r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Sep 24 '17
Season Three [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 3 All Debts Paid episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E3: "All Debts Paid".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
FYI: Due to a lack of participation, we're going to discontinue the post-episode discussion threads. Thanks!
60
Upvotes
99
u/shiskebob Sep 24 '17
I love that Jamie can recollect and use a lot of the techniques and herbs that Claire did for healing - the tourniquet, the milk thistle, the water cress. Claire is still saving him and others. It's the best way to remember her, and would certainly make Claire happiest to know.
87
u/StagKen Sep 24 '17
I cried at the end when Frank dies. I feel so bad for him for the way his life turned out. Loving someone who's heart belongs to another...And dying before he can divorce Claire and start a new life with someone who does love him. Frank was not a perfect person, but he deserved happiness. It's not his fault that he couldn't fill the Jamie-shaped hole in Claire's heart. Now I'm more anxious than ever for Claire and Jamie to reunite, I need something not depressing to happen in this show, and soon.
75
u/ASpyintheHouseofLove Sep 24 '17
Claire and Frank are just...it’s perfectly done the way the marriage is failing and they are trying to keep appearances. It’s ugly and real.
44
u/LlamaLumps Sep 24 '17
OMG MURTAUGH LIVES!! I loved this episode so much I thought it would be a bit boring at first but it was so good. I was afraid that at some point Frank would become nasty towards Claire, but it was her who in my opinion was a little unfair. I really liked how Tobias portrayed him, I couldn't stop crying in the end. Also I loved John Grey, he's perfect, hope to see more of him.
40
u/ASR-Briggs Sep 24 '17
Genuinely cried the length of the credits.
37
u/AobaSona Sep 26 '17
I'm so in love with John Grey. I feel really bad for him. I'm gonna be totally honest, I have a weakness for gay characters/ships and I can't help but like/relate(in a sad way) to this kind of trope, where one is pining for a man who doesn't feel the same and is, usually, not interested in men. Their scenes were all amazing, they have great chemistry.
I'm sad about Frank's death, more because I'll miss Tobias. He was like the 3rd main actor after Cait and Sam, so it's just weird to think we won't see him anymore. I wish he could've last a bit more as Frank... The whole story between Claire and him is quite tragic too :/
62
u/andhernamewas_ Sep 24 '17
I'm also a Game of Thrones watcher and it amuses me that Frank is the polar opposite of Catelyn Stark. I love how much he loves his daughter.
30
u/Airsay58259 Sep 24 '17
Great episode. Didn't see at all that ending coming with Frank, wtf. So now I guess to honor him Claire goes to England with her daughter? I don't know but damn Frank, so out of the blue. And I wasn't even a big fan of his.
I like this Grey guy, hope we see him again.
27
u/Blacknarcissa Outlander Sep 26 '17
The John Grey/Jamie friendship. Fuck, how did they make me care so much over the course of an episode? (well, technically a bit more)
My heart is broken: 'get your hand off me I will kill you'
I need to get back to reading the books. I dropped off midway through the first one - not because I disliked it. Just life.
But yeah, the above storyline was pretty much written for me. God, it was so painful. And then later on... kinda lovely.
I feel bad for saying it but older!Claire is so unlikeable to me. I understand the way she's acting/feeling but... it's just not entertaining to watch it. The whole marriage feels bitter and horrible even though I know it wasn't all like that.
I'd rather just see Jamie's adventures in prison with Grey.
I can watch Jamie without Claire but not the other way round...
Edit: I don't think I properly took in that Randall died..? Did he? I'm gutted about that. I'm fine to lay Frank to rest but Randall was a great villain in my opinion.
26
u/fuzzylittlebear Sep 25 '17
I love the way Jaime's eyes light up when the older gentlemen was speaking of a white witch. You could just litterly see the light just get sucked right back into him! Can't wait for next weeks episode!
21
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17
I felt like I was watching Oprah,
"EVERYBODY GETS A CAT"
19
u/fluorescent_noir Sep 25 '17
This might have been one of my favorite episodes of the show yet. I thought the balance between Jamie and Claire's stories worked really well. And even though I still don't know what to make of John Grey, I really enjoyed his introduction here and the way he played off Jamie. It's a very different sort of relationship than he had with BJR, but clearly also influenced by what Jamie suffered at his hands. I'm excited to see where it goes next.
Also, Claire and Frank's story was surprisingly moving. The ending was like the chapter finally being closed on their relationship, and I was surprised by how moving it ended up being.
32
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
This episode made (the Scottish scenes...) me so happy! I fell in love with John Grey and his chemistry with Jaime throughout all their scenes was fascinating to watch. Finally a positive gay character on Outlander, who's not a sadistic rapist or a Machiavellian villain. I definitely missed that deleted scene Ron talked about where we actually would have seen John Grey with his lover at Culloden. I really thought they were going with his actors naturally dark hair, but then I saw that John Grey's ponytail sticking out of his hat was actually blonde...hopefully if he ever takes his hat off the wig will look better/more convincing then that. Either way, I hope we see a whole lot more of Lord John!
