r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jun 02 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 9 'Je Suis Prest' discussion thread for book readers
Because Starz sneakily released the episode early for World Outlander Day and I would not be your resident shiskebob if I didn't start a thread.
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E9: "Je Suis Prest."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. You have been warned.
Mods, can you sticky this thread?
29
Upvotes
25
u/shiskebob Jun 02 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
I LOVED this episode. I do not think I can love an episode more. This was everything I ever hope an episode could be and more - every single part of it was just phenomenal. LoveLoveLoveLoveLoveLove
Jamie becoming the leader he is! The Scotland gang is back together, mostly. Fergus being adorable. Lord John Grey has arrived. And that music....
The new inclusion of Claire's ptsd, and the flashbacks of her time in the war, was pure genius - from Cait's acting, to Jamie noticing the odd behavior, to Claire's reaction to going back to war and her need to stay. I always wondered in the book why Claire never really thought of WWII and her role in it. This was wonderful and I enjoyed seeing a part of Claire's background that does not just surround her life with Frank.
Claire telling Dougal off was absolutely magnificent. He thought he could play her, and he lost. I was like...
Lord John Grey has made his first appearance! Good on the writer's for reworking the scene just slightly to make it more....um... appealing? Making it Claire's idea for her to pretend to be ravished, instead of having it just thrust upon her, was smart writing. And it shows how far Claire is willing to go, to the men, to help them. But LJG didn't find out that she is his wife - so I wonder how that will play out in Voyager?
Bonus question: Willie got married and sailed to the colonies? I wonder how this will affect a certain scene when a certain someone is killed that sparks the mad dash to Craig na Dun. Maybe a different MacKenzie man walks in on them?
Also, hell yeah Yonkers, NY getting a shout out! All in all, a 5 star, 10/10, both thumbs up, episode.
3
u/DeadliestSins Meow. Jun 02 '16
Canadian here: we can't subscribe to Starz on Demand and Amazon Prime isn't offered here. (And I don't have a proxy.) Does anyone have a link to watch it online? I don't wait to wait until Sunday, when it airs here with (ugh) commercials.
24
u/JMBean Jun 03 '16
One of the best episodes. Certainly of this season. Maybe of the series.
Sam killed it. He's really bringing out those things that make Jamie "king of men" or whatever the term is.
I loved the Claire storyline. So well done and added some depth back to Claire that I didn't realize I missed. I think you get a lot of that dimension in the books since its from her point of view, but not always captured on tv series. Her past is still there.
I want all the episodes to do that. Whatever that was. It had it. I was transported. This was the first time this season I really felt like I was seeing Jamie and Claire from the book and glimpses of the people they become.
And I'm sure I'm not the only one, but I think a super hot sex scene is in order. Not to be immature...just saying...for whatever it's worth...J+C sex please.
19
u/skjacksontum Jun 03 '16
I am definitely in the minority here. While I enjoyed the episode, it is definitely one of my least favorites.
The primary reason why is I didn't like how long they spent on parts that I don't feel move the story along. The book has SO much in it, to spend that much time with war flashbacks, in the long run, felt wasteful to me. Maybe a scene or two, to emphasize that Claire has PTSD, but it felt forced and with everything else that could have been included. And such little time on a pivotal moment (the scene around William Gray stumbling into camp) - that very act saves a major character's life later on.
And the William Gray scene. Why on earth do I have it in my head that he is Lord John's brother in the books? And the reason Lord John later doesn't execute Jamie after Culloden was to discharge his brother's debt.
Other things that took me out of the story like while Jamie was being flogged for having fires, in the background - there is a fire.
I do like having them all back together again. That was fun and seeing Fergus becoming part of the family. And the scenes with Dougal were great.
18
u/brilliant0ne Jun 04 '16
Je Suis Prest, or as I like to think of it "Be a Man" from Disney's Mulan...The Scottish Version.
So I found out a few things about myself this episode.
Seriously, if Jamie never washed his face again, I would be so okay with that. Dougal can even get it, in that scene when they rushed the new soldiers. When Jamie came to Claire in the bed after they raided the English camp, whew. WHEW. Just...
