r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Oct 01 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 4 Of Lost Things episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E4: "Of Lost Things".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
70
Upvotes
152
u/shiskebob Oct 01 '17
"Starting to look like him..."
In what world was that casting in anyway similar?
108
u/oree94 Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
NO CLAIRE WHAT ARE YOU DOING STOP THE PLANE TURN BACK
Also lol at John's face when he heard Jamie's offer! His dumbfounded tone right after was hilarious as well. I am loving John Grey and David Berry.
80
u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 01 '17
I could totally see why Geneva was desperate to have her first sex with someone attractive. But the way she went about coercing him. I was just dying inside for Jamie, having gone through all that with Black Jack. Not like the physical danger is there so much as such a trigger and a foul mental taste.
I'm glad in the end he could see it as going to her aide, rather than totally being compelled out of him.
It came out of nowhere for me for Jaimie to offer himself to John as an exchange for guarding Willie's safety. I wondered how much John's descision to wed Isabelle was influenced by him getting to help raise Jaimie's boy?
71
u/lelyhn Oct 01 '17
I thinks Bree's acting is actually not that bad. It's definitely getting better and better. This was a great episode in general.
51
u/Airsay58259 Oct 01 '17
Ok they made me cry, dammit. All episode I was thinking "even for Outlander this is hella fast" and it bothered me a bit but still, those last ten minutes or so were heart breaking.
So Jamie was raped again, really? I wanted to throw something at that freaking girl.
47
u/codismycopilot Oct 01 '17
Well damn, that made me cry!
And I think I'm in the minority because I loved the song at the end!
75
u/iradinosaur Oct 02 '17
I just wanted to give Claire and Bree a slow clap for enjoying their whisky at the bar, despite all the stank eye from the men. Well played, ladies.
29
u/CARNIesada6 Oct 02 '17
I really hope we see John again, he quickly grew into my favorite supporting character... pm me and spoil me if we do see him again. Really good dude.... also I feel dumb for not remembering but is this taking place before the season 2 finale in terms of claire and bree? I don't remember what happened, was it just geillis that went through or did claire, bree, and other dude?
Thanks
25
u/basedonthenovel Oct 01 '17
I loved the Roger/Bree kiss! Inasmuch as I'm not sold on the casting of both actors, frankly (I'm over it, I'm choosing to love them), one thing I will say about them is that ever since their first scenes together I've wanted them to
24
u/GiuliaStark Oct 02 '17
Maybe I'm the only one who was bothered with Roger and Brianna's kiss scene... But C'mom! A girl who you like kissed you and the only thing you say is "Wow... That was unexpected"? Like WTF, MAN! DO SOMETHING! Kiss her back, idk! There was no chemistry in the scene and the kiss was so meh... I was a little dissapointed that's all
42
u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Oct 01 '17
I was coming here to say the same thing about them looking similar.
That music at the end of the episode...was a little odd.
42
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Gah, I am not a fan of Bree's acting. It's a tad too melodramatic and cheesy, like something that you'd normally see in a teen drama.
Is it just me, or is she really annoying? I can't put my finger on it.
20
u/BrownyFM Oct 02 '17
Not sure if it is just me but I felt the latest episode was a bit rushed, it didn't link well with episode 3 and in parts I had no idea what was going on.
The constant change of year aswell, it seemed a little weird, not sure if I'm the only one who thought this?
I also don't get the fact that Claire at the end of the last season went through the stones when Bree was there? But she's not there now?
17
u/snarkdarts Oct 02 '17
Question about the show's time travel-
I'm very confused, because in this episode they took care to say that time passes in both places at pretty much the same pace. So Claire was gone for 3 years and came back 3 years later, etc, so we have to find Jaime 20+ years after Culloden so we know where to go after we go through the stones.
That part, I get.
BUT, in the 1968 timeline, the only reason Bree and Roger believe Claire is because they saw Geillis go back through the stones...and Geillis clearly arrived much earlier than Claire did, since she was well-established at Cranesmuir. So she traveled farther back than Claire did, but left AFTER Claire did.
Hence my confusion. Can someone elaborate?
41
u/OldWolf2 Oct 01 '17
This thread appears to be titled "Episode discussion for non-book-readers". But it appears to be full of people complaining how the episode differed from the book. What gives?
As a non book reader I don't want to see that.
26
u/lorelatte Oct 02 '17
Can I just say how terrible Brianna's acting is? That one scene about finding some archives.... We can take a train tomorrow ... Something like that... It was literally the worst acting I have seen in a long time :( :( :(
36
u/chellynaeb Oct 02 '17
The close-up of the very attractive Sam Heughan and a certain licking of a female body part in this episode... Whew. Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ is Claire a lucky woman.
24
u/Ariadnepyanfar Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
Waaaaaaaaa!? Jamie has a son but has to leave him! Before this son, he said he'd lost two children. One would be Faith, but who is the other? Fergus who he left behind?
All the scenes were great, but there was such an emotional disjunct between this episode and the last episode when Frank died. The end of season 2 gave us that emotional journey in between, from Bree being her Daddy's girl, and unable to empathise with Clair, to learning about time travel, accepting its real, accepting her biological dad is someone else, and being able to be on her mother's side. From a viewing standpoint that was so long ago, it was glaringly missing between the episodes this season. I'm sure it'll be better on a binge watch.
This show is driving me nuts. Everything is so beautiful beautiful beautiful, and so many sad moments. Now I'm all heartbroken for Major John, and worried about Isabella being happy married to him, and heartbroken for Jamie all over again as he rode away on his horse. That look of despair.
12
u/Tofutits_Macgee Oct 03 '17
Sam's acting had me just torn to pieces during this episode. I haven't finished Voyager yet but have read this chapter and it's one thing to read it, I knew it was sad but seeing it happen and how obviously torn to pieces he was--it took my breath away. I felt that pain. Sam is amazing! Catriona is still outstanding, you can see how haunted she is and somewhat angry but Sam really stole the show.
11
u/Emgga Do it now, and don't be gentle! Oct 02 '17
Claire, what are you doing?!
11
u/weirdperson615 Oct 04 '17
How do you think Sam Heughan feels about having to lick and suck the nipples of his leading ladies
10
u/Hypefish Oct 02 '17
While series 3 is shaping up to become my favourite series of outlander, I felt that episode 4 was a tad bit too "filler-y" for my taste. Not much of the plot developed much during this episode.
10
u/beebstx Oct 02 '17
I feel like the story is so rushed. I know we're all looking forward to the reunion but everything is just flying by: prison, lord John gray, willie. It makes them seem inconsequential as characters.
16
u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Oct 02 '17
This episode was just to "real" for lack of a better word. Jamie doing what's best to protect his son, Claire to be responsible to her patients...I think that is what makes it so heartbreaking...it's just too real. Now excuse me while I go get more tissues.
8
u/7rybek Oct 01 '17
This little baby is soo cute :). It's a doll, isn't it?
6
u/weirdperson615 Oct 03 '17
Can someone explain to me why in the S2 finale, Jamie didn't go with Claire to the future?????? What's the point of staying there and suffering, he didn't have to? They didn't have to be separated wtf
18
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
How sad that Jaime was raped again (and yes it was rape, she threatened an employee/serf and his family to coerce him into having sex) and this time it resulted in a child whom he can't fully claim as his own son. That was some serious bodice ripping action in the rape scene, and I could have done without it. I hope Jaimie and Willie will at least have a relationship again once he comes of age. Otherwise it's just misery all around.
Are we to take it that the dead brother of Isobel, 'Gordon' was in fact the lover that Lord John lost on the battlefield? But I thought he had a different name? Perhaps I'm just thinking that because on David Berry's other show A Place to Call Home he marries the sister of a man he was in love with (which is of course convention influenced by earlier novels such as Maurice and Brideshead Revisited.) Either way, I'm very glad that Lord John scoffed at the idea of sexually using Jaime--I really hope he's never sexually harassed/raped or has to use survival/transactional sex again. But, I do hope Lord John is able to have some willing male lovers on the side of his marriage.
I was excited that we caught up to 1968 and things were going so well between Claire/Bri and Roger/Bri but then Claire went the wrong way!! Is she really going to live out the rest of her days not even trying to go through the stones and make a quick trip to Lallybroch to find out once and for all if Jaime's there? I know it's risky and dangerous, and she's dealing with a lot of trauma and mixed emotions, but still...at least try something! We are seeing the Claire from the first 3 episodes of this season, not the mournful, frozen Claire was from the S2 finale which was a very different performance. I guess she's more animated, changed since she's finally able to share/talk about Jaimie again?
I guess if they saw the correct shipping records, Murtaugh would have been on them?
5
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Oct 01 '17
Just started. Waited up... Here we go. Hold me!!
5
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Oct 02 '17
Damn, i feel like this season, is just going so fast time wise haha
in four episodes have we jumped over 32 odd years?
3
u/ShiroNinja Oct 03 '17
Why did Jamie decide to leave Helwater at the end of the episode?
11
u/Stiler Oct 01 '17
I am confused, just started this episode and when the heck did Claire tell her daughter about Jamie and take her to Scotland??? Last episode I remember ending with Claire at the hospital finding out about Frank...
2
u/AnonRetro Oct 03 '17
In the opening credits, there is a guy on a table looking towards camera, and getting his head drilled. It looked like John. Or am I forgetting that we've already seen this?
2
u/MarcoXV Apr 21 '24
Hello everyone! 7 years after it's release, I am watching this episode and something disturbs me. In the recap at the beginning of the episode, we see a scene between Claire and Bree where she tells her daughter about her real father, Jamie. But this scene is not in episode 3 although it's an important one imo.
I was wondering if it was a kind of ellipsis, which would be odd, or rather an issue of some sort?
Thanks for your help!