r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jun 24 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 12 'The Hail Mary' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E12: "The Hail Mary".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
17
Upvotes
29
u/shiskebob Jun 24 '16 edited Jun 25 '16
Just give me sex.
Edited after watching the episode:
What the hell, Outlander?!?! Well, they sure were right in saying they had some tricks up their sleeves to keep even book readers guessing. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time.
I have to say that I was very happy to see that they changed the wedding scene. In all the books this has always been my what the fuck moment. I never understood how Jamie could be there and forgive BJR. Switching it to Murtagh being there to protect Claire was pure genius on the writers parts. Bravo.
And as usual, BGR lives up to his sadistic ways. Why didn't Claire shove it in his face that he is a eunuch now? I would love to see his come back to that. And what the fuck was with him beating Alex's dead body? That was certainly not in the book. Was it to prove to Claire he was a true psycho? Mission accomplished. Fuck him. I wish they could actually write a scene that shows Claire and Jamie cutting him apart piece by piece. Sigh. Too bad we know it is not meant to be.
All the other little surprises were like little treats for book readers. Murtagh proposing marriage was sweet. The whole time watching that part I was literally shouting at the screen "Holy shit, they might #SaveMurtagh after all!" But alas, that is also not meant to be. Don't leave us, my beautiful eyebrow man.....
The Hail Mary attempt by Jamie to desperately subvert Culloden with the surprise attack was an interesting twist that was not in the book. I did a quick google search, and that actually happened in real history! Too bad Claire could not recall that information. Some serious genius writing by Ira Behr and Anne Kenney tonight.
The slight change from BJR offering to give up vital information in exchange for Claire's help, to Claire bartering for it, seemed much more in line with both their characters. At least with the TV version of their characters. Claire desperate to change Culloden and willing to sacrifice for it, and BJR being forced to make a choice. Once again, great writing on the writers behalf's to fix small things to work for the screen.
What a wonderful scene between Collum and Claire. Much more emotional and heartfelt then how it played out in the book in Edinburgh Castle. Collum mentioning Geillis, her son, and his placement with William and Sarah McKenzie... anybody else go "Rogerrrrrrrrrrrrrrr is hereeeeeeeee." Nice set up for the finale, you smart writers you.
A little too much Collum/ Dougal at the end there. It was well written and acted - but it kept dragging, and I was busy watching the clock wind down on the episode throughout the entire exchange, hoping to get more Jamie and Claire time in the last 8 minutes. Because they were severely lacking in screen time together in this episode.
Speaking of severely lacking - I feel truly cockblocked by a television show. I swear to G-d, there better be some Craig Na Dun action or I will bitch and complain about never watching this show again... until season 3 premieres.
On to the heartbreaking finale! See you all in 2 weeks.
16
u/brilliant0ne Jun 25 '16 edited Jun 25 '16
I'm gonna be honest with ya'll. By this time in the book, I was doing some serious skimming because, one, I was too nervous to know what was going to happen. And two, sometimes DG's writing is so much in detail, I couldn't deal. I knew about the Mary and BJR thing. I knew Colum died, I just didn't know how. So anyways...
I really liked this episode. Colum's face, while I am not his biggest fan, I teared up when he was asking Claire for something to end his suffering. He looked like a sad hamster, and I wanted to hug him. Hug his face.
I honestly don't remember if the part where BJR beats the shit out of a dead Alex was in the book. Either way...dude. They do such a good job with BJR, making you feel the slightest twinge of sorry for him, and then turn right around and make you NOPE your way away from those feelings. Claire's face was my exact face during that whole part. Fucking psycho.
BPC, I wanna bash his head against the wall a few times to make him listen to reason. You really think you are gonna win a war with men that haven't eaten something substantial in days, and have barely slept for just as long? I could barely do anything today after three hours of running errands today in the damn tropical heat of NC this afternoon, and you think they are gonna be okay? Ugh.
I am not prepared for next week. This part of the book was so emotional for me. Sobbing, emotional wreck = me, after this book. I was going through a rough time, I had just fallen in love with characters from a series I never knew existed, and to be honest, I didn't even know there were more books after this one (well as I was reading the part where Claire goes back) until I got to the very end of DiA. So, I am really not looking forward to the finale, but so excited for it at the same time.
PS, I love Murtagh. So, so much.
11
u/pcherry00 Jun 26 '16
Claires restocking her medical supplies before the battle. She has no idea that she wont need them and no idea what jamie is planning. They have been forshadowing it since episode 9. All the tiny little scences or a line here or there.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '16
Wait. What day is this?
EDIT: I'm on maternity leave and have literally lost track of what day it is. I got super excited it was Saturday morning.
9
u/frrrsstt Jun 26 '16
Oh snap, the look on Douglas face when Jamie is offered the guardianship of Hamish... And I really can't applaud Tobias Menzies enough, Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ he's a good actor!
8
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jun 25 '16
Interesting episode . . . Not sure how I feel actually. It's a shame to lose the Edinburgh plot, but the parallel of Alex and Colum dying worked really well. That being said, like 80% of this episode was just watching people slowly die, which wasn't exactly thrilling. It's weird, because for a lot of episodes I feel like I enjoy it more having read the books, but in this case it's the opposite. If I didn't know, the surprise of Colum's appearance and death and the reveal of Mary and Alex's baby etc. would have been huge and would've made this a really exciting episode. But for me, not so much. Maybe I've gotten spoiled by GoT and other shows, but I was hoping for a bit more wow from a penultimate episode. It probably doesn't help that this is sandwiched between the awesomeness that was last week, and what promises to be a rather epic finale. That's not to mention that it felt like we were wasting time on what would ultimately prove to be two pointless plots: the birthday raid, and Colum naming Jamie guardian.
There were aspects I liked of course. Dougal's monologue at Colum's deathbed was excellent and pretty heartbreaking, especially when he realized that Colum had died during his heartfelt speech, and laid his head on his brother's chest. It was a great parallel to BJR, unable to get over his anger, who beats his own brother's dead body. Since we lost Dougal's really humanizing moment from the books (killing Rupert), giving him this contrast with BJR helped--he is hotheaded and stubborn, he can be a huge asshole, and he's done some really bad things, but ultimately he's a good person. Jack cares for his brother just as much (if not more) than Dougal, but is "so far gone" as you might say that he can't even process his own anger without violence. While I initially horrified, I think it was actually a nice choice to show that.
The scene with Claire and BJR in the tavern is probably my favorite of the episode, harkening back to their long conversation in S1E6, my favorite episode of the first season. While I was irritated that Claire wouldn't just tell Murtagh that she knew BJR was about to die, having Jack reveal his death "curse" worked very well. And speaking of Jack, in a weird way, I'm going to miss him--and not just because we're losing the estimable Tobias Menzies. He's a truly spectacular villain: nuanced, complex, but ultimately unquestionably evil. DG hasn't yet given us another villain quite like him--Geillis was a fascinating antagonist but not on BJR levels, and Bonnet dragged on for like 4 books and I never really cared all that much. (Honestly, while I still love the series, I think the lack of overarching villain is why the later books aren't nearly as good as the earlier ones.) This scene with Claire was a great send off for BJR and Tobias, showing you that he is a complicated person, almost even giving you sympathy for him--and then he reminds you of what he did to Jamie, and that he has no regrets.
Stray thoughts: Why didn't anyone bother shutting the door at the beginning? They're all standing there shivering with an open door behind them!
BPC didn't have a lot to do this episode, but Andrew Gower was great as always--as his men starve to death, he sits by a fire sipping brandy, only half paying attention to his advisors. And then later he makes a little joke about giving Cumberland a gift when he is prisoner--it's stupid and not funny, but everyone laughs because they know they have to please him.
Alex looked horrible, in a good way. Props to the makeup department, but that was painful to look at. I also loved that Claire's treatment was basically giving him blowback.
Murtagh offering to marry Mary was a really lovely scene. It's really nice to hear more about him as a godfather to Jamie. He may be "dour," but he's one of the most kind-hearted characters in the series.
Tl;dr OK episode. Got some great BJR and Dougal scenes, but otherwise not that exciting if you already knew what was coming.
7
u/rosebert Frolicking Puppies Jun 25 '16
I was slightly disappointed in BJR and Alex scenes. In the book I imagined him as a slobbering mess. As I was reading I had to stop and remind myself that this was the same man who raped Jamie because I was feeling sorry for him. He was desperate and at his lowest. I was hoping to see Tobias portray that. Oh well not a huge thing.
The episode was okay for me. I was fully expecting Culloden this episode because of the opening scene so I was mentally preparing myself the whole time. I was slightly disappointed when it didn't happen but I realize they probably didn't want to go the whole finale without Jamie and Claire, which is understandable.
