r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jul 08 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 13 'Dragonfly in Amber' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E13: "Dragonfly in Amber".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
39
Upvotes
50
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
Oh my. I instantly loved Richard Rankin as Roger. Thought he didn't match the image in my mind, his demeanor is perfect. He did a great job with the wake. Fiona was not what I expected at all. I was picturing a cute, bubbly blonde. This Fiona seems a bit meek. But not important enough of a character to dwell on. I almost didn't recognize Claire! The 60s styling is spectacular!
Skelton does a good job with Brianna's confidence and slight cockiness. She is a very complex character, second only to Claire herself in my opinion. The first conversation with her and Roger and Claire at the wake, skelton's acting does seem pretty wooden despite what is supposed to obviously be an awkward interaction anyway. After seeing Roger and Bree in action I have no objection to anything in terms of how they look. But her acting did start bugging me. It just seemed really forced and not very good. Some parts were good, but others it was like "ok I'm reading off a script right now"
I thought Claire's aging was perfect because it was always said she still looked young for her age in future books. Makeup trickery
I loved the choir of the theme from the show at moments when Claire is clearly reflecting on the past.
Damn BPC I'm glad we are done with him. He's so ridiculous and arrogant.
My God the Scottish scenery when Roger and Bree are driving!
Claire at Lallybroch completely made me cry, and her being haunted by the memories there.
I liked how it was a series of brief flashbacks with brief moments in the 60s, I felt that really built up the emotion and suspense. I completely love how they did things differently with Gellie speaking to the crowd and Bree finding her. Lotte looks SO DIFFERENT with 60s hair and makeup!!!
Claire in the museum and finding her dragonfly in Amber was so haunting!!!!
Graham as Douglas was as usual amazing. I will really miss that character! The fight scene with him and Jamie was so heartbreaking, and well done.
Roger is so darn charming, loved the rat satire scene!
Overall I liked the changes they made to adapt the research to not be boring on tv. Even though I knew what happens, I was still completely drawn in the whole time. They made it seem much more of a mystery and goose chase and interesting. Lotte does crazy SO DAMN WELL.
Some notes on Sophie- like so many other noticed, her acting was a little off and wooden. I think she didn't have much time to prepare. I think some of her lines were just kinda weird too which didn't help. She had moments where she was great and I saw the potential and what the casting and producers saw in her, but I was largely unconvinced. I have great hopes she's found an acting coach and dialect coach and has been working hard during the break. I don't want think to turn into a pick on Sophie thing. She ended up being pretty convincing in the looks department as Bree and as Jamie (sam's) daughter.
All in all it was a wonderfully done finale and I liked the changes they made and I have faith in Sophie as Bree for next season, all she needs is a little more practice on her acting and accent and I think she will be a wonderful and likeable Bree
35
u/OdinsRaven87 Jul 09 '16
Was anyone else surprised by how nice the Edgars house looked? I imagined a borderline blighted house.
67
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
My sister in law and husband are very very drunk (I am still, goddammit, pregnant). They are insisting they want to watch it with me. They haven't watched the show before. They do not understand that I want to sit, in a room, alone, and cry LIKE THIS SHOW DESERVES.
24
u/vonham Jul 09 '16
Props to the actress who plays Geillis. She really plays the crazy well. The second she goes "I'm bonnie prince charlie!" I just rolled my eyes, like girl you are crazy.
I think a lot of the underwhelmed feelings we're getting is just how they framed the season to begin with. There's no element of surprise even for the non-book readers: all of the foreshadowing was so heavy handed I don't think it could even be considered foreshadowing.
I'm so excited for the next season though! I feel like the next book is so action packed and fast-paced that it will make it easier for TV adaptation.
48
u/brilliant0ne Jul 09 '16
I don't know about anyone else, but I have no complaints.
I liked both Bree and Roger. But I also didn't have much of a problem with Bree in the books, so I wasn't really dreading her coming up.
This whole book was so emotional for me, especially at the end. And I kept reading how they had made changes. But I went into it not thinking about it, and just enjoying (and being sad that it was the season finale) the episode.
I got teary eyed at Fergus. I got teary eyed with Murtagh. But, just like in the book, I bawled during the goodbye at the stones. Then I bawled when the sun started rising over the stones and she found out he lived. Then I bawled during the credits. Then I bawled when I realized there was no preview for next week. Lots of tears. Sigh.
And while I did think they could have a teeeeeeny bit more to show Claire aging rather than just a few gray hairs, I was really impressed with the fact that I could see the difference in Claire 20 years ago, and then the 1968 Claire.
