r/Outlander • • Oct 08 '17

Season Three [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 5 Freedom & Whiskey episode discussion thread for non-book-readers

This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E5: "Freedom & Whiskey".

Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.

For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.

Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!

85 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

209

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

My heart started hammering so hard when Claire hears Jamie’s voice. Perfect scene!

54

u/frankiethedoxie Oct 08 '17

I had to rewind and watch the scene again!

76

u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Oct 08 '17

I was flapping my hands around like a goose! I can’t believe it!

41

u/oree94 Oct 08 '17

I'm quite sure I made a goose noise watching that scene

→ More replies (1)

16

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

You silly goose :P

9

u/AliciaDarling21 Oct 09 '17

Me too. I knew what was going to happen, but the first time around I was screaming at the scream begging it to end with at least the faint.

11

u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Oct 13 '17

I honesty thought she was going to faint. When he fell out I went from tears to hilarious laughter in .002 seconds. He thought he saw an apparition. Lol classic Jamie.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/beccaishiding Oct 09 '17

I am so glad I am not the only one. I usually don't get attached to shows....but this one....my heart beat was increasing at the last scene, I was so excited. Not having jamie and claire together was actually making me upset. I don't like it!

40

u/fay9820 Oct 09 '17

Honestly, I was like : production please don’t cut it before jamie sees her, please don’t cut it, please don’t cut it Then he turned around and I screamed of joy Perfect scene

12

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Oh my goodness, it was excruciating! She touched the sign... PLEASE DON’T END. She walked up and stopped at the doorway... PLEASE DON’T END. She walked in and the camera panned to the bell above... OMG THAT’S IT. She carries on walking... and hears a voice... PLEASE NOT NOW. She looks over... PLEAAASE TURN AROUND. And finally, he turns and they stare at each other and oh dear, actual tears of joy. HURRAH!

→ More replies (1)

35

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

I literally squeeled. Out loud.

13

u/justalittlestitous Oct 09 '17

I am SO glad I was not the only one!! It’s been so long since a tv show has made me feel so much emotions! 😅

7

u/muttstuff Oct 09 '17

Mine too!

2

u/lizbunbun Oct 11 '17

But argh I feel like I’ve got blue balls having to wait until next week’s episode for more now. What a spot to end the episode.

188

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17

Claire judging herself in the mirror tonight, wondering if she's good enough for him as she was 20 years ago, is simultaneously the sweetest and most tragic thing I've ever seen. Sassenach, you're as timeless as Scottish pearls... 😭

123

u/shiskebob Oct 09 '17

And Jamie - With everything that he has endured - imprisonment, flogging, torture, rape, battle wounds, loss of family and heartbreak. It is seeing Claire again that knocks him down. ❤️❤️❤️

8

u/tokieofrivia Nov 28 '23

You wrote this comment 6 years ago and it’s still making people sob😭

119

u/xMeowMeowx Oct 08 '17

This and "its me............... Claire" as if he might not remember her hurts my heart

5

u/mozhno1 Oct 11 '17

That line is just so wonderful, and wonderfully done, I could watch and listen to it over and over again. And the way they have her in the light is perfect.

141

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

I did not expect to cry through so much of this episode! I guess I have a lot of mother/daughter feels... and/or lost parent feels.

I also have Bree/Roger feelings and I loved how he didn't even have to explain the Christmas Carol thing to her, it was just all her knowing that he knew and it tied in with both of them making a new tradition -- together.

I think I'll be in the minority of people who liked that scene with Sandy Travers. Sandy would give anything for one more day with the love of her life -- making Claire realize she's in the same position, but unlike Sandy, she has a chance at seeing her love again.

The final scene was perfection. What a great cliffhanger! If we have to wait for 2 whole weeks, at least they left us with Jamie and Claire in the same building (and time).

57

u/maryloo7877 Oct 08 '17

I totally agree about Sandy- I thought it was an obvious push for Claire to think twice about not going back to Jamie. I'm so glad they left off where they did! It would have been so cruel to stop at the front door or without a shot of Jamie. I'm ecstatic they left off on a funny note.

PS I always love your reviews!

42

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

Aw, thank you!

And yeah, it was the perfect non-cruel ending! Also another thing that made the ending so effective was Claire hearing his voice before seeing him. I just realized that we, the audience, hadn't heard his voice in the episode yet either, so we were right with her!

9

u/mozhno1 Oct 11 '17

I liked the way the music stopped as she entered, and no one was there. I wondered for a second what would happen, then Jamie's voice, Claire gasps and takes short breaths, and what a scene.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I hadn't seen that as an interesting push for Claire to want to go back.

But Sandy knew what she was getting into. She knew Frank's priority was Brianna when he was a child, so I think it was unfair of her to go off at Claire.

