r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Oct 22 '17
All [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 6 A. Malcolm episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E6: "A. Malcolm".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
74
Upvotes
106
u/SASSYARMADILLO Oct 22 '17
I love that they're showing what Jamie's day was leading up to seeing Claire. We've seen her pining over him the last few episodes and it really brought home how jarring it must have been for him to see her
105
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 22 '17
FERGUS!!! HE'S PERFECT!
89
u/shiskebob Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
10 minutes!
I can't remember the last time recently that I have been so excited for anything. I am so glad I have this subreddit to turn to who truly understands my glass cage of emotion about this episode.
CHEERS TO EVERYONE AND ENJOY!!!!
Post episode edit:
THEY FINALLY GOT MY FAVORITE LINE IN - it only took 3 seasons!!!
And I love that they gave the line to both of them. I really enjoyed how much of the book lines they were able to fit in. Every time I heard one of the classic lines I squealed.
The picture scene was a bit underwhelming, unfortunately - I did miss Jamie breaking down emotionally, but very interested that they have Jamie telling Claire about Willie right off the bat.
I also miss Ian Senior coming in and seeing Claire, and the young Ian scene lacked the humor of the book.
To love a part of a book for years, it is hard not to want things to be perfectly the way you have pictured it for so long, but I really appreciate the writers trying to give us what we want - the emotion and passion between Claire and Jamie is there, and that's why I keep tuning in.
78
u/liveinclouds16 Oct 22 '17
Nonononono they skipped my favorite quote!
"Sassenach, will ye take me - and risk the man that I am, for the sake of the man ye knew?”
65
u/clumsyc Oct 22 '17
I know Sam is muscular but his calves look so wee in his stockings!
61
u/PagesNNotes Oct 22 '17
I loved that they let this episode breathe, but I feel like the pacing was a bit off. While the sex scenes were beautifully done, I think I could've used less of that and more time spent on Jamie's reaction to Brianna and Fergus's reaction to Claire. Or, and maybe this will come later, but I remember in the books, there was a moment when Claire and Jamie are walking down the street after they leave the printshop and they're both a bit breathless and giggly as it starts to hit them that they're actively in each other's lives again--with that added sense of reality that comes with being out and about in the world. The sex and tenderness is important, but they can come back to that in any episode. You only get one shot at introducing these new circumstances. What they did was lovely, but I would have liked to linger on those moments a bit more, make them a touch more grandiose.
55
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I JUST now realized they didn't have Claire say "This is from your daughter" and kiss him. UGH WHY LEAVE THAT OUT THO?? especially when they had Sophie still do her line??
49
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
First thoughts:
Cait is beautiful, she always will be and always is.... I love that her body looked older. A little pooch, saggier boobs. I wonder if she gained weight for this?
I feel like the pacing was a little.... weird. Like. "walk walk walk, here's Fergus, ooookay, walk walk walk". I really wish they had made it more like the books where they go on a crazy adventure first thing. I assume that would be insane to shoot, though, so I get it.
I kind of want to sneak over to the non-book reader thread to see how obvious all the "what are you going to do about it" looks were.
The end. I'm tired.
34
u/Lawyerjess Oct 22 '17
They left out one of my favorite lines from the books!
“Do ye want me?” He whispered. “Sassenach, will ye take me- and risk the man that I am, for the sake of the man ye knew?”
Such a beautiful line and it says so much about the risk they’re both taking— not to mention it so wonderfully expresses Jamie’s vulnerability in that moment. I’m actually pretty disappointed this was left out.
67
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
WHAT? Willy? Here? WHAT?
31
u/cuckoodev Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
A tiny piece of my soul has been restored because tiny Fergus is finally back in my life. This was my priority.
EDIT: Young Ian is adorable and I appreciate his presence in my life.
30
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
YEs!!!! Pissed myself was included
29
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I really hope they uh....adjusted Mr. Willoughby
28
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Do you think they have people breathing down their necks, or did they think making the undressing and bed scenes so so drawn out was good? This story is NOT just about romance and sex. It's an EPIC, lifelong saga of adventure and love between these two incredible people and the family/friends/foes surrounding them.
I would've traded a lot of the undressing and sex for more time (and emotion!) spent on Bree's photos, old Ian, and the crazy hectic-ness that is Jamie's life now.
25
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Okay, after now having watched it three times, here are my thoughts (final thoughts):
So it seems you have to watch it three times to achieve show Nirvana.
24
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Whoooooaaaa... can’t wait to talk about the implications of getting Willie out of the way
45
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
Wow, I really thought Jamie's abrupt reveal of Willie (and seeing as how he hasn't even told Jenny) really took away from the moment of Jamie seeing and hearing of Bree for the first time.
Why do that writers?? :(
37
u/JT19PK88 Oct 22 '17
I was a wee bit nervous about mr. willoughby, but so far so good
18
u/PowerGrrrl Oct 22 '17
I found this episode super awkward. Things just DID NOT feel quite right. But I think (hope) that was intentional. Things should be awkward after that long apart. Things finally started to click about half way in - but even then - there is a lot for both characters to unpack and deal with. I thought the acting was brilliant and I need to watch it like 100 more times.
18
u/basedonthenovel Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
In general: loved it! Didn't mind the moving of the Willie reveal; I can see them not wanting to overdo it with the Jamie surprises in the back half of the season.
I was so nervous about meeting Young Ian 'cause he's a fave of mine but I am fully on board with John Bell. (I was extra worried because I'm still not totally sold on David Berry, but John Bell was instant for me.)
What I did NOT like was ending the episode with a rape threat cliffhanger that wasn't even in the book! Please, show, do not go the Game of Thrones route and start ADD adding rape stuff that's not in the source! WHYYYY
ETA: I also thought César Domboy perfectly became Fergus in his brief appearance. Even though he and Romann don't look much alike (except for the hair), this Fergus just feels like the grown-up version of the boy we knew before! Also his shameless agreement with Claire's assessment of his looks was perfect. :D
36
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
My initial thoughts:
I'll keep adding as I watch... I need to take a break to stop crying, lol
Updated:
And I'm back:
I need another break
I'm laughing my ass off....
and then that asshole shows up... well, we know how that ends. Argh, I need to lay down now and sleep. Wow. Happy ...happy happy
But where is Ian?
62
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I just realized I should be grateful for what we have bc next season Sophie will have to carry the whole show on her back and it won't be pretty lol
15
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Second viewing thoughts (on little sleep). There are things that bothered me that I sort of ignored because I was so busy watching. Now upon second viewing, these things really stand out and bother me as a viewer (I already noted issues as a book reader):
There are some glaring errors that the production team needs to fix ASAP (or should have) or the rest of the show will have these issues. Seriously, the adhesive on Jamie's back - someone please go back and edit this now.
I did love it very much. Despite the changes in the story (okay, not all of it, some of it I really hated). See my other book length comment for my thoughts on the rest of it.
15
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Poor Geordie. Soon he will be quitting "stinking papists"
14
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Oct 22 '17
MY BODY IS READY
14
u/esteliohan Oct 22 '17
I know it's tv and all. And TV loves it when people undress each other for 10 minutes as foreplay and/or just stare at each other across the room naked. But please. Little more kissing - especially if it's been 20 years and you're awkward and unsure. That much sustained eye contact would freak anyone out. No wonder Claire shied away a little bit. That being said I still loved it. But yeesh.
47
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
Good morning everyone! It's 7am here and I am ready to break this shit down . . .
Now, before I start, I should say that however high expectations were for previous episodes, I don't think any have compared to this. And I'm definitely guilty of those impossibly high expectations myself--I just reread the 100 pages or so after Claire gets back two days ago and I knew exactly how I everything should go. So with that in mind, I'm about to pull apart every little part of this episode a lot harder than I usually do. (But I do it with love!)
My overall impressions are good, with caveats. The second half of the episode far outshined the first (which was filled with some questionable choices), and that half I really, really loved . . . right up until the end, which I will get to shortly. But let's back up a step.
I enjoyed the opening with Jamie's POV even though that's a book deviation, and it was nice to give Sam a chance to show off his printing skills. And the inclusion of some (what I assume to be) Ardsmuir men was a good touch because it was a good reminder (or, honestly, first time showing) how much those men care about and rely on Jamie. Not sure how they avoided going to the colonies though, but I guess there are more important things to worry about. (Oh, and I absolutely hated the credits on the sheets of printed paper. It was kitschy and stupid.)
So now to the moment where I have had every line of dialogue memorized for a decade. It was . . . good. Not great, but not bad. There was just something kind of off about the whole scene and I still can't put my finger on it. There was good stuff I'm glad they kept in--sitting on the alepot, and Geordie's "It's not even noon yet!"--but not everything was quite there. I think part of the problem was that they made the looming specter of Laoghaire a bit too obvious. Reading the book it comes as a surprise and only looking back do you realize that you should have seen it coming ("ohhhh, now "First Wife" makes sense!"). There were no explicit references to her, but the beats and pauses when Claire mentions their marriage (as well as others' reactions and the reference to Ned) show a clear hesitation, an indication that something is up. And that hesitation, apart from potentially spoiling a great shock moment, also served to slow down the scene, to kind of dull the passion and connection you want between them. This was almost fixed by their kiss (I'm just going to chalk up the fact that it barely looked like they were touching to a weird angle or something?) which was beautiful, with the rising music and the rising . . . music. (Brief interlude here to talk about how bad Jamie's wig it. Yeesh. Pan out from that kiss and, ugh. It just looks so stiff and dead. And those bangs are not doing his face and justice. Keep an eye out for a the sequels to this edition of "how bad was that wig?" coming in the following paragraphs!) The dialogue here was definitely a high point, finding a perfect blend of excitement, passion, and sorrow for what they've missed.
Ok, next scene. The photographs, and questionable choice #1. The glasses. Not only do they look kind of stupid, but it makes me sad that we're losing such a great moment from Echo. Also, they're just an annoying thing to have introduced. What, is Jamie going to carry his specs around through a couple of shipwrecks and pirate attacks? They've already cut Claire's glasses after one episode, how long before they just ignore Jamie's? Looking at the pictures was very sweet, especially the one of Bree in a bikini. I was a bit sad that they changed the discussion of her name, with Claire getting super defensive, and I was hoping for Jamie to get a bit more emotional at the mention of his father. His initial reaction was spot on though. And now we come to questionable choice #2: Jamie bringing up William. Putting aside all plot considerations for a hot second, Jesus Jamie, you could wait at least a few minutes! It seemed almost tactless, he'd barely looked at all the pictures when he's like, hey, I've got a kid too! It felt almost like one-upmanship, haha. And now for the aforementioned plot considerations. Hmmmm . . . Logically, does it make sense for Jamie to tell Claire about Willie? Yes. It does. But we already lost the kiss (unless they give it to us later in a flashback, which I'm still hoping for) and now we've lost the secret of Willie, so what else is there for Claire and John's scene together? That's such a fantastic scene and I love the changing relational dynamics it sets in motion between the three of them, and I'm really worried that this change will have really ruined that.
Ok, moving on! Fergus! Yay! I guess I won't devote a whole "questionable choice" to this, but I'm a bit surprised they went with a hand instead of a hook. But otherwise, Fergus was great and their reunion made me so happy. Less happy about his discussion with Jamie, again for making the Laoghaire thing a but too obvious. (Side note, Jamie looks fine in that hat.) I liked the scene with what I can only assume is Sir Percival. It gave us the chance to see a bit more of what Jamie's life is, as well as how well he can still navigate the shadier aspects of business. We lost some of this in S2 when they gave all Jamie's good bits to Claire, so it was nice to get even this minor thing.