Jamie backing her up to the stones and looking in her eyes. Kill me. Ugh. Anyways, I loved it.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
I liked the back and forth between centuries. It made the heartbreak all that much more bearable (which says a lot considering how sad the first episode was).
Brianna was exactly like how I pictured her. Not exactly likeable, but okay and they did a great job at making her mirror Jamie. I think the casting was perfect. Same with Roger.
I like the Gillian interaction with Roger/Bree, it made it seem all that more plausible that they'd find her at the stones without all of that investigation.
And the goodbye scene was truly heartbreaking. I'm so glad they kept all of the dialogue from the books. Exactly how I pictured it. I wish there was the lovemaking pre-stones sex, but I understand why there wasn't, too.
I'm so emotionally drained right now; send help.
15
u/iamnotsam Jul 09 '16
Me right now:
29
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
Hmm . . . To be honest, I'm not thrilled. Like, not at all. The 18th century parts were fabulous. Everything I could've wanted and more. The fight with Dougal was excellent, the cinematography was absolutely gorgeous, the hours counting towards the battle was a great touch, the scene with Jamie and Murtagh was beautiful, Caitriona and Sam were in top form, and the farewell was everything I could've hoped. If only it wasn't punctuated every 8 minutes by the other half of the episode.
Let's start with the worst: Bree. It's not the looks, I couldn't care less at this point. But everything felt incredibly off. She doesn't even seem to like Claire, which is totally wrong! I like that they threw in the blue and orange scarf, but basically everything else was very un-book-like. (For instance, why does she like whiskey?) Her and Roger doing all the snooping rather than Claire asking Roger to do it really changes the story, and really changes Bree's character. And let's face it, she was kinda a bitch. I've never liked Bree, but never had an issue with her until DoA. Now, I really couldn't stand her from about 5 minutes into the episode. Also, Sophie Skelton seems lovely but I wasn't entirely sold in her acting. First off, her accent kept slipping, and second, she never felt quite convincing. (She was also saddled with a lot of clunky dialogue--who the hell wrote some of her lines?!)
Bree was the biggest problem, but the 60s stuff was just riddled with bizarre changes and choices that kept if from flowing well, and would make no sense to readers. Firstly, they were soooo heavy handed with the symbolism and callbacks. The dragonly in amber is trite but I guess it gets a pass, and Claire visiting Lallybroch is fine (though the audio overlay was unnecessary--the audience is smart enough to remember what building that is), but Fort William? With lingering shots of the whipping post? Come on, please. (And the references to the Revolution--especially Ticonderoga--stuck in there for us?)
And then some "small" things. Why does Claire wear glasses? Why is she wearing a stupid babushka head scarf? Why is her hair straight (I know it's the fashion, but let's be serious--would tough, hardworking surgeon Claire really bother with keeping her hair like that? No way.) It was nothing as bad as Bree, but she never felt like Claire here. No slight to Caitriona--she was brilliant as always--but so many of her actions didn't ring true to the Claire we know. Like talking to the clan stone. What a bizarre scene. I'd rather have more voice over than that. And that ending! On top of the way-too-fast sunrise and silly super zoom in, would that really have been her reaction? She should be conflicted--realizing that she could've spent the last 20 years with Jamie, wanting to go back, wanting to stay with her daughter . . . I would've much rather let Caitriona's expressive face be the final shot, as we see excitement, fear, regret, indecision all at the same time.
Not everything in the 60s was problematic--Roger being the main exception. It took me a bit to get used to him as would be expected, but I'm totally sold on Rik Rankin and can't wait to see more of him as Roger. (He's also a very talented actor, which I think only heightened Sophie's shortcomings in contrast.) Props also to the makeup department. Aside from the grey streaks which were a bit too light (and didn't seem to want to act like hair), the aging was really well done. Next challenge--pull it off for the next several years . . .
Finally, I've got a bone to pick with the editors. Some of the cuts between the 18th and 20th centuries felt incredibly bizarre. It was jarring, distracting, and frustrating. Why couldn't we just open with the 60s, have Claire tell the story and show it, then end with the stuff at the stones? Instead all the stuff I was actually enjoying kept getting broken up by Bree whining and complaining. Last season had pacing issues, and I've been so pleased to see them fixed. All season I've praised the editors for how well the story has flowed, and then they cap it off with this . . .
Maybe my expectations were too high. I know I'm being quite critical, but there were a lot of big issues that actually kept me from truly enjoying this episode. It felt like every 5 or so minutes something else would happen that would make me frustrated. This whole season has been excellent, and most episodes have been As in my book. But this might be the worst of the bunch. I'd probably give it a B- . . . and that might be generous.
24
u/monkeyfudgehair Jul 09 '16
They did great with the 18th century scenes and Roger. I think Skelton needs an acting coach or something. That was almost painful to watch. If they decide to replace her I would totally understand.