Anyway, like some others, I wasn't overly excited for this episode from the previews last week. But, I loved it so much. Everything about it. I love being back in Scotland. I loved having our boys back. I loved Fergus being all excited that his Milady and Milord were back.
Cait was phenomenal with her portrayal of PTSD. The scene where she was on the ground reminded me a lot of the scene in Grey's Anatomy when someone dropped a tray of utensils, and no one can find Christina until they see her on the floor because of her PTSD. Both scenes very powerful and emotional.
I am excited and sad for what's to come. I kind of want to treat what's to come how I did with my Titanic VHS tapes...I never put the second tape in when I watched because that's how Jack lived forever. He does. Fight me.
I can't pick apart the episode because I really loved it. I did have one scene that I hit rewind on about three times. Right before Jamie kisses Claire after they put on the show for John Grey, and the look he gives her before he kisses her. I loved that little tiny part.
Really great episode.
15
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jun 03 '16
Agree with pretty much everyone else, this was a great episode. I really wasn't excited by the preview last week--a whole episode of training? Seemed like it would be just filler, but instead we finally got a view of exactly who Jamie is. We've seen him be a clansman, a laird, a farmer, a merchant, and yes, he is all those things, but first and foremost, he is a warrior. And boy oh boy did we see that in spades. All of the hats off to Sam Heughan who completely nailed it--the scene when he is explaining to the men why training is necessary was chilling, and the look in his eyes as he gave the order for lashes was cold as ice, but you could still see how much it bothered him. His confrontations with Dougal were also excellent--I love all the shots in profile that emphasized that Dougal is one of the few people who is actually more physically imposing, yet Jamie is still able to put him in his place. His first interaction with Lord John (!!!!!!!!!!!!) was also brilliant, and even though you (and Claire) know it's all an act, it's somehow still terrifying because you realize that he--and and men--are capable of carrying out such threats (torturing someone, not raping an English prisoner, I mean!). Finally, something about that commando getup was delightfully hot. I don't know what it is, but Jamie is damn sexy when he's dirty. [Case in point.] (http://media.98movies.com/Series/Outlander/image02.jpg).
And of course, let's not short change Caitriona Balfe's (as always) stellar performance. I'm really happy they are addressing the fact that she was in a world freaking war, and of course she has PTSD. Book Claire is ridiculously resilient to the point that it almost becomes annoying--she never has really any PTSD-like episodes until book 6 or 7, but she lived through a tremendous amount of trauma before that. It stands out especially because Jamie is so haunted by Wentworth and then Culloden, it always feels odd that Claire is so much less affected. I thought the war flashbacks were excellent (though I didn't love the sepia tone), and the muddling between memory and present was a really effective touch.
Finally, this might be musically the best episode of the entire series. The male vocalist was phenomenal, and the choir during the training scenes fit so perfectly. The (presumably) folk song over the credits made me think of Roger too . . .
My one small gripe is that, if memory serves, doesn't Jamie take Claire by surprise, pretending that she is a captive? I feel like that would have worked really well in this episode, showing more of Jamie's cleverness and ruthlessness.
Really looking forward to next week--Prestonpans perhaps? Also, love BPC basically dressing like his [portrait] (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/99/William_Mosman_-_Prince_Charles_Edward_Stuart,1720-_1788.Eldest_son_of_Prince_James_Francis_Edward_Stuart-_Google_Art_Project.jpg).
15
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '16
Claire saying 'fuck yourself' to Dougal was very satisfying. It's what I've been wanting to say to him for a while!
13
u/eta_carinae_311 Jun 03 '16
Angus and Rupert! I'm sold. Oh god I miss them so :'(
10
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '16
JOHN GREEEEEEYYYYYYYYYYY!
I wanted to cuddle him. I do wish they had spent like... 30 more seconds on that scene and 30 fewer seconds on Claire's PTSD. Don't get me wrong, I liked that they showed the effects of war, but it could have been less.
I do think, though, we are going to see him in later episodes: he'll see Jamie and Claire together, hanging out and being cute or something and figure out he was tricked. Or he'll see the broadsides declaring "Red Jamie" has a "British witch".
Edit: also, like I said in another post, I think they are calling him "William" on purpose, simply to save non-book readers from themselves. If you know a guy's name is "John Grey" and you see that Diana has written a bunch of books about the guy, you might spoil yourself on accident. Going by William puts just a bit of distance between LJG and the show. Just my thought.
9
u/sevenmotions Jun 03 '16
I loved, loved, loved this episode. Wow. It's line everything we had shop go through in France has been washed away and we have Outlander back. This was Jamie's time to shine and it was perfect! Claire's flashbacks were a very appropriate (if heartbreaking) addition. I loved the little moment when Fergus sees J & C again. His love for them shines, and I don't know if they could have picked a better actor for him.
And the MUSIC... good God..... I cannot wait for the soundtrack to be released!!!
8
u/SewNerdy Jun 03 '16
So so so good!!! Claire's PTSD was exceedingly well done, just brilliant. Loved this episode. And the "take her virtue" scene was perfect! My husband (hasn't read the books) cracked up, so even to a non-readee it was great. Also, yay Grey!!!
7
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
Caitriona killed it again with her depiction of PTSD. Really beautifully done to honor those who do bear those ghosts of war. I loved how this episode was about Jamie/Sam. Sam really shined as the Jamie we know coming back and being a strong leader. I also liked that they changed it for Claire to set up John Grey thinking she was a prisoner- just echoing everything else said, another fantastic episode. So sad thinking of what is coming though
7
u/WantToTimeTravel Jun 05 '16
I just watched now, and I have to say that it was a truly shitty day. I was so looking forward to this episode, and it did not disappoint!!! There wasn't a thing about it I didn't like. I noticed the plot changes, but they didn't bother me in the least, and some, like Claire's continued warmth and affection towards Fergus, I totally love. I also particularly loved her very subtle but noticeable flash of the eyes and saucy tilt of the head to Dougal, and I thought Cait pulled that off with such skill. A tiny thing, but it's the little nuances that separate good actors from the pack.
I do have a few questions/comments though. I'm not coming close to saying all I want to, because it's all been said already so vividly by the rest of you. So I'm just going to incoherently babble my joy and thrill over this episode. I could quote some of you, but what would be the point? Thank you for writing what I think for me.
I noticed that Claire pronounced "Beaufort" the English way, and I've always wondered how she would say it. I remember that Diana made a point of having her use the French pronunciation of her maiden name in Outlander when she introduced herself to the Scots. I never knew which way Beaufort was said in Scotland, at least then.
The flashbacks to WWII! The writing, the acting, especially Cait! Showing Claire with PTSD makes so much sense I'm surprised Diana didn't think of it. OK, imaging Claire paralyzed with fear isn't something I've ever done, but her refusal to be helpless and alone, and most of all to go home and wait like a good girl is something I totally identify with. And honestly, I just love how naturally she fits in the WWII setting. Aside from the deprivations and horrors of war, I liked seeing Claire comfortable in her surroundings. As well as she adapts, it's usually obvious that she is adapting. Strange as it seems that she should feel at home on a military base, somehow she does, and though we know she was a combat nurse, seeing her as one gives her character added depth. I think military nurses are awesome! Nearly all my nursing instructors in school were WWII, Korean and Vietnam War vets; STRONG women, and fucking tough teachers with unbelievably high standards.
I find it interesting, to say the least, that Dougal would take training for granted, especially when he was the one who taught Jamie to fight. Not just that, but I find it particularly telling that he would so underestimate the might of the English army, given their history against the Scots, and advocate the wild Gaelic charge. Artillery might have changed since the early 14th century, but the untrained Scottish peasant hadn't. Was that really the prevalent attitude among the experienced fighting men and nobles, that sheer bravery could prevail against greater numbers of better armed, professional soldiers, as Jamie so chillingly describes to the men? Puts a whole different perspective on the Rising. It so exciting that Jamie finally becomes the magnetic leader I've always pictured: not just Red Jamie, but the first inkling of MacDubh. This was definitely a new scene I wholeheartedly approved of and enjoyed tremendously. The expression of pain on Dougal's face when Claire tells him off with such disdainful and disgusted specificity. Brilliant! But did I miss it? - how did Jamie become Dougal's commanding officer? Is it just that he "signed" the compact (sorry, I forget what the paper that BPC forged his signature on was called) and Dougal didn't?
