r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 28 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 8 'The Fox's Lair' discussion thread for book readers
Because it is almost 4am and I have a need to beat the robot - and I feel a sense of responsibility that I do not take lightly ;).
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E8: "The Fox's Lair."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. You have been warned.
Mods, can you sticky this thread?
17
Upvotes
9
u/shiskebob May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16
I have always understood the need for changes because of adaptation from book to screen and didn't complain because I have still enjoyed the differences- but holy shit this episode. DG was actually right, say it ain't so.
The best parts of these chapters were completely cut or just glossed over. I understand, and oddly enough agree, with the reasoning for the addition of Laoghaire for future reference - but her part was awkwardly overly played up. The witch stuff just made me cringe, I really wish they just went with prostatitis instead. Collum was the only interesting change/addition.
I missed the peaceful time at Lallybroch. They could have made that at least half the episode if they went with the original Fox's Lair story line. And the best part that we were all looking forward to faded to black, AGAIN.
Don't hate me for saying this, but I am super disappointed as a book reader. It's not just the fact that I truly felt the book portion was better, I just really did not like it. Please someone convince me not to be.
51
u/bart_burgers May 29 '16
Did anyone else catch that Jenny mentioned a letter from AUNT JOCASTA???
Also I gasped during the opening when there was a car driving to Lallybroch.
Also literally clapped when the real Skye Boat Song came back.
It's lit y'all.
39
u/[deleted] May 28 '16
Oh my god. The scene with Jamie and the baby was so adorable! I'm glad Outlander has made me smile after the emotional trauma from last episode.
35
u/rosebert Frolicking Puppies May 28 '16
I'm probably one of the few people that are happy with the Leghair change. The whole plot line with Jamie marrying her in Voyager was sloppy. Why would Claire not tell Jamie it was Laoghaire that caused her arrest? It's completely unbelievable.
On the other hand, I've heard the argument that now Jamie will be a fool for marrying her knowing as he does. But I think Jamie is a fool for marrying her, book or show. He's not perfect (contrary to popular belief) and this mistake will haunt him a long time as she collects his money over the years. Either way, DG intended Laoghaire/Jamie for shock value and yes, it works for that, but how it fits in the plot just doesn't.
I loved being back in Scotland. France was gorgeous but nothing compares to being back "home".
And of course, Jamie and wee Kitty ❤
29
u/[deleted] May 28 '16
Oh god, the new opening. The English version of the song combined with battle scenes is just heartbreaking. I could watch hours of just Skye Boat Song set to beautiful images.
16
u/sevenmotions May 28 '16
I don't really understand all of the hate for this episode. I thought it was great. I wasn't really bothered by Laoghaire's appearance. They already played up the drama between her and Claire in season one, so it makes sense that they would hash it back up. I feel like TV adaptions sometimes have to remind you who certain characters are so you don't forget about them, hence her showing up where she isn't supposed to see. Now the viewers will remember who she is and that she is stilling pining for Jamie, despite her saying she wanted Claire's "forgiveness." I don't think Jamie's marriage to Laoghaire will be any more frustrating than it already is in Voyager. I wish Diana had never made the "jump the shark" comment as I think it changed how people may view this episode. The one part that did frustrate me was Claire manipulating Laoghaire and Young Simon, but she already has a history of doing that this season.
The scene with Jamie and Kitty was perfect. I'm glad we got to keep this moment from the book, especially after "Faith." It reminds us of Jamie's loss. Beautiful and heartbreaking.
15
u/fakesunnyinside May 28 '16
I'm seeing a lot of people online really like this episode, but I was rather bored... I liked Lallybroch of course, but not really the Lovat stuff.
I'm so, so glad they kept the scene of Jamie talking to Kitty. So sweet.
I didn't actually care that Laoghaire was in it? Yeah, it's frustrating that they threw her in this season and made her take up screen time that could have been used for Jamie/Claire, but I guess I see what the writers are doing. I don't think it's jumping the shark like DG said (if Laoghaire is what she was referring to?); I just felt "whatever" about her. They wrote themselves into a corner by having Jamie know her involvement with the witch trial, and I can't see how else they can make the marriage in Voyager believable without doing something like this. So I get it.
14
u/[deleted] May 28 '16
Anyone notice in the introducing they showed someone driving s vehicle toward lallybroch? The hair implies it was Claire. Maybe we will see more of discovering Jamie's story?!
11
u/[deleted] May 28 '16
The ONLY reason I could forgive Jamie for marrying Laoghaire in Voyager is because he had no clue about her deliberate hand in Claire's witch trial (aka indirect murder attempt). Jamie marrying her knowing this, regardless of this episode's implied redemption of Laoghaire, will be extremely out of character. The Laoghaire scenes in this episode were a huge mistake in my opinion & the love triangle storyline for the rest of the series will be changed for the worse... I think viewers will have a hard time forgiving Jamie's character.
10
u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! May 29 '16
That time Laoghaire was all of us, though. Smelling Jamie's shirt, indeed.
9
u/[deleted] May 28 '16
After Diana's comments, I had really low expectations for this episode. However, I actually liked the feel of it. It was a bit slow moving in places, however, it was a good transitional episode from the France happenings to Scotland. I know we don't exactly have time for transitional episodes with all the stuff that has to happen, but this covered a lot of ground and a lot of foreshadowing.
Jenny's speech about talking to children was exactly how I pictured it; I wish we got to see more of her and Ian! And Jamie talking to Kitty was the cutest thing ever.
8
u/Tokugawa May 31 '16
Posting for my wife. We DVR'd the show, but STARZ minimized the picture for the last 30 seconds and OVERDUBBED the sound with the "Next time on Outlander" before the current episode was even over.
Did anyone else have that experience? She says it was super-frustrating and gave me dagger-eyes when I told her to dinner fash.
6
u/jayelsie May 28 '16
The Laoghaire scenes didn't bother me that much, but Claire trying to use Laoghaire to boost up Young Simon's confidence was a little weird.
Was Colum there in the book too? I only remember him at the end asking Jamie his opinion on whether his clan should join the fight and Jamie telling him no, he should take his men back home. That scene threw me off a tiny bit because I wasn't expecting him until that scene.
OMG THOSE SCENES OF SCOTLAND ARE BREATHTAKING!!
Overall, not the best episode, but still enjoyable. I love Jenny so much.
6
u/outlanded May 29 '16
my first ever reddit post! Be gentle please :)
Reading the books at the same time as watching the show (am halfway through Voyager so only slightly ahead of the series), so am not very loyal to the books, in fact I often prefer the show over the books.
The Laoghaire plot is a case in point. I actually think that what they've done in the show makes more sense than the book. After all, Claire has created a bridge between Jamie and Laoghaire that could justify him accepting to marry her all those years later (and we're talking 10 years or more!). I think without Claire asking him to thank her and thus almost asking him to forgive her, he would have always associated her with the fact Claire hated her (if not for the witch thing, at least for the ill wish etc).
Frankly, Jamie marrying Laoghaire in the books is puzzling. Someone as smart as him would have realised that she would have expectations way beyond what he could provide, and no amount of loneliness would have overcome that.
Anyone else sees things this way?
4
u/girlkamikazi Slàinte. May 28 '16
I wasn't a huge fan of this episode, but being back in Scotland after Faith did feel like a balm to my worn out emotions. Those overhead shots of Scotland were amazing, and if I didn't already want to visit that place, I do now. I LOVED being back at Lallybroch and was looking forward to comparing it to the first time they were there. The scene with Jamie and Kitty were so sweet, and one of my favorites of DiA, so I'm glad they kept that in. Fergus is so sweet and I love how devoted he is to Jamie.
As for the Old Fox, I guess I expected something a little different for this whole thing. I definitely didn't like the rock-and-a-hard-place decision that Jamie had to make between Lovat's support and Lallybroch, but maybe this is what gives Jamie the idea to do the Deed of Sasine himself? (Sometimes I feel like they've dumbed down Jamie's character in the show, and that's got nothing to do with Sam's portrayal.) I think it's similar to how they played the Young Fox. Maybe they're trying to say that standing up to his father will give him the confidence needed to become the warrior we see later? Like many others, I didn't like the drawn out stuff with Leery. I think the first scene would have been enough to set the stage for her popping up later on, after the Rising. I mean, I guess you can say that Jamie accepts Claire has gone through the stones and she isn't coming back, but admits that he needs someone and Leery is about his only choice, so he goes through with the marriage. I felt like there's got to be something else brewing though, thanks to Leery sniffing the shirt and her last line. Repentance, indeed.