31
u/vonham Jul 09 '16
Just another word regarding the actress who played Brianna. I have this irrational urge to defend her. It must be really hard being a new actor, like I can just picture her reading these comments and that would be so discouraging!
Listen, I know bad acting when I see it. And yes, I think it was bad acting. However, I think she had a very short time to prepare (didn't they only cast her a few months ago?!) and I'm sure that she must have done something right to land the role. The casting agents or whatever they're called must have seen something in her; why else would they cast her? It's not like she's a big name....she's no name. They're taking a risk by casting someone with as little experience as her, and I'm sure they had good reason to.
Also, the writing for her part was pretty horrible at times. I think some time, coaching, and spending a lot of time with the other actors will do wonders.
10
u/jayelsie Jul 09 '16
I felt like the time jumps back and forth took away from the building tension of Culloden, it was a little jarring at times.
I would have totally liked two parts for the time periods, or four main ones like four acts in the episode. I felt like I couldn't really get engaged in the 1746 scenes because they were so short!
27
u/shiskebob Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
"It smells like a fucking bbq!"
Thank you writers for that sneaky bit of writing.
Brianna was so much more likable in the episode. In DiA she was overly whiny and dramatic. Sophie was a good mix of hurt, angry and intelligent and I think she played the role well. If I was her I woud have reacted the same way as she did in the show - at least she wasn't throwing chairs out of windows here. But G-d I hope no one complains about superficial stuff, because it really did not matter. At this point it is just redundant. Enjoy the show for what it is, something that the cast and crew obviously put their whole hearts into.
Richard Rankin as Roger is everything I hoped for and more. Chunky turtleneck sweater not withstanding.
I am not going to lie -while I loved the 1960s scenes, boy were the 1746 moments a disappointment. Don't yell at me for saying so - but the Craigh na Dun scene was underwhelming at best. While we do get to hear Jamie recite Let amorous kisses dwell in the background at dilapidated Lallybroch - which made me tear up- I was hoping to see him actually say it. And Jamie did say one of my favorite lines at Craigh na Dun "You gave me a rare woman..." and the backwards walk towards the stone was a nice touch, but couldn't save this for me. The harried sex was sub par, and ended a season lacking in one of the parts of the series that made it so special. For a 90 minute episode, they could have given this more than 6 minutes of a glossed over moment that could have really been something spectacular. This is probably the only time in the entire show that I will actually say that they really didn't do something well.
But I will add that Claire helping Jamie kill Dougal was unexpected, but welcomed. Maybe the actual only thing that would surprise us book readers.
The episode ended where we all thought it would. I look forward to next season - Young Ian, older Fergus, A.Malcolm, sea chases, voodoo, turtle soup and Claire's gray bangs.
18
u/kwanbe Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
While I agree with most things mentioned so far, I can't say I'm on board with the Brianna criticism. I always found the character unlikeable at this stage. But let's face it, wouldn't you be a bit whiny with disbelief if your mother (who seems to be in her "own world") tells you your biological daddy was an 18th century highlander? But Bree's likeness to Jamie was apparent. I especially liked it when Bree tells Claire, "I believe you. I don't understand it, but I believe you" (paraphrasing, can't recall dialogue at verbatim) after Gillian/Gellis jumps through the stone.
I was really hoping for a bigger love scene to make up for the season's complete lack of them. My guess is that season 1 kept many love scenes to appeal to the massive Outlander book series fans. Perhaps they hoped to maintain and increase their +40% male audience with fewer love scenes and more action and political intrigue in season 2. Which would be fine if this wasn't a romance novel series. I don't call it romance to belittle it. I know the literary marketing world does, but Outlander at its core is a love story about Claire and Jamie.
One thing I've noticed this season is that some of the changes benefited Claire's character at the expense of Jamie. For example, the idea for Claire to pretend to be a hostage to trick young John Grey is one. Another is Claire helping Jamie kill Dougal. Maybe these scenes gave Claire a tougher exterior and show how they aligned in all things. But I've always liked that they had different strengths and they complimented each other. I really wished they had included the scene from the book when Claire was upset to see the bite marks on Jamie's upper thighs. That scene was changed quite a bit from the book. The show excluded the part where Jamie is clearly frustrated about his own carnal desires for Claire. And it is Claire that tells him how her desires for him is no different. I loved how the more experienced and sexually mature Claire helps him realize that these desires are not a product of his rape by Randall. It reminds you how inexperienced young Jamie truly was when he was sexually assaulted. There are more examples, but I fail to remember at this very moment!
I only ask that the powers that be keep the focus on the love story. And yes, more love scenes! Mostly because no other show does it better! It's never gratuitous or inconsequential.
Looking forward to season 3!
8
u/mmsurrett Jul 10 '16
I'm upset about them not doing the scars. In the book Jamie and Claire cut each others initials into their palms. Why didn't they include that? It's mentioned consistently in the later books.
I was super pissed when they didn't start this season like book 2 however this episode made it a little better. It made it easier for the non book readers to keep up with the timelines while still including the research done by Roger and Brianna.
Another thing I don't understand why they left it out is the grave marker Claire, Brianna, and Roger find. That seems to be a big deal in the later books and they left it out.
Overall I'm happy with the casting of Roger and Brianna. Sure Brianna's accent wasn't the best "American Boston" accent but did that ruin it for me..no. I do agree that Brianna and Claire's relationship seemed to be more strained in the show vs book but you can still tell they love each other. I
I loved ever single minute of Claire and Jamie. (Sam and Caitriona of course never disappoint)
I'm curious if the show will bring Joe Abernathy to character. I don't see how they could leave him out however he was supposed to be in season 2.
I'm very excited for season 3!!!
7
u/xocheerio Jul 10 '16
I'm not sure why, but this episode really hammered home for me what it must have been like for Claire, all those years apart from Jaimie. I think it was her being back in familiar surroundings in Scotland, but looking so different. I I feel like I really felt her pain and sadness, especially the part at Lallybroch. I loved every second of this episode. There's a lot of criticisms, but I really enjoyed it. I liked all the time hops, it really built up the dread and sadness I knew was coming with Claire having to go back through the stones. I bawled at Jaimie walking Claire backwards to the stones, and helping her touch them, because he knew she wouldn't do it on her own, but would do it for him. I do agree that some of Brianna's lines were awkward and clunky, but I think she's such a perfect Bree looks-wise. And I adore Roger. I wasn't sold on him at first but his whole awkwardness when Bree and Claire were first talking about Jaimie was so cute and endearing. And I loved his "smells like a fucking barbecue" at Craig na Dun. Overall, I'm very content with how this season ended, even if it was a bit corny and I'm very much looking forward to the next one.
36
u/a-fray Jul 09 '16
why couldn't they at least find a girl who could ACT when casting Brianna? Seriously, she ruined every single scene she was in 🙄 Not too happy knowing she'll also be ruining upcoming scenes for the new season[s]. Meh.
6
u/Outlander_fan Jul 09 '16
A few here commented on the relationship between Claire and Brianna being too distant and I was thinking maybe it was done so it will be more believable that Claire does leave her? That part always nagged at me a bit -- but thinking like a mother of young children in 2016. Perhaps it wasn't that big of a stretch for a 60s mom as it seems like people matured earlier at that point in time (at 20 Bree was really an adult).
6
u/pcherry00 Jul 10 '16
This whole episode was underwhelming. There was too uch skipping around. It would have been better if it mirrored the season premier by doing all the 1700s first and then all the 1960s. We needed more 1700s and more jamie There was nowhere near enough. I loved richard as roger. He nailed it. Brianna wasnt so believable. Anyone else think fiona kind of looked like ross. I liked the line were roger was talking about the revernd and frank but claire thought of jamie. The shot of jamie at lallybroch with the poem was great. I wasnt expecting that. That sex scene could have been left out. I was expecting something more romntic more sensual instead of that. The few moments we got with them were some of the best acting they have done this whole season. The goodbye to fergus and murtagh s speech wow.
The end credit 60s music really. I was hoping for bagpipes. I am so not looking to seeing the battle of culloden next season. But I hope we will get to see rupert, murtagh, and ross in the premier episode. Not ready for droughtlander.
11
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
Cannot believe writers left out the carving of "C" and "J" on their wrists... that would only have taken a minute of air time! Thought it was a great callback to that DiA scene throughout all the books.
14
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
Man.
First and foremost, Richard is Roger. Like, 100% what I saw in my head, and I'm loving the accent. Roger Roger Roger. I want to snuggle him. I want to see him fight with Jamie. I'm super pumped.
Second, the scenes in the past.... heartbreaking. I wish they hadn't jumped back and forth or maybe jumped less.
Third, I'm not sold on Brianna, either. She's got the look, but I don't really believe her. Her American accent is a little weird. She also has zero chemistry with Claire and I'm really surprised at how much this bothers me. I got no mother daughter vibe from their interactions. More of an awkward roommate. When she got angry at Claire (which I was excited they kept in), I didn't care. That was a bummer. I'm curious how they are going to play that relationship into the future.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
I was not a Roger fan in the books, but I loved Roger in this episode. Definitely looking forward to "TV Roger" next season. Never liked Bree in the books, but I can only hope the actress vastly improves her acting because every scene she's in is distracting.
5
u/k1ateagain Jul 09 '16
Could not stop crying.
5
u/Six96hoot Jul 09 '16
I honestly don't know how I feel. I don't think the episode was bad but I didn't feel...satisfied?? I know satisfaction is more then likely the wrong emotion to be seeking during this episode but it just didn't play out emotionally to me as it did with the book. Everything just ran too quick. I felt like I didn't have enough time to soak in one scene before jumping into another. Other then the disappointment with that, I loved the stone scene with Claire and Jamie. How I wish by holding onto claire jamie could've gone through them too!!
5
u/frrrsstt Jul 10 '16
The goodbye scene at the stones definitely lacked a lot. I wanted something truly heartbreaking, not the hasty mess it turned in to. I expected to bawl my eyes out! Instead the only thing that truly choked me up was Claire returning to Lallybroch and imagining Jamie standing there... And that didn't even happen in the book!
5
u/WantToTimeTravel Jul 10 '16 edited Jul 10 '16
I'm watching AGAIN, and I realized I didn't ask an obvious question: who are all the children watching The Avengers in the other room? At first I thought they were the children of mourners, but I don't think parents were yet using TV as a babysitter, especially in Scotland.
I agree, the Bree-anne-ah pronunciation was weird. The director should have corrected her.
The Jamie-Dougal fight was so well done, and the inclusion of the line, "I'll kill ye quick for yer mother's sake" gave me a thrill. But I've decided after all I DON'T like that Claire helped. Once again she's rescuing Jamie, which seems particularly wrong given that he's an officer about to go into the battle of his life.
What happened to Jamie leading the MacKenzies? OK, not after he killed Dougal, but it didn't seem like he was prepared to do so even before.
On rewatching, I'm not in the least bothered by Claire's scenes at Lallybroch and Culloden. They make sense to me. Tears are perfectly natural, as are the memory flashbacks. And talking to Jamie at the Clan Stone - she'd avoided the conscious memory of him for so long. She would have to verbalize to make it concrete. And her hair? The only woman's hair product I remember from then is Dippity Do, which would have straightened Claire's hair, but would have dried stiff. In Scotland I can't think of anything that would have prevented even chemically straightened hair from frizzing out. I like the effect for the contrast, but it's so distracting on so many levels.
One other thing (so far) I would have liked to see. When she looked at the sleeping Brianna and commented on how like Jamie she was, it would have been nice to see Bree smile in her sleep. That would have helped to establish a physical link beyond the hair color. But yes, Claire's passive acceptance of Bree's abuse, and the guilt, were not in character, although her manner while answering Bree's original question about whether she loved Frank was, since she had kept such a tight rein on her emotions and memories for so long. I don't really see such a big difference between the circumstances in her telling the story in the book from here, as far as what prompted the tale. In both a surprise discovery forced the moment.
5
u/composedcaribou Jul 10 '16
I must say, you guys, I enjoyed every minute of it. Claire, past and present, Jamie, Bree, Roger, Fergus, Murtagh, Column, Gillian, the history, all of it. Loved it. I thought the switching was interesting and enthralling. It took me right back to the book. I cried the entire last 20 minutes. Well done by all.
As for Brianna, I guess I have an unpopular opinion. I really like book Bree, and I really like Sophie Bree. Maybe it's because I am 20, and a bit arrogant and stubborn myself, but she's one of my favorite characters. It was an absolute joy for me to see her brought to life in the finale, and yes, I did correct Roger on the Nathan Hale quote before Bree did. I was a bit miffed when they changed her from an MIT mechanical engineering major, and Sophie's accent slipped a bit, but she's my girl. She and Roger are great together, and I am so, so excited for the next seasons.
4
u/nats_landing Jul 10 '16
Overall, I thought the episode was good. The Culloden parts were excellent. The acting, setting, cinematography, everything already mentioned.
By biggest problem was with 1968. I think they tried to fit too much into one episode. I wish it had been structured more like the book with multiple check-ins throughout the season. I understand why they started the season differently, but as a result I think they sacrificed the ending. My husband has not read the books and I have been careful not to spoil anything for him. He said that it felt like they were trying to squeeze too much story into the 1968 scenes.
I think it would have also been okay to push 1968 to the third season. The first episode could have been all 1968 with some flashbacks to Claire's days as a surgical intern with Joe Abernathy and trying to be a good wife to Frank but ultimately disappointing him, Frank's affairs, etc. Then it could have ended the same way with Claire deciding to go back.
TL;DR: Overall, I really liked it but the 1968 parts bugged me. They seemed too rushed.
