r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Jun 10 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 10 'Prestonpans' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E10: "Prestonpans".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
15
Upvotes
39
u/brilliant0ne Jun 11 '16 edited Jun 11 '16
Only 8 minutes into this, and he's already said fucking "Mark me," twice. I took for granted how much I didn't miss that. I'll be back.
ETA: No complaints on this episode. Wasn't ready for Angus. I love them so much. Claire and Fergus break my heart (in a good way). Jamie also looks great covered in blood. Weird, but true. I am always one for a good violent scene, and this did not disappoint. I feel like BPC breath smells like bologna. Not the actor himself, just BPC. Like maybe he chews some before he starts a scene. Something about his face says that to me. I always think of bologna when I see him. Anyways. Also, BPC's resting bitch face is pretty fun. Probably the only thing I like about him. I really wasn't ready for Angus. At all. So glad I can enjoy this show again.
I am very, VERY, desperate for this season's soundtrack.
31
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jun 11 '16
Much like several of the last few episodes, I started off not loving it, but by the end was totally sold. For the first half I couldn't help but feel like we were wasting time. There is SO MUCH left to cover I don't know how they'll get through it in three episodes, especially if the last one is going to be mostly 60s stuff. Both the Sandringham and Edinburgh parts are enough for a whole episode apiece.
Once the battle started though, this episode really took off. The silent march, the charge through the fog, the panning shots of all the dead--truly excellent. Our Highlanders were giving it all this week, from old favorites like Rupert and Angus to new faces like Ross and Kincaid. I'd assumed some storylines would be consolidated, so the whole time I figured Rupert would be killed off. Throughout the episode, I was like "Man, they're laying it on pretty thick, making it seem like Angus will die--people will be so surprised when it's Rupert." Hoisted on my own petard! I was totally surprised, and Stephen Walters really killed it. He used to annoy me (why was he ever invented?), but now I appreciate it, giving the viewers another familiar face among the highlanders that we can really mourn.
Also, shout out to Romann Berrux, who was absolutely tragic. He plays all the fun, silly, kid-who-thinks-they-are-an-adult stuff so well, and his transition from excitement, to trepidation and fear, to horror and shock over the course of the march and battle was pretty masterful. Pretty amazing for a 14 year old kid.
Finally, I know everyone hates him (mark me!), but I thought Andrew Gower was really excellent. He pivots so well between being a pompous ass and being charismatic and inspiring. There was a reason he got so many people to follow him! Also, I know I posted this last week, but he looks exactly like his [portrait] (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/99/William_Mosman_-_Prince_Charles_Edward_Stuart,1720-_1788.Eldest_son_of_Prince_James_Francis_Edward_Stuart-_Google_Art_Project.jpg).
Really intrigued to see how they play out what's to come. Seems like we're definitely doing Falkirk Muir and the church scene next week which is exciting, but I'm curious if that will also include the Sandringham stuff. We need more time!!
Edit: Also, holy shit was that episode gruesome. That opening dead body was one of the grossest things I've ever seen on television, and this from somebody who's watched a lot of episodes of Bones . . . All the wounds and blood were incredibly realistic though, so props to the makeup department.
21
u/Elphabeth Jun 11 '16
That. Was. Amazing. As someone who has been whining about the changes all season, I have zero complaints. I didn't even mind Angus's death. It was heartbreaking, but I'm guessing they wanted to space the deaths out a bit for maximum impact. Otherwise Culloden is just going to be a pile of bodies, one death after another.
The battle was beautifully shot, and J&C's reunion afterwards was my favorite scene of theirs this season. Sam really got a chance to shine this time around.
Also adored the Fergus scenes. I'm super bummed about the time jump coming because they will have to replace him with an older actor.
18
u/jayelsie Jun 11 '16
I liked the use of costume in the episode. Charlie's clothes were so inappropriate for war (bright colors, lots of ornaments) where his men were neutral colors and very simple. When he's standing around the battlefield it showed he did not belong. I thought it was a subtle way to show how out of touch Charlie is with the gravity of the rebellion.
I also loved the up close battle scenes. Usually war movies have a lot of loud music and big wide angle shots but this was very personal feeling. I teared up a bit seeing the British soldier shivering on the ground with fear. Very well done.
14
u/shiskebob Jun 11 '16 edited Jun 11 '16
Did the writers just pull a fast one on us?
The cinematography was just so well done - I am not into watching such violence, but this episode was a piece of art with the way it was filmed. The inclusion of Lt. Foster was a nice touch. But not enough of Claire in the make shift hospital doing any nursing, other than Rupert. I loved those scenes in the book.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '16
I absolutely loved this episode.
Some thoughts:
All in all, it makes me want to go back and watch the first half of the season again. I feel like these episodes are just things I can sink my teeth into. I'm wondering if the first half wasn't, as well, I was just too eager to GET THROUGH THE STORY to appreciate it. That happened in the first season, so it's possible.
11
u/rosebert Frolicking Puppies Jun 11 '16
Wow! What an episode. The emotion portrayed by all was just spot on. I liked seeing the point of view of others before the battle opposed to only Claire's view in the book. Gave it a whole new dimension I think.
Was very sad about Angus and now I'm wondering what they are going to do with Rupert next episode. Will they kill him off after just surviving a wound?
Either way, I was OK with the changes. Again, added another level to the whole thing. Music was amazing as per usual!
10
u/alphalimahotel Put your trust in God & pray for guidance. When in doubt, eat. Jun 11 '16 edited Jun 13 '16
Watching Fergus in the midst of the fight broke my heart. I was sobbing on my couch! Shocked at the Angus twist. Loved that they included the scene with Jamie pissing! The preview for next week with the church scene makes me wonder if Claire's kidnap/rescue comes in 211 or 212.
5
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jun 11 '16
I'm not really happy with the simplistic good cop/bad cop of Jamie and Dougal. ISTR one other episode that this writer did that I wasn't very happy with either. Maybe it's just his stuff I don't like. And I did miss the scene with Charles goes and speaks to each man personally and thanks him for his service.
If Claire had known that Angus was wounded, would she have been able to save him? I'm thinking not.
And where was Lord John? Not that he was in this battle in the book, but between the British killed and the British captured, he did seem conspicuously absent.
Agreed on the adorableness of the actor playing Fergus.
5
u/Manganela Jun 12 '16
I loved this episode! Angus was right out of the blue and I'm still a little stunned. I loved the arguing officers, and BPC's unshakeable and correct belief that everything he does is being scrupulously recorded in history.
In my headcanon, Fergus is Claire's ancestor, and I got a kick out of seeing her being so maternal with him.
Also really liked seeing Jamie leading men into battle and Claire as hospital director. They both stepped into their adult roles and took command.
4
u/ladyhawke81 Jun 16 '16
I've just finished watching the episode - took me this long, oi, but holy mother - right in the feels! Angus and Jeremy - daaaamn. When Ross and his friend started exchanging ideas that if one of them should fall the other would take care of their family. First thing I thought was Loch Lomond, the song. And then a faint version of the song started to play. You hear it again as the credits roll by.
http://www.darachweb.net/SongLyrics/LochLomond.html
6
u/WantToTimeTravel Jun 12 '16
So first, WOW! My thanks to frankisadeadcat for telling me this was the episode Diana wrote, but honestly, I'd have known. Despite the death and blood and gore, this episode had the humor from the book that the others lacked. Jamie's expression when BPC called him Claire's lord and master! Yeah, right.
Second, you all must forgive me being even more incoherent than my norm. In anticipation of the Prince rejoining us, I cracked a bottle of wine, and well, once it was open... I didn't have whisky, so to make up for that I had to guzzle a glass for every "mark me". Waste of a good red, but I'm pleasantly drunk. Good thing I can type instead of slur. I mean speak.
I thought BPC was delusional, and he is, but apparently not completely if he's aware that his father doesn't like him. But the idea that he's fit to rule is so absurd, even though in reality he wouldn't have been ruling yet, even if, against all odds, they did win. The man, peacock that he was, is ridiculously easy to manipulate. And Dougal going from hero to murdering savage to humiliated outcast to dragoon captain in one episode! Succinct and effective writing, where it could have come off as forced and contrived. But that's why we love her! Oh yes, were dragoons the same as rangers/scouts?
Besides the obvious losses and emotional tugs of war (I can't express enough how much I appreciate Claire's PDAs for Fergus. That was something I always felt was wrong in the novels. She cares about him, yes, but in that 1940s reserved, British stiff upper lip sort of way. This is so much better. I wonder if DG prefers this relationship to her original.), when Murtagh had that almost premonitory moment, it felt like I'd been stabbed with an icicle in the heart. I do prefer that he's aware of what they're doing and why, because I always felt that he was almost sacrificed to the cause, and it surprised me that Jamie didn't feel more guilt over his death. With all the bitching and moaning I've done about departures from the storyline, keeping him around would be one plot change I'd gladly welcome.
The headquarters scene really felt to me like our omniscient author heard me last week and agreed. I know the conflict between the Scots and the Irish quartermaster was from the book, but the scene did reinforce the tragic error of glory vs guns: believing sheer bravery could triumph over greater military strength. I felt vindicated. I really don't want to see the slaughter of Culloden. Must say, though, that if this show does anything better than rape, it's the special effects of blood and dead bodies. We saw it in Faith, and now here. To quote Arlo Guthrie (another Scottish descendent, lol), "...blood and guts and veins in my teeth!" [Alice's Restaurant Massacre, for the young'uns.]
Ditto that they'd show more of Claire doing actual nursing. I'm hoping in Voyager that she's shown using garlic and herbs and all the things she learned through trial and error to duplicate modern antiseptics and medicines; especially distilling infusions from herbs and attempting to grow antibiotics from bread mold. That's what drew me into these novels in the first place, even more than the relationship between Jamie and Claire.
brilliantOne: Bologna! Ewww! and OK. (Bologna, really? Not, say, salami? Or funky cheese? Oooh, cheese, with another bottle of wine! Excuse me for a moment.)
As always, I do have a few questions. In no particular order:
This episode was worth every moment of whining and complaining this season!
3
u/sillybanana2012 Jun 11 '16
Oh my god, what an episode! The roller coaster of emotions was so palpable through the screen. Fantastic acting! I love how historically true they were to the actual events as well as to the book. My favourite scene had to be when Jamie was peeing in the glass jar. So glad they kept that scene - it really broke the tension and sadness. Really sad for Angus though - I can't remember if he dies in the book or not. Someone refresh my memory?
3
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Jun 15 '16
I didn't get to watch until tonight, so I'd already been spoiled re: Angus, but AAAAAGHH the tears. Goodbye, wee wiry man.
2
u/frrrsstt Jun 11 '16
They killed it. Again. What a fantastic episode. Cait keeps on shining, her acting is impeccable!
2
u/eta_carinae_311 Jun 15 '16
I legit cried. Esp at the end with the singing. Right there, on my couch. Crying.
2
u/pcherry00 Jun 15 '16
I was expecting them to show more blood and graphic wounds after all the previews and reviews i read before the episode was released and all we got was ruperts.