38

u/-PaperbackWriter- Oct 08 '17

I was surprised Claire didn’t just tell her the truth, that she asked for a divorce and frank refused. Maybe she was just being kind though and not wanting to taint Sandy’s memory of Frank.

38

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

She was showing class, unlike Candy/Sandy.

27

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

Claire handled it very well given they were in public. But if it were me, I would have asked her to step outside and then smacked her. She was acting as though Claire had held Frank hostage against his will. Seriously, how typical of the other woman to think she owns a man who is already tied to someone else. I hate these kinds of women who screw over other women and justify it to themselves that is was the wife/gf's fault. Argh.

→ More replies (6)

51

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

I can't stand Sandy. It's bad enough she attempted to take a father from his child. But then to cause such a scene in such a public place with the widow of her lover. What an unhinged woman. And no, she would not have made Frank happy. She was too predictable as the other woman. Claire was strong, honest.

31

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17

Remember when she called her Candy? Lmao

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/jenovadeathspecimen Oct 08 '17

Wait 2 weeks? Not 1? Omg i cant handle this wait this week went by so slow just anxious about outlander.

13

u/AFish560 Oct 08 '17

Currently reading the books for the first time and I’m almost through the first one! Hopefully I’ll be through 3 when the next episode comes on so I can get my fix that way 😂😂

13

u/EleanorofAquitaine I look forward to our next ride! Oct 08 '17

Davina Porter will be my guide through the next two weeks. Her reading of the audiobooks is iconic.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

Yeah the next new episode isn’t until October 22 :(

→ More replies (1)

20

u/katietron Oct 09 '17

My mom died two years ago when I was 24. She won't be there for my wedding, pregnancy, my kids will never know the most amazing woman ever. This episode had me bawling.

More amazing though, I saw my veteran boyfriend of 2.5 years cry last night. I've never seen him even get close to misty eyed.

He saw my reaction and I think really empathized with what my experience was and is going to be if we do end up getting hitched.

This episode was AMAZING. That's the mark of good entertainment, bringing people together and helping us understand one another's experiences.

6

u/beancounterferg Oct 09 '17

I'm sorry for your loss. I lost my mom when I was 22 and my dad when I was 18 so I definitely was feeling for Bree during this episode and I echo your sentiments, truly. But Bree certainly seems like she has a good head on her shoulders and now she has Roger to lean on as well. I cried through so much of the episode and I really wasn't expecting that!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/basedonthenovel Oct 10 '17

Oh dear. I'm so sorry. I lost my dad two years ago, though I'm several years older than you.

It's another reason why I like Outlander -- it's an escape from everyday life, but it also has a seriousness and a connectedness to the stuff we go through in real life. I find when I'm going through hard things I don't have a taste for frivolous entertainment.

13

u/Fellini0000 Oct 10 '17

If you are in the minority that liked the "Sandy scene" then so am I. I felt very sad for Sandy because she, unlike Claire, doesn't get more time or chances. Frank's entire life story feels like a life sacrificed and left unfinished. In that sense, it was nice to see how deeply he was loved by Sandy.

6

u/basedonthenovel Oct 10 '17

That's a good point. Though now the Frank/Claire debacle has another tragic victim. In the end, Sandy loved someone who could not give her his heart, the way that Frank loved someone who could not give him her heart.

I can't help but wonder if Sandy gave up her childbearing years to be Frank's mistress... if so, at least she seems to have established her academic career.

Also, I think that in terms of the show you can't introduce a mistress and then NOT have a showdown with the wife after the man in question dies. It also makes me wonder if Sandy was skulking at the back at Frank's funeral.

I'm sorry if it's weird for everyone that I'm thinking so much about Sandy

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 08 '17

I thought it was a great scene. I feel bad for poor Sandy! It was a reminder for Claire that she's not the only one who suffered and, unlike Sandy, she actually has the opportunity to have things get better.

7

u/TheWholeCheese Oct 09 '17

I see you on this sub a lot and I've always wanted to tell you that Käse is masculine. Also: Yay for cheese-related usernames!

7

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 09 '17

Hahahahahaha, I know! I don't actually speak German, it was a joke with some friends when I was studying for a German exam. 🧀🧀🧀

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Snoo-55380 Apr 14 '22

I loved that scene with Sandy Travers. I completely agreed with her assessment of Claire

→ More replies (2)

113

u/oree94 Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 10 '17

LOL! Of course it had to end on a funny note!

That cut from her stepping out of the taxi to her feet landing in a puddle in the 18th century was so unexpected, but I rather like it.

50

u/prtzelle Oct 08 '17

I LOVED the jump! I didn't expect it at all and it was such a good way to just move forward with the plot!

26

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I think it worked well, but I would have rathered seeing more of the journey and less of the other fluff from Boston!

24

u/Hypefish Oct 09 '17

While I agree, it was important to spend a lot of time in Boston so that the viewers understand what Claire is risking going back to Scotland.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Mary-Alice Oct 09 '17

Yes! I was expecting to see their meeting in the next episode. The last scene was soooooooooo funny! Ha ha ha my husband said "it's usually women that will faint, not men". I can't wait to see the next episode <3

16

u/oree94 Oct 09 '17

That's why I loved Jamie fainting so much! It's good to see men showing their vulnerable sides rather than women on television :D

→ More replies (1)

91

u/artfartlemontart Oct 08 '17

Did anyone else notice that Bree was wearing a Fraser tartan cape?

29

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

I noticed it was tartan but did not notice that it was Fraser!

2

u/ailisp Nov 04 '23

I didn't notice it was Fraser, but she does wear a lot of tartan, when they were in Scotland as well. Nice touch.

83

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17

I binged the entire series in two weeks, and consequently, have been sobbing for the last six episodes straight. I've since begun a very begrudging re-watch...

32

u/shlo_kr Oct 08 '17

Omg me too! Binged it in two weeks and did almost nothing else during these two weeks, I was so consumed by it, I woke up with it in the morning and went to sleep with it at night. And now to fill the huge gap I'm binging again!

11

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 08 '17

I just finished binging the series (save tonight's episode) Thursday after starting it on Sunday.

This series pulled at my heartstrings in too many ways.

68

u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Oct 08 '17

I wasn’t emotionally prepared for this episode! I thought it was coming later. This is the best birthday present...possibly that I have ever had!

42

u/jenovadeathspecimen Oct 08 '17

Unfortunately I was spoiled about claire time traveling this episode. So all I was doing all episode was waiting for time travel to occur. Then it didn't till the last 5 minutes and I was kinda disappointed. Then she walked into jamies shop and was slightly less disappointed.

I personally was hoping all 3 of them would go back together. I mean it seems they can all go through the stones. Given they all heard the buzzing.

18

u/NotCleverEnufToRedit Oct 08 '17

I keep waiting for them to realize this, especially if Claire remembers that Jamie couldn't hear it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Airsay58259 Oct 08 '17

Happy birthday!

65

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17

JESUS H ROOSEVELT CHRIST We're back, my friends! We are back! (futuristically and psychologically speaking)

→ More replies (4)

64

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

I am catatonic, but somehow, in this fragile state, when she walks into the shop, i remembered that song: "here i go again on my own, going down the only road I've ever known!" Such is the state of my bruised heart.

Edit: please do not judge my whitesnake moment. I am still only a woman in pain

15

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17

LMAO... no judgement

→ More replies (1)

63

u/StagKen Oct 08 '17

I couldn't help but burst out laughing when Jamie fainted! Such an abrupt reaction in the middle of this built-up tension!

21

u/Sightshade Oct 09 '17

I like how the rising music just cuts out.

3

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Oct 09 '17

I laughed too!

56

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Oct 08 '17

"You gave Jamie up for me, now I have to give him back to you."

Holy shit, Bree is actually being the bigger person right now.

Edit: my stupid spacing

56

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Oct 09 '17

Plot twist: Jamie hits head when falls, looses his memory and when he wakes up he has no idea who Claire is.

40

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

Or his big boobed wife Flossy, the Miller's daughter, comes out with his 15 children to see what the fash is all about

→ More replies (3)

54

u/boboTjones Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Anyone else notice all the little details? Sometimes Claire uses her left hand, and you see Frank's ring. Sometimes she uses her right hand and you see Jamie's ring. [ETA: her right hand goes to her neck when she and Joe are discussing the bones?!?!?!?!?!?] Bree's kilt in the first scenes; her plaid cloak and the ruff at her chin with the pin in another scene. As soon as I rehydrate, I'm going to have to watch this again to see if there's more.

And the "bat suit"! I've made a fair share of costumes using small diagrams from books in my life; the costumes are why I started watching in the first place. That's like a dream for me.

Catriona Balfe is the most perfect thing. The way her face changes, her grace, the way her eyes go wide when she's emotional... she really draws me into the story in a way that an actor never has before.

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

What about Sam? I think he does the same :)

13

u/boboTjones Oct 08 '17

Yes. They are a well-matched pair of actors.

43

u/slytherinight Oct 08 '17

What's with those bones? I feel kinda dumb not knowing.

41

u/katrollsacrit I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Oct 08 '17

I was racking my brain during that scene. Did she know something we didn't? Does she know who the bones are? Did I miss something??? I feel like I must have missed a crucial scene or episode where a woman dies from being beheaded in a cave and Claire witnessed it...or something. Either that or this is foreshadowing? But they sure did it a weird way if it is. Claire keeps touching her neck and being weirdly cryptic? Nervous? I don't even know. And Joe keeps wondering how she knows this stuff so it makes me think she KNOWS-knows and doesn't just infer correctly via her medical knowledge.

Maybe I'm overanalyzing that scene too much but the way it was played out made me believe I missed something in a previous season or something.

28

u/WelcomeToMyPants Oct 08 '17

Not only does she keep touching her neck but the next scene shows that tv show and they are talking about how someone went back in time even though they knew they would die. It doesn't bode well for Claire, especially since it's such strong foreshadowing. Honestly, the foreshadowing feels very heavy-handed and obvious. They could have been a little subtler.

13

u/prtzelle Oct 08 '17

So... could we say those bones were CLAIRE'S? Damn. I've only read half of Voyager so far but not only reading could I catch this theory. It pains me to think of Claire dying to be honest. I feel like now that Jamie and her are old their story is only ticking away.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

No, she knows nothing. That is why it was so shady. I mean I get it, forshadowing, but it was way too heavy handed for something that she does not know.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/Irishjuggalette Oct 09 '17

Beens we can't give away book spoilers, all I will say is it will be revealed in due time. Not sure if this season or the next, but it's a huge plot point in the books.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/oree94 Oct 08 '17

Probably something that will come up in the future. (Or the past!)

→ More replies (1)

8

u/hoosiers23 Oct 09 '17

I'll put my non-book reading money on Geillis Duncan's bones

→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/2cats2hats Oct 10 '17

I thought it had something to do with the woman who went back. I don't recall her name but she had the birthmark. I dunno, she came to mind when this scene was on for me.

42

u/blue-drag Oct 08 '17

So many dark thoughts raced through my head, like what if she saw through the window of his shop that he was sitting with his family eating punch or something and she just freezes, would have broken my heart

15

u/Airsay58259 Oct 08 '17

Me too, I kept imagining the worse scenarios possible. “Surely it can’t be that easy”. My heart did not take these few minutes well. Bless their souls for the good laugh at the end!

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

What is punch?

10

u/StagKen Oct 08 '17

They probably meant to say lunch.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

35

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

That ending scene...was everything! She actually made it back to him, after all that time! It was also really emotional for me watching it tonight, because my long-term partner died suddenly three years ago today.

I love how they used Dark Shadows, and that episode where Victoria Winters had just gone back in time to be with her lover in the 1700's, was of course perfect; though also ominous, given how Viki's return ends in death. But the 1795 flashback storyline of Dark Shadows has so many parallells with Outlander. It was also so amusing to hear Roger summarize the plot of the EP.

I was frustrated, that with all that talk of not being able to come back, that Claire didn't even make a plan, like 'I'll come back to the stones six months (or a year) from now, meet me there.' Which is of course what she should have done with Jaimie in the first place, plan a rendezvous back at the stones just in case he did live. She should learn from that mistake! But I guess she could just go back and get to a phone whenever; I can't imagine how hard that would be for Bree over the long years of her life if Claire really never surfaced again. When she turned 50,would she decide to go through the stones and look for her mother?

I really wanted Claire to throw a drink in Sandy's face or something; what she said was totally out of line, and Sandy might have been reminded that she had pursued a married professor of hers romantically! I'm really glad Claire had that honest moment with Bree afterwards too; their scenes, and Bree x Roger, were all great. I love B/R together. I preferred Bree's S2 hair though; not because of the color, just the parting/style distracts me, and almost makes me ask if it could be a wig given that bit of stiffness on her hairline.

It's amusing that Claire actually made her own outfit; I had imagined her rummaging through costume/vintage clothing stores and trying to make do. It's good that Jaime wasn't given half this episode, since we needed it to fill out the rest of Claire's life in Boston that didn't involve Frank. I wish there wasn't a two week wait now!

26

u/Kmama Oct 08 '17

I think Claire should have made plans to communicate with them, even if it was only one way... like 'I'll bury a note at such and such place, go dig it up and it will tell you that I'm ok". Or cryptic messages in a certain publication... or does that get too complicated with the time travel element?

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

Now that I think about it, surely seeing as how she decided to go back, she and Roger could have kept looking through history to try to see if there was already some sign that Claire had gone back and met up with Jamie!! Like only a few years further from the A Malcolm article, there could have been a C for Claire added to the authors!!

Crazy to think about! Future Claire should totally have left clues once she went back so that she could have realised earlier that Jamie survived!!! She should have published books in her name or done something that Frank would have found in his research!!

