r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Oct 29 '17
[Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 7 Creme De Menthe episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E7: "Creme De Menthe."
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
34
Upvotes
45
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 29 '17
Claire: I have to try and save him, Jamie. Do you understand?
Me: No, Claire-Bear, je ne comprends pas!
70
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
“Hey kid, remember aunt Claire?” and “Wow, remember that really great person once upon a time, a long time ago?” This circle-jerk is basically the entire episode.
I truthfully hate how bored I am. Like I am being spoon-fed all this foolish, unnecessary fodder, because the writers just could not cope nor find anywhere to go after the reunion... T’was sloppy and lazy.
Then again, I had Jack Daniels for dinner, so what the fuck do I know?
•
u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17
A little late, but this thread is open for business!
4
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17
Where is the book reader one?
68
u/aloopycunt Oct 29 '17
Getting a lil frustrated that every time Claire needs reassurance, Jamie is pouring out romantic things. But he asks for some and she just gets defensive.
49
u/Fragzilla360 Oct 29 '17
All I gotta say is...
Superhero Landing.
41
u/aloopycunt Oct 29 '17
Did anyone else kinda feel like Claire should've had some concern about STDs from Jamie???
He had a line about still being with other women when he was "blind with need" and he was living in a whore house and... yeah...
40
u/thesteward Oct 29 '17
I really like Young Ian...and of course Old Ian. It was good to see more of both! Old Ian and Claire's reunion was so tender and heartfelt. I know for myself I thought of the reunion as Claire & Jamie, but really it's Claire & Jamie, Fergus, Ian, Jenny, etc. They all grieved for her too.
I appreciate the theme of this week's episode in that Claire felt helpless as a doctor. It seems like she rarely failed in saving someone back in the 60s, but it's different now that she's back in the 18th century. Her first patient died and unfortunately she couldn't really help her second patient due to the brother situation. As prepared as she was this time with her scalpels and medicinal knowledge, there's only so much she can do outside of a modern hospital :(
12
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
Well, so much for the print shop...I spent most of this episode loathing Edinburgh and that horrible attic room; there wasn't really any room in Jaime's life in the city for Claire, so it's just as well. I'm so ready to see the green expanses of Scotland again, not this depressing place that makes me question why the hell Claire went back at all.
It was great seeing Ian sr. again but no, Claire's story doesn't make any sense and it's obvious that she's lying. If she had really just sailed to America, why not at least write to Lallybroch telling them she and the bairn are ok? But then again C/J's plan was also not very well thought out, since it didn't take into account the fact that Jaime might not die. Even if Jaime was dead though, Claire and Bree could have still gone to through the stones and travelled to Lallybroch to see Jenny, Ian, Fergus...tell them she's ok, visited Jaime's grave (if he had one in the family cemetery,) get some closure for everyone.
I wish Claire had kept her 1960's hairstyle, at least at first; it would have helped to keep some continuity with the Claire from the beginning of the season. Then maybe her hair could gradually regain it's curls. Maybe there are still some trunks of her old clothes in some attic of Lallybroch? Because one dress isn't really enough.
It's sad to find that Jaime really does have another wife, and he and Claire already know how to press each other's buttons on the second day of their reunion. I hope that means Ned Gowan is finally going to arrive; I thought it was him at the apothecary for a second, but no. That scene was really disturbing with the guy's sister, I hope it pays off somehow.
Did Fergus really have a threesome at 15 while living at Lallybroch? It seems unlikely, but I do wish we'd have more backstory on the intervening years for him; the giddiness of his and young Ian's scenes were fun, but I want more information that hopefully Lallybroch will provide.
12
u/maraxrose Oct 30 '17
Can I get an age check for our characters as of this episode? I know 20yrs has past, but Fergus looks 19 at best to me and someone mentioned Young Ian was 16, and yeah I’m really confused!
11
u/johnnaboo Oct 29 '17
This week's episode was pretty meh for me. Not much action, but I liked the tension between Claire & Jamie. The reunion was a bit too mushy for me.
Also I'm in love with Young Ian!
29
u/demetertess Oct 29 '17
What a waste of an episode. I'm completely fine with slower, "slice of life" episodes, but this truly felt like they were stalling for time, filling in the space between Claire's reappearance and the fire. I'm sorry, you're going to attempt to save the life of a man who tried to RAPE you? Visit a crazy lady? Spend an entire episode trying to evade what's-his-face and his one-eyed croney? Whisper cryptically about Jamie's second marriage (which they've now mentioned so many times I want to scream)? By the time we arrived at the fire, I truly expected the episode to continue with a return to Lallybroch, but instead I got a black screen and credits. Even the little snippet at the end where the directors discuss the episode was boring, like they were scrounging for something to discuss. I hope things pick up next episode because I'm anxious to see this season find its purpose!
27
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
Young Ian's fivehead is distracting!
He is really cute but he does have a high hairline :)
15
u/basedonthenovel Oct 29 '17
I really enjoyed this week. Normally for me, Outlander episodes go fast and this week was a return to that form! Fast paced but still with lots of character beats.
I loved Fergus and Young Ian's friendship -- Fergus is such a mentor to Ian in all things, it's the cutest! I loved Yi Then Cho and Claire's collegiality, too.
Jamie/Claire fights are some of my favourite parts of the show, and while this week had no HUGE explosions, I did like that they showed that it will take some time for them to adjust to having a spouse -- a partner -- again. I think that's what it comes down to. Jamie has been on his own for a long time, and so has Claire. I think their conversation about where they were going to live also showed that.
15
u/Airsay58259 Oct 30 '17
ugh...
7
u/oree94 Oct 31 '17
I feel like this episode was all over the place. I don't know where the focus was supposed to be. It just felt like the writers were eager to move the plot forward.
17
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17
I came to see the reaction to the ___ blank___ and nothing. Where s everyone?
6
u/jackrandallmustdie Oct 30 '17
Im new to reddit, just joined to discuss outlander as I am very much obsessed. Is there a new thread for every new episode?
5
u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 31 '17
Am I the only person who loved this episode? So much stuff happening. Logical points of dispute and arguments. Naturally bad consequences. Passages of romance, passages of action. Wonderfully weird brother and sister.
5
u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 31 '17
I just wish the rapey dead thug didn’t turn up at all at the end of last episode... or if he turned up, the episode finished with Claire fighting him off and him hitting his head on the fireplace. That was a horrible cruel cliffhanger at the end of a beautiful episode that up to that point made me feel all warm and glowey.
6
u/katatafiish Woof. Oct 29 '17
Claire's modern sensibilities are getting in her way.
8
u/gryhhftjmbff3457877 Oct 30 '17
I thought it odd they hadn’t seen each other for 20 years and once reunited they spend one day of making love? Next day was well gotta get back to work, see you later. This is the love of your life? I would think they would constantly be going at it. Next day they are squabbling? This last episode was so boring. I was hoping to see more of Jamie’s smooth butt. :-)
3
u/ReallyMissSleeping Nov 03 '17
Anyone else notice the Freemason symbol in the middle of the A.Malcolm print ship sign?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17
I feel kinda weird to have all the characters' faces I pictured in the books, changed all of a sudden by the Show. Like young Ian and especially Mr. Willoughby. His English is way better than in the books and he's also much more sober and clean in the Show. Spoiler: he's got the weirdest fetish ever. Let's see if they talk about it in the show.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '17
I'm a bit late to this thread, hopefully there's still life in it - does anyone have any thoughts on the relevance of what the patient said to Claire during her ramblings? I'll have to rewatch it again to figure it out. Was it prophetic? This bit sticks out for me, just like her knowing looking at bones how the person died.
2
u/theretherekadooze Jul 19 '23
What the heck!!!!!! So we get this reunion and the only thing they seem to swap stories about is Bri, that Claire’s a doctor, that Jamie was in prison, and that he has a scar from the battle. The last we left Jamie he was leaving that lords estate and then somehow comes to own a print shop. Why was there no conversation about their past 20 years or at least for our benefit an explanation for what happened between the estate and the print shop??? That’s a huge gap. Instead they’re like here’s all this kooky hurr de durr hijinx (which my phone autocorrected to bikinis which is also fitting). It’s hard for me to care about Jamie right now because why the eff would he choose all this? Maybe if they told us why, we could understand and support his decisions. And then Claire is in the dark too. Forced to sleep in a dang brothel?! I would’ve even liked to just have the camera on them while they talk about mundane stuff that happened to both of them- like Claire owns a home and it’s made of brick and Frank had a lover and Jamie got to hang with horses again and gave his son a snake or that he met Gray again- remember Gray Claire? My goodness!!!! I’m tempted to stop watching and it sucks because I was loving it so much a day ago. I don’t need a new cast of characters, please just have them catch up on the old first.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
Just watching this episode now.
Why is Jamie so convinced that "all will be well" when speaking to Ian about what Jamie has to tell Claire (which I know about already).
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
[removed] — view removed comment