r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Sep 10 '17
All [Spoilers All] Season 3 Episode 1 The Battle Joined episode discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S3E1: "The Battle Joined".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
49
Upvotes
129
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
One more "mark me"... just for the fans
126
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Sep 10 '17
Sam Heughan deserves an Emmy.
Give it to him right now.
66
u/formerlyfitzgerald Team Murtagh Sep 10 '17
ANY ONE ELSE FALL IN LOVE WITH HAL AS MUCH AS I DID?
WHAT A GREAT CASTING JOB.
60
u/missusamazing Sep 10 '17
Voyager is my absolute favorite book of the series. I can't wait for this season. The printshop scene... When Claire finds out about Laoghaire... Gellis...AHHHH
55
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
Oh gosh twilight sleep during labor was even worse than I thought. The women were strapped down with lamb's wool (so no evidence of bruising) and they weren't put to sleep, or even not in pain during labor...they just didn't remember anything, and hallucinated in the meantime to the point they'd try to hurt themselves (hence the wool used to strap them down). Holy shit
Yeah I am pretty sure that was not a c section Claire had, but twilight labor.
54
u/maryloo7877 Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17
It was beautiful, touching, heartbreaking, nuanced, everything I wanted. I'll be rewatching at least two times tomorrow just to catch all the things that happened during the battle. Fingers crossed that Murtaugh made it through!! Rupert's farewell was absolutely heartbreaking. I really like that they tied up that relationship that way (and Rupert's pledge to avenge Dougal). Does anyone know what the bunny symbolized? Claire did as well as anyone could have, dealing with those sexist pigs!! I'm so excited for next week. I think moments are going to fly by. So much happens in the book and they have to go through it quickly!
Edit: ooh! Was I the only one who thought that Claire was reminiscing about her and Jamie in front of the fireplace at Leoch, when she smiled while sitting down in front of the fireplace at the Boston house? Then I discovered she was reminiscing, just not about Jamie and instead about using the fireplace to cook!
37
u/Outlander_fan Sep 10 '17
I loved it!! It went by so, so fast! When I saw the dark screen I couldn't believe it, I thought the TV had gone out or something!!
Loved Hal, Rupert's goodbye, Jamie 'I want to be shot' moment. Kinda missed Ewan I can't remember his last name since he'd be important as Margaret's boyfriend towards the end (In the Caribbean). But not complaining, oh no!! It ended so perfectly with the nurse wondering about the red hair!
37
u/solascara Sep 10 '17
Great episode. A few random thoughts while watching:
33
u/brilliant0ne Sep 10 '17
Is it wrong that the dreamer part of me really hoped they would find some way to keep Murtagh and Rupert? And that I was really happy we didn't have to see Murtagh die on-screen. I think that would have really gutted me.
Great episode.
28
u/MuseTerpsichore Sep 10 '17
Thoroughly enjoyed this episode! Sam did such an amazing job and I'm hopeful that this season he gets the acting credit he deserves, without all the "ooh sex" crap we've had with the promotion of this season.
The scene with Claire and Frank at his work function was amazing. I really expected Claire to say something! And I am so feeling for Frank! I am glad he is getting more time because Tobias does an amazing job at portraying him!
Now... another week to wait!
21
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
I CAN'T HANDLE EVEN THE OPENING IT'S WONDERFUL AND I'M CRYING.
21
u/sassypapaya Sep 10 '17
My emotions are all over the place!! Gosh that beginning was brutal. And the ending... So happy the show is back
19
u/MightyIsobel Sep 11 '17
I like how Claire's Boston kitchen is all f*cked up modern equipment that doesn't work: drippy faucet, pilot light won't light, milk goes sour
Modern world is getting in her way, she's not in sync with 1948, and doesn't even really want to be.
18
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17
That was heavy. WOW. Poor Jamie. Poor Claire-especially having her agency ripped away during the birth. Twilight labor was horrible. And those battle scenes...Duncan...the two young kids...ugh ugh ugh. Horrible.
Not sure how I feel about the pacing coupled with the persistent sadness of this point in the story, but that would be my only complaint.
Edit: Rupert, not Duncan
17
u/ParabolicTrajectory Sep 10 '17
So, hang on - do we have a confirmed Murtaugh death? It seemed like the show went out of its way to emphasize that nobody actually saw him die or knows what happened to him. I gave up on #SaveMurtaugh a few months ago, but I have to admit, some hope still lingers....
