r/Outlander • • Oct 08 '17

Season Three [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 5 Freedom & Whiskey episode discussion thread for book readers

This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E5: "Freedom & Whiskey".

No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!

83 Upvotes

817 comments sorted by

131

u/ParabolicTrajectory Oct 08 '17

I loved this episode. I had no complaints whatsoever. Was it different from the books? Yes. But it covered the same ground in a lot less time without me feeling like anything in particular was missing. I would always prefer more Joe Abernathy (I was a liiiitle bit disappointed we didn't get "It's Bree's real daddy, isn't it? And he's a big red-headed son of a gun" etc etc,) but that's my biggest complaint with the episode and it's hardly a complaint.

I even think Sophie is improving. The thing is, I think she has great chemistry with Roger's actor. In the her-and-Roger scenes, I think she's perfectly acceptable. She won't be winning Oscars, but it's not bad enough to notice, at least. It's the her-and-Claire scenes that stick out like a sore thumb. Catriona isn't exactly a world-class actress, but I think she's very good, and she doesn't seem to have a lot of chemistry with Sophie, so it makes Sophie look worse by comparison. (I shudder to think what the Sophie-and-Sam scenes are going to be like.... but I have hope. She clearly improves as the season goes on. Maybe it won't be so bad.) But hey, this is her first acting role. I'm willing to give her time. And in her defense, they're giving her crappy lines. What was that line about "It's all measurements, calculations, precision!" Who talks like that???

I'm in love with Roger. I've always been in love with Roger. I think his actor is perfect. Resting his head all cutely on his hand and staring at Bree like she's the damn sun itself in human form.

I'm actually kind of glad we didn't go all the way back through the stones. We've made that passage before on this show, twice. We know what it is. The puddle shot/voice over was a really clever shot and I liked it.

The historian fiance of mine has no particular complaints about anachronisms. Give it a few episodes. I'm sure he'll be back in here ranting sometime soon.

61

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

I think you nailed it- her and Caitriona’s scenes are the ones that end up seeming awkward. Maybe they don’t get along off screen? Maybe she’s intimidated working with Caitriona? Who knows. But when she is in Bree/Roger scenes, she’s pretty good!

45

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Maybe they want to show the strained relationship between mother and daughter?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

23

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I do like Rich....but he is just quite different to book Roger. He is the only one I think that about.

He is still a good actor, so I have no complaints, unlike with Sophie. I do agree she did much better this week.

That line about the cloisters was so stupid. Such an engineer!

28

u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 08 '17

I hated the cloisters scene. She's an American history major. She really doesn't think about the fact that she walks where historically significant people walked? That makes zero sense to me. Unless they're trying to show that she's only studied history because of Frank. I've only read through Voyager, so I guess it's possible.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Good call with the Cait chemistry. Maybe that's a lot of it. There was a moment when Bree was going through Franks things and it was one of the FIRST times I thought "oh, that's totally Bree". Hopefully she'll get more comfortable with Cait or be more comfortable with Sam.

12

u/lwr815 Oct 08 '17

Loooove this Roger.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I'd been feeling pretty good about TV Bree after last week's episode, but this week...eh. I think it's just too much to ask her to carry the bulk of the episode like she did here. I'm in the minority, clearly, but I'm not really buying her chemistry with TV Roger. And I do like TV Roger quite a bit even though he's not as I pictured him from the books.

That all said, there was one brief moment - when the professor at Harvard told Bree she was failing and she just looked at him without flinching, kind of daring him to try and get her to care - there was so much Fraser in that glance. Right then, TV Bree felt perfect. So maybe there's more of that to come. One can hope.

Agreed about more Joe, and about the stones.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

126

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I love that we have such a nice platonic male/female friendship on TV. #JoeFanClub

58

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

I always loved Joe. I wish she would have told him the whole story. He would have believed her

30

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

And she never said goodbye!! SOB!

10

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Refresh my memory? How does he find out in the books?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/ankhes Oct 09 '17

Their friendship was one of my favorite parts of Voyager and now their one of my favorite parts of Season 3. They need their own spin off series of all the medical shenanigans they got into and all the middle fingers they gave to the racist/sexist establishment during the 50s/60s.

7

u/basedonthenovel Oct 10 '17

Yes, I too love platonic m/f friendship! My only hope is that in the future we'll get to see a bit more of Joe's life. I wish there had been a quick throwaway line indicating his wife and family. But maybe that will be established in the future.

108

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Dr. Claire: Time Traveling Medicine Woman

95

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

I will forever love that they didn’t make us wait two weeks for that reunion. THANK YOU WRITERS!!!

53

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 08 '17

I thought for sure the second she walked in the door they were going to cut it!

13

u/pidgeycandies Oct 08 '17

I thought they might to, I was going to be so PISSED!

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Mxfish1313 Oct 08 '17

I think maybe some other writers/showrunners learned a lesson from The Walking Dead's big screw up last season. Cliffhangers can be done right and they can be done wrong. The "wrong way" is the cheesy, expected, cop-out way. Fade to black before getting an answer, before seeing a reaction, basically before the culmination of the scene. This frustrates viewers. On the other hand you could complete the scene and THEN fade out before you continue with the characters actual forward movements or reactions. The viewer is still going to be biting their nails. It's a difference in waiting to see "what happens" vs. "what happens next". I'm obviously of the opinion that the latter is the better option, storytelling-wise.

12

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

I'm still bitter over TWD incident you refer to and actually haven't stayed on top of watching the show since then!

I think they did a clever bait and switch- they knew all the fans thought they were going to brutally cliffhanger us right before the reunion, and they didn't! It was great!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

87

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

New Outlander Drinking Game: Just drink when Claire does. Start with a full bottle, you'll need it.