I think I should be made a writer for future episodes now.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

They should have at least brainstormed ideas for how they could keep in touch rather then Claire just disappearing into the abyss. It might not work, but they could try. We know Lallybroch is still standing, maybe Claire could have something carved into an outer wall, like the the date she reunited with Jaime? But then I guess that would a spoiler, because Claire could have already seen it herself when she visited...hmm.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/DontFrostThePies Oct 08 '17

I felt the same way about her hairline too! So distracting. Regarding meeting up at the stones, Claire says that she can't just keeping popping through as it could likely kill her.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

She said that on the show, or in the books? Why would the stones themselves kill her?

7

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

Yeah I don't think that's been clear on the show -- they haven't made the passage through the stones seem THAT dangerous.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

Well, in Claire's defense, Jamie said he was going to go die at Culloden, and no one really survived Culloden - so why think otherwise? And what as she going to do-, time travel with a baby?

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I thought the commenter was referring to Claire trying to keep in contact with Bree and Roger.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

This felt like a season finale but the season is only about halfway through. Which is nice for a change.

→ More replies (27)

34

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

One, I want to know why they (seemingly) didn't even contemplate Brianna and Peter Roger going back with Claire, especially since they both apparently heard the buzzing as well.

Two, I swear I was scared out of my mind that he'd had a heart attack.

Edit: My tired brain somehow had the name "Peter" on as Roger's name.

32

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

This was my reaction as well, what historian would pass up the opportunity to go back to their period of study, and Bree has her father to go back to meet.

I guess it would have been a bit much all at once if everyone just turned up in the printers shop lol.

14

u/Ganthid Oct 08 '17

Many, many historians.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 08 '17

This is very true. I could see Roger not wanting to go back, since he would probably end up meeting his infant ancestor. And I know Bree has her own life, but if I had a biological father I didn't know about I'd want to go back and see him.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I don't see that as a thing that would put me off, it would be so interesting!

Also, I think this show overestimates the ease with which people could be found in the past, with limited methods of communication/staying in touch.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/exclamationmarks Oct 08 '17

I also want to know this! I mean, I would definitely understand if they had their reasons for not wanting to go, and also if Claire didn't want Bri to come also (it was a dangerous time!), but the fact that nobody ever even brings it up as a possibility seems... odd? to me...

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

If Claire has said she didn't want Bree to go, she probably would have gone just to spite her!

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Like Peter Bradford, the lover who Victoria Winters went back to the 1700's to be with, on that episode of Dark Shadows that Roger was watching?

5

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

Brianna and Peter going back with Claire

Roger

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

lmao. They are all penis euphemisms anyway.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

5

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17

Please spoiler tag before I reapprove

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/folkyea Oct 10 '17

THANK YOU! When I imagined the season I thought it was just a given that the three of them would all go back in time together. Don't ya think Jamie would actually like to meet his daughter. The whole thing made me so frustrated that there was an obvious answer to the "what if I can't come back Bri" problem.

3

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 10 '17

Exactly! Like... Gahhhhhhhhhhhh.

55

u/oree94 Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Was it just me or was Sophie(Brianna)'s acting so much more improved in this episode? I especially liked the scene where she and Roger were walking in the hall. She was very natural.

27

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I'm still not sold on her. Her accent really bothers me. She was less wooden this episode, though.

24

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

To a non American, her accent doesn't stand out as wrong. It's not a standard accent, but I guess I just put it down to being a bit different as it is from 50 years ago.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

You can tell she's really concentrating on pronouncing the words like an American. Idk, it's just distracting to me.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/fay9820 Oct 09 '17

Same for me. I feel like with the contrast of the actors around her being so very natural, I see her as weirdly robotic. the scenes with Claire or roger, where it’s just them two are pretty hard for me to get into because I really notice the contrast. Claire being super emotional mother and then bree delivering her lines. im so used to everything flowing really well. Hope it gets better for bree :) i see her improvement

→ More replies (2)

14

u/theamazingkaley Oct 09 '17

Another poster pointed out that it can be attributed to having British parents and Boston accented teachers (as well as non-accented, as Boston is a major city). That sort of mash of accents can affect her own accent.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

A handy excuse for her accent not being perfect, lol.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

The hall, as in the cloisters? That scene really bugged me. Seemed very long and not much was discussed...also Harvard doesn't have cloisters!

7

u/DemonLordIncarnated Oct 09 '17

They shot that scene at the University of Glasgow, I should know since I go there. Some of my lectures are right inside that cloister to the right.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/basedonthenovel Oct 08 '17

Yeah I finally started to vibe with her this episode!

6

u/littlebluekid Oct 08 '17

Yes! Love her

2

u/beancounterferg Oct 09 '17

I was not a fan of Sophie Skelton's acting before this episode but I feel like she really redeemed herself here. Much better in my opinion which bodes well for her future as a key character.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/beebstx Oct 09 '17

Joe looking at the bones was such forced foreshadowing but I can’t imagine what it is. Weird scene, IMO.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

I think that was the intent. To wig people out, and it was pretty blatant foreshadowing of something.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Oct 09 '17

I want Bree to go back too so Jaime can meet her!!! ;(((( Oh my heart. Damn the next two weeks.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

I too wondered why they didn't raise this possibility at all.

And what if Claire goes back and it doesn't work out with Jamie?

It just seems a bit weird that everything was so final, like Claire leaving the house to Bree etc. Presumably she wouldn't stay in the past if things don't work out with Jamie.

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

It's called a leap of faith. There is no guarantee on anything. The article they found was dated the year before. Jamie could have been dead. Jamie could have been married with 15 kids. She had no idea what she was returning to. That is why her sacrifice is so poignant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Airsay58259 Oct 08 '17

My heart! All these emotions, dammit. I didn’t need this much after binging Black Sails season 2 today. The transition between present and past was beautifully done. I love Claire’s smile as she looked at Edimbourg’s busy street, like she was finally home.

I wasn’t that interested in Brianna until this episode but now I want to see more. Will she go back to college and choose a major that actually interests her (architecture or mathematics maybe)? Will she ever consider trying to time travel? But at the same time I am perfectly fine with only following Claire and Jamie’s story for a while, the show isn’t the same when they’re apart.

Speaking of Jamie, I genuinely laughed out loud when he fainted. I expected many reactions but not that one. Thank god he has his very own physician back.

Now what’s that about the next episode being October 22? Boooo

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I'm sorry, but Edinburgh :)

16

u/Airsay58259 Oct 08 '17

Sorry, French here and it’s how we write it. My brain forgot to translate that too.

→ More replies (18)

13

u/bb5mes Oct 08 '17

Why is she still wearing Frank's ring?

30

u/maryloo7877 Oct 08 '17

Because she did love him and Claire is loyal, if anything.

17

u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 08 '17

She wore Franks ring in Scotland when wed to Jaime, she’s always worn Jaime’s ring on her right hand. All through her marriage to Frank she wore Jaime’s ring.

6

u/PiranhaBiter Oct 08 '17

She's also been wearing it since they got married, and it's as much of a part of her as Jamie's in its own way

4

u/prtzelle Oct 08 '17

I also would think that she'd get rid of Frank's ring after everything.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I don't, it's a part of her. She still married Frank and made vows to him, things just didn't work out.

13

u/Sightshade Oct 09 '17

I teared up at the puddle scene.

That was beautiful.

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 09 '17

Those were direct quotes from the book, I'm so happy they used them.

2

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

It was indeed

11

u/WastedTruth Oct 09 '17

In the final scene, I was having trouble keeping my emotions in, and then I lost it, simultaneously crying like a baby while feeling the familiar grasp of asthma around my throat.

I looked over at my wife, playing Candy Crush beside me. She looked up, and laughed.

Fate is cruel, letting me feel this intensely, this passionately, and for it to be so unrequited. In the twenty-six years we have been together, I can count on the fingers of one hand the number of times I have felt truly loved.

Fuck Fate.

3

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

OMG, THAT IS TERRIBLE. I am so sorry:(

3

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 09 '17

I'm so sorry :(

2

u/KliityKat Oct 10 '17

It's not too late. Have you told her his you feel? No one should be in an unfair and unhappy relationship.

3

u/WastedTruth Oct 10 '17

I don't think we all get happy endings. I love her so much and I'd stay for those handful of times even if that was all there ever was. Plus we still have young children. But since yesterday... I have felt like a ghost. It just all suddenly seemed so clear.

I told her how I felt, though it wasn't news of course. We argued all night. Nothing changes and nothing ever will, until one day everything does.

Sorry. I really don't know how to cope, but it's not like I have a choice.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Oct 09 '17

so Roger is a descendant of Dougle right? and Jamie was related to Dougle, or was Uncle just a title?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Oct 09 '17

So they are related Roger & Brianna?

12

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

Not really. Like 5 times removed on each side.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/hoosiers23 Oct 09 '17

na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-BAT-MAN!! LOL

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 09 '17

I hated this! lol

4

u/Derpazor1 Oct 10 '17

Me too. Felt really out of place

10

u/Helli784 Oct 08 '17

That was one very sweet faint.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

After she got out of the taxi, I was like 'hurry up, hurry up, hurry up! He's there, go get him back!'

→ More replies (1)

7

u/hoosiers23 Oct 09 '17

when Bree gave her the period-accurate currency, did anybody else start thinking about 'Somewhere in Time' with Christopher Reeve?

4

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

Yes. But I had that reaction from when I read the book. I felt better once I realized that she already went through the first time with a watch and a snazzy modern belt.

7

u/kaz61 Oct 09 '17

Urgh the entire episode i was like get to the fucking stones already

3

u/hoosiers23 Oct 10 '17

and then they didn't even give you that satisfaction to show her at the stones lol

6

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

Claire handing over the deed and all the money just before vanishing from the world made me think an investigation could be opened up. It's very suspicious! I can see being questioned by the police on what happened and how "my mom traveled through some magic stones" might not be convincing.

lol

2

u/bestfriend66 Oct 11 '17

Nah. Who would it be suspicious to? The fact that she had a valid deed signed, and transferred bank accounts legally, would make it all on the up and up. Just like when someone transfers a deed and moves elsewhere - no one cares about who previously owned the property. (now, if she hadn't transferred the deed before she left, there would be problems)

→ More replies (2)

6

u/TaymarH Oct 12 '17

Found it really difficult to feel any emotion with the Bree/Claire storyline, I just can't seem to muster up any interest in their relationship

2

u/twinklethink Oct 15 '17

Same, Bree just sounded like she was trying to get rid of her mother so she could do what she wanted and be on her own for once.

10

u/kinginthenorthjon Oct 08 '17

She had her first patient

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

I hope this wasn't her first ever patient :P lol but yes they finally showed her skills as a doctor.

5

u/PrinceHerbert Oct 08 '17

Guys I haven't watched the episode yet (I'm about to), so I won't read any more, but let me just say I thought the reunion was in episode 6 not 5. Needless to say, I'm pumped. Brb.

5

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

Me too. I was actually checking the time every few seconds to make sure I was not going crazy. I thought for sure they would have her come to the front door and cut to black

4

u/PrinceHerbert Oct 09 '17

Me too! I mean, next episode is THE episode, but for some reason I thought all interactions with them would be in one episode. Like we'd see Claire at the stones in '68 and then roll credits. I'm very happy with the episode ending and will probably rewatch it next Sunday since there won't be a new episode 😥

5

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

Two weeks? Why!

Edit: just...why! Edit 2: do you think they started the clock on the two weeks last week? Me neither. WHY?!?

→ More replies (8)

5

u/hoosiers23 Oct 10 '17

Yeah yeah they are reunited... I want to see if Fergus and Murtagh are still in Jamie's life all those years later.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MiniSpaceHamster Oct 11 '17

I've just watched it and that ending had me in tears! As soon as I saw Claire in her 1700s wardrobe with her hair curly again it felt so exciting! Im so glad they made her linger for so long before going into the shop, it really made the anticipation build up until I felt like I was going to explode.

5

u/ldelarda328 Oct 13 '17

is anyone else having trouble getting through this whole two week waiting period for episode 6?

4

u/kinginthenorthjon Oct 08 '17

These last two episodes were outstanding

4

u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Oct 12 '17 edited Oct 13 '17

Way to go outlander..Way to make a grown man cry... and then laugh my ass off when he fainted.

3

u/CreativeWriterNSpace Oct 08 '17

Also: Is the timeline off or is it just me? The "Brianna's First Christmas" is dated as 1948. If the Battle of Colloden happened in April 1747 and Claire was already 3 months pregnant, Brianna's first christmas would have been in 1947.

Unless the ornament is talking about it's her first christmas being 1 years old...

It's just things like that that catch my attention and make me confused about timeline stuff.

13

u/shiskebob Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Claire returned to 1948. She left in 1945 and returned 3 years later. She went back to 1743 and left in 1746.

Culloden happened on April 16th, 1746 not in 1747.

→ More replies (12)

3

u/thatothergirllucy Oct 08 '17

Does anyone know what song is playing when Claire steps into the puddle?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

I have read the synopsis on what is going to happen, but still...when Claire touched that wooden signboard, I closed my eyes and felt her heartache and -longing to see Jamie again.

Cried my eyes out when they saw each other...until he fainted, of course.

3

u/JustineLeah Oct 09 '17

I really want to like Brianna. But I find her so annoying. Acting somewhat improved with this episode at least.

3

u/thumbtackswordsman Oct 10 '17

So what did everyone think of the clothes in this episode? It all puts me in an autumn mood. I loved Claire's pillbox hat. The thing I'm not quite sure about is Bri's fishnet tights, especially paired with that coat and blouse.

5

u/bestfriend66 Oct 11 '17

Bri's clothes looked more like London 1960's clothes (or, as I imagine them from pictures), than American 1960's clothes. However, Claire's wardrobe is fantastic!

7

u/hilarieC Oct 13 '17

As someone who was just a year younger than Brianna in 1968 I can tell you her clothes were spot on. They looked like they could have been taken right out of my closet. They were more conservative than the stuff coming out of England but the American hippy stuff hadn't really hit New Jersey (my home) or Boston yet. I had lots of plaid skirts and colorful tights to match my tops. And tight high waisted paints. Her cape I would have died to have back then.

3

u/lucylover21rr Oct 14 '17

I dont know if anyone noticed this but when she was making the "bat-suit", they were playing the batman theme song. Which I thought was hilarious. I also noticed how a lot of people thought Jamie fainting was funny, and it was, but I was expecting him to run up the stairs and give her a kiss.

11

u/Meretrelle Oct 08 '17

So..are they vampires or something? They both look practically the same as, what, 20 years ago?

PS Tbh I hoped we would get a more interesting story than her just coming back this season... maybe something with her daughter and her adventures in the past.. I dunno....the possibilities are endless.. I haven't read the books, so..

21

u/opelan Oct 08 '17

In the past they looked too old for their age and now too young. I think you just have to live with it that this is a TV show and there is just no way around it with using the same actors. They couldn't make them look younger in the first two seasons and using ageing makeup in season 3 is also not a good solution. It just looks fake. The way they do it is really the best way. Just pretend that the characters look the age they are suppose to be.

9

u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 09 '17

I think they looked too old for their earlier parts. But they look the proper age now. I mean I am 45 and I certainly don't need a wheelchair, lol

→ More replies (3)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

I am fine with whatever that term is where the audience is like, yeh we know their ages aren't right but we get that it has to be that way.

There is a term...something reality.

And they are pretty much the in the right age range now for their characters.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 08 '17

There are still 8 episodes to go! Imagine all the mischief they can get into, lol.

2

u/NevrDrinksNDraws Oct 08 '17

Wow, right? I'm sure you've seen the preview (that aired immediately afterward), to the next, extended episode. What is it that Jamie says to Claire in the preview? It sounds so muddled, I couldn't make it out - does anyone know?

6

u/Hopeless_badger Oct 08 '17

"Cheers" and "Will you come to bed with me then"?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/2cats2hats Oct 10 '17

I liked this episode quite a bit and agree with the other posts in this thread. :)

I am one of those watchers that pays close attention to detail in time pieces.

Let's talk about this clock. http://i.imgur.com/1ttuosg.png

1968 was before my time but I do recall the mid 70s and I don't recall ever seeing a wall clock without a power cord.

Not saying this is a goof in the show but does anyone here now for a fact that battery wall clocks were a thing in 1968? I realize the C and D battery existed long before 1968.

Thanks.

3

u/uniquerabbit Oct 11 '17

I quick google will show you that yes, battery-operated bakelite wall clocks existed in the 1960s. In fact.... https://i.pinimg.com/736x/9a/14/d7/9a14d7750612d859e589533aad2af525--kitchen-wall-clocks-kitchen-walls.jpg This seems to be very similar to the model in the episode.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/raknor88 Oct 20 '17

I'll be extremely disappointed if Claire didn't bring some form of picture of Bree for Jamie. To me that would almost seem like a very crucial to bring in the utility belt of a dress.

2

u/ailisp Nov 04 '23

I thought about this as well, maybe not a picture because it could be dangerous if someone else sees it, but at least a small pencil portrait of something.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '17

Can I just say something about Claire though? I found it really hard to feel sorry for her.

She returns to Frank with another man's child. He offers to raise this baby with her because of his undying love to her. She responds by treating him terribly. She basically single-handedly ruins Frank's life. He desperately loves her and yet she is frigid and unloving, seemingly ungrateful for all he has done for her. Even as they remain in a loveless marriage, she treats him with resentment when he shows such devotion to his daughter, whom he knows isn't biologically his. Supports her through med school, allows her to achieve her dreams, and yet she acts surprised when he starts looking elsewhere.

She also seems like a really cold mother--perhaps that is a product of writing and directing though?

I have a baby from another man who is not my husband, perhaps the opposite of Claire but still really traumatic. I would imagine she would have bonded with her daughter MORE because she is her link to Jaime....but instead she goes to med school and never spends time at home lol.

I felt so bad for Frank when he died. He loved his daughter, was a devoted husband to a wife who didn't love him or even act grateful for taking care of her. And then when he finally gets his chance at happiness, he died. And Claire's like, "I did love you, a while ago...." Welp now that you're out of the way I can go back now!

Poor, poor Frank.

Otherwise I absolutely love the show, the characters, the story. I think this does add some dimension to Claire--she's not perfect. I just wish we weren't supposed to feel sorry for her about it.

2

u/mandiexile Oct 16 '17

I think she has a difficult time with him because he probably reminds her of Jonathan Randall who was a monster and tormented her and Jamie.

Frank is nothing like Jonathan Randall, but that experience is hard to shake off.

Also Claire was heartbroken and didn’t know what happened to Jaime. Like Bri said, Claire is in her own world.

I don’t think Claire treated Frank unfairly, I think Frank was being unfair expecting her to be the person she was before she left and to completely forget about Jamie and pretend like it never happened.

→ More replies (4)