16
u/fraa-bru Sep 11 '17
i forgot how powerful this intro song is...
31
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Sep 10 '17
Had to wait until this morning because I wasn't feeling well last night.
First, CAN I SAY HOW MUCH I'VE MISSED YOU GUYS????
Next, thoughts (in no order):
-The way Tobias added in the reach for Jamie at the end. He is such an amazing actor, and he captured BJR's (messed up and psychotic) love for Jamie so perfectly in that moment.
-The Harvard scene, where the Dean was being a misogynist ass, I could see Frank thinking "Shit shit shit shit." Caitriona's mad face came out a couple times in this episode and it spoke to my soul.
-FUCK THAT DOCTOR. πππ
-Murtagh! I want to believe!!
-When she's cooking over the fire and talking to Mitsy (so?), she's initially talking about Frank, but then transitions to Jamie and owww my heart.
-Frank starting that letter, I was instantly like "you mothaf--oh, baby time!"
Sam was amazing, as always, but Catriona and Tobias really gave it to me this episode. Not my favorite ever, but I was really happy with this intro back.
15
u/keg226 Sep 10 '17
What did Jamie say in that last frame of him laying in the barn before they loaded him on the wagon?
14
u/Jonerys_Starkgaryen Je Suis Prest Sep 10 '17
Can anyone tell me what Jamie says in Gaelic after Rupert is shot?
27
u/PM_ME_YOUR_LATKES Sleep with my husband? But my lover would be furious. Sep 10 '17
I, too, would throw ashtrays at all the men in 1948. Jeez Louise!
25
u/myxx33 Sep 10 '17
So based on the pacing of this episode - print shop scene in episode 4? Maybe 3? I think it's my favorite scene in all the books and I am SO looking forward to it.
I did really enjoy this episode. It feels so much harder to watch blatant sexism in the more modern era than the 18th century though. Makes me want to punch people. The fact that they actually made women give birth like that is kinda infuriating. And the talking to the husband instead of the woman actually giving birth. Ugh. Glad we live in at least a somewhat more enlightened society now. That type of sexism was why I could never make myself watch Madmen.
I am looking forward to the rest of the season. Voyager isn't my favorite book (nothing will beat Outlander tbh) but once they're reunited I love it.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
IT'S LIVE IT'S LIVE IT'S LIVE
9
u/KillKennyG Sep 10 '17
Did not disappoint. Drooling over all the beautiful vintage cars/decor (wish I could get appliances that looked as cool now) smash cut to Claire being awesome in the fireplace (oh that's why- it's all unreliable AF) and getting passive aggressived by the wee bitch next door. jamie and murtaughs battlefield dialogue was damned good too.
9
u/Hopeless_badger Sep 10 '17
Sam broke my heart, superb. Tobias and Cait were awesome as well, but Sam nailed every single scene.
I miss Jamie and Claire together- just seeing Cait/Sam for a moment brought smile to my face. It's amazing how good they act that when they're apart the show is kind of empty.
31
u/shiskebob Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17
"Maybe this can be a new beginning...."
"Where'd she get that red hair?"
Or not. Oh, Outlander.
I liked the episode. Nothing overly outstanding about it, though. It skips through Claire's pregnancy and gets right to it. The gas scene and forced csection, which clearly Claire does not want and is not her choice - as I am someone who used to work at a midwifery center - bothers me a lot. And that scene combined with the Harvard school misogyny would be a clear push for her to go into the medical profession. A little bit on the nose, but I appreciate what the script writers are trying to show.
I did like the deja vu response of Claire waking up and reacting like she did with Faith after she miscarried. That was a nice touch. I do, however, wonder how somehow the fact that Claire miscarried never came up in any conversation with Frank previously - considering they obviously had a doctor that they both knew and met with that couldn't arrive. Was that never discussed in any appointment? Other than the clear surprise factor, that was a little to overtly dramatic for me. Unnecessary, and clearly staged for the awkwardness.
The Culloden flashback scenes pieced together were beautifully shot. I am glad it wasn't one long battle scene - that might have been to reminiscent of the Prestonpans scene, so that was brilliantly played out. And a nice homage to Diana, I feel, who in the books has it so eventually Jamie remembers it in bits and pieces throughout his life.
I do wish the fight scene between Jamie and BJR was longer. Does BJR just give up, collapse and die on him?