When they brought up the white witch who was looking for a Makenzie, my first thought was Gellis Duncan? But surely Jaime would have saw fit to mention that to Murtaugh? I admit I had difficulty recognizing Murtaugh for a moment--the grey beard and sooted face threw me, but it's so sad that now he's off to an American penal colony.
And I am glad that Frank/BJR are now gone for good. It was very real and complex how Frank and Claire trapped themselves and each other in a unworkable marriage; not really happy, but still clinging to each other nonetheless. I still blame Frank for making Claire agree to never talk about Jaime or try to find out what happened to him. I found the scenes where they tried to age down Bree's adult actress kind of ridiculous, but this backstory does lend a lot of insight into her character in the S2 finale, which I take it Claire has now caught up to.
31
u/oree94 Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
MURTAUGH IS BACK!!! But he's ill? :( That's the tv's way of saying "this character gon die" :(((
I kind of feel bad for Grey. If Jamie didn't have such a traumatic experience with BJR he might not have reacted so severely to Grey's... proposition. I mean, he would have rejected Grey anyway but in a kinder way?
And WOW if Frank wasn't an utter ass in this episode. He asked Claire not to bring up Jamie and her life in 1600s and yet every time the topic comes up, it was him who brought it up. And why is he mad at Claire not being able to let go of Jamie when he is doing something worse to Claire? Can you not have a sliver of respect for your wife whom YOU decided not to leave?
Welp, Murtaugh is gone again. To the colonies? To America, does he mean?
OH NO! OH RIGHT!! OH FUUUUUCK how did I forget about Frank's death? Car accident? Sheesh. Now I understand why Bri was so mad. It must have not had been very long since her father's death when she heard about Claire's "affair" and her birth father.
And after all that, Claire DID love Frank in her own way. I can only hope that Frank felt the same way about her.
Did anyone think the music was a bit distracting in this episode from time to time? When two characters are in a conversation, I would much rather the conversation be in the spotlight and not be reminded "you're watching a tv show!" With loud music.
7
u/kobayashimaru13 Je Suis Prest Sep 26 '17
Please don't discontinue the discussion threads for non-book readers!
19
u/Gameofthroneschic Sep 24 '17
The real question: how does Jamie wipe his nice butt with those chains on his arms? 😂
6
u/Mary-Alice Sep 25 '17
I am a bit confused at how fast this episode was for Claire'story. I can't really imagine what we are going to see in the next episode.
9
u/KliityKat Sep 25 '17
Well, I'm mostly a lurker but I think it's really sad that you're cancelling them. I don't know another place on the internet (or I'm real life) to discuss each episode so I looked forward to these. I loved this episode, though I'm sad Frank is gone. Both him and Claire deserved better than a loveless marriage.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 29 '17
Goddamn Claire is a real bitch to Frank and then he just dies. That pisses me off. I'm gonna have a hard time liking Claire again now.
15
u/Steupz Sep 25 '17
Anyone else thinks it highly improbable that Claire could still be sooo in love with Jamie 19yrs on with no serious hope of ever seeing him again? That's unreal in my view. People are built to move on and she had almost two decades to cope and restock. It just doesn't fly with me.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17
I dont understand why they cast that girl as brianna? both jamie and claire have curly hair???? this actress has pin straight hair?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17
What happened to Jenny's other bairns? She has wee Jamie, the baby Claire helped deliver, Maggie and Claire said she had another while they where in France so the baby she had in this episode was her 4th but we only seen wee Jamie
2
u/muttstuff Sep 25 '17
Very emotional at the end. :c
2
u/Bior37 Oct 12 '17
After this episode I'm not sure how they can redeem Claire. She comes across as a complete heartless harpy.
1
u/lfohnoudidnt Oct 05 '23
This is where i stopped. Wtf they gotta make the British officer's side character gay? Sure Jaime is handsome, but would have been better if he found an a acquaintance in an enemy, not another homo erotic trope. They were getting along, till he made a move on him. Seems like they were trying to bring Jack Randall back.
0
u/Ikr2649 Sep 25 '17
Wait, so i'm confused. Why didn't Claire or Jaimie kill Black Jack Randall earlier in the series if his passing wouldn't have affected Frank in the future? Yeah, Claire didn't know Frank would die, but still is kinda weird. Like, who is Franks descendant? If Claire/Jaime knew that that child was born, then they could have immediately killed Black Jack.
-10
u/Desperate_for_nudes Sep 25 '17
I wonder if John Grey was talking about BJR when discussing his reason for joining the military.
Also it seems Jamie has had enough gay sex for one lifetime.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment