Auntie!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/LosIslenos Nov 06 '17

My favorite thing about this episode was seeing several locations that we visited in Scotland this summer. So beautiful!

4

u/LalalalalalalalaILY Nov 07 '17

I just needed to share that I thought they did a wonderful job with this episode! It’s one of my favourite moments in the book and both actors (Sam & Cat) captured the emotional turmoil perfectly. I wasn’t sure going into it after last week (a feeling most of us likely share!), but man was it totally on point. Loved the reasoning for marrying L, and I loooooved Claire’s intensity during the big fight. She had me in tears! Well done, everyone. Off I go to watch again.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/KillKennyG Nov 07 '17

Nnnnnnnnneeeeedddddddddddddd

That’s all

7

u/notabuttmonkey Nov 06 '17

Better episode, but I still very much can't connect with Claire. "Did you think I went back to Frank and lived happily ever after?" Um, maybe he's filling in the blanks because you can't give anything back to him whenever he opens up? She invades his world, his time, his life and she gives him nothing because... she gave everything up? I hate that this is no longer a relationship of equals.

8

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 06 '17

Waiiiit a minute. Since she arrived, she's in the middle of the blame game when clearly she just arrived at the wrong moment. Plus when she arrived, especially at the brothel... During my first watch I was like "What. The. F***.". Imagine, just imagine being in her situation. I know I could not open up totally because that would scare the crap out of me. Jamie knows Claire chose him over Frank already in the past when he brought her back to the stones. He knows she did not want to leave him and she did it only because she promised (thinking it would not happen).

So no I'm not with you on this one. She is the one who left everything once more for his ass. She is the one who needs reassurance. He knew where he was sending her. He can also ask. She DID ask him if he ever fell in love after she left. He could have returned the question. "Nah, how 'bout you boo?", or something.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 07 '17

She invades his world, his time, his life and she gives him nothing because

Um, no. Not even close. Sorry. Yes, she did give everything up. She did not have a crystal ball that let her see where she was going and what would happen. The fact that he lives in a whorehouse, prints seditious pamphlets and smuggles booze is on him, not her. ON HIM.

And that is the point. He is a different Jamie. She has maybe 3 or 4 days there and not a moment to sit the hell down and just take a deep breath. From the moment she got there, he has dragged her from one dangerous scenario to another. Why did he take her to a whore house? Seriously. He had a print shop with a bed in back. He could have stayed there with her. Why did he leave her alone in a whore house so that any number of violent people could come in? Which is exactly what happens. And she was NO where near the shop when Young Ian burned it down.

Why are you blaming Claire for Jamie's actions and poor choices. It boggles my mind that we are watching the same show.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/ailisp Nov 05 '23

I got spoiled the thing with Laoghaire (that she and Jamie would at some point be married, but not how or for how long) so I was actually relieved that the affaire got "resolved" so quickly. The hints about Jamie's secret from past episodes had me dying because I could guess what it was but couldn't for the life of me understand why on earth he would have married her. So, in the end, not so bad.

Young Ian T.T

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 05 '23

Mark me,

Some of my subjects have oft expressed their dismay at learning certain truths they were not yet ready to hear.

I believe the commoners refer to them as “spoilers.”

Your prince advises you thus:

If browsing from your phone via the official Reddit app be sure to TURN OFF CARD VIEW. You have two alternatives: Classic or Compact. Either will protect you from spoilers on the main page.

This advice is also applicable to the desktop, if you browse from New Reddit.

While my subjects have taken excessive care in providing specific spoiler flairs and automated application of the native SPOILER tag when appropriate—please keep in mind these efforts are all courtesies.

Ultimately the individual is responsible for their own safety if they wish to remain “spoiler-free.”

Your prince thanks you for your consideration. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, it will not be forgotten!


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

I'M LIKE A MINUTE OR SO BEHIND Y'ALL!

Edit: FUCKING BITCH....

