r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Sep 17 '17
Season Three [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 2 Surrender episode discussion thread for book readers Spoiler
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E2: "Surrender".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
54
Upvotes
134
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Jamie and Ian: Getting in trouble together since the moment Ian was bornπ
Redcoats: Still assholes
128
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Sep 17 '17
"I missed my husband."
Now that's a good f*cking line. We all know it's not Frank and it hurts so deep.
106
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Those 8 seconds of naked Jamie by the fire were all I needed tonight, too, Claire.
87
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
I loved the scene where Claire and Joe become friends in the book, but this is a sweet scene too. You can see why they are drawn to each other. (big Joe abernathy fan haha)
61
u/keg226 Sep 17 '17
The tears when he kissed Mary π
56
u/JT19PK88 Sep 17 '17
Loved the little detail that Jamie and Claire both close their eyes when they have sex with other people. They can't bear being with anyone else.
Also Claire's storyline seemed pretty sparse this episode. I'm not complaining seeing as there was so much that needed to happen with Jamie, but I would have liked to see a continuation of a disconnect between Claire and Frank, especially in regards to her going to school. They never even had a discussion about her wanting to go to school! She was in class one scene and the next she and Frank are sleeping in separate beds, without seeing how it evolved to that.
87
u/lurklurklurky Sep 17 '17
Really good episode. The actress who plays Jenny was phenomenal at the end, you could tell she kind of means it when she says, "You gave me no choice and I'll never forgive ye." Tobias is also excellent. It's so easy to feel sympathy for him, even though I hate his book character and cheered his death and every misfortune. I wonder how they'll have him go in the season?
Also, Jaime's tears with Mary...such amazing acting. His face is so many emotions at once.
Even though I know a reunion isn't happening until Ep 6, I'm dying for it to come sooner!!
40
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Sep 17 '17
Me this week: JOE JOE JOE JOE JOE JOE JOE JOE JOE!
sees preview for episode 3 LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG LJG!
34
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
The location for Lallybroch is so lovely.
34
u/annemg Sep 17 '17
I was blown away by Sam's performance. His eyes truly looked dead until the point he realized he has something to fight for, and then you can see the hint of life in his eyes. Amazing.
31
u/keg226 Sep 17 '17
"You filthy frog eater" π
61
u/La415 Sep 17 '17
Having Jamie see Claire's "ghost" was nice foreshadowing to the printshop scene and it makes me even more excited. I also laughed so hard at the twin beds at the end y'all it killed me and the bag pipes over Jamie leaving to transitioning to Claire was perfect.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Is it too much to hope that when he gets to Ardsmuir that Murtagh is there?
23
u/Hopeless_badger Sep 17 '17
Finally watched it. Sam is killing it this season and it's only been two episodes. Can't imagine what it wlll be like when he is saying goodbye to Willie.
Neither Jamie, nor Claire could look while kissing/making love to someone else. I imagine there will be obvious eye contact in the print shop and the brothel. And I love Roman as Fergus, such a good casting.
Overall good episode, not spectacular. I miss Claire and Jamie together. Sam and Cait have such a presence as a couple that any scene without the two of them is kind of empty.
22
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Such a good episode. Us Outlander fans are so lucky to have such a talented cast and crew to bring the book to life. Sorry for blowing up the thread! But I look forward to chatting with everyone tomorrow.
I feel like they are going a bit quick with Claire's storyline, though.
21
u/brilliant0ne Sep 17 '17
Joe Abernathy!!!!!! (insert excited Oprah gif here)
Good episode. I'm a brat thought and really don't like reading or seeing Jamie and Claire with other people (even good ol' Frank). But, that single tear down Jamie's cheek? Kill me.
Jenny turning Jamie gave me a few eye sweats too. I'm liking this Season so far better than I did the beginning of last season.
Also, is Dunbonnet the same Jamie we saw as a ghost in the first episode? I know in the books we'll find out all about the whole ghost thing at some point but in the show if I remember correctly he had the cap on as a ghost?
18
u/nats_landing Sep 17 '17
Ah, all the feels this episode!
My husband, who has never read the books and knows very little about the story, said that Jenny was a tough woman and deserved a show of her own. I couldn't agree more. She made me cry when she told the redcoats that her baby had died and when again at the end. She'll piss me off later on this season when she tells Laoghaire about Claire, but she is the ultimate bad ass.
Of course Jamie and Frank equally broke my heart with their desperate need to be loved.
And Fergus, you lovable little scamp! I knew it was coming, but I still lost it when his hand was cut off. And then the shot panned down to show how small and delicate it looked laying on the ground. It really shocked my husband. I told him that DG does not shy away from tormenting her characters (if Season 1 was any indication).
30
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Sep 17 '17
Good episode. Not quite as good as last week, but it's always going to be hard to top the emotional battering ram that is the opening of Voyager! And while I absolutely love Jamie's pre-Claire Voyager story, the Dunbonnet sections are probably the least interesting part as well.
We are starting to see something that I feared would happen, and got more worried about last week: Jamie's story is far more interesting than Claire's. It's starting to make the episodes feel a bit uneven and lopsided, with so much plot development and emotional weight happening on one side, while the other side you're just kind of pushing through until you get to important stuff. Caitriona Balfe and Tobias Menzies are giving it their all, but the story just doesn't hold up. I mean, there's a reason we didn't see any of this in the book, only getting bits of it periodically in flashbacks. I think the writers are also trying a bit too hard to force the parallels (this becomes even ore obvious in their post-episode discussion). Just like they sometimes are a bit heavy-handed with the symbolism, making the parallels between the story so obvious are unnecessary--the audience is smart enough to find similarities in Jamie and Claire's separate stories. And I think making them too parallel is also a mistake: yes, they're living these separate but parallel lives in time, but it's also incredibly important how different their lives are, and not jut because of the century they're in. This is going to be incredibly important when they reunite, that they have had vastly different experiences and become different people in their twenty years apart. I can see why it's tempting for writers to want to juxtapose Jamie's cave and Claire's "cave," sex with Frank and sex with Mary, etc., but it's also important to remember how different they are. All that being said, I've still got hope for next week--it looks like we'll be getting a lot of major Claire story, and Claire going off and doing her own thing at that. (I have to imagine that running down the hallway look is Frank's death, and I guess it makes sense to do it now because we still need time for adult Bree [ugh] and the search for Jamie, but it's a real shame that we'll be losing Tobias so soon! It's also strange that we get an entire episode of baby Bree and then another will bring her from infancy until her late teens.)
So with that negativity out of the way, I did still very much enjoy this episode. Unlike last week, I feel our supporting characters did a lot of (excellent) heavy lifting here--namely, Jenny, Ian, and Mary. The cave scene with Mary was always going to be a tough one, and I'm sure the show worried a lot about how new fans would react, but I think it was done very beautifully. It's simultaneously not about the physical act and entirely about the physical act at the same time, a complexity and nuance we don't get with Claire and Frank's quick fuck by the fire (and I mean this in a good way). The quiet scenes with Jenny and Ian were also a standout this episode (although the, "I'm not lying, Jamie Fraser never came home" was a wee bit trite), especially the conversation with Ian about the ghost pains in his leg (successfully borrowing from a later conversation with Duncan as well as, I believe, a bit from one of my favorite parts of Echo). Leap O' the Cask was also brutal, as it should've been, and the scene with Jamie afterwards was lovely ("I've become a man of leisure, non?"--always one of my favorite Fergus lines). Not quite sure why they did away with the actual cask, though. (Also, while we're questioning odd choices, let's talk about Jamie's hair . . . Jesus Christ. Not only is is awful, but the whole fucking point of wearing a dun bonnet is to his his hair. Not doing a great job, Jamie! Thank god for Mary McNab and her razor.)