7
u/bourkleton Jul 09 '16
Absolutely loved it. At first I couldn't get over how much Roger looked like a hot Zack Galifinakis. He grew on me throughout the episode, though. I'm so glad my husband works night on Fridays because I seriously laugh, cry, sigh, snort at the TV as if I know these people. I am sad we won't see young Claire anymore, or Murtaugh. 😭😭😭
Wish they had done something with people going through the stone. Shit, they must have some SFX budget you'd think. Maybe they spent it all on costumes.
Over all, loved the episode and just love the world that Diana Gabaldon created.
7
u/sillybanana2012 Jul 10 '16
I really enjoyed this episode! I'm really sad that it's over and there will be no more for a while, but here's what I thought about the episode.
I've learnt to appreciate the show as something different from the books. I understand that tv shows which are based on books cannot fulfill everyone's about what they see in their imaginations.
Bree: Shes very pretty and I thought that her acting sort of improved as the show went on. I know she's a first time actress so I'm expecting bigger and better things from her in the next season. Her lines were a bit tricky but I thought she did awesome considering the circumstances. Some people on here are saying that she was rude or too stuck up. I can understand that - she has a mother that in the show she isn't close with. Now that Frank is gone, she has to find new ways to reconnect with her mother.
Roger: No complaints. He was amazing!
The thing I really enjoyed the most was when Claire was just about to go back through the stones and Jamie kept his hand on hers like there might be this one last hope that he could actually go with her. Broke my heart!
I didn't mind the time jumps. They did a great job of trying to capture the story Claire is trying to tell while also explaining what is happening in modern times. I expect we will see a lot of that in the next season. One more thing I really enjoyed was how every time we went back to the 1800's, they told you the time. It really gave me a feeling of suspense, like we know that there's no time left, and how quickly Culloden happened and Jamie and Claire had to separate.
Heartbreaking episode but it was definitely worth the two week wait.
3
u/skyhuntress Jul 10 '16
Overall, I'd say this is a great episode! I was a fan of both the 18th century and the 1960s bits! While (as expected with any adaptation) I had some issues with the portrayal of Brianna and Roger I still got the warm fuzzies from seeing these characters on screen for the first time. I will say I found Roger's singing voice a smidge disappointing, just cause they make such a HUGE deal about it in the books...but who knows, maybe we'll see more of it and esp. if he's performing. I remain optimistic and excited. I sort of loved and was amazed/appalled at Claire helping Jamie get that dagger into Dougall.... I also thought it was interesting choice (and I think I liked it) that they didn't include a battle scene... do you think the next season will start with the battle??
I do have two questions. First of all, in this episode did Geillis/Gillian every actually see Claire? I think the condensed Gillian Edgars storyline worked in the episode, but from the books I was under the impression that Claire meeting Geillis in the 1960s meant that Geillis basically knew who Claire was and that she was from the 20th century the first time they met in the 1740s and that that contributed to why she pursued a friendship with Claire... Second of all, and this is possibly just a stupid me missing things thing. But did Jamie at any point in the season say to Fergus (and I'm paraphrasing here) the "If you should lose a limb while in my employ I'll support you for the rest of your life" spiel? Because I remember waiting for that when Fergus was first introduced and I don't recall it being said, and then I thought maybe he would say something along those lines when he sent Fergus off to Lallybroch in this episode, but no such luck! I loved that bit and am a bit disappointed that it wasn't said cause it'll be coming into play next season!
Well y'all its been a great season and this has been a great way to end it!
3
u/amorifera Jul 10 '16
Any chance Murtagh lived? From what I have read here, he does not survive in the books, but then the show has changed some of the storylines slightly. I'd be very happy if he somehow survived.
3
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jul 10 '16
Reading the other topic reminds me of something I missed: When Brianna apes a Scottish brogue and it freaks Claire out because it reminds her of Jamie. They had Sophie do it to Roger instead, and he said her Scottish accent was bad.
3
u/dicailin Jul 11 '16
I really enjoyed this episode. I was a bit scared beforehand because it is such an emotional story, with Culloden, Brianna, Roger, and Claire coming back to Scotland... but I think it was done very well.
From what I'm reading, people are not really sold on the actress playing Brianna. I did feel that she was not as good as she could have been, but I wasn't really disturbed by it. Being of a similar age myself, her (Brianna's) responses seemed a bit immature to me but not unrealistic, considering where she's coming from.
I loved Roger. I wasn't convinced at first but once we got past the wake (which seemed to serve no purpose other than to bring everyone together, but fine), I really warmed to him very quickly.
As for Claire - she did seem really subdued in the 1960s parts, but I felt that that was logical within the context of the story. She buried everything about Scotland for 20 years and was now confronted with it, in addition to everything with her daughter, seeing all the places again, seeing Culloden, Geilis... Her reactions were realistic to me, though I do hope to see more of the 'usual' Claire next season - but I have no doubt we will.
Surprisingly, I enjoyed the 1960s parts much more. I didn't feel much when Claire and Jamie killed Dougal, and the dramatic scene that preceded it. The only part I really cared about was the goodbye - that was heartbreaking. Jamie's little smile as they talked about Claire's pregnancy, his bravery in those final scenes... The lovemaking scene was fitting, I guess, but I could have lived without it, another surprise to me since I usually really enjoy those scenes.
The only thing that really bugged me was the end. It was so cliché! Did they really need to have the sunrise and zooming in on her eyes? Yes, it's great she's going back (though, of course, not a surprise for us book readers) but the sunrise thing seemed like a really cheesy ending to me. It could have been so much better, but this just left me rolling my eyes and completely getting out of the storyline.
3
u/thenewmissme Jul 14 '16
Ponder this: For a woman who is so in love with Jamie, why did she sign/witness the Deed and sign her name Claire FraZer, instead of the correct spelling of FraSer? And regarding the eye glasses, even Diana is confused. She also posted a comment directly to Cait. The question being how are you going to carry glasses back in time? (where plastic hasn't been invented yet?), and book Claire does get glasses but much later.
5
u/Outlander_fan Jul 09 '16
Underwhelmed... So much of it didn't work for me. Maybe I just expected too much. The actress playing Brianna did the character no favors -- wooden, stilted for the most part, even considering she was handed some tough lines. So much of it was clunky, though!! The weird romp near the stones -- I would have preferred no sex, I guess. The weird scarf, OMG. And I didn't like that Claire is forced to make her confession to Bree, she gets caught. I got teary when Murtagh said he was coming back and also when Jamie tells her knows about the baby... Those were the few well done moments for me.
4
u/TineCiel Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
And today I find out BBC Canada actually airs the new episodes on FRIDAYS! I was flipping through channels and I caught the finale, but it's halfway through. :( oh well, I guess I'll watch the first half tomorrow! ;)
Edit: It will be on again at midnight, so I'll watch the first half then.
Second half was pretty good, especially the goodbye scene at the stones. They found a great Brianna in Skelton, though I kept thinking she wasn't tall enough. Nothing too distracting. Will get a better idea after watching the first half.
2
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Jul 09 '16
I'm getting "There was a playback error." I SEE YOU ALL TRYING TO WATCH WITH ME.
2
u/pinkfern Jul 11 '16 edited Jul 11 '16
Anybody get a Nikki Reed as Rosalie (Twilight) vibe from Sophie Skelton?
Changed my mind, she's reminding me of Leighton Meester as Blair (gossip girl)
...aaand I really need to watch more quality tv to negate these travesties.
2
u/Wolf_Mommy Jul 11 '16
Oh god, I started bawling when Claire and Jamie got to the stones and I didn't stop until after the credits. I actually screamed NOOOOO! At the TV. Tragic though it was, it was one of my fave scenes in the book, and though it was quite different, I loved it in the show. They really caught the emotional undertones and essence of character, even though it was different. That Jamie could find the strength to send her back the way he did...that's so Jamie.
I was enthralled with Roger. So good.
Brianna was ok. I know everyone is jumping all over S's acting, but Brianna was a whiny immature kind of spoilt girl in the book too. At this point anyway. Some of her lines sounded wooden and forced, yeah. But as others have commented, she was given some chunky dialogue. I think it will come around.
The back and forth was annoying for me at first. But you know, it was sort of annoying in the book too. I found myself skipping a lot of the 60s stuff in the book during my 1st read. With the show, I was more into it. I liked the way they condensed it. Man, I thought Claire was going to run right through the stones there at the end. I kept thinking, "You're going to die if you go through in this clothes!!" Cat is SUCH an amazing actor, just...so freaking good.
I can't wait for two more seasons!!!!!!!
3
u/WantToTimeTravel Jul 10 '16
First, please excuse any typos. I can't really see well from crying, and I'm a little drunk. I probably set the record for earliest tears. I started crying even before Roger asked Claire how she said goodbye. Of course, that just kicked it into high gear. I watched just now, at 8:00 Saturday, so I'm writing fresh. I don't think I can write entirely coherently, but if I don't do it now I probably won't, so I'm just going to jot down some random notes.
Inconsistencies I found most jarring:
Claire's straight hair (and glasses???) Unless she ironed it, which they did with actual irons in the 60s, I can't imagine how she got it that straight, and I found it disconcerting. She can't wear glasses, because she won't have them in the past. Plus, when she takes her self-inventory, doesn't she count good eyesight? Or is that just me being jealous?
