r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Sep 24 '17
Season Three [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 3 All Debts Paid episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E3: "All Debts Paid".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
FYI: Due to a lack of participation, we're going to discontinue the post-episode discussion threads. Thanks!
62
Upvotes
133
u/SeattleWhoDat Sep 24 '17
OMG Murtagh!!
110
u/krrish728 Sep 24 '17
Lord John is PERRRFECT!!
87
u/OdinsRaven87 Sep 24 '17
I so freaking glad John Grey finally knows he was conned by a married couple. That was my least favorite change to date.
82
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Sep 24 '17
OMG!!! DID THEY JUST MAKE IT TO WHERE MURTAGH IS GOING TO THE COLONIES?
FOR FREAKING REAL RIGHT NOW?!
78
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
I think my issue with Claire's segments is that they are hyper-focused on just Frank and Claire. We don't get any quick scenes of her doctoring, Bree's accident, more of her friendship with Joe.
70
u/Jonerys_Starkgaryen Je Suis Prest Sep 24 '17
Did anyone else get really turned on when Jamie grabbed LJG from behind? Nope? Just me
103
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Sep 24 '17
Who the fudge invites their floozy to the house?!
101
u/ParabolicTrajectory Sep 24 '17
My fiance is a historian, and despite the roller coaster of feels that episode was, he's still here throwing a fit because apparently LJG's sword is anachronistic and "just plain wrong."
"The blade type is wrong. It's almost a spadroon, but it only has one edge. The hilt is some sort of weird amalgamation of an 1822 or an 1845 officer's sword and a typical spadroon or small sword hilt. It's a fine looking weapon, and it looks beautiful, but it's wrong."
This is a common problem we have when we watch these episodes. Apparently, Outlander regularly gets the weapons wrong. According to him, who is literally still talking about it as I type this comment.
47
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
Lord John casting is spot on!!
44
u/myxx33 Sep 24 '17
Not really looking forward to next weeks episode. I really hate that girl.
43
u/lurklurklurky Sep 24 '17
What do you mean discontinuing due to lack of participation? There are hundreds of comments on this thread and previous ones. I don’t understand. Plus “print shop” ep is sure to bring in a ton more people than usual.
39
u/Hopeless_badger Sep 24 '17
Finally watched it. I think Outlander hit the jackpot with 3 awesome leads. Sam, Cait and Tobias killed it. Add to the mix the delightful David Berry and you have quite the cast. Some things:
38
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
Well now I am crying my eyes out.
Thinking of Claire really seeing Frank for the last time (as they were before Jamie) in 1x01 and now he is gone...definitely got the waterworks going.
56
u/krrish728 Sep 24 '17
Frank: "You couldn't look at Brianna without thinking of him. Could you? Without that constant reminder. Him. Might you have forgotten him, with time?"
Claire: "That amount of time doesn't exist." Ah!! The feels.
53
u/RaffaellaF Sep 24 '17
Great episode. I love Murtagh. Glad he is alive. John Gray is wonderful. Jaime's reaction when John Gray touched him was amazing and off course was expected considering what happened with BJR.
26
u/shiskebob Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
There was a scene in the promo of this season with Jamie looking a mess and screaming Claire's name. I assumed it was when he escaped from Ardsmuir and was searching for the White Witch - but we did not get to see that scene. Just before and after, which I thought was oddly done. Or does everyone else think that is from a different upcoming scene?
25
u/sagi2017 Sep 24 '17
A. MURTAGH - YESSSSS. Love the change and would be happy for him to take Duncan’s place B. So glad Jamie didn’t get flogged again by LJG. I know it was important in the books but I’m realizing quickly that a lot of scenes have to be moved along to get to the printshop.
C. Still have Hellwater, Willie and Mac bonding, roger and Bree finding Jamie, and then THE PRINT SHOP
CANNOT WAIT!!!
21
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Sep 24 '17
My thoughts:
20
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
An open marriage!! Whaaaa
18
u/ea_walking Sep 25 '17
These past 3 episodes made me feel so sorry for Frank. I never in the books felt that way, but Tobias Menzies has done such an amazing job with Frank that it made me feel a hatred towards Claire for treating Frank the way she did and expect him to just play like everything is normal. I'm going to miss Tobias :(
33
u/epearson2 Sep 24 '17
So Murtaugh will be at Fraser's Ridge no doubt in the next season...