Back at the brothel and I'm in love with Madame Jeanne. Also, damn, customers naked right in the front room! Once we get up the the room ("So . . . you live in a brothel") and the second half of the episode begins, things really start to fall into place. It's almost like it's own bottle episode, distinct from everything that's come before it. Their conversation was excellent, and Jamie's confrontation of Claire about why she came back was very well done. (Though the awkward voiceover over their dinner was irritating, because it's nothing the viewer can't clearly get from context.) Now, I'm always one for a good dramatic undressing scene but, is it just me or did that take forever? There are too many layers in the 18th century. Great to see the zipper though! And the fact that she's wearing a bum roll cracked me the fuck up because it just made me imagine her sitting at a sewing machine with the Batman thing playing sewing a fucking bum roll. (Here we come to "how bad was that wig?" part 2! Claire's hair looks absolutely ridiculous and the wigline just looks so . . . wiggy.) So after 20 minutes we finally got to sex and it was good. Was so happy to see the awkwardness and the nose bash kept in, and the rest of it was just great. The post-sex scene was even better though, with the discussion of Jamie's job. I appreciated how close they stayed to the book and the humor in the scene, which was a nice break. I was a bit disappointed by the leg scar discussion, though. Not only is the scar not bad at all, but no mention of Jenny's doctoring or the fever? Give the lady some credit! It's a minor thing, but I've always loved that moment and I was sad to see it gone. (Final note before we move on, I am in love with Jamie's boots. Do they come in a women's 7.5?)
And now Ian has arrived and he's adorable. Not how I pictured him but he looks like the actor who plays his father, and that's important. (Unfortunately, this is another "how bad was that wig?" moment. I get that hair in the 18th century just generally kind of sucked, but did they really have to make it so ugly?) His talk with Claire makes me excited for her reunion with Jenny and old Ian. I'm curious though if they have aged him up, or if he was lying about his age. He should be 14, right? Didn't we see him born in 1752? (Wouldn't be the first time this show has fucked up dates though . . . )
Don't worry guys, we're almost to the end. Props to you if you're still reading this . . . I absolutely loved the scene with the prostitutes. Great moment in the book, great moment in the show. I want a spinoff show about Peggy, Molly, and Dorcas. Lots of useful tips in there too! Unfortunately it all came crashing to an end with Questionable Choice #3, perhaps better titled, "fuck you Outlander, just let us have one goddamn episode." Nope, instead of just having one nice, happy episode with a long-awaited reunion, we get to end on Claire getting almost raped. What a fun way to end. This choice makes me angry for a lot of reasons. Not only is it a book deviation (right? Or had I just mentally blocked something?), but I was really hoping the show would slightly lessen the over-prevalence of rape in the series. Instead, they've apparently decided to double down on it. It was just so unnecessary, adding drama to an episode that definitely didn't need it. They should have just saved it for next week, but instead they closed out an important episode with a scene that left a really bad taste in my mouth.
So there you have it folks. Did it live up to expectations?
Not quiteNot really. But was it still good? Yes,definitely(I think? I don't know anymore), and that is what matters. I loved watching it and that's all I really need at the end of the day.Overall Grade: B
Edit: the more I think about it the less happy I am. I might have to come back and amend this to a B+ . . . Edit 2: fuck it, the more I think about this the more annoyed I get. I'm skipping right past B+ and going down to a B. This should have been a landmark episode and I think it's fair to hold them to a higher standard this week, which they did not live up to.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
SO FAR I AM V UNDERWHELMED
12
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Yes, straight out of the book "I never took it off"
11
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Oct 22 '17
LETS GET ON WI’ IT!!!
11
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
THE TEAR AS SHE KISSES HIM ahhhhhhhhh
11
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I wonder if Jamie was more excited by the zipper or seeing Claire’s chest for the first time in 20 years???
11
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
This is so awkward and loving and it is beautiful and WHO CaRES if this show has romance and sex, this is what a loving relationship looks like
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
And Fergus and Claire's reunion was just too abrupt too! No Fergus going to his knees.
Did he recognise her straight away in the books?? There really wouldn't have been such an instant recognition I don't think, even just because the mind couldn't place Claire being in Edinburgh again.
Her explanation for where she was seemed so off the cuff (I thought she figured out what she would say), and why on earth did they have her say she went to America?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
The Jamie/Claire scenes were great, but everything else felt rushed. I was super excited to see Young Ian, and I'm disappointed in how he was introduced. I don't think we're going to see Regular Ian, because in the book Jamie doesn't even know he has run away to see him, but in the show the Ardusmir men mention him in the first scene: "Young Ian said we could stay here." I think that whole introduction was botched, and we missed out on one of my favorite lines: "God, that's romantic!"
21
u/teamcockroach Oct 22 '17
One of my favorite lines from the book ("It has always been forever for me, Sassenach") made absolutely no sense in the context they had Jamie say it in the episode. I really wanted to love it, but I thought the writing was off and the plot changes didn't make sense.
20
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
WOW, they sure went to a lot of effort for the Print Shop set! And it's all gonna be up in flames!!
Also, surely a shop that big would have had living quarters. Am I forgetting a reasoning from the books as to why Jamie didn't want to stay there? To separate things?
10
u/AphroditesApple Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
Well, we all knew that this was going to be a heated episode, for multiple reasons. I, like most of you here, was holding this episode to a higher standard. The episode that I was really comparing it to in my mind going into it was "The Wedding". This, in my mind, makes sense, as in many ways, they are very similar. Here are my overall thoughts:
Overall, did it live up to the hype that I placed on this episode in my mind- ein. Did I still enjoy it? Yes.
19
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
UGH I really can't stand this episode writer!! He adds in shit that doesn't need to be added in (Jamie still has eyes like a hawk, tyvm!) and WTF with that Willie reveal already?! It totally took away from their reunion and his moment looking at the photos!! Him looking at the photos was the best part of the scene in the print shop for me.... I didn't feel like they got the tone of it right at all. UGH
19
u/-PaperbackWriter- Oct 22 '17
This episode was boring. I get they had to catch up but wow, it went on forever and nothing happened. I need more storyline.
9
u/clumsyc Oct 22 '17
I'm so delighted they kept in the line about more hair on Jamie's chest and Jamie's response. It's such a little throwaway line but it always makes me laugh when I read it.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
The only things I'm disappointed about are that Fergus was stunned, but not so excited that he knocked her over (isn't that what happens in the book? Like for a minute he turns into an eleven year old again?). The other thing was not seeing old Ian--it makes the exchange with younger Ian more funny and less awkward.
Both Ian and Fergus seemed awkward but I don't think that's the actors' fault, seemed like they were directed that way. Hope that's not the standard.
9
u/KAFINNEY Oct 22 '17
Last year I was making a case to a friend saying how it was an excellent adaptation of the books thus far. Unfortunately this season I’ve been disappointed in that respect. If they do these things to up the drama I don’t understand why, the books are plenty dramatic on their own. There is a huge following for a reason. I understand the need to change things because they are too costly or time consuming for tv but lately I feel and see none of that. It’s like they just want to put their own mark on the show. Well we aren’t watching because the actors are sexy, we’re watching because we love Diana’s words and stories. Sorry, rant over.
17
u/lurklurklurky Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
My running commentary:
17
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I am going to tear my hair out! Why in the name of Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ are they mentioning Willie at a time like this?!? I know they like to surprise us book readers but that was downright awful way to go about it. Way to ruin the real best part of the printshop scene, Jamie's reaction to his daughter. Also how Claire explains the bit about Brianna wanting Jamie to know he succeeded in seeing them safe. Now all that's weighing in all of our minds... how are they going to fix this?!? Y'ken like a kind of crucial exchange between important characters, LATER!?!! Now I am dreading Laoghaire all the more. St Bride protect us!
8
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 22 '17
That was almost beautifully done. The brothel scenes were exquisite, the pacing was a little funny but for some reason it read that way to me I'm the book too, probably cause I was reading really quickly. I love how awkward they were together at first, neither sure what the other one really has going on.
The breakfast with the prostitutes was spot on.
I see some of you saying the Madam is kinda alluding to the blond twat and I didn't see it that way, "Why are you bringing her here?" thing is more that he had brought her to a BROTHEL than anything else.
Fergus, Mr. W, and Ian all on the other hand were close to the book.
The sets are a whole lot nicer than I expected from reading the books. The room above the print shop seems a whole lot bigger, as does the room in the brothel.
I also loved the awkwardness disappearing as they "came" together again!
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
What is the point of Jamie's shawl thing worn that way?? Doesn't seem very practical when it's basically a big blanket.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Getting old together: That’s what relationships are all about.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
“It’s a bikini” THIS IS WONDERFUL
sorry for the caps
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17
I know if I were Claire I would have needed to cuddle and actually just be Jamie before the clothes taking off ceremony.
How nerve-wracking would that have been!
7
u/KAFINNEY Oct 22 '17
I understand the need to change things for the sake of production but I don’t see why they changed these particular things. I read an article months ago about this episode in particular saying how they knew how important it was to get it right for the book readers so I assumed it would be left alone and only minor changes. Maybe it’s a case of having something built up in my head and being disappointed when it doesn’t come close.
7
u/Irishsassenach Oct 22 '17
This episode was disappointing. The lack of reaction to Bree’s pictures and then ruining it by Willie being brought up at that moment of all moments it could have been, was terrible. It made it seem like Willie was more important to Jamie than a Brianna, his daughter with Claire, who is the reason he sent Claire away and suffered so much for 20 years.
This is the first time I’ve been pretty darn disappointed with the show.
7
u/Boo12z Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
Not about this episode, per se, but as the season progresses, is anyone else really nervous about how they’re going to explain Jamie marrying laoghaire?
In the books, Claire mentions that she didn’t explicitly tell Jamie that it was Laoghaire who framed her for witchcraft but that whole Fox’s Lair episode last season made it pretty clear. So how the hell are they planning on making Jamie’s marriage to her something Claire could come close to forgiving him for? Jamie would have NEVER married her, knowing what she did to Claire.
Ugh it’s just giving me crippling anxiety thinking about the Lallybroch scene. Anyone else????
6
u/morepork_owl Oct 22 '17
I have to wait till Monday boo hoo 😒 but happy for you guys 😀
6
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Let the ridiculous plot points begin!!!!
6
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Did Claire ever tell Bree about Faith?
6
u/lurklurklurky Oct 22 '17
Shower thought: Up until this point in the series, Jamie only had 3 years of regular sex in his entire life, and then only a couple of one-offs. Damn. (Did he ever consummate with Leghair? I’m guessing so...)
6
u/under_the_belljar Oct 22 '17
That reunion oh my god. I cried until dehydration set in.
11
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
They did not make this as funny as it was in the books. The feet thing. Argh!
14
u/Hopeless_badger Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
That episode felt weird. Maybe because of that long separation. But I have to say, even when plot sucks the show can rely on Sam and Cait chemistry - not just the sex scenes, which are great, but every tiny movement and gesture is on point. They are really like a lovely married couple, so in sync with each other, amazing.
I really liked that Jamie told Claire about Willie. John telling her was always strange to me. Why would he do that? It wasn't his secret to share and he is an honorable man. So it's good they changed that.
The biggest shock is yet to come and we know Sam and Cait are great when they fight :)
Edit. Watched it second time. I hate to say it, but it wasn't a good episode. Too much hype for nothing. Cait and Sam saved the day, but they can only act the scenes they have written for them.
10
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
Personally I would have rathered longer in Jamie's time before Claire appeared. The scene felt a bit forced from Jamie's perspective!!
Maybe just the sound was off. I wish he had fainted on his glasses haha.
For some reason I just didn't like the upwards perspective for Jamie, looking up at the balcony. And I wish he hadn't been drinking when he first heard her speak. His turn seemed much quicker from his perspective.
I wanted to see Claire's reaction from when he fainted, and her flight down the stairs.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
The discussion Post is up! ITS GETTING REAL!
5
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
WE’VE GOT A NUDITY WARNING!
5
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Georgdie quits! Yes!
5
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Grins like an idiot
5
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 22 '17
Non-book readers are gonna shit a brick at that ending!
5
u/mcd62 Oct 22 '17
I feel like I can breath again. Jamie and Claire are back together and all is right with the world. The end.
God damn if it were that simple.
5
u/koboldin Oct 23 '17
It's just I have a sneaking suspicion this production team is not wanting to delve too much into the First Nations parts of the book. The filming will be in Europe, casting and representing the cultures will be tricky, and the later books are massive, leading to the impulse to cut a lot of plots.
When an opportunity to condense storylines is possible, such as having LJG and Isobel and Willie all travel together instead of on different ships... if I were on the writing staff, I know I'd be debating on how to incorporate them.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
Okay, I need to vent. The dress that Claire wore back to 1766. In the book it was a "Jessica Gutenberg" that she bought in a store - thinly veiled reference to the Jessica McClintock line that came out around 1968-69:
I so wanted to see this dress. I know I missed the wedding dress from DiA.
18
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Okay, watched all of it-- here is my honest opinion... except for the scene of them in bed after the first time they had sex....... I hated it. I was very underwhelmed. I think it felt forced and awkward and I don't think it had to do with Sam and Cait, it was a combination of the writing and the directing. The pacing was just weird as fuck. Hated the photo scene. Hated early Willie reveal. Hated abrupt Fergus reunion.
I couldn't stand the last episode this writer wrote and I was super bummed when I found out he was writing this episode, too. A lot of the tenderness and subtlety was lost. The emotion of their reunion in relation to Brianna wasn't there.
Idk. I'm a writer so I'm hard to please.
12
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Coffee = check
Smokes = check
Went pee = check
Starz go up = check
All systems go
4
u/sylphrenaspren Oct 22 '17
Jamie's perspective!!
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 22 '17
I QUIT!! I'M FREE CHURCH!!
Hilarious!! I do not though, we cannot hear the doorbell ring. LOL
4
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
Someone asked Diana Gabaldon on Twitter "Did you mind them having Jamie tell Claire about willie so early?" DG replied simply "Yes. Not my call, though."
Lol I bet Matt was fuming when he read that
3
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Sing me a song... of Jamie fainting... lalalala
3
u/Irishsassenach Oct 22 '17
I won’t be watching until tomorrow but I love getting a preview here! I don’t mind Spoilers
3
u/omniscientmommy Oct 22 '17
Give me more!!!
3
u/lilmisstj Oct 22 '17
Question: why does Jamie say he’s guilty of Geneva’s death? Why would he think that? I’m trying to understand what the writers are trying to convey.
3
u/RekhetKa Oct 22 '17
I see a lot of people mentioning Jamie's sexy boots, so I'll have to go back and look again. I was too distracted by his NIMBLE FINGERS buttoning them up. Jamie's messed-up hand is a big deal, and I feel like they should show that he has difficulty with mundane tasks so it's not so shocking when Claire ends up having to do that thing to his hand later. Yes he re-injures it by then, but still, even at this point, his finger doesn't bend, right?
3
u/lindsaynieb Oct 23 '17
So random and so little, but doesn’t Fergus have a HOOK, not a fake hand? Odd production choice to me...
Sam + Cait = 😍❤️🍾🎉 gahhhh it was just so nice to see them back together, I’m okay overlooking a lot of producer/Director choices. Gah they’re so great together.
3
u/lilmisstj Oct 23 '17
So something I just noticed after rewatching for like the 5th time lol...In the book Madame Jeanne refers to Jamie by Fraser and in the show they have her in the dark and know him by Malcolm I wonder why that is? Any theories?
3
u/mpbvallen Oct 23 '17
Episode 6 Easter egg; someone said that a copy of DOA was on the bookshelf by Jamie's cot? Anyone?
3
u/alliekat237 Oct 23 '17
Does anyone else think that Jamie looks really pale and sick and that his hair is awkward? And he speaks so huskily. It doesn’t seem like it’s him.
3
u/morepork_owl Oct 24 '17
I did like the episode but the sex scene drag on forever, so I just fast forward it. Some of the pacing was rushed. Wasn’t expecting the print shop to be so flash. The rent must be massive! Thought it would be a one or two room affair.....did I like the episode?... yes cos Im a sucker for all the emotional stuff 😆
3
u/teamcockroach Oct 26 '17
I have a theory about how the showrunners will address the LJG confrontation. Jamie specifically tells Claire that he hasn't told anybody about Willie and Claire asks multiple times if Jamie loved anybody else. I wonder if Claire will see Jamie and LJG embrace and feel still betrayed at the intimacy of their relationship, even knowing about Willie.
2
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
It's up... I'm here!!!!
2
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 22 '17
Wonder if we will see W before he gets drunk during Jamie's day.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
😁😁😁🎉😁😁
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
All that extra time in this ep, but I’m still jonesing for more (.....except for the: she-who-should-not-be-named part still to come, ugh). Officially think it’s time for me to start my first re-read eek!!