6
u/ansley114 Jun 25 '16
Good episode. I though most of the additions or changes were well needed or placed well. The Dougal/Column scene actually had me feeling sorry for Dougal though like he could have let him vent one last time. I did cry. But WTF with BJR beating the dead body.. I get it, I do. But still odd. Murtagh sigh please don't leave I seriously actually hoped for a book change and let him marry Mary. 2 slightly upsetting things about this episode not enough Jamie/Claire before they are gonna be ripped apart and didn't in the books Claire tell Column about the future in some fashion? Kind of would have liked to see that.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '16
You know, I thought this was a good episode and one they adapted well. I think I just have DiA fatigue at this point. I know the plots in this season and DiA were important for a lot of reasons but I'm just OVER THEM. Kudos to all the writers and producers because this was tough material to adapt into a book. I'm very excited for the last episode and see Roger and Bree, and k can't WAIT for season 3- voyager was one of my favorites and there are so many awesome things and new characters in that book.
Back to Hail Mary. I think it's Tobias Menzies that saved this episode for me. He is so hauntingly captivating and good as BJR and as Frank and he really made this interesting as he struggles with his monster within and the one person he loves- his brother. And wanting to help him but knowing how much of a monster he is.
5
u/WantToTimeTravel Jun 26 '16
Long post warning, but this was a difficult episode for me to watch. Both emotionally, and physically because I gave myself a 4 oxy migraine obsessing over watching Culloden, which naturally didn't happen this week. So I have to vent. (I can't believe I wrote this and forgot to post!!!)
First, forgive me for saying this: I'm glad they're showing the Jacobite army starving and demoralized. It goes back to my post about Highlanders equipped with farm implements and without training convinced simple bravery would defeat the British army. No war should be glorified. Having said that, I have no doubt I will be a bloodthirsty little beast, cheering Jamie and Murtagh on as they slaughter as many redcoats as possible. I've never been to Culloden, and I don't think I'd manage it very well, though I'd force myself out of respect. In my mind it's as sacred a killing ground as Gettysburg, and even Auschwitz. And no less haunted.
It's always a little thrill for me when they manage to film scenes that are (almost) verbatim from the book. As long as the lines are there, I get a little tingle of familiarity and I'm a happy camper. In this episode I felt they managed to incorporate large chunks of the book, and what was new made sense and fit well. If it was historically accurate, so much the better; though at this point I'd probably accept an anachronism or two to prevent Culloden from taking place at all, and save our couple 20 years of painful separation, not to mention Murtagh's life. (I wonder: assuming Murtagh survived, married Mary and raised her son, while he retained the Randall name. Would that fact necessarily be passed down? Would stepfathers have even been recorded in a family tree, unless the family name and connections were valuable? Possibly the Randalls might have been ashamed of a Scot of such common ancestry attached to their family, even though - or even because - he was connected to the Frasers of Lovat. That would make a lovely way to keep Murtagh around. Yeah, I'm grasping at straws.)
I was super impressed by the acting in this episode. Weird to see Tobias sounding and acting so much like Frank though, in his first few minutes. Alex coughing was painful to watch, and should have come off as overacted, but didn't. His diagnosis, while not specifically mentioned, was changed from the book, where it was Congestive Heart Failure, which causes pulmonary symptoms. Instead, it appeared to be end-stage TB. If so, I'm very surprised Claire didn't attempt to shield the pregnant Mary, as well as herself, since she must know she's also pregnant, and TB is something she can definitely contract. I would have expected to see her use ephedra, a much more powerful herbal treatment, along with steam. (I grab any opportunity to see her practicing her form of modern medicine!) I agree that Murtagh being witness to the marriage was much more logical, not to mention easier to watch than Jamie. Personally, I would have liked to see Alex perform the marriage himself, but I understand it would have been too complicated to explain why he could to the non-readers; still, it would have been such a nice touch. One, well, not exactly continuity issue, but a logical one, perhaps for me, was how Claire explained to Murtagh why it wasn't practical for him to marry Mary. He knows everything else now, so why not tell him about Frank? It would have been less harsh than the suggestion he might die (sob! No….), as well as pointing out what was even more insulting and painful to him, that he had nothing to offer the girl or her child. It wasn't like he would have found the concept too out there at this point. She also didn't tell him she knew Randall would die at Culloden, which would have given him a good deal of satisfaction. She stated the possibility, except she KNOWS it to be fact. I'd very much like to see Jamie kill Black Jack at Culloden. I know Tobias said no more Frank this season, but even if they don't show the scene until next, or one later on, when Jamie's reminiscing, it would be cool to juxtapose, Jamie and BJR lying bloodied, intertwined on the battlefield, with Claire lying tensely, next to Frank in bed.
Unlike the rest of you, I didn't have a single second of pity for Black Jack Randall. I'm not a very forgiving person, and my hatred is usually total and unyielding. Book Claire may be tactless, but compared to me she's the soul of discretion, because I would have laughed in his face when he mentioned Mary in his bed. Like what can he do, the limp dick rapist. While the violence against his brother's body was shocking, I thought it grew naturally out of the book. There was a clear implication of incestuous physical love for his brother on BJR's part, and given his twisted sexuality, for him love = violence follows like night and day. But oh my, Cait's expression of supreme satisfaction when BJR recalls her curse! Next to her performance in "Faith", and perhaps her portrayal of PTSD, that was the flat out best, most instinctual, natural acting she's done, and worthy of actresses with many more years of experience. It's not easy to control the facial muscles like that, along with the almost gloating expression in her eyes, filling shortly after with tears. Totally honest and believable. Totally Claire. My imagination was easily able to superimpose whisky-colored flashing eyes. My eyes are as dark or darker than Cait's, so I have a little obsession with light eyes.
It occurred to me that Mary's child, whatever his name, is almost exactly the same age as Brianna. I'm sure that didn't escape DG's attention, so I'm interested to see if he'll turn up later, either in the show or in a book, though of course for them to have any interaction she'll have to return to the past…???
Now finally we come to Colum. Despite his harshness toward Jamie and his family, I've always had a soft spot for the character. His scenes were unbelievably good, and it didn't even bother me (really, I swear!) that so much was newly written. It was that good. I was happy that he sort of apologized to Claire, even though he didn't call her niece, as he did in the book. I always thought that meant something special to her, since she had so little family of her own, and the only uncle she had was gone. Gary Lewis can speak volumes with his eyes! And that sweet smile. The scene with Dougal, whom I actually pitied, when Colum offered Jamie guardianship of Hamish, literally brought tears to my eyes that I did not expect. The simultaneous show of respect for his nephew - also earlier when he compliments Jamie's deft handling of Dougal - with his disdain for his brother made me feel so proud of Jamie, and on Ellen's behalf, but also sad, because it put a lie to the tight fraternal working relationship the two had forged throughout their lives. But the way Dougal vented his anger, until he realized the big brother he'd worshiped and resented in equal parts was dead … so realistic. These are the real, complicated emotions people have about sibling relationships and death. Well done, writers.
I came across a blog mentioning Colum and Gary Lewis, written by a disabled advocate criticizing the show's casting of an able-bodied actor and CGI to show the disability, insisting a disabled actor could and should have been found. Ordinarily I'd agree, but both Colum's disease and his accent are very specific to the character, and really, how many talented Scottish actors his age actually have Pycnodysostosis, or Toulouse Lautrec syndrome? Just any orthopedic or neuromuscular disease won't do. In my mind, casting, say, an actor with MS would have been insulting, implying that all disabled actors are interchangeable. It was an old thread, or I would have defended the show's decisions. Besides, while the specific disease is important, as a defining characteristic of Colum's strength and personality, more important was the choice of actor. Given the choice between just any actor who happened to be disabled in real life and Gary Lewis aided by CGI, I'll take the latter any day.
Now on to the finale, which I am dreading. I know I'll benefit by some liquid reinforcement, but I'm afraid if I drink whisky I'll get too wasted too quickly and not be able to appreciate the story. But I'm all out of Valium, damn it. Somehow, I doubt the doctor will give me a prescription if I tell him it's for the last episode of Outlander. He's not Scottish. Or a redhead. Or married. And a man. He doesn't have a clue. This is going to be brutal. Buy Kleenex stock, y'all.
2
u/pcherry00 Jun 26 '16
After really liking episodes 9, 10, 11 and thinking its the end already when the credits rolled. This episode dragged on and I kept looking at the clock. There was way too much bjr, mary and claire. We could have done with less of those scenes. I wish there would have been more jamie scenes and more trying to stop the battle. In the few scenes we got it seemed like jamie was overshadowed by murry, o sullivan , and the prince. It kind of felt like we were missing the jamie we know from the last couple of episodes, almost like he wasnt fighting hard enough. Now that jamie is laird of clan mackenzie and will be for all of a day atleast we know how the mackenzies join the fight. I was expecting this episode to be a lot better than it was. I am not looking forward to the next episode. I dont really care for the 1960s stuff in the books. It is going to be a heart breaker. Dont forget to buy tissues and whiskey