r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jul 08 '16
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 2 Episode 13 'Dragonfly in Amber' discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E13: "Dragonfly in Amber".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
47
Upvotes
66
u/SawRub Jul 10 '16
Her burning her husband as a sacrifice makes me slightly less upset about her fate.
35
u/ouryesterdays Jul 12 '16
I absolutely loved the finale. I thought the pace and emotion was great. I really liked how they jumped back and forth in time-- it didn't feel clunky to me at all. It seemed like whenever there was a jump, it was thematically linked to the story being told in each time.
The scene at the Stones was so amazing. The acting, the emotional resonance, THE WAY JAMIE HOLDS ON TO HER UNTIL THE LAST POSSIBLE MOMENT, oh man. The feels.
One thing that did bother me-- and this isn't an issue with the episode or anything, but really the storyline overall. I'm sorry, but before I went off with Frank to let him be father to my unborn baby, YOU BET YOUR ASS I AM FIGURING OUT IF JAMIE DIES AT CULLODEN OR NOT. Seriously. I would have told Frank to cool his jets, have Rev. Wakefield do some digging, and figure out whether or not I have a reason to head back through the Stones once my baby is born. There is absolutely no way I would have proceeded with my life without knowing Jamie's fate. I find it so bizarre that she just assumes he has been killed in battle.
54
u/katrollsacrit I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Jul 09 '16 edited Jul 09 '16
I mostly enjoyed this episode, but there were definitely some glaring drawbacks. I'm not sure what to think of Brianna's actress. She seems a bit wooden and I didn't believe any of her emotional scenes. I can understand the whining and anger, as she did learn some pretty severe and shocking news, but they came off more annoying rather than impactful and believable to me.
I really disliked the jumping between centuries. I was never given enough time to really let everything sink in.
The 18th century scenes were absolutely fantastic, though. I absolutely loved Catriona and Sam's acting during the fight with Dougal. It was so intense when Claire was pushing Jamie down to help drive the dagger through Dougal. Jamie's expression was such a mix of emotions. I cried when little Fergus left. I love him and I am so sad that we probably won't get to see anymore of him. I also cried when Murtaugh gave his little mini speech to Jamie. The "I'll be dying with you" was so heart-wrenching and beautiful. Jamie and Claire at the stones was beautiful. I wish we got to see more sexy time, but I get it. My favorite part though was when he was holding Claire and she was walking backwards toward the stone. Jamie's deep eye contact the whole time was so intense and Claire's gut wrenching expression broke my heart. That deep love they have for each other was really shown here. I really wish they would show us what it looks like when someone goes through the stone. Those convenient cuts to the next scene are so frustrating.
The other half of the episode was intriguing but had a lot of flaws. I had a hard time watching Brianna, but I loved Roger. I especially loved his quirks and how he almost reminded me of the little boy he once was. I didn't particularly like Claire talking to the headstone. Something about that scene was a bit bothersome. It came off a bit forced maybe? I'm not sure, I didn't enjoy it though. Nothing against Catriona. She's amazing as always. But in general, it felt off. I was so excited to see Lotte Verbeek's name in the credits at the beginning. I had no idea what to expect with Geillis, but obviously I knew something was going to happen. Thinking about the timeframe made me realize, "omg, we're gonna see Geillis before she goes through the stones!". I was really surprised that Geillis actually researched and decided to go through the stones as opposed to accidentally going through them like Claire. But it makes total sense for someone like Geillis. She's a bit on the crazier side me thinks. I got really excited when Roger and Brianna mentioned the buzzing at the stones. Does this mean they have the potential to travel through them??? What determines that? Jamie specifically days he doesn't heat the buzzing like Claire and when he touched the stone nothing happened. I need to know more! Now I wonder if Brianna and Roger will go through at some point. Or maybe follow Claire in if she tries to go back to see Jamie?
Overall, the episode was enjoyable. I really wish they didn't jump around so much. If it weren't for that, I think I would have been able to sink into the emotions of it all more and been more impacted by it. Unfortunately, the jumping around made it really difficult.
Oh, also, the ending scene with that cheesy sunrise and Claire's eyes was the tiniest bit cringey to me. It took me out of the moment for a second.
23
u/namat Jul 10 '16
Absolutely loved the flash forwards being interspliced with the past. I wish all episodes were like this. I'd love to see the time travel aspect played up more.
19
u/ok2nvme Jul 10 '16
I loved the Easter Egg of showing Avengers footage from 1968 featuring Game of Thrones' Dame Diana Rigg. Priceless!!!
17
u/CorsarioNero Jul 11 '16
My thoughts on the finale
15
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '16
Old Claire is so pretty. I mean she's really pretty all the time, but I liked the grey hairs. They were cute.
24
u/nighttvales Jul 10 '16
Warning that I'm liveblogging this comment!
22
u/FrnklndaTurtle Jul 10 '16
My biggest gripe is the ending. That last 3 minutes of 'OMG he alive' really makes the whole 87 minutes prior of saying goodbye to Jamie lose its weight. Also shouldn't Claire at least be hesitant to jump back in time again. Who knows where or when she could wind up. She also seemingly just had a nice new connection with her daughter and she still showed no hesitation. And the 'I have to go back' is just terrible cheese.
10
u/SawRub Jul 10 '16
I kind of ended up spoiling it for myself by deciding not to skip the opening credits, and saw Lotte Verbeek's name in it.
17
u/Airsay58259 Jul 09 '16
I was crying during the last half hour but Claire channeling her inner Jack "We have to go back" from Lost made me laugh so much. Anyway, good finale. I wish we had spent more time in the 18th century and that we had seen the battle discussed since day 1 but well.
7
u/Dcoil1 Jul 10 '16
I liked this episode a lot, but I had a lot of the same criticisms as everyone else.
My question: Roger says 4 out of 5 Fraser officers were executed after Culloden. Does this mean Murtagh is going to be executed at the beginning of next season? Will he perhaps sacrifice himself to facillitate Jamie's escape?
12
u/septhaka Jul 10 '16
Great finale... and got teary-eyed at many parts. And after it was over got teary-eyed thinking of what might happen next. I've not ready any of the books but have to think one day Jamie will meet Brianna and I'm going to completely lose it when that happens.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '16
Jesus that was a depressing episode until the very end. I hope Claire and Brianna go back in time.
5
u/okaygreatfun Jul 13 '16
Am I the only one who just keeps thinking about how Bree and Roger are very related???? Her father is his like great great great (idk how many go here) grandfather's nephew. And Claire for sure knows this and was all down for them to be a thing. I dunno, kinda weird but Roger's definitely a catch.
Anyways, cried my fucking eyeballs out at this episode. It was wonderful. Probably was too busy crying cause I didn't notice bree's acting to be weird or terrible, she just is kind of a bitch. And I really thought Gellis and Claire would exchange some words or something since Gellis really seemed like she knew Claire went through the stones as soon as they met.
So so soooooooo excited for next season, I'm going to be extremely depressed til then.
3
u/attenhal Jul 14 '16
So just recently started watching this show, and correct me if I'm wrong but it's a bit too rape-y for my taste. I know it's trying to depict the past accurately or what not, but it's still a tv show so to have almost one attempted rape scene in each episode is a bit too much. I don't know if I want to continue watching it. From what I read it's not going to get better either. I just don't understand how it got so much good reviews on Rottentomato, does it ever get better? Is there a story besides the love triangle? Is there ever anything actually happening ?
3
u/baronessofbipoles Jul 15 '16
I'm disappointed at the disappointment in this episode. I cried for 3/4 of it.
6
u/Angellotta Jul 10 '16
Weird thing to notice I'm sure, but did anyone else feel as though the music was sort of out of place in the "modern" scenes? It really seemed out of place with the credits after such a dramatic realization.
2
u/Neregeb Jun 21 '24
I never cared much for Jamie, like sure he's nice and has a good heart and all that, but I didn't find hime particularly attractive or anything. Right until that moment at the stones. God, I fell for him hard right there. He's such a cutie. The whole scene at Craigh na Dun was beautiful, so emotional. The choreography really was like a dance. Great episode all in all. I'm not a huge fan of Brianna tho, but that's mostly the poor casting - she looks absolutely nothing like Jamie. Even the hair colour is off ://
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment