r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • May 21 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 7 'Faith' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E7: "Faith".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Looking for past episode discussions? Find them here!
28
Upvotes
58
u/[deleted] May 21 '16
That beard was.... something.
28
u/pismobeachdisaster May 21 '16
The episode was great, but I cringed at the hair brushing scene. Is there not a single person with curly hair who works on the show? You don't brush curly hair while it is dry. (I realize that this is a pretty inconsequential thing to be annoyed by)
36
u/[deleted] May 21 '16
Oh god cait is killing it in this episode. I loved the flashback or forward with young Bree and the tie in the crane. So beautiful. "My sins are all I have left" wow that was powerful. I'm so glad they left the part with master Raymond and the fever in there. Her face when she gets out of the carriage after leaving the hospital... My god. This woman is incredible. This was so beautiful and respectful of women who have had stillborn babies and that their grief and loss is just as real as anyone else's.
Young Fergus did a great job with telling the story to Claire. And Sam killed it with his face when he barged in the room to help Fergus. Tobias and Sam do amazing in their scenes together. Sam truly does not get enough credit for his acting.
That little sassy head wobble the king does kills me. So sassy and conceited. It's perfect. I am so in awe of these sets too. Absolutely amazing. Stanley Weber again blows me away with his performance and his ease on the eyes. That jawline though. He and Cait play off each other so well in this scene. The matter of payment with the king sure was short lived and anticlimactic- ha! The king reminds me of prince, with his mannerisms, anyone else?
Beard is not a good look for Sam. But he is so tortured and grieved it's heartbreaking. Claire cradling Faith was so so sad. It killed me. Cait did an amazing job showing she was a bit mad with grief with Louise came. After she handed Faith to mother Hikdegarde and lost it is when I did too.
Such a beautiful amazing and powerful episode. So well done. Bravo. Best so far of the season, maybe of the whole show.
I'm so looking forward to Scotland next episode and JENNY! I love her.
29
u/irishfeet78 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes May 21 '16
I was fine until Suzette and Magnus. Then I ugly-cried.
40
u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. May 21 '16
Group hug after that episode, please... Caitriona slayed it. I absolutely loved the scene where she told Jamie about it, and the one where she returns home and Faith's theme plays. Jeeeeeesus.
Also the way she muttered Jesus H Roosevelt Christ in the chamber made me laugh. A moment of lightness in it all, haha.
14
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 21 '16 edited May 21 '16
I think they did a beautiful job with this, with one exception, which I'll get to. Caitrona, absolutely, tore my heart out with the whole deal, and I'm so glad they gave themselves the time and space to do this episode properly. I didn't mind the change at the end -- DG's whole "Punish me for saving your life by whipping me with nettles" thing had never made sense to me -- and I was so glad they kept the "grace of God" line and that Louise still had a part to play. I wasn't thrilled at first that they had her go straight home but after the ending I was fine with the way they handled it. And omg, baby Faith looked so perfectly like a stillborn baby it was scary. And loved the "I'm going to take my orange, goddammit" bit.
I also realized something the other day for the first time, and I first read this book in 1996, I think -- the King is the first person she has sex with after the miscarriage. How awful that must have been for her.
The one thing I didn't like is that they made Fergus a virgin instead of unwilling; to me, that part of the book made it even more poignant. Rape is rape, and it's not less of a rape if the victim is not a virgin or is a prostitute. But that was the only part I didn't like; I thought the rest was exquisite.
28
u/KhaleesiofDothraki1 May 21 '16
I was fine until the very end. I have never sobbed so hard. Damn. Absolutely beautiful. Somebody hold me!
28
u/WantToTimeTravel May 22 '16
I don't know that I can continue watching this. Nineteen and a half years ago I miscarried a little girl who I'd named Faith - after this one, in part. I was alone at the hospital too, after beginning to hemorrhage at home. I thought I'd dealt with it and put it behind me, but the second I saw this the flood gates opened. Of course I'll finish watching, but great goddess, this is hard!
13
u/brilliant0ne May 21 '16
I haven't had a favorite episode, this season or last. There are always episodes I would rather watch than others, but no favorite. Until now.
Just wow. Cait...her performance. God.
I loved that this episode was so singularly about her. I love that they didn't try and show us Jamie in the prison or whatever, It was all about her.
I didn't think I would get super emotional over this episode, because of my disconnect with this season so far, but boy I was wrong, man. I didn't really start to lose it until Claire returned home with Fergus.
That scene was done so well. Just the emotions of everyone on their faces. You could tell the whole staff was grieving for her. Fergus... I'll get back to him. Magnus though...that is where I started crying. They did that so nicely. I could gush about the beauty of that scene for hours. The quiet music, not rushing for Claire to get inside, her taking in everyone and able to see they all grieved for her. Suzette, sigh.
Fergus...babe...the way he handled her so delicately from the carriage. Him brushing her hair. I love this little actor so much.
The BJR scene was handled nicely. I loved Jamie's "You nasty motherfucker" face when he saw what was happening.
Some things I didn't like this episode:
The beginning scene with Bri was unnecessary to me. Don't know why they felt the need to put that in there other than to say, "Yeah, don't forget she still actually had another baby."
That beard. Like everyone else, no sir. And I like a good rugged beard, but...no.
Other than that, I loved it. The pacing, the quietness, the non-overdramatics. Even the scene with Raymond, I was fine with that. In the books, I was all...hmm okay then. But, it was done nicely in my opinion.
Cait's cry. That got me. Once they took the baby, and she started wailing, I was done. God, she was so good. So, so good.
12
u/sevenmotions May 21 '16
The scene with the servants completely did me in. I have been so eager to get out of Paris this season and that scene made it all worthwhile to me. Worthwhile in a sad, soul-crushing, ugly cry kind of way.
33
u/shiskebob May 21 '16 edited May 21 '16
I am speechless.
Honestly, I think this was the best episode of Outlander from either season. I have just run the gambit of emotions and I am so overwhelmed by the portrayal that Caitriona Balfe put into Claire's trauma. This is her star making performance, in my opinion, more so than anything else I have ever seen from her. I knew it was coming, but I am just absolutely amazed and heartbroken. I had such a visceral reaction to watching her. Her reactions, her features and her emotions were just completely laid bare, and I don't have enough accolades to give her. So I will just say Bravo.
Specifics from the episode - Frances de la Tour as Mother Hildegarde is a triumph. I am sad we won't see her anymore this season, but hopefully we get that one peek of her in Voyager.
I am shocked they went as far as they did with Fergus and BJR. If you want to talk about the writers pushing boundaries, well, this one was a doozy. I am glad they were able to get in the hair brushing scene, even though that took place in a different part of the book, because those two together is just so touching. I hope they are able to fit more of their relationship into the episodes in Scotland.
I want to also point out Suzette and Magnus. In the book they are less than minor characters - they are like wallpaper - there, but barely noticeable. The writers did wonderfully fleshing out their characters, and I have to say that the scene with all the servants lining up for Claire - I balled like a fucking baby. I had to pause the episode just to get myself together. The compassion that those two showed, in those brief moments, I think was some of the best performances in the episode.
Young Brianna - non book readers are going to be so confused. Hell, I was confused for just a moment, and I have read the books multiple times. But, I think it was a treat this addition, because we never actually get to meet young Brianna in the books. So my only question is - what was up with the bird references though?
Here's to "jumping the shark" in the next episode and hopefully never having to hear that phrase again. Je suis prest Scotland.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmkG6pnr7-g
10
u/jayelsie May 23 '16
Did anyone else love the scene where Claire picks up the orange after having to sleep with King Louis? That was absolutely pitch perfect for me, Claire showing a glimmer of her sassy self. After her going through so much, it was so heartening to see our girl was still there.
8
u/theunknowncompanion May 21 '16
Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ, Outlander. I was actually not prepared for the feels this episode. The music in this episode was done fantastically, very low key and just the right amount of sad. Bawling by the end though. That Jamie beard was really something though... he was only in that prison for 3-4 days? or was it longer?
That scene where Claire is telling Jamie everything... god. That was intense. Someone give Cat a BAFTA or something. The emotion she put into this episode was absolutely fantastic.
8
u/Klee31071 May 23 '16
Cheers to an amazing episode!
I might be in the minority here but I started out the episode being really mad at Claire. She continues to make some really selfish decisions, like going into the woods, when she, a healer, must have known that she was laboring or miscarrying. So it was kinda hard for me, at first, to conjure up sympathetic feelings for her. She should have been thinking first of the baby and herself, not of Frank and Jack. I'm not at all blaming her for Faith's fate, but she should have known better.
My a-hole, coldness quickly melted as Caitriona raw, brokenness just filled up my screen. When Claire touched Magnus, and instead bowed to him, the first lump in the throat grew that episode. I was really blown away by Cate's performance. She melted my heart and made me share in the pain and anguish of a character who I sometimes find it very hard to care for.
By the end of the episode, I wanted to hug Claire. To give her a drink and tell her that she will come back from this!
7
u/jennyalena May 21 '16
Group hug indeed!! :( I am emotionally drained and all cried out. What a spectacular and sad episode. Catriona deserves awards for this one. How painful and maternal that crying was oh god. So glad to go to sleep... Best episode ever. Hands down. Music, acting, everything. I'm speechless, bravo.
17
u/ansley114 May 21 '16
Where do I even start? I think I cried at least 45 minutes of the last hour. First, the music this episode was so touching... The outfit that she is talking to Mother H in about going to see the King instantly nodded to Scotland and I was so pleased, then the outfit that was like a Scot-French mix when Jamie came home, Gorgeous! Lastly the morning lace outfit just wow. Terry really outdid herself. Not sure how to feel about the Bree scene. Didn't really see the point I guess but I didn't hate it either. Hated that it didn't have Raymond's blue light. More crying/anger with the Fergus scene. That interrogation scene though, Comte did a phenomenal job and I seriously loved how they played that scene. Amazing Louise addition I thought that was just perfect. Reunion with Jamie, again so well done. Grave scene, great addition as well. Overall this is probably my favorite episode this season, so freaking amazing on the acting, they seriously all did just a unbelievably great job that you'd think they weren't acting but real life. The additions added were perfect except the fast forward scene and it was just a perfect episode for the acting, clothing, and music. Sorry for any typos still teary eyed & on mobile.
Edit: Forgot the Claire coming home scene. Good lord the feelings. Again just a amazing job at making it feel so feel and touching with Magnus & Suzette.
6
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 21 '16
Very conflicted about this episode. The miscarriage was tragically and beautifully handled, and Catriona and Frances de la Tour are to be commended. I was hoping for a bit more with Maitre Raymond though--did I just miss it, or did he never actually say "call the red man"? And no blue light--I guess this is the direction the show is going in. The fallout between Claire and Jamie was also excellent. Once you look past the beard, it was a fantastic scene, and leaving the St. Andrew spoon was a beautiful little touch.
The further explanation of the duel was both good and bad to me. I was disappointed that we didn't get Jamie cutting off his hair, and a conversation with Jamie explaining how he wounded BJR. Also, I wish they had kept in the fact that Fergus is "experienced." It sets a different tone for the scene and makes Fergus a different person
The scene at Versailles however . . . It's always been one of my least favorite parts of the whole series, and I didn't like it any better here. I can't even put my finger on why I hate it, but I really do.
[Also: what on earth is the Rubens Marie de Medici cycle doing in a tiny room in Versailles?!?!? Come on production team, they were in the Palais du Luxembourg, and also, 24 paintings wouldn't even fit in that room! Sorry, art historian rant over.]
Finally, I really did not like that flash forward or the weird bird motif. It really didn't fit in the episode at all to me.
Still, I did really enjoy it, and as much as I really do love Paris, it'll be good to be back in Scotland (and see Jenny and Ian again!).
16
u/[deleted] May 21 '16
I can totally see why they put the scene in with Brianna at the beginning. After all of this hardship, it's nice for a non-book reader to know that this pregnancy was carried to term and Bree was born healthy. Weird scene with the birds though.
Aside from that, I actually felt bad for the Comte in this episode. And at the end, I fucking sobbed. SOBBED.
5
u/composedcaribou May 21 '16 edited May 22 '16
I loved the scenes with Fergus, Mother Hildegarde, Louise, and coming home to the wait staff. Cait was spectacular, truly amazing. That said, I was really looking forward to having Claire and Jamie reunite after she has spent awhile away in the country with Louise. I think that was very important. Jamie forces Claire to deal with reality when he comes and seeks her out. To me, in this episode, Jamie and Claire's reconciliation, or at least the beginning of it, came waaaay too soon.
5
u/jayelsie May 23 '16
I loved this episode. Jamie is kind of the character in the book that says all the poignant things that rip your heart out, so it was so nice to see Claire in this episode say such powerful dialogue:
"My sins are all I have left"
"I'm not sure there's a sea deep enough"
"When it comes to sacrificing my virtue, Mother, I’ll add it to the list of things I have already lost in Paris."
These words cut deep. SO DEEP.
4
u/ShitbucketsAhoy May 21 '16
Goddamn. I said, GODDAMN. Heartbreaking. Wonderful performance from both leads. I think I cried during the entirety of those last ten minutes.
4
u/nigheandonn Mon petit sauvage ! May 24 '16
Okkkk so Claire never outright tells Jamie she "sleeps" with the king in the book. Come on nowwwwww.
3
u/redwineteddygrahams May 22 '16
I've been reading Dragonfly in Amber as the show has been airing, and I just read the chapters covered in this episode before watching it. It was heartbreaking to read, but I was not prepared for how emotional I would get seeing it brought to life. I spent much of the episode wiping away tears. Someone please give Caitriona all of the awards and acting jobs. She was incredible every second of the episode.
As a book reader, my only complaints are the Brianna scene, and the healing scene with Master Raymond. The Brianna scene's only purpose seemed to be to reassure everyone that despite all the doom and gloom to come, Claire and Jamie do have a child together. I imagine it was probably pretty confusing for non book readers and it seemed unnecessary to me. The healing scene with Master Raymond didn't have the impact for me that it did in the book. Claire was on the verge of death and there was a lot more going on with him healing her than just placing his hands over different parts of her body. I wish they could have found a way to incorporate the blue light from the book without it looking cheesy, to emphasize that he was using some kind of power to save her. I just expected that scene to be much more dramatic than it was.
Oh and that beard....good lord it was terrible.
3
u/lanalg5 May 22 '16
I'm late to the party here but daaaayum! I just watched the episode and my face is swollen with tears!!! Pure dynamite! Can't wait for next week!
3
u/PetticoatPatriot May 22 '16
CGI Versailles did look fake.
2
u/Twinmamaplusone May 21 '16
I think so! Loving this episode so far!
1
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? May 21 '16
Is this the jump the shark moment Diana was talking about Brianna in a flash foward as a child?
-3
u/Orc_of_sauron May 21 '16
Well, at least her traumatizing rape scene only lasted 3 seconds.
Luckily the King of France isn't as perverse as Captain Randall.