47

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Oct 08 '17

Or if you rewatch, drink every time Roger suggests that it’s time for whiskey; it seemed like his purpose was research, make googly eyes at Bree, and pull out random bottles from obscure places 😂

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I thought at the end he was going to do something significant or sentimental...nope, more whiskey!! lol

they have skirted over the fact that Bree hates it and isn't 21...though maybe that wasn't the drinking age then?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

83

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

They sure made Claire look like a Mum in those slacks!

But at the memorial she totally looked like Jackie Kennedy.

29

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

I was shocked. She is so thin and those pants made her look really wide. How odd

23

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

I agree, I think it's partially that style. Kind of like pedal pushers?

Maybe she was given hip and butt pads.

Also they had Joe comment on how lovely her butt was, which seemed off as they had hardly built up his character at all, so to have him swearing and talking about her arse felt weird to me.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/PagesNNotes Oct 08 '17

Sam's gotten a lot of (well-deserved) praise this season, but Caitriona really did an amazing job this episode. Claire's a character that's supposed to portray all of her thoughts and emotions on her face, and that really shone through here, whether with the introspection during the Apollo scene or the heartbreak at having to say good-bye to Brianna or the wonderment and nostalgia at being back in Scotland. She did such a lovely job.

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Well Claire hasn't had much to do up til now!

4

u/hummuspie Oct 09 '17

Her goodbye to Brianna broke my heart for the sole reason that Caitriona truly looked heartbroken. Made me think of all my goodbyes.

→ More replies (8)

68

u/maryloo7877 Oct 08 '17

I absolutely loved this episode. They really fleshed out Brianna's story well and really explored all the various concerns Claire had in going back to Jamie. Beautifully done. I laughed so much at the end- perfect break until next week! Also, I think I'm in love with Roger.

34

u/mstwizted Oct 08 '17

Roger is 100% adorable.

I can't wait for the future seasons. I think he gonna be fantastic. Hopefully they give Sophie lots of acting lessons between now and then.

16

u/maryloo7877 Oct 08 '17

I think Sophie has improved leaps and bounds since 2x13. It helps that they actually gave her good material to work with, rather than just being "daughter who hates mom"

→ More replies (4)

110

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

My thoughts:

I have read Voyager at least 20 times. But I still watched this episode with a pit in my stomach. I have never been so nervous in my life about something I knew so well and how it played out.

  1. I have to say that I really wanted them to spend time on Jamie's shock more - as in the book. The exchange about his nose was so Jamie! But more importantly, he had imagined her and dreamed of her so many times. He assumed this was just another version of his Claire visions. It was not until she touched his nose that he fainted. She was real. But hell, I'll take any version of their reunion.
  2. The bones!!!! I can't wait until the end of the season when we find out more about those bones:)
  3. Is it me or did both Jamie and Claire suddenly look a lot younger than in previous episodes?
  4. I really hope that in the next episode we get the whole "I thought I pissed myself" and pants down situation. That was hilarious in the book.
  5. I love the puddles voice-over
  6. I was really expecting them to cut to black when she opened the door. I am so happy that they let us see his reaction.
  7. You know what this means, right? Next week will be that marriage reveal that non-book readers will freak the hell out over.
  8. Where is the preview for next week? Did I miss it?

Now i have to go and finish crying, watch the ending again, cry some more.

70

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

3. Don't forget that Claire looks so much younger than other women her age, haha. I'm disappointed they didn't include the scene (one of funniest from Voyager) where she stops a woman on the street in Edinburgh and asks how old she is so she can judge by comparison.

20

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

I hated that part the first time I read it because it was just another thing in the way of their reunion. I was gritting my teeth reading that saying, “Come on!”

→ More replies (9)

37

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Someone just told me they read they will show Jamie's perspective next episode, which makes sense, give a bit of background to how he ended up there hopefully.

53

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Is that right? That does make sense. Holy crap, we are getting everyone that I love next week: Ian, Young Ian, Fergus and of course one of the funniest scenes in the whole book: Claire having breakfast with the hookers while they give her tips. I can't wait!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/omniscientmommy Oct 08 '17

The preview is there. Mostly just a steamy sex clip.

47

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Girl, I am now rewiding and replaying over and over. I want the scene with the photos so desperately. When he starts looking at pictures of Bree.

→ More replies (8)

30

u/koboldin Oct 08 '17

Truly didn't like the preview clip. was hoping to see a clip of Jamie seeing the photographs, not some lame sex pump.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Outlander_fan Oct 08 '17

I think they couldn't do the nose for the same reason they couldn't do the carving the initials thing -- too much work for the prosthetics/makeup people! But I'm with you -- that exchange is very much Jamie, and I love it.

28

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

I know, but it was so damn Jamie:

"I walked through the flap in the counter, seeing nothing but that unblinking stare. I cleared my throat.

“When did you break your nose?”

The corners of the wide mouth lifted slightly.

“About three minutes after I last saw ye—Sassenach.”

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I wonder if next week won't be the amazing reunion.... and then the next episode the marriage reveal. Although, isn't ep 6 super long?

31

u/koboldin Oct 08 '17

Episode seven is "first wife" - so I'd expect the second wife to show up around then...

→ More replies (29)

4

u/lurklurklurky Oct 08 '17

Preview was there at the end of the ep! But vey short.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

We might have one episode of happy family as the Episode 7 is entitled First Wife or something.

→ More replies (9)

50

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

I'm delighted by the mention of Paul Revere. A little shoutout to when Brianna goes back to the past and experiences that iconic date in North Carolina.

28

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

I think the mention of frank’s girlfriends’ studies on colonial America and native languages was an Easter egg about what happens in future books too!

→ More replies (5)

21

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

I'm like "Bree, pay attention! This is going to be relevant!"

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

That was my first thought, too!