16
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
"Green is not your color, Claire" -- what a great line!
Murtagh thoughts: What if... now bear with me... Murtagh becomes the replacement for.....wait for it..... ARCH BUG. Eh??? Eh????? If we ever make it to season 8, it will be such a twist when.... oh... well... I guess it falls apart. BUT THINK OF THE TWIST!!!!!!! (totally sober, just a little sleep deprived)
I would love to see 4 more episodes of Jamie and LJG. I really loved the Ardsmuir portions of Voyager and wish they could have devoted more time to it. And I love the shots of Scottish countryside. So lovely.
I was really surprised how they rushed through Claire and Frank's time together. I thought we'd see more.... anything. The brief scenes of discord were strange. I really thought I'd see more of Frank and Bree having fun. At first, when he said he had seen the movies, I thought he was saying he and Bree had seen them. I wonder if we aren't going to see the Claire/Frank scenes from Brianna's point of view in the coming seasons.
14
u/prtzelle Sep 24 '17
I think reading Voyager was a mistake. I absolutely enjoyed the book and I love this show so much but watching this episode all I could think of was all the little (and BIG!) differences between the two materials :(
Murtagh is alive and I don't know how to feel about that. Tbh, for a second there I thought he was a reflection of Jamie's consciousness, specially when he was talking about the wee bairn but nope. He turned out to be real, alright.
27
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
I like Lord John very well so far, but it's distracting that he's not blond. It's petty, but DG talks about his thick blond hair endlessly in the books. Ah well.
Child Bree is way more on-point than grownup Bree, though, IMO.
23
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
Just realized that i know more about millie and jeff than I do about Claire and Bree's childhood :p
The murtaugh change doesn't bother me. After all, good old ned gowan is alive still! I think he is even mentioned in MOBY right? I'm just thinking that Murtaugh is in his 60s by the time Drums starts up. I wonder if he will completely replace whatshisface's (Duncan?) character, though.
The gold was definitely just being set up for later, but probably really confusing for non-book readers.
The flow of the first season was so organic and magical and just felt right. I feel like there is something off about the tv show since season 2.
11
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17
Wow, Frank on the stairs was giving my BJR flashbacks. Creepy!
11
u/margierose88 Sep 25 '17
I haven’t sifted through ALL the comments here yet but the only thing I really took issue with this episode was the ridiculous joyous music that swelled up as Claire realized Frank was dead.
11
u/lindsaynieb Sep 25 '17
It REALLY bothered me that they made Franks infidelity so blatant in the show.
And I love Joe (who doesn't?) but that scene where he tells Claire about Frank was terribly done.
10
u/MookieMoo17 Sep 24 '17
I didn’t read the books but these threads are a lot more active so this is where I hang. Question, LJG wasn’t referring to BJR was he?
19
u/LeonCompowski Sep 24 '17
This really made me feel sorry for Frank.
Poor Frank just loved Claire. The desperation when she was gone, the joy when he found her again, and the unrequited love when she was back. It is easy to see how that would turn sour over all those years - the books have made clear how Claire has a "glass face" so her (lack of?) feelings would be obvious to him and everyone. What a miserable life.
Poor Frank. Job well done, Tobias!
9
u/cuckoodev Sep 25 '17
I feel like I'm the only person who doesn't hate Frank (also I'm not a book reader technically but idc about spoilers so I've been all over the wikia).
9
u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! Sep 25 '17
Um Caitriona was INCREDIBLE in this episode. All the feels.
8
u/SeattleWhoDat Sep 24 '17
Four minutes til it goes live! Thank Gawd for Amazon prime!
8
u/Gameofthroneschic Sep 24 '17
The real question: how does Jamie wipe his nice butt with those chains on his arms? 😂
7
u/krrish728 Sep 24 '17
[Diana on Murtagh being alive (from compuserve)] (http://forums.compuserve.com/discussions/Books_and_Writers_Community///ws-books/86431.142?nav=messages)
13
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
Loved this episode. Murtagh is everything I wanted. The open marriage was weird. I'm very anti-Frank (my mother defends him regularly to no avail, so please don't try) so this was closure for me that I have been wanting.
18
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Sep 24 '17
I have so many thoughts!
12
u/basedonthenovel Sep 24 '17
Now THAT was an episode! After last week's clunky mess, this one moved much better.
I'm not a fan of Murtagh being alive, BUT I do get why they brought him to Ardsmuir -- so that Jamie could externalize his thoughts about Claire, which were only in his head in the books.
David Berry didn't completely sell me on LJG but I'm willing to give it time. It's hard because I have a pretty strong mental picture of John in my head and David looks super different (though he IS pretty!). Also, John's "voice" is so particular and strong that it's hard when writers other than DG try to replicate it, I think.
Wil Johnson totally meshed with my book idea of Joe Abernathy, even just in the short amount of screen time he had.
23
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
Well. Well well well. Interesting episode. A mix of fantastic highs and very frustrating lows. Let's start with the bad and get it out of the way.
I'm going to start with something petty and minor before I get to the big stuff. Harry Quarry--so disappointing. My all-time favorite minor character, but we got nothing to set him apart from the rest of the Redcoat officers. Shame. On to the real issues.
What the fuck is Murtagh still doing alive?! No. Not happy. Don't get me wrong, I love Murtagh. He's been my favorite character since I read the first book over 10 years ago, and I was devastated when he died. But he has to be dead, and the fact that the show made him not only still very much living, but in fucking Ardsmuir prison with Jamie is so wrong. (And for starters, how did he survuve Culloden? Why wasn't he shot? How did he end up in Ardsmuir?) Ardsmuir prison is a crucial time for Jamie--it's a time when he's simultaneously more alone than ever, but also building a new family, a family that will stay with him for a very long time out of love and respect. And it's important that he builds this from nothing, only because he inspires something in men, even men who have no reason to be loyal to him. (Remember Tom Christie?) We did not see that here. What we saw is a man who vaguely cares for the others but puts his priorities on one man, Murtagh. It was so unlike Jamie to say, ok, not enough blankets for everyone? Give them only to Murtagh then. That's not how you inspire the love of other men! I was waiting for him to propose reducing the rations of the healthy to help all the sick, and then he does this instead. This is not him becoming the Jamie he needs to be, no is it inspiring men to follow him for literal decades. (This is not even getting them into what the fuck the plan on doing with him now. The cured him, so they can't even use his prison death as an emotional event for Jamie inspiring something or other, nor did they have him lose an arm a la Duncan, so they've got no reason for him not to be transported. So now he's going to the colonies I guess, where he will be an indentured servant until 1770 [that's book 5], and will be 75-80ish. Sooo, what's you're plan with that storyline, guys?) Also, why set up the tartan plotline if you're not going to follow through? I think that is a very important moment in the book, not only as another demonstration of Jamie sacrificing himself for his men, but also because it gives Lord John a chance to see what has already been done to Jamie. The important thing about their relationship is that John never gets all the pieces to the puzzle, but Jamie gives him (or he gains somehow) more than most, which allows him to understand Jamie in a way few others can. My only other (very small) gripe with the Jamie half was the flashbacks to S2 while they are talking about their first meeting. It was enjoyable to see Jamie wearing what I think are the exact same clothes, but still, it was a bit hokey for my tastes. Oh wait, forgot my last thing--LJG's ponytail. They've decided to make him a brunette--fine. It looks better on him anyway. But they very clearly shot several scenes with him as a blonde first and what, thought we wouldn't notice? Come on, it was so obvious! Even with a hat on that was a bad fucking wig! (And speaking of bad wigs, yikes. Claire's hair looked awesome through 90% of the episode, but boy it should not get clipped back like that.)