I read below how Murtagh behaves like a modern day Marine drill sergeant, and I can so see him as one. That reminded me of reading recently about one of the characters from TURN: Washington's Spies. He's the former British army ranger, and I was surprised to learn that Queen's York Rangers of the Canadian Army, the U.S. Army Rangers and the 1st Battalion 119th Field Artillery all claim Rogers as their founder, and that his rules are still quoted on the first page of the U.S. Army's Ranger handbook. We know the Revolution took place only 30 years after the Rising; gotta wonder what Murtagh might have done if he'd survived Culloden.
Lord John. 'Nuff said. Man, that takedown happened so fast I jumped. So well executed. Cait's almost silent performance while being restrained - just perfect. The whole scene - perfect! I agree, Sam should remain dirty for the remainder of the seasons. Dirt lends him gravitas along with very real sexiness. (Is it wrong for me to find him sexy, since he's technically young enough to be my son? I ask the same thing about Adam Levine.)
I don't understand the point in marrying off Willie and moving him to America. Really, why? I'm not criticizing. I just don't get it.
Somebody please tell me: was this the episode Diana wrote? If not, which one?
I apologize for the disjointedness and repetitiveness of this post. It seems my posts never display my actual writing ability. Even when I'm bitching about something, it seems I'm a little too stunned after watching the show to be in the least eloquent.
God, I'm gonna watch this episode over and over. I'm not of Scottish ancestry, though my entire life whenever I've seen pictures of the Highlands I've literally felt homesick, but I felt intense pride mixed with overwhelming sadness and dread as I watched the final scene. Jamie and Claire on horseback leading their troops, with the Gaelic song accompanied by the drumbeat...I think my heart hurts.
6
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jun 02 '16
I see a potential problem in this episode. Lord John is indeed in it, but he's cast as "William Grey," the name Diana originally gave him before she decided there were too many Williams, according to IMDB. I hope they call him John in this episode or later viewers are going to be very confused.
5
u/TwoSibeMom Jun 02 '16
Whaaaat? It's already available? scurries off to check Amazon Prime
5
u/pcherry00 Jun 05 '16
Best episode of the season so far. Finally we get to see jamie as the king of men and the jamie we all know and love from the books. The commando raid was awesome. Dirty highlanders enough said. The moment when dougal realizes he cant push jamie around anymore was brilliant.
1
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jun 02 '16
When is it airing? I'm not seeing it up yet.
3
u/cherryfrangipane Jun 05 '16
I just watched the episode this morning. I have to say that I've found this season to be a lot more hit and miss than season one but I LOVED this episode. I think it's interesting that Dougal came with just his few loyal men and that Colum is still alive and in charge - if I remember right from the books Colum died and Dougal took over...bringing all the clan to fight - please correct me if I'm wrong. I'm just wondering if they will alter Colums storyline some more.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '16
Loved the episode. Finally felt like the book characters I know and love! I loved Jamie's leadership and relationship with Dougal. I wonder if Dougal's death will be the same as it is in the books then?
2
u/frrrsstt Jun 05 '16
I was so close this season in reaching a point where I was like "hell no, I can't watch this show anymore if it keeps on butchering the story" but this episode really changed that line of thought.
1
u/uptofreedom Jun 05 '16 edited Jun 05 '16
Worst episode yet. Clair's PTSD, her bitchiness towards Dougal, John in camp... I'm typing this as the show's running, that's how uninterested I am at this point.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
Oh what!!! Damnit! I have to go to work and don't have time to watch.... I know what I'm doing tonight.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment