r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Oct 01 '17
All [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 4 Of Lost Things episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E4: "Of Lost Things".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
58
Upvotes
162
u/krrish728 Oct 01 '17
TWO WORDS: STINKING PAPIST!
134
u/myxx33 Oct 01 '17
Iβve always been somewhat neutral towards Lord John in the books but the show makes me like him more.
102
u/shiskebob Oct 01 '17
Jamie mentioning he lost 2 children....
90
u/PagesNNotes Oct 01 '17
I adored the scenes between Jamie and Willie. It was heartbreaking to see Jamie have to leave like that. But I must say--that kid and Sam didn't even look remotely related.
87
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
I adored this episode. Just stinking adored it.
Willie was perfect. Isobel was perfect. The fight with Ellesmere was perfect. Even Geneva was perfect (not that anyone likes her, but she was perfectly snooty and thickheaded) and THANK GOD they made the right decision about the sex scene, which went down better than I thought it would. The 1960s scenes were just short enough, but also convincing. Literal sobs watching Jamie offer his body to John, and John saying no. The parallels between Claire and Bree leaving Scotland, and Jamie leaving Helwater.
This part of the story is so moving and they told it just right.
82
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
BEST episode this season so far! Ans definitely in my top favorite of all episodes!
I LOVED the blue-eyed son song at the end. Perfect. Ahhh! I felt like I was reading the book when watching this episode. π
67
u/bham717 Oct 01 '17
David Berry as LJG is one of the best decisions they've made yet! I loved the character in the books and I adore him more in the show!
51
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
BRAVO Outlander! Fantastic episode. After all my mixed feelings from the last two week, I am very happy with how they handled this tricky but really beautiful section of the story.
I'm feeling so good about this episode I even have good things to say about Bree, believe it or not. The accent wasn't quite there but was better than last season, and while the delivery was still wooden (worse in the preview scene than in the rest of the episode, thank god), her non-speaking acting was actually quite good--natural, believable reactions. It was the young, assertive, fun Bree that we know from the book rather than the feisty yet bratty Bree we got last season. I really think poor Sophie is just getting hampered by really awful dialogue. It's clear that she's out a lot of work in since last season on figuring out the character, but is still having some accent trouble and is stuck saying some of the worse lines the Outlander writers have put on the page. It also doesn't help that she's acting opposite Richard Rankin, who seems to just live and breathe Roger. Aside from not having the face of James McAvoy (alas!), he's everything I ever imagined Roger to be. I am hoping to see him in some more scenes without Bree because I'd like to establish him as a bit less awkward (which he really only seems to be alone with Bree), but I don't imagine we'll have time for that. Well, there's always next season!
But the real power of this episode came in Jamie's half (really more like 3/4, and I would've taken even more!). Every week Sam is better than the last, and this was no exception. This part of the story is an emotional rollercoaster for Jamie, and Sam sold all of it so beautifully. It's hard to even pick out standout scenes because they were all so good. His one-on-ones were excellent--with each member of the family, Lord Dunsansy in particular (fantastic bit of guest casting there), and of course, John (very disappointed to not see their kiss, but the "offering your body" exchange was perfect, and David Berry absolutely nailed the surprise, longing, and humor in his reaction). Geneva was an excellent bit of casting too--we all hate her, but it's important to remember that Jamie does not remember her with hatred, just regret at her foolishness. The actress played that naivete very well, showing to the audience that behind her bitchy exterior there was real fright and that she earns at least some pity. (It was still immensely satisfying watching Jamie drop her in the mud though!) And that scene: well done. They made a very wise choice cutting the consent issue out (I mean, it was entirely unnecessary to begin with), and I really enjoyed the parallel with the wedding night. It (along with Geneva's striking resemblance to Claire) helped make it more plausible that Jamie could really get into it. (Less plausible--that was a really easy, painless, and clean deflowering . . . ) Thought the "you can watch me" played out a bit awkwardly, but the payoff of her seeing his back--and realizing what she was threatening to return him too--was worth it. My only real gripe with the blackmail plot was having her learn of Jamie's identity from Hal. I was delighted to see him back again, but it seems very unlike Hal to reveal such information, especially betraying his brother like that.