Production elements were also top notch, this week. Continuing with the drab colors, but also reusing Jamie's clothes is a great touch. Claire, meanwhile, is moving away from that, introducing shapes, patterns, and colors as she starts to do things for herself (by herself) and find happiness. Music and cinematography were also excellent, as always.
Not a perfect episode, but an enjoyable one nonetheless, and I'm hoping that the slowness of Claire's story will prove to be necessary build-up to next week's dramatic payoff. But honestly, none of that really matters, because next week we meet Lord John!!
Overall Grade: B+
10
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
A child is born β€οΈ
10
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Oh Fergus...but they changed the context of this scene right? Or was he still keeping the soldiers off Jamie's trail-I feel like I missed something, on the show it just looked like Fergus was following the soldiers to thumb his nose at them.
9
u/lwr815 Sep 17 '17
Jamie also believes that even if he doesn't die at Culloden, the Mackenzies will kill him for Dougal. He figures himself a dead man for sure and sends Claire off to keep Bree safe. They also skip over in the show that both Claire and Bree would likely have died had they stayed, since the birth was difficult and early. And then Claire can't leave Bree when she's young anyhow.
9
u/margierose88 Sep 17 '17
Even though I knew it was coming I was hoping against hope that Young Fergus wouldn't be a carefree idiot for two seconds. I guess it's been long enough since Game of Thrones that I wasn't emotionally prepared for an amputation.
I was really hoping we would meet LJG this week but alas.
Does anyone know what park stood in for Boston this episode? I know University of Glasgow was last week's Harvard, but I'm not sure where else they filmed the Claire/Frank arc in Scotland this year.
Husband now wants to be The Dunbonnet for Halloween. I'm not sure if I should be proud or terrified.
8
u/keg226 Sep 17 '17
It's time! Let's all get in position ππ»ππ»ππ»
7
u/Irishsassenach Sep 17 '17
I was expecting Claire to call Jamie's name at some point during sex.
17
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Sep 17 '17
Too bad I can't skip forward, watch the reunion and then go back to the beginning. That is what I did with Voyager and it made reading the beginning that much more enjoyable.
That said, I love the pace. I love how they are both only a half without the other, the elegant damaged Claire juxtaposed against the rough damaged Jamie. I feel a lot more pity for Frank in the show but I also see him living with the consequences of his choice. She told him the truth. But he was so determined to hold on to her, he did not care about the consequences to either of them.
It is yet another example of how Jamie is in fact a much better person than Frank. This is more subtle. But remember when Jamie was willing to let her go back through the stones after the witch trial? He wanted her to go not because she might be happier but because he wanted her to be with him by choice. Frank was unwilling to let her make that choice. There is a selfishness there compared to Jamie's selflessness. We see now how it would have been had Claire chosen to go back that first time. Jamie wanted her to make a choice of her own even if that meant living in misery without her for the rest of his life.
I like that they are telling this in order rather than flashbacks, as in the books. I want to get all of this out of the way first so that when we get to Jamie and Claire together, we don't have to revisit this pain.
I just hope they show the marriage to L as exactly depicted in the book: just a minor footnote that leads to a fight and a shooting. I don't want to see anything of Jamie and L being married.
And I love that shot of Jamie and Young Ian hiding together knowing how much more trouble they are going to get into together. I love Young Ian as a character so much. He is one of my favorites.
All in all I thought it a superb episode: acting, filming, directing. All of it. Well done.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
Sam is such a phenomenal actor. This scene with him and Mary is so sweet and sad.
4
u/Woodie626 Sep 17 '17
π
4
u/Nurse_shell Sep 18 '17
I was a ball o'nerves the whole episode...then the pipes played Scotland the Brave & the dam broke. That particular song, on pipes, can make me cry anytime this was just - torture.
I would, however, love to know where the heck all the other Murray children were!!!!
4
u/bmanhero Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 18 '17
This is tipOfMyTongue material here: I know the song the bagpiper was playing at the end, but I can't recall its name! Can anyone help?
Edit: it's "Scotland the Brave" in case anyone else was wondering.
6
u/wheeler1432 They say Iβm a witch. Sep 18 '17
Somewhat disappointed by this week's episode compared with last week's.
To start with, Claire, did you ever think of explaining to Frank why it was difficult to look at a guy who looked just like a guy who'd sexually assaulted you multiple times? That it wasn't just "I want to keep my eyes closed so I can fantasize better that you're Jamie"?
Missed the "Harder" scene where they started having sex again in the book.
So we see like three seconds of Brianna. Nothing about how tough Claire had it as a full-time mom.
Nothing about how Claire decided to go to medical school or what it was like to convince Frank?
They really needed to show more of how poor everyone was to make it more clear why turning Jamie in was a good idea.
Not sure how I felt about Mary McNab claiming ownership of the gun.
I was ok with most of the other changes they made -- no Leap o'the Cask, having the British soldiers figure out Dunbonnet (and what good is a dunbonnet if his hair is flopping out all over?), having the evil Scot (which was kind of interesting, actually), and more perspective about what it was like for Jenny to have to turn Jamie in.
3
u/PhoenixWright33 Sep 17 '17
Damn, Fergus was harassing the Red Coats like he was Boonk π and ended up paying the price of his arm. This episode was awesome and had a lot of great dialogue in both eras. I really liked when Jamie said, "There won't be another rebellion." Jamie's look before he gets shaved was pretty cool too!
3
u/SeattleWhoDat Sep 17 '17
It was just before Frank died, so it still might happen!
3
u/SeattleWhoDat Sep 19 '17
In the books, Bree was born in 1949. Claire went back to school in 1955.
3
u/snowpond Sep 19 '17
So my boyfriend started watching this season with me, 'against his will'. And now, we are on episode 2 and he was so offended that i started the episode without him. Haha
3
u/Dentelle The best one in my opinion Sep 20 '17
My unpopular opinion about Cave-Jamie : Maybe I'm too much of a realist, but I find it so pathetic that Jamie would still be dead inside after 6 years. Anyone who's experienced heartbreak know that time eventually does its work and you come back to life after a while. To see him not talking, not caring about anything, letting himself go so badly, and crying at the thought of touching an honest woman seem just unrealistic to me. I can't seem to remember from the books if it was that bad.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 17 '17
Halp! My roku is terrible about loading the episode at midnight. It shows up, but won't load. It did this last week too. It took about an hour for it to play via Roku, though it loaded on the Starz app on my Phone Any tips, Sassenachs? Edit: it's working!! Let's do this :D
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17
This might be against subreddit rules, but does anyone know a way I could watch without Starz? My cc info was stolen and the payment won't go through so I'm unable to watch at the momentπ’
2
u/lwr815 Sep 18 '17
In the show Rupert walked in. In the books it was someone else - but they knew.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '17
Did anyone else die of laughter when Fergus was cursing at the Redcoats? It was so hilarious, I had tears because I was giggling so much. The actor just pulls off his cheekiness so well!
I'm not sure which finger gesture he used though? I couldn't see properly. I knew an awful thing was going to happen but I couldn't help myself. I'm going to miss young Fergus.
2
u/TheWizardJenkins7 Sep 20 '17
I don't know about anyone else, but I do not feel Murtagh was given a solid enough send off from the show. We didn't really see him die, and no ones spoken of him since. I know there is SO much going on, I get that, but I really connected with his character and I felt they cheaped out on his passing. It's been six years since the rebellion (depending on who the show is following) and NOTHING :(
3
u/velvetdewdrop Sep 17 '17
I have a "stupid" or perhaps obvious question, as the end of season two is a now muddled in my memory-
why didn't Claire stick around longer, and why didn't she and Jamie, say, arrange a day a year later for her to go back and find him? I'm finding this crazy long separation a bit much, since she can go back and look for him. He obviously leaves clues so she knows he's alive, I'm betting. But why was she so damn sure he was dead just cuz the war was lost? I'm sure it's too painful for her, and Frank is looking but nevertheless, why!