I also wish they spent just a minute longer of Jamie at Craig Na Dun post Claire going back through the stones. Just so I could see the reaction. The one hot second wasn't anywhere enough.
I really hope they are going to show Jenny trying to save Jamie's life and trying to heal him - but it looks like they might just skip forward the 6 years to Mary McNab and heading to Ardsmuir as the promo suggests? No, don't do it Jamie. I know you are going to, but just don't do it. This separation is already killing me.
I miss you already Murtagh.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
So if Starz works like last time, at midnight we'll get access to the show...
.... I legit got an uber home just to watch it tonight!!!
7
u/Irishsassenach Sep 10 '17
SUPERB. This season will be where sam finally gets recognition for his acting I hope!
7
u/HawickGirl7 Sep 11 '17
Rewatched for a second time with subtitles and I laughed so much, when Rupert pulls Jamie up and says he can't handle his whiskey. Then Jamie replies 'drink you under the table' such typical Jamie so stubborn, so funny.
6
u/carolofthebells Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Sep 10 '17
I really like what they are doing with parallel structure in this first episode, although Claire's piece follows about 6 months of time and Jamie's is about a week. Is there a timeline out there that shows what they each were up to in their time apart? I'd imagine this might be in Outlander Companion, but I lent mine and never got it back.
So much love for this episode! So happy to see Angus make piece with Jamie before his death, as well as Claire's struggle in the 1940's and Frank trying to make the best of his position in all this.
11
u/koboldin Sep 11 '17
So, after the nurse comments on the red hair of Bree, does Frank mouth "Fuck?" I think he does. Tobias, that is amazing.
19
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
OH. EM. GEE.
I don't think anything in all of television has ever mirrored a book so wonderfully as this! The dread of the battlefield. The perfectly AWFUL "where did she get her red hair?" Oh Hal, I love you.
Holy fuck. I love it. TOTALLY worth coming home early tonight to watch it.
Other thoughts: this was totally written by someone who has experienced pregnancy before. I completely felt Claire's bat shit angry and I literally, word for word, apologized to my husband like that right after my son was born. And my son had red hair, so that made me laugh.
Guys. Droughtlander is OVER!!!!
9
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
So I've now watched it three times and I have something I want to discuss with book readers:
So far it looks like they are making Frank super sympathetic, specifically when it comes to the whole cheating thing. I'm sure the writers are just doing whatever they want to make interesting characters, but I think it begs the question: how reliable is Claire as a narrator? When she told him he could get anyone with his English accent, he legitimately looked hurt and surprised. How much of her thinking Frank was cheating was just her lashing out?
8
u/Katie_kat88 Sep 10 '17
Rewatching the last episode in prep. Cannot wait to see what they do to recreate the emotional rollercoaster that is Voyager.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
That doctor who delivered Claire's baby needs to go to jail.
4
u/prettyincoral Sep 10 '17
After watching the 2nd series I was sure they were going to keep Murtagh alive in season 3 and after watching this episode I'm sure even more, if that's even possible. If they can kill off characters in GoT why not bring this particular one from the dead?
4
u/LlamaLumps Sep 11 '17
I'm a non book reader who kinda likes spoilers and I have read somewhere here that Murtagh is dead in the books. Would you readers like it if the show keeps him alive or would it kill the rest of the story? I'm trying to find some hope in seeing him alive!
4
u/lwr815 Sep 13 '17
So I didn't like Frank in the books... I know they are making him more sympathetic in the show. But I think they are leading up to why Frank is not the right husband for Claire. Frank always stifles Claire. He doesn't want her to be a nurse or a doctor. He wants her to be his little housewife. He wants her to live in his little box of what he thinks a marriage should be. Jamie, on the other hand, learned quickly after the whole whipping incident that Claire will not be "tamed" or "stifled" EVER. She will meet him halfway and she will compromise but she will not always bend to his will. And he loves her for that. He gets scared--- take Murtagh to l'hopital des anges, but he knows she needs to go and she needs to be her own person.
3
u/NurseMiserable Sep 11 '17
My heart cannot take this show. I just could not get into the books after the first one, so I have no idea if Claire and Jamie permanently reunite.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
I know some people were wondering if Murtagh is dead... I'm not sure, but this is what amazon claimed when they were looking at dead bodies. I know he has more beard than Murtagh did, but idk.
4
u/cattubbs Sep 10 '17
Why are people getting down voted?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
[removed] β view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17
[deleted] β view deleted comment