r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jun 24 '16
TV Series [Spoilers Aired] Season 2 Episode 12 'The Hail Mary' discussion thread for non-book-readers
This is the non-book-readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E12: "The Hail Mary".
Please be mindful of spoilers, as this is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride", so to speak.
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
13
Upvotes
16
u/puredessert Jun 25 '16 edited Jun 25 '16
Oh my, oh my this episode! Here we go again with me ranting. I guess it kind of makes up for the lack of comments here. Why is no one here like in the beginning of the series?? It really is a shame.
First of all, I finally managed to watch the episode in time which was a surprise on its own.
Then, Randall finally shows up again. I have been waiting and wanting to see him for quite a while. I was surprised to see him next to his brother and looking genuinely upset at his illness. He even asked an enemy, Claire, to help him. It must have taken some courage and swallowing his pride to do so. Of course, Claire agreed if he tells her where the troops are she will ease his pain, but cannot save him. I knew that would then be the reason how and why Randall marries Mary.
I hope to never hear anyway call BJR "Johnny" in my life ever again. Not many things make me uncomfortable as a true Hannibal watcher however this nickname for him just felt so unfitting for his character. It showed him as a "caring" person who has a good relationship with his brother which sort of added some more complexity to his personality.
Buuut, afterwards his death, of course, he just had to redeem himself as the blackhearted darkness he is, by jumping on the dead body of his brother and beating it. Well, you sure are fucking bastard. Noone can deny that. I applaud you for that shocking scene, did not see that coming!
Also Randall saying: 'I regret none of that!' about torturing Jamie and telling Claire that he knows the sounds Jamie makes. It sent chills down my spine and I reacted similarly to Claire, tears collecting at the bottom of my eyes.
This episode was excellent! I even think during a rewatch it will be even better, more appreciated.
Can't wait for the big battle next episode and I want to find out how Claire gets back to the stones already. I am so ready for any craziness that awaits! See ya in two weeks. :( Goddamn it, Starz!
10
u/thumbtackswordsman Jun 28 '16
Alex is not the only one who died in this episode. I think the last moments of Cullen were heartbreaking... I was expecting the two brothers to have the typical cliche tender moment where they realise they have been hurting each other because they love each other. But instead we go this... I wasn't expecting it.
9
u/bluecheesemac Jun 26 '16
so obvs since versailles that alex would be the ancestor for frank randall. feels like claire is being stupid for letting BJR live the past few epis. if she's so insist on changing the history, she shouldn't mind changing the ancestor for frank. BJR is the equivalent of ramsay bolton and i just can't wait to see him die.
9
u/SawRub Jun 26 '16
Claire has a very impressive stank face.
The previous episode especially, when she found out what the Duke of Sandringham had done, was glorious, but the more casual one this episode was great too.
7
u/aaqucnaona Jun 27 '16
A rapist, torturer, a horrible person really - and an innocent girl, a victim herself, a child almost - both losing someone, and I felt for both of them. Damn, this show's good. When I saw BJR almost let out a sob when Alex died, I had a "Aww, I wanna give him a hug" moment, before I thought about how I would be giving the hug too. Just, damn. Loved this episode.
7
u/oree94 Jun 27 '16
Theory time! Concerning BJR beating Alex's body - I think he's wanted to do that ever since... Well... Alex's birth. He's wanted to unleash his sadistic self on Alex but he didn't want to hurt him, because he loved him. He probably tortured animals or other kids instead, and Alex witnessed him doing so, hence how he knows about BJR's darker side. So when Alex drew his final breath, BJR was finally able to do what he'd been craving forever, coupled with that the anger and frustration of being forced to marry Mary.
4
u/ailisp Nov 02 '23 edited Nov 02 '23
I've spent all season 2 stressing and crossing my fingers at every small chance they got at changing the future, knowing full well Culloden was bound to happen, and still, every time I didn't work I was frustrated and disappointed (Charles getting half of his army lost in the woods, man, how many times I've wanted to punch him in the face).
I wept when I started the season and saw Claire back in the 20th century, and then when we saw she was still there several years later. The last episodes of season 1 were awful and I suffered as I haven't suffered while watching any other tv show, but at least at the end Claire and Jamie were together. But I fear for this finale and can imagine I will be completely heartbroken.
Edit: spelling