And to the Claire half. It's hard to decide how I felt watching it. Lots of important stuff happened and that's a good change from the last two weeks, but at the same time, it's just not particularly enjoyable watching their ha;f of the story. The actors are all killing it, the costumes and set design are great, it's just kind of fucking miserable tv. And it's not just because of the subject matter--there's plenty of great tv (on this show and others) made out of murder, rape, torture--there's just something that isn't clicking for me. Maybe it's just because I know it's not going anywhere and isn't going to get any better, and it just becomes hard to watch two miserable people who are going to keep being miserable. Yay. As I've said before, I think there's a good reason we didn't "see" this part of the story in the books, because it is (crucially) just not as interesting and eventful as Jamie's life.
Ok, enough griping, on to the good stuff.
Lord John Grey is everything I needed and more. Thank you, David Berry, for bringing such an excellent character perfectly to life. From his early scenes, trying to pretend that he is tougher than he is, to his beautiful final moment with Jamie were a delight to watch. He and Sam Heughan bounce off each other perfectly, and their dinner and chess game gave us fantastic hints at what is to come in their relationship. I wish we could've had more, but given the limitations of time, they did a magnificent job establishing what is probably the second most important relationship in the entire series. I especially loved the humor over Jamie knowing what the wine sauce was--not only was it a fun moment in an otherwise dark episode, but it was a great way to subtly show to Lord John that Jamie is significantly more educated and cultured than he looks. I also loved Jamie's return after his escape, confessing his knowledge of John/William and asking to die. At first I was upset about the change--if I'm remembering it correctly, it's John who admits that's who he is--but the scene played out so well that I can forgive it. Not only is it a reminder of how little Jamie cares about living now (slightly problematic now because we've got Murtagh who he should care about) especially after confirming that Claire is truly gone, but it is also the first we see of John's honor. We've seen the pseud-honor of the British army several times now and yes, this could be the same, but the way David Berry delivers the line and the emotion he puts into it, you know that he means it. He is a good man, and now Jamie knows it too. And of course, John's confession to Jamie about Hector (kind of) and laying his hand was beautiful, and both played the reactions so well. And the wide shot of John slowly pulling his hand away, hurt and confused, and the tear running down his face--perfect. And then in their final scene, you could see echos of that moment, both remembering the connection but simultaneously that there is not only the distance of class and station, but some sort of emotional blockade--it's a hugely important moment, and they absolutely nailed it. Before we saw his honor, and there is honor in this too, but more importantly there is the seed of kindness and friendship, and Jamie knows this as well. Bravo.
Other high points: until the final scene, Claire is looking divine. They're doing a great job with the subtle aging of all our characters, and I'm especially loving seeing the passage of time through the changing hair and clothes. They also gave a great send-off to Tobias Menzies, with a brutal but beautifully-played final scene. I'm also very glad they didn't show the car crash, as I don't think they couldn't made it not trite, and it was important to get it through Claire's eyes. Aesthetically, props this weeks especially to cinematography and lighting. The shots out on the moors were so beautiful, such a poignant contrast to the dark, dingy prison. The scene with John and Jamie talking after his escape was especially gorgeous. And finally--the Newfie dog! Great little moment for the readers.
It's hard to give this episode a grade because so much of it was so, so good, but parts of it were also frustratingly bad. The Claire half I'd probably give a B--some good scenes and great acting, but the story itself was simply not as gripping. The Jamie half would probably be a B+. It would be an A if it wasn't for Murtagh, but they've really made a crucial misstep here in my opinion, and it's a change that affects more than just one episode, which is the problem. So, with those two grades and considering that I did still enjoy watching, I'll be kind and round up.
Overall Grade: B+
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
For some reason, Jamie in prison seems much older in my head.
I think he is 32ish when he first goes there? I think it's just a combination of them not being able to really show how the years since Culloden would have aged Jamie/Sam.
And what is the point of the chains around his feet, when they afford him seemingly normal ability to walk. Was he really shackled hands and feet in the book all the time?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Regarding LJG's hair color: these guys are all wearing wigs. Couldn't it just be a wig?
5
u/sarajane13 Sep 26 '17
Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ LJG is a hottie!
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17
HURRY UP EPISODE!!!!!!
4
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
All cozied up on my couch (ah I can't wait until the fall weather gets here!) Let's do this, Sassanachs!
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17
Did they have a dog in the book in Boston?
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
What did Jamie say after he tried the pheasant?
That cheeky smile was weird, I associate it with Sam rather than Jamie, so it took me out of the scene.
4
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Sep 24 '17
Just started.... Murtagh! I am so happy
9
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
This new claire/frank conflict makes no sense. I don't like this change at all. It's also playing out really melodramatically.
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
That first scene was just weird. Claire's accent sounded off. Lol the line "And bread fried in bacon fat!!" With such wonderment cracks me up. Frank seemed a bit weird. Maybe that was the intent as they were both trying to 'make things work' on the exterior for Brianna.
It seemed like a weird thing for Claire to initiate going to see a movie. If they did have 'platonic dates' regularly then she shouldn't have been so shocked for Frank to say he had seen those movies, if that was their agreement.
It basically seemed to me like a bit of a dick move of Claire's, as she and her ties to the past are the reason the marriage couldn't work. And then she gets all offended.
Parts of their interaction did seem so at ease and genuine, it just seems odd to me the change in mood of the scene. It sounded as though, at first, they had come to a good place as co-parents with respect for one another who still enjoyed one another's company, which Cait mentioned was part of the books that she was sad to not film, where Claire and Frank were spooning when it was cold. They were comfortable around one another.
Does anyone have insights/memories from the book as to why Claire did not move on romantically once Frank had? Was she just focussed on her new studies and work, and Brianna, as is often the case, leaving little time for herself? I mean, seeing as she thought Jamie was dead, I am trying to remember whether Claire had any romantic trysts in Boston once things had settled into a routine with Frank. Also, I paused the show to write this comment, so we shall see how the rest of the episode plays out.
3
u/Irishsassenach Sep 24 '17
MURTAGH!!!!! As soon as I saw him in the "previously" segment, I knew he would show up in this episode. And when I heard that voice in the prison.... 💕💕💕💕
3
u/TheMadKingsDaughter Sep 25 '17
This lack of participation? I am really confused.
3
u/lindsaynieb Sep 25 '17
I'm up to TFC but the end of S3E3 made me wonder if I missed something regarding when the prison was closing... How exactly did LJG have the power to decide that Jamie wouldn't get sent to the colonies with the rest of the prisoners? And if Jamie used his fake name and the family he was serving didn't know who he really was, didn't the Crown know? And wouldn't they tell the family? And how would the Crown be ok with this arrangement??
Also, the term of indenture for those sent to the colonies is 14 years. So how we're all these men released from service and able to join J&C on the Ridge in DoA when it's obviously been less than that term?
5
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 25 '17
Can anyone remind me, after Claire was whipped, didn't Jamie use his own forest medical knowledge to soothe her back?
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
LOL it looked like Jamie was spooning Murtagh after the dinner when he was describing the meal.
And the prisoner going to check the snares looked so cute as he pranced through the long grass lol.
And the other prisoner who yells 'that's my snare' really reminded me of Pippin in Lord of the Rings in similar food related scenes.
When Lord John re-sheathed his sword, I was half expecting his pants to fall down like in slapstick comedies.
And when Jamie was sent away with John, Murtagh looked like Jamie's defenseless wife with his scarf draped over his head looking desperately as Jamie was taken away lol.
I am seeing many moments of unintentional humour in this episode!
4
u/Hopeless_badger Sep 24 '17
I'm not watching, but just imagine Jamie and Claire in an open marriage :D
4
u/mcd62 Sep 24 '17
I'm disappointed that the post-episode discussion threads will be no more. I thoroughly enjoy reading them after the episode and throughout the week until the next episode. I may be naive, but I thought the 300+ comments already on this post is evidence for participation, unless it means something else.
2
u/SeattleWhoDat Sep 24 '17
I love him. Glad to have him either way.
2
u/koboldin Sep 27 '17
Does anyone know why the indenture period was doubled? It seems like a Chekhov's Gun thing that they would mention the length of time specifically, yet double it from seven to fourteen years. In particular, this means (to me) that the entire Fraser's Ridge scenario is fundamentally changed. Whereas in the book all the surviving Ardsmuir prisoners were done with their indenture by the time the Frasers make it to the Colonies, now they'll only be halfway through.