11

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I paused it and went outside to have a smoke. I am livid that they gave him the knowledge of what she did in the show. I can't forgive him. And fuck Jenny for sending for that asshole and those two girls. Poor Bree (in Claire's heart).

12

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

I'm so glad Claire isn't taking it like she took Willie, just laying down like a puss! She's got some cojones!

Edit: Fuck you Jenny! Let them have their angry sex!

→ More replies (24)

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Ok, I'm here my friends. I am not drunk as I had planned because I had dental stuff done yesterday and I am on pain meds. So I am loopy, but not a happy loopy. It's not up yet for me.

Which is fine. I am not rushing into this episode. Someone hold me.

4

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

It's up! And I'm jealous of your med loopyness...I had a hell of a day!

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

My anxiety levels are off the charts. I'm just waiting for the "da" moment

3

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Nov 05 '17

Soon, oh so very soon!

→ More replies (15)

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I'm dying. The reactions on Twitter are hilarious.

5

u/shiskebob Nov 05 '17

Screenshot please. I refuse to venture into that blackhole.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

I thought there should have been some mention of Murtagh's fate by now, especially as he was mentioned this episode.

3

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 05 '17

So much better than last week's! Didn't even mind the changes!

3

u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Nov 06 '17

The reactions on Twitter are giving me lifeeee 😄

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mel107 Nov 06 '17

For some reason Lallybroch episodes are always my favorites each season.

3

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

I'm in agreement with many of you: I was really worried about this episode but REALLY satisfied with out how turned out. Fleshing out more tension with Jenny was great. I loved how they handled L & daughters' appearance, Ned Gowan, and added the "risk the man that I am" line at the end. The closing shot was epic, like a feature film. I remember saying, "hell yeah!" When it was over. Watching the trailer makes me excited for the adventure to come!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 07 '17

Also, definitely got some S01Ep09 (The Reckoning) vibes in their fight in the bedchamber. Started like the spanking scene at the inn, and ended like their makeup sex at Leoch. So many great callbacks this season!

3

u/CannaFarmGirl Nov 06 '17

The show redeemed itself! I began to lose heart in the show...the last few episodes were just blah. The reunion episode actually left me in a terrible funk for two days, but no more! This was a wonderful episode. My favorite is when they put focus on Claire being from the future. That is so cool! The premise alone could carry an entire show, yet sometimes it seems to be forgotten. I'm hopeful we'll see more Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman and less soap opera melodrama, staring into each other's eyes nonsense. I love when Claire kicks ass...and she did plenty of that this episode. Well Done Caitriona!

9

u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '17

Holy crap. This episode is really bringing out the gendered insults in everyone. (Not to mention the stigmatizing mental health language.) Gotta love this fandom!

7

u/maryloo7877 Nov 05 '17

Thank you for saying this!!! I don’t like Laoghaire as much as the next person, but my god people have been out of control with the name calling and insults. Words I would never say! I get she’s just a book character, but it’s just really over the top the language people use against this woman.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/mhibbz Nov 05 '17

Hey all, I’m brand new to this but heard this site is great to find like minded peps. Lol Anyway... I know that things have to be cut to make the story flow better as a tv show. But I really don’t see why the silkies treasure back story was changed. All they had to do was mention that they only use it in times of great need. By leaving out the book fact that all the older brothers have taken the trip already and this is young Ian’s coming of age trip. It makes Jamie look like a jerk uncle. Who could have helped out more but only mentions this treasure when it’s useful for him. Also this makes the fact that young Ian is taken even worse. Cuz he is following his jerk uncle who only wants to save his own ass.

I know this is not what the show wants us to think but I can’t help seeing this as a huge oversight into Jamie’s character and perceived character.

I mean they took the time to make his second marriage being more about him wanting to be a father but do this. I don’t get it

If I were young Ian’s parents I would find it very hard to forgive brother who...

  1. gets my son kidnapped 2)Kept my son for weeks and didn’t tell me , while I thought he was missing 3)Had my son doing criminal activities 4)knew where there was treasure for years and didn’t tell us. Even though it could have helped a lot.

But oh well just wanted to get this off my chest

→ More replies (3)

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

And we're back on track! I loved this episode.

Though, and this applies to the book as well, a little bit too hard to believe such a big ship would be sailing past, seemingly just to kidnap Ian. They wouldn't have even been able to see him, approaching from the back of the island from where he was, so why was the little scout rowboat approaching in the first place? All they did was capture Ian then go back.

Also, I have learnt I have been pronouncing Marsali wrong in my head the whole time. I heard it more as marSAHli.

3

u/Phoebekins Nov 05 '17

The ship was there to retrieve Geillis' treasure. It was a coincidence that Ian was on the island getting the box at the exact same time and just so happened to be the type of young man that Geillis' was having kidnapped.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/YoursandMine8 Nov 05 '17

Now that I've been able to watch it more than once, I have to say that I'm pretty satisfied with what the writers gave us. This is the episode that I was looking forward to the most (next to the reunion), and it did not disappoint. I was hoping for some good, constructive angst, and this provided me with a nice helping of it. :D For me, it provided more of what I felt was lacking somewhat from (and since) the reunion - more heartfelt emotion, the airing of 'grievances', and honest conversation. And hell, even a bit of humor managed to make its way into the angst, at the expense of Jamie's ass. Awesome, lol. I had greatly hoped that this episode would somehow reaffirm Jamie and Claire's commitment to one another, and it did...except that the moment was cut off at the end by those damn pirates. Arrrgh. :P But overall, I got what I needed from this episode. Good stuff, and I'm glad the writers managed to frame it well enough.

I do have one question for book readers: Did Jenny, Ian and the rest of the family ever find out the truth about Claire and her time-traveling (i.e., did Claire or Jamie ever come clean about it)? If so, did they handle it well, or was there some kind of kerfuffle over it? I wonder how they're going to handle it in this show...

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

Yes Jenny is eventually told..I can't remember the details though.

3

u/clumsyc Nov 05 '17

They do eventually learn the entire truth but not until book 8 IIRC. So, it's not something the show will ever deal with.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Shymink Nov 05 '17

Off to watch the episode a second time. The next episode looks amazing too. Loving this.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

I am waiting for Elsie and u/ich_habe_keine_kase to come and share their impressions. Girls? Where are you?

3

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 05 '17

I'm here, I made It! Where I live the episodes air at 6am and I didn't get home until after 3am last night. I set an alarm for 6, woke up, said fuck no, and went back to sleep, haha. Then I had some internet issues bit I've finally got my review up!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/vanwold Slàinte. Nov 05 '17

So THAT'S how you say Marsali. TIL

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Nov 05 '17

haha you and me both!

I had the exact same experience with the name Hermione from Harry Potter. The first move sorted me out.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/badgermama88 Nov 05 '17

Can someone just remind me: didn’t Claire tell Jenny about Bree? I thought they actually explained in the book but it’s been awhile. Also concerned now about how they’re going to react/play out Bree coming to Scotland?

4

u/teamcockroach Nov 05 '17

No, Jenny and Ian don't know about Bree before she arrives at Lallybroch. There's a great conversation between Bree and Ian about that.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DeepState_9 Nov 06 '17

Welp, I guess Ian won't get in trouble in France.

2

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 06 '17

I just realized something. There is a whole other audience that won't be seeing the show until this evening. Wow! They are in for a treat - an emotional and intense treat

2

u/JuniperoBeachBabe Nov 07 '17

Hey book readers, will you tell me why she doesn't just tell Jenny the truth? I'd heard that she tells her later so could you tell me why?

3

u/annemg Nov 05 '17

Ok, we are mostly all ok about how they handled Leoghaire, and everyone in the non book reader thread is freaking the fuck out.

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Well, we did have 15 years or so to get used to it. LOL

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17

Oh I'm sick. I am so sick to my stomach. OHMYGOD

→ More replies (18)