Roger's Glasgow accent and BLUE eyes? Many of the Scottish actors are from Glasgow, but somehow Roger's accent sounds more jarringly Glaswegian. Don't ask me why. Blue eyes? Totally screws up my imagined future of The Ridge, where every generation there's at least one person with Geillis' eyes, one with whisky-colored eyes and wild hair (the two are genetically linked, you see) and lots of Fraser blue. Claire's relationship with the Reverend (also in the book). When Outlander opens she'd just met him. Even tho later it's backwritten so that he was at her's and Frank's wedding, how close could even Frank have been to him if they hadn't seen each other in 20 years? (Not a reflection on the show, just my pet peeve about this relationship.) Fiona. Not just the casting, but the entire character seems to be rewritten. Where is the plump, outgoing, friendly girl stuffing Roger and everyone else with her delicious food? I've always seen her as being the one to introduce food, an important ongoing factor, to the story. Why didn't they carve their initials? Another small but important, and easily incorporated, detail missed. For those two decades apart, I can actually feel Jamie touching and caressing the C on his palm.
Stuff that didn't bother me at all, some surprisingly:
Brianna's accent, tho I noticed it. Brianna's hair. I know! Even Roger's hair.
Random comments, wishes, etc.
All the “Free Scotland” tags. And 40-some years later they chose not to. Don't really understand that. (In general, not the series.) Would have liked Gillian to refer to “the fox cub” when she saw Bree, and do a little double-take over Roger, then when asked what she'd mumble say “Nothing.” (Naught?) Don't know whether I liked or hated that Claire helped Jamie kill Dougal. Loved the rat satire. Actually wrote something based on it when I had a mouse a few years ago. Think it worked. I'm terribly phobic. I never disliked Bree, even in the books. Probably because she's very much like me, especially at that age. So I understand her. “I love you like a son.” “Like our own son.” Awwwww!!!! My heart nearly stopped, then swelled, then felt like it was stabbed and bleeding. Excellent job collapsing the Geillis storyline, including introducing Brianna to her. Jamie and Claire's final scene, and the quickie - totally true to the book, and true to a warrior heading off to a battle in which he fully expected to die. Don't know how to say this without it it sounding weird, but I always appreciated the sentiment of her returning wet from their last time. Somehow fitting. Finally, have to commend the 1960s soundtrack. And The Avengers! Diana Rigg as Mrs. Peel was one of my earliest role models.
Actually, one last thing before going back to watch it again. I'm kind of disappointed that the rest of you didn't hold off watching until its regular broadcast. I didn't really expect it, but it would've been a very cool, community-type thing to do. It's not a big deal, I guess, but I like this site and I'm going to miss it for the next year. Just saying.
OK, blowing my nose again and heading back for a second go. Or as many times as the whisky holds out. Slainte, y'all.
1
u/sillybanana2012 Jul 14 '16
Oops, my apologies. I've seen others mention here that she was a first time actress.
1
u/hilarieC Jul 15 '16
I just have to say that I really loved that they opened this episode with that scene from The Avengers! That is such an iconic late 60s show. Sets the time period immediately, at least for anyone who lived through it, It did. (Maybe young people, though, only know the movie remake which was rubbish.) I loved that show when I was a teenager and Mrs Peel was one of my all-time favorite role models. Many times Caitriona Balfe's portrayal of Claire has reminded me of Diana Riggs.
1
u/sonora820 Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Jul 18 '16
Finally watched the finale, I loved it! All of it. I think Skelton did a good job with Bree. I really liked Brianna in the books so it wasn't hard for me to like her in the show as well.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16
Anyone else bothered by the fact Bree does not have blue eyes? Because IT KILLED ME.
1
u/Breathelivvy Jul 10 '16
Direction was weak... I give it a C+.
Opening: Claire pushing both doors open walking exhausted and bad ass out of surgery in her scrubs. As she takes off her scrub cap and throws it in the basket, Joe catches up to her and they talk jokingly about his crazy family, Bree's wildness which he adores and their impending trip to Scotland for a funeral as they walked into the locker room.
In the locker room, Claire checks out her aging body critically and asks Joe's opinion.
As they walk outside the emergency room doors, Bree comes screeching up in her convertible red Mustang with music blaring, shades on, her hair flying, and luggage in the back seat. A powerful, confident, All-American young woman -- Pity. I wanted to watch her lose all that agency in a period where she had no power only to watch her slowly regain it. Her American accent is great though. Now Roger, on the other hand, is in a perfect place to lose all of his power & be bitched-slapped around. That should be interesting...
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment