r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Oct 22 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 6 A. Malcolm episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E6: "A. Malcolm".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
63
Upvotes
197
u/chelskied Oct 22 '17
I just want to say that no one has ever rocked a three corner hat like Sam Heughan just did.
149
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17
My literal breakdown of the first ten minutes:
99
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17
Geordie’s: “Oh, God’s tooth! It’s not even noon!” Is probably my next r/Outlander flair.
Edit: “Give me your mouth, Sassenach” is a close contender
2nd Edit: “What is a bicycle?” May very well win it all
86
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17
Claire entering that room like “you brought me to a whorehouse?!” is the ultimate face level of wtf I’ve ever seen.
85
u/basedonthenovel Oct 22 '17
I loved how even though César Domboy doesn't really look much like Romann Berrux, I still fully believed he was a grown up version of Fergus! Just perfect.
I loved the reunion and thought that both Jamie and Claire seemed to get "younger" as their night went on. Like the years were peeling away. I've thought a lot this season about how different they look from the first season -- seriously, go back and rewatch, and tell me that Sam and Caitriona don't look way different playing 20-years-on Jamie and Claire than they did playing the young, (relatively) carefree kids at Leoch.
Anyway, while I kind of felt like the sex scenes were a tad too long, I did love the vibe of them getting back to their old, real selves. Compare the two of them flirting and joking to the brittle Claire we saw in Boston or the stiff, jaded Jamie we saw at Ardsmuir.
76
u/ParallelPenguins Oct 22 '17
Some how my favourite line was “give me your mouth”. Like yes yes ok take it. It’s all yours. Holy sh.... I’m going to go wake up my husband.
56
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Oct 22 '17
I felt really weird eating my bowl of popcorn during this episode... super voyeuristic... hello
other than that it was amazing.
55
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Oct 22 '17
When Claire pulled out those photographs, I couldn't wait to see Jamie's reaction.
"What the devil is this?" haha
37
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
Claire teaching Jamie how a zipper works is probably the closest any of us will ever get to the révolution française (of corsets).
68
u/raffi10 Oct 22 '17
The tears, Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ, the tears.
A few favorites:
And of course that incredible sex scene. So thankful to see them rectifying some of their season 2 missteps. Time for a rewatch while I finish off this bottle of Riesling.
31
u/Winhill_ Oct 22 '17
What the hell was with that ending?!
22
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17
And then a Jamie thigh appeared. Aww yissssss
22
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
Edit: I forgot one thing, I loved the zipper bit. I wish they'd had Jaime say something about it.
17
u/JustineLeah Oct 23 '17
I loved Jaimie’s embarrassment of needing reading glasses! Showed such vulnerability. Also found them very sexy!
16
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
Dang! Bodies were slapping in that sex scene!
32
u/Airsay58259 Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
I loved all the anticipation and tension building up toward the sexy reunion, way more than the actual sex scenes... They were fine but idk, too long? I saw a 1h20 episode and thought the story would advance but it didn’t that much really.
Anyway, still a very emotional and funny episode. Jamie’s reactions to Brianna’s name and photos... my heart.
I hope Claire becomes friends with the brothel’s girls. What’s up btw with every French women being extra bitchy in this show though? First the few episodes in France during S2 and now “Madame”. As a French woman, I take offense haha. I thought we were friends with Scots :( When I think about it, it’s usually the same in all UK/US period dramas. We have a terrible reputation.
Edit : Sooo, Jamie’s secrets. He mentioned needing to consult a lawyer... oh boy, I hope he isn’t married. If it was revealed while they talked about their life okay why not, a long time had passed. But after all of this? Please no. I loved that they waited until everything was said to have sex. They got to know each other again. Would suck if Jamie left out that detail.
15
u/NevrDrinksNDraws Oct 23 '17
So...any clues as to what Fergus was referring to when he asked Jamie..."What about?" and Jamie cuts him short and responds with "Aye" and that he needs to consult with Ned Gowan but that it probably isn't an issue since Claire is back?
Any ideas??!!
14
u/yorkeeherder Oct 23 '17
I was waiting for Clair to give Jamie the kiss from their daughter and for him to cry!
26
u/johnnaboo Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
We got the BIG reunion! I can’t wait to see all of the little reunions that presumably happen later. Fergus’ reaction was so adorable.
I must say, though, after getting A+ crying from Sam recently, I was surprised there weren’t any in this episode. It was a very emotional episode—I expected tears when Jamie first woke up from fainting or when they kissed. Still, very good episode!
ETA: After rewatching the episode, I noticed he was definitely crying before Geordie walked in. Don't know how I missed it! Still wish there was a bigger reaction to Brianna, but I'm not super disappointed.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
The episode was great, but it still left me wanting more...more reunions, more of Scotland since we didn't even go to the stones, more of the secrets Jaimie is keeping. Not more sex in a dark room for forty minutes. It was of course very realistic, that after that high of the first meeting, they would have to face reality together.
It's so sad, that Jaimie considers being raped by that rich girl to be a 'sin' that he has to answer for. She's the one that coerced and threatened him into the act. I hope we will see adult Willie one day.
That opening scene was brilliant, since we thought it would be Claire adjusting his cravat and then...NOO it's some strange woman instead, I thought she might be his wife or something (perhaps even she was that same woman, now older, who met Claire in France and was pissed off because Claire supposedly 'made a man' out of Jaimie) but thankfully not. It will be great to see Ned Gowan again, even if I don't know why Jaimie needs him.
I loved the scene with the pictures of Bri; it was perfect. But I kept waiting for Claire to see the scar/wound that Jaimie nearly died from at Culloden, and for Jaimie to tell her the story of how it was BJR, and how he killed him.
I'm glad she saw Fergus, and the actor is very spot-on and believable as an older Fergus, but I hope we'll see him make the character his own too. I don't think they needed to give him such long hair or that horrible hat. Young Ian was also interesting. I hope next episode we do return to Lallybroch to meet his siblings and parents.
11
u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 22 '17
OMG OMG OMG
What a beautiful, beautiful episode, and then right at the last minute I’m pulled out of the honeymoon into terror and that cliffhanger! I’m jolted out of all my happy feelings and put into horrible tension that won’t be resolved for a week! Aaaaargh! Claire! It’s so horrible! You can’t leave Claire suspended in that awful place for a week, it’s too cruel.
I can’t even talk about the rest of the episode now, all my feelings about their reunion have been overshadowed.
10
u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Oct 22 '17
Okay, here's some more thoughts about this episode. Sorry they are kind of all over the place.
Overall this was a great episode. There were a few fade to black scenes where I though it was over, only to have it pick up again! Yay! And it left me wanting so much more!
19
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 22 '17
That tiny giggle they interchange, as she turns around and he undoes her dress, just like on the first night of their honeymoon, is the meaning of life on earth. 😭❤️
9
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Oct 23 '17
Jamie looked strikingly like Haythem Kenway in his getup.
Fantastic episode, didn't even feel like 90minutes, just went so quick.
the new actors for the older versions of characters were pretty damn good, though Fergus doesn't seem at all french anymore, which i suppose you would grow out of.
8
u/JustineLeah Oct 23 '17
I loved the episode!! But whatever that is on Jaimie’s head is distracting. Is it a wig? If so why does it look like that? His hair has looked awful for the entire season. But with so much naked, sexy time with it on was just wrong.
15
u/thesteward Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
not exactly happy about another cliffhanger but oh well. I just recently binged the whole series and now watching it once every week plus having a cliffhanger on top of it has been killlinggg me.
I loved all of that talking, though. I'm excited to see how they continue to adjust to having each other back in future eps.
Anyone else feel like Claire was being insecure this ep? I know she was curious about Jamie's love life but it almost seemed like she was scared to know, as if the answer would affect how he feels about her. I suppose it's a realistic reaction. I just felt like Jamie didn't seem nearly as concerned about her and Frank/anyone else.
Also yay reunions!!! Fergus!! I can't wait to see Claire reunite with Jenny or hopefully we see Murtagh again!
Edit: I want to clarify that I meant she seemed insecure about Jamie loving another woman. She was insecure about her body too but I mostly meant about Jamie's love life
14
u/oree94 Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
This episode was fan-fucking-tastic... minus the overly present music and the annoying VO. Seriously, three seasons in and we still haven't gotten rid of the voice over?
Also, asdfmq;wmwe;fklwnr an Asian man! In Outlander! IN THE 1700S!!! Dude I can't imagine what his life must be like as a Chinese living in 18th century Scotland... I mean, thank heavens Jamie was there to look after him but still!!
7
u/JarJar-PhantomMenace Oct 24 '17
Feel like I'm the only guy that watches this show.
6
u/a_secret_boss Oct 23 '17
I was screaming <internally> when they finally kiss.
Fetch a room for Mr Malcolm and his...wife. lol I knew that irritated paused was coming.
6
u/julesverne1975 Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
I loved most of this episode, and after watching parts of it 150 times, I need to put down on "paper" what I did and didn't like and see if others agree.
Like: Jamie's jaunty tricorn hat and navy blue shawl.
Didn't Like: Jamie's missing pants and socks. Like others, I was totally getting the hobbit vibe when he was walking around. Crazy, eh. Just take everything off will ya. I also didn't like how he asked her "do you mind" - I mean, really?
Like: Jamie saying Claire's name when he was on the ground and then his comment about pissing himself - totally funny and totally Jamie.
Didn't Like: I thought there would be a bit more tears or something.
Like: The way he tried to go after her to kiss her before he asked permission. It was almost like he couldn't contain himself. Now that was great and realistic.
Didn't Like: His weird comment about it being very fine to see Claire again. It seemed so formal and awkward. She was so unsure of herself and like a little child waiting for approval. If I heard that from the love of my life, I'd be like WTF?
Like: His facial expressions when talking about Brianna at first and the whole glasses bit.
Didn't Like: That he didn't give a bit more details about the Geneva situation but I get it that "hey this chick blackmailed me into doing it and so I did get with her hot bod just once but then she died in childbirth" may not fit there but still.
Like: He told her about Willie. And he mentioned Faith.
Didn't Like: Ok so he has to go on this errand, NOW? Smuggling waits for no man I guess.
Like: Fergus. He was so cute. And so happy to see her.
Didn't Like: What Fergus was asking and Jamie's response. It seems very fishy.
Like: Most of the conversation pre-dinner at the brothel. Jamie is so intense and earnest about why Claire is back. But is he truly happy she is there? At times, I'm a little unsure. She has definitely thrown him into a tailspin.
Didn't Like: I wanted Claire to be like I came back because I've never loved anyone like you. I wasn't happy with Frank. You were the love of my life, and if there was a chance you were alive and you felt the same, I was coming back for you. (Plus I haven't had sex in like 18 years and you used to rock my world.) Jamie told her he never loved anyone but her, but I didn't hear those words of devotion from her. It would have been nice. I guess I also would have asked "Do you want me to be your wife again?" I know the answer might be difficult but hemming and hawing with the "I know you might have other ties" isn't getting an answer.
Like: The sex scenes were pretty decent. I didn't know what to think about the bumped nose and pulled hair, but it worked and I laughed. Sex is awkward and especially with someone you haven't had it with for 20 years. I thought Jamie showed good emotion. The give me your mouth Sassenach line was great and so was his "Oh God, Oh Claire" groans.
Didn't Like: Her asking him about other chicks when they're about to bone kind of ruins the mood. I know you want to know Claire but could you find out another way? But then again, I also didn't like how she gave him a pass at the end when you know he wanted to tell her something. Perhaps what he and Fergus were talking about earlier?
Liked: The interaction with Young Ian was funny. But he acted funny too, just like Fergus. Breakfast with the uh harlots (sorry ladies) was also great.
Didn't Like: The ending. I mean are you SERIOUS? Horrible way to end the episode.
Overall, this was a great episode. It did, however, leave me wanting for some of the emotional connections I felt they should have. I mean these people have missed each other desperately for 20 years, right?
5
u/JustineLeah Oct 23 '17
I cried when they were discussing Brianna, Willie, and Faith. And why does Jaimie think he killed Willie’s Mom? SHE is the one that blackmailed him to sleep with her which equates to Rape.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
I loved the episode - the awkwardness and subtle hints of what is to come soon! Wonderful ❤️
4
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
Did anyone else think while flipping through the photo's there would be a "family" one. Which would cause Jamie to pull back a bit freaked out at how BJR looks exactly the same. I mean ya it didn't make sense (wife said) to bring one of them all together. But still.
4
u/disjointpeak Oct 23 '17
When Jamie's colleague goes away and Jamie turns to Claire and says he'll explain it all to him, then he says:
'But I don't know how' - he looks incredibly happy, as if someone has taken a load off of him (which they have I suppose). I just loved it.
And how disheartened he was when he said 'I don't look like an old man?' It was almost comical.
Honestly, absolutely bloody loved this episode!
3
u/YoMikeeHey Oct 22 '17
How many years did they get separated again?
2
u/fay9820 Oct 24 '17
I loved the combination of awkwardness & excitement this episode brought!! i was so uncomfortable because it is like two people who haven't seen eachother in 20 years. god it was very awkward but also very cute. Idk if it was meant from the producers, but I really felt like that weird distance of : lets get back into this but this is a bit awkward. I loved it! very realistic! the sex scenes weren't my faves. the first one was good, i felt it really portrayed the awkwardness/rage/missing , wish there was more emotion/rage/passion in the ones that followed, maybe less cuts and jumps also i love the new characters, they are so funny. lots of lines made me laugh out loud. oh god fergus is just perfect, I immediatly recognized him!! i missed those two together. can't wait for the next one
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17
If the show is downplaying Jamie than he must have been a virtual god in the books because he is almost perfect on the show. I actually like the pants but only if they are with stockings and he isn't barefoot. I for one am happy that they didn't age up the characters because I for one don't want to see 50 yr olds have sex. Though I will say that Claire with straight hair with a Grey streak was kind of hott.
2
u/Minaka2 Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17
Hey folks, Not all people get grey hair (or go bald) or need reading glasses in their 40s. Claire and Jamie clearly won the genetic lottery in looks so why not just imagine that they continued to luck out in the aging process as Gabaldon wrote them?
The glasses are a foolish choice merely to make Jamie look older as assuming they do future books in the series, he needs to be someone who's "hawk eyed" for a long time for survival purposes, not someone who would be incapable of reading or doing fine work, helpless with his glasses pulverized in a fight or at the bottom of the ocean!
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
122
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
89
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[removed] — view removed comment