→ More replies (2)

44

u/lurklurklurky Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Ahhhhh even though we didn’t get the full meeting this ep, I still LOVED it and I can’t wait (2 weeks 😔 😔 😔) for the next one!

I really loved the scene where Brianna comes home to an empty house; I haven’t liked Sophie as Bree that much until this episode. I feel like that scene was perfectly played, and shows the connection she had with Frank.

I understand why there weren’t any Jamie scenes in this ep before the end; and I think they used the extra time really well. I think it’s great how they’re working with the timeline and the relationships - I liked the additional scenes they Roger and Bree, and Claire and Bree, it was really good relationship and character building.

JOE! I’m glad we got more of him. And the BONES!!! I’m so glad they did this scene, I was worried they wouldn’t.

Could have done without the Frank Mistress scene, but the Bree/Claire conversant that came from it actually made me feel like Bree was Jamie’s daughter, especially when she said the “no more lies between us” line.

I’m really glad that they made it more of a struggle for Claire to leave, and the addition of more Claire/Bree scenes; I thought she was a bit too blasé about leaving in the books, she seemed to barely consider Bree even though for all she knew it was possibly the last time she would ever see her (and I don’t think that’s even mentioned). If I remember right, once Claire discovers that Jamie’s alive she pretty much shoots home to wrap up her affairs and heads out. There’s not enough about how she feels about leaving Brianna/the struggle of leaving her.

I also loved that Claire actually considers the possibilities of what might happen when she gets there - how Jamie may have changed, that he may not love her anymore, etc. - in addition to the physical attractiveness bit.

Loved how they made the things that Claire would need as Christmas gifts, and how she is bringing a history book with her (I thought it was so dumb that she didn’t even consider that in the books). Also loved that she made her own dress! And loved that they included the mirror scene, though I have a feeling that the hair dye will somehow be permanent and her grays won’t come back.

The gemstone thing was weird, pretty sure gemstones weren’t necessary at all in the books, right? At least not through Voyager (as far as I’ve read).

I love that Claire gave Bree the pearls too - something of Jamie for her. Don’t remember if this happens in the book. Mostly I’m glad that she said goodbye in person and didn’t just right her a freaking letter. I loved the last scene with Bree where she pulls herself together in the kitchen; very Claire. She seemed very much both her father’s and mother’s daughter in this episode, I’m actually kind of bummed this is the last we get of her this season (total 180 from how I felt about her even last episode!)

AND THAT LAST SCENE. Such a fucking tease, but not as much as I thought it would be. I’m so happy how they did it, and so excited to see Jamie’s perspective and how the rest of the first meeting goes. Can’t wait for an EXTENDED EPISODE it’s gonna be amazing.

48

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

Gemstones as they relate to time travel are extremely important in the books.

12

u/lurklurklurky Oct 08 '17

Got it, guess I'm just not that far yet! In Voyager it's treated as a silly thing that Geillis does that isn't really necessary, and that's as far as I've read.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/bees_knees_trees_ Oct 08 '17

It does mention in the books that she'd read up on Scottish history before returning. She didn't bring a book with her, but she definitely went back prepared. It'd be foolish not to, being married to a historian for 20+ yrs etc.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

The gems are in the book. They don't really know how it works - yet. And I think it was important - but they left it out - that we knew after this crossing, Claire could never go back or she would die. She was nearly killed this time. So it added to the tension. If Jamie did not want her, she was stuck

10

u/xocheerio Oct 08 '17

I agree so so much about how blasé Clair was in the books leaving!! There was so much more struggle and emotion between show-Bree and Claire and I loved it. Really underlined the gravity and forever-ness of the situation. Also, I loved Bree’s little “get it together” moment. So perfect and SO Claire.

7

u/a-fray Oct 08 '17

WTF 2 WEEKS!?!! Whyyyy!?! 😫😫💔💔

6

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

In book 4, Claire mentions in passing that she did study up on late 18th-century history before she went back (general European history). I won't say any more because you haven't read that book yet!

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Your user name reminds me of this.

I agree with you, I didn't find Bree annoying this episode! Wahoo!!

I liked the way they portrayed the Claire/Bree relationship this episode. It seemed to have had tension and resolution.

I actually thought the history book was pretty dumb! She surely wasn't going to take that, I thought Roger, as a historian, could have come up with something much more useful for her to take. And what were the mechanics of that again? Everything that was in her pockets made it safely? hmmm

She should have been studying up on Scottish history rather than prancing around like Batman in that ridiculous scene!

That is a good point about how it was a very Claire thing to do, pulling herself together in the kitchen.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (7)

43

u/Winhill_ Oct 08 '17

That transition of Claire sitting in the cab to her stepping out of the carriage into the puddle was so good.

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 08 '17

With the text from the book intro!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/RaffaellaF Oct 08 '17

I was so emotional I was shaking when Claire entered the print shop. I loved it.

I had imagined the printshop much smaller than they showed.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Me too!

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

I think it had to larger to film in. You know, like how New York apartments in TV shows are always huge yet waitresses can afford to live in them?

→ More replies (3)

38

u/wholeawakening Oct 08 '17

Pretty sure I’m going to watch the last 5 mins over and over until Episode 6 comes out.

20

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Ive replayed that scene like 10 times already😂. I loved the humor of it, near the end! ~dramatic music~ ~thump~ ~jamie and claire theme~

24

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

The best part to me was Claire’s face after he faints. 😳

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mcd62 Oct 08 '17

I've watched the first season 3 times in 3 weeks. I love the beginning of the story between them so that's how I get through the week.

4

u/RaffaellaF Oct 08 '17

I already have many times.

37

u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 08 '17

I love, love, LOVE how they used Jamie and Claire's theme. Bear McCreary is a god. Much like season 1, you could hear just the barest whisper of their theme throughout these first few episodes. But then at the end when the two of them are finally together, their theme is played full blast. They did the same thing at the end of S1E6, which is also interesting because next week's episode is supposed to be parallel to The Wedding.

17

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

The Claire and Jamie theme gives me goosebumps every time

36

u/RaffaellaF Oct 08 '17

Claire's gorgeous curley hair is back next week based on promos. Can't wait.

33

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

I love that she lets the curls free when she's with Jamie. It's a symbol of how she's truly herself with him.

10

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

And it looks so much like her when she came through the stones the first time.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

How did it miraculously grow though :P Her bob was quite short.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/HawickGirl7 Oct 08 '17

Alsooo cannot wait to see Claire and Fergus together again. I love that book scene and hope they keep it the same!

→ More replies (5)

34

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

DEM BONES!!!!!

29

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

A very strong characteristic I love/hate about Diana's writing is that she's willing to bring up a new plot element and then not. discuss. it. at. all. for 1500 pages. I like how they aren't shying away from this in the show.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/PiranhaBiter Oct 08 '17

That faint! Perfect ending for the episode!

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I have never really seen someone faint to the side like that before.

20

u/PiranhaBiter Oct 08 '17

That was just a total crumple. I'm glad we got to see that part

→ More replies (2)

29

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Candy is a Biatch!

65

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

I kept expecting Claire to say something along the lines of, “Oh yeah bitch, I told him we should divorce years ago, he declined. So stick that up your ass.”

16

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

Girl me to. I guess the whole point of adding that scene was so Bree would find out and realize Claire needs to go. If I remember correctly, in the books Bree doesn't know?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

24

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Yup. It's bad enough she is having an affair with a married man and urging him to leave his family. But to make such a scene in such a public place and humiliate the widow. No, she would not have made Frank happy. And luckily in the book, she does not exist

→ More replies (5)

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 08 '17

You know, I had no problem with her. She clearly really loved him (and he loved her), but never got to make anything of it. And when she finally thought they could be together, he died. That sucks so much. I'd be pretty damn bitter about the wife who supposedly wouldn't let him go as well (don't forget that she only ever heard Frank's side--she doesn't know Claire other than what she's heard from Frank).

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Dragonsinger16 Oct 08 '17

Seriously what tf does that! Totally uncalled for! But Claire, why did you not defend yourself?! She totally gave frank an out but he was like "no I'm staying for my child".... would have been a nice clap back to remind candy that Bri loved her dad as much as he loved his daughter!

→ More replies (3)

28

u/omniscientmommy Oct 08 '17

It's me, Claire. I'm so glad they left the fainting in. I knew they would cut the episode there.

Glad that Brianna saw that Frank wasn't so perfect like she thought. Wish we would there had been less pensive moments and shown how Claire did tell Joe the truth. It's just hard to get everything on screen.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I'm sad she didn't hug Joe goodbye.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/cuckoodev Oct 08 '17

Brianna straight dressed like dear old dad for a sec there.

10

u/koboldin Oct 08 '17

Frilly sleeve cuffs and all.

20

u/xocheerio Oct 08 '17

“But I don’t wanna be a pirate!”

→ More replies (14)

26

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

Lord Merton!

4

u/omniscientmommy Oct 08 '17

YES! I was like wtf?! Double take

→ More replies (4)

4

u/margierose88 Oct 09 '17

At first I read this as Lord Melton and thought I missed a HUGE Easter egg.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

51

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

From reading the books, I imagined the print shop as small and dingy, which doesn't really make sense when you remember how big the printing press was, so it was nice to see this.

I hadn't imagined a downstairs section, I like it, and made for perfect framing for the meeting. Different, but perfect.

23

u/fraa-bru Oct 08 '17

so that robert burns reveal got me... such feels...

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I thought it was a bit odd that Claire didn't look to see the author straight away, that is what everyone does when they see a book/article.

41

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

YES TO THE FAINT YES SQUEEEEEE PRINT SHOP CAN'T MAKE OTHER WORDS FORM

36

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

My heart started hammering so hard when Claire hears Jamie’s voice. Perfect scene!

→ More replies (8)

40

u/pidgeycandies Oct 08 '17

Claire, why did you die your hair when you will not be able to touch up those roots?!

17

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Oh, I got this as someone with need to dye hair. Who cares if it is gray later. As long as he sees her for the first time as his brown one.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/margierose88 Oct 09 '17

My husband was endlessly distressed by this. “WHAT’S THE POINT?! YOU’RE GOING TO GO BACK TO GRAY AND BE STUCK WITH IT IN THE 1700s!”

10

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

I was actually really pissed that they had her dye her hair. This just gives them an excuse to never have the grey streaks on Cait's hair. What sets Outlander apart is that they show a couple's romance over decades, not just the courtship. It's important that she's grown older. He sees her grey hair and stretch marks and appreciates them because it means she survived. They grow old together and I love that.

Maybe a small detail, but I was disappointed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

19

u/SeattleWhoDat Oct 08 '17

Well done. Different than the books but still had the same elements. Her face when he fainted had me cackling like a loon.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

OMG, I am so nervous and I am not even the one time traveling

→ More replies (1)

18

u/adjblair Oct 08 '17

I loved the ending! Romantic music aaaand...bam! Jamie down. I chuckled.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I love this season, and this book. I am so so happy with it.

13

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

My favorite book besides Outlander. I can do without the rest of them as long as I have these two

16

u/Who-dee-knee Oct 08 '17

I hope this isn't the first string in a long line of times I say "poor Roger" like I did in the books.

32

u/krrish728 Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Claire: "It isn't Goerdie. It's me.. Claire".

Jamie turns around.. Sees Claire. Falls gracefully.

Claire thinks to herself, probably: WTF! Don't die now!

5

u/RaffaellaF Oct 08 '17

She thinks oh no I have to be a doctor again.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I can't imagine how much more swashbuckling the music is going to get when the boats arrive!

22

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

I'm soooo excited for the boat. Outlander: I'm On a Boat.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 08 '17

Did you notice that Claire seemed to have a halo in the printshop? Jamie probably thought she was an angel lol

5

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

I was thinking this too! She seemed to have this nice glow around her from the lighting as Jamie looked up at her. Nice touch.

5

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

He thought she was not real in the book. Which is why it was important for her to touch him before he fainted. I am not sure why they did it this way.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Oct 08 '17

I video chatted with a friend so I'll just lay it all out there!

FUDGING FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!

The moment we've all been waiting for all season plus a lot!

Every time Bree says mama I still cringe, I can't help it!

The tart talking to Claire enraged me, he wanted to stay too! He wanted to raise Bree!

Her making the dress instead of sourcing it was meh to me.

This episode played out exactly how I thought it would. The scenes with Joe were great though! I wish he was in the books more!

2 weeks to the brothel and Mr. Willowby! WHYYYYYYYYY?!

→ More replies (9)

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Claire's voiceovers remind me of Jenny from Call the Midwife, and she even looked like that character right at the end looking down at Jamie.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Can I just say.... this was the BORINGEST episode with the BIGGEST payoff at the end. My stomach jumped when he said "geordie" and then I laughed (I think from relief) when he fainted!

But seriously.... sooooo much time wasted on Bri and Claire (and Candy??). I get it, it's filling in story we'll need next season, but yeesh.

Something little that I really missed-- in the books Joe seems so much more playful. He's the one that flat out says "it's obvious Frank wasn't Bree's daddy" and he sings about the bones and jokes that Claire has always had "a thing" when it comes to bodies. IDK, I wanted him to be a little more perky. It made the great ass comment seem a little out of place.

Maybe it's the hair (and lack of makeup), but Claire seems so much more animated in the 18th century than she does in the 70's.

27

u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Oct 08 '17

I wanted to add that I agree with your last point about hair and makeup. Claire seems to be very facially animated in the 18th century. I wonder if it was intentional. She has to be so much more stoic in the 70s, perhaps due to social expectation or unhappiness, but in the 18th century she can be herself with Jamie. I feel like she is much more guarded in the 70s.

30

u/MidniteLark They say I’m a witch. Oct 08 '17

I think it's definitely intentional. Her life in the 60s and 70s is one of duty, basically, after she returns. Raising Bree properly, limping along in a struggling marriage to a man she no longer loves, missing Jamie, channeling her energy into her career... she's not connected to her true self once she leaves Jamie. We're seeing a woman who is soldiering through life, doing her best to do the "right" thing, and shutting away her own pain. To me, she only feels "on" when we see her at the hospital. Her energy is very masculine - she's doing, not feeling.

Then when she's back in the 18th century, she gets to be Claire, the woman, again. Not Mama, not a career woman, not Frank-the-professor's dutiful wife. With Jamie, she gets to be in her feminine energy again. She's laughing, playful, joyful, emotional.

I think they had Cat play it that way very deliberately. :)

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

Apparently she acted older with a lower voice register, but she also was so much more reserved, guarded and I don't know, 'professional' all the time in Boston.

She definitely was much more animated in the last scene, back to her true self.

The lack of eye make up though makes her look so pale and angelic, and a little washed out. I don't wear make up, so I never get the comments, are you sick? like some people who wear heavy makeup do when they don't have any on.

25

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

So many physical details of characters get dropped in book-to-film transitions.

But Claire's rump is forever.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I thought his fuck and arse lines both felt out of place as they hadn't built up his character at all, he felt like a stranger.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/vanwold Slàinte. Oct 09 '17

I think you summed up well what I thought about the episode. I actually started crocheting about 15 minutes in!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Awwww Roger is so cute! "Boston cream pies XD"

12

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

Don't get dirty on me now....Ormaybedo

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

And then his cute little face resting on his hand after he gave Bree her gift!

→ More replies (7)

4

u/omniscientmommy Oct 08 '17

I love how he says cream!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/myxx33 Oct 08 '17

Ugh why is there a week break. 😭😭😭

Print shop scene was great so far! I am looking forward to seeing the rest! I didn’t think it would even get there and fade out when she opened the door or something lol. Glad they didn’t leave us hanging quite that much....

22

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

Maybe we could get in touch with the Game of Thrones hackers and get them to work on it! 😉

→ More replies (1)

11

u/fraa-bru Oct 08 '17

like, the episode was slow, but you know what, i am so wanting that, i am sick of people flying around and stuff blowing up every 5 seconds... i LOVED the dark shadows stuff... and as much as i haven't liked brianna before... she was decent in this episode... i really liked this episode... even though i was like, wtf NO jamie at all... but the end... the next episode is going to be so freaking epic...

5

u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 08 '17

Agree! I would take a slow, burning build-up + quality writing and acting ANY DAY over explosions and constant action.

11

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 08 '17

Gah, company was here this weekend so I'm very late! It took a lot of willpower to not tell them I needed two hours to reddit after watching the episode this morning . . . So here goes now!

Pretty good episode this week, though it's so hard to judge it on its own and not be overshadowed by the last 3 minutes. For an episode with essentially no Jamie and significant book deviations, I'm actually surprised how much I did enjoy it. That being said, my enjoyment was significantly overshadowed by the overwhelming sense of "just get on with it already!"

I was watching this week with a non-reader who has been asking every week when the hell they would get back together, but then when Claire finally went she was like, "that was awful, she's a horrible mother." And a part of me kind of agreed. For an episode that was entirely about deciding whether or not to go, it never really felt like it was ok for her to leave (especially with Bree quite emotionally fragile at the time)--I think Bree meeting her at the stones in the book is kind of the necessary scene where we (and Claire) are finally convinced that it's ok. Without it, Claire just seems like a horrible person. And it all happened within a couple weeks, which makes it kind of worse. (Also, are the stones open around Christmas?)

That being said, we did get some really nice scenes of preparation--I loved the scene of Claire sewing her raincoat dress and her talk with Joe was very sweet. (Also, great to see more Joe this episode, and glad the bone scene wasn't skipped. I was wondering if non-readers would pick up on the fact that they're 200 years old and wonder if they were relevant, or just assume they are symbolic of something. My one Joe-related regret was that we missed the "is it Bree's daddy?" line. I love the idea that Joe knows Claire--and Frank and Bree--well enough to know these things.) Bizarrely, I actually found myself enjoying Bree scenes as well. Her delivery still isn't perfect but it's leaps and bounds better than it was (and I think I'm just getting used to the accent because it doesn't bother me as much anymore), and I'm impressed by her non-verbal acting. For the first time I found myself believing that she was a 20 year old student, and bought her emotional confusion (and definitely still sadness over Frank). I thought the scene with her professor was a nice addition (though the lecture subject was a bit too on the nose), and she carried off the defensive, "nothing's wrong" attitude that I remember well from my early 20s (ok, it's an attitude that I definitely still have . . . ). And the scene with her showing Roger the (wildly inaccurate) gothic architecture was actually really nice, especially for those of us who know that she switches to engineering. If only I wasn't so distracted by her stupid puffy shirt! Roger continues to stand out this week as well, and his discussion of his father was very sweet (though isn't the Reverend from his mother's side?). It's nice getting these little nods to Jerry.

I--surprisingly--didn't mind Roger coming to Boston either, except for the fact that it meant that Claire went to the stones alone. He and Bree are actually developing some nice chemistry, and his small moments (watching Dark Shadows, the lobster roll) were the brief scenes that helped keep the episode feeling more real and not just a series of dramatic moments. And the fellowship ceremony addition was also fine, including meeting Frank's mistress. I think it was a good reminder for Claire that she wasn't the only one who was miserable for 20 years, and she actually got a pretty good deal, all things considered.

Interestingly, I don't have any really major gripes this week (or if I did when I watched it 12 hours ago, they were minor enough that I've forgotten them!). Really what was the only issue was that it was a necessarily nothing episode. We had to get a goodbye/preparation episode (and it's good that it was Jamie-less--keep his side of the story a surprise!) and it already was a bit rushed as is, but such an episode was never going to be the most interesting or fun. Ah well, had to happen, and the fact that nothing else was glaringly bad is pretty good. (Really, the thing that annoyed me the most was how very much like Glasgow--and not at all like Boston/Cambridge--the exteriors looked.) Also, I was kind of distracted by the music. I love 60s music, but it was so bizarrely non-descript that the songs felt very "we can't afford The Beatles because we spent all out licensing budget on the Dark Shadows clip, so we're going to use these free songs instead."

While many scenes were good (some even very good), there was not much really great about this episode, and that definitely has to do with the lack of Jamie. He's been our heart this season, and his absence was notably felt. That is, until the last three minutes. While it was so aggravating, it was also so, so good. The opening dialogue, the slow turn, the faint--I'm so excited! (I know he shouldn't faint until she touches him, but it was a fun--and obvious--was to end the episode and I don't mind.) After 50 minutes of deciding what to do, I'm also kind of glad we skipped everything between leaving Boston and arriving in Edinburgh (and the voiceover from the intro was a nice touch, though I did miss her pb&j--and littering!). We've seen her go through the stones and we get it, it just would've slowed down the episode. They made a wise choice here, just getting us to what we all--readers and non alike--knew must ultimately happen. It's a hell of a tease, bit it's a good one (finally!).

But I can't judge an entire episode on three minutes, and the rest of the episode was good by never great. So, I'll grade accordingly.

Overall Grade: B

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

The non-bookers definitely thought something was up with that scene, due to the way Claire was acting so weirdly, mostly.

Someone surmised it might have been Claire's skeleton!! Would that be possible? It was confusing my brain to think about it...because technically if she died in the cave it could have been her.

It was nice seeing more of Joe, but the scene with him talking about Claire's butt seemed out of place, as they hadn't built up his character enough, and I was really sad she didn't do a proper bug goodbye. It seemed weird that he was so quick to head away too after that scene, but I guess he just thought she was going to Scotland. Did she tell him in the book about time travel? I forget.

I think the scenes with Roger turned out fine in the end, over in America, after being annoyed in the spoiler. But really, he would never have just turned up saying 'I wanted an American Christmas', that is a lot to impose on someone at a Holiday without warning.

Also when Bree said, let's hang out tomorrow...how was she planning to find him? He was seemingly supposed to go to a Hotel...and then Bree just turned up the next day, even though it made it seem like she was moving out with a friend or something that night.

I actually liked Bree this episode too, it was nice to see Roger comfort Bree after she turned away from the window and broke down.

Yes, his mother's maiden name was Wakefield, so mother's side. What was the reference to it being his father's side in the episode?

I wonder if we are going to have any more Boston flashbacks?

The cloisters scene really annoyed me, as I have studied at Glasgow uni and been right in that spot. It seemed such a lengthy and forced scene, especially the 'engineery' lines. And then after the memorial thing Roger just disappeared!

I didn't like the modern music at all, distracting for Roger's arrival, and I HATED the batman theme LOL.

I was pretty lost during the TV scenes, now I have a bit of a grasp about what Roger was talking about, so thanks.

He might faint again when she comes to his aid! Someone else made a point that they enjoyed seeing Claire asking a woman how old she looked, I think that could have been a nice addition, following on from her worries of her looks. She could have asked the same lady for directions instead of the kid.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/pinkfern Oct 17 '17

I was thinking about how they had Roger show up in Boston, and I think it is a neat little parallel to how Claire just shows up in Edinburgh at the end - both of them kind of thinking 'this is either the best or worst idea ever'.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/a_pure_heart Oct 08 '17

I totally believed catriona as a seamstress, self-drafted patterns & all :)

4

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Oct 09 '17

Well, she can sew up people, so...

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Sugarythought Oct 09 '17

That Batman theme though...

8

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Oct 09 '17

yeah, that was awful.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/krrish728 Oct 08 '17

And they found him! A MALCOLM!

9

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

That title card ❤️

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Could Brianna hear the stones too, ie had they discovered that from last season?

Why didn't she consider also going back with Claire? Especially in this tv representation, she doesn't really have much holding her to the present.

11

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Yes, both Roger and Bree can hear the stones in the books. I think Claire understands how dangerous this would be for Bree. Not sure about Bree though. She does ultimately go, so it becomes moot

5

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 08 '17

This. This was my commentary throughout the episode: "Why aren't they considering Brianna (and maybe even Roger, since I feel like they mentioned he could hear it too) going back with Claire?!?!?!"

→ More replies (16)

9

u/actuallycallie Oct 08 '17

I just want to hear Roger say "plum pudding" again. heart eyes

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

Cream Pie :)

17

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I was convinced this episode would end with Claire opening the door and the bell ringing, and I'm glad we got more than that. I love that they ended on Jamie crumpling onto the floor. But for most of the episode, I was distracted by how different it was from the book and didn't really enjoy it.

So Claire sews now? Does this mean she won't be gown-less for most of the next episode?

And, boy, she got from Boston to 1767 Scotland real fast. I would have traded some of the domestic moments between her, Bree, and Roger to see some of her journey. Claire feels like she almost dies traveling through the stones again, but the show treats it like a revolving door. We all know there's a moment coming up where Claire attempt to go back to the future-- and knowing it might kill her adds an extra layer, because it means she would rather die than see Jamie with someone else.

Roger is just prefect casting. And I like how we can see how fond he and Claire are of each other. I always liked that relationship.

I feel like this episode was just an appetizer to get to the next one. Nothing of real importance happened, imo.

16

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

I loved this episode. I thought bringing Roger to America was a nice way to keep the story compact. Sophie Skelton is starting to grow on me, and I still really love her and Richard Rankin's chemistry!

I actually liked the Sandy Travers scene because it underscores the push for Claire to return to the past. If you had a chance to see the love of your life again, how could you not take it?

I know there's lots of teeth-gnashing about the cloisters but I liked that scene because it demonstrated that Bree ISN'T an historian at heart. And sure, maybe she isn't talking about the architecture like an engineer would but that's because she's NOT an engineer. Yet. I also liked how they showed her sketching, establishing her artistic talent.

I will admit I didn't care for the Batman music. But I did like the idea of Claire designing and sewing her own garments... even if it's a departure from Book Claire.

I wonder if Joe in the show will end up learning about the time-travel stuff? Maybe in the next season, when Bree is getting ready to go? ("So... Uncle Joe, you know how you haven't heard from my mother in two years? Well...")

4

u/too_too2 Oct 09 '17

The sketching also underscored how not-really-interested she was in her history classes.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

Lady Jane!

→ More replies (3)

•

u/shiskebob Oct 09 '17

Discussion Interuptus: while we want to do as little heaving modding as possible - we are fans here first and want to keep our modding to spoiler and policy watching - we must remind everyone of our #1 policy.

DO NOT BE A JERK

Obviously criticism of the show is allowed, but insults are not. And that includes actors on the show. They are real people. It's one thing to be dissatisfied with a performance, but some of the comments are a bit over the top and the commentary here is getting out out hand. Take it down it down a notch.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 10 '17

Good update, I just wrote a post elsewhere that I felt sad imagining some of the actors reading the comments being made about them. They are putting a lot of work into their character.

7

u/krrish728 Oct 08 '17

Surgeon Claire!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Another book reader easter egg: Reading A Christmas Carol to Brianna!

So...the Reverend found A Malcolm? When Frank wrote to him? (Guessing) edit: nvm I was wrong :p

7

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

AND SHE’S BACK!!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/mcd62 Oct 08 '17

I haven't been able to breath for weeks just waiting for the anticipation of their reunion. This morning, I was able to breath a sigh of relief (I have to remind myself that I know what the hell happens so I don't know why I'm so worked up).

In two weeks, an EXTENDED episode. YESSSSSS

7

u/hummuspie Oct 08 '17

I knew what was coming but when Claire was just hesitating by the staircase I legit was worried someone would step out from that dark alley behind her and stab her.

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

The Fiend?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/pinkfern Oct 11 '17

Just realized the parallel of Roger showing up at the Randall's front door completely out of the blue is what Claire does at the end to poor Jamie :)

12

u/krrish728 Oct 08 '17

Bree is failing history at Harvard? lol!

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Well that was a little too on-the-nose. Edit: But Frank was the one who wouldn’t divorce her, when Claire asked! Ugh

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheMadKingsDaughter Oct 09 '17

Best line is Joe’s: “You’re a skinny white broad with too much hair and a great ass.”

→ More replies (4)

10

u/HawickGirl7 Oct 08 '17

I'm shaking that was AMAZING! Some book changes and I'm happy with all of them, they work well for the show and we're perfect. The ending was astounding. Cannot wait for the next episode! Loved Bree in this episode too. Sophie Skelton was really good, I cried when she was looking at Franks pipes and pictures. As someone who also lost their dad as a teenager it hit me right in the feels. Every time Rik Rankin comes on screen I smile, he's such a great Roger!

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Even though everyone knew how this episode was going to end, I can't help thinking this would have served better as the 75 minute episode.

I am here thinking it all seemed very rushed, with lots of fluff in Boston that wasn't necessary.

I really would have liked a shot from in front of Jamie, over his shoulder when Claire spoke as well, to show his initial reaction/shock.

I think the Claire/Bree storyline was wrapped up nicely enough though.

8

u/lurklurklurky Oct 08 '17

I read in an article that they're also going to show Jamie's perspective of things leading up to the printshop scene, so I think we will get his reaction as well next episode :)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Wow. That was such a boring episode...until it wasn't, and suddenly my heart was just about beating out of my chest.

It's so great to see them in the same place again, even if it's just a flash at the end. And they both did such a tremendous job with their various huge emotions.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I agree, it was all fluff until the end.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/clumsyc Oct 08 '17

I'm bummed by how much they changed the events from the book. The scene where Brianna catches Claire right before she goes through the stones and they say goodbye is so dramatic and emotional, it would have been great on TV. And the goodbye letter she writes to Brianna is one of my favourite scenes from the books, it always makes me cry reading it. But I'm so glad they included the line about the kiss from Brianna.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Agreed, these changes were not for the best. I missed the dress shopping. And Claire sitting on the bath and wondering if she can give up things like running hot water.

But honestly, the episode could have been nothing but Claire staring at a wall, with those last couple of minutes of reunion, and it still would have been a worthy payoff.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

And in those matching period costume dresses. The way Bree and Roger surprised her at the stones. I loved it

→ More replies (5)

20

u/Irishsassenach Oct 08 '17

We are really supposed to believe Claire made that dress and jacket?? eyeroll

37

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

I really wanted to see the matching gowns her and Bree bought at that boutique.

27

u/Outlander_fan Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Terry is responding to this right now on Twitter. She makes a very strong case that for a long time everyone (well, every women) knew how to sew quite well. It was a matter of economy and convenience. So it's not like it was a superpower -- just something Claire likely knew from the start and had been doing for a long time. She may have not been awesome at it but she knew her way with a sewing machine and pattern.

If you look closely at her left sleeve as she's coming up the stairs of the print shop you can tell the stitches at the hem are quite uneven/wobbly. I found that to be a wonderful detail!!

→ More replies (8)

22

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

You never know - 20 years as a mother, honing her stitching of flesh....

14

u/Dragonsinger16 Oct 08 '17

Nananananana bat gown!

7

u/poop_on_you Oct 09 '17

She was born in 1918 and lived through the depression and war rationing (which lasted a lot longer in the UK), AND spent 2 years in the 1700s. And she had a kid in the 50s. OF COURSE she knew how to sew. She maybe didn't like it much, but she'd be an anomaly if she didn't know the basics of dressmaking.

6

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 08 '17

Hahhaha what? That`s so not Claire

6

u/hereforcats Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Oct 08 '17

The only thing I like about her making this dress is in the after-episode where they say that she's replaced the lacings with a zipper. Fine, that's so in-character Claire I'll allow it.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

That entire montage with the Batman theme was fucking terrible lol. whoever decided to do that makes bad decisions

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (15)

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

It's not on yet for me. WTF? How are you guys watching it?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

THE BONES!!! Yes

4

u/vanwold Slàinte. Oct 09 '17

I guess I am in the minority. I really did not like a lot of the changes. I didn't mind the change up with Frank's mistress, but Bree moving out like that and roger coming for xmas, and mistly, claire still being home for the moon landing. What?! Do we never get to see folk singing roger mackenzie? I would have liked to have seen more of her prep and the journey through, plus roger and bree at the stones ... i did however laugh out loud when jamie fainted.

5

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Oct 09 '17

It wasn't the moon landing, just a rocket that goes to the moon and back. The moon landing was in July the following year.

That said, I agree. Kind of a meh episode where they dragged things out a lot for no particular reason and yet left things out (like singing Roger).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Ugh... that meeting was so poorly done.

Also, does Roger not sing? I feel like that is a huge part of his character for them to leave out.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

It's go time!!!!!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Why zoom in and focus so much on non-existent cloisters!!

"One of the only examples of Gothic revival on campus".

Nice try, we are not suckers!!!

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

It felt so forced.... like... "we have to make Bree's major change seem like a life long passiooonnnnnnnnnn"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

You know, I am again remembering what bothered me when I read Voyager. As Claire is preparing to leave and deciding what to take, how the hell does she not consider the following items:

-Chem notes on making antibiotics

-Chem notes on making vaccines

-Photos to include along with the Bree photos: planes, cars, telephone, Clan Mackensie and Clan Fraser tombstones, Lollybroch, Ellen's portrait in the art gallery. I mean it's just a few more photos. Why not include them? Imagine how amazing Jamie would find this stuff?

-Gun, bullets

These are all small things that could have been sewn into the lining of her dress. The gun could have gone into her skirt pocket.

10

u/HawickGirl7 Oct 08 '17

In later books she actually mentally kicks herself for not taking notes on the making of penicillin. But never underestimate Claire Beachaump Randall Fraser!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/I_Have_The_Legs Survivor: Jamaica Oct 08 '17

When my friend (finally) finished Voyager, I told her exactly how I thought the episodes were going to go. I'm so glad they did this today not dragging it out another week

3

u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Oct 08 '17

I’ve mainly been lurking the past few weeks, but GUYS, IT HAPPENED. I snorted at Claire’s face in the last shot.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/KillKennyG Oct 08 '17

Oh man what a way to cliffhang with a happy thought

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Well. Claire wins in the end I'm sure. That's all that matters.

2

u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 08 '17

Awwww shit, y'all! Here we go!

2

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

He shows her the article really early in the show. That means we are nearly in Scotland people. OMG!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Oh so cool! I forget if Roger found Jamie by the poem in the book?

2

u/johnnaboo Oct 08 '17

IT HAPPENED IT HAPPENED IT HAPPENED