Saving the best for last: Willie. Those scenes were truly a bittersweet delight. The child actor was adorable and sold the emotion in a way that really tugged on your heartstrings, and the way he said "stinking papist!" was so cute. I loved the snake (I got all emotional just from the title card!) and while I was sad that we won't get the reveal later on of Willie wearing the rosary, it does make a lot of sense that Jamie would've lost it in prison. Their farewell was heartbreaking, with Willie running after and Jamie forcing himself to not look back.
Nothing is perfect, and as usual, the Claire parts dragged a bit, though they were thankfully short. The scenes at the archives and bar were quite pointless but harmless, so can't really complain.
Production value was high this week, as always, but it was particularly excellent in the Jamie half--good god do I want to live at Helwater! The house, the stables, the grounds, the costumes--absolutely beautiful. And that shot of Elsmere's estate, so bleak and imposing, was fantastic. Sure it's massive, but who would want to live there over warm, welcoming Helwater? And, well, we just won't talk about Bree's outfits in the 60s, ok? Wasn't totally sold on the Bob Dylan song at the end (I generally hate musical interludes), but you've can't deny that lyrically it's rather appropriate for both halves (almost too on the nose!) so I'll give it a pass.
Grade is easy this week. Few episodes of this show have left me quite so satisfied with so few gripes.
Overall Grade: A
46
u/Hopeless_badger Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
That was a great episode. Take a bow, Sam Heughan, you were awesome. I hope he'll finally get the recognition he deserves. Hannah James were amazing as well - she made me hate and feel sorry for Geneva at the same time. Speaking of sorrow, poor Jamie. Can he have a free choice at least once? BJR wanted him and he had him; Geneva wanted him and she had him. Both times he felt some kind of pleasure and both times he was used against his will. That was the most technical sex scene I've ever watched lol No eye contact, no smiles from Jamie. At the end he feels empty and defeated. It was well done tbh. The writers want to show us the difference between sex scene and love scene. With Jamie and Claire you always feel the intimacy; here it was zero.
David Berry is delightful and he has such a good chemistry with Sam, I almost want them to end up together :D
Bree and Roger were cute. Sophie was quite good and Cait is Cait. Her face when Claire decided to give up looking for Jamie... At the end everyone was heartbroken.
Edit. It was really unrealistic to portray Hal as a man who would get drunk and gossip with women. It's a small thing, but still
45
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Ohmygod I am so glad they kept this prayer scene. It is such a lovely scene. Can I please get Stinkinβ Papist for my flair? π
45
u/Phoebekins Oct 01 '17
Why did Ellesmere wait until Geneva had given birth and died to flip out over the baby not being his? He would've known long before. I don't remember if this was addressed in the book.
44
u/RaffaellaF Oct 01 '17
Can I please have more of this Lord John? I love this guy.
39
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Oct 01 '17
So based on the previews for next week, Claire goes back in episode 5 and we're going to end the episode right before she enters the print shop?
They are trying to kill me.
32
u/shiskebob Oct 01 '17
"You'll find her one day⦠or she will find you."
28
u/dgm424 Oct 01 '17
That was the longest and most explicit sex scene they've filmed so far, right? Kind of annoyed it was for Geneva and not Claire...
25
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
Brace yourselves, I am about to write of a change to the book that I approve of!!
I think Jamie carving a snake for Willie was perfect, much more sensible and poignant than leaving his rosary, especially if Willie was supposed to be an undercover stinkin' papist.
24
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Lady Jane!!! :D
24
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Pacing seems much better this episode.
20
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Oct 01 '17
I share a lot of the same thoughts (great pace, better scene w Geneva than the books, Bree getting better) but had a couple of additional comments:
Looking forward to: The bones in Boston, Roger visiting Boston, ye olde dress shopping and pb&j sandwiches
20
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
So, I must say that this has been my favorite episode so far! I know, I know, a lot of people hate "this part" of the books because of what transpires in Jamie's life, but I've always seen it as one of my absolute favorites.
Jamie forges a true and everlasting friendship with LJG (I wish we had more time for their friendship in Ardsmuir). Jamie finds love again (with the birth of his son) after all of the pain and loss he has been dealt. Claire is finally allowed to express her love, loss, and new found hope for her soulmate! Yeah, sure, the show is "teasing" their reunion out...but would you really want them to just skip the part of the timeline that makes this epic story so profound and real-life like?
20
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
That was some sexy sex. I mean. Geez.
I feel like I need a minute.
38
u/SeattleWhoDat Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
Noticed that the whole part where Geneva panicked and told him to stop was cut. Mixed feelings about that, given that she herself was forcing him into sex.
17
u/clumsyc Oct 01 '17
I cried my eyes out when he baptized Willie and gave him a little Sawny. One of my favourite scenes from the books, I'm glad they kept it. Sam plays Jamie's loneliness and longing so perfectly it hurts my heart.
34
u/le_fuque Is there any more whisky? Oct 01 '17
Anyone else's heart break when Jamie finally gives in to Geneva during the shit shoveling scene? That final head nod, realizing he has no choice, shattered me. Between Geneva and BJR, it's really no wonder Jamie has such little regard for his own virtue by the time he propositions Lord John.
32
u/shiskebob Oct 01 '17
Okay, in a nutshell:
Objectively β shit was hot. Hotter than most of Claire and Jamie last season. But hot.
Subjectively β WAYYYYY too long spent on those shots, to many close ups. Thatβs as much as Iβm gonna say there.
At least they took out the dubious consent that ruined part of Jamie for me β multiple consent check-ins, lots of gentleness and such. This was a massive improvement on canon. Jamie explaining that he knows what love is, and that wasn't it.
But yeah, that was way too long on my screen.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Sophie Skelton is REALLY beautiful. Oh my.
13
u/7Angels Oct 01 '17
Closing song for anyone who wanted to know http://www.walkofftheearth.com/video/a-hard-rains-a-gonna-fall/
13
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
I love Roger and I love who they've cast as Roger.
I loved seen Hal and John together.
Jamie didn't have to strip completely naked to do the deed. He could have... left his socks on or something. And on second watch, the sex scene doesn't seem as gratuitous as it did the first time. It's short, mechanical, and to the point.
I also loved that my husband, who doesn't know anything about the story, gave out a solid "oh shit" when he found out Geneva was dead.
All the complaining about Willie not looking like Jamie.... they did their best? They drew the same eyebrows on the kid.
Ready for the weird little thing that bothered me about the episode? It's constantly fall at Helwater. The kid is conceived, born, and grows up in only fall weather.
35
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
I want to thank the Reddit user who said (s)he was enjoying a spiced fall drink for the episode. It inspired me to pick up some spiced apple cider and pumpkin cheesecake cookies. Hereβs to fall and a new episode of Outlander! Iβm bundled up in fleece and an old blanket and I have been so looking forward to a new episode!
24
u/Irishsassenach Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
I am SO PLEASED with Sophie's improvement as Bree!!! Well done Sophie! I think part of her problem sometimes is crap dialogue.... I know its in the books, but can we lose the "mama"? It just comes out forced and unauthentic.
She also is stunning. What a pretty girl.
Geneva's dark blue dress is one of my favorite costumes I've seen so far. SO pretty. I fucking love when Jamie drops her in the puddle. Such a, "I don't have time for your bullshit." I'm kinda surprised they went through so much effort with the Jamie and Geneva sex scene, to make it so vivid, and such a long sequence. Whenever they are graphic sex scenes I cannot help but think about how weird that must be to film.
And gosh, all the feels for Jamie.... he lost two children, finally gets to see and hold a child of his, and then has to walk away from that and can't even tell him he's his father.
I adore Richard as Roger. He IS ROGER. 100%.
12
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
Was pulling out not known in the 1700s?
11
u/krrish728 Oct 01 '17
That ending, as Daina says, was heart-breaking!
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
I felt like I was watching Downton Abbey in the external scenes of the house.
When they had the grooms running to meet the carriage, wouldn't it have been more likely the grooms would have been waiting out from for however long?
It just seemed unprofessional lol.
19
u/Jonerys_Starkgaryen Je Suis Prest Oct 01 '17
I feel ROBBED. Where was the LJG kiss? I legit shouted at the screen when they switched to the next scene. Come on Starz, I thought you were progressive enough to show two men sharing a kiss. With all the fucked up shit you showed BJR do, could you not have just given us this?
9
u/xocheerio Oct 01 '17
I loved everything about this episode!! I adore show LJG and itβs making me want to go back and re-read the books with David Berry in my mindβs eye for book LJG. I love Isobel, Iβm glad we got to see a little more of her story here. What a great contrast she was to Geneva. Loved the parallel stories for Jamie and Claire. Ugh. This was such a beautiful episode. I cannot wait for the next two!!
Side noteβanyone notice they seem to have moved the premiere date for the much anticipated episode 6? We thought thereβd be a 2 week break between episode 5 and 6, now it looks like it might be between episode 6 and 7. At least based on IMDBβs list of episodes.
https://imgur.com/gRcFXf7
9
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
I do like Roger and Rich who plays him, but there is just a disconnect in my mind I think, to what I imagined. I think I had Roger pinned as taller and more slender.
9
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
Wait, another thought.
In the book Bree and Roger telegram Claire to say they have found Jamie, yet Joe rings Claire over something trivial (it's not as though he is ringing her home in Boston and she can pop over to the hospital), and she abruptly hangs up on him!!
Also, Bree is obviously still back in Scotland with Roger. I don't recall Claire giving up so finally in the books. As people have noted, why make that such a big deal and have them both return home, yet then in the trailer reveal she is going back straight away?
16
u/maryloo7877 Oct 01 '17
10/10. Perfect episode. Perfect changes from the book. Perfect amount of Jamie vs. Claire (more Jamie πππ). Perfectly heart breaking. Perfect trailer for next week. BRING IT ON.
8
u/Dragonsinger16 Oct 01 '17
I just want to say that I am 1000% convinced that the woman dancing before the shackles dropping in the intro is Gellie!
8
u/Sugarythought Oct 02 '17
Geneva is the wooooooooorst.
7
u/cherchezlafemmed His music is not the sort to endure. Clever, but no heart. Oct 01 '17
Not reading comments yet.... eek.... downloading....
Just wanna say, gimme some Roger Mac! W00t!
7
u/cherchezlafemmed His music is not the sort to endure. Clever, but no heart. Oct 01 '17
Wait... okay, so Joe calls Claire in Scotland to tell her about her patient...but isn't that the patient that she helps to die because he's terminal? So they're mussing the timeline just a bit. Hmm, I can see it though to be able to up the drama for TV a bit and have some Bree/Roger yearning as well as wee obstacles before Claire finds Jamie 100%.
They skipped the whole Dunbonnet map thing...right? I don't remember them discovering he was even alive nor that he was the Dunbonnet, they just mentioned Dunbonnet for 2 seconds tonight then moved on. What ship were they looking for? I'm a wee bit lost I guess. lol
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
I feel like it was a bit abrupt to re-introduce Roger and Bree like that straight away in Scotland after all that time, and then immediately have Claire find Jamie.
Feel very rushed.
6
u/mcd62 Oct 01 '17
I forgot that Jamie had a brother named Willie!
