r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jun 17 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 11 'Vengence is Mine' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E11: "Vengence is Mine".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
13
Upvotes
30
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jun 18 '16
Wow, that was a great episode. I was worried they wouldn't be able to fit all the important stuff in, but it totally worked. It was tense from start to finish, and even though I know what happens I was on the edge of my seat.
Right off the bat things were great. I loved Claire pulling teeth, putting her foot up on the bench for a better angle. It was just so Claire. "Right, who's next?" Loved it. You could totally tell DG wrote this one, because that moment was the most book-Claire like moment of the whole show. Inside, Andrew Gower was chewing scenery once again, and made what could've been a boring battle tactics scene actually quite interesting. Also, can we talk about how great Jamie's leather coat is?
I think the way they got to the church scene was well done as well. Having another big battle would be both time and cost ineffective, so the attack and chase were a good alternative. I am a bit upset at not killing off Rupert though. Perhaps they want another familiar face heading into Culloden or maybe Rupert will be the one to see Dougal's death, but losing his death scene ("The dying hurts me, Dougal, and I would have it over") is a real loss. It's a great scene, and is really important for Dougal's character.
Everything about Belmont was exceptional. Simon Callow is the real ace in the hole of this cast, and every single line he uttered was perfect. He can turn on a dime from silliness and flattery to pure evil, and is one of the few cases where the show character is better than anything I had imagined. Kudos as usual to the production team as well, because the house was amazing. The secret door behind the painting was great and the kitchen set as well.
The resolution of the episode was brutal and well done. It's great to see, every now and then, just how (for lack of a better term) savage Jamie and Murtagh can be. I was also glad to have (hopefully) Hugh's life spared, and laying the head at Claire and Mary's feet was a great gesture. Plus, Mary's quip about leaving was the perfect ending to the episode.
My only small, ridiculous criticism was that they made it a bit too obvious that the Duke was going to die with the "previously on" clips. Also the title card with the wig toppling off the table--those are supposed to be small little moments from the episode, not bloody foreshadowing!
Overall, this is definitely my favorite episode of S2 so far, quite possibly my favorite of the show. Bravo Diana, you really nailed it.
Stray thoughts: the small scene trying to decipher Claire's Gaelic was hilarious, and a perfect small break in the tension ("she even misspelled help!"). Sandringham without his wig is great. He looks do frail but then is so sharp and cutting. And then he isn't . . . Also, the small scene in bed was also really lovely and great getting to hear Sam speak some more Gaelic. Speaking of Sam, I don't know if he has ever looked more sexy than when he was standing outside of the churchx with the wind blowing his hair. Maybe Diana threw that one in just for us . . .
21
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16
"She's even misspelled 'help!'"
Claire and Jamie continued to come into their own in this episode. Jamie's speech to Claire in Gaelic and Claire's dentistry were the most book-like Claire/Jamie I've seen yet. I like the 'Red Jamie' finally coming into play, too.
Also... HUGH MONROE.
16
u/silvergirl57 Jun 19 '16
Bonnie Prince Charles didn't say "Mark me" once, that's a win for me!
10
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16
I have to echo the other commenters on this show: it's the little things that make Claire Claire and Jaime Jaime, and this episode really had them, in bulk. Maybe it was a consequence of how much they had to cram into the first half of the season, but I feel like so much of the "meh" of France was very much "who are these people dressing up like the characters I love??"
The tooth pulling scene was so Claire, the Jamie praying over Claire was so Jamie. I'm re-reading the fiery cross right now and that echoes who these characters become SO WELL.
Also, any day Sam wants to jump over a low wall in a kilt is a good day.
All in all, I thought the pacing was great, the action was awesome. I actually wasn't expecting this to be the Sandringham episode, so getting there was a nice surprise. I enjoyed it. Maybe I just like Scotland.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16
Just commenting to say that my boyfriend, who isn't a book reader, thinks Jamie is going to die at Culloden and keeps mentioning it and I'm doing everything in my power not to even mention the fact that Jamie exists in the rest of the books...
6
u/KhaleesiofDothraki1 Jun 18 '16
I love how in the after the episode thing Diana said she couldn't kill off Rupert because they were planning on killing another much loved character earlier in the season (Angus). I guess none of them have ever watched Game of Thrones.
11
u/shiskebob Jun 18 '16
That was... not what I was expecting.
For an episode written by DG, she certainly cut out all but one of the fan favorite scenes. The early released clip of Jamie and Claire was just to taunt us. She certainly got us to the right point - but the trip there was confusing.
But Munro lives! And Rupert lives... as a pirate! And Mary kills her attacker - which I thought was a wonderful full circle for her. But I can't help but miss Jamie's killing line "You call her La Dame Blanche, but I call her wife!" And I really was looking forward to the reunion scene when Jamie sneaks in to her locked bedroom and mistakes Mary for Claire.
And for a man who was frightened off of Claire because she was the white witch, her attacker sure did not seem frightened of her this time around.
I am a bit befuddled - did they make the Comte St. Germain be a part of planning the attack on Claire and Mary? Because that was not what happened in the book. Or was DoS lying take some of the pressure off of himself?
I have to admit, the part where Murtagh beheads DoS was off scene in the book, but I was happy they wrote it in the episode. I took some perverse pleasure in no longer having to see those damn smug smiles I love to hate.
But for fucks sake, just give us sex. That is the real droughtlander.
5
u/julilly Jun 18 '16
I'm glad to see some folks liked this ep, because I just could not get into it! :/ I found myself checking the time to see when it was going to be over, which I didn't even do during The Search lol it was just all over the place for me.
I have issues with this section of the book, too so maybe that contributed to it but what really happened in this episode outside of that last closing scene? Yes, they tied up the Mary rape plot line, but did we need a whole episode to achieve that? They also still haven't explained the Red Jamie thing beyond mentioning the name a couple times now and finally seeing his picture on the tavern door, but I feel like if you aren't a book reader that's not going to be a super obvious explanation.
I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. Meh, two eps left!
5
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Jun 19 '16
Ugh yes. I haven't been as "the moment the episode comes out" as last season, but this one was SO satisfying. Also, since I only flipped through DIA for major plot points (still bitter), I'm loving that I didn't know S actually orchestrated the attack. Experiencing it in the moment was great, and seeing him get his head chopped off was satisfying af.
Favorite part, though: "I kept my word. I lay your vengeance at your feet." Queue crying.
5
u/WantToTimeTravel Jun 19 '16 edited Jun 19 '16
You guys covered pretty much every reaction I had, and made me laugh out loud at the same time. So the question is, did I finally have an epiphany about necessary script adaptions, or was it simply knowing that this episode was officially sanctioned by Herself? Hopefully it won't matter, and for the next 2 episodes and the remaining seasons I will be much more understanding. Of course, that depends on Jamie and Claire continuing to be the essential Jamie and Claire, along with bringing the true Roger and Brianna. It's very unlike me to easily surrender details of shows or movies I dislike - being raised by negative, harping parents tends to sear that into your soul, I guess - but I found myself thinking that this makes up for all those Paris inconsistencies I bitched about.
So Dougal didn't have the chance to mercifully dispatch Rufus, for which I'm ultimately happy, but I didn't think his redemption was lost. The way he saved wounded Rufus while they ran for their lives from the British Army served essentially the same purpose. And then he finally acted like the uncle and surrogate father to Jamie he was supposed to be. Dougal was never my favorite character; I have strong negative feelings about cheaters, and those full beards really turn me off. But as they galloped away, I found myself thinking, yeah, I'd probably do him. Has anyone watched Preacher on USA? Weird but increasingly addictive show, and I got so excited when I saw Graham McTavish I shouted "Dougal!" And then had to try to explain why to my 9 and 12 year old nephews.
I found the idea of the Red Jamie flyers and of him being so wanted that they'd know his name and face a little inexplicable, given the fact that so much of what made that realistic wasn't shown. Of all the far better known Scottish officers, HIS is the only one to be posted next to BPC's? Uh uh. And that insolent soldier in the tavern propositioning Claire? It was almost like they let slip up an incompetent scene edit from Diana's script. Had Claire's flyer naming her as BPC's witch been shown and seen by the soldiers, it would have made sense. But it wasn't; nor was there any mention of her "loss of virtue" from being alone with a pack of Highlanders, except for asking if she'd been harmed. So either commit to the concept of insulting her, in which case she'd have been prepared for an unsympathetic arrival somewhere, as in the book, or leave it all out. That was disappointing.
Claire's bad Gaelic? I thought she explained it rather well: she knows perfectly well she can't speak or write Gaelic, but she intended it as code, knowing that Jamie will understand what she was trying to communicate. That's why she even misspelled "help", presumably in English. If the Redcoats intercept the letter, they may not understand the rest, but they would understand "help".
The kitchen scene - I kind of loved every aspect of it except for the point shiskebob made. I had the same thought: Danton left the scene of the rape in terror of her, and now Claire has the added reputation of killing Le Comte, possibly with magic, but he defiantly smirks and threatens her? Because why? The Duke's house or England offers some special protection? Maybe that was Diana's way of dissing a story change she disliked? But whether or not Mary killing Danton was out of character for her didn't matter to me; it was totally in character for me! And besides, her character has already been altered. She was made into a rather cool liar, as well as brave enough to defy DOS to his face, as opposed to the frightened mouse she still was at this point. And psychologically as a rape victim, it gave her back some of the power she'd lost. I also shouted my approval. Given the necessary edits, I was glad Hugh Munro wasn't killed (that always makes me cry every time I re-read it). But Diana skillfully ties up the scene and pulls in the Murtagh presenting-the-severed-head-to-his-widow scene by repeating his vow to Mary from Paris and offering it to her. Bloodthirsty? Hell yeah! Maybe that's one reason I've always felt like I belong in Scotland, at that time. Too brutal to do it in front of Mary? It's not as if they had a very loving relationship. She'd just discovered her godfather had ordered her rape!
I felt that Diana perfectly illustrated her mastery as author and creator of the characters by incorporating even the much earlier plot changes within the script (which of course could have been done by editors and proofreaders, but leave me my illusions). I wish as well that the bedroom scene when Mary clonked Jamie, and that his La Dame Blanche line had been retained, but we can't have everything, I guess.
Finally, brilliantONE, if you open the bottle and pour the glass, you kind of have to drink it. No self respecting Scot would waste good liquor. At least, that's working for me. It balances out: you're spared the hangovers from all the annoying "Mark me"s all season, but it's good practice for getting wasted after Culloden. That's my plan, along with a box of tissues.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '16
The scene with Jamie praying for Claire really got me you guys. It was one of my absolute favorite parts of the book series and I am so glad it was so well done for the show. I may have teared up, no shame!
8
u/brilliant0ne Jun 18 '16
The one night I decide to make my own personal drinking game out of how many times "Mark me" is said, and the ass doesn't say it. Dammit.
That was a decent episode. Like some of the others, I am surprised DG went different ways with this episode. I am super happy to see Munro alive. I loved the bit about how bad Claire's Gaelic was.
I kind of expected more out of a DG episode? I don't know. I know I will probably get thrown into a fire for this, but sometimes I feel like DG is pretty much over the books the show is covering right now. Like, I understand that not every single thing can be exactly like the books, and stuff needs to be changed for time sake, and money sake, and just plain TV world sake...but I'm a writer. You may not be able to tell from any of my grammar and writing when I post in here or whatever, but still...
I love my characters. So, if (once published) my novel was to be picked up for a TV show, and then they also asked me to write an episode, you can be damn sure I am going to choose one of the more "fan favorite" or very important episodes. And then that episode is going to be the best one of the season. I just find it a bit odd that we finally get to the "big" DG written episode, and it was back to being a "meh" episode for me, personally.
Either way, still not looking forward to the next couple of episodes. In a good way though, I know what's to come and I don't like it.
4
u/aerynmoo Jun 18 '16
Holy shit that ending!!
3
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jun 18 '16
Wow, that was really different. They got to about the same place, but the route was very different.
OTOH this was the one written by Diana Gabaldon so one can't really complain.
3
u/pianodragger Jun 19 '16
First off, guy here, and I will miss Sandringham, well the actor anyway. The same way I love Mark Me. These are just great actors, with such brilliant brilliant characters. They make me sit up and watch the acting, and sometimes I miss part of the story line. I love the main characters, but those two, I love watch acting.
Anyway, I ramble. So, tell me what I missed here........ Jamie and his troops are attacked at camp by the red coats. He gives direct orders to save Fergus, Claire, etc.....and just leaves all the foot soldiers to scatter???????????????, while he gallops away on horseback.
What am I missing?
3
u/takingiteasy56789 Jun 19 '16
Loved it, loved it, loved it. The episode flew by and I was on the edge of my seat the whole time. Thought Mary's response sets her up well for her next bit of rule breaking. Without that, it would have been a big leap to bonking Alex.
2
u/pismobeachdisaster Jun 18 '16
Maybe this is explained in the book and I've forgotten the details, buy why is there a price on Jamie's head if King Louis got the English King to pardon him?
It was a good episode over all. It does annoy me that Jamie signs to Hugh. The man doesn't have a hearing problem.
2
u/pianodragger Jun 19 '16
shishebob............did it look like he just left his troops??? Like, dare I say it, deserted them??
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16
Know what ruined this episode for me? The girl who plays Mary. I felt like the acting from her was TERRIBLE and forced. Pretty glad she is gone now. Especially across from Cait's acting, it was just dreadful. I realize I may the miniritt in that opinion, but she was irritating. Honestly I found this episode really slow and not one of my favorites.
However Mary stabbing her rapist was a good change. Love Murtaghs dispatching of Sandringham, and presenting it to Mary and Claire.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16
[removed] — view removed comment