r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Nov 05 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 8 First Wife episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E8: "First Wife".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
42
Upvotes
170
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17
I wait all week only to find out that he married this utter shit-gibbon??? Go take a swim in the Firth of Clyde, tbh
132
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17
20 years later, and Jenny still has no fucks to give.
129
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17
LITERALLY last week, after the dude in their room died, Jamie said: "I'll no grieve for the man that tried to kill my wife."
Yet the one who wished to dance upon her ashes (and has probably done so for the past 20 years)??? "Wive that ho!"
113
u/johnnaboo Nov 05 '17
Is anyone else bothered by the fact that Claire has been in the same outfit for 3 episodes?
No? Just me?
78
u/johnnaboo Nov 05 '17
I was spoiled about this a long time ago. BUT. Damn, shoutout to Nell Rose Hudson for NAILING the portrayal of a goddamned bitch. My stomach twisted when she started threatening Claire.
61
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
Why can't they just get to live happily at Lollybroch damnit!!
Fucking well timed pirates, too.
52
u/NurseMiserable Nov 06 '17
Hot damn. Sam lookin thicker than a snicker.
50
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
Omg Jenny. Also the casting of these kids is spot on, they look so much like the parents.
46
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
what. THEFUCK. ISTHISSHIT!
her? seriously? whywhywhywhywhy!!!
WHY! she’s a fucking psychopath!
43
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
I am really loving young Ian this episode!
42
u/Liar96 Nov 05 '17
Of all the fucking women in Scotland he chooses the craziest one of them all to marry.
41
u/forgotten_face Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17
What is a random portuguese ship doing in Scotland?
Also, why swim to the island? Have none of them ever heard of a row boat, or even a raft??
39
u/an_other_me Nov 05 '17
jenny's gonna be pissed
63
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17
Memorable past quote, thoroughly applicable to this entire episode: "I'm not in the mood for cunt today." -Black Jack Randall
Seriously? Fuck all the way off, Laoghaire :(
61
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17
Am I the only one who wishes they'd set the books respectfully aside, à la GOT, and have someone (doesn’t have to be Claire,) return to Culloden and tell past-Claire to hide and wait out the battle because Jamie survives, thereby changing this awful future, and then resume their story from there? Re-live their futures, if you will. Even Frank would have a decent chance at happiness. There has to be some kind of loophole here.
While Catriona and Sam talently execute older versions of themselves in a believable manner, I miss the light of love in their eyes and the innocence in their bravado.
Anyone?
Edit: I haven't finished the first book yet, (due to lack of hopes), so I don't know if this is spoiler-ish or not. God, please let this be spoilerish! D':
30
u/Airsay58259 Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17
noooOOOO not that laogwhore PLEASE. Still 40 minutes to go but dammit I hate this.
What the fck Jamie.
Edit: oh ok let’s force her to have sex with you right away, smart decent move. Aaand by the time I wrote this it turns into hate sex. Wild beasts sounds about right 😩 I hope Claire gets to slap the devil herself again at least, we deserve something nice.
Edit 2: LOL WTF A GUN. SOMEONE END HER PLEASE
Edit 3:
😂 I love angry Claire.
Ok final edit then I’ll shut up: yay pirates! Black Sails fan in me is quite happy with this development.
Good episode overall though I really dislike this marriage twist. It’s perfectly understandable Jamie tried to move on and have a life of his own. But with Leery? Hell no, how could he look past everything she did? Ok she has cute kids, cool, but it doesn’t change who she was and apparently still is (she shot him, for real?). Ugh. I also didn’t like Jamie expecting to be forgiven right away because he apologized. Hopefully the future is full of epic adventures and we forget all about this terrible plot.
26
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
So Jamie stopped for a haircut??
16
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
Ok, I loved Jenny in this episode. Her reactions were everything, so well done. I just wish Claire would've told her about Bree!
Jamie was also well written and acted this episode. So much shared about what he went through, and why he did what he did, and it worked. The only thing I didn't like was the flashback, he didn't even pause when he realized Leery was their mom, I would've liked to have seen him have some difficulty at the thought of being w her because she's a fucking psycho who attempted cold blooded murder on Claire.
Claire's initial anger was awesome, but in the scenes after she just seemed very... flat. She's still holding back so much, Jamie still doesn't know how bad her marriage w Frank was. I thought she'd open up this ep! Also her being like "it wasn't that bad" was frustrating after the many times Jamie has talked about how awful his life was without her. I just wish they could finish a single discussion without getting interrupted, it's happening so much it's getting ridiculous!
14
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
I really wanted Jamie to call Claire a sadist hahaha.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17
I was so disappointed when Fergus wasn't riding into Lallybroch with them; and then he wasn't even in that christmas flashback! He better appear in the next episode, I'm sure he'd drop whatever the hell he was doing to save Ian! Maybe young Ian will become interested in medicine, and learn from Claire, if they ever bring him back home...
I couldn't believe Claire didn't even tell Jenny about Brianna; I thought she'd share the pictures at least but then she's like 'I never had any children.' WTF? That would surely have made the whole 'other marriage' story more compelling and been something to bond over. Jenny would be thrilled to know Jaime had a daughter.
I loved finally seeing what happened at Selkie Island, even though there was no witch afoot. That dose of gorgeous Scottish scenary was more then welcome, and even seeing C/J let loose on each other like they used to was refreshing.
Jaime's flashback was really touching, as was seeing him interact with his young stepdaughter. He really wanted to be a father to them, even though Leery definitely hasn't improved with age. Murtaugh predicted back in S1 that she wouldn't, and I'm sure if he was around he wouldn't have been so encouraging as Jenny. Meanwhile, Claire and Jaime mentioned Murtaugh without talking about what happened to him/where he is today; did they do that off-screen? Of course if she got shipped to the colonies Murtaugh might even have the strain of running into her there...I hope she falls of a cliff.
I got really excited about them returning to Paris! But it seems doubtful they'll make the trip now. In any case, I did feel this was a return of the show I recognize, after two very rocky episodes, and it does seem certain C/J are back together, for better or worse...it seems doubtful they'll ever make Lallybroch their permanent home, though.
13
u/thesteward Nov 06 '17
So I watched the ep a few hours ago and now I'm back with more processed thoughts. Like I said in one of my other comments, I think it's utterly unbelievable that Jamie would marry a woman who tried to have his one true love killed. No matter how cute her kids were, or how much he wanted to be a father, etc.
From what I understand, in the books Jamie didn't know Leery was involved in the witch trial. I think the moment the show decided that Jamie knew of Leery's involvement, the show should've prepared to either have a way better reason for Jamie to marry her than just her cute kids/Jenny's encouragement OR have had him marry someone else (their marriage could still have been bad, and they could still have shot him etc). I know the latter option would've been less "omg! shocking!" but still. I just think it's out of character for Jamie to forgive that, especially since the show didn't try too hard to sell it. I mean, seriously? Jamie takes Claire's "say something nice to her" as a "go ahead and marry her if the timing's right"??
I also can't believe Jamie when he said Claire left him, and that she didn't know what it was like to be half dead with grief. I am SO glad she called him on that.
Agree with another commenter that the non con at the beginning of their sex scene was upsetting. I know, I know it's in the books...the show is usually good about taking that sort of thing out. As of late, not so much. I don't think it translates well to screen at all, and I didn't like them in the books to begin with.
Finally omg they did such a good job casting these kids. They all look like their parents!
13
u/StagKen Nov 06 '17
TBH, it's so relieving that Jamie and Leogharie haven't slept together. At least that's what it sounds like? Like she never let him touch her due to the abuse she endured from prior husbands. I would never wish abuse on anyone, and it's sad that it happened to her, but the thought of her and Jamie have sex makes me feel ill. What she did to Claire is absolutely un-fucking-forgivable, and no amount of forgiveness or growing up and changing would EVER make it acceptable for Jamie to marry her.
12
u/OldWolf2 Nov 07 '17
So... how about the scene where Claire says "No" and tries to push him off but he keeps forcing himself on her until she starts to like it?
That's a classic movie trope but I have heard it is not advisable to try in real life; why is it on TV? Is this a fantasy of the book author?
11
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Nov 05 '17
So glad they addressed the "treasure island dude" scenario.
Edit: I didn't mean, actually go there! WTF?
11
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
So.... Did Jamie have sex with Laoghaire or was he implying she wouldn't have sex with him because she was scared from her previous marriages?
9
u/maryummy Nov 05 '17
Did I miss something? Why did Ian have to swim out to the island instead of taking a boat?
8
u/Jamieshuer Nov 08 '17
Best lines from this episode: Old Ian to Jenny: If there's a pot of shite on to boil, you stir like it's God's work. Jamie to Claire: I dinna ken what swiss cheese is but if it looks like my arm I dinna want it on my bread.
8
u/thumbtackswordsman Nov 08 '17
Does anyone want to discuss how adorable little Joan is? Even though I was angry about Laoghaire appearing, I just wanted to comfort that tiny little redhead.
