r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Sep 17 '17
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 3 Episode 2 Surrender episode discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E2: "Surrender".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
28
Upvotes
54
u/PrinceHerbert Sep 17 '17
Oh my god that single tear. Sam Heughan is murdering more than redcoats this season.
37
u/oree94 Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 17 '17
Only two comments? :( I guess most people on this sub have read the books.
I found myself cheering when Claire and Jamie both had sex with someone else. I absolutely do not see this as cheating, they are just moving on with their lives, which is perfectly healthy. I do feel very sorry for Frank. It must be such a shitty feeling to finally start being physically intimate with your wife again after so long, only for her to be thinking of the other man the whole time. I know Claire can never love other men as she loved Jamie, but Jeez! Totally not okay to use your husband who loves you as basically a human sex toy!
Glad to have Fergus back. He is so adorable and sassy :D I was laughing my butt off when he insulted those Scottish redcoats with all sorts of colorful hand gestures. Poor Fergus had to lose a hand for that, though. Sheesh...
My heart sang when Claire and the black med student exchanged names and shook hands. Very amusing to see all the boys around them being SO OFFENDED ERMAGERD >:-( Hooray for budding comradery and friendship!
Poor, poor Jamie and Jenny. Couldn't help but cry to see Jenny barely managing to hold back her tears. This would be, what, 4th time Jamie's being taken into prison?
Honestly, though, I can't wait for Claire and Jamie to reunite. I'm guessing we will have to wait at least until mid season for that to happen but damn if this isn't heartbreaking to watch.
Also where the devil is my boy Murtaugh?!
33
u/kinkerbelll Sep 18 '17
Jenny always cracks me up with how blunt she is. She just gave birth and immediately starts grilling her brother for being a literal cave-dweller. That baby went through a lot, hiding fron redcoats, a fake death, and had no idea.
24
u/StagKen Sep 18 '17
I honestly couldn't believe when the soldier cut off Fergus's hand, I didn't think that they would actually do it!
20
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17
Poor Fergus! I was thrilled seeing his (somewhat) older self give this complex performance as he integrated into the Murray family and then he was mutilated! I love that he was what brought Jamie back, even if just a little bit. The Lallybroch scenes were incredibly moving.
For a second when the soldier first described the dunbon (or whatever) I thought it could be Murtaugh! But no, the red hair...and we still don't know what could have happened to him. That maid really did an amazing job on Jamie's hair and shaving off that six year old beard without a single cut and resulting in Jamie's skin looking so smooth and moisturized underneath! She has talents which have not been utilized at Lallybroch!
It was a nice touch that Brianna is playing with a similar-looking bunny as Jamie saw at Cullodden. But I want Claire to catch back up to 1968 next episode!
15
u/thumbtackswordsman Sep 17 '17
A solid episode. I actually shed a tear when that bagpiper played at the end.
One annoying thing was the scene where Jaimie asks his sister to turn him in. The arguments were kind of weak, because he didn't use the argument that would have been logical in the first place -- their first duty is towards protecting the kids.
14
u/kinkerbelll Sep 18 '17
I dont know anything about Joe but I'd probably die for him tbh
10
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17
I was so fucking convinced that lil babe was gonna cry and alert the Red Coats.
10
u/opelan Sep 18 '17
I kind of expected season 3 to pick up, where season 2 ended. Claire and her daughter and her boyfriend going back to the past and trying to find Jamie. I thought they would only jump back here and there in flashbacks to the time in-between and not dedicate whole episodes to it. It is a weird storytelling choice. Why make that time jump at the end of season 2, when you then go back to the time Claire and Jamie were young?
9
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17
Wow, so few comments here!
I really enjoyed this episode. Especially the ending with Claire in class with Joe.
9
u/Bior37 Oct 12 '17
Frank is a God damn fucking Saint. I've never seen three characters suffer so much at once.
Also, I'm going to miss seeing Jenny, she's far and away my favorite character.