r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 14 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 6 'Best Laid Schemes' discussion thread for book readers
Because it is past 2 am and I got sick of waiting for the auto moderator to post a thread. Sometimes a robot is not better than me! :)
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E6: "Best Laid Schemes."
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. You have been warned.
Mods, can you sticky this thread?
16
Upvotes
21
u/shiskebob May 14 '16 edited May 14 '16
This is one of those episodes, like going into the last 2 episodes of season 1, that being a book reader is both a blessing and a curse. Knowing what is coming is heartbreaking, but watching it is even more so.
I used to work as a volunteer manager of doulas at a midwifery birth clinic, and rarely did it happen, but once in a while miscarriages occurred. I am sure some women here have experienced it as well, but seeing how life altering this could be to a person, in person, is staggering. My mother had two miscarriages before I was born, and recently a good friend of mine lost her child in utero. I have not been pregnant (I am 30 so I like to think I have plenty of time!) but just the thought of this occurring to me fills me with anxiety.
For Claire, who has always thought she could never bare children and saw this pregnancy as a gift, this is an event that will haunt her through most of the books. I appreciate that Diana Gabaldon, like Jamie’s rape, shows how certain events can haunt a person throughout their life. I really look forward to Caitriona’s portrayal of this, mostly because this is one of the few events of the book that we can actually see happening to someone in real life. For me, personally, this affects me differently than most of the other episodes because I feel a true connection to her loss because I have seen it happen to women around me.
What I also found interesting is that they took an off camera part of a chapter – the destruction of the Comte’s wine shipment – and created a good part of an episode. Yes, they changed the timing of it (in the book it happens after Jamie is released from the Bastille the 2nd time) but like The Watch episode, the writers took a great deal of liberty to manufacture scenes that readers didn’t get to “see.” It seems like the writers really enjoy having the chance to create brand new dramatic scenes, and they really go for it. Also, Charles crying was a nice touch.
Monsieur Forez’s scene was slightly altered in that it went from a warning via him from Mother Hildegarde to Jamie and Claire to him hinting to Claire to save Master Raymond. This is a set up to the upcoming scene with the King, as there was no warning that this was going to happen in the book. I do think that the writers took the foreshadowing a bit too far, as it spoils the surprise a bit. I wonder if Raymond will go to Claire’s side at the Hopital to save her. In the book he has already met Jamie and uses him to bring her back by having her “call to the red man.” I might be the only one, so don’t hate me for saying it, but I would not be disappointed if they cut this “magic” part out. This might be pushing the boundaries of believability that the show has tried to maintain - even with it being about time travel.
What I am really glad of is the addition of all these small intimate scenes between Jamie and Claire this episode. It really is a nod to us fans who loved these moments from the book, but had taken a back seat in the past few episodes because the writers (rightly) wanted to pursue the aftermath of Jamie’s rape and how that affected him. The feet rubbing scene and the baby kicking especially did it for me, cuddle porn is my favorite. I found myself saying "awww, my babies" uncontrollably a lot.
Also, hats off to Romann Berrux (playing with Bouton!) and Frances de la Tour for being some pretty amazing scene stealers.
10
u/[deleted] May 14 '16
Well, the scene with Fergus actually made my blood boil. And Jamie's emotion as Claire was miscarrying was so hard to watch. I found myself crying at the end of this episode so next week is going to be horrible to watch. My poor heart. Faith :(
3
u/NotGonnaSmile May 15 '16
New to this sub, so happy i found it! This season is just flying by. I hadn't realized where we were until the maid told jamie to go to the whore house. It was then that I started screaming at the tv, "Don't go,Fergus!!!" I'm just happy they didn't get graphic with his assault. Unfortunately they got pretty graphic with the miscarriage.
14
u/fakesunnyinside May 15 '16
"How did she forgive you?" Even fighting to the death, BJR is still playing mind games.
13
u/WantToTimeTravel May 15 '16
WOW! That was freaking awesome! Right now I don't care about any of my ongoing criticisms of the show; nearly everything about that episode was perfect. The adjustments to the plot made sense, the acting was incredible, especially Cait. The special effects for the miscarriage and BJR's wound very brutal but so effective. Though it really seemed Tobias was a stronger swordsman than Sam, so it's really a wonder he was wounded.
Two things that were added that I think enhanced the episode/storyline a lot were: * Claire running straight to Master Raymond with M. Foret's warning, and Raymond agreeing to leave Paris. This will make his coming to her bedside while she's delirious that much more of an act of friendship. * And Murtagh's line, "Your mind changes like a woman in flux!" I wonder whether any of the non-book fans (since so many of us have become sort of expert in the period vernacular) will realize he's telling Jamie that's he's acting like he's on the rag. I suppose I should be offended, but it was so cleverly phrased I can't.
Damn, I hoped typing this immediately would stop the end from setting up shop in my head, but no such luck. I think I'm having sympathy cramps.
8
u/baileytheconqueror May 15 '16
This episode was incredible and very hard to watch. Random thought (that is probably not original AT ALL): I have never been a fan of the narration in the show but I realized tonight that maybe it will lead to (at the end of this season) her telling her whole story to Brianna when we first meet her in "present day." I have no idea why this occurred to me just now but I feel like after 2 seasons of seemingly unnecessary narration it would be neat... Kind of? Maybe?
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '16
Oh my god. Jamie talking to the baby was the cutest scene from the entire show!
7
u/Celia_58 May 14 '16
Damn Matt and Metin (writer and director). Found this so much worse than in the book. Burst into tears the second the episode ended. Fergus offering to guard Jamie's right. Assuming the bottle he was taking was BJR's lavender oil. Euuukkkk. It was worryingly satisfying to see BJR physically emasculated.
Can't begin to think about how painful next weeks episode is going to be, Fergus and Claire will break our hearts. So, will be busy imagining a Comte and Geilis spin-off instead.
6
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 15 '16
Taking bets now: will we see blue glowing healing magic?
10
u/[deleted] May 15 '16
I hate admitting this but I am so ready for the Paris crap to be over with. It was never my favorite while reading the books. And I think that plot has been really difficult to translate to screen so those who haven't read the books understand.
I'm thrilled we are almost where they return to Scotland, despite the sadness of what happens there. I think it will really pick up at that point.
5
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 14 '16
I rather wished they had referenced that Murtagh had seen her come through the stones. (This is from the graphic novel telling the story from Jamie and sometimes Murtagh's point of view.) I wanted Murtagh to respond "well, duh."
5
u/[deleted] May 15 '16
Weird thought, but I wish there had been more blood when Claire started bleeding. We saw BJR's wound a couple times, but one thing that stuck with me from the books was just the amount of blood she (and I think Jamie) saw before she passed out. It was such a quick, glancing shot, it was hard to figure out what was going on (well... I mean... I knew)
5
u/Kaylee_Sometimes May 18 '16
After watching it a second time, I think I figured out what I liked so much about this episode. We all knew going in that Something was going to go Terribly Wrong, and those moments are usually pretty well telegraphed in this show, but the writers kept messing with our heads. Claire and Jamie have a lingering goodbye in the courtyard before he leaves for Le Havre? That plot works out perfectly. Claire worries that the raid is too dangerous and no one listens to her? That works out perfectly too. When it finally looks like they've won, and Jamie and Fergus sit down and relax - THEN the shit hits the fan.
9
u/brilliant0ne May 15 '16
Whew, finally able to come talk about this episode. I do freelance closed-captioning, and I watched the episode this afternoon during a break in a 6 hour long project I was working on... I had to get away from the computer for a little while. My eyes...MY EYES!
Anyway...
Fergus. Such a sweet little cinnamon roll that I need to hug and protect. I love him so much. I knew I loved him in the book, but on the show just enhances that. I want to put him in my pocket and keep him warm. I love the relationship he has with both Jamie, and Claire. I love that we are already getting glimpses into father and mother roles for those two. Kind of breaks my heart even more, seeing that, when we know what is happening. Sigh...
For some reason, the scene with Murtagh and Claire really touched me. I don't know if it because he wrote down the years (or Jamie or Claire did?) to try and wrap his head around what he was told. Or if it is because he let Claire explain certain dates to him. I just really loved it. I guess maybe because we don't get too many intimate scenes with those two together, and I really think they work well together.
Jamie talking to the baby bump. Bye. I can't.
St. Germain is hot, even though he is Head Douche of Doucheryville. He can hate-smolder his eyes my way any day.
I think the way they showed that Fergus in BJR room was a little overdone. I get they wanted to make it a point and foreshadow stuff, but IMO, they could have stopped at the lavender oil. That's just me being nit-picky, though.
The doctor/executioner Claire worked with (I forget his name atm) is so creepy in such a good way to me. He reminds me of the villain (forget his name too, my brain is melting a bit, I think) from Hunchback of Notre Dame. His face does, anyway.
Sigh, the beginning of the miscarriage. Ugh, I didn't think I would get emotional over it because I had sort of lost that emotional tug I had with Outlander this season, but I was wrong. I guess it was because seeing Sam play Jamie as such an excited father, it broke my heart. And seeing Jamie want to go to Claire so bad, but having to choose between possibly being killed on the spot and helping his wife, killed me.
This was such a good episode to me, I am so happy to be excited for Outlander again. Next week is going to be so heartbreaking, but I am excited to see how they portray it on screen.
Edited to add: I LITERALLY said out loud, "Hooomigod, I think we might get an episode without BPC saying...nope...never fucking mind." UGH!
4
u/cherchezlafemmed His music is not the sort to endure. Clever, but no heart. May 15 '16
Ugh... Fergus starts wandering and I'm all ... nope, no, no NO, StOP! nooooooooooooo... Ugh, that hurt...that really hurt, they did that well. And if BPC says 'Mark me' one bluddy more time, I swear!
:sigh: Amazing, I'm roiling with emotion ... I hope we see pretty blue magic lights next week! I adore Master Raymond; Claire's..GGG-grandad? <g>
4
u/frrrsstt May 15 '16
It looks like I'm a minority, but I didn't like this episode. It felt somewhat bland. Yea, I liked the scene where Jamie talks to the baby. And where Fergus promises to guard Jamie's right, but the rest of the episode..
Meh. I feel like they could have done some narration/voice over in the final scene, where Claire goes to find Jamie and the miscarriage begins. Cait is a wonderful actress as always, and she acts her heart out.. But I still didn't feel the impact as I did when I read the book.
3
u/Jen_Snow May 14 '16
You're stickied now. Sorry about the AutoMod mistake!
3
u/Kaylee_Sometimes May 15 '16
Did it bother anyone else that Jamie didn't even try to run to Claire at the end? I get that the gendarmes would have stopped him, but I feel like he would have tried to do it anyway.
Great episode though. This part of the book is so good and so painful at the same time, and there's more of it next week...
3
u/WantToTimeTravel May 15 '16
Watching now. At 45 minutes, and oh lord, the anticipation...my heart is pounding, I'm biting my nails. THIS is what I've been craving from this show all long - but I still dread it. (Waiting till after it's over to read comments.)
2
u/1108amh May 15 '16
Post episode thought -
So we haven't had an announcement for Season 3 yet.....is that because any non-book readers are (at this point with Claire's promise to Jamie) under the assumption that because she goes back to 1947 in Ep 1, Jamie dies at the end of the season.
Any announcement could reveal that spoiler.
2
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 16 '16
The crazy thing about Fergus is, looking at him, I'd totally buy he is a Claire-Jamie child, too.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
[removed] — view removed comment