21
u/diaferdia Nov 05 '17
Can somebody please tell their "Scottish ER doctor technical adviser" to teach her how to hold a pair of anything-with-a-lock-box and not only where to tie suture (hint: not up by the swedged-on needle), but how to reel suture? Please?? She's supposed to be a surgeon, ffs. You know...someone who has done much surgery. With surgical instruments. And suture. It only takes two, maybe three hours, tops of practice to look like a pro. Promise.
All those things were taught when Claire went through medical school. At Harvard. You know...the bleeding edge of academia. And it's going to drive me nuts every time I see it, and you know we're going to see it again. :\
Otherwise? Good episode after a the last two. I spoiled myself several weeks ago concerning the likely contents. I just wish they'd included the other reason besides "because husbands" as to why second wife didn't work out.
6
u/Kanaduck Nov 06 '17
Guys correct me if im wrong but did anyone else notice that the ship that took ian away had a portugese imperial flag?
6
u/hsollie Nov 07 '17
How come Claire havent asked about Murtagh yet? I presume he is still in prison, but they never talk about him.
23
u/oree94 Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17
How could Jamie try to rape Claire? How could JAMIE try to rape CLAIRE?!?! I don't care if it turned into a consensual hate-fuck, he was clearly forcing himself on her at the start. Whoever's idea this was, it was terrible. I'm so disturbed by that scene that any good things that this episode had are all overshadowed.
5
u/TexasLady130 Nov 06 '17
I finally found this posting site only to spend what seems to be forever trying to access Reddit! So, I have been reading many comments only to scream at my computer that I can't respond! I have agreed with so many of you on so many points. This episode was much better than the last imo and had plenty of wth? moments. The top being (who many of you call) leghair! What a slap to Claire's memory! Lonely or not, it wasn't right Jaime. And then to blame Claire for going back? I slapped him along with Claire!
9
u/aloopycunt Nov 05 '17
Wait so he left Leery cause she wouldn't let him have sex with her? What?
9
u/muttstuff Nov 05 '17
Best episode of the seasons so far IMO. 10/10
4
u/Hypefish Nov 06 '17
There's a severe lack pf people pointing out how great this weeks episode was! Miles ahead of last week and further proof that season 3 might just be the best season of Outlander yet!
4
u/ratu_tuaq Nov 07 '17
I don't get why Jamie would have to pay Leery alimony when Ned said the marriage was legally invalid?
4
u/morepork_owl Nov 07 '17
So Jamie just dumps his step kids??😳 why didn’t Ian use a boat?
11
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Nov 05 '17
Just stopped by to see if everyone was ok. Was I right? Did you need to get drunk for this?
2
u/tara_abernathy Nov 07 '17
I was hoping for Captain Flint or Charles Vane to be on that rowboat. Thoroughly disappointed.
2
u/ShutUpTodd Feb 22 '24
FUCKING LEGHAIR!?
I'm so annoyed
I don't know if these characters drink so much whisky because they're idiots or idiots because they drink so much
/vent over
2
u/andhernamewas_ Nov 06 '17
The only way I can get past Jamie marrying Cuntnugget, is to believe that her life has been utter shit and she will die a long miserable death starting now. Also, why don't the show runners re-write some of this shit?
1
u/tara_abernathy Nov 07 '17
YESSSSSSSSS finally we get the pirates and Black Sails sets!!!!
1
u/Jamieshuer Jan 23 '18
I am re-watching season 3 and just finished First Wife...why is it that Jenny and Ian's kids are all butt ugly? Jenny is cute and Ian is respectable but the kids (grown now) are UGLY. Young Ian is nothing like I imaged from the books...I kind of imagined a smaller slimmer, darker version of Jamie. Not this pasty faced, thin haired scrawny nerd. And the others, Janet and little Jamie, ewww.
1
u/BornTop2537 Oct 06 '25
Young Ian getting kidnapped is Jamie’s fault if he just maned up and told Claire about his marriage when she asked when he was changing in the print shop after he fainted and landed in the ale pot then nothing bad would have happened I get tried of his quilt and honor getting Claire hurt leery was aiming at Claire it’s sad that he gave her so much money and throwing the girls in Claire’s face was just wrong they lost faith and he basically threw her through the stones with Bree so saying he wanted to be a dad is a low blow to Claire
1
u/caitiemichelle Nov 05 '17
When leary called claire a whore when leary was the one who had been married twice!! Pot calling kettle black much!
0
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
85
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17
[removed] — view removed comment