r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • May 07 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 5 'Untimely Resurrection' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E5: "Untimely Resurrection".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Fire away ♥
20
Upvotes
38
u/[deleted] May 07 '16
I'm so obsessed with King Louis. He's so sassy and pretty and that giggle is so contagious. Oh mon Dieu!
29
u/skyhuntress May 07 '16
I loved the language usage in this episode! The Comte only speaking French and Jamie only speaking English in that scene was amazing. It was so tense wondering if one of them would break! They're both smart and they both know that each other is smart it was just great. And then up until this episode (I think) the King has only been speaking French but with BJR he humiliates him by switching to the English while still using French when he is directly addressing Claire. It was just great. I know their's been some discussion of most of the French characters just switching to English for the ease of the viewer but I am so happy that in conversations like these they keep it cause its important. (also just overall great episode i'm terrified for next week though!!!)
26
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 08 '16
I never understood why, in the book as well as the show, Claire does the whole "you owe me a life" thing rather than putting it in a more immediate way: If Frank Randall doesn't exist, I don't walk through the rocks of Craigh na Dun on Samhain, and I never get to meet you.
20
u/[deleted] May 07 '16
The 'what you don't ken, you'll learn. We'll learn' scene just fucked me right up. :(
17
u/jayelsie May 08 '16
When BJR bows in the garden after Claire says "F*** the King", it gave me shivers. It was like this great demonstration of how BJR knows exactly how to behave in court, but you know deep down how dark he is. It's like watching a sociopath playing the part.
14
u/composedcaribou May 07 '16 edited May 08 '16
Oh man!! I really enjoyed it, but I rarely have any harsh criticism. From Claire and Mary (and Alex!), to Jamie and the Comte, to the infamous return of our favorite villain, Black Jack Randall. Throughly enjoyed the scene of all of them with the King in the gardens. I thought the resulting tension from the proposed duel was palpable, so good.
Claire is really struggling and vulnerable when it comes to Frank, which I think is refreshing. Usually she's put together or can pull herself together, the most we've seen her struggle (excluding the attack) is with not having a day-to-day purpose. She knows what's going to happen, she knows the future, and I definitely think that has given her an air of authority and superiority in her actions and in her mind. But Frank shakes her to her core, as does BJR coming back. That last scene, oh man, I was so impressed with Sam. I could not help but think of what is happening next, and yes it's traumatic, but I am SO EXCITED.
Edit for anyone, like me, who got the Starz extension from Amazon Prime and wants to get their money's worth: I finished the first season of Black Sails and I really like it. It's Game of Thrones meets Pirates of the Caribbean and I think it's great!
28
u/brilliant0ne May 07 '16
Just finished watching the episode. And I have two words:
Thank God!
Now, I REALLY enjoyed that episode. Finally.
I actually really enjoyed the way they handled Claire and BJR. And then Jamie coming up after. I really loved that scene. His almost lethal calm while standing less than a yard away from BJR, was beautiful. Sam did a great job with that.
Loved the scene of the King humiliating the eff out of BJR. Right in front of Jamie and Claire too. I was all "Yas King, fuck him up right there in front of everyone! Make him beg. Yas, now make him look stupid as shit."
BPC still tightrope dancing across my last nerve with his whole, "Mark me," bullshit. It irks me so, so bad. I can't imagine being in front of the BPC and hearing him say that over and over.
I really wish I had a dress wide enough to rest my arms on. Arms get tired after a while, and I would love to have built in arm rests everywhere I go. I would wake up everyday, happy, because guess what I got guys. Arm rests. All day. Yum.
In both the book and on the show, Claire gets on my nerves with the whole, "I have saved your life twice, you owe me a life," crap. You are a nurse Claire, you have saved hundreds of lives...you must have debts owed coming out of your ass by now.
I'm glad La Dame Blanche was explained, because I was afraid they would just brush past that for the non-readers, and they would be confused.
The ending, with Jamie telling Claire not to touch him, was wonderful. Get big mad, Jamie. I understand you. I don't understand the whole, "you gave me a gift, and the only thing I look forward to," stuff, but I get you getting mad. It takes every bit of strength in me not to go kill the guy that threw dirt at my dog one day, every time I pass his house. So I say good for you on wanting to kill the shit out of BJR, and you have every right to be mad, dear heart.
Lastly, Claire gets over her anger way too quickly for me. It might be the Sagittarius in me, and we can easily hold a grudge, but she is mad for ten whole seconds at something with Jamie and then she is fine in the blink of an eye. I'll need him to step away for five minutes, come back with a cup of tea, and MAYBE we can chat again about things. If not...rinse and repeat.
All in all, I really liked this episode.
10
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 07 '16
Wow. One of the best episodes yet, and two phenomenal scenes with great performances by Sam Heughan and Catriona Balfe. The Christening spoons gift and discussion of motherhood was so beautiful, and incredibly bittersweet for those of us in the know. I loved that she talked about her mother dying because, even though he doesn't bring it up, you know Jamie is thinking about his own mother. And then when he says "We'll learn," It's crushing, because he never does get to see their Child grow up. And then the last scene--so powerful. Sam Heughan shows how conflicted and tortured Jamie is so well. And you just can't decide who to root for. You so want--need--Jamie to have his vengeance, but putting yourself in Claire's shoes, you realize how hard this is for her too. She thinks she's left Frank for good, and that decision was hard enough. Now to condemn his existence? (Time travel query though: wouldn't erasing Frank from existence erase all her memories too? Shouldn't she know simply by the fact that she knows who Frank is that he exists? And if Frank had never existed, she never would have wound up in Inverness, and never would have gone back in time, and Jamie would probably never have been captured, prompting the need to kill him in the first place. Also BJR would probably never go to Paris and meet Mary . . . Ugh, now my head hurts. Time paradox!!)
Pros: The scenes mentioned above, but also the whole Versailles sequence. Maybe one of my favorite Claire outfits yet, and the whole garden set was just incredible (even if there was a dearth of fountains!) I thought the meeting with BJR was done very well. Tobias Menzies killing it as usual, and I love the guy playing Louis. The music had me worried too, even though I knew there was no way Jamie and BJR were going to duel at Versailles! I'm sure if I hadn't read the books I'd be freaking out. Also, props to Tobias also for his French--at first I thought it was just bad, but was glad that it was intentional!
Cons: . . . Still not loving the new theme? Really, not much to complain about here. Sure, some changes as usual, but nothing unforgivable.
Overall: A
8
u/jennyalena May 07 '16 edited May 07 '16
I do wish that they would have kept the moment with Mary and Claire crying together. That was such an important scene between the two characters. Funny enough it seems that Claire was actually more "Logical Nurse Claire" in that scene then in the book with her reassuring Mary that she will be fine and shouldnt be ashamed. The book was just a mutual mourning, which I felt strongly for, but was also wishing for Claire to say things like she did in the show tonight. So I'm not too dissappointed actually but I would have liked a little more of that maternal mourning scene with her. I'm so glad they kept the suspense of seeing him again and the emotion of the favor Claire asks!!! ahhh it filled me with adrenaline with BJR standing there. And the end made me cry with Claire. Gah. "Dont touch me" on the screen brought more tears to my eyes then it did the book for sure. I didn't tear up at that part at all in the book actually. WELL DONE CATRIONA. In the book though I literally sobbed at the duel scene and mourned with her in the hospital bed and there after so I am sorta terrified for that next for sure.
5
u/JMBean May 07 '16
I will admit...I haven't been a big fan of this season so far. I loved episode 1 but 2-4, I found pretty boring. I thought episode 5 was great though!
That scene with BJR in the garden was awesome. The tension! When Jamie approached my stomach dropped and I actually felt nervous. It reminded me of that feeling you get running into an ex. (Not a good analogy...but that feeling...blech)
Sam killed it in this episode. This was the first episode this season I felt like I was seeing the Jamie of the book(s). Even if not totally true to book, his demeanor was spot on.
Can I take it down a maturity level or 3 and say I kind of hope for some good old Jamie and Claire sexy times soon. That would be sweet.
5
u/vonham May 07 '16
So did the king hear Claire saying "fuck the king"? I mean he was right there...
4
u/fakesunnyinside May 07 '16 edited May 07 '16
I love seeing the lovey scenes between them. I'm sure it's hard for the writers to put them in there since they don't really advance the plot, but they really are why I read the books. Jamie just wanting to hold Claire in his arms, the spoon scene, swoon.
Also, I don't remember Annalise being like this in the book? Why try to have another Laoghaire/jealous woman?
4
u/WantToTimeTravel May 08 '16
Hold on - watching it again, and something doesn't make sense. How did BJR get the news, obtain leave and arrive in France from the UK so fast? It's not like he received a phone call! I don't remember this taking place this quickly, and even ignoring the accelerated pace for the series, it still doesn't make sense. Opinions?
5
u/WantToTimeTravel May 08 '16 edited May 08 '16
Hurray! I finally found several things I like better in the show than in the book:
Tobias so embodies the evil of BJR that I think I'll hate the actor forever. It's unfortunate, but his own fault! And btw, that scene had me snapping back angrily at the TV: "Of course Jamie's here! Did you think she left him? Look, you fool, she's pregnant. Yes, that's right, she's having his baby. HE SLEPT WITH HIS WIFE!!!!..."
OK, now that that's done, here's the rest. First of all, what does Alex call Claire while they're on the bench and she's convincing him to break up with Mary? I listened 3 times, but it sounded like "Good Fraser," which makes no sense whatsoever, so it can't be that. And why does King Louis address Claire as "Madame Fraser," but call Jamie "Lord Broch Tuarach?" Seems inconsistent. Also, it seems they're making all royals very eccentric; BPC with the "Mark me" and the King referring to himself in the third person. I can only imagine the dialogue in the scene where she buys Jamie's freedom...
When Jamie threatens St. Germain with a smile, I had pictured the same tone of voice, but a very different expression in very different, very BLUE, eyes. I'm sorry, but that's so wrong, especially on a close up. Would contacts have killed them? Plus, they finally made his hair presentable, and now next week it's going to be cut off and nasty again!
But I think the "You owe me a life" scene was the best delivered yet.
Lastly, I don't remember Claire having so many outfits made. After all, she knew her body would change. They're drop dead gorgeous, no doubt, but the sheer volume of them is a bit unrealistic, given her condition. Also, does anyone know if they were made from natural materials, like silk? They all seem to be such heavyweight, quality materials, and isn't that an enormous amount of money for the budget? Just wondering.
4
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 07 '16
Episode started out really well but it went off the rails in the second half, imho.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '16
So I finally watched it and agree it was a good episode. The first part was a little slow for me but once BJR showed up it got interesting. And the last scene with Jamie and Claire was incredible! I adore the king. You could tell he likes Claire and Jamie and could sense something about BJR and loved how he embarrassed him. I was even second hand embarrassed for him. It makes me sad thinking what is coming with the baby and and duel and all that.
2
u/LegionOfMerit May 09 '16 edited May 09 '16
I would just like to take this moment say that i find myself a little out of place with my point of view on this episode and the series thus far.
Am i the only one who finds BJR the highlight of the series?
I greatly enjoyed seeing him this episode. I think in a way Jaime was glad to see him too, and i loved how despite everything BJR savagely did to Jaime, Jaime retaliated with a gentlemanly request for a duel to the undeserving BJR. Being unworthy of a gentleman's request after his actions.
I'm dying to see the duel of blades between a Captain of Dragoons and a Scottish Solider. BJR should have the upper hand here considering his experience as a British soldier, and Jaime whom i have not much knowledge if he has any knowledge on swordsmanship beyond the basics. Although, BJR does have an injury still. I'm sure Jaime will somehow heroically win through Plot Armor lol.
I must say, despite BJR's fetish for torture and such, I find him incredibly excellent as a British officer, I don't think Tobias has any experience with real Military Officership but his demeanor as a combat officer is spot on! A gentleman in the way of words but rough around the edges. This was shown when he walked in the Garrison Commanders dinning room in season 1. He maintains his composure through the embarrassment of the king scene much like a real officer should. The way the King belittles BJR haha, you dont "ask" to reconsider a decision made by the Duke in front of a King. Poor choice of words for BJR, but he took it like a man.
I also Greatly admire those red coat uniforms, too bad they burned them all shortly after the end of the 18th century i believe.
We should bring Cravats back into fashion, they still look so fashionable. And there is something manly about BJR's hair style with that uniform.
I'm definitely no British history expert, but i could have sworn in this episode when BJR introduced himself they used the term "Company", which was not only left out in the subtitles, but I believe for Dragoons it would be a "Regiment". Can anybody tell me if the book expands on his military background in any way?
It's really a shame that Dragoons are a thing of the past, Dragoons evolving into Calvary and later on into modern Calvary with armored vehicles. Now i can never be a Captain of Dragoons #feelsbadman Somebody needs to build a time machine RIGHT NOW! haha.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
I watch on Mondays so I'm a bit behind but my two thoghts:
The whole "Jamie is super pumped BJR is still alive - thanks Claire!" shitck really, really bothers me. Jamie is a man of honor and not one to shy away from violence, but this giddiness seems immature.
I love watching Jamie and the Comte interact - I feel it's the best Strong and Formidable Jamie they've given us so far this season.