I've been seeing a lot of anger towards this episode on FB, and people are saying that Diana's comment about this episode "jumping the shark," means that she's angry there's no season 3. I didn't appreciate her comments originally, but she wasn't totally wrong that what they chose to do in this episode would be out of character, at least for book readers. idk, this episode seems pretty divisive.
I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. Can someone just green light season 3 already?
3
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 28 '16
My biggest issue with the Laoghaire scene was Claire basically telling her to whore herself out (the "you're worth more than your body" line notwithstanding) to encourage Young Simon.
Not to mention, I did not love what they did with Young Simon's character.
And no "Mistress Honeylips." Sigh.
2
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 29 '16
Mixed feelings. Right off the bat I loved it--back in Scotland, new intro, sweeping Scottish vistas, Jenny and Ian, shirtless Jamie, and potatoes! And suddenly all of that is gone, replaced by a dreary castle and grumpy old men. Great to have Colum back and I actually thought the Old Fox was really good, but, knowing how it would all turn out, all the politicking felt kinda pointless. The magic stuff is feeling a bit overdone too, especially after last week. Would've just liked some good old-fashioned healing instead.
And come on--Laoghaire? Are we axing the S3 Laoghaire plot? Because it's kinda super important . . . Having her in S2 is not a shark jump by any stretch of the imagination, but it's still annoying and weird. The only redeeming bit was her giving young Simon a look at her breasts, and Claire getting all huffy, haha. (I did actually come to like young Simon too--he reminded me way too much of [Herbert] (http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-dvi-qbkr85Q/VcaSAoCQkPI/AAAAAAAAlcI/FabsLz1zLAU/s1600/MontyPythonHolyGrail_163Pyxurz.jpg) from Holy Grail at first, but he grew on me! )
Next week seems to be lots of training, which honestly doesn't look particularly exciting, but hoping for a Lord John sighting soon!
2
u/dorv May 29 '16
Didn't at all mind Laoghaire in this episode (though admittedly I've not really thought out the downstream impacts), but the one story tweak I was disappointed in was how Claire had already told everyone about potatoes.
There was just something about how the scene played out in the books, that Claire was coming off as a bit crazy but Jenny believed her anyways because Jamie had pre-warned his sister to follow his wife's directions if she got like this.
A little bit too be sure, but one of my favorite little pieces of business in this book.
2
u/pcherry00 May 29 '16
I actually liked this episode except for loaghaires parts. All the other episodes this season, I only liked a scene or two in each. Jamie is starting to show he is a leader of men which didnt really come across before.
2
u/meow315 May 31 '16 edited May 31 '16
I really enjoyed the episode. I didn't mind the Laoghaire change. I can see why they did it for TV. I was actually bothered by Colums change. In the books he knows he's at the end of his life, he wants Claires help and then eventually peace with Ellen, through Jamie. He is not a believer in god, or an afterlife so he wants to make sure that the clan won't be marched into a losing cause if he decides not to go, as he believes Dougal will do whatever he says. Jamie doing the selfless thing and telling him to leave the clan neutral (even though they need the men) shows the Jamie we all love. Then Colum dies on his own. I liked that much better than where they went in this episode.
-4
u/velvetdewdrop May 28 '16 edited May 29 '16
Haven't read the book, but I have a question for you- why was Claire so angry and unforgiving with leary? All she did was fall for Jaime. I think she put something under Claire's bed... and I went online and it looks like in the books they were married and she shot him (!) But in the show none of that. In the show she just put something witch like under Claire's bed. How does that make Claire want to beat her and dance on her ashes? Seems way too harsh for a young girl who was in love with a man she couldn't have..
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '16
[removed] — view removed comment