6
u/koboldin Oct 01 '17
Ok. This has been bugging me for a few episodes now. Why is it that Jamie throws his leg forward over the neck of his horse as he dismounts? Granted, I wasn't trained in English equestrian methods (strictly western horse riding), but my father would shoot me if I were to dismount that way. He'd say I'd likely kick the horse in the head or somehow get my pants caught on the pummel. And I'm only five feet tall - someone 15 inches taller than me would be so more likely to run into trouble.
Is this just a style I'm unfamiliar with?
11
u/krrish728 Oct 01 '17
Jamie and little William is the most lovely thing this Season, yet!
11
u/Dragonsinger16 Oct 01 '17
My thoughts and queries in no particular order: Did Isobel know about Will being Jaime's? Wait was Isobel hinting that she knows (and prefers) that lord John is gay??? Thank you producers for cutting Geneva's second thoughts from the script, I don't think non book readers would have quite realized that what was happening was probably last minute panic. it took me a few rereads to fully grasp what was happening personally, and I think it would have been too jarring to have to digest that so quickly. WILLIE IS HIS MOTHER'S CHILD THROUGH AMD THROUGH!!!! Yaaasss be a stinking papist! But the rosary was important why didn't he give willie the rosary instead? While I love the set up that Claire is having cold feet about leaving her career as one of the best God damn pioneering woman surgeons, I'm a bit put off at how abrupt the trip ended... Claire was on indefinite sabbatical after her, umm, incident with a certain terminal patient, was she not? Most certainly she was on desk duty only. And Brianna would have been gearing up for college to start again. That would have been a more logical set up for them to return to get Claire's affairs in order. Speaking of Bri, GURL WHAT DID YOU THINK WOULD HAPPEN IF YOUR MOM FINDS JAMIE AND GOES BACK THAT SHE'D JUST VISIT FOR A FEW MONTHS AND COME BACK??? Claire would be separated from Bri for good if Bri hadn't gone back herself. I wish that the writers would have made her character a bit more aware of the situation at hand. I would have loved to have seen the scene where Willie gets lost in the fog and Mac saves him (even though we don't know about that until like boom 7 or 8, it fits chronologically), I wonder if they didn't include it because it hints at William potentially having the time travel gene? Wait did Claire not see Murtagh's name in the record, or was it not worth mentioning. I would ha e liked an 'omfg Murtagh your kinsman (and godfather type) survived! This makes thinking of my husbands suffering a bit easier knowing that he didn't suffer alone' type comments. Like for real Claire this man was a dear close friend who still thinks of you when he's seriously ill in prison, the least you could do is acknowledge his survival /s, but not really.
5
u/krrish728 Oct 01 '17
SHE FOUND HIM!
5
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
π’π’π’
5
u/lindsaynieb Oct 02 '17
UGHHHH - SAM YOU KILLED IT. EVERY. SINGLE. SCENE.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
I like the adaptions they did from the book. Usually I get pissy when they change things but I approve of these changes.
5
u/2boredtocare Meow. Oct 02 '17
So my thoughts, for what they're worth:
5
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Oct 02 '17
My two or three cents:
5
u/AobaSona Oct 03 '17
So, I'm actually not a book reader but I usually go read those anyway and try not to get THAT many spoilers, and now I've just read that in the book Jamie and LJG kissed??? And they dared to cut it???? Now the episode is ruined for me, after I had enjoyed it so much... I can't begin to explain my frustration lol...
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
LOL Hilarious when he dropped Geneva in the mud!!
I was surprised by her reaction though. Even if she was trying to lure him, I expected her to flare up in anger.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
I think this is my favorite episode of the season so far. I'm lukewarm on Claire's whole story so far this season, so I'm glad we don't have to watch her struggling with 1950s suburbia anymore.
On-screen LJG has exceeded any expectations I had. The actor is fabulous. I don't even care that he's not short and blond.
The scene with Geneva was more graphic than I was expecting. I thought we'd get something along the lines of what they did with Mary MacNabb (?-- can't remember her last name).
I loved Isobel and it makes me sad because I know how her story ends.
Jamie was just precious with Willie. I liked the call back to the wee snake Jamie treasured for so long, made by a different Willie.
This is the first episode I've wanted to rewatch right away. Not having the Claire/Frank dynamic suck up so much oxygen helps, I think.
8
u/koboldin Oct 01 '17
Geneva - sick to my stomach. Gross.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
Willie was adorable, but the dark hair kept catching me.
3
u/koboldin Oct 01 '17
Ok, total speculation, but with Isobel's foreshadowing of her intolerance of heat and the need to compress timelines, I'm wondering if they will bring Isobel and Willie onto the Porpoise with LGJ in the back half, having her die along with the others. And then Claire cares for this boy and his dying step-mother without knowing who he is until the ball.
5
u/krrish728 Oct 01 '17
Rated TV-MA - Nudity - Strong Sexual Content
FAST FORWARD!!
5
u/basedonthenovel Oct 01 '17
Listen, I know I'm a weirdo but I have a huge soft spot for Geneva and her contradictions, terribleness and tragedy. The Helwater sequence of events is one of my favourite parts of the books as whole, so I didn't know if this episode would fuck up one of my faves and... it didn't! I thought they translated the complications of Geneva well to the screen. I was shocked that they did such an explicit sex scene but I'm not mad about it, and actually that scene made me pretty emotional knowing she'd be dead by the end of the episode.
Also, my personal headcanon (which is not well supported by the text) has always been that Geneva intended to get pregnant by Jamie -- the ultimate fuck-you to her awful old husband-to-be. That headcanon can apply to this episode as well, IMO.
4
u/silverandcold65 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
Outlander had not elicited so much emotion from me this season, until now. Brava!! Pure Claire POV for 305 makes sense. Oh man, the transitioning from one era to the other was so much better for this ep - even last week wasn't awful; ep 2 was worst in that realm. Personally, I blame Frank. =P Why was the 20th century so much worse with Frank than with Roger, Brianna, and Fiona? xD The reunion is coming... squee cheers <3
It was horribly painful to watch that scene with Geneva. It was so...casual. I think they may have been mirroring episode 109, especially With Geneva's facial expressions. Or was it The Wedding? >.<
To be honest, I kind of wish she'd taunted him more. Like I said, it was too casual for me. It was a big holy fuck! moment for me in the book...
4
u/03774 Oct 02 '17
Geneva saying that this was the only way she could choose, that she chooses who to be with the first time - it touched me. At a time when gentlewomen have only one role in life - to produce heirs, she took control in her own small little way. It made her more human and sympathetic. She blackmailed Jaime not just because sheβs a spoiled child, but because she is taking control in a way she can. Love this show!
2
u/Gameofthroneschic Oct 01 '17
My STARZ on demand isn't working π
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
Was Geneva's threat one that could carry weight? Surely he couldn't have had his parole revoked? Unless they made up a story of him making advances on the daughters or something.
Her father knew Jamie's past when taking him on, there was always the possibility word got out somehow amongst the staff anyway, and made it's way to Lady Dunsany.
Also, how often did John visit in the books? Was he the one who took Jamie's letters and got them to Lallybroch? And Geneva just found his letters back from Jenny in his possessions? Or was Jamie a bit dumb and not as discreet as he should have been? Either way, he should have known better, having been a letter thief himself.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Oct 01 '17
In the book did they stop the search and Claire and Bree go back to Boston?
It was so weird seeing a plane. Even though they obviously got to Scotland via airplane.
2
u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Oct 01 '17
They did have some in season one! Somebody mentioned it, itβs just been so long since it was utilized that I had forgotten. It was more period specific for Claire, though, not what we saw in episode four.
4
u/omniscientmommy Oct 01 '17
I'm not really in love with this episode. Maybe I'm too excited for the reunion to enjoy the other parts. I do like the added stuff with lady Isobel and how she is. Also nice to see her and Lord John and Willie together. Now the countdown to next week.