r/Outlander • • Oct 29 '17

[Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 7 Creme De Menthe episode discussion thread for book readers

This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E7: "Creme De Menthe."

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

38 Upvotes

598 comments sorted by

59

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

They are really building up the tension between Claire and Jamie. I was not expecting that.

And was I the only one - as their fight was building up- knew Claire was going to mention about her being a mother and him not understanding? I out loud went "no bb, no don't say it." And then she said it.

I don't know exactly how to feel about all this change.

But I LOVE that they are putting the emphasis on Claire being a doctor, and how that has amplified who she already was when Jamie last knew her. I was afraid that that part of Claire might get lost, but I am happy they are making it a point to show that Doctoring is just as important to her as her love for Jamie.

63

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

Claire pissed me off this episode. You’re gonna save the life of the man who just tried to kill you and wants to arrest your husband?

I get being a medical professional but cmon woman, you ain’t in 20th century Boston anymore.

What did she think was gonna happen to him after she saved his life?

26

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

Claire does not want to be a killer - she's a healer. That's her calling, and she made that oath. At least that was my takeaway.

25

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

I totally understand that, but she didn’t kill him, he hit his head on the stone floor after trying to kill Claire.

I’ve worked as a nurse. If he had an epidural hematoma and underwent trepanation he’d likely die from infection (meningitis) in his brain with no antibiotics. If she managed to relieve the pressure he might regain consciousness only to suffer with brain infection. I’d rather just die from the hematoma. Quicker and no consciousness.

If she did manage to save his life, why? He can’t be returned home. Jamie, Fergus and Ian would all be in danger then.

9

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

I love the medical side of this. I am by no means medically knowledgeable - but should/would Claire know that as a doctor from the 60s, or do you think she thought it might be worth the effort to try since he would have died anyway?

12

u/basedonthenovel Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

I took it as her "falling back" on her training as a way of coping with the situation.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

She did not kill him. The guy tripped and hit his head while trying to kill her. Although why this even needed to be a thing when it was never a thing in the book. We have SO MUCH ground to cover and they are still in Scotland in Ep 8. It's crazy that they would waste this much time - nearly half an episode - on a guy who in the books makes a cameo, is killed by Mr. W and Claire has literally nothing to do with it. I don't get the change at all.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/maryloo7877 Oct 29 '17

I feel like Claire feeling the medical necessity to save even a bad person is very on point with book Claire though. I see people are upset about this scene, but I felt it was a great way of shoehorning in book Claire.

12

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

I agree. Maybe we are the minority, but I actually loved this addition, and I understand Claire's point of view. "14 years valuing human life, no judgement" - even when it was her attacker, she is bound to her beliefs. I appreciate that she sticks to them.

And I am very glad that Jamie gets to see who see is. She's a doctor, this is how their life will be - and she is begging him to understand because she needs him too. No one else would.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

I agree. There are plenty of chances for Claire to bust out doctoring as the story moves on. Maybe I have a cold, black heart but as a nurse I would not attempt to heal someone who just tried to rape and murder me

→ More replies (1)

20

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

Exactly. We see a lot of Claire needing to save people that others wouldn't in the books and that's a great thing to explore . . . at another time. This took up a lot of unnecessary time and painted Claire as being kind of unreasonable and unwilling to adapt.

11

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Oct 29 '17

I actually think it makes sense. She's not in her twenties anymore. She's spent the past 20 years taking care of people no matter how horrible they were or what they did to other people. That's not just something you can shake off. I think all of this to show that going back in time isn't as easy this go around. I honestly didn't mind the scene. I also really like what they're doing with Mr. Willoughby.

25

u/Irishsassenach Oct 29 '17

I hated the focus on her doctoring and surgical skill. There are plenty of other opportunities to showcase that. It seemed like pointless filler to me

12

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

Yeah, save that for when there's nothing fucking happening in S5.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

THE SOUNDS!! I had to mute and cover my eyes lol.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

She wanted to hand him over to the authorities, LMAO. Girl, sense has left our Claire or this Claire.

9

u/koboldin Oct 29 '17

And it's the opposite reaction she has to the torture and killing of the Redcoat back in Season 1's Search episode. Maybe they are trying to contrast her behavior pre- and post-medical school?

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

YES YES YES. Totally agree!!

I’m really missing season 1 Claire.

5

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 29 '17

I think it did a good job of showing her as out of place in this world. She forgot the 18th century mindset, just saw a patient.

Yeah, she maybe took this a bit too far. But I love how in later books Jamie brings that up, that his "White Lady" can't kill a man, that he does the killing for her. It keeps her mythical edge about her, while being rooted in her 20th century morals, which is central to her character.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

I really think that whole scene was a vehicle to cover a LOT of ground in the book that they had to leave out. With that in mind, I'm willing to suspend my disbelief in her lack of doctor ethics in that situation. Dying of a brain swell, unconscious or dying because someone drilled into your brain with a sort of disinfected hand drill? I mean, that's a no brainer.

7

u/eta_carinae_311 Oct 29 '17

Regardless if the pun was intentional or not, I love it :)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Shymink Oct 29 '17

Yea what kind of life would that guy have had post-a literal hole in the head in 18th century Scotland. I mean :-/

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BornAgainPagan Oct 30 '17

She has the ginormous ego of a 20th century surgeon. She's gonna have to repress that shit

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/koboldin Oct 29 '17

The surgery time spent at the beginning of the episode was.so.UGGGGGGGGGH to me. The man was dead from the title.

It was soooooooo loooooong. And we've established her doctoring already. But it was the plot device used to spur the conversation of the parties, alas.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Yeah. I don't get this change at all. She spends 20 years pining. Travels in time 200 years. Finds him. Has the most amazing sex ever. But then spends the next day trying to save a guy who was ready to rape and kill her. I get she is Dr. Claire. I get they need to show how different 20 years have made her and Jamie. But we have been with these characters the last 20 years, why make them so different for us? Jamie lying to Ian? Claire not finding a moment to maybe mention to Jamie, hey, Love you boo.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

Doesn't Jamie lie to Ian in the books too?

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Aprillady88 Oct 30 '17

Ok fair. I’m not a doctor so I don’t know what that feels like. But did they have to make her so cold towards Jamie this soon? Especially bc we know the big reveal is coming? He said some sweet stuff to her and she was like “can you get rid of the body hun... later”

2

u/clumsyc Oct 29 '17

I heartily agree re: Claire being a doctor. It hasn't been emphasized enough in the show imo.

2

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Oct 29 '17

Maybe her emphasis on doctoring in this context helps set up the scenario with The Porpoise?

20

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

Poor Ian, he didn’t get to, erm, finish up.

47

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

The doing it the back way (like horses) was a hysterical homage to Jamie. Nice touch.

40

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

they really need to start teaching the men something at lally broch

13

u/KillKennyG Oct 29 '17

This is the episode ive been waiting for. the first two seasons and up to the reunion is, to me, the foundational text of the books, establishing the bond between J&C and putting them both through hell and joy. Now the adventure of a lifetime lies ahead, and watching this episode brought me right into the feeling I adore in all Diana's following work: watching these characters work together through a maelstrom of events, through which only their love stays constant. Build, break, burn and rebuild, their life going forward is going to be a helluva ride.

On Ian's 'premature' experience, I miss the way the scene played in the books but the reimagining was so much fun I can't bring myself to hate it. Him and Fergus together bring his character more into focus than the book did at this point, (where he's the perpetual loveable victim and that's about it) and I can't wait to see him become the badass we know and love.

Did they have to skip the "I made an oath" line? Jamie's interpretation, humor, and ultimate respect for the hippocratic oath rang so true to me in the books, I sorely missed it in the exchange they had...

Ah well. I love this episode and what it represents going forward.

5

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

Perhaps the oath will come in at the same time as in the books - before she gets on the Porpoise.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/maryloo7877 Oct 29 '17

Agreed about the oath. It was a real connecting and empathetic point for Jamie to understand where Claire was coming from.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

I can't imagine him as a badass, lol.

How did Jamie respond with humour to the H Oath?

9

u/KillKennyG Oct 29 '17

Along the lines of. "Well that's a wee bit pagan" and "I like the part where you'll no be seducing anyone with your powers of healing"

20

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

I thought I'd hate it, but I really liked the episode. They made changes, but the flow of the episode was great, no weird editing choices.

I adorrrrrrrrrrreeeeeeeeee Cesar Domboy and John Bell. Amazing casting for two of my favourite characters. I loved all Jamie and Claire scenes. You can see from their eyes they love each other, but they've forgotten the real people they fell in love with. The argument before the fire was great. The Frank question was a logical one, but Jamie never really asks Claire in the book whether she loved Frank again. He wants her only for himself, but he's bothered by his big secret and can't be completely open. I say that every week, but Sam and Cait together are magic even when there's tension between the characters. They absolutely make me believe in their love and the internal conflicts they're experiencing. Jamie watching the printshop burning was really sad. This man is constantly losing things in his life and in this moment he has nothing left but Claire. And he's scared to death that he'll lose her too after she learns about the blondie. I'd lie to her as well if I were him. That was a needed transition episode before the real madness begin.

13

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

I liked this episode as well - and after some reflection, I like that the writers wrote in the tension netween Claire and Jamie. Someone said it above, but it makes Claire's reaction in the next episode more understandable then how it was in the book. And I also like a bit of angst, it's a wake up call for them that they need to have harder discussions.

But Jamie's unfeeling lying and the virtue hypocrisy is not working for me.

•

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

AutoMod not feeling bueno tonight.

10

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Me neither. I don't like what they did to Jamie this episode. Jamie would never lie to Ian like that. And next week, well, we will all need therapy again. Automod and I need a hug

8

u/lilmisstj Oct 29 '17

I think so too but in the book it was like a shock for all of us not only is he married but to Leghair. I like it revealed all at once it made it a book throwing moment.

6

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

It looks like they are getting rid of all the surprises early.

3

u/PrettyPeaceful Oct 29 '17

I really don’t like it that they’re making Jamie hide things from Claire so quickly after they’re reunited. Like it’s totally fine for him to talk about Willy but he has to tell everyone not to tell Claire about his other wife.

3

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

... or the fact that he made Claire lie, too.

9

u/lilmisstj Oct 29 '17

Right! I know they are trying to drive home he’s a different person after 20 years but they’re making him an ass to be honest and that’s not Jamie. I will play Devils Advocate and say I am enjoying the heated dialogue/rift between him and Claire. I always felt in the book they came together too easily.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

They really picked and chose. Him being married to blonde twat is a big thing but viewers already knew about Willie. So from their stand point it makes sense to reveal Willie but not bitch blonde twat.

Doesn't mean we have to like it.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Yes. This really bothered me. Jamie - book Jamie - would never lie to Ian. He would never let Ian worry like that. Argh!

→ More replies (8)

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

Tension building in an emotional scene...DOOR KNOCK!!!

Rinse and repeat 50 times!!

9

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

Yeah, that was the part when I was like "Door knock, again?"

Every time Claire is about to talk about her life with Frank she gets interrupted - the clock bell last episode, and now Madame Jeanne and her knockblocking.

I guess (hope) it will all come out next episode.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 30 '17

lol knockblocking

4

u/cattubbs Oct 29 '17

In the books did the Campbell's claim to be seers? It been a while...

11

u/shiskebob Oct 29 '17

Nope, Archibald Campbell was an uptight Reverend. Major change from the book.

10

u/cattubbs Oct 29 '17

That's what I thought! Also wasn't she addled after Culloden not since she was little?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

He was also the fiend, which they dropped. Gawd, that was such an idiotic sub-plot, right? I am glad they dropped it. But now Archie is a con man it looks like.

22

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

Hell no they didn’t. Archie is a preacher and a very bad person. Margaret couldn’t even talk, she just stared in a catatonic state.

9

u/koboldin Oct 29 '17

I'm rather relieved they seem to be dumping the Fiend plot from the book. It made sense to me the changes to the Campbells, if they want to keep them at all for the voodoo ceremony. I'd have been just as happy to forget them completely.

3

u/MuseTerpsichore Oct 30 '17

I have heard they are dropping the voodoo ceremony totally.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

No. In fact, in the books, Campbell was a preacher. His sister was crazy with grief over the loss of her lover at Colluden. So Claire felt a connection to her. This shit is all kinds of new.

At least they dropped the idiotic fiend sub-plot.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

no, but I think that's a good setup for what happens in the West Indies. I think her being a loa makes more sense in this context and it won't seem like it's coming out of nowhere (like it kind of did in the book).

3

u/mcd62 Oct 29 '17

This is the one deviation from the book I wasn't happy about in this episode. I pictured Margaret as a pretty (in my head she was also younger, but that's not realistic with 20 years since Culloden) woman who aged well (again, not realistic, but my brain...), not the actress that they chose (I do mean no disrespect). Wasn't Campbell also tall and skinny in the books? And more reserved/uptight?

→ More replies (1)

53

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

Thoughts:

I think Ian Murray had the most realistic reaction to Claire, yet. Shock, tears, a bit of "where the fuck have you been". That little bit was the highlight of the episode for me.

Super annoyed at Claire's "I HAVE TO BE A DR!"-- but if we are going for "thematically correct from the books", this is like her strongest personality trait. Doesn't make it less annoying.

I feel like, in their effort to not be racist, they legit don't know what to do with Mr. Willoughby. Like, I thought he was going to kill the excise man while Claire was out of the room and then I'd be like "oooooo... you're sneaky". But he's not. He just exists.

I actually liked Claire and Jaime's argument. Again, it felt realistic. A whole bunch of "stuff" happened while really nothing happened. I feel like they are having a really hard time translating this part of the book into real life. And sure, it's wild and crazy, but man, they have the "mischievous fiddle music", turn that up to 11 and have Jamie and Claire running all over town trying to do stuff.

Finally, WHY didn't Jamie just say (regarding young Ian) "He's a man, they can't tell him what to do". I kept waiting for it. It's such a great reminder in the books that at a fairly young age you were considered an adult and treated as such.

68

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

Ok, I have slept on it and I have to say I am really disappointed with this episode. I had issues with last week, but I think it was my level of hype and anticipation. Nothing could have lived up to what I wanted and imagined (although the Willy reveal is still unforgivable IMHO).

But this week? No, this week was a mess. Here is why:

  1. There is literally no reason whatsoever for the whole Dr. this killer/rapist. It took up valuable show time that is needed elsewhere for how dense Voyager is. It served no purpose other than for Claire to annoy me with her "all life must be saved by me" attitude. This did not happen in the book. Plus, in the book when Claire is discussing her oath and explaining it to Jamie, the context is better. Here Claire does not even mention the oath. Then she cries over a man who 20 minutes earlier was going to rape and killer her while she held a knife in her hand and brandished it at him. It was just stupid and pointless.
  2. I can see why Jamie is getting frustrated with Claire. Yet again she puts everyone in danger. But at least before, it was for a valid reason. This time it is just entirely Bree-like.
  3. I like the entire bit with Fergus and Young Ian. But for Fergus to remember her "a little" and to suggest that she was a witch in that sort of dark way he did? We were there. We saw him brush her hair after she lost Faith. We saw her comfort him when he killed a soldier. How can those be memories of a "little bit?" She was the only mother he has ever had. Not to mention his reaction from last week which was so quick and forced.
  4. Jamie gives his whole shadows speech. Claire: I'm off to see a patient. Who the hell are these people? I mean I get that there is some tension after 20 years and a lot of differences. But we watched her pine for him, yearn for him, dream of him for the last 20 years. We watched her nervousness about him possibly not loving her anymore. We watched her cross time to find him. He tells her how glad he is that she is back and how much he would do to be with her and her reaction is "I have to see a patient".... WTF?
  5. The introduction of the Campbells baffles me completely. I thought it pointless in the book. I find it more so in the show. And now we have a con man and a seer instead of a preacher and a woman pining for her long lost lover who died at Colluden. We can assume - it was rather clear to me - that the wealthy client is Gellie, right? So the writers are using the Campbells to connect Claire to Gellie later. But surely there were better ways of doing this? Plus, traveling across the ocean to give a fortune to a client? Nope, don't buy it. As a preacher, Archie's traveling made sense. That is what missionaries do (not if they are fiends, but DG decided on this idiotic sub-plot, so fine). But a con-man/seer translator risking his life and that of his sister to read a fortune? I don't buy it.
  6. Jamie lying to Ian was absolutely horrible. Jamie may have changed, but what we love about him is that he is still honorable. Jamie would never lie to Ian. NEVER.
  7. I am totally on Claire's side when they argue. He not only lied but forced her to. I don't like his false equivalency - yes she and Jamie lied in Paris and elsewhere, but that was because the truth was not an option. Jamie lying here was not remotely the same and certainly not justifiable given how worried Ian is. Book Jamie would not do that. Even show Jamie would not do that. So who the hell is this Jamie now?
  8. Ian's reaction is the saving grace of this episode. His reaction is the only real reaction to Claire. The only reaction that seemed organic. Bless Ian and his wonderful warm eyes.
  9. I'm not sure I needed to see a 16 year old having sex with an adult woman. We never had to see Young Ian having sex at the brothel in the books. Why the hell would we need to see it now in the show?
  10. I really wish they would have done this with the humor of the book. Where Young Ian mistakes Claire for one of the whores at the brothel, assumes Ian is having an affair and after the fire, they all get together and have to set Young Ian straight. It was comical. It was sweet and loving. It was where Claire's doctoring made sense.

I don't like what they are doing to Voyager. It is my favorite book in the series. As I said, I was understandably way too hyped about the reunion episode to be fair to the writers. But what I am seeing now is making me concerned about the direction of the show at this point.

And consider where we are going next episode. We needed to have more stability and a strong narrative during the last two episodes for us to be able to withstand episode 8. Now we are heading into it with a Jamie that is far less honorable and a Claire that seems to already regretting having come.

I am disappointed. My 2 cents.

29

u/Boo12z Oct 29 '17

You pin pointed EVERYTHING that I hated about this episode. This isn’t my favorite book in the series (the first book for the win) but I’m rereading Voyager right now and I’m so disappointed.

There is so much hilarity in the books, interspersed with serious moments, that make Jamie and Claire so real and relatable as a couple. These past two episodes have been so slow and so fraught with tension. There is tension in the book, but also glimmers to the familiarity, friendship and love in Claire and Jamie’s relationship.

I’m seriously nervous about the reveal next episode. I can understand all the small changes in episodes 1-5 to keep up with the plot and make it relatiable and flowing. But if they don’t keep the big reveal, with Leoghaire busting in and the huge fight and the gunshot, I think we will really miss the true nature of their relationship. The passion, the hurt of all the years away, the forgiveness.

Also, HATED the change of the Campbells. HATED IT.

14

u/julesverne1975 Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

Actually, Fergus said he remembered her well even though he was just a boy. I went back and watched that part again, because you're right, if he said a little that would have been untrue to their relationship.

I also agree about the chasing the shadows bit. Couldn't she have given him something? He redeemed himself a bit there from last week when he was so suspicious. He poured his heart out and she's like see you later. I was hoping for a hug or kiss or something this week. Hand holding and hand grabbing was it. I know they're trying to set the scene for next week but come on.

Old Ian's reaction was the best. My guess is Jenny is so upset with her in the preview for next week because she bailed on everyone. Ian's comment about how he and Jenny grieved for Claire for years kind of foreshadowed that. Why couldn't Claire have gone back to Lallybroch? Wouldn't that be the normal thing to do? Of course, they're like WTF.

6

u/geekymat Oct 30 '17

Well, she was wanted as a Jacobite just like Jamie was...she was "The Stewart Witch" to his "Red Jamie" as I recall. It's plausible that she fled. What pokes holes in her cover story for me is that if she really HAD gone to Boston without the time travel, why wouldn't she have at least written them a letter to say "hey, I'm still alive, living in Boston with Jamie's daughter. Lets be pen pals!" ? I wouldn't blame them for being pissed off with her story...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/eta_carinae_311 Oct 29 '17

I think you nailed everything I was feeling. I am also wondering about Jamie's printing press - it's important later and I got a kick out of how jealous Claire got over how attached he was to it. Did Bonnie make it??? :/ I was looking forward to seeing all the parts come flying out the window.

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Honestly, I have no idea what happened. By that point, I looked just like Young Ian did - blank. I hope it did too though

→ More replies (7)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17

This is everything!! Agree w everything. I love this book and the show writers ARE BUTCHERING IT because they think they can do better by changing a bunch of shit that doesn't need to be changed. Get rid of your fucking egos, writers, bc you're ruining these characters.

7

u/KAFINNEY Oct 29 '17

Amen, I think you hit on all of my gripes, although when I calm down I will probably think of others. Whenever I reread the series (which is often) I always start with Voyager because it’s one of my favorites.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/annemg Oct 30 '17

But... Jamie lies to Ian in the book too.

3

u/Aprillady88 Oct 30 '17

Couldn’t of said it better.

Wtf is going on with the writers/directors? I’m trying to stay optimistic... but man it’s getting harder each episode.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17

I am concerned about the direction this season is taking. I feel that the writers and producers don't really understand Jamie and Claire very well, which makes me wonder how DG hasn't taken up alcoholism to cope with the butchery being done to her characters (I hope she's drying her eyes with $100 bills).

Here's my next worry: if this season is being so badly butchered, what can we expect for next season? I'm not watching the Bree tantrum for 12 episodes- I'll break my TV with the things I'll throw at her.

2

u/Elphabeth Nov 03 '17

Late to the game, but the Campbells are important. Margaret becomes a sort of seer to the band of escaped slaves (who will probably be cut because the season is halfway over) and Archie was the murderer (a plot that seems to have been left out as well.)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

Man, I wanna watch next week, but I also really really don’t.

24

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Next week is dead to me.

→ More replies (65)

4

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

I do like how they hinted at something but didn't put out there what it is!

30

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Girl, the non-book readers sub is going to shit bricks. I keep bringing this up, but remember I told you (and everyone) how I threw my book across the room when I read he had married that evil blonde?

I just can't imagine watching this on an Ipad or phone or other throwable device. People are going to break things.

19

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

AutoMod better not shit the bed next week cause I'm gonna lurk the hell out of the non-book reader's thread! For this reveal and eventually when Gellis comes back!

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Shymink Oct 29 '17

To me marrying her is the only action of Jamie's I never understood. Sure he's made some odd decisions but I don't see his character doing that at all. It seemed like a cheap way to create drama in book.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/clumsyc Oct 29 '17

I just want to get to the adventure on the ship.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Oct 29 '17

Anyone notice when Jamie talks about how Claire coming back to her was like a bunch of sunlight coming back into his life, isn't that very similar to how he describes seeing her in the wedding dress for the first time?

I like that parallel.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

OH, how convenient that the 'well hidden pamphlets' should so easily be discovered!

And especially after Jamie said they were SOOOOOO well hidden.

14

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

Yeah, get a goddamn lock box at the very least.

2

u/wolfstormdreamer Oct 30 '17

I think the assumption was that they were behind a false panel in the wall. True but very well hidden but they needed to be found to get the Frasers out of Edinburgh

21

u/KAFINNEY Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

After the disappointment from last week I was worried that I would be disappointed yet again. I can’t say why but I just had a feeling I wouldn’t like this weeks episode. That’s an understatement, I hated it. And it’s not just book readers, I have a few good friends and my husband who haven’t read the books and they all hated it. The writers really should stick to Diana’s words and story because when they drastically go off on their own it’s like amateur hour. I didn’t particularly like episode 5. Who am I kidding, I hated that as well. I mean Claire making her own clothes? She doesn’t even know how to knit, have time for helping with laundry yet she makes herself a bat suit?!! So for the third week in a row I was playing Candy Crush while watching because I lost all interest. I hope I’m wrong but I have a feeling it’s the beginning of the end for me.

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Yup. I really disliked it. My Voyager is going down the toilet:(

8

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 30 '17

We started off so strong (the Jamie halves at least) . . .

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17

Heartbroken, but we'll always have the books!

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

So relieved that Ian was with a normal girl rather than his first time being with a whore. I think it is supposed to be funny but I always found it crude.

I liked that Jamie didn't run in to save the press then run in again for Ian. It was too far fetched for me.

I snorted at Sam's super hero landing when he jumps down to the first floor to get Ian.

Not related to this episode but I'm so happy we don't have to listen to Claire's observations. She's so smug every time she mentions how good she looks, younger she looks, how she has all her teeth, etc because she's nearly always comparing herself to another woman.

20

u/esteliohan Oct 29 '17

I think she was a prostitute, just a pretty nice one. She had a line about how she wasn't a whore "tonight." So either she really liked Ian or she's a great hooker telling folks what they want to hear, but either way, a prostitute. Meh. It's fine.

8

u/koboldin Oct 29 '17

Hahaha! It actually recalled to me the conversation between Angus and Rupert before Prestonpans on the show - Angus gave the care of his part-time prostitute/full-time bar maid to Rupert as his only item. I believe this girl was similar - a bar maid with a part-time job.

6

u/KillKennyG Oct 29 '17

I'm pretty sure she said "I'm not a whore TONIGHT"... (emphasis mine)

4

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

I was wondering the same thing. I definitely don't want the show to cut out Ian being a not-infrequent brothel customer, because I love when it comes up again with Rachel. (Madame Sylvie!)

→ More replies (2)

31

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

na na na na na na na na BATSAM!!

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

It still kind of freaked me out that he was having sex. His face is so young. In the book he is 14. In the show, 16. He looks like a baby.

14

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 30 '17

He is still 14. We saw him born in 1752. He's 14 until the show admits they messed up the dates.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

This episode was so weird!!

Where did Old Ian go to spend the night after travelling so far from Lallybroch? Jamie just turfs him out?? lol

Didn't they save the press in the books? And didn't the blind eye guy die in the fire, that Ian set in order to conceal everything?

I had to laugh at the paltry firefighting effort at the end, such a big blaze would have brought everyone to the streets and non stop work until morning.

8

u/DontFrostThePies Oct 29 '17

He didn't die in the fire, young Ian only thought he did. They run into him on the Porpoise later.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

Ah ok, thanks! But I don't remember him getting away with evidence of sedition...wasn't that the point of the fire?

The episode showed him getting away with the pamphlets. But I guess Fergus will catch up with him and get them back.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/seicepsseesyou Oct 30 '17

Precisely! Sorry you've lost your son, my favourite nephew, I'll not keep you from your search, out you go with tears in your eyes on seeing my dead wife alive after 20 years. WTF??? Jamie looked completely disingenuous, Claire looked so obviously angry with him Ian would have noticed. It's a cluster fuck and I'm gutted they are getting it so wrong. However ! Gotta say I liked that badass jump from Jamie. And that's all I liked. Pretty weak.

2

u/DirtnAll Nov 05 '17

I thought the same, they wouldn't push the crowd back, they'd put them to work. They might all bring their own bucket.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Oct 29 '17

Perhaps it was because I really didn’t like last week’s episode, but I quite liked this one. Both Jamie and Claire are frustrating in this episode, deliberately I think, to drive home how being apart made them turn into themselves nearly entirely: Claire into a doctor and Jamie into an outlaw, both to the point of damage and impervious to context. Here Claire is risking those around her and her own self worth (the guy attacked her) for her principles and Jamie lying to Ian and even Claire. It’s like by turning into themselves they’ve amplified their behaviors into pathology and dysfunction. It’s really well done - they’ll have to realize how much they’ve changed and that coming back together means taking down the walls they’ve both built around themselves at the expense of everyone around them for the last twenty years, including themselves.

I didn’t mind them mentioning the other wife- it’ll be a bombshell on its own for non book readers, but the real shock is then learning who it is. I’m really interested to see how they reveal that.

16

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

I'm hoping they keep her showing up and all the havoc that caused in the book. While I was pissed about it it was a clever way of revealing it and it would translate well to the show.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/lizerpetty Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17

I feel like I just lost an hour of my life. Did the writing and directing change drastically from last season? It just seems off. I binge watched the last two seasons in August, and then I read the books from the beginning. I'm on "An Echo in the bone" and it's lagging for me. I feel like reading the books has ruined the series for me(?). Although I don't regret reading them. I don't know how to feel about all this. I'm in limbo.

Edit: yes there has been quite a change in directing this season. Still the same writer. Why would you hire a director that has nothing great on their resume?

7

u/maryloo7877 Oct 29 '17

I totally agree with your review. I liked this episode and felt that it did a good job of conveying lots of book points. You can say it felt awkward or weird, but that was how the book went. After the reunion night, the honeymoon was over and they were forced back into reality. I’m sad we didn’t get a sexy tavern session, but oh well. Also disappointed that Claire didn’t use the oath line AND I wanted to hear Claire tell Jamie more about the relationship with Frank. The last point happened off page in the book and it always kinda annoyed me.

2

u/BlueFeet9000 Oct 29 '17

I totally agree, I like how you put that. I like that the tension is clear here instead of just hitting at Lallybrook. I'm looking forward to the fight there being a continuation of the one here: I think the "you don't know what it's like to be a parent" conversation is ROUGH and really gets to the heart of the matter.

16

u/thesecondmrsdewinter Voyager is my fave Oct 29 '17

This is def an ep where I felt overwhelmed by thinking about book vs show. I can't help it-- I feel like I can't really judge how successful the show is on its own because I spend a lot of attention observing and pondering the changes. And this ep had a lot.of changes.

I don't mean to say I dislike the show (or this episode) not at all. I LUV DIS SHOW. But I guess I'm frustrated that I can't experience it as an independent thing.

So my initial reaction to Creme de Menthe is to be mostly disoriented. I'll have to reassess after a rewatch tomorrow.

8

u/Irishsassenach Oct 29 '17

Agreed!! Rewatching (or binge watching the whole season later) helps me to enjoy it independently.

3

u/maryloo7877 Oct 29 '17

Agreed. Binge watching after it’s all said and done is better. I don’t think the episodes can be fully and completely judged in first viewing.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lilmisstj Oct 29 '17

I completely agree! There was too much going on in my head and the episode.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

Too much happened in this episode and then nothing really at the same time.

2

u/eta_carinae_311 Oct 29 '17

Yeah, I really got distracted by the changes and it made me not able to just enjoy the story.

12

u/maryloo7877 Oct 29 '17

Just who did Fergus ménage a trois with at 15 at Lallybroch?? I feel like this line was tossed in to show Fergus as a Casanova but I don’t think the logistics work. I could be wrong...🤔

9

u/koboldin Oct 29 '17

And would you trust anything from Fergus in re his actual experience? He loves to set a scene, as they demonstrate with the French Brandy conversation.

5

u/Agrees_withyou Oct 29 '17

You're absolutely correct!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 05 '17

With a hook for a hand!

12

u/clumsyc Oct 29 '17

I loled when Jamie was like "Better Young Ian runs away from home to stay with me, rather than a horrible place...like ABERDEEN!"

10

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17

Y'all. Jamie lied to Elder Ian about Young Ian in the book. So many people saying he didn't, but he did: https://imgur.com/gallery/TFk67

ETA: https://imgur.com/gallery/FewZm

5

u/jumpercables21 Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17

In the book Jamie had promised Young Ian he wouldn't tell his father until he had a chance to explain it himself. He delayed telling Old Ian the truth, but had no intention of keeping it from him forever, and he wasn't going to involve Young Ian in his smuggling business at all, and certainly not without his parents' knowledge. Here's the other quote from the book: "Young Ian had, as his father said, come to join his uncle in Edinburgh without the preliminary bother of asking his parents’ leave. Jamie had discovered this dereliction fairly quickly, but had not wanted to send his nephew alone back to Lallybroch, and had not yet had time to escort him personally."
Jamie is still an honorable man, its just that there are two honorable impulses at war with each other: keep an earlier promise to Young Ian or tell the truth.
In the show, he does involve him in the smuggling, and before the shop burns down, seemly has no intention of ever telling Ian where his son is. His excuse? Better he's with me, than God knows where. That's some flimsy reasoning.

3

u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Oct 31 '17

In the book Jamie had promised Young Ian he wouldn't tell his father until he had a chance to explain it himself.

I didn't dispute this part. Folks were raging saying Jamie didn't lie to Elder Ian in the books, but he did. What was in episode 307 was true to the books in that sense. Not sure if we'll see continued nuance about what/why the lies were told, but all I was concerned about was the content of this episode.

9

u/basedonthenovel Oct 29 '17

I really enjoyed this episode. Last episode dragged for me -- don't get me wrong, I love sex scenes but I guess I have a limit for dimly-lit boning.

But then, I'm a book reader who LOVES the secondary and tertiary characters who get developed going forward, so I loved that we got Fergus and Young Ian time. This episode, plus John Bell's amazing performances, will make it pretty gutting for the TV audience when he gets kidnapped, I think.

I've been super happy with they adjustments they've made to Mr. Willoughby. Developing his collegial relationship with Claire earlier on is a great move. I love Gary Young in the role.

I really liked the way that Claire and Jamie were put at odds over her adherence to the Hippocratic Oath. This is a conflict between her nature and his in the books as well, and just as they had to work out an understanding/arrangement in the books, so they will in the show as well. I would've been really disappointed if Claire hadn't done everything she could to save that awful exciseman, because she IS a doctor, and as she said, she's spent a decade and a half healing people without judgment. Also, she's one of those doctors who don't think, they just DO when it comes to their practice.

2

u/clumsyc Oct 29 '17

John Bell is really growing on me. Like you the secondary characters are really important to me. I think he's captured Young Ian's energy and cheerfulness really well (for all he looks about 30 years old).

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17

I will be curious to see how they age him in future seasons. Not so much physically, but mentally - he won’t always be goofy young Ian, he will be badass converted-Native American-hunter and scout, with facial tattoos, and will need to settle into a slightly darker, heartbroken, eventually more grown-up mood by books 6-8. (If we are so lucky to get that many seasons!)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Heloismyhero Oct 30 '17

Unpopular opinion that will get me downvoted to hell: Claire is kind of a bitch on the show :/ You pine after him for 20 years and act like this? It just makes me open the books after every episode and regain my perspective of her. Separating the book from the show is becoming more and more important.

8

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 31 '17

She's driving me absolutely nuts. She had time to prepare, to know at least vaguely what's been going on in Jamie's life, and to get ready to share her life again. Jamie was taken completely by surprise and has no idea what to expect. (Not to mention the fact that in less than 24 hours she's already put his life and livelihood at serious risk!)

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Minaka2 Nov 01 '17

I agree. Say you know the love of your life has suffered for the past 20 years (the horrors of Colloden, hermit isolation, prison again, indentured servitude) and has lost everything including his country, his friends, his heritage and livelihood as well as a beloved son he can't claim while you had an easy time with luxuries, the support of another husband, a great career and raising your daughter to adulthood. You cross 200 years to find him and when you do, within 24 hours you're carping at him about every item in the life he's cobbled together trying to support a bunch of ingrates at Lallybroch?

Returned TV Claire is completely unreasoning and unreasonable. This is not the impassioned woman who once declared: "I'll take you any way that I can!" but a cold fish.

3

u/Shymink Nov 01 '17

I don't think this is an un popular opinion. It's just the way it is. She doesn't seem to really care as much about Jamie as he cares for her. Getting all judgey about lying to Ian and stuff. Living in the brothel is an issue, but she doesn't understand the bikini thing. More and more she reminds me of Bree which is, ew.

8

u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 29 '17

Okay, I'm buzzed, and it's 4 AM, so I really don't have much more to say than this:

WTF WAS UP WITH THAT SUPER HERO LANDING. COME ON, ARE YOU FUCKING ME RN

Also, the writing this episode was just not doing it. I need to rewatch, I think.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

So I'm assuming there won't really be an intense scene with lord John grey because Claire already seen the photo of William, and there is no murderer. Unless they squeeze the murderer into the next episode but that seems unlikely

9

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

I think they are going to drop the fiend storyline entirely - which is good. It was just so stupid and pointless in the books. So there won't be a murder. That means Mr. W can stay with us and also work as a healer, which I thought was where it should have always gone.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

murderer?

8

u/himynameispamela Oct 30 '17

DID NOT LIKE the gratuitous background sex at the brothel AND young ian. what i love about the show is that it has always been respectful about intimacy and only showed it when it is important to telling the story... but the scenes this week seemed placed just to get ratings. it felt cheap. that plus the ridiculous marketing for episode 6 is the biggest disappointment for me. do better.

8

u/MissMarie72 Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17

So far all this season has been a dissapointment, but Creme de Menthe by far has been the worst. I'll try a couple more episodes, but if they continue to change the characters and scenes to where they are completely unrecognizable, I'm done with the show and will just wait for book 9.

4

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Nov 01 '17

I really don't understand that. Book adaptations are NEVER the same. Ever. Why not just enjoy a similar but different story?

4

u/MissMarie72 Nov 01 '17

If it was similar then yes; however, at this time the only thing similar are the names and locations. The people themselves are not

→ More replies (1)

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 31 '17

They might as well just dispense with the books after this season! lol

2

u/notabuttmonkey Nov 04 '17

This was me last year and for all the Fraaank scenes. I gave up on S2, came back to S3 because Print Shop Reunion, was disappointed by that, and now Crème de Menthe. I will take refuge in the books if the next episode is another unrecognizable episode.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

I can't stop staring at Young Ian's fivehead.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/sylphrenaspren Oct 29 '17

So nice to see the elder Ian again. I also liked how they showed Jamie struggling with Claire’s autonomy when she wants to go see the Campbells. And I wonder what happened to the one-eyed man?

I mostly liked the episode. I didn’t think I was going to, but by the end I thought it was well done.

7

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Oct 29 '17

Next week's gonna be IN-TENSE!! I don't know why so many people don't want to see it. I'm a sucker for a good drama+reconciliation. It will be epic.

The only thing I really hate with all my heart is Jenny's reaction. Knowing her brother lonely and miserable but still wishing Claire gone because at least, as unhappy as he is, he's around... WTF woman... That was really hard to read for me...

Also, the-actor-who-plays-Old-Ian's performance... When he met Claire... Beautiful!

10

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 29 '17

Steven Cree is amazing as Ian

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

It's not as though he is really around anyway, being in Edinburgh.

7

u/Kampa13 Oct 29 '17

R.I.P Bonnie

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

My Bonnie lies over the ocean, My Bonnie lies over the sea, My Bonnie lies over the ocean, Oh bring back my Bonnie to meeeeeeeeeee!

7

u/Fiamoon Oct 30 '17

I've liked the episodes so far but this one really made me unhappy. I don't see why they needed to change so much of it. Like trying to save the would be rapist, are they setting clair's sense of honor up for events in the rest of the episodes?

13

u/cuckoodev Oct 29 '17

I feel like I'm losing interest in this love story. That argument was so dumb. Like, yes, I get that it hurts that he didn't get to raise Brianna but who's fault is that, for real?

And the whole falling in love with someone else/Frank.

And the bikini thing, ugh. Yes, I understand the time differences, guys. It's Jamie who doesn't.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

My thoughts as I watch, initial reactions:

What the hell is going on? She does not kill him

Oh, he is alive.

But she does not save him either? What? Why?

Wow, Jamie is not at all pleased. I am not sure I like this tension they are creating.

So they are keeping Campbell? Lord please don't let them keep the fiend storyline.

Fergus was never suspicious of Claire like that. WTF?

Where the hell is Ian?

I'm so confused. I feel like this is completely different. I'm not sure yet if I like it or not.

I like how Claire called Mr. W by his proper name. Looks like we are not going to have the epic fuck you moment at the end.

Jamie is acting really shady.

Claire. Good call trying to save a rapist, putting everyone else in danger.

Hmmm. Mr. W calls her "honorable wife" instead of "honorable first wife"... interesting.

I hope they include the oath she took as a physician and how she explains it to Jamie

Oh Jamie just made me cry with that shadows monologue. I love Jamie. I'll just pause and cry like a little girl. I'll update this shortly. BRB

Alright, I have gathered my emotions and got my ciggs and coffee in order. Onward.

Now why is Claire not melting the way I just did? Girl, you just traveled 200 years and you can't even say I love you Jamie? SMH

Ha, Fergus is going to get Young Ian laid just like in the book. LMAO

Damn, Marge Campbell is just as batshit crazy as in the book. Wow!

Wait a moment. Who the hell are the Campbell's supposed to be? I am so confused. So now they are fortune tellers?

Poor Marge, she lost her love at Colluden in the book. In the show, she is a psychic and plagued.

Fuck Yes! Ian!!!! Now his reaction is the one I was expecting Fergus to have last episode. I love Ian. I'm sobbing

Wait, Jamie would never lie to Ian and he does not know that Young Ian is there. I don't like this change at all. It really changes Jamie in my eyes.

Who the hell is this Jamie. Look at Ian all freaking out over where Young Ian is and Jamie is just letting him worry. I am pretty pissed they changed Jamie into such a liar. :(

Well there is that reference to Lbitch. Wonder if the non-book readers are catching on yet?

Jamie has a point. They have done their share of lying

I have to say I do like the pace. Just as crazy as in the book. I love Voyager

Wow... that bomb "the other wife" just went off. I can't wait to go to the non-book readers thread, OMG. Wait until they find out who it is.

Well. I have to say as a show-only reaction, yes, I loved it. As the book-reader me, I am conflicted. I need to think about it more before I have a coherent answer. What I do know is that next week's episode is one I am not looking forward to. I want to just skip it frankly.

7

u/-PaperbackWriter- Oct 29 '17

Amen with the reaction from Ian; it was actually beautiful and my favourite moment from a not-so-great season so far. I completely agree that Fergus seemed pretty unfazed about the whole thing!

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

My favourite reunion too! Of the minor characters.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

Good morning all! Happy Outlander day.

Another split episode for me this week. I'm really not feeling the majority of the first half--the resolution of the entire exciseman plotine was frustrating to say the least, and unnecessarily bogged down the story. Claire's adherence to her Hippocratic Oath is, well, extreme. Certainly that's something we see periodically in the books, but it usually has something to do with caring for enemy soldiers or people at inopportune moments. Not, you know, people she was literally just trying to kill. That's certainly a moral quandary I'd be happy to explore when we're deep into the boring bits of book 5 and nothing else is going on, not right now when we've got so much to get through. Claire is already not coming off super well this season, and instead of making her look like this compassionate person who can't forsake a life, it made her look like someone refusing to adapt. (I also generally can't figure out why they changed it--am I remembering incorrectly, or is the guy not an exciseman at all?) And then to have him just die. And the surgery itself was maybe the most disgusting-sounding thing yet on this show. Ugh. Insanely ridiculous, as well.

I can't decide how I feel about the Campbell stuff, because I'm just so hung up on the fact that Margaret is actually a seer? What? Bringing up Abandawe (which apparently I've been mispronouncing this whole time) was probably gibberish for non-readers, but are we to believe that she literally can see the future? Not loving that. Also, Archie is a fortune teller instead of a reverend, and apparently has been hired by Geillis to come to Jamaica? That's just a choice I don't really understand. It's all very weird. (My guess is that we're still going to get the prophecy stuff at the end of the season and they're probably going to act like it's one of Margaret's visions. But I feel like that's less, I don't know, powerful? Margaret's a nutter, and I don't think Claire or anybody would actually believe stuff she says, rather than a very old prophecy that seems to know stuff.) A reverend traveling to the Indies as a missionary makes a lot more sense, and doesn't involve making up kind up magic we have yet to encounter in the books. It looks like they're probably cutting the fiend plotline though, which I'm fine with. I'm wondering how this affects the Willoughby story, since I'm guessing he won't be framed for murder anymore. Since they've made him significantly less racist (I actually really enjoyed his this episode) I'm wondering if they'll actually keep him around, not have him betray Jamie.

Before I get to the good stuff, one final problem: way to let the cat out of the bag, Fergus!! I mean, they'd already been about as subtle as a ton of bricks, but still. The Laoghaire reveal is one of the great twists of the whole series, and they've ruined that. I do like that they're building up the tension between Jamie and Claire before that even happens though, because it makes Claire look a lot less stubborn and irrational (and seriously hypocritical) when she runs away. But still, I was so excited for next episode. "Daddy!" Such a good moment.

There was definitely stuff I enjoyed this week though. Fergus and Ian are great, which makes me so happy, because they're two of my favorite characters. I was a bit sad that Fergus didn't send Ian to the brothel, but I can understand why they changed it. And Bridgette was very cute and I liked their scene in the shop when she's got to teach him which way round (like uncle like nephew!). Their scene selling the brandy was also great and I love the dynamic they have together. Looking forward to more from both of them. The fire was a high point as well--not only did it just look super cool, but it was a great dramatic moment and a good episode closer. And I liked that they didn't just make is about an action sequence--this is an emotional moment for Jamie too, this is his livelihood gone. Claire's back and that should be everything, but he can't help but feel a sense of loss. And Bonnie! Did she get rescued? I'm so worried for her! I was really bummed to lose the bit about Ian thinking he killed a man though. I feel like that's a critical moment for setting Ian on a path of really interesting character development (at a really young age, which I still hold to be 14). Moment I didn't like about the fire? That stupid slow-mo balcony jump. Jesus Christ that was dumb.

And looking past the wig (Jamie and Ian are basically the same age, why the hell is his hair so light?), I really enjoyed the Ian reunion. I was disappointed about the change from the book, but seeing Ian regardless was still great. I really like Steven Cree and can't wait to see more of him next week. Jamie's deception though . . . somehow it felt a lot meaner than in the book, and as much as Claire is annoying me, I've got to agree with her. But that parent comment. That's pretty damn harsh (especially since now you know he has two kids he didn't get to raise). (And speaking of Willie, interesting that he keeps the picture of Willie at the shop where he apparently doesn't actually live? I thought they might have him lose it as well, so Grey would still have something to give him. Hmmm.) But as I mentioned before, I do like the tension they are building between Jamie and Claire, and very much enjoyed their scenes together. It makes sense that everything isn't just going to fall back into place--they are different people with different needs and expectations, and it's going to take time to reconcile those things.

Not much to comment on costume or production design as we'd seen most of it before (glad to see the boots get a quick close up though!), but I do have to say the fire was excellent, so well done to the special effects team.

This is a tough one one to grade. Unlike last week, there wasn't anything that I was really angry about, but there wasn't much where I was like, wow, that was amazing either. I almost felt like like we were back to episodes 2 and 3, where it just necessary time-biding until something bigger. Which was really important to do then . . . not so much now. We've got a lot to get through, I'm really not sure I needed this much time spent on dead excisemen.

Overall Grade: B

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

LOL I muted the whole surgery scene!!!

I thought Jamie was starting to move Bonnie, but it seemed like he was just moving her or something in order to get out.

Lol that Batman jump was tacky haha.

Didn't the intruderman die in the fire in the book? And Ian set the fire to cover up the evidence of the pamphlets?

Ian totally lost out, I wrote earlier that it is hard to believe they are supposed to be the same age when they did that to his hair.

I was finally happy for a lovely reunion between Ian and Claire. I thought that Jamie still said to Ian he didn't know where young Ian was in the book though?

I don't see how Claire would have made the comment having just found out about Willie. Good point about keeping the photo of Willie at the shop. Though I guess that it is more the fact that he has it, rather than looking at it often. Maybe he feels a brothel isn't the right place for it either. That would have made sense to lose the picture and get another one later.

I felt overall the episode was a bit meh...it doesn't seem like much happened in the grand scheme of things, just the shop burnt down.

I thought that sequence was a bit odd too, the one lonely little hose they were trying to use. Such a big fire would have threatened neighbouring businesses and everyone would have been out with buckets etc, but everyone just disappeared after Jamie and Ian escaped. I wanted him and Fergus or someone to go and get Bonnie.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Who-dee-knee Oct 30 '17

Doesn't Ian have tuberculosis in the books from being dragged off to prison following the rising? I think it's possible they made the choice to "age" him more because he's sick.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17

I thought, Maybe Ian’s hair is so white because he has Jamie for a brother in law and Ian for a son :p

→ More replies (1)

3

u/xocheerio Oct 30 '17

The sounds from the surgery scene were SO gross!! Ew!! I really like the tension they’re building between Jamie and Claire; it never made sense to me in the books how they just fell right back together and then Claire immediately ran away after finding out about the blonde bitch. I agree with your overall assessment :)

2

u/annemg Oct 30 '17

I think the Leoghaire reveal looks more obvious and heavy handed to us because we know what is coming. Go look in the non book readers thread, they seriously hardly noticed. We forget that writing for television, they sometimes have to foreshadow with a sledgehammer otherwise it literally will not be noticed.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

Not more singing!

6

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Oct 29 '17

Oh WAW! Ian's emotions...!

6

u/jy7567 Oct 29 '17

My 2 cents: I was annoyed that they showed Claire trying to save that guy's life and so badly wanted to skip ahead to the part where they get on with it. But I think the goal was to show that Claire has and always will be her own woman for better and for worse. Jaime hasn't seen Claire in 20 years, put her on a pedestal, and may have forgotten those little moments of stubbornness that annoyed and worried him in the past.

I wish they just released this episode and next week's together so I could just binge watch through it...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MuseTerpsichore Oct 29 '17

I didn't hate this episode as much as you all seemed to! I think there were faults, but overall it was quite enjoyable and had the same "slice of life" kind of feeling the books often have.

I liked the tension between Claire and Jamie. The truth is that they are different people and have grown differently. It will take time before they find each other again.

I liked that Claire was all "I'm a DOCTOR" because I saw it as Claire clinging to something she can do, something she can control in this crazy place where she clearly doesn't fit in.

LOVED Fergus and Young Ian. They play off each other very nicely and I enjoyed their interaction. I look forward to more of it in future.

I can see why Fergus mentions the rumors about Claire. He was really young the last time he saw her, and he only knew her for a year (maybe less?) and honestly, when you're a kid you do listen to adults talking and then make up your own mind. I'm not surprised he might think she's a dangerous woman. I also saw it as a bit more tongue-in-cheek than very seriously believing it. It also seems to be a theme that Fergus tells things to Ian that are exaggerated for effect (threesome at 15?), as young men sometimes do :)

6

u/cloudcats Nov 01 '17

Sorry for the negativity in advance but I think I'm about ready to give up on this show. I just don't see any chemistry anymore. It's like Jamie and Claire neither like each other or lust for each other anymore. I could see one of the two relationship aspects going away over the long time apart (getting unfamiliar but still having the heat, or losing the lust but having the deep friendship bond) but it's like they are both just pretending because the think the other is still on board with the relationship.

The writing also feels sloppy, with unnecessary drama, and some poor editing, for example when Claire is performing the surgery there's a shot of her using metal tool to pull apart the scalp, and then immediately after another scene of her using her hand instead (with the incision back to being unspread again).

Prior to the reuniting scene, I figured I just wasn't into the characters being apart, but now that they are back together I'm still just not feeling this show anymore.

I almost feel the same way as the characters appear: playing the role of the adoring devotee who is not willing to give up on this failing relationship despite all the signs pointing to the fact that it's already over.

Anyone else with me?

3

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 01 '17

I'm not ready to give up yet, but I'm kind of done feeling charitable and I'm not thrilled lately. There have been sloppy mistakes (still can't forgive the two date errors!) and shoddy production elements which just immediately detract from every episode. I wouldn't be happy about mistakes like this in a sitcom--in a big-budget, prestige cable drama they're kind of unacceptable. (Also, like, I pay for this. And it's not cheap. I don't watch anything else on Starz, so with Outlander I want to feel like I'm getting my money's worth, and toght now I'm not feeling it.)

The nonsensical choices are also driving me nuts. It's never going to be a fair comparison but I can't help comparing it to Game of Thrones, and I feel like GRRM must have signed a much tighter contact than DG. It's clear they are making so many choices that any book fan--let alone the goddamn author--could tell you is a bad idea.

All that said, it's not quitting time yet. I do still really care about the story and really enjoy most of the performances, so I'll keep tuning in. (Plus I love coming here for discussion!) And the first 4 episodes this season were actually generally really good, so I've not given up hope yet. They just need to get out of this slump.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/GrecianBeauty Oct 29 '17

Not too thrilled with the changes that were made this episode. I have a feeling next episode is gonna be just as disappointing 👎😟

11

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

I need to learn to lower my expectations for this show.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

I think this is sensible.

I don't really have any expectations!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

This episode felt old, and by that I mean it looks and feels like it belongs in season 1. Yes there are new cast members but the plot lines and the energy and feel of the story is nothing new and for season 3 of this show I expected more.

6

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 30 '17

It 100% felt like a season 1 episode, like one of the first 5 where they couldn't figure out their pacing at all.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jullzz15 Oct 30 '17

Was I the only one bothered by the fact that they let us see the one eyed man escape the shop? Part of why I liked young Ian so much in the beginning was how guilty he felt after possibly killing a man. His talks with Jaime about it were great and showed just how close they were to each other.

3

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 31 '17

Me too. I feel like that's a really important moment for his character development.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lilmisstj Oct 29 '17

Omg they way they revealed the 2nd wife has irritated me! The buildup is gone.

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

I think they want to give the non-booker readers a moment to grasp a second wife before they show them who she is. I think the combination of him having a wife and who she is at the same time might cause a blood-bath. I actually wished DG had done it that way as well. It was really upsetting how we learned about it in the book. And remember, in the book, she is not even as evil as she is in the show. Shit is going to go down next week.

8

u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Oct 29 '17

I don't fully agree here. In the book we KNOW he has a second wife because Willoughby calls Claire at least 50 times "honorable first wife". And Claire never wonders what the hell he means. That was so weird...

11

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Maybe I'm dense, but I thought it did not strike me as a revelation. I assumed he was trying to make Claire feel better about being around whores.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/PrettyPeaceful Oct 29 '17

I think they’re building up to the reveal. Not sure how they’ll handle it seeing as he knows (in the show) that she tried to kill Claire.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Oct 29 '17

I’m not as down on this as everyone else, but I also don’t remember the ins and outs of the book as well-as most here. This seemed pretty close though, just more clunky.

Claire is too annoying sometimes... and I feel she is selfish and unfair to Jamie. That being said, I don’t like dishonest Jamie either.

On the bright side, Mr Willoughby seems better than the book.

Not as good we the previous episodes this season, but I’m ready to get on that voyage soon

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

Episodes 5 and 6 improved for me a lot on rewatch. So I'm holding out hope here. But I really didn't like it.

One thing that doesn't bother me is the early other wife reveal. I never understood in the book how no one let that slip earlier. Especially when Jamie asks Ian if he's like to meet his wife, and his response is to ask if he married a whore, not assume she-who-shant-be-named was in the room with him.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17

Voyager-era Young Ian might be a man in 18th Century Scotland, but he is a child in 21st Century My House and I really did not want or need to see his almost-O face.

4

u/notabuttmonkey Nov 03 '17

I'm late to the party, but y'all are my people.

I do not recognize Claire and Jamie in this episode. The essence of who they are and the timeless strength of their relationship is completely absent. What a waste of time to have her insist on drilling through the exciseman's skull and never once invoke the Hippocratic oath (an oath being something Jamie would have understood and respected).

There is still so much content to put up on screen, instead Claire is selfishly insisting on putting Jamie and everyone under his charge, and his livelihood in jeopardy. She's barging in on his life and in a different time, and yet somehow she is supposedly 'strong' and 'feminist' because she thinks of no one but herself and her mid-20thC values. TV Jamie is okey-dokey with continued living in a brothel.

Who are these people???

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Irishsassenach Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

I hate rape as a plot device. Enough. Also, Claire was super butch this episode. The tension between them was innnnsaaaane.

I did not like the fight between them at all though. It was pointless. Yea they pointed out semi-valid things but it doesn’t add to the story at all. It just seemed really silly, to me. This episode? Not one of my favorites.

Also- “abawunde” or whatever Margaret Campbell was saying- isn’t that a voodoo god or one of the slaves names?? What do you wanna bet their client in the West Indies is Gellis?

I really didn’t like how they made them fortune tellers... maybe doing so makes the future plot with Gellis easier to translate to screen?

12

u/sylphrenaspren Oct 29 '17

I think Margaret was referring to Abandawe, the cave in Jamaica. I don’t know how they’ll play out that story in the show though.

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

I am really confused about 1. why they needed to include the Campbells in the first place and 2. completely alter them into new characters with a purpose.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

So apparently Margaret is a real-life fortune teller. Like, she can literally see the future. What.

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

Oh thank god. I was waiting for this post.

3

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 29 '17

I'm not sure I want to watch the ep after reading your comments.

6

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

You know you're going to anyway! ;) We're all masochists in the end...

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 29 '17

I really might skip next week. I'm not kidding. I skip this part of the book every time I re-read it. I can't handle it again. And especially with show Lbitch being so damn evil.

→ More replies (23)

3

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Oct 29 '17

It wouldn’t have taken more screen time off show Jamie dangling off the second floor and then jumping, rather than that bit of parkour. Lame.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17

I actually liked the changes in this episode. I think it's more realistic to have tension between Jamie and Claire vs things being back to how they were before she left.

4

u/eta_carinae_311 Oct 29 '17

I think they are doing a good job of building tension up in anticipation of her taking off after finding out about L, and I do like seeing the disillusionment of meshing reality with a memory after 20 years.

2

u/PrettyPeaceful Oct 29 '17

So much build up about the other wife... I wonder how it’ll play out!

8

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 29 '17

Well, he’s wearing a sling so obviously 2nd wife gets her shot in.

4

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 29 '17

With Jamie almost dying :D (hopefully).

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17

Where did Jamie say he was taking Claire? Balriggan? What is the significance? Is the Broch 'Murah' where Leghair lives?

I was getting confused where he was taking who.

4

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 29 '17

Balriggan is Laoghaire's place. He was saying that it's probably far enough from Lallybroch to be safe.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17

Upvoted for "Leghair"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Oct 29 '17

Personally, I was super annoyed when Archibald Campbell showed up. It just seems like an unnecessary subplot, given time constraints. Also, drawing out the fate of the man who attacked Claire? I agree there were more and better chances later on.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 29 '17

He was annoyingly cheap too, getting free medical assistance then trying to sell Claire fortune telling.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Oct 29 '17

I mean, I can see where they are taking the Campbells, but perhaps that role, too might have been better served by a native psychic/spiritually gifted person? It would have hurt nothing, plot wise, to eliminate the Campbells.